U
n
i
v
er
 si
  t
  yJD
    e
    nt
     Sc
      ie
       20
        1
        5
        ;1(
          2
          ):
           60-
             66                                                                                                   University
                                                                                                                  Journal of
                                                                                                                Dental Sciences
SINGLE VISIT MTA APEXIFICATION
                                                                                                                        Case
TECHNIQUE FOR FORMATION                                                                                                 Series
OF ROOT-END BARRIER IN
OPEN APICES- A CASE SERIES
1
Bhumika Kapoor, 2Osama Adeel Khan Sherwani, 3Rajendra K Tewari, 4Surendra K Mishra.
1,2
 Junior Resident, 3,4Professor, Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics.
Dr. Z. A. Dental College & Hospital, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh
ABSTRACT: Mineral trioxide aggregate apexification is a viable option for treatment of open
apex. MTA forms an apical barrier at the root end against which endodontic treatment can be
successfully completed. The multiple advantages of MTA such as its biocompatibility, sealing           Keywords :
ability, antimicrobial properties, bioactivity along with single appointment treatment option for      Mineral trioxide aggregate,
open apex is a boon in the field of endodontics. Using calcium hydroxide for root end formation        open apex, apexification.
has many disadvantages like decrease in strength of radicular dentin and long follow up visits.
Therefore, MTA is material of choice for such cases. However, using calcium hydroxide dressing         Source of support : Nil
before MTA placement increases pH of acidic environment and hence maintains hydrated gel like          Conflict of interest : None
structure of MTA.The following case series represents 4 cases of open apex in which MTA was
used for root end barrier formation against which obturation was done successfully.
INTRODUCTION : Apexification is defined as a method to                   appointment apexification was done with MTA.
induce a calcified barrier in a root with an open apex or
continued apical development of an incompletely formed root              CASE REPORT 1: An 11 year old boy was referred to
in teeth with necrotic pulp tissue(1). Several materials are             Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics,
used for the management of open apices. The most widely                  Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh with the chief complaint
used material until recently was calcium hydroxide that was              of spontaneous pain in upper front teeth. He had a trauma 3
replaced over intervals for several months, to stimulate                 years back but was asymptomatic till recently.
calcific barrier formation. Torabinejad and Chivian                      Clinical examination revealed fracture of tooth 11. The tooth
introduced mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) as an apical                 was tender on percussion and labial mucosa of the concerned
plug and now it is an accepted material for apexification till           tooth showed inflammation. The tooth was painful on
date.                                                                    palpation.
The use of calcium hydroxide affects various mechanical                  Intraoral radiograph showed incomplete root end formation
properties of radicular dentin (2). The alkaline pH of calcium           of 11. The dentinal walls were thick. (Fig1)
hydroxide increases the chances of fracture due to
denaturation of dentinal organic proteins. Hence, it is not
recommended in teeth with thin dentinal walls.
Mineral Trioxide Aggregate is a powder consisting of fine
hydrophilic particles of tricalcium silicate, tricalcium
aluminate, tricalcium oxide and silicate oxide. It also contains
small amounts of other mineral oxides, which modify its
chemical and physical properties. Radio opacity is provided              Fig1: Preoperative radiograph revealed open apex in tooth 11.
by bismuth oxide. The pH of MTA IS 12.5 which imparts it
antimicrobial activity(3). MTA has good sealing ability, good            Pulp testing was done with pulp tester (Parkell inc, USA) and
biocompatibility, excellent long term prognosis and ability of           thermal test with heated gutta percha, showed no response in
tissue regeneration. These properties prove it to be a material          the suspected tooth when compared to adjacent, contralateral
of choice for cases with high failure rates. The following case          tooth. The tooth was diagnosed with pulp necrosis with
series consist of 4 cases with open apex in which single                 periradicular periodontitis.
                                                                    60
U
n
i
v
er
 si
  t
  yJD
    e
    nt
     Sc
      ie
       20
        1
        5
        ;1(
          2
          ):
           60-
             66
The patient was discussed with various treatment plans and                        CASE REPORT 2:
consent was obtained. Following isolation with a rubber dam,                      A 14 year old boy was referred to the Department of
an endodontic access opening was made. Working length was                         conservative dentistry and endodntics, AMU Aligarh with the
established with the help of intraoral periapical radiograph                      chief complaint of pus discharge from the openings near the
using 80K file. Minimum instrumentation was done and the                          root apex of tooth 11. He had trauma 4 years back but was not
walls of canal were circumferentially cleaned with 80K file.                      symptomatic till last 2 months.
