Postoperative Catheter Management After Pelvic Reconstructive Surgery: A Survey of Practice Strategies
Postoperative Catheter Management After Pelvic Reconstructive Surgery: A Survey of Practice Strategies
Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery • Volume 00, Number 00, Month 2017 www.fpmrs.net 1
     Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Boyd et al                                               Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery • Volume 00, Number 00, Month 2017
                                                                                declared for all results yielding P value less than 0.05. The SPSS
TABLE 1. Characteristics of Survey Respondents (N = 105)                        v. 21 (IBM, Armonk, NY) was used for all data analyses.
Characteristic                                                    n (%)
                                                                                                               RESULTS
Specialty of practice*
                                                                                       A total of 105 respondents completed surveys. Participants
  - Ob/Gyn                                                      27 (36.5)
                                                                                had a mean age of 36.5 years (range, 36 years) and averaged
  - FPMRS                                                       34 (45.9)       5.7 years of clinical practice (range, 34 years). Table 1 shows char-
  - Urology                                                     13 (17.6)       acteristics of the responding physicians.
Type of hospital                                                                       Table 2 contains responses regarding type of catheterization
  - University affiliated                                       88 (83.8)       after voiding trial failure by specialty, region of practice, and hos-
  - Community based                                             17 (16.2)       pital setting. Distribution of catheterization by specialty differed.
Role of provider                                                                CISC had the greatest prevalence in all specialties and was the
  - Resident                                                    39 (37.1)       highest, by percentage, in Urology (33% Ob/Gyn, 41% FPMRS,
  - Fellow                                                      28 (26.7)       and 60% Urology; P = 0.026; Table 2). Type of catheterization dif-
  - Attending                                                   38 (36.2)       fered significantly between Ob/Gyn and FPMRS respondents
                                                                                (P = 0.045). There was no difference in type of catheterization
Region of practice
                                                                                by region or hospital setting. Furthermore, there was no difference
  - Northeast                                                   37 (35.2)       in type of catheterization when comparing physicians in Urology
  - Midwest                                                     23 (21.9)       to Ob/Gyn (P = 0.125) or FPMRS (P = 0.219).
  - South                                                       38 (36.2)              Table 3 depicts responses regarding initial duration of catheter
  - West                                                         7 (6.7)        use based on procedures performed. Catheters were discontinued
                                                                                most frequently (93.4%–98%) by postoperative day 1 across all
    *n = 75.
                                                                                procedures evaluated in the survey. Survey participants most fre-
                                                                                quently performed voiding trials after incontinence procedures
of void attempts before voiding trial failure, and management of ab-            and least frequently after vaginal hysterectomy alone and poste-
normal PVR including type of catheter, administration of antibi-                rior repair alone (95% vs 57% and 59%, respectively).
otics, and duration of catheterization until repeat voiding trial.                     Table 4 shows the responses to questions regarding the as-
Providers were asked if their standard management included 1 of                 sessment and definition of abnormal PVR. The definition of ab-
the following techniques of postoperative catheterization: CISC,                normal PVR varied. Responses included defined cutoffs ranging
TUC with continuous drainage, TUC drained intermittently by                     from 50 to 250 mL and proportions of urine voided out of volume
the patient (“plug-unplug” method or catheter valve), SPC, or pa-               instilled. Measurement of PVR was performed most frequently
tient preference. In the plug-unplug method, the TUC is plugged                 using a bladder scanning device and least frequently by bladder
with a plastic cap and unplugged by the patient when she has an urge            catheterization (77.7% vs 22.3%). However, this difference was
to urinate or at set time intervals. The plug-unplug method is similar          not significant when comparing by specialty (P = 0.092). A total
in concept to catheter valves, which allow the intermittent drainage of         of 48.6% of participants defined voiding trial failure after 1 mea-
urine from the bladder at the patient's discretion; however, the for-           surement directly after the first void, whereas 37.1% performed 2
mer technique has not been evaluated in a controlled setting.                   measurements after 2 separate voids, and 2.9% defined voiding
      Survey respondents were also asked their definition of urinary            trial failure by 1 measurement after the patient's second void.
tract infection (UTI) and indications for antibiotic administration.                   When comparing measurement techniques for PVR and number
      Descriptive data analyses included frequencies for nominal                of measurements before voiding trial failure, there was no difference by
data and were reported as percentages. The χ2 tests were used for               type of catheterization (P = 0.692 and P = 0.423, respectively).
