Unit 6                                                         Organisational Appraisal
UNIT 6: ORGANISATIONAL APPRAISAL
         UNIT STRUCTURE
         6.1       Learning Objectives
         6.2       Introduction
         6.3       Concept of Organisational Analysis
         6.4       Characteristics of Organisational Analysis
         6.5       Strategic or Competitive Advantage
         6.6       Factors in Organizational Analysis
         6.7       Methods and Techniques in Organization Analysis
         6.7       Let Us Sum Up
         6.8       Further Reading
         6.9       Answers to check your progress
         6.10      Model Questions
         6.1       LEARNING OBJECTIVES
         After going through this unit you will be able to:
               •   discuss the concept of Organisational Analysis
               •   outline the characteristics of Organisational Analysis
               •   learn about Strategic or Competitive Advantage
               •   describe the factors in Organizational Analysis:
               •   discuss the methods and techniques in Organization Analysis
         6.2       INTRODUCTION
         Essential components of carrying out an organizational analysis include
         evaluating external factors that can affect the organization’s performance
         as well as strategically assessing the organization’s own resources and
         potential. Internal strengths and weaknesses along with outside opportunities
         and threats are keys to an organization’s success. SWOT analysis, which
         stands for strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats, is a strategic-
         planning method an organization’s leaders often use to aid them in
         establishing business objectives or achieving the organization’s mission
118                                      Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                        Unit 6
goals.Let us discuss the various aspects of orgnisational appraisal in the
following sections
6.3     CONCEPT OF ORGANIZATIONAL ANALYSIS
Organizational Analysis is the process of evaluating systematically
organizational capabilities which can give it competitive advantage in the
market .The capabilities enable the organization to achieve strategic
advantage for long term success. Organizational Analysis is also known
as internal analysis, corporate appraisal, self approval, company analysis
etc.
Organizational Analysis is the analysis of internal environment which refers
to all factors within an organization that influence its capabilities to
accomplish its strategic intent. The main purpose is to determine the
capabilities of its strength and weakness of an organization. An organization
may adopt an highly systematic approach to analyses. Proactive
organization adopts a systematic approach on the other hand reactive
organization use the ad hoc approach in response to the crisis. Both
secondary and primary sources are used for collecting information needed
for organizational analysis. Internal sources of information are employees
opinion, company files and documents, financial statements and external
sources includes newspapers, magazine, journals, government publications,
trade and industry report etc.
6.4     CHARACTERISTICS OF ORGAINSATIONAL
        ANALYSIS
The important characteristic sor components of carrying out an
organizational analysis includes evaluating external factors and Internal
strenghts and weakness.The external factors are the organization’s
performance as well as strategically assessing the organization’s own
resources and potential and internal strengths, weaknesses along with
outside opportunities and threats are keys to an organization’s success.
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                               119
Unit 6                                                        Organisational Appraisal
         A. Strengths: An organization’s strengths are internal characteristics that
         can give it an advantage over competitors. Evaluating organizational
         strengths usually involves assessing current management, resources,
         manpower and marketing objectives. Generally, internal analysis examines
         an organization’s available resources and core competencies. Determining
         the organization’s capabilities helps its leaders make long-term plans and
         sound decisions. Other factors included in an internal analysis include taking
         a look at the organization’s financial goals and strategic-planning initiatives,
         in addition to its exceptional strengths. Offering high quality products or
         services, building a solid reputation, maintaining strong financial health and
         investing in new technologies are some of the strong points an organization
         can focus on developing in order to improve its position within an industry.
         Efficient delivery of products or services and providing excellence of
         customer service are other positive factors.
         B. Weaknesses: An organization’s weaknesses are another example of
         internal characteristics that can affect its operations and level of
         performance. Identifying weaknesses helps organization to spot problems
         to make the necessary changes. This strategy allows decision makers to
         develop other more suitable alternatives in their strategic planning objectives
         when operations fail to perform as projected. Weaknesses may include
         poor leadership, low employee morale, weak financial, low cash flow,
         outdated technology and inefficient organizational functions or processes.
