Treaty E
Treaty E
NATIONS CRC
Convention on the Distr.
GENERAL
Rights of the Child
CRC/C/8/Add.20
6 June 1995
ENGLISH
Original: ARABIC
Addendum
YEMEN
CONTENTS
Paragraphs Page
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 - 6 3
GE.95-16889 (E)
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 2
CONTENTS (continued)
Paragraphs Page
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45
Annexes
Introduction
1. Yemen having ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child in 1991,
Yemeni society is expected to fulfil its obligations towards children and to
provide the means for their welfare and protection. However, the problems
now facing children in that society are such that a review of the laws and
legislative acts is required, as is increased government and foreign support
aimed at the social and cultural development of the family and the improvement
of its health so that children may lead decent lives.
3. Yemeni society, which declared the unification of its two parts in 1991,
has faced various predicaments and challenges, both at home and abroad, that
have played a part in reducing the variety and number of services provided by
the Government to Yemeni children. The recent events in Yemen also disrupted
various development projects and had adverse effects on the economic and
social structure, meaning that more support and assistance is required
if society is to overcome its children’s problems.
7. In the light of international concern for the rights of the child and
the convening of the World Summit for Children in September 1990, State
leaders undertook to end child mortality and the spread of malnutrition by
the year 2000 and to provide essential protection for the physical and mental
development of all children throughout the world.
9. Three fundamental rights are covered under the Convention: the right of
the child to survival, development and life. Comparing the articles of the
Convention with the legislative acts of the Republic, we find that the Yemeni
legislature has complied with the charters of the United Nations and
international organizations working for the protection of human rights. The
provisions contained in the legislative acts of the Republic are, moreover,
consistent with the Convention on the Rights of the Child as guaranteed by the
aims of the revolution and the Constitution. The sixth aim of the revolution
calls for respect for the charters of the United Nations and international
organizations, adherence to the principles of positive neutrality and
non-alignment, and endeavours to establish world peace and promote the
concept of coexistence among nations.
11. The Constitution considers that "the family, which is rooted in religion,
morality and patriotism, is the cornerstone of society; the law shall
safeguard the family entity and strengthen family ties, and the State shall
protect mothers and children, as well as juveniles and young persons". It
also considers that education, health and social services are essential
foundations for the shaping and advancement of society, foundations which
society helps to provide in conjunction with the State.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 5
"The State shall also guarantee the provision of social security for all
citizens in cases of illness, infirmity, unemployment, old age and loss
of the provider ... particularly for families of martyrs, in accordance
with the law."
15. These articles are consistent with articles 2, 3, 4, 5, 19, 24, 25, 26
and 28 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
16. Article 28 of the Civil Code (Act No. 19 of 1992) stipulates that the
personality of the individual shall commence at the time of his live birth and
shall end at his death. A comparison shows that this provision is consistent
with article 1 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, which states that
"a child means every human being below the age of 18 years unless, under the
law applicable to the child, majority is attained earlier". This provision of
the Convention takes into account the right of States to determine the age of
majority, particularly Muslim countries which specify the age of majority as
15 years. Article 5 of the Civil Code (Act No. 19 of 1992) stipulates that
the age of majority is 15 full years if the person who attains that age has
the use of his mental faculties, is rational in his behaviour and is fully
competent to exercise his civil rights. Special legislation may stipulate a
higher age whereby a person is entitled to the exercise or enjoyment of any
other rights, as indicated in Electoral Act No. 2 of 1990, article 13 of which
specifies the minimum age of the voter as 18 years.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 6
18. Article 9 of the Convention stipulates that "States Parties shall ensure
that a child shall not be separated from his or her parents against their
will". Similarly, article 138 of the Personal Status Act No. 20 of 1992
states that "custody means the care and upbringing of a young person who is
unable to manage his or her own affairs, and protection of the said young
person from harm or danger, in a manner consistent with the rights of his or
her guardian. It is an inalienable right of the child which, if precluded
by any particular circumstances, is nevertheless restored when those
circumstances change".
19. Article 140 of the Act stipulates that the guardian shall be a rational
and trustworthy adult who is capable of undertaking the physical and moral
upbringing and protection of the young person. It also stipulates that,
if the guardian is a woman, in addition to the above, she should not have
renounced Islam, should not undertake charge of the young person in the home
of anyone who is ill-disposed towards him and should not be so busy outside
the home that she is unable to devote attention to the custody unless there is
someone present to cater for the young person’s needs. If the guardian is a
man, he should have religious leanings.
20. Article 141 stipulates that the mother has a greater right to custody of
her child, provided that she is found fit to undertake that custody, and she
cannot forfeit this right unless the child accepts a person other than her,
nor may her marriage to another person preclude her where there is no person
other than her. Similarly, her right to custody shall not be denied by
reason of her poor moral character until the young person attains the age
of five years.
21. Article 148 of the Act gives the child the right to choose between his
father and his mother to act as his guardian in the event of a dispute between
them, with a view to the child’s interests. In the event of a dispute between
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 7
guardians other than the father or mother, the judge shall, after consulting
the child, choose the person most capable of furthering the child’s interests.
(c) If he habitually runs away from home or plays truant from school;
23. Article 11, paragraph 3, stipulates that a juvenile under 12 years of age
may not be detained in a police station or by any security organ and must be
assigned to the care of his parents, his guardian or his trustee. If that is
impossible, he must be placed in the nearest juvenile rehabilitation home for
a period of not more than 24 hours. If his release constitutes a danger to
himself or to others, he must thereafter be referred to the Office of the
Public Prosecutor for consideration of his case in accordance with the
provisions of the Act. Under paragraph (b) of the same article, a juvenile
who has attained the age of 12 years may be detained in any police station,
provided that the period of detention does not exceed 24 hours and that he is
detained in a particular location that prevents him from mixing with other
detainees who are older than him.
