Compressor
Air Compressors
COMPRESSOR – A device which takes a definite quantity of fluid ( usually gas, and
most often air ) and deliver it at a required pressure.
Air Compressor – 1) Takes in atmospheric air,
                    2) Compresses it, and
                    3) Delivers it to a storage vessel ( i.e. Reservoir ).
Compression requires Work to be done on the gas,
  ⇒       Compressor must be driven by some sort of Prime Mover ( i.e. Engine )
                      Classification
                          Air Compressors
          Reciprocating                      Rotary
                                            Centrifugal
  No. of Stages No. of Sides of Piston
for Compression     in operation
 Single – stage     Single – acting
 Multi - stage      Double - Acting
          Reciprocating Compressor - Working
2. Principle of Operation
   Fig. shows single-acting piston actions in
    the cylinder of a reciprocating compressor.
    The piston is driven by a crank shaft via a
    connecting rod.
    At the top of the cylinder are a suction
    valve and a discharge valve.
    A reciprocating compressor usually has
    two, three, four, or six cylinders in it.
Reciprocating Compressor - Working
                              COMPRESSORS
                  POSTIVE                ROTO--DYNAMIC
               DISPLACEMENT
                                  TURBO COMPRESSOR       EJECTOR
   RECIPROCATING       ROTARY
                                 RADIALFLOW     MIXED      AXIAL
                                (CENTRIFUGAL)   FLOW       FLOW
SINGLE STAGE    MULTI STAGE
SINGLE ACTING     DOUBLE ACTING
 Single stage reciprocating compressor with clearance:
 With clearance volume the cycle is represented on Fig.
 The work done for compression of air polytropically can be
  given by the area enclosed in cycle 1-2-3-4.
 Clearance volume in compressors varies from 1.5% to 35%
  depending upon type of compressor.
 In the cylinder of reciprocating compressor (V1-V4) shall be
  the actual volume of air delivered per cycle.
 Vd = V1 – V4. This (V1 – V4) is actually the volume of air in
  hated in the cycle and delivered subsequently.
         Equation for Work without clearance volume
 Thus, comparison between the Isothermal Work and the Actual Work is important.
                                 Isothermal Work
 Isothermal Efficiency, ηiso =
                                  Actual Work
 Thus, more the Isothermal Efficiency, more the actual compression approaches to the
 Isothermal Compression.
                                         Actual Work = Wact = Area 4-1-2-3-4
     3     2’ 2 2”
P2                         PV = C        Wact = Area (4-1) – Area (1-2) – Area (2-3)
                        (Isothermal)
                                                    2 2 − PV
                                                   PV
                         PV γ = C                =         1 1
                                                               + PV
                                                                  2 2 − PV
                                                                         1 1
                        (Adiabatic)                   n −1
                            PV n = C
     4                  1 (Polytropic)
                                                        n 
                                                              ÷ ( PV      1 1)
P1
                                                Wiso =            2 2 − PV
                                                        n −1 
            V2         V1
     Equation for Work without clearance volume
                                                               n          n
     3     2’ 2 2”                         Now,            P1V1 = P2V2
P2                          PV = C                                             1/ n
                         (Isothermal)                              V2  P1 
                                                          ⇒          =  
                          PV γ = C                                 V1  P2 
                         (Adiabatic)
                             PV n = C
     4                   1 (Polytropic)            n          
                                                                 P2 
                                                                         n −1/ n
                                                                                    
P1                                         Wiso =       ÷ PV
                                                            1 1      ÷         − 1
                                                   n −1        P1              
             V2         V1
                                                                        n −1
                                                                                 
                                                   n            P2   n
                                                                                 
                                          Wiso   =       ÷ mRT1     ÷      − 1
Delivery Temperature,                              n − 1          P
                                                                  1           
                             n −1                                               
             P2             n
     T2 =T1 
            P          
                        
