Learner Guide: Heart Trust/National Training Agency
Learner Guide: Heart Trust/National Training Agency
LEARNER GUIDE
OPERATE IN A CULTURALLY DIVERSE WORK ENVIRONMENT
2ND EDITION
Published by
Produced by
This material is protected by copyright. Copying this material or any part of it by any means,
including digital or in any form is prohibited unless prior written permission is obtained from
the HEART Trust/NTA.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
Introduction...............................................................................................................................1
Welcome .........................................................................................................................1
This Competency Unit .....................................................................................................1
Before you start ...............................................................................................................2
Planning your learning programme ..................................................................................2
Self-Assessment Checklist ...............................................................................................3
How to use this Learner Guide.........................................................................................4
Using the Computer and Other Resources........................................................................6
Method of Assessment.....................................................................................................6
Quality Assurance ...........................................................................................................6
Element 1: Communicate with customers and collegues from diverse backgrounds ............7
LG-THHCOR0061A:
OPERATE IN A CULTURALLY
DIVERSE WORK ENVIRONMENT
INTRODUCTION
Welcome
Welcome to the Learner Guide for Unit of Competency “Operate in a Culturally Diverse
Work Environment”. This is just one of a number of Learner Guides produced for the skills
stream of the Hospitality Industry, and it is designed to guide you, the learner, through a series of
learning processes and activities that will enable you to achieve the specified learning outcomes
for the competency unit.
The content of this guide was developed from the Competency Standard THHCOR0061A,
which is one of the basic building blocks for the National Vocational Qualification of Jamaica
(NVQ-J) certification within the industry. Please refer to your Learner’s Handbook for a
thorough explanation of standards and competencies, and how these relate to the NVQ-J
certification.
You are also advised to consult the Competency Standard and assessment instrument for a better
understanding of what is required to master the competency.
“Operate in a culturally diverse work environment” addresses the knowledge and skills
requirements to effectively operate in a culturally diverse work environment. There are two
main areas or elements:
As you go through each element, you will find critical information relating to each one. You are
advised to study them carefully so that you will be able to develop the necessary knowledge,
skills and attitudes for operating in a culturally diverse work environment.
a. Obtain a Learner’s Logbook. You will use it to record evidence of your new
skills/competence. As you demonstrate your new skills, record your activities and have your
learning facilitator sign off on them. This will allow you to provide evidence of your
competence when you are being assessed against the competency standard.
b. Ensure that you have access to the facilities and equipment necessary for learning.
d. Ensure that you are wearing suitable clothing, that tools and equipment are safe, and that the
correct safety equipment is used.
The self-assessment checklist on the following pages will assist you in planning your training
programme and it will help you to think about the knowledge and skills needed to demonstrate
competency in this unit. As you go through each one you will be able to find out which aspects
of the elements you have already mastered and which ones you already have and which you will
need to pay more attention to as you go through the learning process.
To complete the self-assessment checklist, simply read the statements and tick the ‘Yes’ or ‘No’
box. You should do this exercise now.
Self-Assessment Checklist
- Operate in a culturally diverse work environment
If you ticked all or most of the ‘Yes’ boxes, then you might not need to go through the entire
guide. Ask your learning facilitator to assist you in determining the most appropriate action you
should take.
If you ticked a few of the ‘Yes’ boxes or none at all then you should work through all of the
guide, even though some of the material may be familiar to you.
Plan your learning based on your answers. Be sure to involve your learning facilitator in the
planning process.
This Learner Guide is designed to assist you to work and learn at your own pace.
Check your progress at each checkpoint to ensure that you have understood the material
Observe the icons and special graphics used throughout this guide to remind you of what you
have to do and to enhance your learning. The icons and their meanings are as follows:
Definition Box
Words/phrases are defined or explained in this box. The
words/phrases being explained are in bold print.
Checkpoint
This denotes a brain teaser and is used to check your
understanding of the materials presented. No answers are
provided for the questions asked.
Activity
This denotes something for you to do either alone or with
the assistance of your trainer/supervisor.
Reference
Points you to the reference materials and other support
documents or resources used in compiling the unit content.
Ask your learning facilitator for help if you have any problems with the interpretation of the
contents, the procedures, or the availability of resources.