The root canal was copiously irrigated with 5.25% sodium                          Clinical examination revealed fractured tooth 11 involving
hypochlorite and normal saline. Intracanal dressing with                          the pulp. Sinus opening was present near the root apex. The
calcium hydroxide (Ultradent Products inc, USA) was given                         tooth was not tender on percussion and there was no pain on
for one week and the provisional restoration with Cavit(Cavit                     palpation. Labial mucosa adjacent to the concerned tooth was
GTM) was given. On recall visit, the tooth was asymptomatic.                      inflamed.
The temporary restoration was removed and canal was                               Intraoral periapical radiograph showed open apex of tooth 11.
irrigated with normal saline and dried with size 80 absorbent                     The dentinal walls were thin.(fig 4)
paper point(Ultradent Products inc, USA). A suitable plugger
size that fitted loosely within 2mm of apex was chosen. MTA
was mixed with distilled water to a consistency of wet sand
and placed in increments in the apical region of the canal
using Micro Apical Placement (MAP) system(DENTSPLY
Tulsa).Mineral trioxide aggregate was compacted with the
plugger previously fitted to the root canal system. Care was
taken to prevent extrusion of the material into the periapical                    Fig 4: IOPA revealed open apex in tooth 11
area. The final adjustment was done with inverted cut end of
gutta percha size 80(Dentsply, USA) with the help of                              Treatment protocols included apexification with calcium
radiograph till a minimum thickness of 5mm. Once the MTA                          hydroxide, single visit MTA apexification and
layer is adequately compacted to the working length and                           revascularization technique. The patient gave consent for
confirmed with a radiograph,(fig 2) the excess was removed                        single appointment apexification as he could not report at
from the coronal and middle third of the canal with the help of                   regular intervals.
sterile wet fine brush.A moist cotton pellet was placed against                    Following isolation with a rubber dam, an endodontic access
it, as the presence of moisture is essential for the material to                  opening was made. Working length was established with the
set.The access cavity was temporized. The patient was                             help of intraoral periapical radiograph using 80K file.
recalled after 24 hours. At the next appointment, the MTA felt                    Minimum instrumentation was done and the walls of canal
hard to an endodontic explorer DG-16 (Hu-Friedy                                   were circumferentially cleaned with 80K file. The root canal
International).The remaining part of the root canal was back-                     was copiously irrigated with 5.25% sodium hypochlorite and
filled with injection molded thermoplastic gutta-percha                           normal saline. Intracanal dressing with calcium hydroxide
(Obtura III, USA) and sealer (AH 26, Dentsply, Germany).                          (Ultradent Products inc, USA) was given for one week and
Post obturation radiograph was taken.The patient was asked                        access cavity was temporized with Cavit ( Cavit GTM). On
to report after a week for clinical evaluation and the post                       recall visit, the tooth was asymptomatic. The temporary
endodontic restoration. During recall, the tooth was                              restoration was removed and canal was irrigated with normal
asymptomatic and post endodontic composite (Tetric Ceram,                         saline and dried with size 80 absorbent paper point (Ultradent
Ivoclar Vivadent Inc) restoration was placed(fig 3) and                           Products inc, USA). A suitable plugger was chosen. MTA
patient was recalled after 3,6,12 months for the follow-up.                       was mixed with distilled water to a consistency of wet sand
                                                                                  and placed in increments in the apical region of the canal
                                                                                  using Micro Apical Placement (MAP) system
                                                                                  (DENTSPLYTulsa).Mineral trioxide aggregate was
                                                                                  compacted with the help of plugger. Care was taken to prevent
Fig 2: Mineral trioxide aggregate plug   Fig 3: Post obturation radiograph        extrusion of the material into the periapical area. The
                                                                             61
U
n
i
v
er
 si
  t
  yJD
    e
    nt
     Sc
      ie
       20
        1
        5
        ;1(
          2
          ):
           60-
             66
thickness of MTA was kept 5mm and a moist cotton pellet                     help of suitable carrier gun. The material was then condensed
was placed against it for proper setting(fig 5).Access cavity               to a thickness of 5mm and confirmed radiographically. A wet
was given temporary restoration. Patient was recalled next                  cotton pellet was placed over cement for proper setting.
day for obturation. Obturation was done with                                Patient was recalled further for custom made cast post and
thermoplastisized technique using Obtura III (Obtura                        crown fabrication (fig 8). The patient was kept on follow up.
