International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
Volume VI, Issue XI, November 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
  Investigation on Magnetorheological Damper for Its
                 Various Applications
                                             Sidharth Sharma1, Sumanyu Khurana2
    1 ,2
           Department of Mechanical Engineering, Amity School of Engineering and Technology, Amity University, Noida, Uttar
                                                         Pradesh, India
Abstract: - Magneto Rheological damper is a special type of         Magnetorheological fluids consists of micron sized, ferrous
damper that is filled with Magnetorheological fluids which can      particles (mainly iron) that are suspended in an appropriate
be controlled by magnetic field using an electromagnet. These       carrier medium such as mineral oil, synthetic oil, water or
types of smart fluids change their physical properties when         ethylene glycol. The MR effect is immediately reversible if
subjected to magnetic field and turn into visco-elastic solids in
few milliseconds. This property allows the MR damper to be
                                                                    the magnetic field is reduced or removed. Response times of
used as a shock absorber by controlling its damping                 6.5 ms have been recorded. If the magnetic field is reduced or
characteristics by changing the intensity of electromagnet. This    removed, the MR effect is straight away reversible.The
paper focuses on the various applications of MR dampers in          recorded response time is 6.5 milliseconds.MR materials that
latest technologies.                                                have been already developed are usually stable in temperature
                                                                    ranges from –50oC to 150oC. Magneto rheological materials
Keywords- Magneto rheological damper, Electro rheological
damper, Vehicle, Suspension                                         are more advantageous than electro rheological materials. In
                                                                    compare to electro rheological materials, MR fluids are more
                                                                    constructive because of the large change in their physical
                        I. INTRODUCTION
                                                                    properties[6].On comparison to ER materials, MR materials
T    he magnetorheological damper was patented by J. David
     Carlson and Michael J.Chrzan on 11 Jan 1994. The
discovery of MR fluids is ascribed to Jacob Rabinow in
                                                                    respond less to moisture and contaminants, and as a result
                                                                    they could be used in dirty or contaminated environments.
                                                                    The power (50 W) and voltage (12–24V) requirements for
1940’s. MR dampers are semi-active devices that are filled          MR materials activation are comparatively small as compared
with magnetorheological fluids. When magnetic field is              with ER materials. Moreover, the MR Fluid and different
applied, the MRF varies from liquid to semi-solid state in just     carriers is given in Table1.
few milliseconds, so the outcome is an infinitely variable,
                                                                      TABLE 1: MR FLUIDS AND DIFFERENT CARRIERS
controllable damper are capable of large damping forces[1].
The MR fluid is controlled by magnetic field using an
electromagnet. As the electromagnet intensity increases the
fluid viscosity also increases within the damper. MR dampers
offer a striking solution to energy absorption in mechanical
systems could be considered as “fail-safe” device. Many
everyday items are already incorporating smart materials
(bikes, cars, glasses, washing machines) and the number of
applications for them is growing steadily.
     Magnetorheological (MR) fluid is a functional fluid that
changes its physical characteristics when magnetic field is
applied.Magnetorheological fluids (MRFs) consist of
suspended ferrous particles like carbonyl iron particles that
are micron sized, and are dispersed in a carrier medium. When
magnetic field is applied these suspended particles in MRF
gets magnetised and align themselves in structures like chains
which resists the shear deformation of fluid. This change in
material results in a rapid increase in viscosity or in the
formation of a semisolid state[2]–[5].                               III.CONSTRUCTION AND WORKING OF MR DAMPER
                                                                    MR dampers consist of a piston, magnetic coil, accumulator,
              II. MR FLUIDS AND ITS BEHAVIOUR                       bearing, seal, and damper reservoir which are filled with
www.ijltemas.in                                                                                                         Page 10
        International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
                                Volume VI, Issue XI, November 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
MRF. The fig.1 shows the schematic diagram of MR damper.           Semi active suspension systems are becoming more popular in
In this damper as soon as the piston rod enters the housing,       automobiles as they can overcome all the inherent limitations
MRF in the piston head flows from high pressure chamber to         of passive and active suspension systems and also combine
low pressure chamber through orifices. The accumulator             the advantages of both. This is due to their design simplicity,
consists of a compressed gas and its piston provides a             infinite possible dynamics, low voltage requirements, better
moveable barrier between MRF and the gas. When a current           damping capacity.Ride comfort and vehicle stability are two
travels through the solenoid a magnetic field is developed         main concerns while designing an effective suspension
which causes the fluid to change its state from the fluid to       system. The selection of damper is typically a tradeoffbetween
semi-solid. When there is no external magnetic field applied,      these requirements.
the iron particles are randomly suspended and the fluid shows
                                                                   The selection of MR fluid is done on the basis of purpose the
behaviour of an incompressible fluid and this act like a
                                                                   vehicle is serving i.e., sports cars, luxury cars or heavy
passive system. The properties of semi-active system can be
                                                                   vehicles. Semi active suspension system using MR dampers
regulated in response to a command signal using a small
                                                                   necessitates two nested controllers as shown in fig 2 and fig 3.
external power source[2].