Complete each activity as you come to it. If the activity requires you to perform an actual
task, be sure to tell your learning facilitator when you get to that activity so that he/she can
make any arrangements, if necessary.
Get your learning facilitator to sign and date in the Learner Logbook when you have
completed an activity.
When you have worked through all elements of the guide, and when you can tick every ‘Yes’
box, you are ready for assessment and should ask your learning facilitator to assist you in making
the arrangements to have your performance assessed.
Where your activities refer you to the library, computer and Internet resources, ask your learning
facilitator to assist you with locating these resources. If you are getting your training in an
institution, there may be a library and a computer laboratory. If this is not the case, visit the local
library and find out what resources are available.
If you are new to the computer and the Internet, someone in the computer room should be able to
show you how to use these resources.
Please note that in many of your activities you have been referred to information on the Internet.
This is because the Internet has a vast amount of information that can help you in acquiring the
particular competencies. We would like to advise you, however, that we cannot guarantee that
all the sites will be available when you need them. If this happens, ask your learning facilitator
to assist you with locating other sites that have the information you require.
Method of Assessment
Competency will be assessed while you are actually performing the tasks related to this
competency. This may be in a real workplace or a simulated situation that accurately relates to
the work situation. You are advised to consult the associated competency standard for further
details relating to the assessment strategies.
Quality Assurance
A feedback form is included at the back of each learner guide, so all users are afforded the
opportunity to document their concerns pertinent to the various aspects of the guide. Such
concerns will assist in the review process of the learner guides. Users are encouraged to cut out
the form, complete and submit same to the address provided.
You may now start your learning. Have fun while you work!
LEARNING OUTCOMES
As you go through this element you will acquire the knowledge, skills and attitudes necessary to
communicate with customers and colleagues from diverse backgrounds. Your learning
facilitator is there to assist you with the various activities, so that on completion you should be
able to:
1. Value and treat with respect customers and colleagues from all cultural groups
2. Communicate verbally and non-verbally according to cultural differences
3. Obtain assistance from colleagues, reference books and outside organizations when
required
VALUE AND TREAT WITH RESPECT CUSTOMERS AND COLLEAGUES FROM ALL
CULTURAL GROUPS
Internal
External
An internal customer is someone who works for the organization e.g. a colleague, while an
external customer is not employed to the organization but requires the product or service.
For empathy
To feel welcome
To feel important
To be appreciated
To be understood
To receive help or assistance
To receive prompt service
Age
Family status
Culture
Country of origin
Social groups
All customers expect that persons working the Hospitality and Tourism Industries will be
sensitive and respectful of their needs. When you show respect to your colleagues, you respect
their differences as well as their contributions.
Each customer/colleague is unique. You can show respect and demonstrate that you value your
culturally diverse customers and colleagues by understanding their cultural backgrounds.
CHECKPOINT:
Now that you are aware of what culture is and what is cultural
diversity, give examples of how you can show that you respect
and value persons from other cultures
How many cultures exist in Jamaica?
Can other cultures exist within a culture? Explain
To which culture do you belong?
ACTIVITY 1
ACTIVITY 2
Research and discuss the cultural norms of Jamaica, the United States
of America, Japan, Germany and England. Do a comparison, listing
them according to similarities and differences. Discuss your results
with your learning facilitator.
A Guest Service Agent, who strongly believed that an individual had a right and a responsibility
to make decisions for self, approached a guest directly to advise of a more cost effective vacation
package. The guest was Japanese, and in that culture the family has primary decision-making
responsibility (not the individual). The guest responded with a nod and smile, expecting the
Guest Service Agent to return when the family is present to discuss the matter.
This type of common misunderstanding can become a significant barrier to the delivery of
excellent service.
Knowing everything there is to know about different cultures throughout the world
Stereotyping persons that “look or sound” a certain way
Assuming a person has certain values or beliefs if he/she belongs to a specific ethnic or
cultural group
Learn Continuously
Show Respect
Take Action
Learn Continuously:
Show Respect:
Take Action:
Get the details - Failing to do this can create major problems later
Summarize - The time taken to summarize decisions helps to prevent future challenges
Simplify - You must use simple words that are easily understood
Question
How do you
Answer
demonstrate II. Appreciate the
cultural importance of
I. Recognize
awareness? cultural diversity.
individual
human rights
III. Value
diversity of
language.
