The Possibilities For Reuse of Steel Scrap in Order To Obtain Blades For Knives
The Possibilities For Reuse of Steel Scrap in Order To Obtain Blades For Knives
Submitted: 4 February 2016; Accepted: 22 February 2017; Available On-line: 23 March 2017
ABSTRACT: The paper presents the characterization results of various types of steel component at the end
of product life with the unknown chemical composition, mechanical properties and previously implemented
thermo–mechanical treatment. This study was done aiming to examine the possibilities for reuse of some end–
of–life agricultural and industrial steel products in order to obtain blades for knives in non–industrial conditions
with appropriate and acceptable properties. Demanded shapes of the blades were obtained by applying vari-
ous types of thermo–mechanical treatment. Chemical analysis of the investigated steel components was done
using the energy–dispersive spectrometer. The microstructure was analyzed using optical and scanning electron
microscopy. Hardness of analyzed steel scrap and obtained blades was measured using Rockwell C scale. The
hardness values of the obtained blades (with optional quenching or not) indicate to a good selection of the steel
end–of–life products for this purpose.
KEYWORDS: Blade for knife; Hardness; Microstructure; Steel scrap
Citation / Citar como: Štrbac, N.; Marković, I.; Mitovski, A.; Balanović, L.; Živković, D.; Grekulović, V. (2017)
“The possibilities for reuse of steel scrap in order to obtain blades for knives”. Rev. Metal. 53(1): e086. http://dx.doi.
org/10.3989/revmetalm.086
RESUMEN: Posibilidades de reutilización de la chatarra de acero para la obtención de cuchillas para cortar. El
trabajo presenta los resultados de la caracterización de diversos tipos de aceros que han llegado al final de su
ciclo de vida útil, y de los que se desconocía su composición química, propiedades mecánicas y tratamiento
termomecánico aplicado previamente. El estudio se realizó con el objetivo de analizar las posibilidades de reuti-
lización de algunos de estos materiales en aplicaciones agrícolas e industriales, obteniendo hojas de corte. Las
formas exigidas a las hojas de corte se consiguieron aplicando diversos tipos de tratamientos termomecánicos.
El análisis químico de la chatarra de acero de acero se realizó utilizando Energías Dispersivas de Rayos X. La
microestructura se estudió utilizando Microscopía Óptica y Microscopía Electrónica de Barrido. La dureza de
la chatarra de acero y de las cuchillas obtenidas se midió utilizando la escala Rockwell C. Los valores de dureza
de las cuchillas obtenidas indican una buena selección de los productos finales de acero.
PALABRAS CLAVE: Chatarra de acero; Cuchilla; Dureza; Microestructura
Copyright: © 2017 CSIC. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License (CC BY) Spain 3.0.
2 • Nada Štrbac et al.
Revista de Metalurgia 53(1), January–March 2017, e086. ISSN-L: 0034-8570 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/revmetalm.086
                                                      The possibilities for reuse of steel scrap in order to obtain blades for knives • 3
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
 Figure 2.  Knives as the final products made from different steel scrap: (a) SS1 – hacksaw; (b) SS2 – steam turbine moving blade;
                                    (c) SS3 – sword of a chainsaw; and (d) SS4 – rototiller hoe.
The hardness of the blades was measured at five                      etched using a solution prepared by mixing 15 ml
points, depending on the distance from the cutting                   HCl, 5 ml HNO3, and 80 ml H2O. Microstructure
edge. The average value was taken for further analy-                 was analyzed using Carl Zeiss Jena Epityp 2 optical
sis. The microstructure of the initial steel scrap was               microscope (OM) and Tescan Vega 3LMU scanning
analyzed after standard procedure for microstruc-                    electron microscope (SEM). Oxford Instruments
tural preparation (grinding, polishing and etching                   X – Act energy–dispersive spectrometer (EDS) was
with 2% solution of nital). Only the sample SS2 was                  used to determine the chemical composition of the
          Revista de Metalurgia 53(1), January–March 2017, e086. ISSN-L: 0034-8570 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/revmetalm.086
4 • Nada Štrbac et al.