Spartan,Canada). The patient was asked to report after a week
for clinical evaluation and the post endodontic restoration (fig
6). During recall, the tooth was asymptomatic and post
endodontic composite (Tetric Ceram, Ivoclar Vivadent Inc)
restoration was placed and patient was recalled after 3,6,12
months for the follow-up.
                                                                              Fig 7: Preoperative radiograph     Fig 8: MTA condensed at
                                                                                 showing open apex and            the apex. Cast post and
                                                                                  crown in tooth 21 with             crown fabricated
                                                                                 no endodontic treatment
                                                                            CASE REPORT 4: An18 year old female patient reported in
                                                                            department of conservative dentistry and endodontics, AMU
Fig 5: MTA condensed at the apex   Fig 6: Post obturation radiograph        Aligarh. She complained of pain in upper front teeth. The
                                                                            patient had trauma 7 years back.
CASE REPORT 3: A 21 year old female patient reported to                     On examination, tooth 11 was fractured. There was a sinus
Department of Conservative Dentistry and endodontics,                       tract in relation to tooth 11 and 12 and there was pain on
AMU Aligarh. She complained of pain in upper front left                     palpation
tooth since last 4 months.                                                  Intra oral radiograph revealed large periapical pathology in
On examination , tooth 21 had a crown placed on it. The tooth               relation to tooth 11 and 12. Tooth 11 showed open apex and
was tender on percussion and there was pain on palpation.                   exposed pulp. (fig 9)
Intraoral periapical radiograph revealed open apex of tooth                 Endodontic management of both teeth were decided with
21. The tooth was not endodontically treated and the crown                  single appointment MTA apexification for tooth 11 and root
was placed on it. The dentinal walls were thick (fig 7)                     canal treatment for tooth 12.The teeth were isolated by rubber
Single appointment MTA apexification was planned. On the                    dam and access cavity was made. The working length was
first appointment the crown was removed using crown                         established with the help of intraoral radiograph. The canal
removal system(Safe crown and bridge removal, Anthogyr)                     walls of tooth 11 were circumferentially cleaned with 80K file
The tooth was isolated by rubber dam and access cavity was                  and copious irrigation was done with 5.25% hypochlorite and
made through remaining tooth structure. The working length                  normal saline. For tooth 12, chemomechanical preparation
was established with the help of intraoral radiograph. The                  was performed with hand K Files (Dentsply, USA).Calcium
canal walls were circumferentially cleaned with 80K file and                hydroxide ( Ultradent Products inc, USA) dressing was
copious irrigation was done with 5.25% hypochlorite and                     placed for 1 week. The tooth was given temporary restoration
normal saline. Calcium hydroxide (Ultradent Products inc,                   with cavit (Cavit GTM3M ESPE, Seefeld, Germany). After 1
USA) dressing was placed for 1 week. The tooth was given                    week, the patient was symptomatic, therefore, second
temporary restoration with cavit (Cavit GTM3M ESPE,                         calcium hydroxide dressing was placed. On the next
Seefeld, Germany) After 1 week, patient was asymptomatic                    appointment, the provisional restoration was removed and
and tooth was not tender on percussion. The temporary                       irrigation was performed to remove all calcium hydroxide.
restoration was removed and irrigation with hypochlorite and                The canal was dried with paper points and MTA was mixed
normal saline was performed to remove calcium hydroxide                     with distilled water and placed in apical region with help of
from the canal. Absorbent paper points (Ultradent Products                  suitable carrier gun. The material was then condensed to a
inc, USA) was used to dry the canal completely. MTA was                     thickness of 5mm and confirmed radiographically(fig 10). A
mixed with distilled water and placed in apical region with                 wet cotton pellet was placed over cement for proper setting.