CHECKPOINT
ACTIVITY 1
TIP! Meeting a client or customer for the first time is your opportunity to add meaningfully to
their holiday experience, you should at least be able to say hello!
Find the following words in the crossword puzzle then match the place with
the appropriate word for hello:
G A O B C D H S T G O E I E D A G L W
U E L U C E A A W O E C H I N A R A E
T I L L I F L L Y E P R I K Z S E S S
E O E F A G L A U D D S M L X W E V T
N I H A O G O M R E D E H A L Q C P I
T I T A L Y Z Q A M O R N I N G E D N
A F R I C A A D I O W I P S W Y K A D
G I A Z O E P S B R R O P R E H R I I
O Y X R W A C E A G U A F E R F A S E
D N C U B A E N R E I N O P T D M E S
D A H O L A N H A N A N D A R S N N D
A M A J N O N J V R E S N E E P E O A
G R O N N E P K S U H O L L A N D D X
E E O O U T U B U E N O S D I A S N L
B G P B O N J O U F G H M A N T E I V
Communication can be verbal or nonverbal. Effective communication is the process in which the
receiver interprets the message in the same way intended by the sender. This is extremely
difficult to do across cultures unless there is a common language.
Communication and culture are interrelated. Language embodies culture and therefore cultural
diversity lives in language.
How you speak i.e. your language or your form of communication denotes your connection to a
culture. Your accent within that language identifies your social class or place of origin. Your
choice of vocabulary links you to certain subgroups. You "speak" from your place within a
society.
Verbal and non-verbal communication must take account of your cultural differences. These
differences include:
Language Spoken
Forms of address
Levels of formality/informality
Nonverbal behaviours
Work ethics
Personal grooming
Family obligations
Recognized holidays
Customs
Special needs
Product preferences
In a culturally diverse environment, as the sender of the message you have four basic ways in
which you can send or receive information, they are:
Speaking
Listening
Writing
Reading
Communication has the potential for many different interpretations because it has several
components. These are:
Considerable thought has to be given to the components of the communication process in order
to minimize the number of interpretations.
Conceiving the Message - Ask yourself, what is the best means of getting your message across?
Who is the message for, an internal or external customer? Ensure that your message suits the
recipient(s) particular needs.
Encoding the message - You must translate the information in the best form or use symbols that
represent your ideas or concepts in order to convey the meaning that you want. The symbols can
be in the form of languages, words, or gestures.
Selecting the communication channel - The channel is the means used to convey the message.
Most channels are either oral or written, but currently visual channels are becoming more
common as technology expands. Common channels include the telephone and a variety of
written forms such as memos, letters, and reports. Consider such elements as speed,
confidentiality, simultaneous delivery of message, cost, accuracy, feedback needs.
Decoding the message - The receiver of the message then tries to understand the meaning of the
message.
Interpreting the message - Your interpretations as the receiver are influenced by your
experiences, attitudes, knowledge, skills, perceptions, and culture. It is similar to the sender's
relationship with encoding.
Feedback - Feedback is the final link in the chain of the communication process. After receiving
a message, the receiver responds in some way and signals that response to the sender. The signal
may take the form of a spoken comment, a long sigh, a written message, a smile, or some other
action. Feedback ultimately provides an opportunity for the sender to take corrective action to
clarify a misunderstood message.
Effective Communication
Clear: Communicate clearly so that the recipient of the message will not be confused and
the meaning is understandable.
Concise: Use as few words as possible to convey your thoughts. Use short paragraphs,
short sentences and simple language.
Correct: Make sure you follow the rules and styles for business communication and that
the structure and format for meeting the organization’s standards.
Courteous: This is polite and respectful communication. Communicate in a business like
yet friendly and courteous manner.
Complete: Make sure that all the relevant information is stated and that no details are
omitted or left out.
Sensitive: This is communication that is influenced by the special needs of your
customers and colleagues.
Additional Guidelines
Respond to all correspondence in a timely manner
Be sure to observe the rules of grammar, punctuation, and spelling
Do Don’t
Speak clearly. (Some clients may have Let your sentences trail off. (It gives the
difficulty in hearing you. Your mouth should impression that you are uncertain).
be free of chewing gum and other food).
Keep the volume moderate Use a sharp tone. (You could sound
aggressive).