25. Articles 7 and 8 of the Convention concern the right of the child to
acquire nationality, the right from birth to a name and the right to preserve
his or her identity. The provisions of the Nationality Act No. 6 of 1990 are
consistent with the provisions of the Convention in that respect; article 3 of
the Act stipulates that Yemeni nationality shall be enjoyed by:
(b) Any person born in Yemen to a mother holding that nationality and a
father who is stateless or of unknown nationality;
(c) Any person born in Yemen to a mother holding that nationality and a
father whose nationality has not been legally established;
(e) Any expatriate holding Yemeni nationality on his departure from the
national territory who has not relinquished that nationality in accordance
with the law and at his explicit request, even if he has acquired the
nationality of the country of his residence under its laws.
26. Although these provisions under the said paragraphs of article 3 are
satisfactory, they do not entitle the children of a Yemeni woman married
to a foreigner to enjoy Yemeni nationality as their birthright. Assuming,
therefore, that a Yemeni woman marries a foreigner whose country’s laws
stipulate that nationality is acquired only by a person born to two parents
having that same nationality, the children of the Yemeni woman would, in
that case, be stateless. We note that, under article 4 of the Act, Yemeni
nationality may be granted by presidential decree, based on a proposal by the
Minister, to a person born abroad to a mother holding that nationality and a
father who is stateless or of unknown nationality. We also note that here
also the problem still exists.
27. The Act stipulates that the working hours of young persons must not
exceed 6 hours per day or 24 hours per week. Young persons must not be
required to work overtime or on weekly rest days, official holidays or other
periods of leave. Article 45 of the draft Labour Act prohibits the employment
of young persons in arduous or harmful occupations or industries.
28. Article 19 of the Basic Labour Code (Act No. 141 of 1978) promulgated at
Aden prohibits the employment of young persons up to 16 years of age who have
not completed their basic education unless special approval is granted by the
Minister after each case has been considered on its merits in the light of a
special social study and report.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 9
29. Article 23 of the Convention affirms that States Parties recognize that a
mentally or physically disabled child should enjoy a full and decent life, as
well as special care, and shall encourage and ensure the extension to the
eligible child and those responsible for his care of assistance that is
provided free of charge. The disabled child should also be assured of
receiving education and training in accordance with this article. Although
a Care and Rehabilitation of the Disabled Act was drafted by the competent
persons at the Ministry of Social Security and Labour, it has not yet
appeared, even though it was one of the first to be submitted to the House
of Representatives for approval and promulgation immediately after the
unification. Article 5 of the draft stipulates that all categories of
disabled persons shall, according to their individual needs, be entitled
to one or more of the following benefits:
(a) Welfare;
(c) Education;
(f) Follow-up in the case of those who are employed to ensure that they
are settled in their jobs;
(i) Exemption from customs duty for aids, equipment and educational
and training materials which they are obliged to import on account of their
disability;
30. Under article 11 of the draft act, disabled persons who have attained
the age prescribed for compulsory education are entitled to receive all stages
of that education, while those who are illiterate and above the official age
are entitled to enrol in illiteracy programmes in the same way as their
able-bodied peers. Through the Ministry of Social Affairs and Labour, the
State undertakes to establish special homes, centres and institutes for the
care and rehabilitation of disabled persons (art. 7).
32. Despite the promulgation of these legislative acts, their many positive
aspects and their consistency with international conventions, in particular
the Convention on the Rights of the Child, ratified by Yemen, which
participated in the International Conference on the Rights of the Child,
they have not been applied in practice and remain largely unenforced.
33. Yemen’s ratification of the Convention on the Rights of the Child in 1991
brought about the establishment of the Yemeni Council for Maternal and Child
Welfare in that same year and the adoption, in 1992, of the population
strategy covering mothers, children and family planning. However, despite
all attempts by the State to provide welfare, protection and educational
and health services for children, the objectives were not achieved, as the
political and economic situation in Yemen overshadowed the lives and future of
children in Yemen and had adverse repercussions on their social condition, as
follows:
35. Although the Convention may require the protection of children from
all forms of economic exploitation, harsh economic conditions are not easily
tackled by mandatory decree. The circumstances imposed by such conditions
produced a social and economic upheaval in various fields in which children
were among the victims, despite the existence of legislation guaranteeing
protection from all forms of child exploitation.
36. The disastrous Gulf war, which forced some 1 million Yemeni expatriates
to leave their jobs and sources of income and return without compensation to
Yemen, had a far-reaching effect on numerous families and children. Over
56.5 per cent of returnees were dependent children.
38. As a result of the April 1994 war, a large number of families were
displaced from the combat zones, leaving behind them many demolished homes.
They were also accompanied by various people who were injured or disabled,
most of them children either disabled or totally incapacitated by their
injuries.
40. The loss of life and equipment was extremely costly, in addition to which
public funds which should have been spent on development and on repairing the
economic infrastructure were used for military purposes.
42. Accurate statistics concerning the number of dead and wounded and
the material losses resulting from this armed conflict have not yet been
published, although the competent authorities are expected to announce them
eventually. However, an enormous number of families have most certainly been
displaced from their places of origin, particularly areas where battles took
place, damaging their homes and amenities and making schools vulnerable to
looting and sabotage.
43. For a period of one month, international organizations supplied food aid
and blankets to some 2,000 displaced families and also helped to administer
first aid to the injured, as well as to provide treatment. Various national
charities played a humanitarian role in supplying relief for victims which
included food, medication, tents and blankets.
44. The Yemeni State guarantees equal educational rights for both sexes under
the provisions of the Unified Education Act of 1993. It also guarantees free
education and is endeavouring to achieve the principle of equal opportunities
and compulsory education at the basic stage (1-9). The statistical
indicators, however, clearly show the various problems facing child education,
which can be summarized as follows.
45. In 1991-1992, the illiteracy rate was 55.3 per cent among sections of the
population aged 10 years and over, amounting to 77.8 per cent among females
and 32 per cent among males at the overall level, 93 per cent among females
and 49 per cent among males at the rural level, and 70 per cent among females
and 38 per cent among males at the urban level.