                                                                       62
U
n
i
v
er
 si
  t
  yJD
    e
    nt
     Sc
      ie
       20
        1
        5
        ;1(
          2
          ):
           60-
             66
Patient was recalled next day for obturation and post                   Open apices are usually seen in young individuals and hence
endodontic restoration. Tooth 11 was obturated using obtura             surgery is not a desirable treatment for this. The thin, fragile
III and tooth 12 was obturated with lateral condensation (fig           dentinal walls poses a threat to fracture on compaction of root
11)                                                                     end filling material. Also, patent dentinal tubules of young
                                                                        dentin cannot be sealed completely by root end filling
                                                                        material.
                                                                        Many materials have been reported to induce calcific barrier
                                                                        formation. The use of non setting calcium hydroxide was
                                                                        done by Kaiser in 1964(5) and later Frank(6) brought this to a
                Fig 9: Preoperative radiograph
                                                                        higher level. Coviello and Brilliant in 1979 introduced
             showing fractured 12 with open apex
                                                                        tricalcium phosphate(7)Later, Schumache and Rutledge in
                                                                        1993 suggested calcium hydroxide as a permanent apical
                                                                        barrier (8).
                                                                        The Frank's technique of placing calcium hydroxide
                                                                        sometimes provides inconsistent results like: 1) The periapex
                                                                        closes with a definite (though minimal) recession of the root
                                                                        canal. The apical aspect continues to develop with a
 Fig 10: MTA apical plug      Fig 11: Post obturation radiograph
                                                                        seemingly obliterated apex. 2) The obliterated apex develops
DISCUSSION :                                                            without any change in the root canal space. 3) A thin, calcific
Open apices have always been a challenge to an endodontist              bridge that is not radiographically discernable develops. 4) A
since it requires an apical barrier against which the canal can         calcific bridge forms just coronal to the apex and can be
be successfully obturated. Premature loss of permanent tooth            determined radiographically.
can lead to various problems such as wide, diverging or                  One of the major drawbacks of calcium hydroxide is that it is
parallel canals, inappropriate crown root ratio, thin dentinal          a multiple visit procedure. In this procedure, the calcium
walls etc. These problems can pose a threat to successful               hydroxide dressing is replaced every three months until a
treatment. Apart from this, fear of dentist of the young                barrier is formed, which may require up to 24 months. So,
individual and discontinuation of any treatment procedure are           such repetitive procedures are difficult to maintain.
other risk factors that may not lead to successful treatment.            The long term and short term of calcium hydroxide can affect
Apexification is the last treatment option of an immature               the mechanical properties of radicular dentin.(9,10,11) The
permanent tooth which has lost its pulpal vitality. It causes           pH of calcium hydroxide is 11.8 which is highly alkaline.
root end closure by forming an apical plug but does not cause           Some authors have proposed that the alkaline pH of Ca(OH)2
increase in root length and thickness or root end development           may lead to neutralization and denaturation of dentin organic
unlike apexogenesis or revascularization technique.                     proteins. This may cause collagen degradation leaving the
Apexogenesis is treatment to preserve vital pulp tissue in the          root more prone to fracture(2,12)
apical part of a root canal in order to complete formation of           Infection control is an upmost factor for any successful
root apex(4).Therefore, apexogenesis is only possible when              procedure. Similar, is the case with apexification where
some vital pulp is remaining . It was not possible in our cases         presence of infection can cause delay in root end
as all of them had necrotic pulp. Revascularization technique           closure(12,13) . However, some authors have claimed that
has an added advantage of complete formation of pulp dentin             there is no significant difference in apexification time when
complex. The defense mechanisms of pulp dentin complex is               infection is present(14,15,16) The long term procedures also
also completely established by regenerative techniques.                 exposes the risk of loss of coronal seal. This further can
However, long term follow up and uncertainty of the results             increase the duration of procedure as infection free
are disadvantages of revascularization protocol. Also, till date        environment cannot be maintained.