             1         
Minimum Compression work
 Isentropic Compression
                  γ−1
                        
    γ        p2  γ
                        
W =    p1V1     ÷, − 1
   γ−1       p1      
                       
polytropic compression
                      n− 1
                            
        n        p   n
                            
  W =      p1V1  2 ÷ −1
      n −1       p1      
                           
Isothermal compression
                  p2 
       W =RT1 ln     ÷
                   p
                  1 
As Compressor is a work consuming device, every effort is desired to
reduce the work.
Work done = Area of P-V curve
⇒    1 – 2” : Adiabatic Compression = Max. Work.
⇒    1 – 2 : Polytropic Compression
⇒    1 – 2’ : Isothermal Compression = Min. Work.
  Methods of cooling/ Methods of improving
  isothermal efficiency
 Faster heat dissipation from inside of compressor to
  outside by use of fins over cylinder. Fins facilitate quick
  heat transfer from air being compressed to atmosphere
  so that temperature rises during compression can be
  minimized.
 Water jacket may be provided around compressor
  cylinder so that heat can be picked by cooling water
  circulating through water jacket. Cooling water circulation
  around compressor regulates rise in temperature to
  great extent.
 The water may also be injected at the end of
  compression process in order to cool the air being
  compressed. This water injection near the end of
  compression process requires special arrangement in
  compressor and also the air gets mixed with water
  and needs to be separated out before being used.
 In case of multistage compression in different
  compressors operating serially, the air leaving one
  compressor may be cooled up to ambient state or
  somewhat high temperature before being injected
  into subsequent compressor. This cooling of fluid
  being compressed between two consecutive
  compressors is called intercooling and is frequently
  used in case of multistage compressors.
             Equation for Work with clearance volume
                                                          Clearance Volume :
             6      3          2
        P2                                                Volume that remains inside the cylinder
                                                          after the piston reaches the end of its
                                                          inward stroke.
                                            PV = Cn
             5                4              1
        P1                                                    Thus, Effective Stroke Volume = V1 – V4
                     V3      V4              V1
                              Effective Swept Volume, V1-V4
Clearance Volume,
      V3=Vc             Swept Volume, V1-V3=Vs                Actual Work = Wact = Area 1-2-3-4
                    Total Volume, V1                          Wact = Area (5-1-2-6) – Area (5-4-3-6)
             Equation for Work with clearance volume
                                                                    n −1
                                                                                                 n −1
                                                                                                           
                                                      n        P2  n           n         P3  n      
                                           Wact   =      PV
                                                          1 1     ÷     − 1 −       PV
                                                                                        4 4     ÷     − 1
             6      3          2                    n −1         P
                                                               1             n − 1         P
                                                                                             4          
        P2                                                                                              
                                                                 But, P4 = P1 and P3 = P2
                                                                                               n −1
                                                                                                         
                                            PV = Cn
                                                                                n        
                                                                                         P2    n
                                                                                                         
                                                              ⇒ Wact        =      PV
                                                                                    1 1     ÷      − 1 
             5                4
                                                                              n −1         P
                                                                                         1            
        P1
                                             1                                                          
                     V3      V4              V1                                                        n −1
                                                                                                                
                                                                                     n         
                                                                                               P2      n
                                                                                                                
                                                                                 −       PV
                                                                                          1 4       ÷      − 1
                              Effective Swept Volume, V1-V4                        n −1            P
                                                                                               1             
Clearance Volume,                                                                                              
      V3=Vc             Swept Volume, V1-V3=Vs
                                                                   n                      
                                                                                            P2  
                                                                                                   n −1/ n
                                                                                                              
