CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
                               2.1 Introduction
                               2.2 Review of International Studies
                               2.3 Review of National Studies
                               2.4 Conclusion
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
                                         REVIEW OF LITERATURE
               2.1 INTRODUCTION
                      Economists and social scientists have conducted a number of studies relating to
               consumer behaviour and consumer protection. A detailed review of literature has been
               made to find out the research gap and to identify the relevant issues for the study.
               This section provides a sketch of the available related studies carried out in National and
               International level. The review of literature has been confined to WTO’s discussion
               papers, Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India, Ph.D., theses and from
               various books related to consumer protection laws.
               2.2 REVIEW OF INTERNATIONAL STUDIES
                      Fetterman, E. and Schiller, M.K. (1978)1 in their book “Let the Buyer Be
               Aware: Consumer Rights and Responsibilities”, explains how the consumer can avoid
               problems through better buying techniques and careful planning. They also stress the
               need of the consumer for knowing about their rights and responsibilities to choose the
               alternatives among the available choice.
                      Grada Hellman-Tuitert (1999)2 in the study “Promoting Consumer Education In
               Schools” state that the objectives of consumer education at school are to educate
               independent, discriminating and informed consumers. It is to equip the pupil with knowledge
               and insight into the conditions of being a consumer in a complex, multi-faceted society by
               providing basic knowledge in such areas as consumer legislation, personal finances,
               economics, advertising and persuasion, consumption and the environment, global
               resources, housing, clothing, price and quality, diet and health. Schools should contribute
               to making pupils aware of the influences they are exposed to with respect to life styles,
               consumer habits, values and attitudes.”
                      Frank William (2006)3 in the study “Consumer Protection Law and Executive
               Regulations – Egypt” state that from the perspective of the associations, the biggest
               problem for Egyptian consumers is price. Although the new law won't have direct effect
               on prices, but through consumer awareness of how to shop and how to demand rights, the
               ultimate result will be more competition, lower prices and better quality goods. Because
                                                           8
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               lower income persons tend to buy lower quality products with a cheaper price and often
               not aware that purchasing goods are of a lower quality or, if aware willing to accept it. In
               addition to price, the major areas of consumer complaints revolve around food, clothing,
               electronics and appliances.
                      Md. Shahriar Akter,Johra Kayeser Fatima,Md. Habib-uz-Zaman Khan (2007)4
               in their study “An Integrated Protection Framework to Preserve Consumers Rights and
               Responsibilities in Bangladesh” state that through legislative framework, consumers
               legal rights are ensured , through regulatory framework, products quality and safety
               standards are ensured and through voluntary framework consumers awareness about their
               rights and a movement against mass exploitation are ensured.
                      Sune Donoghue and Helena M.de Klerk (2009)5 in their study “The Right to be
               Heard and to be Understood :A Conceptual Frame Work for Consumer Protection in
               Emerging Economics” state that one way of protecting the consumer is by establishing a
               redress environment that would ensure fair redress as well as an understanding and
               appreciation of the consumer.
                      Ahamuduzzaman, Md. Lutfor Rahman, and Nahida Nazmus Zannat (2009)6
               in their study “A Contextual Analysis of the Consumer Rights Protection Laws with
               Practical Approach: Bangladesh Perspectives” state that the concept of consumer rights
               depends upon the promotional activities and the protection mechanisms of a particular
               society or of a state. The protection of a consumer rights ultimately ensures safety in
               products and security in service whereas the promotion of a consumer rights depends
               upon the education, monitoring of the supply and marketing systems of various products,
               examining goods, enforcing proper scale in weight and measurement, enacting proper
               laws, creating awareness, upliftment of moral standards etc.
                      Anna Luczak (2011)7 in the study “Evolution of Consumer Protection Law in
               The Light of the Proposal for A Horizontal Directive on Consumer Rights and Rome
               I Regulation” conclude that Consumer protection policy in the European Union is
               undergoing a deep and necessary reform influenced by many factors, including the growth of
               cross-border consumer contracts concluded by electronic means of communication.
                                                           9
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
                      Dennis Odigie & Job Odion (2011)8 in their study “The Impact of Consumers
               Protection Laws and the Regulatory schemes in Nigeria” conclude that the courts,
               relevant consumer protection statutes and regulatory agencies have failed to offer
               protection to the consumer. Consequently, the consumer is simply left unprotected and at
               the mercy of unconscionable manufacturers and exaggerated traders. The legislature,
               regulatory agencies and courts must rise up to the occasion of entrenching a sustainable
               administration of consumer protection.
