For Public Comment: Draft Malaysian Standard
For Public Comment: Draft Malaysian Standard
MALAYSIAN 15D005R0 q
STANDARD
STAGE : PUBLIC COMMENT (40.20)
DATE : 01/02/2016 - 01/04/2016
t
en
m
om
Malaysia National Annex to MS EN 1998-1:
2015, Eurocode 8: Design of structures for
C
ICS: 91.120.25
Descriptors: Earthquake, Seismic Design of Structure, PGA, Site Natural Period, Hybrid Response
Spectrum, Return Period
© Copyright
DEPARTMENT OF STANDARDS MALAYSIA
15D005R0 q
Contents
Page
t
en
NA.4 References to non-contradictory complementary information ........................... 13
Annex A
m
Horizontal Elastic Response Spectrum Model for the whole of Malaysia and for
om
all ground types .................................................................................................. 14
Annex B Importance factor (γI) and design peak ground acceleration (PGA) for the whole
C
of Malaysia ......................................................................................................... 18
lic
Bibliography ............................................................................................................................ 19
ub
rP
Fo
Committee representation
The Industry Standards Committee on Building, Construction and Civil Engineering (ISC D) under whose authority this
Malaysian Standard was developed, comprises representatives from the following organisations:
t
Pertubuhan Akitek Malaysia
en
Pertubuhan Perancang Malaysia
Projek Lebuhraya Utara-Selatan Berhad
Real Estate and Housing Developers’ Association Malaysia
SIRIM Berhad (Secretariat)
Suruhanjaya Perkhidmatan Air Negera m
om
The Cement and Concrete Association of Malaysia
The Institution of Engineers, Malaysia
Universiti Sains Malaysia
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia
C
The Technical Committee on Earthquake which developed this Malaysian Standard is managed by The Institution of
Engineers, Malaysia (IEM) in its capacity as an authorised Standards-Writing Organisation and consists of
lic
Foreword
The Malaysia National Annex was developed by the Technical Committee on Earthquake under
the authority of the Industry Standards Committee on Building, Construction and Civil
Engineering. Development of this national annex was carried out by The Institution of
Engineers, Malaysia which is the Standards-Writing Organisation (SWO) appointed by SIRIM
Berhad to develop standards for earthquake.
Acknowledgement is made to BSI for the use of information from the above publication.
t
This Malaysia National Annex contains information on those parameters which are left open in
en
MS EN 1998-1:2015 for national choice, known as nationally determined parameters. The
Malaysia National Annex is to be read in conjunction with the MS EN 1998-1:2015, Eurocode
8: Design of structures for earthquake resistance - Part 1: General rules, seismic actions and
m
rules for buildings. Reference can be made to other parts of BS EN 1998 where applicable.
om
At the time of publication, this standard is expected to be used as a reference in the Uniform
Building By-Laws (Revision 2012), which is a Statutory Document gazetted by the Act of
C
Parliament.
include Reader Dr. Nelson Lam, Dr. Megawati, Dr. Tsang Hing Ho, Prof. John Wilson, Prof.
Murat Saatcioglu, Prof. Friedeman Wenzel and PhD candidate Engr. Daniel Looi Ting Wee who
ub
Compliance with a Malaysian Standard does not of itself confer immunity from legal obligations.
Fo
NA.1 Scope
This National Annex gives:
a) the Malaysia decisions for the Nationally Determined Parameters described in the following
subclauses of MS EN 1998-1:2015:
t
– 3.1.2(1) – 5.8.2(3) – 9.2.2(1)
en
– 3.2.1(1),(2),(3) – 5.8.2(4) – 9.2.3(1)
– 3.2.1(4) – 5.8.2(5) – 9.2.4(1)
– 3.2.1(5) – 5.11.1.3.2(3) – 9.3(2)
– 3.2.2.1(4) – 5.11.1.4 m– 9.3(2)
om
– 3.2.2.2(1)P – 5.11.1.5(2) – 9.3(3)
– 3.2.2.3(1)P – 5.11.3.4(7)e) – 9.3(4), Table 9.1
– 3.2.2.5(4)P – 6.1.2(1) – 9.3(4), Table 9.1
C
– 5.2.1(5) – 7.1.3(4)
NA.2.1 General
The terms and definitions given in MS EN 1998-1:2015, clause 1.5 apply. Further terms are
used in the NA with the following meanings:
The PGA used in the NA is actually the maximum response spectral acceleration divided by
2.5 (notional PGA = RSAmax/2.5) and not the peak value on the accelerogram, it is termed as
“notional PGA” to quantify the underlying meaning of the design PGA.