         One example of converting a weakness into strength might be how an
         organization that lacks adequate financial resources works to control costs
         in order to develop a more competitive advantage.
         C. Opportunities: In general, external organizational analysis weighs the
         potential opportunities and threats that are present outside of the
         organization. External analysis may include market analysis, sizing up the
         competition and evaluating the impact of new technological advances. When
         assessing opportunities in the external environment, organizations must
         set out to identify current market and industry trends, potential niche markets
         and the weaknesses of major competitors. An organization should also
120                                     Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                         Unit 6
consider recent developments in technology as vehicles of opportunity.
Innovation is a key to creating new opportunities; therefore, an organization
that succeeds in setting itself apart from others has the chance to build up
a strong competitive position in the industry. In order to accomplish this
success, an organization must offer something different that its competitors
are incapable to provide something better than the standard.
D. Threats: External risks are not always bad for an organization. For
example, the labor market can pose either a potential threat or an opportunity
depending on the state of the local, national and global economies.
Legislation and government regulation are other factors that can have an
effect on how well an organization performs. Whatever the case, the goal
of an organization striving to succeed is to reduce the impact of external
threats and work on improving its internal weaknesses. Organizations must
be able to adapt and keep pace with the constant changes that occur in the
environment outside of the organization.
6.5 STRATEGIC OR COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE
The strategic advantage of an organization is developed through its
resources, behavior strengths, weakness, synergistic effects,
competencies and capability.Let us discuss these resources in the following
points:
Organizational Resources: Organization resources contain all physical,
human and financial resources. Plant and machinery, raw materials,
geographical location and technology are the examples of physical
resources. Human resources include intelligence, experience, training,
judgment, relationship of members of an organization. Formal structures,
systems and processes are also important resources. Valuable, scarce,
inimitable, durable and non substitutable resources enable an organization
to achieve strategic advantage and to achieve superior performance in the
long run. Organisation which possesses superior resources can produce
more efficiently, better satisfy customers, deliver better value for many and
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                                121
Unit 6                                                       Organisational Appraisal
         thereby earn higher returns on investment. An organization obtains
         resources and its success depends on the cost, quality and adequacy of
         these resources .An organization have in low cost, high quality, and abundant
         resources has an enduring strength which can be used as strategic weapon
         against the competitors.
         Organisatonal Behaviour: An organization does not become capable
         merely by acquiring resources. Its strength and success depends on an
         efficient utilization of these resources which in turn depends on the behavior
         of individuals and groups in an organization. Organizational behavior refers
         to the manifestation of various forces and influences operating within an
         organization that create the ability for, or place constraints on , the uses of
         resources. Several forces and influences such an management philosophy,
         organizational climate and culture, organizational politics and use of power
         shape organizational behavior. If resources are considered the hardware
         of an organization, behavior is its software. The two together create it
         strength and weaknesses.
         Strength and Weaknesses: Strength is an inbuilt capability which an
         organization can use to gain strategic advantage over its competitors. On
         the other hand, a weakness is an inherent limitation or constraint which
         creates a strategic disadvantage for the organization. For example, low
         cost of capital is strength and inexperienced management is a weakness.
         Strength and weaknesses do not exist in isolation but combined within a
         functional area, and also across different functional area, to create
         synergistic effects.
         Synergistic Effects: Synergy occurs when two element complement each
         other. It is popularly known as 2 + 2 = 5 Effect. In other words synergy
         means the whole is more/ less than some of its parts. /synergistic effects
         occur in an organization in many ways. For example, when marketing and
         production departments support each other there is a operating synergy.
         Within a functional area eg. Marketing, when product, pricing, distribution
         and promotion support each other there is a marketing synergy. Synergetic
122                                    Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                          Unit 6
effect can also be negative ( 2 + 2 = 3) . For example, conflict between
marketing and production area leads to negative synergy. Synergistic effects
influence the type and quality of the internal environment of an organization
and many lead to development of competencies.
Competencies: An organization’ competencies are its unique qualities that
facilitate it’s withstand its competitive pressure in market place. The ability
of an organization to compete with its rival depends on its unique quality.
