05
05
                                                                  A. M. Malik*
                                                                  M. Rashid**
                                                                 S. S. Haider***
                                                                   A. Jalil****
ABSTRACT                                                                   1050, which shows that its existence was due to its placement
                                                                           along the major trade route through Central Asia and the
Built heritage is not merely about living quarters, but it                 Indian subcontinent. The city was regularly marred by
also reflects the living standards, cultural norms and values              invasion, pillage, and destruction (due to its lack of
of any society. The old built heritage gives references to the             geographical defenses and general over exposure) until
past, the way people used to live and their living                         1525, when it was sacked and then settled by the Mughal
arrangements. This is done by understanding the spatial                    emperor Babur. Sixty years later it became the capital of the
layouts of that particular built heritage. This research aims              Mughal Empire under Akbar, and in 1605 the Fort and city
to focus on documenting a historic building from the colonial              walls were expanded to the present day dimensions. From
period located in the walled city of Lahore, to highlight the              the mid-18th century until British colonial times, there was
need and significance of conservation of these historical                  a fairly lawless period in which most of the Mughal Palaces
buildings that are neglected and under threat. The method                  (havelis) were destroyed, marking a decrease in social norms
of research adopted for this paper was to document this                    and association with the built environment, that has continued
building via an ethnographic analysis using photographic                   unabattingly till today. Much of the walled fortification of
surveys, questionaires, interviews from government                         the city was destroyed following the British annexation of
authorities (Walled City of Lahore Authority) and local                    the region in 1849, as both a defensive measure to allow the
residents, and several site visits for detailed documentation.             colonists to better control the city and because of a
This paper aims to identify the aesthetics and structural                  commercial objective in order to resale the bricks for new
threats and other aspects of the Pirzada Mansion, which is                 projects (PEPAC, 1993). In 1864 many sections of the wall
a splendid example of the British colonial period and is                   had been rebuilt. Major physical contributions of the British
located in Walled City of Lahore.                                          to the old city consisted of piped water and well system,
                                                                           established right outside the former walls. The building of
Keywords: Pirzada Mansion, Walled City, Deterioration,                     the railroad and a station well outside the old city, set the
Damage, Conservation, Lahore.                                              stage for later expansion. A new wave of destruction washed
INTRODUCTION                                                               over the city in 1947, following the partition of British
                                                                           colonial India into the Hindu majority nations of India and
Lahore is a multi ethnic city filled with diverse architecture             the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. The resulting inter-
belonging to different areas. It is the capital of the province            communal strife destroyed wide areas of the urban fabric,
of Punjab, the most fertile area of Pakistan and the chief                 some of which was repaired by the 1952 Punjab Development
producer of agricultural products for the country. The earliest            of Damaged Areas Act. Many of the arriving Muslim families
credible records of the city date its establishment to around              from India moved into the emigrating Hindu residences,
*      A. M. Malik, Assistant Professor, School of Architecture and Planning, University of Management of Technology, Lahore, Pakistan.
       Email correspondance: ayesha.malik@umt.edu.pk
**     M. Rashid, Assistant Professor, School of Architecture and Planning, University of Management of Technology, Lahore, Pakistan.
       Email correspondance: meoona.rashid@umt.edu.pk
***    S. S. Haider, Assistant Professor, School of Architecture and Planning, University of Management of Technology, Lahore, Pakistan.
       Email correspondance: sajjad.haider@umt.edu.pk
****   A. Jalil, Assistant Professor, School of Architecture and Planning, University of Management of Technology, Lahore, Pakistan.