                                                                   A system controller which reads the road profile and
                                                                   computes damping force required. Since MR dampers
                                                                   function on the applied voltage, a damper controller
                                                                   commands the damper to give the desired force. There are
                                                                   various control algorithms to perform the above mentioned
                                                                   function[6].
            Fig.1- MR Fluid Damper constructional model
                     IV. APPLICATIONS                                        Fig.2. Quarter Model of a vehicle suspension system
MR dampers are used as a shock absorbing or damping and
vibration controlling device. It has a vast range of application
in field of automobile, defence and various medical
purposes.This Magneto Rheological Shock Absorber is used
in mentioned automobiles i.e., Buick Lucerne, Cadillac ATS,
CTS-V, DTS, XLR, SRX, STS, Chevrolet Corvette, Camaro
ZL1, Ferrari 458 Italia, 599GTB, F12 Berlinetta, Shelby
GT350, Holden HSV E-Series and Lamborghini Huracán[7]–
[10]. However, The applications of MR damper system is not
only restricted up to shock absorbers in automobiles but also it
is being used in man researches in field of defence, medical
applications like prosthetic limbs and in designing massive
structures with can be full proofed from natural disasters[1],
[11]–[14].
4.1. MR Damper in Automobile Sector
                                                                                    Fig.3.MR damper ON and OFF state
www.ijltemas.in                                                                                                                    Page 11
         International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
                                 Volume VI, Issue XI, November 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
Other than the application of MR dampers in vehicle                         Dongting Lake Bridge is a cable-stayed bridge crossing the
suspension system, it can also be used in car seat suspension.              Dongting River[6].
This easy to implement, improved design for car seat will
improve the ride comfort for driver and the passengers. The
problem of poor feel of seat suspensions can be removed by
employing MR damper using skyhook algorithm. MR
dampers have a lot of potential to be used in motorcycle
suspensions system also. Currently, it is used in only high end
sports bikes. Motorcycle suspension designers have
historically sought a good compromise between a comfortable
ride and performance handling. The new Ducati Multistrada
1200 S shown in the fig.4 has an innovative Ducati skyhook
suspension with reduced vibrations and better vehicle
                                                                                             Fig 5. Dongting Lake Bridge, China
stability[6].
                                                                            When the bridge was made, the designer realised it was
                                                                            sensitive to vibrations due to wind and heavy raining as
                                                                            shown in fig 5. So a study was carried out, which deduced that
                                                                            with the help of MR dampers this problem can be resolved.
                                                                            Other than this MR dampers are used in railway bridges and
                                                                            buildings in earthquake prone areas.
                                                                            4.3. MR Fluid in Defense
                                                                            Researches are being carried out to develop smart Kevlar vest
                                                                            with layers of MR fluids. These vests can be hardened before
                                                                            a blink of the eye by applying magnetic field across it. In the
                                                                            absence of magnetic field, the vest is light and flexible but
 Fig 4- Ducati Multistrada 1200 S with DSS Semi active suspension system.   with a flip of a switch it can stiffen as shown in fig 6. Defence
                                                                            research agencies are designed armour suits using MR fluids
Unfortunately, this comprises generally leads to a suspension               that can sustain impact of grenades by preventing the shrapnel
design that is good for a mix of performance and comfort, yet               from piercing the suit. The United States of America’s army,
does not excel at either of the two. Usually the tuning of                  California is working on using MR dampers in army heavy
motorcycle suspension system is done by changing the fluid                  vehicles like Army's HMMWV Hummer. Still it is going to
viscosity of the front fork. In case of using a MR damper,                  take more work in this field before MR fluid vest can stop
changing the fluid viscosity is consummated by varying the                  bullets in battles[6].
magnetic field intensity using electromagnets. The use of MR
dampers can be seen in quite a few four wheeler vehicles but
still its use in two wheelers is very less due to its cost.There
are many studies and researches carried out in application of
MR dampers for motorcycle suspension system. They all
prove that it is perfect solution for improving the stability of
motorcycles and are far better than the conventional OEM
suspension systems[6].