Competencies may exist in a form of unique resources, core capabilities,
surrounded knowledge, invisible asset, Etc.
Organizational Capability: The capability of an organization means its
intrinsic capability or potential to develop its strength and to rise above its
weaknesses so as to exploit its opportunities. And face the treats in its
external environment. In the absence of capability, even exceptional and
valuable resources may be worthless. According to several thinkers in
strategic management, capabilities are the outcomes of an organization
knowledge base or the skills and knowledge of its employees. Organizational
capabilities are important for strategy making due to two reasons: First, it
indicates an organization capacity to meet environmental challenges.
Second, it reveals to potential that should be developed in the organization
to achieve success.
Strategic and competitive Advantage: Strategic advantages are the
shareholders value and market share and are the outcomes of organizational
capabilities. On the other hand, strategic disadvantages are the
shortcomings due to lack of organizational capabilities. Both can be
measured in absolute terms. For example, higher the probability, greater is
the strategic advantage. Comparative advantage is a special type of strategic
advantage. It is a relative term and is compared with respect to rivals in the
industry. For example, a company has a comparative advantage when its
profitability is higher than that of its rivals. Thus strategic advantage is a
broader concept and competitive advantage is one of its parts.
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                                 123
Unit 6                                                       Organisational Appraisal
                                          CHECK YOUR PROGRESS
          Q1:   Define Organisational Analysis
          …
          ………
            ………
              ………
                ………
                  ………
                    ………
                      ………
                        ………
                          ………
                            ………
                              ………
                                ………
                                  ………
                                    ………
                                      ………
                                        ………
                                          ………
                                            ………
                                              ………
                                                ………
                                                  ………
                                                    ………
                                                      ………
                                                        ………
                                                          ………
                                                            ………
                                                              ………
                                                                ……
          Q2:    What is Organisational Resources?
          …
          ………
            ………
              ………
                ………
                  ………
                    ………
                      ………
                        ………
                          ………
                            ………
                              ………
                                ………
                                  ………
                                    ………
                                      ………
                                        ………
                                          ………
                                            ………
                                              ………
                                                ………
                                                  ………
                                                    ………
                                                      ………
                                                        ………
                                                          ………
                                                            ………
                                                              ………
                                                                ……
          Q3:   What is organizational capability?
          …
          ………
            ………
              ………
                ………
                  ………
                    ………
                      ………
                        ………
                          ………
                            ………
                              ………
                                ………
                                  ………
                                    ………
                                      ………
                                        ………
                                          ………
                                            ………
                                              ………
                                                ………
                                                  ………
                                                    ………
                                                      ………
                                                        ………
                                                          ………
                                                            ………
                                                              ………
                                                                ……
         6.6    FACTORS IN ORGAISNATIONAL ANALYSIS
         Organizational analysis involves the identification of factors which indicate
         organizational capabilities. These factors are known as organizational
         capability factors or competitive advantage factors or strategic factors. The
         following are the organizational capability factors that exist within an
         organization which are critical for the formulation and implementation of
         the strategy.The following are some of the factors in organisational analysis:
         a.     Capability Factors in Finance: Financial capability factors are
                concerned with the availability, usage and management of funds.
                Some of the important factors which influence an organization’s
                financial capability are as under:
                i.      Sources of funds - related factors-financing pattern (capital
                        structure), cost of funds, financial leverage, reserves and
                        surplus, relationship with provider of funds, etc.
                ii.     Usage of funds - related factors - fixed assets, current assets,
                        loans and advances, dividend distribution.
                iii.    Management of funds - related factors-accounting and
                        budgeting systems, financial control system, tax planning
                        return risk and management, etc.
124                                    Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                          Unit 6
b.      Capability Factors in Marketing: The main factors that influence
       the marketing capability of an organization are as follows:
        i.      Product related factors-product mix, branding product
                positioning, differentiation, packaging, etc.
        ii.     Price related factors-pricing policies, price competitiveness,
                value for money pricing, price changes etc.
        iii.    Place related factors-distribution network, transportation and
                logistics, relations with intermediaries, etc
        iv.     Promotion related factors-promotion mix, promotion tools,
                customers relationship management etc.
        v.      Integration and control related factors-market standing,
                company image, marketing information system, marketing
                organization, etc.
