Final Draft W Paper
Final Draft W Paper
DIET 3231W
Research Paper: Final Draft
May 5, 2018
one-third of adults are obese, and one in six children between the ages of 2 and 19 years
old are obese.(Ogden C.L et al., 2015) For children and adolescents ages 2 to 20 years,
obesity is characterized as a Body Mass Index at the 95th percentile or greater according to
a child’s age and sex.(Ogden C L et al., 2015) Obesity in children increases the risk of
acquiring many comorbid conditions, such as Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus, Hypertension, and
imbalance of between energy intake and expenditure. The concern today is that many
children are not getting sufficient activity, which increases the risk of energy
Physical activity is important as it: builds and maintains skeletal and cardiovascular
strength and endurance; increases sensitivity to insulin, in turn decreasing blood glucose
levels; and releases serotonin to boost self-esteem. The recommendation for physical
activity for children is 60 minutes of daily moderate- to vigorous- intensity physical activity
2018) Examples of MVPA include walking briskly or with purpose, mopping or vacuuming,
or raking a yard. Whereas vigorous-intensity physical activity includes walking very fast,
running, carrying heavy groceries or other loads upstairs, shoveling snow by hand, mowing
this activity.
This paper will explore the connection between physical activity and obesity,
focusing on the role that the neighborhood in which a child lives and how it influences the
amount they exercise. One barrier to a child’s ability to attain an adequate amount of
unsafe or lacks the facilities and programs necessary to facilitate and encourage physical
around the country, interventions should be multi-level following the social ecological
model: making policy changes, initiating school and community physical activity programs,
and helping families to adopt more active habits, in order to affect each individual child.
This paper will cover the following topics: general information about obesity and physical
activity, how a child’s environment affects the amount of physical activity they achieve, the
unsafe neighborhood and its effects on participation in physical activity, facilities and
This section will examine evidence of associations between physical activity and
obesity in community-based studies. The research discussed in this section was uncovered
by exploring the research done by searching PubMed with the terms ‘“physical activity”
Secondary data analysis of a large cross-sectional sample of U.S. children ages 11-18
(over 1300 children) revealed that children who did not engage in school-based physical
education(PE)-related physical activity were 1.6 times more likely to be obese compared
with those who met the national guidelines for weekly physical activity. In addition, the
analysis underscored the relationship between the duration of physical activity and the
BMI percentile among children. The children who participated in physical activity <112
minutes/week had a similar result as those getting no physical activity, supporting the
need for children to obtain 60 minutes per day to lower their risk of excessive adiposity.
Furthermore, more males than females participated in PE-related physical activity in the
average week; approximately 5% more males meet the national requirement of PE-related
Overall, the study discovered that 32.5% of middle and high school students do not
get any PE-based physical activity. (Hohensee & Nies, 2014) However, the study is not
without limitations. The use of a large data set does not allow for the addition of other
variables of interest. Similarly, missing data can only be estimated or excluded from the
data set, not regenerated. Specifically, in this study, age and race/ethnicity contained
missing data. Furthermore, the physical activity data collected included only PE-related
physical activity, and did not include physical activity during lunchtime or recess. Thus,
some children may not be meeting the physical activity requirements during PE, but they
may engage in physical activity during lunch or recess periods. Finally, collecting self-
reported data on physical activity duration and frequency may be a cognitive challenge for
provided in the International Study of Childhood Obesity, Lifestyle and the Environment
(ISCOLE) study.(Katzmarzyk et al., 2015) The sample was at least 500 children ages 9 to
11 per site, from 12 multinational sites. The data collection was cross-sectional and
included lifestyle behaviors including sleep duration, time spent doing moderate to
vigorous physical activity, and dietary intake patterns. The analysis revealed that
lower odds of obesity, in boys and girls, and independent of sleep, TV watching, diet
patterns, and demographic variables (Table 2, Model 2). Of these additional lifestyle
with decreased risk of obesity. Improved factors that encourage or facilitate physical
activity participation in the environment can reduce the risk of obesity. It is not only
important for cardiovascular and skeletal strength and endurance, but it is also crucial for
discuss the correlation between a child’s physical environment and their opportunity for
physical activity. The physical environment is defined as the characteristics of the physical
context in which a child spends their time, such as their school and neighborhood. It
includes features of urban design, traffic density and speed, distance and design of places of
physical activity, crime, safety, and weather condition.(Davison & Lawson, 2006)
A regression study using a large, population-based sample of middle and high school
students (mean participant age 14.5 years) in Minneapolis/St. Paul, MN, examined the