                      Etefia E. Ekanem (2011)9 in his study “Institutional Framework for Consumers
               Protection in Nigeria” state that it is obvious that beside the problem of lack of
               appropriate legislation, the court has not been able to raise to the occasion, whenever a
               consumer approaches it for redress.
                      Giesela Ruhl (2011)10 in the study “Consumer Protection in Choice of Law” state
               that consumer protection is generally explained, and justified, with the concept of the
               “weaker party.” Consumers are considered to be “weaker” than their contracting partners,
               the professionals, and assumed to be unable to protect their interests due to inferior
               bargaining power.
                      Nicky Campbell and Stephen Logan (2011)11 in their study “The Consumer
               Protection Guide for Lawyers” in the Law Society of South Africa August 2011 state
               that “Accredited consumer protection groups may protect individual consumer interests
               or the interest of consumers collectively in any matter or before any forum contemplated
               in the CPA. Such groups may intervene in any matter before any forum contemplated in
               the Act, if the interests of consumers represented by that group are not adequately
               represented in that forum. Accredited consumer protection groups may direct a generally
               stated concern or complaint to the Commission in respect of any matter within the
               purposes of the CPA.
                      Spencer Weber Waller, Jillian G. Brady and R.J. Acosta (2011)12 in the study
               “Consumer Protection in the United States: An Overview” state that American
               consumers are protected from unsafe products, fraud, deceptive advertising, and unfair
               business practices through a mixture of national, state, and local governmental laws and
               the existence of many private rights of actions. These public and private rights both
                                                         10
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               protect consumers and, at a formal level, equip them with the knowledge they need to
               protect themselves. Although U.S. mechanisms for consumer protection often exist
               separately from each other, what the overall scheme lacks in centralization, it gains in
               depth and variety of protection. Its strength is the array of governmental actors, formal
               legal rights, and remedies protecting consumers. Its weakness lies in the unequal reality
               of who has access to the government and the courts.
                      Van Heerde, C. & Barnard, J. (2011)13 in their study “Redress for Consumers
               in terms of the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008: A Comparative Discussion” state
               that consumer rights are of little value if they cannot be enforced. The European Union
               has always placed great value on the consumer being able to obtain redress, whether it is
               by way of courts or out-of-court dispute resolution. By establishing important EU
               Directives and formulating Green Papers with regards to consumer protection and being
               in constant communication with the member states, access to justice and redress is always
               an important factor.
                      Kamarudeen Babatunde Bello, Jamila Bisi Aduke Suleiman, Ibrahim
               Danjuma (2012)14 in their study “Perspectives on Consumerism and Consumer
               Protection Act in Nigeria” state that the level of consumer awareness in Nigeria is still
               relatively low and Nigerian consumers are continuously confronted with substandard
               goods and services, lack of information and limited choices in the market. The ability to
               enforce the laws relating to consumer protection will provide the necessary force for
               safeguarding the rights and safety of consumers in Nigeria.
                      Mohammed Solaiman, Sanoara Yasmin and Ahasanul Haque (2012)15 in their
               study “Issues of Consumerism in Bangladesh: Present Status and Challenges” state that in
               Bangladesh, consumerism movement is still in initial stage. However, Government of
               Bangladesh has adopted some legislative measures in order to protect consumers from the
               malpractice of the dishonest businessmen/marketers. The important legislation with
               regard to this include (a) The Patents and Design Act, 191 1, (b) Trade Marks Act, 1940,
               (c) Prevention of Adulteration Act, 1954 (d) Pure Food Ordinance, 1959 (e) Bangladesh
               Drugs Act, 1982, etc.
                                                          11
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
                       Mukhtar Halliru (2012)16 in the study “The Development of Consumerism in
               Nigeria: Prospects and Challenges” state that the CPC was established Via the Consumer
               Protection Council Act of 1992 in order to enforce consumer rights in the country.
               The council is charged with the following functions among others: provide speedy
               redress to consumer complaints through negotiations, mediations and conciliations; seek
               ways and means of removing or eliminating from the market hazardous products and
               causing offenders to replace such products with safer and more appropriate alternatives;
               publish from time to time, list of products whose consumption and sale have been
               banned, withdrawn or not approved by Nigerian government or foreign governments; and
               cause an offending company or individual to protect, compensate, provide relief and
               safeguards to injured consumers or communities from adverse effects of technologies that
               are inherently harmful.