                                         LET US KNOW
                     Marketing strengths and weaknesses of some
                     companies are given below:
 •      Hindustan Unilever is known for its marketing capability. It has a
       countrywide distribution network with a large number of clearing
       and forwarding (C&F) agents , wholesalers and retailers. It has
       prominent brands in its kitty, most of them provided by its parent
       company.
 •      Parle enjoys a strong image and appeal among Indian consumers.
       Several of its biscuits and confectionery brands are market leaders
       in their category. The company enjoys a high market share with its
       biscuits brands such as Parle-G, Monaco and krackjack and
       confectionery brands such as Kismi, mangobite, Malady and Poppins.
 •      Philips India adopted premium pricing strategy for its colour
       televisions on the premise of popularity of its brands in electrical and
       electronic segments, But customers could not relate quality of Philips
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                                 125
Unit 6                                                          Organisational Appraisal
                  TV sets with higher price due to several quality-price-performance
                  offerings from its competitors like L.G. , Samsung, Sony. Etc.
          •        Several studies reveal that ineffective marketing is prone of the
                  major causes of industrial sickness in the small scale sector.
         c.        Capability factors in Operation: Operations capability factors
                  relate to the production of products and services. Major factor
                  influencing an organization operation capability are as under :
                   i.      Production system : Factors related production system are
                           plant location, capacity and its utilization , plant layout,
                           product design, material supply system, degree of
                           automation , extent of vertical integration etc.
                   ii.     Operations and control system: factors related to operation
                           and control system are production planning, inventory
                           management, cost and quality control, maintenance system
                           and procedures, etc.
                   iii.    Research and Development : Factors related research and
                           development are product development , R & D staff,
                           technical collaboration and support, patent right, level of
                           technology used etc.
                                           LET US KNOW
                              Strength and Weaknesses in the area of operations
                              of some companies are given below :
              •    Reliance Industries got access to global technology for its
                  pertochemicla plant through technical collaboration with Dupont
                  (USA), ICI (UK), Navocor (Cananda), and Crest (Netherland).Its high
                  level of vertical integration serves as an entry barrier to new entrants
                  in petrochemicals.
126                                       Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                        Unit 6
     •    ICICI Bank has used information technology to offer value to its
         customers. In its operating process, more than 20 per cent
         transactions take place on the Internet , about 65 percent through
         ATM and less than 15 percent in branches . As a result ICICI Bank is
         narrowing the gap between itself and the largest bank, State Bank
         Of India, though the latter has much more number of branches than
         ICICI Bank.
d.        Capability factors in Human Resources: In any organization
         human resources make use of non-human resources. Human
         resource capabilities relate to the acquisition and use of human
         resources, skills and all connected aspects that pressure strategy
         formulation and implementation. Some of the important factors which
         determine human resource capability are given below.
          i.     Factors related to the human resource system - Human
           resource planning recruitment and selection, training and
           development, human resource mobility, appraisal and
           compensation management, etc.
          ii.    Factors related to employee retention - Company’s image
           as an employer, career development opportunities for employees,
           working conditions, employee benefits, employee motivation and
           morale, etc.
          iii.   Factors related to industrial relations - Union management
           relationship, collective bargaining, grievance handling system,
           employee participation in management, etc.
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                               127
Unit 6                                                          Organisational Appraisal
                                           LET US KNOW
                                 Some examples of human resources capability and
                                 their impact are as under:
              •    Infosys Technologies is considered a good employer and
                   employees are its greatest strength. It recruits people with good
                   academic record; attitudes for teamwork and high learn ability. The
                   company spends about 3 percent of its resources on training and
                   development and has a very attractive employee stock option
                   scheme.