46. The State adopted the 1981 national literacy campaign (Sana’a) and
the 1984 comprehensive national literacy campaign (Aden) and an executive body
was established with the task of coordinating official and popular efforts in
the field of literacy and adult education. The objectives of the efforts to
eradicate illiteracy, however, have not been achieved, since not all children
can be accommodated in education, nor do they all continue with it,
particularly in the case of females. In addition, educational opportunities
differ between the sexes, as they do between rural and urban areas.
Illiteracy is therefore mainly among females, given the contrasting enrolment
rates between males and females and between rural and urban areas. The
illiteracy rate is 54.3 per cent among 10-14 year-olds and 60.4 per cent
among 15-16 year-olds (see annex II).
47. Despite the positive enrolment rates for female students compared to
geographical distribution (rural/urban) which indicate that 60 per cent of
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 13
48. Statistics show a slight fall in illiteracy every five years. In 1976,
illiteracy was widespread, amounting to 87.5 per cent, while for inhabitants
aged 10 and above it was 98 per cent among females and 75.5 per cent among
males. However, 10 years of continuous efforts point to the failure of the
mechanisms used to free people from illiteracy. This applies particularly to
females, since the campaign was not conducted in tandem with a similar plan
to improve basic education. The population pyramid for 1992 shows that
60 per cent of the population is of school age. In addition, although the
population is increasing by an annual 3 per cent, there is no corresponding
increase in educational resources. The illiteracy rate is therefore expected
to remain static for the next five years, particularly in view of the delay in
implementing measures that could help to surmount the difficulties that face
girls’ entry into education, such as increasing the absorption capacity in
basic education, attempting to reduce drop-out rates from the first grades
and applying the principle of compulsory education from the age of six, as
provided for in the education legislation.
52. At the regional level, the urban to rural enrolment ratio in the first
stage rises to 40 per cent in towns, whereas in some rural areas it declines
to less than 10 per cent and falls even lower in the higher grades.
Altogether, there are 52,496 teachers in basic education, 9,737 of whom are
female, representing 18.5 per cent. Most of the 13,665 schools are mixed,
although 8.6 per cent are single-sex schools for girls only.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 14
3. Completion of schooling
53. The likelihood of children completing their schooling is poor for various
social and economic reasons, which include early marriage, the need for girls
from rural families to perform agricultural and domestic work in a society
that is predominantly rural, and the refusal of families to allow girls to
attend schools that are far from their homes, have no female teachers or
are not single-sex girls’ schools. While 8.6 per cent of schools in basic
education and 6.2 per cent in secondary education are for girls only, in
rural areas they amount to only 1.5 per cent.
54. Between 1985 and 1990, the average pass rate of those sitting
first-certificate examinations in basic education ranged between 80 and
85 per cent, but fell to 55 per cent among those sitting second-certificate
examinations. In addition to the difficulty of repeating the same class or
level, statistics indicate that education is lost in various ways, such as
truancy and drop-out. Between 1977 and 1983, education was lost at the rate
of about 60 per cent in the primary stage, whereas between 1985 and 1990 it
was 65.8 per cent between the first and ninth grades in that stage. This
high rate begins after completion of the first grade in the first stage and
gradually increases among females to reach its peak between the fourth and
sixth grades for various reasons, including the social attitude towards girls’
education and the poor economic returns from such education, particularly
since the curricula have little connection with the environment or with
training and qualification and since education is scarcely available to
females in remote areas where services are lacking. Schools may stop after
or at the third-grade level because the building is either inadequate or
unsuitable. Students are consequently transferred to a higher school in
areas that are further away and beyond the financial resources of the family.
Social barriers cannot therefore be broken down.
55. Given the rise in the rate of educational loss in the first stages of
basic education, amounting to 90 per cent among females in the southern and
eastern governorates and 70 per cent in the northern and western governorates,
overall illiteracy among females is expected to escalate, particularly when
combined with the factors of population growth and the modest educational
resources, which are non-existent in some rural areas, with male and female
drop-outs added to the high numbers of illiterate adults.
57. This illustrates various negative factors. Over 70 per cent of teachers
with secondary school qualifications are concentrated in the major towns as a
result of population migration from rural areas. In addition, not all of them
settle in the teaching profession after the prescribed five-year service,
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 15
as there are few financial incentives for doing so. The highest number of
teachers, amounting to 46,450, is in basic education. Of these, 21 per cent
are females who are to be found mostly in the major towns. No notable
progress has been recorded, however, in the number of female teachers in
rural areas.
59. The above information clearly indicates that child education in Yemen is
facing various problems, including:
(i) The high illiteracy rate among the population (65 per cent,
87 per cent among females); illiteracy among girls at the
compulsory school age of 6 to 15 years is 70 per cent;
(iii) The disparity between the number of schools and teachers in rural
and urban areas;
(vi) The high truancy and drop-out rate among children, amounting
to 65 per cent at the basic education stage.
61. The principle of free education does not include all educational
requirements. On the contrary, there are token fees which not all students
are able to pay. Free education does not include subsidized access to
educational items which school students need, such as clothing, pens and
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 16
paper. The principle of free education does not take into account the
resources of families in the deteriorating economic situation which the
country is experiencing.
62. The principle of compulsory education has not been applied for various
reasons, including:
(iii) The lack of equal educational opportunities for children who work
to support themselves at other times.
63. Social distinction occurs in education between boys and girls, between
rural and urban areas, and between the most and least privileged members of
society:
(i) Statistics indicate that 70 per cent of girls do not attend school
and that the enrolment rates for boys and girls are clearly
different, namely 85 per cent for boys and 30 per cent for girls;
(iii) Some groups are opposed to school attendance, one example being the
"Akhdam", who refuse to emerge from the abyss of poverty and who
reject education for their children.
64. This situation in education confirms that more effective measures are
needed in order to apply the principle of equal educational opportunities as
a service for children that is provided by the State (see annexes I, II, V
and VI).