to food sources, access to recreational places, opportunities for physical activity, perceived
the sample, a higher BMI was significantly associated with a lower proportion of
park/recreation land and the perception of being unsafe during the day and night in both
boys and girls. Similarly, convenient access to unhealthy foods and lack of safe space for
both boys and girls. The researchers formed six clusters of neighborhoods, two of high SES,
one median SES, and three of low SES. These six clusters demonstrated the complexity of
the neighborhood environment, and contrary to the researcher’s hypothesis, all three low-
SES clusters contained high land use for parks/recreation or were in proximity to
recreational facilities. The limitations of this study include that this study is not necessarily
generalizable, as all participants were drawn from schools within just one metropolitan
While each individual factor identified in the previous study is a contributing factor
in impacting the physical activity achieved within a neighborhood, the following study
looks at the neighborhood affect as a whole and its role in preventing or facilitating
data was collected through the formation of 8 focus groups meeting for semi-structured
sessions of 60-90 minutes in Greenville, South Carolina. The focus groups discussed
benefits to being physically active, neighborhood factors associated with physical activity
The sample included 76 residents with mean age 61.5 years, in which 72% was female, and
95% was Black. The participants were able to describe various benefits of physical activity,
and identified safety concerns as often inhibiting physical activity. They were also able to
recognize that seeing others engage in neighborhood physical activity influenced others to
participate in both physical and social activity. The residents demonstrated that they
viewed their neighborhoods as prime settings for physical activity and had many
suggestions for increasing their incidences of MVPA. The residents communicated that
implementing a walking track, walking groups, and cleaning up the neighborhood would all
greatly impact the participation of PA in the neighborhood. While the results from the
focus groups were promising, there were several limitations to the study. To begin, the
neighborhood president’s social network. This may have not provided the many other
valuable perspectives from other members in the neighborhoods. Finally, the participant
sample was fairly homogenous with respect to income, education, and race/ethnicity.
environment and physical activity for transport by looking at the potential moderating
effect of parent participation in walking and cycling. The study had a sample of 677
children with their parents across low and high SES areas. The mean age was 11.5 years of
age. 23% of the children were overweight and 6.2% were obese. Overall, 45% of children
walked the dog with a parent and 52.1% walked with a parent for fitness (at least once or
twice a month). There was no parent or child demographic differences between children
whose family was involved in co-participation when walking and cycling compared with
children who did not participate. Four factors were identified as having a positive
association on the number of incidences a child and parent participate in walking or cycling
in a week: the density of intersections, number of sport options available within 800m, and
the population density. In addition, parent accompanied walking and cycling were
significant positive associations of the frequency of a child’s walking and cycling trips. The
findings are pictured below in table 2. The limitations of this study include the use of
cross-sectional data, which means that the observed associations cannot be interpreted in
terms of causality. Furthermore, the study relied on parent reports on the frequency of
physical activity and thus may be overestimated. A final limitation is that this study only
examined a limited amount of physical environments were studied, so other factors such as
crime-related variables and the presence of nature were not examined. Regardless, this
cycling trips in the neighborhood. The study also indicated the connection identified by
previous research that the more parents co-participate with their children, the parents and
children have an increased confidence in the child’s ability to navigate traffic on their own,
increasing their frequency of using physical activity for transport. (Ghekiere et al., 2015)
The studies analyzed in this section the factors influencing an individual’s ability to
participate in MVPA within their neighborhood. The neighborhood can be used for walking
and cycling, a convenient mode of physical activity important for social interaction and
transport. The presence of green space and recreational facilities within a neighborhood
also associates with a lower BMI. These findings can help to guide future childhood obesity
interventions by encouraging the focus on parent encouragement and facilitating outdoor
This section will discuss the correlation between the actual measures of safety and
children. The research discussed in this section was uncovered by PubMed Searching using
perceived safety from crime, objectively-measured crime, and physical inactivity. The
review indicated a small but significant association between perceived safety from crime
and physical activity, indicating that feeling safe in the neighborhood has a 27% greater
odds of achieving higher physical activity. Figure 2 is a forest plot that demonstrates the
odds ratios of the included studies, analyzing physical activity participation in areas
relating to perceived safety from crime. Similarly, those living in areas with higher police-
reported crime have a 20% reduced odds of achieving higher levels of physical activity.