initial steel scrap samples and the element distribu-                          Figure 4 shows the results of SEM – EDS analy-
tion maps of the sample SS4.                                               sis for the steel scrap SS2. Chemical analysis of the
                                                                           area in Fig. 4a is given by EDS spectrum in Fig. 4b.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION                                                  It shows that the investigated material is a chrome–
                                                                           alloyed steel with medium carbon content with
    In Fig. 3, the results of SEM – EDS analysis for                       grade X20Cr13, according to EN 10250 standard
the steel scrap SS1 are given. Chemical analysis of                        (EN 10250–2, 2000). This was expected, because the
the area in the Fig. 3a was given by EDS spectrum                          steel scrap SS2 was the end–of–life steam turbine
in Fig. 3b. It can be observed that the investigated                       moving blade. Due to its high chrome content, this
material is a tool steel with tungsten, molybdenum,                        steel has got good corrosion resistance, plasticity
chromium and vanadium, corresponding to the                                and high shock resistance (Xi et al., 2008).
high speed tool steel with grade HS 6–5–2 according                            SEM microstructure of the steel scrap SS3 is
to EN ISO 4957 (1999). The numerical designation                           shown in Fig. 5a. Fig. 5b shows the EDS spectrum
in the steel grade refers to the content of W, Mo and                      of the area in the microphotograph in Fig. 5a. The
V in wt.%, respectively. This steel has got improved                       EDS analysis shows that the investigated end–of–
cutting performance due to a high content of tung-                         life product SS3 is a spring steel of grade 38Si7,
sten, and it is often used in the manufacturing of                         according to EN 10089 standard (EN 10089, 2002).
a numerous cutting tools (Da Silva Rocha et al.,                           Its chemical composition contains 0.4 – 0.45 wt.%
1999), hacksaws among others. Results of EDS                               C, 1.8 – 1.9 wt.% Si, 0.8 – 1 wt.% Mn.
analysis of white phase (carbides) at points 1, 2 and                          Figure 6a represents the SEM microstructure of
3 in Fig. 3c were given in Fig. 3d. It is shown that                       the steel scrap SS4. In Fig. 6b, the EDS spectrum of
this phase was the complex carbide phase with W,                           the area in the microphotograph in Fig. 6a is shown.
Mo, Fe, V and Cr.                                                          Having into account the chemical composition,
(a) (b)
                                            14000                                                                                              Spectrum 1
                                            12000                                             Fe
10000
8000
                                              6000           Fe
                                              4000          Mn
                                                            Cr
                                              2000          V    W Mo                Cr            Fe
                                                                                 V     Mn           W       W
                                                           C    W                                                    W
                                                 0
                                                           0        2      4              6             8            10    12      14     16   18
                                            Full Scale 14430 cts Cursor: 19.794 (3 cts)                                                              keV
    (c)
                                                 (d)
C Ti V Cr Fe Mo W
       Figure 3.  SEM – EDS results of the steel scrap SS1: (a) SEM microphotograph; (b) EDS spectrum of the area in the
    microphotograph in Fig. 3a; (c) SEM microphotograph with higher concentration of the white phase; and (d) Results of EDS
                                  analysis of white phase (carbides) at points 1, 2 and 3 in Fig. 3c.
Revista de Metalurgia 53(1), January–March 2017, e086. ISSN-L: 0034-8570 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/revmetalm.086
                                                    The possibilities for reuse of steel scrap in order to obtain blades for knives • 5
(a) (b)
                                                    15000                                                                  Spectrum 1
                                                                                           Fe
                                                                                           Mn
10000
                                                        5000    Fe
                                                                Mn                   Cr
                                                                Cr                       Cr     Fe
                                                                C        Si              Mn
                                                          0
                                                          0        2        4        6         8      10    12   14   16   18      20
                                                   Full Scale 15362 cts Cursor: 20.248 (4 cts)                                    keV
    Figure 4.  SEM – EDS results of the steel scrap SS2: (a) SEM microphotograph; and (b) EDS spectrum of the area in the
                                                 microphotograph in Fig. 4a.