65. The different media undoubtedly have some influence on various aspects of
young people’s behaviour and are an important means to develop the culture and
abilities of children, who constitute 41 per cent of the total population in
Yemen. The media therefore have a duty to devote a reasonable amount of
attention to this population group.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 17
66. At this point, we can review the media output since the time of signature
of the Convention on the Rights of the Child. The media in the Republic of
Yemen consist of the press, radio and television.
The press
68. The children’s press emerged belatedly in early 1981 at Sana’a and
in 1983 at Aden in the form of the two magazines Al-Hudhud and Wadhah,
neither of which survived in view of the obstacles that they encountered.
70. There are several radio stations in the Republic of Yemen: the
countrywide station at Sana’a, the second station at Aden and local radio
stations at Hodeida, Ta’izz, Mukalla and elsewhere. Radio is the most
widespread medium. However, there are obstacles impeding the development and
improvement of children’s programmes; all radio stations, for instance, limit
their programmes to weekly serials, story programmes and special programmes on
the occasion of national events and holidays.
71. The main reason for this lacklustre performance is no doubt attributable
to lack of programme planning and the fact that there is no competent
committee responsible for ensuring the success of children’s programmes.
Most children’s programmes are the result of personal endeavour, since there
is no research on children’s programmes and no specialized advisory committee
to help to develop such programmes and appoint their presenters.
Television
73. Television is the most important medium and has attracted a large
audience of children. Children’s television programmes were first broadcast
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 18
when television began in the 1960s at Aden and the 1970s at Sana’a. Special
sections and departments for children’s programmes have been established, but
the number of minutes allocated to the transmission of children’s programmes
on the first and second channels is limited to between 30 and 90 minutes a day
divided among local, Arab and foreign programmes. Children’s programmes are
slotted in among local programmes, transmission material being divided into
three equal sections as follows:
Local programmes.
Local programmes represent 33.3 per cent of the total output, with children’s
programmes representing 5 per cent.
(i) The lack of programme planning and the meagre budgetary allocation
to children’s programmes;
(iii) The small number of people with the enthusiasm to write, produce or
present special programmes for children;
(vi) The fact that Yemeni television transmissions do not cover all
regions of the Republic.
2. Cultural activities
76. The achievement of Yemeni unification ushered in a new and historic phase
in the development of Yemeni society. Yemen has acceded to the Convention on
the Rights of the Child and has taken steps to provide comprehensive child
welfare.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 19
78. Cultural activities began late for a variety of reasons which can be
summarized as follows:
79. The trends in the development of the artistic talents of children in our
country illustrate a desire for Yemeni children to reach exemplary standards
and enjoy the kind of personality conducive to the modernization, advancement
and development of society. The lack of resources, however, prevents this
from happening in all cases.
Literature
80. There has been considerable activity in Yemen since the 1970s. In 1979,
the International Year of the Child, the State took steps to set up publishing
houses in Yemen, for example Al-Hamdani printing and publishing house, the
printing houses of the Ministry of Information and some private publishing
companies.
81. During the 1980s, a number of children’s newspapers and magazines were
founded and children’s stories were published, but the lack of authors,
writers, illustrators, producers and designers specializing in children’s
publications, as well as the lack of technical staff such as printers and
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 20
83. Unfortunately, however, the Children’s Theatre closed down and children’s
dramatic activity gradually dwindled for the following reasons:
(ii) The lack of materials and equipment for staging theatrical events;
(iii) The lack of a budget and of plans and programmes for children’s
drama;
Children’s cinema
86. To date there is no special cinema for children but there are annual
festivals of imported films containing new concepts and moral values for
children. Such films are censored before being shown. However, Yemen itself
lacks the equipment, trained staff and other resources needed to make
children’s documentaries and children’s programmes.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 21
87. Given the importance of the family as the appropriate primary natural
unit for the development of the child, in accordance with articles 26 and 27
of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the State has taken steps to
promulgate legislation and undertake activities such as the following:
88. Under this Act, needy families receive monthly financial support and some
support in kind. A total of 39,000 families have received such support, which
amounts to 153 million Yemeni rials annually for the country as a whole. Its
purpose is to help improve the living conditions of the families concerned so
that they can rear and educate their children. They continue to benefit until
their children find employment, are in a position to support themselves or
complete higher studies.
89. However, if we compare the number of families benefiting from the scheme
with the number of poor and destitute families, we find that the problem
persists and that the material assistance provided is very modest in the light
of low family income levels and other economic problems.
91. To achieve its aims, this scheme requires greater support to make its
resources sufficient to improve its services to families and children. In
addition, schemes of this kind need to be studied by social researchers to
ensure that they provide services to the really needy and to persons with no
fixed income so that they can educate their children in the same way as other
social groups.
92. Alongside family care, children are provided with compulsory basic
education services from the age of six and should, in principle, have access
at an earlier age to crèche and kindergarten facilities to prepare them for
the first stage of compulsory basic education. Such crèches and kindergartens
exist only in the larger towns, while rural areas have only basic education
facilities. A total of 64 crèches and kindergartens now operate in the larger
towns. There is a serious shortage of social services to ensure proper
childrearing, and working mothers suffer great hardship in attempting to hold
down a job while ensuring that their children are in safe hands during their
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 22
93. Steps have recently been taken to provide social services and training
for the disabled to assist them in developing their abilities, to prepare them
for productive employment and to help them to integrate into society. Homes
and centres providing services, social welfare, education and training have
been established for children with motor, mental and visual handicaps, and
recreational activities are organized on their behalf. However, in view of
the large number of beneficiaries and the paucity of resources available in
relation to the scale of the services required, the personnel employed in this
branch obviously lack the expertise required for this kind of work and need
training, continuous professional development and more material incentives to
remain in their jobs. There is also a shortage of facilities for treating
different kinds of disabilities. The number of such establishments is shown
in annex VIII.
94. Mention may be made of two social welfare projects for the disabled:
the early home education project and the CBR project.