                       Suraiya Ishak & Nur Faridah M. Zabil (2012)17 in their study entitled “Impact
               of Consumer Awareness and Knowledge to Consumer Effective Behaviour” state that
               awareness is prior to effective consumers behaviours and the awareness of consumers rights
               serve as soft-control mechanism aiming at creating more responsible business society.
                       Mark Peacock, Charlotte Slater, Marc Eatough, Angina Jugnauth, Stefania
               Chirico, Katarzyna Majkut (2013)18 in their study “Consumer rights and economic
               growth” state that consumers lack confidence and certainty when asserting and exercising
               their rights if existing consumer law is fragmented, complex and opaque in nature. This will
               undermine their ability to seek redress and switch consumption in a manner that punishes
               inefficient, poor-quality businesses while rewarding efficient, high-quality businesses.
               This lack of consumer participation will reduce pressure on businesses to innovate and
               pursue efficiency in order to offer high quality products that are price competitive.
                       Javier Gutierrez, Bufete B. Buigas, Barcelona, in their book “Consumer
               Protection in Spain” conclude that there are several sector-specific regulations
               conforming to EU law where applicable, which further enhance consumer protection.
               These cover specific aspects such as advertising, safety standards, warranties, redressal,
               and allied matters in relation to, inter alia, food, medical products, vehicles, toys, textiles,
               travel, and insurance. Consumers whose grievances are not satisfied after a direct
                                                             12
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               complaint to the seller or manufacturer, have the option to resort to arbitration,
               administrative claims, or file a civil or criminal action, as relevant. Claims also may be
               filed through regional consumer bodies or consumer organizations.
               2.3 REVIEW OF NATIONAL STUDIES
                      Joyeeta Gupta (1986)20 in his study “Consumerism: Emerging Challenges and
               Opportunities” state that most consumer groups subscribe to the view that consumer
               protection involves mainly distribution of information and education. But there are a
               handful of consumer groups like the voluntary organization in the interest of Consumer
               Education (VOICE) in Delhi and Consumer Education and Research Centre (CERC) in
               Ahmadabad which believe inaction at the level of influencing policy decisions, raising
               questions in Parliament, doing active research into various subjects and involving the law
               to protect the rights of consumer.
                      Saraf, D.N. (1990)21 in his book “Law of Consumer Protection in India” narrates
               the evolution of consumer law and depicts its development in USA, U.K and India.
               It gives a profile of Indian consumer problems arising out of operation of public utility
               services which are peculiar to India due to monopolization of production, distribution
               and control of some essential goods and services by state and critically examines utility
               of certain doctrines like “Caveat Emptor”.
                      Sundar G.Bhardwaj, Thirunarayana, P.N. and Rajan Varadarajan, P. (1991)22 in
               their study entitled “Attitudes towards Marketing Practices, Consumerism and Government
               Regulations: An Exploratory Survey of Consumers in India” states that over
               80 percent of the consumers feel that the exploitation of consumers by business firms
               deserves more attention than it receives, and the procedures followed by most manufacturers
               in handling complaints and settings grievances of consumers are not satisfactory.
                      Savarkar, G. (1996)23 in his study “Consumer Awareness: A Survey Analysis”
               concluded that the main reasons, why dissatisfied consumers did not file complaint
               before any District Forums were the lack of awareness about the Consumer Protection
               Act’s measures.
                                                            13
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
                      Arora, R. (1999)24 in the study “Consumer Protection through Voluntary Consumer
               Protection through Voluntary Consumer Organizations” highlighted some of the problems
               faced by these organizations were nonparticipation of the consumers in their activities, ritual
               approach of the government and poor financial standing of the voluntary organizations .
               Lastly trade and industry also have total ignorance for the safety of the consumers.
                      Amrik Singh Sudan (2002)25 in the study “Activating Consumer Movement :
               A Case Study of Division Consumer Forum, Jammu (J&K state )” state that the process
               in the disposal of complaints has been observed to be slow due to part time nature of the
               faculty members, administrative delays and non-clarity about the provisions of CPA.
                      Cheena Gambhir (2002)26 in her study “Consumer protection: Law and
               Practice” reveals that 54 percent of the respondents are aware of ISI mark and 46 percent
               of respondents were not aware. Further out of 54 percent respondents, only 30 percent
               bought products that had ISI mark and remaining 70 percent even though aware, did not
               buy these products.