(a) (b)
                                               35000                                                                       Spectrum 1
                                                                                          Fe
                                               30000
                                               25000
                                               20000
                                               15000       Fe
                                               10000      Mn
                                                5000                                       Fe
                                                         C          Si              Mn
                                                   0
                                                       0        2        4         6             8   10    12    14   16   18       20
                                               Full Scale 35944 cts Cursor: 20.118 (7 cts)                                        keV
    Figure 5.  SEM – EDS results of the steel scrap SS3: (a) SEM microphotograph; and (b) EDS spectrum of the area in the
                                                 microphotograph in Fig. 5a.
it is concluded that the material used in the produc-                         of production and thermo–mechanical treatment
tion of this component is a low–alloy steel of grade                          in order to product a hacksaw. A 2% nital solution
59Si7 according to ISO 683 – 14 standard (ISO 683–                            was used for etching steel scrap SS1 because it is the
14, 2004). Its chemical composition contains 0.58 –                           most commonly used etchant for tool steels. It is a
0.61 wt.% C, 1.8 – 2 wt.% Si, 0.8 – 0.9 wt.% Mn, 0.2                          suitable etchant for showing structure of carbides
– 0.37 wt.% Cr. The distribution maps of elements                             (Small et al., 2008). The microstructure is consisted
Fe, Cr, Mn, Si and C in the scanning region in Fig.                           of tempered martensitic structure and un–dissolved
6a are shown in Fig. 7. From the distribution maps,                           eutectic carbide particles (Leskovsek and Ule,
the even distribution of all elements on the investi-                         1998). In this kind of steel, directed carbide par-
gated region can be observed.                                                 ticles of the following types can occur: M6C, MC,
    The optical microphotographs of the initial steel                         M2C and M7C3, indicating previous deformation
scrap are given in Fig. 8. SEM and optical micro-                             (Dziedzic, 2007). The chemical composition of the
photographs of the steel scrap SS1, given in Figs. 3a                         carbides done by EDS (Figs. 3c and 3d) shows that
and  8a, respectively, show a fine–grained structure                          the carbides are mainly of the type M2C or M7C3.
with directed distribution of complex carbides,                               Additionally, some primary carbides of the type
which has been achieved by the specific methods                               MC are visible.
         Revista de Metalurgia 53(1), January–March 2017, e086. ISSN-L: 0034-8570 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/revmetalm.086
6 • Nada Štrbac et al.
(a) (b)
30000 Spectrum 1
                                                                                                      Fe
                                                        25000
20000
15000
10000
                                                                      Fe
                                                         5000                                              Fe
                                                                                            Cr
                                                                  C        Si                    Mn
                                                              0
                                                                          2           4          6              8         10      12   14   16   18         20
                                                        Full Scale 30810 cts Cursor: 20.474 (0 cts)                                                         keV
     Figure 6.  SEM – EDS results of the steel scrap SS4: (a) SEM microphotograph; and (b) EDS spectrum of the area in the
                                                  microphotograph in Fig. 6a.
           60 µm                                      60 µm                                                                    60 µm
                         (d)                                                    (e)
60 µm 60 µm
Figure 7. Distribution map of elements in the scanning region in Fig. 6a: (a) Fe; (b) Cr; (c) Mn; (d) Si; and (e) C.
Revista de Metalurgia 53(1), January–March 2017, e086. ISSN-L: 0034-8570 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/revmetalm.086
                                                    The possibilities for reuse of steel scrap in order to obtain blades for knives • 7
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 8. Optical microphotographs of the starting steel scrap: (a) SS1; (b) SS2; (c) SS3; and (d) SS4.