                                                                          ÷ P1 ( V1 − V4 )  ÷
                    Total Volume, V1
                                                          Wact   =                                        − 1
                                                                   n − 1                     P
                                                                                            1              
                                       Volumetric Efficiency
                                   Volumetric Efficiency :
                                   Ratio of free air delivered to the displacement of the compressor.
             6      3          2 Ratio of Effective Swept Volume to Swept Volume.
        P2
                                                   Presence of Clearance Volume
                                              ⇒    Volumetric Efficiency less than 1. ( 60 – 85 % )
                                            PV n = C
                                                                                  Effective Swept Volume
                                                    Volumetric Efficiency =
             5                4              1                                        Swept Volume
        P1
                                                                                   V1 – V4
                     V3      V4              V1
                                                                             =
                                                                                   V1 – V3
                              Effective Swept Volume, V1-V4
Clearance Volume,                                                                 Clearance Volume
      V3=Vc             Swept Volume, V1-V3=Vs                Clearance Ratio =
                                                                                   Swept Volume
                    Total Volume, V1
                                                                                   Vc
                                                                             =         = γ ( 4 – 10 % )
                                                                                   Vs
                                   Volumetric Efficiency
                                                    V1 − V4
                                           ηvol   =
                                                    V1 − V3
                               ⇒
        6    3        2
                                   ⇒
                                                  =
                                                    ( V1 − V3 ) + (V3 − V4 )
                                                                               =1+
                                                                                      V3
                                                                                             −
                                                                                                 V4
   P2                                                      (V1 − V3 )              (V1 − V3 ) (V1 − V3 )
                                                         V3         V4       V3
                                                  =1+           −          •
                                                      (V1 − V3 ) (V1 − V3 ) V3
                                                         V3         V3       V4
                                                  =1+           −          •
        5             4                1              (V1 − V3 ) (V1 − V3 ) V3
   P1
              V3     V4                V1
                Effective Swept Volume,
                          V1-V4
Clearance Volume,
V3=Vc          Swept Volume, V1-V3=Vs
            Total Volume, V1
       Reciprocating Compressor – Volumetric Efficiency
       6    3           2
  P2                                                       V3  V3 
                                             ηvol   = 1+        1 − 
                                                         V1 −V3  V4 
                                                           V3  V3     
                                             ηvol   = 1−         − 1
                                                         V1 −V3  V4   
       5               4                1
  P1                                                            
                                                           V3   P3 
                                                                        1/ n
                                                                             
             V3       V4                V1   ηvol   = 1−            − 1
                                                         V1 −V3   P4      
                  Effective Swept Volume,                                   
                            V1-V4
Clearance Volume,                                               P 1 / n 
V3=Vc          Swept Volume, V -V =V         ηvol   = 1 − γ •   3  − 1
                                                                P4      
                                1   3   s
            Total Volume, V1                                              
          Reciprocating Compressor – Actual P-V Diagram
       Receiver Pressure       1-2-3-4-1 : Theoretical P-V Diagram.
           3         2         At 4, inlet valve does not open due to :
P2
                               1. There must be a pressure difference across the valve to open.
                               2. Inlet valve inertia.
                                                        Pr. Drop continues till sufficient level
                             Atmospheric Pressure       for valve to force its seat.
                                         Intake Depression
                    4                                        Some valve bounce is set (wavy line).
                                     1
P1                                               Eventually, the pressure sets down at a level lower
                      Valve Bounce               than atmospheric pressure. This negative pressure
                                                 difference is known as Intake Depression.
     Similar situation appears at 2, i.e. at the start of the delivery.
  Pressure rise, followed by valve bounce and then pressure settles at a level higher than
  the delivery pressure level.
 Air delivery to a tank / receiver, hence, generally known as Receiver Pressure.
                Reciprocating Compressor – F.A.D.
Free Air Delivery (F.A.D.) : If the volume of the air compressor is reduced to atmospheric
temperature and pressure, this volume of air is called FAD (m3/min)
                          Delivered mass of air = intake mass of air
                         PtVt   P1 (V1 −V4 ) P2 (V2 −V3 )
                              =             =
                          Tt         T1           T2
If clearance volume is neglected
                                   PtVt   P1V1 P2V2
                                        =     =
                                    Tt     T1   T2
Where
          Pt = 101.325KN / m                  2
         Tt = 15 C = 288 K
                     0
Limitation of single stage compression
Advantages of multi stage compression
          Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
High Pressure required by Single – Stage :
⇒     1. Requires heavy working parts.
      2. Has to accommodate high pressure ratios.
      3. Increased balancing problems.
      4. High Torque fluctuations.
      5. Requires heavy Flywheel installations.
                 This demands for MULTI – STAGING…!!
            Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
Series arrangement of cylinders, in which the compressed air from earlier cylinder
(i.e. discharge) becomes the intake air for the next cylinder (i.e. inlet).
                                                                  L.P. = Low Pressure
            Intercooler                                            I.P. = Intermediate
                                         Air Delivery
                                                                          Pressure
                                                                   H.P. = High Pressure
  L.P.                      I.P.                H.P.            Intercooler :
 Cylinder                 Cylinder             Cylinder
                                                                Compressed air is cooled
                                                                between cylinders.
                                 Intercooler
  Air Intake
             Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
    Delivery Pr. 6   9      3    5                           Overall Pr. Range : P1 – P3
                                      Perfect Intercooling
     P3 or Pd
                                                             Single – stage cycle : 8-1-5-6
                                      Without Intercooling
                     H.P.                                    Without Intercooling :
                                           PV = C
                                              n
                                                                     L.P. : 8-1-4-7
Intermediate Pr. 7                     4
      P2                          2                                  H.P. : 7-4-5-6
                                                  PV = C
                         L.P.                                With Intercooling :
     Intake Pr. 8                            1                        L.P. : 8-1-4-7
       P1 or Ps
                                                                      H.P. : 7-2-3-6
                                Volume
Perfect Intercooling : After initial compression in L.P. cylinder, air is cooled in the
                       Intercooler to its original temperature, before entering H.P. cylinder
                       i.e. T2 = T1 OR
                            Points 1 and 2 are on SAME Isothermal line.
                Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
Ideal Conditions for Multi – Stage Compressors :
    A. Single – Stage Compressor :
     6    9      3   5              Single – stage cycle : 8-1-5-6
                                                                         n −1
                                                                               