comparison of categorical variables. Statistical significance was               When asked to note duration of time until patients underwent a
    Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery • Volume 00, Number 00, Month 2017                                Preferences in Catheter Management
repeat voiding trial, participants most frequently reported imple-             up to 9% of patients viewed postoperative catheterization as a sur-
mentation within 7 days of initial voiding trial failure (89%).                gical complication, and 15% considered catheterization to be the
      Table 5 depicts responses regarding antibiotic administration            worst aspect of the surgical experience. At 1 year follow-up,
after voiding trial failure. Respondents were allowed to mark all              Mahajan et al10 found that 15% of patients from the original co-
that applied to their daily practice. Antibiotics were administered            hort continued to cite catheter-associated complaints as the worst
most frequently based on urine culture alone (92.4%), with                     aspect of the surgical experience. Patient satisfaction with specific
58.1% of antibiotic therapy based on cultures with greater than                catheter type is an area of limited study. One recent prospective
100,000 bacterial colony-forming units (CFU). A total of 17.1%                 trial comparing valve catheters and traditional drainage catheters
of survey participants routinely administered antibiotics during               found patients with valve catheters had better satisfaction overall
or after catheterization.                                                      compared with drainage catheters and scored more favorably on
                                                                               quality of life measures, specifically a decreased limitation in so-
                           DISCUSSION                                          cial activities and less frustration.4 With the current era of health
                                                                               care quality improvement based largely on patient satisfaction
      Postoperative voiding dysfunction is common after pelvic re-
                                                                               scores regarding hospital stay and interventions coupled with the
constructive surgery, and its management varies widely among
                                                                               large percentage of patients that consider catheterization to be
practitioners of all training levels.1,3 Commonly used techniques
                                                                               one of the worst aspects of their hospital stay, further studies eval-
for bladder drainage include CISC, SPC, and TUC managed with
                                                                               uating patient satisfaction with specific catheterization types are
either continuous drainage or intermittent drainage using catheter
                                                                               necessary to optimize patient experience.
valves or plugs. Standardizing short-term catheterization tech-
                                                                                     Regarding the rates of UTIs associated with types of cathe-
niques in patients with acute postoperative voiding dysfunction
                                                                               terization, a recent meta-analysis reported no difference in UTI
is difficult because one must consider factors such as infection
                                                                               rates between SPC, CISC, and TUC if duration of catheterization
risk, patient satisfaction, invasiveness of the method, impact on
                                                                               was less than 5 days.7 This analysis identified 14 randomized con-
surgical recovery, and cost. Current evidence to support the use
                                                                               trolled trials including 1391 patients. Four compared CISC with
of each catheterization method is varied, making a consensus on
                                                                               TUC, 3 compared SPC with CISC, and 7 studies compared TUC
optimal method difficult to determine.
                                                                               with SPC.7 There were no randomized controlled trials that directly
      When evaluating patient satisfaction with surgical experi-
                                                                               compared intermittent drainage catheter techniques with the other
ence, the placement of a urinary catheter and use on hospital dis-
                                                                               methods. Similarly, a recent Cochrane review, including 42 trials
charge is a common area of dissatisfaction.9,10 A study by Elkadry
                                                                               on short-term bladder catheterization defined as catheterization
et al9 on patients' perceptions of postoperative outcomes reported
                                                                               for 14 days or less, determined there was not enough evidence
                                                                               to conclude whether 1 route was superior in reducing UTI.11
TABLE 4. Assessment and Definition of Abnormal PVR                             The Cochrane review did conclude that SPC decreased the num-
                                                                               ber of patients with asymptomatic bacteriuria, recatheterization,
Protocol                                                  N           %
Technique of residual volume measurement
  - Bladder scanner                                       80          76.2     TABLE 5. Antibiotic Administration After Voiding Trial Failure*
  - Catheterization                                       23          21.9
                                                                               Indication for antibiotic therapy                           N     %
Definition of abnormal residual volume
  - 50 mL                                                  2           1.9     Routinely during or after catheterization                  18    17.1
  - 100 mL                                                22          21.0     Symptoms without confirmation of urinalysis or culture     20    19.0
  - 150 mL                                                32          30.5     Treatment based on urinalysis alone                        70    66.7
  - 200 mL                                                24          22.9     - Leukocyte positive only                                   4     3.8
  - 250 mL                                                19          18.1     - Nitrite positive only                                    30    28.6
  - Proportion voided > ½ of volume                       29          27.6     - Both nitrite and leukocyte positive                      36    34.3
    instilled in bladder                                                       Treatment based on culture alone                           97    92.4
  - Proportion voided > 2/3 of volume                     27          25.7     - 1000 CFU on culture                                       8     7.6
    instilled in bladder                                                       - 10,000 CFU on culture                                    28    26.7
  - Patient reported incomplete emptying                  9            8.6     - 100,000 CFU on culture                                   61    58.1
    after fluid instilled in bladder
  - Other                                                 11          10.5        *Responses are not mutually exclusive.
    Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Boyd et al                                             Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery • Volume 00, Number 00, Month 2017
and pain compared with indwelling catheters. However, evidence             surveys completed by practitioners in the western United States
regarding SPC compared with intermittent catheterization was               was low. Furthermore, surveys were distributed only to practitioners
lacking.11 Furthermore, evidence was inconclusive regarding                in ACGME-accredited programs. Therefore, we cannot comment
symptomatic UTI in the setting of SPC compared with indwelling             on the practice of clinicians in nonteaching practices, which also
or intermittent urethral catheters. This review did not have suf-          decreases the generalizability of our findings.
ficient data to compare intermittent catheterization with in-                   Postoperative catheter management among practicing physi-
dwelling catheterization directly.7,11 Future high-quality studies         cians in the fields of Urology, FPMRS, and Ob/Gyn widely vary.
evaluating infection rates in the setting of intermittent drainage         Our findings show consistency with national guidelines of cathe-
catheters such as catheter valves, the plug-unplug technique, and          ter management including the emphasis on shortened duration of
CISC are warranted.                                                        postoperative catheterization and limited use of antibiotic therapy
      The CISC was the most prevalent technique reported by all            during catheterization unless urine culture results in growth of a
respondents surveyed in the current study. Although evidence is            large volume of UTI-associated bacterium. In addition, the study
inconclusive regarding optimal short-term catheterization tech-            shows significant differences in distribution of responses in regards
niques, both CISC and SPC have been shown to have lower rates              to the type of catheterization after failed voiding trial. Clean-
of UTI in patients requiring long-term catheterization compared            intermittent straight catheterization was more prevalent among
with indwelling transurethral catheters.7,12 In addition, CISC has         all survey respondents and had the highest percentage of use
the advantage of decreased surgical complications compared with            among urologists compared with other catheterization techniques.
SPC.12 Although respondents were not queried on reason behind              The reason behind this choice for short-term catheterization is un-
their choice of catheterization in patients who failed inpatient           clear considering the inconclusive evidence available regarding
voiding trials, CISC may have been more commonly chosen for                superiority of a specific short-term catheterization technique. The
these reasons.                                                             plug-unplug technique of catheter management has never been
      Hakvoort et al3 performed a similar survey of perioperative          studied in a clinical setting, and thus, future studies are necessary
catheter management across hospital systems within the Netherlands         to evaluate its efficacy in the management of patients with acute
in 2008. Surveys were distributed to entire hospital systems rather        postoperative voiding dysfunction. The optimal method of post-
than individual practitioners to assess presence of bladder cathe-         operative catheterization has yet to be determined, and future stud-
terization protocols, assessment, and management of abnormal               ies to determine a superior method are necessary to reveal an
PVR. Whereas the current study assessment of individual practi-            underlying clinical impact or improved patient satisfaction.
tioners across the United States showed CISC to be the most com-
mon catheterization for postoperative voiding dysfunction, Hakvoort
et al3 found 57% of hospitals within the Netherlands preferred in-                                         REFERENCES
dwelling transurethral catheters. In addition, all respondents in our       1. Baessler K, Maher C. Pelvic organ prolapse surgery and bladder function.
study reported removing postsurgical urethral catheters by postop-             Int Urogynecol J 2013;24(11):1843–1852.
erative day 1 regardless of the procedure performed, which is in            2. Kowalik U, Plante MK. Urinary retention in surgical patients. Surg Clin
contrast to Hakvoort et al,3 who noted initial catheterization for             North Am 2016;96(3):453–467.
up to 3 days after anterior repair alone. A recent Cochrane review          3. Hakvoort RA, Burger MP, Emanuel MH, et al. A nationwide survey to
stated a 5% cumulative daily risk of developing bacteriuria in the             measure practice variation of catheterisation management in patients
setting of catheterization, with up to 20% of these patients devel-            undergoing vaginal prolapse surgery. Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor
oping symptomatic UTI.13 Limiting duration of catheterization to               Dysfunct 2009;20(7):813–818.