The notional design PGA value for Class II structure is 2/3 of the notional design PGA value of
a 2475 year Return Period (RP) earthquake action, it is associated with a notional Return Period
of 475 year. For example, a notional PGA value of 0.07 g on rock site for the Peninsular
Malaysia is deemed to be associated with notional 475 years RP.
NA.2.3 Symbols
t
en
SDR (1.25) elastic response spectral displacement on rock site at T = 1.25 s
VS weighted average shear wave velocity over the total thickness of soil layers
lic
NA2.4 Abbreviation
FS Flexible soil
R Rock
RP Return period
SS Stiff soil
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015
Clause Nationally Determined Parameter Eurocode recommendation Malaysia decision
2.1(1)P Reference return period TNCR of seismic TNCR = 475 years TNCR = 475 years (notional)
action for the no-collapse requirement PNCR = 10 % PNCR = 10 % (notional)
(or, equivalently, reference probability of Refer to Annex B.
exceedance in 50 years, PNCR).
2.1(1)P Reference return period TDLR of seismic TDLR = 95 years TDLR = 475 years
action for the damage limitation PDLR = 10 % PDLR = 2 %
requirement (or, equivalently, reference for Importance Class IV buildings
t
probability of exceedance in 10 years, (deemed to satisfy for Importance Class I to III
en
PDLR). buildings)
Refer to Annex B.
m
3.1.1(4) Conditions under which ground None No additional investigation is necessary. There
om
investigations additional to those is an option to employ geophysical
necessary for design for non-seismic measurements to assist in the determination of
actions may be omitted and default site classification.
ground classification may be used.
C
3.1.2(1) Ground classification scheme accounting None Refer to Annex A.
lic
for deep geology, including values of
parameters S, TB, TC and TD defining
ub
horizontal and vertical elastic response
spectra in accordance with MS EN 1998-
1, 3.2.2.2 and 3.2.2.3.
rP
3.2.1(1), (2), (3) Seismic zone maps and reference None Malaysia reference ground accelerations are
ground accelerations therein. divided into Peninsular Malaysia, Sarawak and
Sabah. Refer to Annexes A and B.
Fo
3.2.1(4) Governing parameter (identification and ag ≤ 0.78 m/s2 or agS ≤ 0.98 m/s2 The whole of Malaysia is classified as low
value) for threshold of low seismicity. seismicity.
15D005R0 q
3.2.1(5) Governing parameter (identification and ag ≤ 0.39 m/s2 or agS ≤ 0.49 m/s2 No part of Malaysia is classified as very low
value) for threshold of very low seismicity.
seismicity.
3
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015 (continued)
15D005R0 q
4
3.2.2.1(4), Parameters S, TB, TC, TD defining shape In the absence of deep geology effects, and for Type 1 Refer to Annex A. for parameters required for
3.2.2.2(1)P of horizontal elastic response spectra. spectra (where earthquakes that contribute most to the constructing horizontal elastic response
seismic hazard defined for the site for the purpose of spectrum.