                                                        n           P5   n
         H.P.                                      W=      P1 V1  ÷ − 1
                                                                
                                                      n −1        P1        
     7                       PV n = C                                        
                         4
                     2           PV = C       Delivery Temperature,
              L.P.                                                         n −1
     8                          1                           P5            n
                                                    T5 =T1 
                                                           P            
                                                                         
                                                            1           
                Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
    B. Two – Stage Compressor (Without Intercooling) :
                                Without Intercooling :
6    9      3    5                      L.P. : 8-1-4-7
                                        H.P. : 7-4-5-6
    H.P.                                                         n −1
                                                                           
                                               n            P4   n
                         PV n = C        W =        P1 V1  ÷ −1
                                                          
7                    4                       n −1          P1           
                                                          
                                                                          
                                                                           
                 2          PV = C
         L.P.                                                         n −1
                                                                             
                                                   n            P5    n
8                           1                +          P4 V4  ÷ −1
                                                              
                                                 n −1          P4         
                                                              
                                                                            
                                                                             
    Without Intercooling   ⇒Delivery Temperature also remains SAME.
                                  This is SAME as that of Work done in Single – Stage.
                Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
    C. Two – Stage Compressor (With Perfect Intercooling) :
                                With Intercooling :
6    9      3     5                      L.P. : 8-1-4-7-8
                                         H.P. : 7-2-3-6-7
                                                                  n −1
                                                                              
                                                n            P    n
                                          W =        P1 V1  4 ÷ −1
    H.P.                                      n −1          P1             
                                                           
                                                                             
                                                                              
7                         PV n = C
                      4                                                  n −1
                                                                                
                                                    n            P       n
                  2          PV = C           +          P2 V2  3 ÷ −1
         L.P.                                     n −1          P2           
8
                                                               
                                                                               
                                                                                
                            1
                                            Delivery Temperature,
                                                        n −1                  n −1
                                                P3     n            P3     n
                                      T3 = T2              = T1              , as T2 = T1
                                                P2                  P2 
                Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
    C. Two – Stage Compressor (With Perfect Intercooling) :
6    9      3    5
                                    With Intercooling :
                                             L.P. : 8-1-4-7-8
    H.P.                                     H.P. : 7-2-3-6-7
7                        PV n = C            Now,     T2 = T 1
                     4
                 2          PV = C                    P2V2 = P1V1
         L.P.
8                           1
                                             Also     P 4 = P2
                                                     n −1       n −1
                                                                      
                                      n         P2   n    P3  n
                                W =      P1 V1  ÷ +  ÷ − 2 
                                              
                                    n −1       P1        P2      
                                              
                                                                     
                                                                      
                            Shaded Area 2-4-5-3-2 : Work Saving due to Intercooler…!!
Condition for Min. Work :
6    9      3   5
                               ⇒ There is an Optimum P         2   for which Area 2-4-5-3-2
                                     is maximum,
    H.P.
                                     i.e. Work is minimum…!!
7                       PV n = C                    
                                                          
                                                             n −1
                                                                      
                                                                         n −1
                                                                              
                    4                      n             P    n     P     n
                                      W=      P1 V1   2 ÷ +  3 ÷ − 2 
                2          PV = C        n −1         P1        P2       
         L.P.                                                               
                                    For min. Work,
8                         1
                                                  n −1         n −1
                                                                     
                                              P   n      P   n
                                          d  2 ÷ +  3 ÷ − 2 
                                             P1         P2      
                                    dW      
                                                                    