       Email correspondance: adnan.jalil@umt.edu.pk
34                                                                      Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)
although the low land values of the old city established the                    SELECTION OF THE PIRZADA MANSION
concentration of lower income groups in the city center,
                                                                                The Walled City of Lahore is enriched with a multi-
with wealthier families residing outside the fortification
                                                                                diversified timeline from Mughal to Sikh great British
wall. In the 1950's an organization called the Lahore
                                                                                architecture. History has left buildings from all the eras
Improvement Trust attempted to initate a plan for commercial
                                                                                (both original and transitions of the either two eras) (Table
development in the old city, but these efforts were largely
                                                                                1, Figures 1 and 2). A lot of work has been done in order
without effect. Between the early 1970s and '80s, 29% of
                                                                                to preserve these historic legacies yet a few are still untouched
the old city population moved out. The Walled City of Lahore
                                                                                and are under severe threat. There are many glorious
is the product of the cultural influences of atleast three major
                                                                                buildings from the Sikh colonial period that show splendid
empires in the subcontinent of India: the Mughal Empire,
                                                                                architectural elements of the two periods, out of which the
the British colonial presence, and the modern nation-state
                                                                                Pirzada Mansion is selected for this study, based on its
of Pakistan. As a result of its position along a major trade
                                                                                architectural and regional milieu. This building has private
route, it has also been influenced by many other, less dominant
                                                                                ownership and there are no such national policies that apply
cultures, such as Afghanistan and China. Unlike Peshawar,
                                                                                on it.
which has lost much of its larger scaled architectural past,
and Islamabad, which can only boast modern monumental                           LOCATION
architecture of some merit, Lahore contains some of the best                    Pirzada Mansion is an old Haveli located on Fort Road, in
expmples of all the empires which have touched it, as well                      close proximity to the Lahore Fort, Badshahi Mosque and
as smaller scale vernacular architecture.                                       the Walled City. The area of the haveli is 3880 sq.ft. It was
                                                                                constructed in the colonial period and is called Pirzada
                                                                                Mansion, also known as Peerzada House.
Table-1: Famous Sikh Colonial Havelis in Walled City During Sikh and British Eras.
     Havelis from the                         Illustration                        Havelis From The                      Illustration
   Sikh Colonial Period                                                         Sikh Colonial Period
Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)                                                                  35
                                                                      VI
                                                                    RA
                                                                R
                                                             VE
                    TO KABU
                           L                               RI
SHAHDARA
                                                                                  KOT KHWAJA
                                                                                  SAEED
                                                                     CHAH MIRAN                   MUGHAL PURA
                                          G. T. RO
                                                  AD                SULTAN PURA
                                                       NAULAKHA
                                                                              BEGUM PURA          HI
                                                                                              DEL
           DATA                                                                            TO
           DARBAR
                                                TRIPOLIA
                                             MOHALLA
                                             ZAYN KHAN
MOZANG
                   AN
                 LT
               MU
          TO              NAWAN KOT
ICHHRA
Figure-1: Location of havelis outside Walled City of Lahore. Figure-2: Examples of plans of havelis in Lahore.
The site of Pirzada Mansion is located in the oldest part of                                                       and Grand Mosque complex (Figure 3). During the British
Lahore, approximately three hundred meters from the                                                                rule the wall of the city was demolished and the esplanade
Roshnai Gate of the Walled City, connecting to the Fort                                                        of the Fort complex, where the site is located, was inhabited.
36                                                                                                              Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)
The Fort Road, along the southern façade and main entrance                      RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
of the haveli, has since then become one of the main vehicular
routes into the Walled City. The northern (rear) gate of the                  After a detailed study of the Pirzada Mansion many historical
haveli opens into a courtyard across which lies the famous                      and cultural evidences were revealed, that indicated its
Cuckoos Café(Figure 4). The eastern wall faces the outer                     architectural significance (Figures 5 and 6). Pirzada Mansion
fortifications of the Lahore Fort. To the west of the                           is one gem among all the colonial era buildings found here.
consolidated property, a 9 ft wide lane connects the Fort                       It seems to be inspired in style and design by buildings
Road to the rear courtyard space.                                               conspicuously popular among the Sikhs, primarily the
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Figure-5: External view of the Pirzada Mansion. Figure-6: Internal view of the Pirzada Mansion.
Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)                                                             37
religious monuments. Their secular edifices such as fortresses,       house has a basement, ground floor, first floor, mezzanine
palaces, samadhis (mausoleums built over places of                    floor, second floor and top floor (mumty floor), with the
cremation), havelis (fortified houses), bungas (residential           centralized courtyard that is supported by columns, thick
cum educational houses) and educational institutions, are             walls of 13 inches. The courtyard makes the building warmer
no different from the contemporary style which is generally           in winters and cooler in summer, and protects the severe
a mixture of Mughal and Rajput Architecture, or as Percy              weather to enter the building. Some changes have been
(Browne, 1942) an art historian, has described, a late form           incorporated in the last 40 years in which rooms near the
of the Mughal style of architecture.                                  back entrance have been repaired the entrance of the basement
                                                                      has been closed for security issues, decorative columns have
Architectural Significance                                            been replastered and the room on the front also has been
                                                                      replastered. Furthermore, the stair near the back entrance
Prominent examples of this type of architecture are the               of the haveli has been altered.
Samadhi of Maharaja Ranjit Singh in Lahore and the Khalsa
College in Amritsar. Whereas massive columns, portals,                The layout of the haveli is similar to the typical plans of
inner structures, bukharchas (three or four paneled projecting        havelis having a courtyard and a central space around which
windows in a row) on penda or gharvahj (projecting base)              different rooms have been arranged (Figures 10-15).
in the shape of bisected open lotus, the chhatns (kiosks) on
the parapet, all trace back their origin to Rajput Architecture.      The haveli was built in the traditional brick and kankar
The dome, arches, minarets and underground cellars bear               lime construction. Repairs have been done in portland
the stamp of Mughal style architecture (Figure 7). Religious          cement mortar. The columns are massive and reflect a design
buildings of the Sikhs, the gurdwaras, also display essentially       style beloging to that period and can be noticed in the
eclectic nature of the architectural design, but they at the          elevation (Figure 16). The columns are based on vine, plant,
same time possess some special features, and present an               flower, bird and animal motifs. (Figures 18-20). The main
identifiable picture of a style which can doubtlessly be called       entrance to the haveli is decorated with floral designs.
Sikh architecture.
38                                                                 Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)
                                                                              7
                                                                       45-4 16 
                                                                          LOBBY
                                   REPAIR FLOOR                       12-2X21-10                  CRACK IN WALL
                                                                     DOUBLE HEIGHT
                                                                           +2-0                    BUCKLING IN WALL                REMOVE PIPES
                                                                                                                                      FROM WALL
                                         ROOM
           FP CLOSED             12-0 1/2X13-10 1/2          INSERTION OF NEW COLS.
                                   DOUBLE HEIGHT                       REINF.CELING                        DIP IN FLOOR
                                                                 REINF. / EXTEND BALCONY
                                                                                                                BATH
                                                                                                           9-11 1/2X6-8
                                                                    8X8 GULLEY TRAP                         CH 10-0              CRACK IN WALL
                                                                          VER.
                             STORE                                      CH 10-0
                           5-1 1/2X4-0   LAUNDRY                     +2-2
      REMOVE FIXTURE                          4-3X4-0                                 LINTEL CRACK
                                                                  REPLASTER CEILING
                                                                   EXPOSED REINF.
                                                                        DAMAGED PILLARS                                              CRACK IN WALL
                             REPLASTER ROOM
      REMOVE FIXTURE               KITCHEN
                               10-1 1/2X7-10            LINTEL CRACK            LINTEL CRACK
                                   CH10-0
                                     +2-0                                                                        VER.