                      Gnanadesigan, C. and Sudha, P. (2002)27 in their study “Consumer Awareness
               about Consumer Legislations – A Study” clearly state that most of the respondents are
               aware of the consumer protection act and researcher concludes that consumer protection
               is an ineffective national problem affecting every section of the society irrespective of
               age and education.
                      Naegeswara Rao, D. (2002)28 in the study “Consumerism in India –Emerging
               from its Teething Troubles” states that even among the urban and educated masses the
               awareness of the consumer rights has not reached to a desired level. The consumer
               protection thus remain a legend, instead of being a king, the consumer is still a victims of
               the market force.
                       SampathKumar, R. (2002)29 in the study “Consumerism in India: An
               overview” state that consumerism is society’s attempt to redress the inconsistency in the
               exchange transactions between sellers and consumerism.
                      Purushotham Rao, P. and Praveen, S. (2004)30 in their study “Consumer
               Protection in Andhra Pradesh” (A case study of Hyderabad District Consumer Voluntary
                                                            14
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               organizations and Consumer Redressal Forums) state that “No pain, no Gain” is the right
               technique for Consumer Protection. The Consumer must be aware of his basic rights.
               The famous principle of “Caveat Emptor”- Let the Buyer Beware – must be replaced by
               “Caveat Venditor” - Let a seller beware – by strong determination of consumer side”.
                      Sadar, S.B. and Fulzele, T.U. (2004)31 in their study “An Introspection of
               Consumer Movement India” state that apathy, disinterest, unorganized and unlimited
               tolerance were found in seventy percent consumers. Low publicity of consumer
               associations to the activities, achievements, aims and education programmes is also a
               major reason for not knowing the consumer movement.
                      Tangade and Basavaraj (2004)32 in their study entitled “Awareness and
               Perception of Educated Consumer about Consumer Protection Laws”, analyses the level
               of awareness and satisfaction of educated consumers about the various laws .This study
               also highlighted the significant role of electronic and press media in creating awareness
               amongst the consumers.
                      Sardar, S.B. and Fulzele, T.U. (2005)33 in their study “Consumerism: Where
               does Consumer see himself?” found that unless and until the consumer associations have
               a mass appeal and public response, they cannot attract public support and consumer
               association should undertake activities that will support consumer awareness and
               education of the consumers.
                      C&AG (2006)34 according to their survey commissioned through ORG centre for
               social research report that about sixty-six percent of the consumers interviewed were not
               aware of consumer rights and 82 percent were even unaware of the Act and Nearly
               49 percent of the aware consumers had come to know about the Act only in the last 4 years.
                      Lokhande, M.A. (2006)35 in the study “Consumer Awareness – A Case Study of
               Jalna City” shows that out of 90 respondents, only 33 (36.67%) had complained against
               greedy sellers while 63.33% of the respondents had not lodged compliant, in spite of
               understanding that they       were cheated. 25 respondent complained to the Grahak
               Panchayat and 8 had complained to district forum and nobody had complained to the
               State or National Commission.
                                                           15
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
                       Shrimant F.Tangade and Basavaraj, C.S. (2006)36 in their study “Perceptions
               about Consumer Protection Laws and the Consumer Forum: An Emperical Study of
               Complainant-Consumers of Gulbarga District” state that consumer should organize their
               rights and fight for their protection by organizing themselves and with the help of
               redressal agencies established by the Government in each district , when majority of the
               consumers become cautious and reactive, businessman would be compelled to pay proper
               attention to the consumer rights for their own survival.
                       Praveen, S. (2009)37 in his study “Consumer Protection in India (With Special
               Reference to Andhra Pradesh)” states that consumer protection and welfare is not the
               task of s single entity or the society. Rather it is the collective responsibility of the state.
               The consumer must be aware of his basic rights and should fight for these rights.
                       Shashi Nath Mandal (2009)38 in his study entitled “Protection of Consumers
               Right through Judicial and Extra Judicial Mechanism in India” concludes that consumer
               protection laws are federal and state statutes governing sales and credit practices
               involving consumer goods such statutes prohibit and regulate deceptive or
               unconscionable advertising and sales practices, product quality, credit financing and
               reporting, debt collection, leases and other aspects of consumer transaction.