Other factors relating to safety and physical activity participation were identified but not
analyzed, including the income level of the country studied, age, gender, and racial/ethnic
minorities. However, this meta-analysis was limited by the small number of published
studies, impacting the extent to which it could analyze other factors identified that might
influence physical activity previously mentioned. (Rees-Punia, Hathaway, & Gay, 2017)
including physical activity, sedentary behavior and diet and BMI in which the participants
were 17 years or younger. The meta-analysis was performed to estimate the pooled effect
size of neighborhood safety on each outcome and behavior. Table 4 summarizes the
modeling results from the meta-analysis. A finding from the meta-analysis is that living in
significant) increase in BMI z-score and a reduction in weekly PA duration among children.
The finding, however, did not illustrate an association between these results and the risk of
childhood overweight and obesity. Children living in unsafe neighborhoods were found to
be associated with a significantly higher BMI by 0.018 standard deviations when compared
with their counterparts living in safe neighborhoods. Similarly, children living in unsafe
neighborhoods were associated with a decrease in the duration of weekly MVPA compared
with their counterparts living in safe neighborhoods. That said, unsafe neighborhoods were
not significantly associated with overweight or obesity in children. The limitations to this
study may explain the limited influence the safety of a child’s neighborhood has on weight-
related behaviors and outcomes. To begin, the effect of the safety of the neighborhood may
be over-shadowed by the direct effect of another factor such as the neighborhood food
diverse residential groups, which is not typically viable in these studies. Finally, the
measures on neighborhood safety were often not standardized and predominantly relied
a cohort of 6-11 year olds living in San Diego, CA to examine individual factors related to
weight, physical activity, and nutrition behaviors. Neighborhoods were given ratings
lighting, and litter to name a few. The City of San Diego’s police reported crime data was
then discussed and assessed for its association with participation in MVPA. From the
analysis, only police-reported crimes were associated with lower total MVPA. The
children’s MVPA was significantly lowered by 0.01 minute for each additional police-
reported crime in the neighborhood. Children living in the neighborhoods with the lowest
reported crimes had the highest total and neighborhood MVPA. There were limitations to
the study. To begin, all police-reported crimes were included, including those which may
not have an impact on children’s physical activity, such as fraud, for example. There is
evidence that the type of crime plays a role in affecting MVPA in children. Another
limitation is the generalizability of the findings; the sample was primarily non-Hispanic
white, and all were able bodied children ages 6-11 living in a single US city.(Kneeshaw-
safety and encouragement and child outdoor physical activity participation in low-income
children. The target population in this study lived in low-income areas and included
children eligible for Medicaid. Of the participants in this study, more than half of the
children were overweight or obese, and less than half (47%) of the parents were physically
active. The study identified that perceived neighborhood safety was significantly
associated with parent’s encouragement for boys physical activity; however, no significant
association was observed among girls. In both the adjusted and unadjusted models,
children have increased reported outdoor physical activity with parents that encourage
their child. Similarly, girls whose parents encouraged outdoor physical activity had higher
reported outdoor physical activity was greater when parent’s perceived their
neighborhood as safe. The figure of table 4 below demonstrates the unadjusted model of
parental perceived neighborhood safety and reported outdoor physical activity. This study
used both parent-reported and child-reported physical activity, and indicated that there
were discrepancies between the parent and child reports of physical activity participation.