              •    Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) recruited 1.7 lakh employees,
                   much more than what it actually required due to faulty human
                   resource planning. This resulted in heavy losses to SAIL due to
                   huge wage/salary bill. Moreover, availability of ample idle time
                   created complacency among employees. On the advice of its
                   consultants (Mc Kinsey & Co), SAIL pruned its workforce to one
                   lakh employees and paid heavy compensation under the Voluntary
                   Retirement Scheme (VRS).
         e.        Capability Factors in Information Management: Information is
              valuable resource and can provide a competitive advantage to the
              organization. Information system is concerned with collection,
              processing, storage and dissemination of Information relevant for
              decision- making. Some of the factors that influence information
              management capability are as follows:
              i.   Factors related to acquisition and retention of information - sources,
                   quality, quality, timeliness and cost of information, capacity to retain
                   and protect information.
              ii. Factors related to processing and synthesis of information - computer
                   systems, software capability, database management, synthesizing
                   capability.
128                                       Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                                Unit 6
         iii. Factors related to retrieval and usage of information - availability of
             right information in the right format, a capacity to assimilate and
             use information.
         iv. Factors related to transmission and dissemination of information -
             speed of transmission, willingness to accept information etc.
         v. Factors related to integration and support – availability of appropriate
             IT infrastructure, investment in state-of-the-art system, competence
             of computer professionals, top management, support, etc.
                                             LET US KNOW
                      Some examples of companies with information system
                      capability are given below:
     •       Infosys Technologies has linked its various software development
           centers, located at different places in India and abroad, through
           computerized networks, It has similar networking with its clients too.
           As a result, its staff can share relevant information among
           themselves as well as with the clients.
     •       All branches of ICICI Bank spread throughout the country are
           interlinked through computerized networks. This creates value for a
           customer as he can operate his account from any place even if he
           does not have an account in the branch located at that place.
f.           Capability Factors In General Management: General
            Management involves integration and direction of the functional
            capabilities. Some of the major factors that influence general
            management capability are as under:
             i.      Strategic management system related factors - Processes
              relating to developing strategic intent,-strategy formulation and
              implementation, strategy evaluation, rewards and incentives for top
              managers, etc.
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                                       129
Unit 6                                                   Organisational Appraisal
             ii.     Top management related factors - Values, norms, personal
              goals, competence, experience, orientation and risk propensity of
              general managers.
             iii.    External relationships related factors - Public image as
              corporate citizen, sense of social responsibility, rapport of
              government and regulatory agencies, public relations, etc.
             iv.     Organizational climate related factors - Organizational
              culture, powers and politics management of change, balance of
              vested interests, etc.
                                            LET US KNOW
                        Some examples of companies with or without
                        general management capability are given below:
         •   Hindustan Unilever limited had exceptional capability in general
             management. It is considered a leadership laboratory. As a result,
             it has produced a large number of chief executives both for itself
             and its parent company, Unilever.
         •   Amul is a household name in India. Gujarat Cooperative Milk
             Marketing Federation (GCMMF), the producer of Amul brand milk
             and milk products, is a success story in the cooperative sector. It
             is legendary founder, Verghese Kurien, is called the father of White
             Revolution in India. His vision and the top management team of
             GCMMF have made it.
130                                Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                           Unit 6
                                    CHECK YOUR PROGRESS
 Q4:    Write any two factors that influence the marketing capability of an
 organization.
 …
 ………
   ………
     ………
       ………
         ………
           ………
             ………
               ………
                 ………
                   ………
                     ………
                       ………
                         ………
                           ………
                             ………
                               ………
                                 ………
                                   ………
                                     ………
                                       ………
                                         ………
                                           ………
                                             ………
                                               ………
                                                 ………
 Q5:    Write any two factors that influence the marketing capability of an
 organization.