                       Shashi Nath Mandal (2010)39 in his study “Protection of Consumer Rights -A Socio
               Legal Challenge in India” found that consumer should have adequate rights and right of
               remedy to redressal measure against defaulting businessman.
                       Hawa Singh and Monika Singh (2011)40 in their study, “Consumer Education
               and Awareness” suggest that the Government should take necessary steps to improve the
               functioning of consumer redressal for quick settlement of complaints by providing all
               necessary amenities such as infrastructure and staff facilities.
                       Jayachandra Reddy, K., Himachalam.D and Praveen Kumar Reddy, N. (2011)41
               in their study entitled “Awareness about Consumer Rights in India in the Globalized
               Business Environment – An Empirical investigation of Andhra Pradesh” found that around
               40 percent respondents are ignored about three tier redressal mechanism functioning at
               various levels to protect the consumers from the control of the merciless business community
               from different mal practices, unfair trade practices and defective goods and services.
                                                             16
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
                      Kiran chaudry, Tanu Chandhiok and Praveen Dewan (2011)42 in their study
               “Consumer Protection and Consumerism in India” state that the Government has enacted
               nearly 50 laws in favour of consumers.
                      Rishikant Agnihotri, Beenu Singh and Arti Singh (2011)43 in their study “Role
               of media in Consumer Protection “state that television was the main media which
               influence their buying.
                      Rachna Kesharwani (2011)44 in the study “Insights on Consumer Education”
               consumers should keep speed with innovation in technology, particularly the rapid
               expansion of mobile technology.
                      Yamuna Krishna, B. and Suganya, Y. (2011)45 in their study “A Comparative
               study of Consumer Courts in Tamilnadu and Kerala states -An Statistical Survey Report”
               state that Indian courts suffer from severe weaknesses which reduce its popularity and
               create a negative opinion among Indian consumers on its functioning. The researchers
               conclude that consumer courts in Kerala are functioning more efficiently than consumer
               courts in Tamilnadu. Neither the Government nor the consumer can be individually
               blamed for any cause and benefit.
                      Gadhe Dattatray Punjaji (2012)46 in his study entitled “A Review of Status of
               Consumer Protection Law in India” states that the existing consumer forums need to be
               strengthened to provide fair and speedy justice and there is a need to increase awareness
               and adopt publicity measures as the consumers are not sure as to whom they should
               approach in case the service providers or the suppliers of goods take them for a ride.
                      Jayasubramanian, P. and Vaideke, A. (2012)47 in their study “A Study on
               Consumer Awareness and Attitude towards Consumer Protection Measures” shows that
               consumer protection measures are not aware to general public because of lack of proper
               communication. They also said that consumerism is not going to be a threat but only a
               better opportunity for better business.
                      Krishnamurthi, A. and Suresh, K.M. (2012)48 in their study “Evaluation of
               Consumer Protection Council with special reference to Erode District” suggests that
               establishment of mobile consumer courts and offices of settlement of Commissioners for
               free , easy and speedy means of legal redressal to aggrieved consumer is a most.
                                                          17
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
                      Ramu, B. (2012)49 in his study entitled “Consumer Protection Movement” observed
               that the percentage of disposal of consumer cases at the apex agency is 78.03 percent.
                      Partap Singh and Joginder Grewal (2013)50 in their study entitled “Consumer
               Protection in India: Some Issues & Trends” state that consumer rights could be protected
               in a competitive economy only when right standards for goods and services are ensured
               by evolving a network of institutions and legal protection system.
                      Parag A. Inamdar, (2013)51 in his study of “Consumer Protection - A Study of
               Consumer Awareness in Mumbai City District” found that 32% consumers were aware
               about the consumer protection law and 68% were not about such protection law and
               14.6% know the procedure of filing a complaint in consumer courts and 85.4% does not
               know the procedure of filing a complaint in consumer courts.
                      Pushpa, M. and Senthilvasan, K.G. (2013)52 in their study “A Study on
               Consumer Awareness among the People in Palani Town” reveals that a vast majority of
               consumers in our country lack Consumer Education particularly those in rural areas who
               are easily subject to exploitation and for this purpose there must be practical support on
               the part of the Government, non- Government organizations, business and corporate
               Entities, consumer protection department and educational research institution.
                      Sudesh Kharb (2013)53 in the study “Consumer Literacy Regarding Consumer
               Protection Act 1986” conclude that in spite of being well educated, people are not aware
               of the provisions of CPA and the study clearly shows that most of the people hardly
               know anything about CPA except the existence of the CPA.