The study had several limitations including a high nonresponse rate of around 10%,
resulting in a reduced sample size. In addition, the study may not be “adequately powered”
for all the research questions of interest. That said, the findings in this study can be used to
increase children’s participation in physical activity by educating parents the importance of
encouraging their children to participate in physical activity outside. (Nicksic et al., 2018)
The studies analyzed in this section identify the complex relationship between
perceived safety and physical activity, in which the effect of safety is not very large, though
neighborhoods to make them appear safer would be a valuable effort that would positively
impact physical activity participation, but should not be prioritized as a critical component
of intervention strategies.
This section was uncovered by PubMed Searching using the terms ‘”physical
activity” AND childhood obesity’ looking for interventions and analyses of physical activity
in schools and other community programs aimed to increase physical activity. The socio-
ecological model emphasizes the importance of multiple levels of organization that interact
and influence an individual.(Schuler & O'Reilly, 2017) To expand, habits and behaviors
formed at the individual level are influenced by policies and programs within the family,
the neighborhood, at school, within the community, and because of policies set by town,
implemented at each of these levels to have an effect on the amount of daily physical
activity achieved by each individual child and, in turn, affecting overall obesity rates in
children.
environment and physical health, 649,442 total Taiwanese students grades 7 to 9 across
urban and rural settings were studied. Schools were analyzed for their facilities and their
location (rural versus urban). The analysis indicated that the students performed better
on the physical fitness tests attended schools with more space for physical activity. Boys in
schools with access to a sports field performed better on the fitness tests then those
without access. Girls with access to sports fields had significantly higher endurance,
explosive power, and cardiorespiratory ability than those who didn’t have access to sports
field. Table 3 below demonstrates the aforementioned findings. (Lo et al., 2017)
Another study analyzed the longitudinal relationship between community programs
and policies to prevent childhood obesity and BMI in children, the Healthy Communities
programs and policies (CPPs), to determine the relationship between BMI in children and
the intensity of the CPP. A total of 9681 CPPs were identified and characterized through
interviews with 10-14 key informants per community and supplemented with reviews of
reports. Each CPP was given intensity score based on the behavior change strategy,
duration, reach, and other dimensions like target behavior and the sector through which it
was delivered. A higher score was given to programs that reached a greater proportion of
the community, that were ongoing, and that modified policies or access, barriers and
opportunities as opposed to those that provided information and enhanced skills. The
scores given were low (0.1), medium (0.5), or high (1) for each of the dimensions, and a
weighted score was averaged over the three dimensions then summed to create an annual
intensity score for the program. BMI data was collected from pediatric health care
providers of families and by trained field data collection personnel during at home visits.
Linear mixed effects models were used to assess longitudinal relationships between
the CPP intensity scores and childhood BMI, with adjustments made for correlation among
participants from within the same school/community and repeated measures on children.
The relationship between BMI and CPP intensity differed significantly with a child’s grade
in school, race, ethnicity, family income and parental education, but did not differ
relationship between BMI and CPP intensity also differed significantly by community
race/ethnicity, but not by region, urbanity, or community income. The relationship was
also significantly different for children in grades K-2 and 6-8, but not for grades 3-5.
The parameter that captured the relationship between the CPP intensity and
childhood BMI demonstrates that if a community at the minimum observed CPP intensity
score was instead at the maximum observed CPP score, the children were predicted to have
BMIs of about 1.6 BMI units smaller. The finding that higher CPP scores are associated with
lower BMI in a large diverse sample of US children suggests that community programs
aimed to decrease childhood obesity over the past 10 years had a beneficial effect.