 …
 ………
   ………
     ………
       ………
         ………
           ………
             ………
               ………
                 ………
                   ………
                     ………
                       ………
                         ………
                           ………
                             ………
                               ………
                                 ………
                                   ………
                                     ………
                                       ………
                                         ………
                                           ………
                                             ………
                                               ………
                                                 ……
6.6     METHODS AND TECHNIQUES IN ORGAINATION
        ANALYSIS
Methods and Techniques used in Organization Analysis and appraisal may
be classified as follows:
A.      INTERNAL ANALYSIS: The internal analysis of an organization
     involves investigation into its strengths and weaknesses by focusing
     on factors which are relevant to it :
      1. VRIO Framework: The VRIO stands for Valuable, Rare, Inimitable
         and Organized for usage. The terms are explained as follows :
            a. Valuable: These are the capabilities that enable the
                 organization to generate revenues by capitalizing on
                 opportunities and / or to reduce costs by neutralizing threats.
                 The ability to provide high quality after sale services to
                 customers and the ability to develop rapport with the
                 government.
            b. Rare: These are the capabilities that one or a few firms in
                 the industry exclusively possess. A unique location and a
                 highly motivated workforce are example rare capabilities.
            c. Inimitable: these are the capabilities which competitors
                 either cannot duplicate or can duplicate only at a very high
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                                  131
Unit 6                                                      Organisational Appraisal
                    cost. Excellent corporate image and the ability to acquire
                    new business are example of inimitable capabilities.
                 d. Organized for usage: These are the capabilities which an
                    organization can use through its appropriate structure
                    business processes, control and reward system. The
                    availability of competent R & D personnel and research
                    laboratory to continually strong out innovative products is an
                    example of organized for usage capability.
         2. Value Chain Analysis: Every organization performs several
            activities. These activities are interrelated and form a chain. Each
            activity in the chain creates some value and involves cost. Thus, a
            value chain analysis is a set of interlinked and value – creating
            activities performed by an organization.
            a.      Primary Activities: These activities are directly related to
                 the creation of product or service. Primary activities consist of
                 the following.
                      i.      Inbound logistics: All the activities used for receiving,
                             storing and transporting inputs into the production
                             process are known as inbound logistics.
                      ii.     Operations: All activities involved in the
                             transformation of inputs into outputs are called
                             operations.
                      iii.    Outbound logistics: All the activities used for receiving,
                             storing and transporting finished products are known
                             as outbound logistics.
                      iv.     Marketing and sales: These consist of activities used
                             to market and sell products services to customers.
                      v.      Service: These are the activities used for enhancing
                             and maintaining a product’s value.
            b.      Support Activities: These activities provide support to the
                 primary activities. Support activities consist of:
132                                  Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                              Unit 6
                      i.   Firm infrastructure: All activities for general
                           management of the organization to achieve its objective
                           are called firm infrastructure.
                      ii. Human resource management: These comprise
                           recruitment, selection, and training, deploying and
                           retaining the human resources of an organization.
                      iii. Technology development: Typical activities in this
                           category are research and development, product and
                           process design, equipment design etc.
                      iv. Procurement: Obtaining raw materials, parts, supplies,
                           machinery, equipment and other purchased items are
                           included in procurement.
3.    Quantitative analysis: In quantitative analysis both financial and non
      financial aspects are covered.
                i.         Financial Analysis: In order to judge strength and
                           weaknesses in different functional areas, ratio analysis
                           and economic value added analysis are used.
                ii.        Non-Financial Analysis: There are several aspects of
                           an organization which cannot be measured in financial
                           terms. Non-financial analysis is used to assess these
                           aspects .Employee absenteeism and turnover,
                           advertising recall rate, production cycle time, service
                           call rates, number of patents registered per annum,
                           inventory turnover rate, etc. are such aspects.
     4. Qualitative Analysis: Those aspects of an organization which
         cannot be expressed in quantitative terms are assessed through
         qualitative analysis. Corporate image, corporate culture, learning
         ability, employment morale, etc. are examples of these aspects.
         Qualitative analysis can be used to support and strengthen
         quantitative analysis.
     B. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS: Strengths and weaknesses provide a
        competitive advantage to the organization when these are unique
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                                     133
Unit 6                                                Organisational Appraisal
         and exclusive. Therefore, an organization should compare its
         capabilities with those of its competitors. Comparative analysis can
         be over a time period, on the basis of industry norms and through
         bench marking.