probabilistic hazard assessment have a surface-wave
magnitude, Ms, greater than 5.5)
Ground S TB TC TD
type (s) (s) (s)
t
A 1.0 0.15
en
0.4 2.0
B 1.2 0.20 0.5 2.0
C 1.15 0.20 0.6 2.0
m
D 1.35 0.20 0.8 2.0
E 1.4 0.15 0.5 2.0
om
In the absence of deep geology effects, and for Type 2
spectra (where earthquakes that contribute most to the
C
seismic hazard defined for the site for the purpose of
probabilistic hazard assessment have a surface-wave
magnitude, Ms, less than 5.5):
lic
Ground S TB TC TD
© STANDARDS MALAYSIA 2016 - All rights reserved
ub
A 1.0 0.05 0.25 1.20
B 1.35 0.05 0.25 1.20
rP
C 1.5 0.10 0.25 1.20
D 1.8 0.10 0.30 1.20
E 1.6 0.05 0.25 1.20
Fo
3.2.2.3(1)P Parameters avg, TB, TC, TD defining shape Spectrum avg/ag TB TC TD avg/ag TB TC TD
of vertical elastic response spectra. (s) (s) (s) (s) (s) (s)
Type 1 0.90 0.05 0.15 1.0 0.70 0.05 0.15 1.0
Type 2 0.45 0.05 0.15 1.0
3.2.2.5(4)P Lower bound factor β on design spectral β = 0.2 Use the recommended value
values.
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015 (continued)
© STANDARDS MALAYSIA 2016 - All rights reserved
4.2.3.2(8) Reference to definitions of centre of None Any appropriate method may be used.
stiffness and of torsional radius in multi Further guidance is given in UK (BSI) PD
storey buildings meeting or not 6698.
conditions (a) and (b) of BS EN 1998-1,
4.2.3.2(8).
4.2.4(2)P Ratio ϕ of coefficient ψEi on variable mass Use the recommended values.
Type of variable Storey ϕ
t
used in seismic analysis to combination
en
coefficient ψ2i for quasi permanent values action
of variable actions. Categories A–C* Roof 1.0
Storeys with correlated 0.8
m
occupancies
Independently 0.5
om
occupied storeys
Categories D–F* 1.0
and Archives
C
* Categories as defined in MS EN 1991-1-1.
lic
4.2.5(5)P Importance factor γI for buildings. Class I: γI = 0.8 Class I: γI = 0.8
Class III: γI = 1.2 Class III: γI = 1.2
ub
Class IV: γI = 1.5
Class IV: γI = 1.4 Refer to Annex B.
rP
4.3.3.1(4) Decision on whether nonlinear methods None None
of analysis may be applied for the design
of non- base-isolated buildings.
Fo
15D005R0 q
4.3.3.1 (8) None 3D (spatial) analysis models are
relating to the permitted use of analysis recommended.
with two planar models.
5
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015 (continued)
15D005R0 q
6
4.4.2.5(2) Overstrength factor γRd for diaphragms. For brittle failure modes, such as shear, γRd =1.3. Use the recommended values.
For ductile failure modes, γRd =1.1
4.4.3.2(2) Reduction factor ν for displacements at Class I & II: v = 0.5 Only Class IV buildings need to be checked for
damage limitation limit state. Class III & IV: v = 0.4 damage limitation limit state based on a return
period of 475 years.
v = 0.5 is to be adopted.
t
5.2.1(5) Geographical limitations on use of None None
en
ductility classes for concrete buildings.
5.2.2.2(10) qo-value for concrete buildings subjected Adjustment to qo-value is a factor in the range 1 to 1.2, No adjustment is permitted on qo-value.
m
to special Quality System Plan. with no recommended value within this range.
om
5.2.4(1), (3) Material partial factors for concrete Use the γc and γs values for the persistent and transient Use the recommended values.
buildings in the seismic design situation. design situations.
C
5.4.3.5.2(1) Minimum web reinforcement of large The minimum value for walls given in MS EN 1992-1-1 The minimum value for walls given in MS EN
lightly reinforced concrete walls. and its National Annex. 1992-1-1 and its National Annex. Single layer
of reinforcing in a wall is not recommended.
lic
5.8.2(3) Minimum cross-sectional width bw, min and Buildings up to 3 storeys: Use the recommended values.
© STANDARDS MALAYSIA 2016 - All rights reserved
ub
beams hw, min = 0.4 m
Buildings with 4 or more storeys:
rP
bw, min = 0.25 m
hw, min = 0.5 m
5.8.2(4) Minimum thickness tmin and t min = 0.2 m Use the recommended values.