Both projects provide home, social and training services for disabled children
and their families. A total of 278 children benefited in the initial
years (1992-1993).
96. Since the mid-1970s, five centres in the Republic of Yemen have been
providing social, psychological, educational and vocational rehabilitation
services for juveniles in these categories who have lost their natural link to
the family and have become homeless and open to exploitation. However, the
centres fail to play their proper role because of the shortage of resources
and the lack of comprehensive services. There has been an attempt in the last
two years to proceed with the promulgation of the Juvenile Welfare Act, to
formulate its implementing regulations and to prepare for the establishment of
juvenile courts. However, the social and economic situation prevailing after
the Gulf war impeded such action and the existing centres, with their current
capacity, are unable to provide adequate services for needy children.
Moreover, the recent events have led to an increase in the number of homeless
and delinquent juveniles.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 23
6. Orphanages
99. It may be concluded from a first reading of the Convention on the Rights
of the Child that, with reference to the articles dealing with mental and
spiritual dimensions, appropriate conditions for children have not been
provided because of a large number of economic and social circumstances.
Some services are, however, provided, such as:
(i) Establishment of the Yemeni Higher Council for Children and the
Children’s Fund and the holding of a number of meetings on
development and population;
104. In spite of the existence of numerous social bodies and some legislation
guaranteeing children’s rights, the deterioration of these services and the
failure to expand and develop them in line with population growth prove beyond
a doubt that children in our country live in distressing circumstances. This
has been particularly true since the recent war, which had a destructive
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 25
impact on the economic and social infrastructure in general and also led
to the destruction of children’s educational, social and recreational
institutions.
106. It should be noted that these basic services reach only about 2 per cent
of those in need because of limited resources and because they are restricted
to the main cities of the principal governorates. There are no social
services to speak of in the remote governorates. Under these circumstances,
mass organizations, parties and regional and international organizations
and bodies must support existing establishments by meeting their needs,
particularly in respect of children, in the areas laid waste by war, since the
governorates in question are still deprived of social services and the war has
disrupted many aspects of daily life in Yemen.
107. Greater coordination of action by the State and by private and benevolent
organizations calls for the following measures:
F. Health
108. Child health is the key to a society’s future well-being. Every child
should have the opportunity to grow up in a healthy environment, given the
fact that 90 per cent of human physical and mental growth occurs in early
childhood. Hence the need to protect children’s health. The Yemeni
Government is fully aware of the importance of ensuring such protection
through programmes designed to reduce infant and child mortality by the
year 2000, in accordance with the provisions of article 24 of the Convention,
based on the idea of primary health care.
109. Children under one year old constitute 4.5 per cent of the population of
Yemen, children under five 22 per cent and children under fifteen 54 per cent.
Women of childbearing age (15-44) constitute 25.2 per cent of the population.
Hence the prime importance of the mother and child welfare programme, which
targets three quarters of the population of Yemen.
110. It is a well-known fact that child health is closely bound up with the
health of society, which is influenced by social, economic, environmental and
other factors. Yemen has made considerable progress in the past 20 years
despite the problems impeding its development. As a result of its development
programme, the infant mortality rate declined, albeit slowly, from 171 per
thousand live births in 1985 to 130 in 1990. The mortality rate for children
under five declined from 390 per thousand live births in 1960 to about 192
in 1990. But these rates are still too high and a greater effort is needed to
reach the target rate of under 70 per thousand live births by the year 2000,
which was set in the Health for All strategy and also in the 1992 national
population strategy.
Primary health care coverage ratio: 45 per cent (68 per cent in urban
areas; 32 per cent in rural areas);
Coverage ratio of health expenditure: 51 per cent (70 per cent in urban
areas; 30 per cent in rural areas);
Illiteracy rate: 60.6 per cent (46 per cent for males; 85 per cent for
females);
114. The major causes of child mortality in Yemen, as set forth in the paper
on health programme priorities in the 1990s, are:
115. Large numbers of Yemeni children thus continue to die of contagious and
infectious diseases and malnutrition, diseases that can be treated only by
means of preventive services that ensure child safety through immunization,
treatment of dehydration due to diarrhoea, monitoring of child growth and
promotion of breast-feeding, all of which are strategic services aimed at
ensuring child survival.
117. Important objectives set by the Ministry of Health in its strategy for
the period 1992-2000 included a child immunization rate of 90 per cent and
eradication of poliomyelitis and infant tetanus. These targets formed part
of its interim oral rehydration plans for the prevention of dehydration.
118. In the past 10 years, the acceptance of oral rehydration treatment for
the prevention of dehydration due to diarrhoea, the main cause of infant
mortality in Yemen, has increased. Health workers and specialists have been
trained in its use and a media campaign has been conducted to stimulate
awareness among families and mothers. The mother and child demographic survey
carried out in 1991 showed that 57 per cent of women knew about this treatment
and 92 per cent of them knew of sources from which it was available but
only 55 per cent of mothers used it when their children fell ill with
diarrhoea. As a result, it is one of the most widespread of children’s
diseases, representing 34 per cent of diseases contracted by children under
the age of five. However, its incidence can be reduced only by taking action
in other areas such as ensuring a clean supply of drinking-water, hygienic
disposal of waste and effluent, and environmental rehabilitation. There is
a serious lack of such facilities in our country. For example, garbage
collection facilities exist in only six of the main towns and a large
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 29
119. In late 1993, the State launched a national anti-diarrhoea and health
awareness campaign and began to implement environmental rehabilitation
projects and to encourage breast-feeding, child growth monitoring and health
care for mothers in the following ways:
(a) Breast-feeding
120. Studies in Yemen have shown that breast-feeding still predominates but
that artificial feeding has begun to spread in urban and rural areas. The
last demographic survey conducted in 1991 showed that 73 per cent of mothers
had begun to feed their children artificially during the first three months of
their lives and 10 per cent of nursing women weaned their babies at that age.
The average duration of breast-feeding in Yemen was found to be 16.8 months.