         Historical Analysis: In historical analysis an organizations strengths
         and weaknesses are compared over different time periods. Its
         reveals whether the strengths are improving or declining. Areas which
         show continuous improvement are durable strengths. Hofer and
         Schendel have developed a functional-area profile and resource
         deployment matrix for historical analysis.
         Industry Norms: Every industry has certain norms or standards
         for key parameters of performance. The performance levels of a
         firm can be compared with the norms of the industry in which the
         firm operated. For example, cost levels of Maruti Suzuki may be
         compared against cost standards in the car industry. A more
         selective approach can be to compare with firms that follow similar
         strategies. These firms are known as strategic group .According to
         Miller and Dess, a strategic group is “a cluster of competitors that
         share similar strategies and, therefore , compete more directly with
         one another than with other firms in the same industry.”
         Benchmarking: A benchmark means a reference point for the
         purpose of measurement and comparison.” Benchmarking is the
         process of identifying, understanding and adapting outstanding
         practices from within the same industry or from other businesses
         to help improve performance.” The basic purpose of benchmarking
         is to match and even surpass the best performer. The key question
         is benchmarking are: What to benchmark and whom to benchmark.
         These questions can be answered by knowing the types of bench
         marking . On the basis of what to benchmark, benchmarking is to
         following types:
                    i. Performance benchmarking
                    ii. Process benchmarking
                    iii. Strategic benchmarking
134                            Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                       Unit 6
                    iv. Competitive benchmarking
                    v. Functional benchmarking
                    vi. Generic benchmarking
C.    COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS: Each of the techniques has its own
benefits but fails to offer a comprehensive representation of organizational
strengths and weaknesses. Comprehensive analysis is required to defeat
this limitation. The techniques used in comprehensive analysis are given
below:
Key factor rating: In this technique the key factors as discussed under
are analyzed to judge their positive and negative impact on the functioning
of the organization.
Balanced Scorecard: Balanced scorecard is the most comprehensive
method of analyzing an organization’s strengths and weaknesses. It
integrates different perspectives with vision and strategy to present a
comprehensive and balanced picture of organizational performance.
The four key performance actions identified in balanced scorecard are as
under
            i.         Financial perspective’
            ii.        Customer perspective
            iii.       Internal Business Processes Perspective
            iv.        Learning and innovative perspectives
Business Intelligence Systems: Data from a range of internal and external
sources are used to estimate the company strategic directions and
operational performance. Data mining, data warehouse and analytical
reports are used.
D.    SWOT ANALYSIS: The SWOT stands for the following:
        1. Strength(S): Strength is a competency which facilitates an
           organization to gain an advantage over its competitors.
        2. Weakness (W): A weaknesses is a limitation or constraint which
           creates a competitive drawback for the organization.
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                              135
Unit 6                                                       Organisational Appraisal
                3. Opportunity (O): An opportunity is an encouraging condition in
                   the environment.
                4. Threat (T): A threat is an adverse condition in the environment.
         Strength and weaknesses can be identified through organizational appraisal
         or analysis of the internal environment. Environmental appraisal or analysis
         of the external environment reveals opportunities and threats.
         SWOT analysis is also known as WOTS and TOWS analysis. It helps in
         understanding the internal and external environment. It is very useful in
         strategy as the organizations strengths and weaknesses can be matched
         with the opportunities and threats. An effective strategy makes use of
         strengths to capitalize on the opportunities and minimize the impact of
         weaknesses to neutralize the threats. After SWOT analysis, an organization
         had to decide how to maximize its strengths and minimize its weaknesses.
         It can also decide how to exploit the opportunities and to cover the threats.
         Main advantages of SWOT analysis are as follows:
                        i.     It is simple to use
                        ii.    It is inexpensive
                        iii.   It provides a comprehensive picture of environment
                        iv.    It is flexible and can be adapted to different types of
                             organizations
                        It serves as the basis for strategic analysis.
                                           CHECK YOUR PROGRESS
          Q6:    Define Benchmarking.
          ……………………………………………………………………………………………
          ……………………………………………………………………………………………
          Q7:    What is SWOT analysis.