only case reports and case series have been reported for                Thus, keeping all facts in mind a single appointment, non
regeneration technique. The randomized controlled trails are            surgical approach to open apex is best treatment plan. A
still lacking for a definite evidence.                                  desirable material which can form an apical plug is required
                                                                   63
U
n
i
v
er
 si
  t
  yJD
    e
    nt
     Sc
      ie
       20
        1
        5
        ;1(
          2
          ):
           60-
             66
for this procedure. To, the best of our knowledge Mineral                by using MTA carrier or amalgam carrier and condensed with
trioxide aggregate (MTA) is material of choice for single                suitable pluggers and cut end of inverted GP cone no. 80. It is
appointment apexification and till date no material has been at          placed 4 to 5mm in thickness(27). The adequacy of material is
par with MTA. Torabinejad et al discovered orginal form of               verified radiographically. As the setting time of MTA is long
MTA which was gray MTA(17) The main constituents are                     and it needs moisture during setting procedure a moist cotton
calcium silicate(CaSiO4), bismuth oxide(Bi2O3), calcium                  is placed in the canal. While, placing the cotton it is kept in
carbonate(CaCO 3 ), calcium sulfate(CaSO 4 ), Calcium                    mind that cotton is not directly placed above MTA as cotton
Aluminate(CaAl2O4). MTA cement contains a hydrophilic                    fibers may get entrapped in the material. The tooth is then
powder that reacts with water and produces a calcium                     given suitable provisional restoration with tight coronal seal
hydroxide and calcium silicate hydrated gel.                             and canal is usually condensed with obturating material in the
A major advantage of MTA is its biocompatibility                         next appointment keeping in mind it's long setting time.
(18,19,20,21) and hard tissue formation. This hard tissue                It is difficult to prevent extrusion of material from
formation is because of ability of MTA to induce                         blunderbuss canals. Hence, placement of MTA is done with
cementoblastic cells(22) Scanning electron                               caution and it is placed 1 to 3mm short of root end. While,
microscope(SEM) analysis has shown that cementoblasts                    condensing MTA any voids should be avoided and it should
have ability to attach and grow on MTA. MTAforms a                       be condensed in a single plane. Any excess MTA sticking on
biologic barrier at the apical end which prevents regress of             the walls should be removed by scrubbing wet cotton or brush
microorganisms(23) It causes deposition of new cementum                  against canal walls.
and periodontal regeneration.                                            MTA is also not affected by blood contamination(28).
MTA has longest setting time of 2 hours and 45 minutes. The              Holland et al theorized that the tricalcium oxide in MTA
compressive strength is low 40MPa but it increases to 67MPa              reacts with tissue fluids to form calcium hydroxide, resulting
in 21 days. The initial pH is 10.2 which rises to 12.5 in 3 hours        in an apical barrier (29).Since , apexification is done in
after mixing. Gray MTA had a disadvantage of discoloration               necrotic pulp it is important to create an environment free
which was solved by discovery of white MTA in 2002 .The                  from microbes. This further renders the need of a material
composition of both varieties is similar and a difference of             with antibacterial properties . MTA is proved to possess some
less than 6 % is seen in any one of the component. The                   antibacterial properties. Torabinejad et al tested MTA,
radioopacity of both kinds is similar and it is 3.04mm of                amalgam, ZOE and SuperEBA against nine facultative
aluminum. However, placing gray MTA at the apex is not                   bacteria and seven strict anaerobes(3). Mineral trioxide
unaesthetic in anyway.                                                   aggregate was found to have an antibacterial effect on five of
 The use of MTA as an apical barrier was first reported in               nine facultative bacteria but no effect on any of the strict
1996.(24) Shabahanget al compared MTA, osteogenic                        anaerobes. The other materials had similar effects. It was
protein- 1 and Calcium hydroxide for apexification in                    concluded that none of the test materials had all of the
dogs(25) and found that MTA induced hard-tissue formation                antibacterial effects desired for a root-end filling material.
more often than any other test materials. Thus, MTA was                  Hachmeister et al emphasized that the apical plug thickness
suitable for use as an apical barrier for apexification in               may only have a significant impact on displacement
immature roots. In 2007, Simon et al used MTA on 57 teeth                resistance(30) while in the present case the thickness of
had showed successful results(26) .He concluded that that use            apical plug of MTA was 5 mm and the remaining part of the
of MTA reduces root fracture risk, had better patient                    root canal was back-filled with injection molded
compliance and showed early results.                                     thermoplastic gutta-percha (ObturaIII, USA) and sealer (AH
Before placement of MTA it is advocated to place calcium                 26, Dentsply, Germany).