122. The monitoring of growth is one of the most difficult components of the
health strategy for child survival. Effective use of the health card "The
Road to Health" is still far from satisfactory in many mother and child health
care centres, although health workers have been trained to use it. Because
of certain habits and illiteracy, mothers are unaware of the purpose of the
card. Moreover, failure to supply them consistently in all health centres
and a number of other factors have led to symptoms of malnutrition or
undernutrition. Mothers need to make a special effort to provide additional
nourishment for their children and to supervise their children’s state of
nutrition. It should be noted that in most cases malnutrition has less to do
with the supply of food than with repeated illness and lack of information
concerning proper nourishment for children. Some bad habits in Yemeni
society, such as failing to supplement mother’s milk with other food or
depriving children with diarrhoea of food and drink, are conducive to
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 30
malnutrition. The 1991 statistics showed that 53 per cent of children under
the age of five were underweight and 15 per cent of children under the age
of two were emaciated.
123. Maternity care has been given insufficient attention in our country.
Statistics on maternal disease and mortality are poor. It is not surprising,
therefore, that the maternal mortality rate, estimated at 800 to 1,000
per 100,000 live births, is one of the highest in the world. Maternal
mortality accounts for about one third of deaths among women of childbearing
age. The perinatal mortality rate (death of the embryo during the eighth to
the twentieth week or later in pregnancy, and death of live infants within
the first week of life) is also very high: 26 to 74 for every thousand live
births according to studies undertaken in hospitals and in society in general.
These ratios reflect the poor state of maternal health in Yemen.
124. It has been established beyond doubt through global studies that there
is a strong relationship between maternal and child mortality. According to
the 1993 study of significant factors in maternal mortality, 60 per cent of
live-born children under the age of five fail to survive when their mother
dies during or after birth, compared with 38 per cent of children in cases
where the mother is still living. The study, which was carried out in the
country’s northern and eastern governorates, also brought to light the
following causes of maternal mortality:
Hepatitis;
Haemorrhage;
Extrauterine conception;
Septicaemia;
Difficult delivery.
125. The following are a selection of indicators from the 1991 mother and
child demographic survey:
(d) The mortality risk is greater for mothers who give birth at an
early or late age (under 20 or over 39) or in quick succession (less than
two years between births), as shown in the following tables:
Table 1
Table 2
2-3 years 52 26 76
126. All these indicators provide clear evidence of the poor standard of
maternity care, bearing in mind that careful family planning and health care
during pregnancy and childbirth play an important role in reducing high child
and maternal mortality rates alike. According to Ministry of Health
statistics for 1989, complications of pregnancy and childbirth occurred
in 19.6 per cent of cases, 12 per cent of deliveries took place in health
centres and 16 per cent were supervised by trained personnel. Contraceptives
were used by 7 per cent of those surveyed.
127. In the early 1990s, the Government began to give increased attention
to mother and child care in an endeavour to implement the mother and child
strategy, which aims at halving the maternal mortality rate by the year 2000
through the quantitative and qualitative improvement of maternity services, by
educating mothers to avoid traditional methods that are harmful to children,
and by helping them to attend to their child’s nutrition, thereby protecting
both themselves and their child against risk.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 32
129. However, this does not mean that the right of children in our country
to proper care and attention has not received official recognition. The
Government has taken a variety of steps in the field of legislation and
social, health and educational policy with a view to identifying and meeting
existing needs, so that Yemeni children now enjoy certain rights under
domestic legislation. These requirements must be met as a matter of urgency
in order to develop children’s intellectual and mental capacities and
aptitudes, enhance their social skills, diversify their sources of culture
and knowledge, and consolidate their civil and legal rights with a view to
promoting the development of their personality, preparing them for the
responsibilities of life and shaping their future.
(i) The limited capacity of the bodies that formulate general child
welfare strategies;
(e) Some existing child welfare plans and programmes are meaningless
because they do not fully grasp the real nature of children’s present and
future needs.
(g) The lack of social and field studies to identify children’s needs,
to help provide the requisite factual basis for the preparation of future
projects and budgets for child welfare programmes and to serve as a
performance indicator for the implementation of programmes and ideas for
future plans.
(h) The lack of child welfare training establishments, which means that
child welfare establishments are unable to meet their needs for a wide range
of professionals with diverse qualifications, scientific expertise and
practical experience in the field. This type of expertise calls for
pre-service and in-service training designed to improve standards of
performance.
(i) The rising cost of and growing demand for social, educational,
health, cultural and recreational services, which have created difficulties
for existing establishments and may compel them to suspend the provision of
such services and the formulation and implementation of child development and
welfare goals and policies designed to prepare children to lead a decent life,
the kind of life that enhances their capacity to assume the responsibilities
required of them in the future.
(l) Most child welfare establishments are located in urban areas and
many rural areas have no access to their services because the formulators of
development policy have no concept of the needs arising from the immense
suffering of children in those areas. In addition, the economic situation of
families in urban and rural areas prevents them from taking advantage of the
services offered by child welfare establishments, especially those for which
a fee is charged.
(n) Institutional child welfare services are few and limited in scope.
They fail to meet children’s basic and growing needs in a variety of areas.
133. Moreover, many privileges and legal provisions that would improve
the lot of disabled children have not been implemented because of the
lack of clear-cut and integrated national strategies dealing with care
and rehabilitation for the disabled.
134. The role of child welfare services and social workers in existing social,
educational and health establishments is still limited in terms of the
relationship between the child and the social worker, especially in
orphanages, homes for juveniles or the disabled, and preschool educational
establishments. It is also a well-known fact that children with special
development problems do not receive the necessary care and support because
the services that social workers should be providing in the context of
educational, social, health or recreational establishments such as clubs,
psychiatric clinics, crèches, kindergartens, schools and centres for the
disabled are limited and cannot be used to benefit children. As social
workers do not play their proper role in these establishments, they cannot
easily tell the difference between individual children’s circumstances and
needs, or how they would respond to the social worker or to the help that they
require. In addition, social workers are greatly lacking in expertise and in
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 35
the theoretical and practical skills needed to deal with children in these
establishments because of a lack of in-service training, all of which impedes
the implementation in Yemen of the articles of the Convention.