Fo
5.8.2(5) Minimum reinforcement ratio ρb, min of ρb, min = 0.4 % ρb, min = 0.2 % in top face and 0.2 % in bottom
concrete foundation beams. face
5.11.1.3.2(3) Ductility class of precast wall panel DCM No specific requirement for precast wall panel
systems. systems.
© STANDARDS MALAYSIA 2016 - All rights reserved
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015 (continued)
Clause Nationally Determined Parameter Eurocode recommendation Malaysia decision
5.11.1.4 Factor kp on q-factors of precast kp = 1.0 for structures with connections conforming Use the recommended values.
systems. to MS EN 1998-1, 5.11.2.1.1, 5.11.2.1.2, or 5.11.2.1.3
kp = 0.5 for structures with other types of connection
5.11.1.5(2) Ratio Ap of transient seismic action Ap = 0.3 unless otherwise specified by special studies In the absence of a site specific assessment,
t
use the recommended value.
en
assumed during erection of precast
structures to design seismic action
defined in MS EN 1998-1, Section 3.
m
5.11.3.4(7)e) Minimum longitudinal steel ρc, min in ρc, min = 1 % Use the recommended values.
grouted connections.
om
6.1.2(1) Upper limit of q for low-dissipative 1.5 2.0
structural behaviour concept. Further guidance is given in PD 6698.
C
Limitations on structural behaviour None No limitation on structural behaviour concept.
lic
concept. Further guidance is given in PD 6698.
ub
ductility classes for steel buildings. is given in PD 6698.
rP
6.1.3(1) Material partial factors for steel buildings Use the γs values for the persistent and transient design Use the recommended values.
in the seismic design situation. situations.
Fo
6.2(3) Overstrength factor for capacity design of γov = 1.25 Use the recommended values.
steel buildings.
6.2(7) Information as to how EN 1993-1-10 – None The fracture toughness and through thickness
selection of steel for fracture toughness properties of the steel should be selected on a
and through thickness properties – may project specific basis. Further guidance is
15D005R0 q
be used in the seismic design situation. given in PD 6698.
6.5.5(7) Reference to complementary rules on None Complementary rules for connection design
acceptable connection design. may be developed on a project-specific basis.
Further guidance is given in PD 6698.
7
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015 (continued)
15D005R0 q
8
6.7.4(2) Residual post-buckling resistance of γpb = 0.3 γpb = γpb * Nb,Rd (λ bar)/Npl, Rd
compression diagonals in steel frames (γpb * times design buckling resistance over
with V- bracings. plastic resistance)
γpb* = 0.7 for q ≤ 2
γpb* = 0.3 for q ≥ 5
For 2 ≤ q ≤ 5, γpb* = 0.3 may be assumed or
refer to PD 6698.
t
Further guidance is given in PD 6698.
en
7.1.2(1) Upper limit of q for low-dissipative 1.5
m
structural behaviour concept.
Limitations on structural behaviour None
om
concept.
C
ductility classes for composite steel-
concrete buildings.
7.1.3(1), (3) Material partial factors for composite Use the γs values for the persistent and transient design
lic
steel concrete buildings in the seismic situations.
© STANDARDS MALAYSIA 2016 - All rights reserved
design situation.
ub
7.1.3(4) Overstrength factor for capacity design of γov = 1.25
composite steel-concrete buildings.
rP
7.7.2(4) Stiffness reduction factor for concrete r = 0.5
part of a composite steel-concrete
column section.
Fo
9.2.3(1) Minimum strength of mortar in masonry fm,min = 5 N/mm2 (unreinforced or confined masonry)
buildings. fm,min = 10 N/mm2 (reinforced masonry)
9.2.4(1) Alternative classes for perpend joints in None
masonry.
t
1996-1 alone.
en
9.3(2) Minimum effective thickness tef,min of None
unreinforced masonry walls satisfying
m
provisions of BS EN 1996-1 alone.