However, there were no statistically significant differences in the CPP intensity scores
limitations in recall for the documentation of CPPs, which affected the intensity scores of
CPPs further back in time. Another important limitation of this study is due to the methods
used to recruit children and key informants within the same school, factors related to non-
The articles reviewed in this section identify programs that are beneficial for
facilitating physical activity. Physical education and space for participating in physical
within a neighborhood, affecting the family and the child to increase their participation in
physical activity.
This section was uncovered using the framework described in the early article by
Heath et al. The article explores the effects and efficacy of interventions implemented to
change physical activity participation within neighborhoods. In addition to land use, the
article demonstrates the relationship existing between the built environment, funding
people residing within walking distance of shopping, work, and school; improved
implemented include body mass index screening, a healthier school meal program, a new
physical education program, and a comprehensive school physical activity program. The
study revealed a 2.5% absolute decrease in obesity from 2006 to 2012. These findings
were in contrast with the 2.5% absolute increase in obesity prevalence documented by the
NHANES national data, indicating that the decrease in obesity in Mebane, NC was related to
the intervention strategies implemented and not a result of a nationwide declining trend.
Finally, the most important finding in this case study was that the highest dose score was
calculated for the physical activity intervention portion which ranged from a 5.6-9.7% in
physical activity due to its high reach and the strength of the strategy. The study did have
some limitations, however. The study did not evaluate changes in the environment outside
of the school setting that could influence a child’s weight status over time. In addition, the
dose was assessed at the end of the study period and reflects an estimation of
implementation at the end of six years, instead of throughout the six years. Finally, while
the study is a promising indicator of different interventions that can be made within the
school setting alone to decrease obesity rates, the findings are not generalizable.(Heelan, et
al., 2015)
The American Heart Association published an article discussing the idea of shared
recreation spaces based on research done analyzing physical activity habits in America. In
this article, the organization proposes a policy allowing school recreation facilities (such as
sports fields and playground spaces) as a way to provide convenient and economical
spaces for communities. This involves opening school grounds and even some school
buildings during non-school hours for the use of all members of the community. The
shared use can be in the form of a formal, written contract, or an informal agreement
between the school or district and the individuals or organizations wishing to use the
property. The challenges to this policy include: providing adequate funds necessary to
maintain the school facilities for extra hours, establishing the coordination and
communication among the various individuals and organizations wishing to use the
property, and ensuring protection from liability, crime, and other damaging risks that could
affect the school’s ability to function during the normal school hours. (Young et al., 2014)
Policies can be implemented at each level of the social ecological model: policy within
schools, communities, towns, and even up to the county, state, and national level. Each of
these levels impact a child’s experience within their neighborhood and their family, and in
turn will impact the child, thus demonstrating the importance of policies as a method of
obesity intervention.
The following section was uncovered through the presentation of other research
being performed in the field of childhood obesity. As mentioned throughout this paper,
factor influencing a child’s BMI, many other factors also significantly impact adiposity and
One of factor that impacts a child’s risk of obesity is sleep. Decreased sleep
bedtime is also associated with higher obesity risk. When a child is lacking in sleep, they
will have increased energy consumption following the sleep restriction. Thus, sleep
indirectly impacts a child’s energy imbalance, which is the basis for obesity as discussed in
Another factor that impacts a child’s risk of obesity is the presence of food outlets in
the physical environment. Unhealthy food outlets include but are not limited to fast food
identified a significant positive association between the density of unhealthy food outlets
and the prevalence of overweight and obesity in children. The analysis compared the
association in children ages 4-5years old and ages 10-11 years old, and found that the
correlation is greater in the older group, with over a 3.5% difference between the age
Inadequate sleep duration and the presence of unhealthy food outlets in the physical
environment are two factors significantly associated with an increased risk of overweight
Conclusion
Energy imbalance is the main cause of childhood obesity. This imbalance can be a
food options due to the presence of unhealthy food outlets in the neighborhood, or many
other mediating factors. Increasing physical activity participation in children has life-long
health benefits in addition to reducing their risk of overweight and obesity. The
environment in which a child is raised can either hinder their ability to be physically active,
or can be one that encourages physical activity throughout the community. To successfully
neighborhood and school, community, and policy levels, both state and federal.