135. These problems will continue to exist until such time as the relevant
government bodies address the problems and take practical steps to meet these
essential and growing needs under scheduled plans backed up by annual budgets,
thereby improving the situation in different areas. In pursuit of that aim,
section III of this report sets out a number of proposed plans in support of
the implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child in the
Republic of Yemen.
The problem
Aims
137. The proposed plan of action would have the following aims:
(c) To remove anything that might remind the juvenile girl that she is
undergoing punishment;
(e) To develop the juvenile girl’s social awareness so that she can
reintegrate easily after her release from the home;
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 36
Justification
138. Rapid population growth and the growing demands and everyday needs of the
family and society in response to social change and changes in habits, customs
and traditions have produced signs of moral degeneracy among juvenile girls in
some poor, needy and neglected environments as a result of family and social
pressures that have undermined family structures in a number of ways.
139. Juvenile girls are currently held in women’s prisons alongside hardened
women criminals. This situation undermines any preventive reform programme
for juvenile girls and there is no clear-cut policy to establish a juvenile
institution for girls where their behaviour can be changed and their previous
attitude towards themselves and others revised.
Means
Funding
The problem
142. The problem underlying the proposal to establish a training centre for
the staff of preschool educational establishments (crèches and kindergartens)
is the lack of instructors, teachers and administrators with specialized
training in child welfare, who should possess a number of academic, personal
and professional characteristics to qualify for this kind of responsibility.
Aims
Justification
144. A field study of public and private crèches and kindergartens carried
out in recent years brought to light a number of shortcomings in the human
resources employed in such establishments, particularly private crèches and
kindergartens whose teaching staff had not been properly trained and used
inappropriate teaching methods. These projects require additional support
through the establishment of a training centre for kindergarten teachers and
instructors for the following reasons.
145. The tendency for women to seek employment has created an urgent need for
the establishment of kindergartens and crèches, and this has in turn created a
demand for qualified teachers trained in the methods to be used in such
establishments.
149. The plan of action calls for the implementation of the following
measures:
(b) Provision of the requisite human and material resources, the basic
ingredients needed to ensure the success of the project;
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 39
(c) Design of a building to house the centre or, failing that, rental
of an appropriate building for the purpose;
Budget
150. The Ministry of Social Security and Labour and the Ministry of Education
will assist in establishing the training centre by incorporating a separate
budget for the project in their 1995-1996 budget. The sum involved is
estimated at 4 million Yemeni rials. Provision for payment of the salaries of
the staff recruited to work in the centre will come under the annual budget of
the Ministries.
151. Foreign support will be used to provide equipment for the centre,
to supply it with the furniture, materials and resources required for the
training process and to equip the crèches and kindergartens with the requisite
furniture and playthings:
The problem
152. Notwithstanding its social and economic progress, our country still lacks
certain facilities, especially social services such as care for paraplegics
and persons suffering from multiple disabilities, a system of foster families
and other services of the kind provided by SOS-Kinderdorf International
(SOS Children’s Villages) in a number of countries, including Arab countries,
whose practical experience in this field has proved successful in terms of its
beneficial and effective role in caring for the groups concerned.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 40
Justification
154. Owing to the prevailing economic and social situation, many people who
would previously have been willing to adopt orphans and children of unknown
parentage are now unable to incur the expense and responsibility of rearing
and educating them. As a result, the children in question are deprived of a
natural family environment that would offer them security and protection. The
establishment of this kind of institution as an alternative care system is
necessary to extend the scope of services available to groups of deprived and
homeless children.
Aims
Means
156. The children’s villages will require the provision of the following:
A house for the village director measuring not more than 150 m2;
A house for the administration measuring not more than 150 m2;
Measures
Budget
158. The Yemeni Government will assist in obtaining the plot of land, in
paying the salaries of the staff and in defraying the village’s monthly
expenses:
Foreign support
160. Many public and private bodies providing educational, social, health,
informational, cultural, recreational and other services are suffering from
serious shortcomings in the institutional care they offer to beneficiaries
because of the lack of professional staff qualified in the field of individual
and community service.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 42
Justification
161. Given the extent and complexity of child welfare and of children’s
needs for a sound and harmonious upbringing, and in view of the emergence of
institutional child welfare services in various government bodies dealing with
child-rearing and education, as well as the existence of other institutions
providing individual and community services, it has become necessary to set
up a specialized department that can play a beneficial role in comprehensive
development encompassing all aspects and sectors of society. One cannot speak
of comprehensive development where one component is developed at the expense
of another. Social development goes hand in hand with economic, cultural and
political development since they all serve the same aim of promoting the
welfare of the human person as the means and end of development.
Aim
165. The aim of the department will be the provision of qualified personnel to
work in the following fields:
Means
166. The following means will be employed to achieve the aim of the
department:
Measures
Budget
168. The budget for the department would be incorporated in the Faculty budget
and investment programme. Coordination with the Faculty of Education of
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 44
Estimated total for the Government and donor agencies: US$ 6.5 million.
Summary
169. The Republic of Yemen ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child
in 1991 and took wide-ranging steps to implement its provisions, adopting
legislation and announcing the establishment of a Higher Council for Maternal
and Child Welfare in 1991.
170. The statistics show that the prevailing economic and political situation
impedes full implementation of the Convention and that the emergence of
certain practices constitutes an obstacle to sound child development, for
example the spread of begging and vagrancy among children and rising
disability ratios as a result of the prevailing economic and social
circumstances and the wars and conflicts that have led to a reduction
in family income levels or the loss of a breadwinner.