hydroxide in the canal for 1 week interval for disinfection of
canal. The acidic pH raises which reduces inflammation of                CONCLUSION : The development of MTA is a milestone in
periapical tissues . After one week interval if the tooth is free        field of dentistry. The properties of MTA like its bioactivity,
from symptoms then the tooth is isolated with the help of                sealing ability and biocompatibility prove it to be an excellent
rubber dam and calcium hydroxide is washed away. After                   tool for cases that have poor prognosis. Many advantages of
drying of canal by paper points MTA is placed in increments              this material along with single appointment apical closure
                                                                    64
U
n
i
v
er
 si
  t
  yJD
    e
    nt
     Sc
      ie
       20
        1
        5
        ;1(
          2
          ):
           60-
             66
outweigh any disadvantage of MTA. As discussed previously                    commonly used Root end Sahebi S, Moazami F, Abbott
single appointment is better than multiple appointments.                     P. The effects of short-term calcium hydroxide
Therefore, MTA apexification can be a feasible and effective                 application on the strength of dentine. Dent Traumatol
treatment option for open apices.                                            2010;26:43–6.
                                                                       11.   Marending M, Stark WJ, Brunner TJ, et al. Comparative
ACKNOWLEDGMENT: The authors are grateful to                                  assessment of time-related bioactive glass and calcium
Professor Ashok Kumar (Department of Conservative                            hydroxide effects on mechanical properties of human
Dentistry and Endodontics, Dr. Ziauddin Ahmad Dental                         root dentin. Dent Traumatol 2009;25:126–9.
College, AMU , Aligarh) for his support and guidance in the            12.   Cvek M: Treatment of non-vital permanent incisors with
above cases.                                                                 calcium hydroxide. I. Follow-up of periapical repair and
                                                                             apical closure of immature roots. Odontol Rev,
REFERENCES:                                                                  1972;23(1):27-44.
1. American Association of Endodontists: Glossary of                   13.   Kleier D J, Barr ES: A study of endodontically apexified
    Endodontic Terms, ed 7, Chicago, IL, 2003, American                      teeth. Endodont Dent Traumatol, 1991;7(3):112-117
    Association of Endodontists                                        14.   Yates JA: Barrier formation time in non-vital teeth with
2. Andreasen JO, Farik B, Munksgaard EC. Long-term                           open apices. Int Endodont J, 1988;21(5):313-319.
    calcium hydroxide as a root canal dressing may increase            15.   Mackie IC: UK National Clinical Guidelines in Pediatric
    risk of root fracture. Dent Traumatol. 2002                              Dentistry. Management and root canal treatment of
    Jun;18(3):134-7.                                                         nonvital immature permanent incisor teeth. Int J Paed
3. Torabinejad M, Hong CU, Pitt Ford TR, Kettering JD:                       Dent, 1998;8(4):289-293.
    Antibacterial effects of some root end filling materials. J        16    Ghose L J, Baghdady VS, Hikmat YM: Apexification of
    Endod, 1995;21(8):403-406.                                               immature apices of pulpless permanent anterior teeth
4. Heasman P, McCracken G: Harthy's dental dictionary,                       with calcium hydroxide. J Endod, 1987;13(6):285-290.
    3rd Edition, London, 2007, Chuchill Livingstone                    17.   Torabinejad M, Watson TF, Pitt Ford TR. Sealing ability
    Elsevier                                                                 of a mineral trioxide aggregate when used as a root end
5. Kaiser JH: Management of wide- open canals with                           filling material J Endod, 19: 591–595, 1993.
    calcium hydroxide. Paper presented at the meeting of the           18.   Torabinejad M, Hong CU, Pitt Ford TR, Kettering
    American Association of Endodontics, Washington, DC                      JD:Cytotoxicity of four root-end filling materials. J
    April 17,1964. Cited by Steiner JC, Dow PR, Cathey                       Endod, 1995;21(10):489-492.