Put expression in your voice and watch your Do not sound monotonous or ‘sing-song’ nor
rate of speech. speak too fast. (Customer may not be able to
follow you).
Speak too slowly. You could sound patronizing
TIP! The new cultural paradigm - Many countries throughout the world are embracing the
Internet as an efficient and cost-effective method of verbal communication.
CHECKPOINT
ACTIVITY 1
Non-verbal Communication
Everything you do carries a non-verbal message. For example, a well-typed letter on good
quality paper with an attractive letterhead will carry a non-verbal message that this organization
is efficient and takes pride in its work. On the other hand, what does a few words hastily
scribbled on cheap and tattered paper with dirty fingerprints say about you?
Culturally diverse customers have some differences in the way they communicate.
Conversational Style:
Personal Space:
Recognize that different cultures have different beliefs about personal space
For example, someone may be seen as aggressive for standing too close or as distant for
‘backing off’ when approached
Be sensitive to someone else’s need for personal space
Eye Contact:
Different cultures have different beliefs about making direct eye contact
Avoiding direct eye contact may be perceived as:
- A sign of respect
- An effort to refrain from invading someone’s privacy
- An appropriate gender interaction between men and women
Don’t view being different as something negative
Time Orientation:
In some cultures, life is paced according to “clock time” which is valued over personal or
subjective time
In other cultures finishing a conversation, regardless of how long it takes, is more valued
than being “on time”
Generally, communication is most effective when the non-verbal cues support/reinforce the
spoken word.
Table 3 below provides a list of common non-verbal cues in a homogenous or melting pot work
environment and the associated meanings:
CHECKPOINT
ACTIVITY
Noise
Technical Jargon
Incorrect Grammar
Words that conflict with body language
Cultural Differences
Bias and Stereotyping
Lack of Empathy
Gender Issues
Interpersonal Skills
In many cases where language barriers exist, you can communicate through the use of gestures
or simple words in the other person's language. Drawing diagrams can also assist. Most visitors
appreciate an attempt made to understand and communicate with them in their own language,
such as:
NOTE:
You need to be aware of barriers so that you can prevent them. You must also
recognise them when they are disrupting communication and stop them
Barriers to communication may affect not only your external customers but also
your internal customers/colleagues as well
CHECKPOINT
ACTIVITY
Occasionally, you may have a customer with whom you are not able to effectively communicate.
You will need to seek additional help to satisfy the customer. Your company may have foreign
language dictionaries or guides to which you can refer, as well as videos or brochures for
customers who speak a different language.
Interpretive services
Diplomatic services – of the particular country
Local cultural organizations
Government agencies – Jamaica Tourist Board, Tourist Information Centres
You can also use an online translator to assist persons to communicate if an interpreter is not
available. To practise using the translator visit:
http://www.worldlingo.com/en/products_services/worldlingo_translator.html.
For Example:
When you say - bienvenue à notre hotel you are telling a French Canadian guest, welcome to
our hotel. To say the same thing in German you say, Willkommen zu unserem Hotel.
CHECKPOINT
Have you ever had to communicate with someone who did not
understand you? What did you do to help the person to understand
what you are trying to tell him/her?
ACTIVITY
Make a list of all the resources that are available to help you with
the languages that you encounter in your respective areas of
work. Keep it handy as your reference.
Assuming you have a guest visiting from Spain, how would you
say the following in Spanish?
You can seek assistance from your peers, reference books, learning
facilitator or outside organizations.
Now that you have completed this element, check whether you have fully grasped all the
components by doing the following Self-assessment:
Checklist 1 Yes No
Checklist 2 Yes No
LEARNING OUTCOMES
As you go through this element, you will acquire the knowledge, skills and attitudes necessary to
deal with cross-cultural misunderstandings when operating in a culturally diverse work
environment. Your learning facilitator will assist you with the various activities, so that on
completion you should be able to:
Poor communication
Lack of patience
Making judgments based on our own cultural values
The use of slang and colloquialisms
Speaking too quickly or quietly
Not listening actively
Not clarifying or asking questions
Using offensive body language and gestures
Inappropriate humour
Diverse workplace conflicts and misunderstandings may take place because of different views
due to different cultures. To ensure a united workplace, such issues must be identified and dealt
with before they cause disruptions.