171. The statistics show that educational programmes and policies do not
correspond to the present size of the population and fail to meet children’s
real educational needs. The ratio of children benefiting from education to
the total population is only 54 per cent. Full educational coverage for
children has not been achieved because the principles and goals announced
are out of tune with reality. Free education does not cover educational
requisites and does not imply exemption from fees. Moreover, the public
authorities have not yet been able to enforce compulsory education or ensure
equality of opportunity in education despite the fact that schools now exist
even in remote regions of the country.
172. Although the public authorities are aware of the need to provide for
child welfare and although the media and cultural channels are used to further
that aim, Yemeni children do not benefit from such services as they should.
Although radio broadcasting began as early as 1959 and television
transmissions in 1965, the programmes have not fired children’s imagination,
responded to their aspirations or contributed to their development because of
the lack of material and technical resources and the fact that media coverage
does not extend to all parts of the country.
173. The statistics indicate that the number of children benefiting from
health services is steadily declining because of the inadequacy of children’s
health care, the increase in population growth compared with available health
services and the high illiteracy rate, especially among people in rural areas,
who account for 81 per cent of the population of Yemen.
CRC/C/8/Add.20
page 45
References
Annex I
Annex II
0 - 4 1 176 900 1 200 680 1 212 410 1 519 410 1 183 820 1 190 600
5 - 9 959 620 979 390 1 030 000 888 590 935 280 977 460
10 - 14 696 940 796 000 169 930 621 030 664 330 713 460
15 - 19 480 490 517 600 555 730 475 980 496 820 518 070
20 - 24 317 470 338 950 366 030 376 690 386 620 401 310
25 - 29 264 570 269 400 274 060 355 070 355 560 354 360
30 - 34 231 480 234 650 238 970 314 360 320 050 325 980
35 - 39 210 970 213 220 214 810 365 180 273 110 279 990
40 - 44 180 380 184 140 188 220 205 230 212 960 222 060
45 - 49 154 480 154 510 155 970 172 230 174 950 177 820
50 - 54 137 270 142 520 143 560 143 560 147 110 119 070
55 - 59 112 560 114 700 119 300 212 370 115 090 119 070
60 - 64 91 800 88 580 87 820 87 820 95 400 91 500
65 - 69 66 610 66 070 65 880 67 810 98 540 69 780
70 - 74 53 290 47 120 43 670 56 860 49 070 44 940
75 74 550 71 830 69 260 84 440 18 370 78 320
Total 5 210 170 5 419 360 5 535 620 7 586 630 5 590 150 5 716 860
Annex III
Hudayda - - - - 3 24 24 58
Ibb - - - - 2 35 35 82
Al-Baida* 1 2 2 4 - - - -
Mahwit
Annex IV
Year
Name of 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 Total
institution
City of 48 72 130 160 173 104 98 88 80 98 125 125 155 152 157 1 765
Sana’a
Aden Centre - - - - - - - - - - - 18 - - - 18
Ibb 37 33 54 58 64 75 72 49 52 47 54 39 49 50 53 786
Sa’dah - - - - - - - - - 18 11 10 10 - - 49
Total 182 201 334 403 441 329 334 233 264 303 307 326 343 358 341 4 699
page 51
CRC/C/8/Add.20
Annex VII
Public and private centres for the disabled: services and programmes
Name of institution Region Disability Responsible Capacity Type of service Number of Educational Vocational Additional
authority beneficiari programmes training activities
page 52
es programmes
Al-Nur Centre Sana’a Blind Social security 50 Education and 108 Braille tuition None Cultural, social,
care to preparatory recreational,
level musical
CRC/C/8/Add.20
Al-Nur Institute Aden Blind Social security 50 Education, care 25 Braille tuition Wickerwork Cultural, social,
and training recreational,
rehabilitation musical
Al-Nur Institute Mukalla Blind Social security 50 Education, care 80 Braille tuition Wickerwork, Cultural, social,
and bookbinding, recreational,
rehabilitation carpentry, musical
stonework
Cognitive Sana’a Deaf, dumb and Social security 120 Education and 238 Special tuition Carpentry, Cultural, social,
Development Centre mentally and the local rehabilitation for the deaf printing, recreational,
retarded council knitting, sports, musical
upholstery,
bookbinding,
agriculture
Project for Ta’izz All Social security Open Consciousness- 278 Consciousness- None None
rehabilitation of Lahej disabilities raising and raising and
the disabled within education education
society
Early home education Sana’a All Social security 80 Consciousness- 63 Education and None None
project for mothers disabilities raising and training
of disabled children education programmes for
mothers of
disabled
children
Rehabilitation and Sana’a Motor Health Open Natural therapy, Open None None None
Natural Therapy handicapped prostheses,
Centre prosthetic
equipment
School for the Deaf Hudayda Deaf and dumb Local council 30 Education 50 Special tuition None Cultural, social,
for the deaf: recreational
lip-reading and
sign language
Public and private centres for the disabled: services and programmes
Name of institution Region Disability Responsible Capacity Type of service Number of Educational Vocational Additional
authority beneficiari programmes training activities
es programmes
School for the Deaf Zabid Deaf and dumb Education: 40 Education and 48 Special tuition Sewing, Cultural, social,
Literacy rehabilitation for the deaf: handicrafts sports,
Department lip-reading and recreational
sign language
Home for the Elderly Sana’a All Local council 80 Care, 125 None None None
and Disabled disabilities accommodation
and the elderly
Home for the Elderly Aden The elderly Social security 150 Care, 45 None None
accommodation
Al-Salaam Sanatorium Hudayda Mental illness Social security 150 Care, 245 None None
accommodation,
therapy
Mental Sanatorium Sana’a Mental illness Reform Society 34 Mental care and 28 None None
for Women therapy
Society for Motor Sana’a Motor Society for the 30 Education, 225 Literacy Printing,
Handicapped Persons handicapped Disabled rehabilitation knitting, sewing,
handicrafts
Mental Sanatorium at Sana’a Mental illness Interior Open 220 None None None
the Central Prison
Home for the Elderly Hudayda The elderly Social security 600 Care, 285 None None None.
accommodation Recreational
outings
page 53
CRC/C/8/Add.20