   The microstructure of the steel scrap SS2 is                    It is known that in the steel which contains 2% sili-
shown in Figs. 4a and 8b. For steel of this composi-               con, a large amount of austenite is retained during
tion, homogene martensitic structure is expected to                cooling to room temperature. With increasing the
be formed after air cooling from austenitiziting tem-              amount of retained austenite, both ductility and
perature (Mann, 2013; Gupta, 2015). Depending                      strength increase. Silicon is an inhibitor of carbide
on a heat treatment conditions, various phases can                 precipitation and ferrite stabilizer (Matsumura
occur in the microstructure. The most appropriate                  et al., 1987; Chen et al., 1989). The microstructure
procedure for heat treatment of this steel involves                of steel with silicon may contain retained austenite,
quenching from the temperature of about 1000 °C                    ferrite and martensite or bainite, depending on heat
in oil or in the air, following tempering at 700 °C.               treatment (Chen et al., 1989). Microstructural con-
The resulting microstructure which consists of uni-                stituents vary with annealing temperature and time.
formly distributed globular carbides in the ferrite                For a shorter annealing time during tempering, a
matrix can be expected in the structure (Masters,                  martensite–ferrite structure is a predominant, with
1989), which corresponds to the microstructures                    a small fraction of bainite and retained austenite,
shown in Figs. 4a and 8b. Gooch (Gooch, 1982)                      similar to the microstructures shown in the Figs. 6a
identified these precipitates as M23C6 carbides.                   and 8d. Longer holding time at annealing tempera-
   SEM and optical microphotographs of the steel                   ture results in removal of retained austenite and
scrap SS3 are shown in Figs. 5a and 8c. The micro-                 formation of ferrite–bainite structure (Matsumura
structure of the steel scrap SS4 is shown in Figs.                 et al., 1987).
6a and 8d. According to their composition, both                        Figure 9 shows the hardness values of the initial
steel scrap, SS3 and SS4, belong to spring steel                   scrap (first column), obtained blades (second col-
of type Si2Mn, which have a good combination                       umn) and hardness values of the blades made of
of high strength, good ductility and high shock–                  end–of–life products SS2 and SS3 after oil quench-
resistance in the quenched condition as well as in                 ing (third column).
the tempered condition. These types of steel belong                    The hardness value of the scrap SS1 is 63 HRC,
to the hypo–eutectoid class (Qinghua et al., 2003).                while the blade made of this steel scrap only by
         Revista de Metalurgia 53(1), January–March 2017, e086. ISSN-L: 0034-8570 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/revmetalm.086
8 • Nada Štrbac et al.
                70                                  Steel scrap                  the starting steel scrap. The same hardness value
                                                    Blades                       was obtained on the blade made of steel scrap SS3
                60                                  Blades after oil quenching   after thermo–mechanical treatment followed by
                                                                                 quenching. The hardness values of blades made of
                50
                                                                                 steel scrap SS2 and SS4 were lower, 34 HRC and
                                                                                 43 HRC, respectively. By reusing steel scrap for dif-
Hardness, HRC
                40
                                                                                 ferent purposes various benefits can be achieved
                30
                                                                                 (reduction costs, saving energy, less raw material
                                                                                 usage and  decrease in waste disposal costs), which
                20                                                               is in accordance to the basic requirements of the
                                                                                 European Union waste management strategy
                10                                                               (Vehlow et al., 2007).
                 0                                                               ACKNOWLEDGMENT
                     SS1      SS2             SS3        SS4
                                    Samples
                                                                                    The research results were developed under the
          Figure 9.  Hardness values (HRC) of steel scrap SS1, SS2,              projects TR34023, TR34003 and OI172037 for
          SS3, and SS4; blades made of SS1, SS2, SS3, and SS4; and
               blades made of SS3 and SS4 after oil quenching.                   which the funds were provided by the Ministry of
                                                                                 Education, Science and Technological Development
                                                                                 of the Republic of Serbia. The authors would like
using mechanical treatment (cutting, grinding and                                to thank Prof. Dr. Svetlana Nestorović (deceased in
polishing) shows the same hardness value.                                        2015) and Igor Kalinović for their help.