4.2. MR Damper in Structural Applications
MR dampers are one of the most prospective semi active
control devices for civil engineering applications to
earthquake hazard mitigation, because they have many
advantages such as small power requirement, reliability, and
low price to manufacture. A smart passive system based on an
MR damper system without including a power supply,
controller, and sensors consists of an MR damper and an                                      Fig6. MR fluid used in Kevlar vest
electromagnetic induction (i.e., EMI) system that uses a
permanent magnet and a coil. The electromotive force induced                4.4. MR Damper in Prosthetic limbs
by movement of a structure can control MR damper                            It is one of the major innovations in prosthetic limbs for
effectively without any external power supply and control.The               amputees. Biedermann Motech, (a Germany based
www.ijltemas.in                                                                                                                    Page 12
        International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
                                Volume VI, Issue XI, November 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
manufacturer of spinal implants and prosthetic legs) has also      creates shock and vibrations on passengers[23]–[25]. There
recently commercialized an MR damper for a prosthetic knee;        are two such systems i.e., active and semi-active suspension
this includes in-house damper, controller and battery as shown     system as shown in fig 8. Since the required forces to keep the
in fig 7. The use of MR damper in prosthetic legs have made        system stable are excessive in rail vehicles, active suspension
it many times more responsive than the conventional stepper        system can become unstable. So, the more appropriate
motor power devices. MR technology provides infinitely             solution to this is using a semi active suspension system using
variable, real-time damping control. Slopes and stairs have        MR dampers. It can precisely control its damping
been giving real hard time to amputees but with this system        characteristics according to the rail track profile[2]–[5], [7]–
they can experience nearest neural human response time             [10], [15]–[26]. It is proven through various researches and
possible.Conventional stepper motor–powered prosthetic             studies that rail vehicle vibrations have been abridged
devices lack the same degree of stability that                     throughthe damping force generated by MR damper.
BiedermannMotech's battery-operated and electronically
controlled MR damper knee mechanisms can provide and they
are more flexible and have less complicated controlling
capabilities. This MR damper is incorporated with different
sensors to adjust any changes in the walking speed, up or
down hill motion. The system analyzes the patients gait to
adapt knee motion accordingly and respond to it in few
milliseconds[6].
                                                                           Fig. 8 Semi active suspension model using MR dampers.
                                                                        V. EXPERIMENTAL SETUP OF MR DAMPERS
                                                                   5.1. Constructionand Testing
                                                                   The experimental set up consists of vibration exciter, laptop
                                                                   and two accelerometers (one placed near or on the vibration
                                                                   exciter and other on top on mass pan).
                 Fig 7. Application in Prosthetic Leg
The receptiveness of this MR Fluid is below 10 milliseconds,
and the resistance against force can be varied over an infinite
range. This property makes MR fluid perfect for improving
this technology.
4.5. MR Dampers in Rail Vehicles
So as to solve increasing traffic problems and air pollution,
the importance of rail vehicles has risen as one of the mass
transportation systems[15]–[22]. One of the most important
factor to provide comfort, safety and stability in rail vehicles
is suspension system which absorbs the energy caused by
disruptive effects and aims to reduce transmitting of
                                                                                        Fig 9 (a)Experimental setup
vibrations to the car body to cover the rail irregularity which
www.ijltemas.in                                                                                                                Page 13
            International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
                                    Volume VI, Issue XI, November 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
                                                                                       Upper                      X=5.758
                                                                          500g                      20.350                        1.22
                                                                                       Lower                     Xst=4.687
                                                                                     VI. LIMITATIONS AND REMEDIES
                                                                         Although smart fluids have many potential applications but
                                                                         they are limited in commercial feasibility because of the
                                                                         following reasons:
                                                                                 Settling stability of MR fluid.
                                                                                 MR fluids of high quality are expensive.
                                                                                 Durability of devices.
                                                                                 Generation of heat in shock absorber because of coil.
                    Fig 9(b) Sketch of the experiment                    Active suspension use electro-hydraulic actuators which are
                                                                         commanded to give a desired control force. The active
The MR damper was used in this study has 36.5cm length                   suspension has high control performance over a wide
with 1333gm weight. Also it requires bottom fixture length               frequency range. However, it is very expensive and cannot be
5cm with M8 internal thread with 12V and 9amp.D.C.power                  used for commercial application as it requires a high power
supply as shown in Fig 9 .                                               supply, many sensors, and servo-valves.