                                                                      = 0
                                        =
                                    dP2                 dP2
                 Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
Condition for Min. Work :                                  n −1          n −1
                                                                               
                                                       P   n      P    n
                                                  d  2 ÷ +  3 ÷ − 2 
                                                     P1          P2       
                                             dW                               
                                                 =                               = 0
                                             dP2                 dP2
                 1         n −1         n −1         n −1           n −1         n −1  
                                 ( P2 )  n  + ( P3 )  n                     ( P2 )  n   = 0
                                                −1                                   −      −1
                  n −1
                         •                                           • − 
         ( P1 )    n       n                                            n                       
  6 9        3       5
                                                        ( P2 ) −1/ n         = ( P1 P )
                                                                                        n −1 
                                                                                       
                                                                                         n 
                                                                                              
                                                               − 2 n +1            3
      H.P.                                            ( P2 )  n 
                              PV n = C
  7
                     2
                          4
                                 PV = C                             ( P2 ) 2 = ( P1 P3 )
        L.P.
  8                                                                                  P2  P
                                1                       P2 = P1 P3             OR       = 3
                                                                                     P1  P2
            Reciprocating Compressor – Multistage
P2 obtained with this condition (Pr. Ratio per stage is equal) is the Ideal Intermediate
Pr. Which, with Perfect Intercooling, gives Minimum Work, Wmin.
  ⇒
            Reciprocating Compressor – Efficiency
Isothermal work done / cycle = Area of P – V Diagram
                             = P1V1 loge(P2/P1)
 Isothermal Power             = P1V1 loge(P2/P1) N   kW
                                   60 X 1000
Indicated Power : Power obtained from the actual indicator card taken during a
                  test on the compressor.
 Compressor Efficiency        = Isothermal Power
                                Indicated Power
 Isothermal Efficiency       = Isothermal Power
                                 Shaft Power
NOTE : Shaft Power = Brake Power required to drive the Compressor.
            Reciprocating Compressor – Efficiency
Adiabatic Efficiency : Ratio of Power required to drive the Compressor; compared
                         with the area of the hypothetical Indicator Diagram; assuming
                         Adiabatic Compression.
                                                         γ −1
                                                               
                                   γ                P    γ
                                       P1 V1 1 −  2  
                                 γ −1              P1  
                                                             
        η adiabatic   =
                        Brake Power required to drive the Compressor
Mechanical Efficiency : Ratio of mechanical output to mechanical input.
                  Mechanical Efficiency, ηmech = Indicated Power
                                                   Shaft Power
            Reciprocating Compressor – Efficiency
How to Increase Isothermal Efficiency ?
A. Spray Injection : Assimilation of water into the compressor cylinder towards the
                     compression stroke.
                    Object is to cool the air for next operation.
                     Demerits : 1. Requires special gear for injection.
                                2. Injected water interferes with the cylinder lubrication.
                                3. Damage to cylinder walls and valves.
                                4. Water must be separated before delivery of air.
B. Water Jacketing : Circulating water around the cylinder to help for cooling the
                      air during compression.
             Reciprocating Compressor – Efficiency
How to Increase Isothermal Efficiency ?
C. Inter – Cooling : For high speed and high Pr. Ratio compressors.
                    Compressed air from earlier stage is cooled to its original
                    temperature before passing it to the next stage.
D. External Fins : For small capacity compressors, fins on external surfaces are useful.
E. Cylinder Proportions : Short stroke and large bore provides much greater surface
                          for cooling.
                          Cylinder head surface is far more effective than barrel
                      surface.
             Reciprocating Compressor – Efficiency
Clearance Volume : Consists of two spaces.
         1. Space between cylinder end & the piston to allow for wear.
         2. Space for reception of valves.
 High – class H.P. compressors : Clearance Vol. = 3 % of Swept Vol.
                                : Lead (Pb) fuse wire used to measure the gap
 between
                               cylinder end
Low – grade L.P. compressors : Clearance    and
                                         Vol. = 6piston.
                                                  % of Swept Vol.
                               : Flattened ball of putty used to measure the gap
                                 between cylinder end and piston.
 Effect of Clearance Vol. :
           Vol. taken in per stroke < Swept Vol.   ⇒     ↑ Size of compressor
                                                         ↑ Power to drive compressor.