   The steel scrap SS2 has a significantly lower
value of hardness of about 19 HRC. The blade                                     REFERENCES
made of this type of steel scrap has a slightly higher
hardness value of about 22 HRC, as a result of the                               Bramfitt, L., Brenscoter, A.O. (2002). Metallographer’s Guide.
applied thermo–mechanical treatment in order to                                       Practices and Procedures for Irons and Steels, ASM Inter-
                                                                                      national, Materials Park, Ohio, USA.
shape scrap to final blade. This blade was further                               Chen, H.C., Era, H., Shimizu, M. (1989). Effect of phospho-
quenched from the austenitization temperature,                                        rus on the formation of retained austenite and mechani-
which additionally increased its hardness value to                                    cal properties in Si–containing low–carbon steel sheet.
                                                                                      Metall. Trans. A 20 (3), 437–445. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/
34 HRC.                                                                               BF02653923.
   Steel scrap SS3 has a hardness value of about                                 Cooper, D.R., Allwood, J.M. (2012). Reusing steel and alu-
43 HRC. The performed thermo–mechanical treat-                                        minum components at end of product life. Environ. Sci.
                                                                                      Technol. 46 (18), 10334−10340. http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/
ment has not affected the hardness value. However,                                    es301093a.
quenching of the obtained blade in oil caused a sig-                             Da Silva Rocha, A., Strohaecker, T., Tomala, V., Hirsch, T.
nificant increase in hardness, up to 64 HRC.                                          (1999). Microstructure and residual stresses of a plasma–
   Steel scrap SS4 has a similar hardness value                                       nitrided M2 tool steel. Surf. Coat. Tech. 115 (1), 24–31.
                                                                                      http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0257-8972(99)00063-8.
(about 41 HRC) as steel scrap SS3. Applied mechan-                               Dziedzic, A. (2007). Microstructure of remelted zone of HS
ical treatment, which was aimed to form steel scrap                                   6–5–2 high speed steel. Arch. Foundry. Eng. 7 (3), 43–46.
into blade, had no effect on the hardness value.                                 EN ISO 4957 (1999). Tool steels. International Organization for
                                                                                      Standardization.
                                                                                 EN 10250–2 (2000). Open steel die forgings for general engineer-
4. CONCLUSIONES                                                                       ing purposes – Part 2: Non–alloy quality and special steels.
                                                                                      CEN, Brussels.
                                                                                 EN 10089 (2002). Hot rolled steels for quenched and tempered
   Various end–of–life agricultural and indus-                                        springs – Technical delivery conditions. CEN, Brussels.
trial steel products are very valuable for reusing.                              Gooch, D.J. (1982). Creep fracture of 12Cr–Mo–V steel. Met. Sci. 16
Therefore, this paper studies the possibilities of                                    (2), 79–89. http://dx.doi.org/10.1179/030634582790427190.
reusing of some end–of–life agricultural and indus-                              Goune, M., Danoix, F., Argren, J., Brechet, Y., Hutchinson,
                                                                                      C.R., Militzer, M., Purdy, G., Van der Zwaag, S., Zurob,
trial steel products in order to obtain blades. The                                   H. (2015). Overview of the current issues in austenite to
characterization of chosen steel scrap showed that                                    ferrite transformation and the role of migrating interfaces
the initial materials were very different in struc-                                   therein for low alloyed steels. Mater. Sci. Eng. R. 92, 1–38.