9.3(3) Maximum value of ground acceleration ag,urm = 0.2 g
om
ag,urm for the use of unreinforced
masonry satisfying provisions of MS
EN1998-1.
C
9.3(4), q-factor values in masonry buildings. Unreinforced masonry in
Table 9.1
lic
accordance with MS EN 1998-1: q = 1.5
Confined masonry: q = 2.0
ub
Reinforced masonry: q = 2.5
9.3(4), q-factors for buildings with masonry None
Table 9.1 systems which provide enhanced
rP
ductility.
Fo
15D005R0 q
9
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015 (continued)
15D005R0 q
10
t
Unreinforced, with any 170 15 0.35
en
other type of units, in
cases of low seismicity
Confined masonry 240 15 0.3
m
Reinforced masonry 240 15 No
restriction
om
Symbols used have the following meaning:
tef thickness of the wall (see BS EN 1996-1-1);
C
hef effective height of the wall (see BS EN 1996 1-1);
h greater clear height of the openings adjacent to the
lic
wall;
l length of the wall.
© STANDARDS MALAYSIA 2016 - All rights
ub
9.6(3) Material partial factors in masonry γm = 2/3 of value specified in National Annex to
buildings in the seismic design situation. BS EN 1996-1, but not less than 1.5.
rP
γs = 1.0
Fo
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015 (continued)
© STANDARDS MALAYSIA 2016 - All rights reserved
9.7.2(1) Maximum number of storeys and Acceleration at site ≤ 0,07 ≤ 0,10 ≤ 0,15 ≤ 0,20
minimum area of shear walls of “simple ag.S k.g k.g k.g k.g
masonry building”.
Type of Number Minimum sum of cross-
of sections areas of horizontal
Construction storeys shear walls in each
(n)** direction, as percentage of
the total floor area per
storey(pA,min)
t
en
Unreinforced 1 2.0 % 2.0 % 3.5 % n/a
masonry 2 2.0 % 2.5 % 5.0 % n/a
3 3.0 % 5.0 % n/a n/a
m
4 5.0 % n/a* n/a n/a
Confined 1 2.0 % 2.5 % 3.0 % 3.5 %
om
masonry 2 2.0 % 3.0 % 4.0 % n/a
3 4.0 % 5.0 % n/a n/a
C
4 6.0 % n/a n/a n/a
Reinforced 1 2.0 % 2.0 % 2.0 % 3.5 %
masonry 2 2.0 % 2.0 % 3.0 % 5.0 %
lic
3 3.0 % 4.0 % 5.0 % n/a
4 4.0 % 5.0 % n/a n/a
ub
* n/a means “not acceptable”.
** Roof space above full storeys is not included in
rP
the number of storeys.
Fo
15D005R0 q
expressed as a percentage pmax of the
total floor plan area above the level
considered.
11
Table NA.1 Malaysia values for Nationally Determined Parameters described in MS EN 1998-1:2015 (continued)
15D005R0 q
12
10.3(2)P Magnification factor γx on seismic γx = 1.2 for buildings Use the recommended value.
displacements for isolation devices.
t
en
Malaysia decision not indicated shall use recommended value of MS EN1998-1:2015.
m
om
C
lic
© STANDARDS MALAYSIA 2016 - All rights
ub
rP
Fo
15D005R0 q
MS EN 1998-1:2015 informative Annex A should not be used. The basis of the Malaysia
response spectrum is based on elastic displacement.
t
en
The following contains non-contradictory complementary information for use with MS EN 1998-
1:2015:
m
PD 6698:2008, Background paper to the UK National Annexes to BS EN 1998-1, BS EN
om
1998-2, BS EN 1998-4, BS EN 1998-5 and BS EN 1998-6.