no more than 24 hours greatly decreases the risk of symptomatic             4. Kandadai P, Duenas-Garcia OF, Pilzeck AL, et al. A randomized
UTI in this patient population, and our findings are consistent                controlled trial of patient-controlled valve catheter and indwelling foley
with this recommendation.13,14                                                 catheter for short-term bladder drainage. Female Pelvic Med Reconstr Surg
      Similarities between the current study and that by Hakvoort              2016;22(2):88–92.
et al3 include the heterogeneity of responses regarding abnormal
                                                                            5. Sabbuba NA, Stickler DJ, Long MJ, et al. Does the valve regulated
PVR and routine administration of antibiotics during prolonged
                                                                               release of urine from the bladder decrease encrustation and blockage of
catheterization by 20% of respondents in the Netherlands study                 indwelling catheters by crystalline proteus mirabilis biofilms? J Urol 2005;
compared with 17% of respondents in the current study. The Cen-                173(1):262–266.
ters for Disease Control (CDC) has strict definitions for symptom-
atic UTI, catheter-associated UTI and non–catheter-associated               6. Jannelli ML, Wu JM, Plunkett LW, et al. A randomized controlled trial of
                                                                               clean intermittent self-catheterization versus suprapubic catheterization after
UTI with the requirement in all definitions of “urine culture with
                                                                               urogynecologic surgery. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2007;197(1):72.e1–72.e4.
no more than 2 species of organisms identified, at least 1 of which
is a bacterium of greater than or equal to 105 CFU/mL”.15 It is             7. Han CS, Kim S, Radadia KD, et al. Comparison of urinary tract infection
reassuring to note that whereas the majority of hospitals in the               rates associated with transurethral catheterization, suprapubic tube and
Netherlands study diagnosed UTI by the presence of symptoms                    clean intermittent catheterization in the postoperative setting: a network
alone, individual practitioners surveyed in the current study diag-            meta-analysis. J Urol 2017;198(6):1353–1358.
nosed and treated UTIs by urine culture (74% vs 92%), and 58.1%             8. Tunitsky-Bitton E, Murphy A, Barber MD, et al. Assessment of voiding
of respondents diagnosed UTI by urine culture with presence of                 after sling: a randomized trial of 2 methods of postoperative catheter
greater than 105 CFU/mL of bacterium.                                          management after midurethral sling surgery for stress urinary incontinence
      Strengths of our study include the even distribution of respon-          in women. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2015;212(5):597.e1–597.e9.
dents across all clinical training levels, individual responses, and the    9. Eman AA, Kenton KS, Fitzgerald MP, et al. Patient-selected goals:
evaluation of practice characteristics in 3 specialties that commonly          a new perspective on surgical outcome. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2003;
perform pelvic reconstructive and incontinence procedures.                     189(6):1551–1557.
      Response bias is an important limitation inherent to survey          10. Mahajan ST, Elkadry EA, Kenton KS, et al. Patient-centered surgical
studies and is reflected in the complete survey response total                 outcomes: the impact of goal achievement and urge incontinence on
and may affect generalizability. Although surveys were completed               patient satisfaction one year after surgery. Am J Obstet Gynecol
by respondents in all regions of the United States, the number of              2006;194(3):722–728.
    Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery • Volume 00, Number 00, Month 2017                                    Preferences in Catheter Management
11. Kidd EA, Stewart F, Kassis NC, et al. Urethral (indwelling or intermittent)   14. Gould CV, Umscheid CA, Agarwal RK, et al. Guideline for prevention of
    or suprapubic routes for short-term catheterisation in hospitalised adults.       catheter-associated urinary tract infections 2009. Infect Control Hosp
    Cochrane database Syst Rev 2015;12:CD004203.                                      Epidemiol 2010;31(4):319–326.
12. Healy EF, Walsh CA, Cotter AM, et al. Suprapubic compared with                15. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Urinary tract infection
    transurethral bladder catheterization for gynecologic surgery: a systematic       (catheter-associated urinary tract infection [CAUTI] and
    review and meta-analysis. Obstet Gynecol 2012;120(3):678–687.                     non-catheter-associated urinary tract infection [UTI]) and other
13. Lam TB, Omar MI, Fisher E, et al. Types of indwelling urethral catheters          urinary system infection [USI]) events. 2016 NHSN Patient Saf
    for short-term catheterisation in hospitalised adults. Cochrane Database          Compon Man 2016:1–16. http://www.cdc.gov/nhsn/pdfs/pscmanual/
    Syst Rev 2014;9(9):CD004013.                                                      7psccauticurrent.pdf.
Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.