                      Sudarsana Murthy, D., Narasaiah, P.V and Mohan, B. (2013)54 in their study
               “Performance of Consumer Forums: An Empirical study of Kadapa District Consumer
               Forum” state that most of the respondents strongly complained that the district forums
               were taking more time to solve the cases.
                      Vanisree, D. (2013)55 in her study “Role of Media in Consumer Protection” state
               that television was the main media which influence their buying. There is a significant
               difference between the awareness levels of the respondent of different age group about
                                                            18
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               consumer organization working in and around their area. Respondent above the age
               group of 42 were more aware about the consumer organization working in their area than
               the respondent below the age group of 41.
               2.4 CONCLUSION
                      Review of literature enables the researcher to know the availability of related
               literature in the context to the present study. The information given in this chapter is from
               the newspaper articles, journals, magazines and internet sites. The present research is an
               attempt to fill up the gaps by studying the fundamental values of consumer protection
               laws, which are expected to be followed in general in the consumer education as
               consumer in particular. Thus, the researcher has made a reliable and sincere attempt to
               cover the hindrances and limitations that are responsible for not having the awareness of
               consumer protection laws.
                                                           19
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               REFERENCES
               1.    Fetterman.E and Schiller.M.K in their book “Let the Buyer Be Aware:
                     Consumer Rights and Responsibilities”, Fairchild Publications, New York, 1978,
                     p.217.
               2.    Grada Hellman-Tuitert - “Promoting Consumer Education In Schools”-Katarina
                     Tryck AB, Stockholm, August 1999, p-15.
               3.    Frank Williams-“Consumer Protection Law And Executive Regulations –
                     Egypt” - USAID-funded TAPR II project, September 2006 ,p-5.
               4.    Md. Shahriar Akter,Johra Kayeser Fatima,Md. Habib-uz-Zaman Khan-“An
                     Integrated   Protection   Framework    to   Preserve   Consumers’   Rights   and
                     Responsibilities in Bangladesh” in the Daffodil International University Journal
                     of Business and Economics, Vol. 2, No. 2, July 2007 p-170-182.
               5.    Sune Donoghue and Helena M.de Klerk - “The right to be heard and to be
                     understood: a conceptual frame work for consumer protection in emerging
                     economics” -International Journal of Consumer Studies 2009 p.456.
               6.    Ahamuduzzaman ,Md. Lutfor Rahman, and Nahida NazmusZann at-
                     “A Contextual Analysis of the Consumer Rights Protection Laws With Practical
                     Approach: Bangladesh Perspectives” ASA University Review, Vol. 3 No. 2,
                     July–December, 2009 p.191.
               7.    Anna Luczak -“Evolution Of Consumer Protection Law in the Light of the
                     Proposal for a Horizontal Directive on Consumer Rights and Rome I Regulation”-
                     “Wroclaw Review of Law, Administration & Economics” 2011,p-121-130.
               8.    Dennis Odigie & Job Odion - “The impact of consumers’ protection laws and
                     the regulatory schemes in Nigeria” -International Journal of Advanced Legal
                     Studies and Governance, Vol.2, No.1, April 2011, p .149.
               9.    Etefia E. Ekanem - “Institutional framework for consumers protection in
                     Nigeria”- International Journal of Advanced Legal Studies and Governance,
                     Vol.2, No.1, April 2011 p.44.
                                                       20
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               10.   Giesela Ruhl- “Consumer Protection in Choice of Law”- Cornell International
                     Law Journal 2011, Vol. 44 p.
               11.   Nicky Campbell and Stephen Logan - “The Consumer Protection Guide for
                     Lawyers” -Law Society of South Africa August 2011.
               12.   Spencer Weber Waller, Jillian G. Brady and R.J. Acosta - “Consumer Protection
                     in the United States: An Overview”- European Journal of Consumer Law,
                     May 2011, p-2.
               13.   Van Heerde.C & Barnard .J -“Redress for Consumers in terms of the Consumer
                     Protection Act 68 of 2008: A Comparative Discussion” - Journal of International
                     Commercial Law and Technology. Vol. 6, Issue 3 (2011) p.138.