    GM: Inducing root end closure of nonvital permanent                19.   Torabinejad M, Hong CU, Pitt Ford TR, Kariyawasam
    teeth . J Dent Child 35:47,1968                                          SP: Tissue reaction to implanted Super-EBA and mineral
6. Frank AL: Therapy for the divergent pulpless tooth by                     trioxide aggregate in the mandible of guinea pigs: a
    continued apical formation. J Am Dent Assoc 72:87,                       preliminary report. J Endod, 1995;21(11):569-71.
    1966.                                                              20.   Torabinejad M, Pitt Ford TR, Abedi HR, Tang HM: Tibia
7. Coviello J, Brilliant JD. A preliminary clinical study on                 and mandible reactions to implanted root-end filling
    the use of tricalcium phosphate as an apical barrier. J                  materials (abstract 56). J Endod, 1997;23(4):263.
    Endod. 1979 Jan;5(1):6-13.                                         21.   Torabinejad M, Pitt Ford TR, Abedi HR, Kariyawasam
8. Schumacher JW, Rutledge RE. An alternative to                             SP, Tang HM: Tissue reaction to implanted root-end
    apexification. J Endod. 1993 Oct;19(10):529-31.                          filling materials in the tibia and mandible of guinea pigs.
9. Twati WA, Wood DJ, Liskiewicz TW, et al. An                               J Endod, 1998;24(7):468-471.
    evaluation of the effect of non-setting calcium hydroxide          22.   Thomson TS, Berry JE, Somerman MJ, Kirkwood
    on human dentine: a pilot study. Eur Arch Paediatr Dent                  KL:Cementoblasts maintain expression of osteocalcin in
    2009;10:104–9.filling materials. J Endod, 21: 537–542,                   the presence of mineral trioxide aggregate. J Endod
    1995                                                                     29:407,2003.
10. Kettering JD, Torabinejad M. Investigation of                      23.   Andreasen JO, Munksgaard EC, Fredebo L, Rud J:
    Mutagenicity of Mineral Trioxide Aggregate and other                     Periodontal tissue regeneration including
                                                                  65
U
n
i
v
er
 si
  t
  yJD
    e
    nt
     Sc
      ie
       20
        1
        5
        ;1(
          2
          ):
           60-
             66
     cementogenesis adjacent to dentin-bonded retrograde                  tissueto implanted dentin tubes filled with mineral
     composite fillings in humans. J Endod 19:151, 1993                   trioxideaggregate or calcium hydroxide. J Endod,
24. Tittle KW, Farley J, Linkhardt M, Torabinejad M:Apical                1999;25(3):161-166.
     closure induction using bone growth factors andmineral           30. Hachmeister DR, Schindler WG, Walker WA
     trioxide aggregate. J Endod 22:198, 1996 (abstract#41).              (3rd)Thomas DD: the sealing ability and retention of
25. Shabahang S, Boyne PJ, Abcdi HR, McMillan P,                          mineral trioxide aggregate in a model of apexifecation. J
     Torabinejad M: Apexification in immature dog teeth                   Endod, 2002;28(5):386-390.
     using osteogenic protein- 1, mineral trioxide aggregate,
     and calcium hydroxide (abstract 65). J Endod,                    CORRESPONDENCE :
     1997;23(4):265.                                                  Dr. Bhumika Kapoor,
26. Simon S, Rilliard F, Berdal A, Machtou P: The use of              Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics,
     mineral trioxide aggregate in one-visit apexification            Dr. Z. A. Dental College & Hospital,
     treatment: a prospective study. Int Endod J 40:186, 2007.        Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, India
27. Valois CR, Costa ED, Jr: Influence of the thickness               E-mail: bhumika.kapoor88@gmail.com
     ofmineral trioxide aggregate on scaling ability of root-
     endfillings in vitro. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral
     RadiolEndod 97:108, 2004.
28. Torabinejad M, Higa RK, McKendry D J, Pitt-Ford TR:
     Dye leakage of four root-end filling materials: Effects
     ofblood contamination. J Endod, 1994;20(4):159-163.
29. Holland R, de Souza V, Nery M J, Otoboni Filho
     JA,Bernabe PF, Dezan E: Reaction of rat connective
                                                                 66