You use different systems of understanding gestures, posture, silence, spatial relations, emotional
expression, touch, physical appearance, and other nonverbal cues in a culturally diverse
environment.
Be aware of your differences with respect to your customers and your colleagues.
Primary personal characteristics e.g. race, gender, sexual orientation, nationality, mental
and physical ability
Secondary personal characteristics e.g. marital status, educational level, values, beliefs
Organization-related characteristics e.g. position in hierarchy, tenure, status (fulltime,
part-time or casual).
Even when two people speak the same language, communication may be hindered by different
values or belief and nonverbal differences.
Nonverbal behaviour arises from your cultural common sense, that is, your ideas about what is
appropriate, normal, and effective as communication in relationships. Cultures attribute different
degrees of importance to verbal and nonverbal behaviour.
For Example:
In the United States and Canada, less emphasis is placed on nonverbal communication to
receiving the intended meaning of the communication as a whole.
Providing quality customer service involves identifying and satisfying customer needs and
expectations in a positive and professional manner.
Refer to:
http://www2.tafevc.com.au/SCRIPT/001_THHCOR02A/scripts/serve_home. Retrieved
March 8, 2006.
CHECKPOINT
ACTIVITY
A team member may need to take the day off to go to his child’s
christening/baptism. This person’s culture places a lot of emphasis
on family and it would be considered an insult if he did not go.
However, there is a meeting that he should attend. He is trying to
make it clear that he needs to go to the function but his supervisor is
adamant that he should be at the meeting. After discussions for half
an hour it is now time to seek assistance from the Manager. Simulate
this activity with the assistance of your peers. Show how the
Manager could deal with such a situation. Discuss with your learning
facilitator.
You should try reasoning out the problem without attacking the person. If no solution can be
found, seek assistance from someone else who can mediate i.e. help solve the misunderstanding.
Team member
Team leader
Supervisor
Manager
It is important that these issues are discussed openly and team members get a chance to share
their concerns. You may feel offended by a customer’s action but that may be the norm for that
person.
When relating to your colleagues, seek assistance if you are the person who unintentionally
offended another and the person responds to you inappropriately. Address the problem; do not
express anger at the individual or the culture.
If you are the mediator, then first identify what caused the conflict between the parties.
Remember that differences can be primary, secondary or organization-related. It is very
important that the misunderstanding is dealt with in the correct manner without offending either
person. A good way to do this is to use the company’s policies, procedures and standards to
emphasize what is appropriate at the workplace. Then ask the sender and the receiver of the
message to comment on the message intended and the message received to identify
communication barriers. If the elements of the misunderstanding require someone with greater
experience to address them, then seek assistance from the relevant person.
Here are some tips that some companies use to help them to prevent misunderstandings. They:
Have regular brainstorming and goal setting sessions with team members and allow for
feedback on issues
Clarify work ethics held by different cultures
Inform everyone about department and organizational goals and cultures
Hold fun days and social outings away from the work place so that team members can
bond
Have cultural awareness seminars to inform team members of the different cultures at the
workplace
Institute exchange programmes for employees – to travel abroad or locally, so they will
be exposed to other cultures
CHECKPOINT
Conflicts will arise in your workplace from time to time. When this happens, you must look at
the culture of the person(s) involved in the conflict. If their cultural views differ, you will need to
assess whether or not misunderstandings arise from these differences or are aggravated by these
differences.
There may be a divide created when groups respond in stereotypical ways such as:
Anger
Fear
Sadness
Disgust
Surprise
The following examples demonstrate the differences related to socially acceptable displays in
various cultural settings, and by whom. An understanding of these will assist you in identifying
and addressing conflicts:
Facial Expression
Space
A Jamaican man may feel offended because a male European co-worker came too close to him.
In Jamaica this is not acceptable behaviour. Here cultural difference with regards to personal
space will be the issue. It is important to look at cultural orientation before trying to solve the
problem.
North Americans tend to prefer a large amount of space. Europeans tend to stand more closely
with each other when talking, and are accustomed to smaller personal spaces. If someone is
accustomed to standing or sitting very close when they are talking with another, they may see the
other's attempt to create more space as evidence of coldness, condescension, or a lack of interest.
Those who are accustomed to more personal space may view attempts to get closer as pushy,
disrespectful, or aggressive.