               14.   Kamarudeen Babatunde Bello, Jamila Bisi Aduke Suleiman, Ibrahim Danjuma -
                     “Perspectives on Consumerism and Consumer Protection Act in Nigeria”- European
                     Journal of Business and Management Vol 4, No.10, 2012 page 77.
               15.   Mohammed Solaiman, Sanoara Yasmin and Ahasanul Haque - “Issues of
                     Consumerism in Bangladesh: Present Status and Challenges” in the International
                     Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 2, Issue 3, March 2012.
               16.   Mukhtar Halliru - “The Development of Consumerism in Nigeria: Prospects and
                     Challenges”- International Journal of Arts and Commerce Vol. 1 No. 4 September
                     2012 P.278.
               17.   Suraiya Ishak & Nur Faridah M. Zabil- “Impact of Consumer Awareness and
                     Knowledge to Consumer Effective Behavior”- Asian Social Science; Vol. 8,
                     No. 13; Oct 18, 2012. P113.
               18.   Mark Peacock, Charlotte Slater, Marc Eatough, Angina Jugnauth, Stefania
                     Chirico, Katarzyna Majkut th – “Consumer rights and economic growth”
                     -A report submitted by ICF GHK 11 January 2013 p.8.
               19.   Javier Gutierrez,Bufete B. Buigas,Barcelona, -“Consumer Protection in
                     Spain”- Comparative Law Yearbook of International Business.p-67.
                                                        21
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               20.   Joyeeta Gupta-“Consumerism: Emerging challenges and opportunities” -Vikalpa
                     vol.II no.2 April-June 1986 p.152.
               21.   Saraf.D.N - Law of consumer Protection in India N.M.Tripati, Bombay 1990.
                     p, 259.
               22.   Sundar    G.Bhardwaj,      Thirunarayana.P.N      and    Rajan     Varadarajan.P
                     -“Attitudes towards marketing practices, Consumerism and Government
                     Regulations: An Exploratory survey of consumers in India” -Vikalpa Vol: 16 No
                     1Jan-Mar 1991, p.22.
               23.   Savarkar.G, “Consumer Awareness: A Survey Analysis,” Indian Journal of
                     Marketing, Vol. 25, Dec. 1996, p. 13-21.
               24.   Arora.R-“Consumer Protection through Voluntary consumer protection through
                     voluntary consumer organizations” Indian journal of marketing, Jan-Mar 1999, p29.
               25.   Amrik Singh Sudan-“Activating Consumer Movement: A case study of Division
                     Consumer Forum, Jammu (J&K state)” - Indian journal of marketing –Vol XXXII
                     Jan-Feb 2002.p.5.
               26.   Cheena Gambhir- “Consumer Protection: Law and Practice”- Indian Journal of
                     Marketing Vol XXXIII NOV 2002, p.19.
               27.   Gnanadesigan.C      and   Sudha.P-“Consumer       Awareness      about   Consumer
                     Legislations – A Study” -Indian Journal of Marketing Vol XXXII Dec 2002, p.32.
               28.   Naegeswara Rao.D- “Consumerism in India –Emerging from its Teething
                     Troubles” –Indian Journal of Marketing Vol XXXII March-April 2002, p.5.
               29.   SampathKumar.R-“Consumerism in India: An overview” -Indian Journal of
                     Marketing July 2002, p.32.
               30.   Purushotham Rao.P and Praveen.S- “Consumer Protection in Andhra Pradesh”
                     (A case study of Hyderabad District Consumer Voluntary Organizations and
                     Consumer Redressal Forums) - Indian Journal of Marketing July 2004, p.7.
               31.   Sadar.S.B and FulzeleT.U- “An Introspection of Consumer Movement India” -
                     Indian Journal of Marketing Feb 2004, p.26.
                                                          22
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               32.   Tangade and Basavaraj- “Awareness and Perception of Educated Consumer
                     about Consumer Protection Laws” -Indian journal of marketing –April, 2004 p3-6.
               33.   Sadar.S.B and Fulzele.T.U- “Consumerism: Where does consumer see himself?”
                     -Indian Journal of Marketing May 2005, p.18.
               34.   CAG, Performance Audit of the Implementation of the Consumer Protection Act
                     and Rules-Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India for the year
                     ended March 2005, Union Government (Civil), Performance Audit, 2006, p. 9.
               35.   Lokhande.M.A-“Consumer Awareness – A Case Study of Jalna city”- Indian
                     Journal of Marketing, May 2006 p.27.