          …………………………………………………………………………………………
          …………………………………………………………
136                                    Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                                Unit 6
               6.7      LET US SUM UP
In this unit we discussed the following :
•        Organizational Analysis is the analysis of internal environment which
         refers to all factors within an organization that influence its capabilities
         to accomplish its strategic intent. The main purpose is to determine
         the capabilities of its strength and weakness of an organization.
•        The strategic advantage of an organization is developed through its
         resources, behavior strengths, weakness, synergistic effects,
         competencies and capability.
    a. Organizational Resources
    b. Organisatonal Behaviour
    c. Strength and Weaknesses
    d. Synergistic Effects
    e. Competencies
    f.   Organizational Capability
    g. Strategic and competitive Advantage
•        The organizational capability factors that exists within an organization
         which are: Capability Factors in Finance, Capability Factors in
         Marketing, Capability factors in Operation, Capability factors in
         Human Resources, Capability Factors in Information Management
•        Methods and Techniques used in Organization Analysis and
         appraisal may be classified as : internal analysis, comparative
         analysis, comprehensive analysis and SWOT analysis
               6.8     FURTHER READING
1. Cherunilam Francis (2015), Business Policy and Strategic Management,
         Himalaya Publication House , New Delhi
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                                       137
Unit 6                                                         Organisational Appraisal
         2.    C Appa Rao, B Parvathiswara Rao, K Sivaramakrishna (2008);
               Strategic Management and Business Policy, Excel Books, Nerw Delhi
         3.    Tandon A (2010); Business Policy and Strategic Management; Anmol
               Publications Pvt.Ltd.
         4.    Rao Subba P();Business Policy and Strategic Management: Text
               and Cases; Himalaya Publication House , New Delhi
                      6.9     ANSWERS TO CHECK YOUR
                             PROGRESS
         Ans to Q1:    Organizational Analysis is the process of evaluating
                       systematically organizational capabilities which can give it
                       competitive advantage in the market .
         Ans to Q2:     Organization resources contain all physical, human and
                       financial resources. Plant and machinery, raw materials,
                       geographical location and technology are the examples of
                       physical resources. Human resources include intelligence,
                       experience, training, judgment, relationship of members of
                       an organization.
         Ans top Q3:    The capability of an organization means its intrinsic capability
                       or   potential to develop its strength and to rise above its
                       weaknesses so as to exploit its opportunities.
         Ans to Q4:     The factors that influence the marketing capability of an
                       organization are:
               a.       Product related factors-product mix, branding product
                        positioning, differentiation, packaging, etc.
               b.       Price related factors-pricing policies, price competitiveness,
                        value for money pricing, price changes etc.
         Ans to Q5:     The important factors which determine human resource
                       capability are:
               a.       Factors related to the human resource system - Human
                        resource planning recruitment and selection, training and
                        development, human resource mobility etc
138                                      Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)
Organisational Appraisal                                                              Unit 6
        b.         Factors related to employee retention - Company’s image
                   as an employer, career development opportunities for
                   employees, working conditions, employee benefits, employee
                   motivation and morale, etc.
Ans to Q6:         Benchmarking is the process of identifying, understanding
                  and adapting outstanding practices from within the same
                  industry or from other businesses to help improve
                  performance.
Ans to Q7:         The SWOT stands for the following:
             1.    Strength(S): Strength is a competency which facilitates an
                   organization to gain an advantage over its competitors.
             2.    Weakness (W): A weaknesses is a limitation or constraint
                   which creates a competitive drawback for the organization.
             3.    Opportunity (O): An opportunity is an encouraging condition
                   in the environment.
             4.    Threat (T): A threat is an adverse condition in the environment.
                  6.10     MODEL QUESTIONS
Q1:     Define Organisational Analysis.
Q2:     What are the characteristics of Organisational Analysis.
Q3:     Outline the factors for Strategic advantage of an organization.
Q4:     Describe the organisational capacity factors that exists within an
        organization.
Q5:     Explain the methods and techniques in organisational Analysis.
                                         *****
Business Policy and Strategic Management (Block 1)                                     139