5.2. Response of Frequency, Amplitude response at different              A semi-active suspension uses MR or ER dampers which are
loading condition.                                                       commanded by two nested controllers that are system
When the MR damper experiment was held out without                       controller and damper controller. A semi-active suspension
magnetic field under zero load, 200gm load, 400gm load                   contains the properties of both i.e. active suspension as well as
respectively the frequency was found to be decreased with an             passive suspension. It is much more effective and
increase in the ratio of input to output(X/Xst) and as when the          economical.If the system fails then the semi-active suspension
MR damper experiment was tested with magnetic field under                can also work as a passive suspension. Various applications in
same loads respectively the frequency decreased with                     the field of defence are yet to be worked on to become
decrease in the ratio of input to output(X/Xst) as shown in              feasible.
Table 2.                                                                                       VII. CONCLUSIONS
Table 2: Frequency, Amplitude response at different                      Magneto-rheological dampers (MR dampers) have a lot of
loading condition without Magnetic field.                                potential use in applications where controllable damping force
Loading                                                                  is necessary. These applications consist of dampers for
             Acceleromete    frequenc     Amplitude(m/s2   Ratio(X/Xst
conditio                                                                 automobiles (Acura MDX), heavy commercial and army
              r Position         y              )               )
   n
                                                                         vehicles (U.S. HUMMER VS, Rail vehicles),Motorbikes
                Upper                         X=4.396                    (Ducati Multistrada1200 S with DSS system), prosthetic knee
Zero load                     22.325                          1.38
                Lower                        Xst=3.183                   and legs, special Kevlar armours and others.This suspension
                Upper                         X=5.212                    system when used in automobiles will provide better vehicle
  250g                         21.00                          1.41       stability and ride comfort than the conventional passive
                Lower                        Xst=3.690
                                                                         systems. It applies a smart controllable approach to handle the
                Upper                        X=12.230                    vibrations caused due to change in road profile.
  500g                        19.350                          1.50
                Lower                        Xst=8.110
                                                                         Passive type suspension systems have permanent damping
Table 3:Frequency, Amplitude response at different                       properties and cannot be controlled according to the road
loading condition without Magnetic field.                                profile, whereas the active suspensions systems cover all these
                                                                         limitations but are not cost effective. Semi active suspension
Loading                                                                  system using MR dampers is becoming popular because it
             Acceleromete    frequenc     Amplitude(m/s2   Ratio(X/Xst
conditio
   n
              r Position         y              )               )        overcomes all the inherent limits of the above two and
                Upper                         X=3.566
                                                                         combines the advantages of both.These are few important
Zero load                     23.200                          1.35       applications of MR dampers and a lot of research is being
                Lower                        Xst=2.639
                                                                         carried out for its potential scope in various fields.
                Upper                         X=3.380
  250g                        21.400                          1.29
                Lower                        Xst=2.615
www.ijltemas.in                                                                                                                 Page 14
        International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science (IJLTEMAS)
                                Volume VI, Issue XI, November 2017 | ISSN 2278-2540
                           REFERENCES                                                    and evaluation of a semi-active damping system for rail vehicles,”
                                                                                         Veh. Syst. Dyn., vol. 29, no. S1, pp. 669–681, 1998.
   [1]. R. C. Redfield and D. C. Karnopp, “Optimal performance of                [15].   S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “Dynamics Analysis of Wheel Rail
         variable component suspensions,” Veh. Syst. Dyn., vol. 17, no. 5,               Contact Using FEA,” Procedia Eng., vol. 144, pp. 1119–1128,
         pp. 231–253, Jan. 1988.                                                         2016.
   [2]. S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “Ride performance of a high speed             [16].   S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “A comparative study of Indian and
         rail vehicle using controlled semi active suspension system,”                   Worldwide railways,” Int. J. Mech. Eng. Robot. Res., vol. 1, no. 1,
         Smart Mater. Struct., vol. 26, no. 5, p. 55026, May 2017.                       pp. 114–120, 2014.
   [3]. U. Saini, S. K. Sharma, and A. Kumar, “Semi-active control to            [17].   S. K. Sharma and S. Lavania, “An autonomous metro: Design and
         reduce lateral vibration of passenger rail vehicle by using                     Execution,” in Futuristic trends in Mechanical and Industrial
         disturbance rejection and continuous state damper controller,” J.               Engineering, 2013.