                                                                                      http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mser.2015.03.001.
tural, chemical and mechanical properties. The                                   Gupta, K.M. (2015). Engineering Materials. Research, Applica-
blades obtained in non–industrial conditions, using                                   tions and Advances, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, USA.
four different steel scrap as initial materials, had                             ISO 683–14 (2004). Heat–treatable steels, alloy steels and free–
a wide range of hardness values (from 22 HRC to                                       cutting steels – Part 14: Hot–rolled steels for quenched
                                                                                      and tempered springs. International Organization for
64 HRC) depending on the type of steel scrap and                                      Standardization.
implemented thermo–mechanical treatment. The                                     Kumar, A., Bhushan, B. (2015). Nanomechanical, nanotri-
blade made from steel scrap SS1 showed the high-                                      bological and macrotribological characterization of
                                                                                      hard coatings and surface treatment of H–13 steel.
est value of hardness, which was achieved without                                     Tribol. Int. 81, 149–158. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
further quenching, only by mechanical shaping of                                      triboint.2014.08.010.
Revista de Metalurgia 53(1), January–March 2017, e086. ISSN-L: 0034-8570 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/revmetalm.086
                                                         The possibilities for reuse of steel scrap in order to obtain blades for knives • 9
Leskovsek, V., Ule, B. (1998). Improved vacuum heat–treatment           Pacelli, F., Ostuzzi, F., Levi, M. (2015). Reducing and reusing
     for fine–blanking tools from high–speed steel M2. J. Mater.             industrial scraps: a proposed method for industrial design-
     Process. Tech. 82 (1–3), 89–94. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/              ers. J. Clean. Pro. 86, 78–87. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
     S0924-0136(98)00023-5.                                                  jclepro.2014.08.088.
Mann, B.S. (2013). Laser treatment of textured X20Cr13 stain-           Qinghua, Z., Jinping, W., Hujian (2003). Nonequilibrium lever
     less steel to improve water droplet erosion resistance of               principle and new type of dynamic phase diagrams for
     LPST blades and LP bypass valves. J. Mater. Eng. Per-                   Si2Mn–type steel. Met. Sci. Heat Treat. 45 (11), 415–418.
     form. 22 (12), 3699–3707. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/                    http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/B:MSAT.0000019193.27879.3b.
     s11665-013-0687-8.                                                 Small, K., Englehart, D., Christman, T. (2008). Guide to etching
Masters, J.E. (1989). Fractography of Modern Engineering Mate-               specialty alloys. Adv. Mater. Process. 166 (2), 32–37.
     rials: Composites and Metals, Volume 1, ASTM, Balti-               Vehlow, J., Bergfeldt, B., Visser, R., Wilén, C. (2007). European
     more, USA.                                                              Union waste management strategy and the importance
Matsumura, O., Sakuma, Y., Takechi, H. (1987). Enhance-                      of biogenic waste. J. Mater. Cycles. Waste Manag. 9 (2),
     ment  of elongation by retained intercritical annealed                  130–139. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10163-007-0178-9.
     0.4C–1.5Si–0.8Mn austenite in steel. T. Iron Steel I. Jpn.         Xi, Y., Liu, D., Han, D. (2008). Improvement of corrosion and
     27 (7), 570–579. http://dx.doi.org/10.2355/isijinternational           wear resistances of AISI 420 martensitic stainless steel
     1966.27.570.                                                            using plasma nitriding at low temperature. Surf. Coat.
Morfeldt, J., Nijs, W., Silveira, S. (2015). The impact of climate           Tech. 202 (12), 2577–2583. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
     targets on future steel production – an analysis based on a             surfcoat.2007.09.036.
     global energy system model. J. Clean. Prod. 103, 469–482.          Zeng, Y., Mu, S., Wu, P., Ong, K.P., Zhang, J. (2009). Relative
     http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.04.045.                        effects of all chemical elements on the electrical conductiv-
Oda, J., Akimoto, K., Tomoda, T. (2013). Long–term global                    ity of metal and alloys: An alternative to Norbury–Linde
     availability of steel scrap. Resour. Conserv. Recy. 81, 81–91.          rule. J. Alloy. Compd. 478 (1-2), 345–354. http://dx.doi.
     http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2013.10.002.                      org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2008.11.035.
Revista de Metalurgia 53(1), January–March 2017, e086. ISSN-L: 0034-8570 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/revmetalm.086