C
lic
ub
rP
Fo
Annex A
(normative)
⎛ T2 ⎞
T ≤ T C : S De (T ) = S D (TD )⎜⎜ ⎟⎟
⎝ TCTD ⎠
⎛T ⎞
TC ≤ T ≤ T D : S De (T ) = S D (TD )⎜⎜ ⎟⎟
⎝ TD ⎠
t
en
T D ≤ T ≤ 4 : S De (T ) = S D (TD ) + m × (T − TD )
m
The elastic response spectrum model in the acceleration format can be conveniently obtained
by direct transformation from the displacement format using:
om
⎛ 2π ⎞
2
S e (T ) = S De (T ) × ⎜ ⎟
⎝ T ⎠
C
Ground Type TS S D (T D ) m TC TD
(s) (mm) (s) (s)
ub
4× HS
TS =
VS
The values of the site natural period (TS), small-strain shear modulus or shear wave velocity (SWV, VS) of soils can
be measured by various geotechnical or geophysical testing techniques. Sedimentary layers with SPT-N value
greater than 100 can be omitted in the computations of site natural period and weighted average SWV.
Generally two boreholes for a block of low-rise building is sufficient. Spacing of boreholes for multi-storey buildings
should be 15 m to 45 m. More boreholes are necessary for problematic and erratic soil formation. The arithmetic
mean of the site natural period TS shall be adopted for site classification.
* For TS > 1.0 s, or deposits consisting of at least 10 m thick of clays/silts with a high plasticity index (PI > 50),
dynamic site response analyses shall be performed or Type 1 elastic response spectrum for ground type D shall
be adopted.
Table A.2. Regional-dependent hazard parameters, agR, SDR (1.25), mR and mF for
notional 475 years return period
Figures NA.1 to NA.3 show the elastic horizontal response spectrum on rock sites in Malaysia
for Class IV structures (γI = 1.5) correspond to 2 475 years return period.
t
T ≥ 1.25: SDe(T) = (16 x 1.5) + (6.7 x 1.5)(T - 1.25)
en
50
SDe (mm)
40
m
om
30
20
C
10
lic
0
0 1 2 3 4
ub
T(s)
(a) Displacement Response Spectrum
rP
Fo
Figure NA.1. Elastic Response Spectrum on rock for Peninsular Malaysia (Notional
design PGA = 0.1 g, RP = 2 475 years)
20
SDe (mm)
15
10
t
0 1 2 3 4
en
T(s)
(a) Displacement Response Spectrum
m
om
C
lic
ub
rP
Fo
200
SDe (mm)
150
100
50
t
0 1 2 3 4
en
T(s)
(a) Displacement Response Spectrum
m
om
C
lic
ub
rP
Fo
Annex B
(normative)
Table B.1. Notional design PGA on rock sites for Peninsular Malaysia, Sarawak and
Sabah
t
Sarawak
en
I 0.8 Minor constructions 0.06 0.10
(0.8 x 0.07) (0.8 x 0.12)
II 1.0 Ordinary buildings
m
(individual dwellings or
0.07
Reference
0.12
Reference
om
shops in low rise buildings) PGA (notional PGA (notional
475 years RP) 475 years RP)
III 1.2 Buildings of large 0.08 0.14
C
communication facilities)
Fo
Bibliography
[1] MS EN 1992-1-1:2010, Eurocode 2 - Design of concrete structures - Part 1-1: General rules
and rules for buildings
[3] BS EN 1996-1-1:2005, Eurocode 6 - Design of masonry structures - Part 1-1: General rules
for reinforced and unreinforced masonry structures
t
1998-2, BS EN 1998-4, BS EN 1998-5 and BS EN 1998-6
en
m
om
C
lic
ub
rP
Fo
t
Mr. Ong Ka Thiam Master Builders Association Malaysia
en
En. Syed Hazni Syed Abd. Ghani Construction Industry Development Board,
Malaysia
Dr. Wan Azli bin Wan Hassan
m
Malaysia Meteorological Department/
Ministry of Science Technology & Innovation
om
Dr. Nazirah Ahmad Malaysian Rubber Board
Ir. Prof. Dr. Mohd. Zamin bin Jumaat University Malaya
Dr. Lau Tze Liang Universiti Sains Malaysia
C
t
en
Members of Working Group 6 (WG6) on Task Force on National Annex