         Vib. Eng. Technol., no. In Press, 2017.                                 [18].   S. K. Sharma, A. Kumar, and R. C. Sharma, “Challenges in
   [4]. S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “Disturbance rejection and force-                     railway vehicle modeling and simulations,” in International
         tracking controller of nonlinear lateral vibrations in passenger rail           Conference on Newest Drift in Mechanical Engineering
         vehicle using magnetorheological fluid damper,” J. Intell. Mater.               (ICNDME-14) , December 20-21, M. M. University, Mullana,
         Syst. Struct., p. 1045389X1772105, Aug. 2017.                                   INDIA, 2014, pp. 453–459.
   [5]. S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “Ride comfort of a higher speed rail          [19].   S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “Dynamics analysis of wheel rail
         vehicle using a magnetorheological suspension system,” Proc.                    contact using FEA,” in 12th International Conference on
         Inst. Mech. Eng. Part K J. Multi-body Dyn., p. 146441931770687,                 Vibration Problems (ICOVP 2015), 2015.
         May 2017.                                                               [20].   D. Kulkarni, S. K. Sharma, and A. Kumar, “Finite element
   [6]. H. M. Bajaj, G. S. Birdi, and B. A. Ugale, “Application of                       analysis of a fishplate rail joint due to wheel impact,” in
         Magneto Rheological (MR) Fluid,” Int. J. Mech. Prod. Eng., vol.                 International Conference on Advances in Dynamics, Vibration and
         2, no. February, pp. 83–87, 2014.                                               Control (ICADVC-2016) NIT Durgapur, India February 25 - 27,
   [7]. S. K. Sharma, “Zero energy building envelope components: A                       2016, 2016.
         review,” Int. J. Eng. Res. Appl., vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 662–675, 2013.     [21].   S. K. Sharma and S. Chaturvedi, “Jerk analysis in rail vehicle
   [8]. S. K. Sharma and S. Lavania, “Green manufacturing and green                      dynamics,” Perspect. Sci., vol. 8, pp. 648–650, Sep. 2016.
         supply chain management in India A Review,” in Futuristic trends        [22].   S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “A comparative study of Indian and
         in Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 2013.                                 Worldwide railways,” in Recent Advances in Mechanical
   [9]. S. K. Sharma and S. Lavania, “Skin effect in high speed VLSI on-                 Engineering (RAME 2013), October 05-06, Quantum School of
         chip interconnects,” in International Conference on VLSI,                       Technology Roorkee, 2013., 2013, pp. 1–8.
         Communication & Networks, V-CAN, 2011.                                  [23].   S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “Impact of longitudinal train
   [10]. S. Lavania and S. K. Sharma, “An explicit approach to compare                   dynamics on ride comfort and train operations: A simulation based
         crosstalk noise and delay in VLSI RLC interconnect modeled with                 study,” J. Vib. Eng. Technol., vol. In press, 2016.
         skin effect with step and ramp input,” J. VLSI Des. Tools Technol.,     [24].   S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “Impact of electric locomotive
         vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 1–8, 2011.                                                   traction of the passenger vehicle Ride quality in longitudinal train
   [11]. R. Goodall, G. Freudenthaler, and R. Dixon, “Hydraulic actuation                dynamics in the context of Indian railways,” Mech. Ind., vol. 18,
         technology for full and semi-active railway suspensions,” Veh.                  no. 2, p. 222, Mar. 2017.
         Syst. Dyn., vol. 52, no. 12, pp. 1642–1657, Dec. 2014.                  [25].   S. K. Sharma and A. Kumar, “The Impact of a Rigid-Flexible
   [12]. J. Guo, Z. Xu, and Y. Sun, “A new semi-active safety control                    System on the Ride Quality of Passenger Bogies using a Flexible
         strategy for high-speed railway vehicles,” Veh. Syst. Dyn., vol. 53,            Carbody,” in Proceedings of the Third International Conference
         no. 12, pp. 1918–1934, Dec. 2015.                                               on Railway Technology: Research, Development and
   [13]. U. Viereck, T. Stützle, W. Rulka, and A. Stribersky, “Analysis of               Maintenance, Stirlingshire, UK, 5-8 April 2016, Cagliari,
         the braking performance of a rail vehicle emphasizing mechatronic               Sardinia, Italy, 2016, p. 87.
         components,” Veh. Syst. Dyn., vol. 44, no. sup1, pp. 823–833, Jan.      [26].   S. K. Sharma, R. C. Sharma, A. Kumar, and S. Palli, “Challenges
         2006.                                                                           in Rail Vehicle-Track Modeling and Simulation,” Int. J. Veh.
   [14]. [A. Stribersky, A. Kienberger, G. Wagner, and H. Müller, “Design                Struct. Syst., vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 1–9, Feb. 2015.
www.ijltemas.in                                                                                                                                  Page 15