References
2018 Physical Activity Guidelines Advisory Committee. (2018). 2018 physical activity
guidelines advisory committee scientific report (Scientific Report. Washington, DC: U.S.
An, R., Yang, Y., Hoschke, A., Xue, H., & Wang, Y. (2017). Influence of neighbourhood safety
Obesity Reviews : An Official Journal of the International Association for the Study of
Cetateanu, A., & Jones, A. (2014). Understanding the relationship between food
Child, S. T., Kaczynski, A. T., Fair, M. L., Stowe, E. W., Hughey, S. M., Boeckermann, L., et al.
(2017). 'We need a safe, walkable way to connect our sisters and brothers': A
Davison, K. K., & Lawson, C. T. (2006). Do attributes in the physical environment influence
Ghekiere, A., Carver, A., Veitch, J., Salmon, J., Deforche, B., & Timperino, A. (2015). Does
physical neighbourhood environment and active transport among 10-12 year olds?
The effectiveness of urban design and land use and transport policies and practices to
increase physical activity: A systematic review. Journal of Physical Activity & Health,
Heelan, K. A., Bartee, R. T., Nihiser, A., & Sherry, B. (2015). Healthier school environment
leads to decreases in childhood obesity – the kearney nebraska story. Childhood
Hohensee, C. W., & Nies, M. A. (2014). Physical activity in american schools and body mass
index percentile. Journal of Child Health Care : For Professionals Working with Children
Katzmarzyk, P. T., Barreira, T. V., Broyles, S. T., Champagne, C. M., Chaput, J. P., Fogelholm,
M., et al. (2015). Relationship between lifestyle behaviors and obesity in children ages
9-11: Results from a 12-country study. Obesity (Silver Spring, Md.), 23(8), 1696-1702.
doi:10.1002/oby.21152 [doi]
Kneeshaw-Price, S. H., Saelens, B. E., Sallis, J. F., Frank, L. D., Grembowski, D. E., Hannon, P.
A., et al. (2015). Neighborhood crime-related safety and its relation to children’s
physical activity. Journal of Urban Health : Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine,
Lo, K. Y., Wu, M. C., Tung, S. C., Hsieh, C. C., Yao, H. H., & Ho, C. C. (2017). Assocation of school
childhood. Current Opinion in Endocrinology, Diabetes, and Obesity Journal, 22(1), 41-47.
Nicksic, N. E., Salahuddin, M., Butte, N. F., & Hoelscher, D. M. (2018). Associations between
activity among low-income children. Journal of Physical Activity & Health, 15(5), 317-
Ogden C L, Carroll M D, Fryar C D, & Flegal K M. (2015). Prevalence of obesity among adults
and youth (NCHS Data Brief No. 219). Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health
Statistics.
Rees-Punia, E., Hathaway, E. D., & Gay, J. L. (2017). Crime, perceived safety, and physical
Schuler, B. R., & O'Reilly, N. (2017). Child development and the community environment:
Understanding overweight across the income gradient. Childhood Obesity (Print), 13(6),
Strauss, W. J., Nagaraja, J., Landgraf, A. J., Arteaga, S. S., Fawcett, S. B., Ritchie, L. D., et al.
prevent childhood obesity and BMI in children: The healthy communities study.
Wall, M. M., Larson, N. I., Forsyth, A., Van Riper, D. C., Graham, D. J., Story, M. T., et al. (2012).
doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2012.02.009 [doi]
Young, D. R., Spengler, J. O., Frost, N., Evenson, K. R., Vincent, J. M., & Whitsel, L. (2014).
Promoting physical activity through the shared use of school recreational spaces: A
policy statement from the american heart association. American Journal of Public