The English and Americans are serious about standing in lines, in accordance
with their beliefs in democracy and the principle of "first come, first served.”
The French, on the other hand, do not, and that irritates many British and
Americans.
Bulgarians shake their heads up and down to mean no. The Chinese count from one to ten on one
hand, and eight is displayed by extending the thumb and the finger next to it. The same gesture is
interpreted as meaning two in France and as pointing a gun in North America.
The French word "char" means army tank in France and car in Quebec. The word "exciting" has
different connotations in British English and in North American English. While North American
executives talk about "exciting challenges" repeatedly, British executives use this word to
describe only children’s activities (children do exciting things in England, not executives).
Although the sight of a black cat is considered a lucky event in Britain, it is considered unlucky
in many other countries. Dragons are viewed positively in China, but negatively in Europe and
North America.
In extreme cases, miscommunication can lead to casualties. For example, a plane was running
short on fuel but the pilot did not manage to communicate the urgency of the situation to the air
traffic controller, who put the plane on a holding pattern because of airport congestion. The plane
then crashed when it ran out of fuel.
Individualistic
Preserves image of self and exerts control in situations to achieve this goal
Takes a competitive stance in negotiations
Confrontational if wronged
Comfortable in mediation to frankly discuss differences
Communitarian
Cross-cultural issues also arise at the organizational level. Companies in different countries
organize their daily business differently and since the business of tourism is global, some
noticeable differences include the:
Flow of information
Germans tend to share information with only those people they believe need to know the
information. In Canadian companies, information tends to move more freely to everyone.
Hiring process
Cross-cultural differences are fairly significant in this area. For example, people interviewed for
positions in France will be asked personal questions that are considered illegal in Jamaica and
Canada. Can you think of any such questions? More importantly, in France they hire graduates
who appear to have long-term potential and create jobs for them. As a result, large French
companies tend to emphasize soft skills.
Canadian companies tend to look for strong technical skills in the employees. They do not expect
employees to remain with the company throughout their careers only to fill an existing vacancy.
Jamaicans are a lot like Canadians and both may consider themselves superior in knowledge to
their German counterparts without an understanding of cross-cultural hiring practices.
Cross-cultural Communication@
http://www.beyondintractability.org/essay/cross-cultural_communication/
Retrieved March 8, 2006
CHECKPOINT
ACTIVITY
Discuss with your learning facilitator and peers. Also discuss how
you can reduce other cultural misunderstandings or conflicts.
RESOLVE MISUNDERSTANDINGS
Problems should not be left unsolved when they occur at the workplace as they could escalate
and cause major disruptions. Efforts should be made to resolve misunderstandings, bearing the
cultural orientation of employees in mind.
Your supervisor may have to call a general meeting if the misunderstandings will have effects on
the workplace in general. Try not to offend any particular culture when providing suggestions, or
stating your opinion.
When a problem occurs and both parties cannot reach a solution on their own, or with the help of
a co-worker, you may need to advise your supervisor or team leader. If it is something that needs
some additional attention they should be able to provide it. If it is something that causes offence,
your supervisor will follow up the problem and take appropriate action. Be certain to follow the
chain of command at your workplace.
Refer to: HEART Trust/NTA (2004). LG-THTCOR0051A, Deal with Persons from
Other Cultures
http://www.umanitoba.ca/anthropology/courses/122/module1/culture.html
Retrieved March 6, 2006
http://www.talkaboutculture.com Retrieved March 3, 2006
http://www.reedsmith.com/careers/u.k._opportunities/commitment_to_diversity.cfm
Retrieved March 7, 2006
http://cecp.air.org/cultural/Q_howdifferent.htm Retrieved March 7, 2006
http://www.culturalsavvy.com/differences.htm Retrieved March 7, 2006
http://www.diversityaustralia.gov.au/_inc/doc_pdf/add_value_hrm_model.pdf
Retrieved March 7, 2006
Now that you have completed this element, check whether you have fully grasped all the
components by doing the following Self-assessment:
Checklist 1 Yes No
Checklist 2 Yes No
Your feedback on the Learner Guides is important to us. Please complete the
form below to indicate areas for review as you see necessary. For each
component tick [√ ] the appropriate column.
Other Issues:
Telephone #: E-mail:
Please cut along the dotted line and submit to:
Version Control 1