               36.   Shrimant F.Tangade and Basavaraj C.S -“Perceptions about Consumer
                     Protection Laws and the Consumer Forum: An Emperical Study of Complainant-
                     Consumers of Gulbarga District” -Indian Journal of Marketing, June 2006 p.35.
               37.   Praveen.S- “Consumer protection In India (With special reference to Andhra
                     Pradesh)” -Indian Journal of Management -May-June 2009 p.27.
               38.   Shashi Nath Mandal- “Protection of consumers Right through Judicial and Extra
                     Judicial Mechanism in India” -Hooghly Mohgin College, Govt of West Bengal-
                     Higher Education Dept.: The University of Burdwan, Rajbati. April 4, 2009.
               39.   Shashi Nath Mandal -“Protection of consumer Righs-A socio Legal Challenge in
                     India” October 6, 2010 The University of Burdon Rajbati- Gujarat.
               40.   Hawa Singh and Monika Singh- “Consumer education and awareness” -
                     International journal of Research in Social science –vol 1.August 2011 p.181.
               41.   Jayachandra Reddy.K,. Himachalam.D and Praveen Kumar Reddy.N -
                     “Awareness Abou Consumer Rights in India in the Globalized Business
                     Environment – An Empirical investigation of Andhra Pradesh” - International
                     Journal of Research in Computer Application and Management-Vol; 1 Issue No:
                     05 July 2011 p.14.
                                                        23
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               42.   Kiran chaudry, Tanu Chandhiok and Praveen Dewan-“Consumer protection and
                     consumerism in India”- International Journal of Mutidisciplinary Research vol.1
                     May 2011 p.91.
               43.   Rishikant Agnihotri , Beenu singh and Arti singh -“Role of media in consumer
                     protection”- VSRD International Journal of Business and Management Research
                     – vol.1(10) 2011 p.630-631.
               44.   Rachna Kesharwani-“Insights on Consumer Education” -Online International
                     Interdisciplinary Research Journal, (Bi- Monthly), Issue 1: Vol: 1 Sep-Oct 2011, p.20.
               45.   Yamuna Krishna.B and Suganya.Y in their study of “A Comparative study of
                     consumer courts in Tamilnadu and Kerala states -An Statistical survey Report” -
                     Indian Journal of Marketing, Dec 2011 p.45.
               46.   Gadhe Dattatray Punjaji- “A Review of Status of Consumer Protection Law in
                     India” -Indian Streams Research journal- Vol 2, Issue 10: Nov 2012, p.5.
               47.   Jayasubramanian.P and Miss.Vaideke.A- “A study on Consumer Awareness
                     and Attitude towards Consumer Protection Measures” -Indian Journal of Applied
                     Research Vol.1.Issue:12, Sep 2012 p.31.
               48.   Krishnamurthi.N.A and Suresh.K.M- “Evaluation of Consumer Protection
                     Council with Special reference to Erode District” -Journal of Management and
                     Science – Vol-II No: 2 April- June 2012 P.105.
               49.   Ramu.B- “Consumer Protection Movement” -HRD Times –August 2012 p.28.
               50.   Parag A. Inamdar - “Consumer Protection - A study of Consumer Awareness in
                     Mumbai City District”- International Journal of Social Science & Management,
                     Volume - 1, Issue - 4 January, 2013 p13-14
               51.   Partap Singh and Joginder Grewal –“Consumer Protection in India: Some
                     Issues & Trends” -International Journal of Latest Trends in Engineering and
                     Technology Vol. 2 Issue 1 January 2013 p.p 272.
               52.   Pushpa .M and Senthilvasan K.G- “A Study on Consumer Awareness among
                     the People in Palani Town” -Kisan World May 2013 Vol.40 No.5 p.32.
                                                          24
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
               53.   Sudesh Kharb-“Consumer Literacy Regarding Consumer Protection Act 1986” –
                     International Journal of Research in Commerce and Management-Vol; 4 Issue
                     No: 03 March 2013 p.103.
               54.   Sudarsana Murthy.D, Narasaiah.P.V and Mohan.B -“Performance of
                     Consumer Forums: An Empirical Study of Kadapa District Consumer Forum” –
                     Prabandhan Indian journal of management –Feb 2013 p-46.
               55.   Vanisree.D- “Role of Media in Consumer Protection”- Indian Journal of Applied
                     Research, Volume: 3, issue: 8, August 2013 p.404.
                                                       25
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.