                                                                                                                 CH 10-0
                                                                                                                  +2-2
                                                                                                                  DAMP IN FLOOR
                                    PORCH                                                                          DIP IN FLOOR
                             10-1 1/2X17-5 1/2
                                   CH 11-6
                                                                                                                                            FP CLOSED
                                                               CRACK IN WALL                                             ROOM
                                                                                                                     8-10X11-2
                                                                                    CRACK IN FLOOR                     CH 10-0
                                                                                  7
                                                                           48-4 16 
Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)                                                                             39
                                                                           CRACK IN
                                                                            LINTEL
                                                                               DN STAIR
                                                                              10-0X11-9
                                                                                              CRACK IN SLAB
                                                                                   EDGE
                                                                                 DAMAGED
                                     STORE
                                 12-0 1/2X5-8
                                     CH 7-5
                                                                 CRACK IN LINTEL SILL
                                                                            SITABILATY
                                                                            WINDOW ABOVE
                                                                               BELLOW
                                                                                LOBBY                   CRACK IN WINDOW SILL
                                                                      CRACK IN BALCONY
       CRACK IN WALL                                                        CRACK IN BALCONY
                                                                                                          WATERTANK
                                                                            EXPIRE STEEL
                                          LAUNDRY                 CRACK
                           STORE                               WINDOW ABOVE                                                        CRACK THROUGH STAIR IN WALL
                                          4-9 1/2X4-2 1/2
                         5-8X4-2 1/2
      CRACK IN LINTEL
                                                                          CRACK
                                                                         BALCONY                        CRACK IN WALL
                             CRACK IN WALL
                                   ROOM
                              10-1 1/2X13-0
          FP CLOSED               CH 7-5
                                                                                                                              CRACK IN LINTEL
                                                                     CRACK IN BALCONY
                                                                                                                 CRACK IN
                                                                   CRACK IN LINTEL                               CEILING
                                                                                        CRACK IN WALL
                                    ROOM                                                                                    CRACK IN FLOOR
                                10-2X17-5
                                  CH 7-5
                                                                                                                       ROOM
                                                                                                                   8-10X11-3
                                                                                                                      CH 7-5
BALCONY BALCONY
40                                                                                    Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)
                                                                                  CRACK IN BELOW ABOVE
                                                                                                                                  CRACK IN FLOOR
                                                                              STAIR
                                       SOME CRACK BUT                                      CRACK
                                        ROOM IN TAKE
                                                                                                        ROOM
                  FP CLOSED                 ROOM                                                                                   FP CLOSED
                                                                                                                                  CRACK IN WALL
                                                                                                          ROOM
                                                                                                                                   FP CLOSED
                                          CRACK IN WALL
                                                                              LOUNGE
                                                                                       CRACK IN        CRACK IN WALL
                  FP CLOSED                                                       BALCONY FLOOR
                                                              CRACK IN SILL                             & DAMPNESS
                                           ROOM                                                                                   CRACK FLOOR
                                                                                                                                  CRACK
                                                                         CRACK FLOOR (MAY BE
                                                                             CRACKED IN                        BATH
                                                                          VIBRATE IN FLOOR)
                CRACK IN SILL
                                                                                                           CRACK
                                                                                                                                  CRACK IN WALL
               CRACK IN WALL
BATH CRACK
                                                                                CRACKS IN BALCONY
                                                                                                         CRACK
                                                                               LOWER
                                    BADLY DAMAGED                             TERRACE
             CRACK IN WALL              FLOOR                                                                                     SEVERE CRACK IN WALL
                                                                                                               CRACK
                                        BATH                                                                   VER.
                                                                   CRACKS IN BALCONY
             CRACK IN LINTEL
                & WALL                                              CRACK IN WALL
            CRACKS IN LINTEL
                                                                   CRACKS IN BALCONY
                                        KITCHEN
                                       9-3X17-3                                                                   ROOM
                                                                              CRACKS IN BALCONY                    9-3X11-4
                                                                CRACK
                CRACKS IN FP
                                                             TREE GROWTH                                        CRACK IN LINTEL         SEVERE DAMPNESS
                                                                                                                                       FRONT FACADE WALL
                                       BALCONY                                                                     BALCONY
                                                                               TERRACE
                                                          CRACK IN SHADE                                       CRACK IN SHADE
  Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)                                                                            41
                                                                                              CRACK
CRACK IN CORNER
                                     DAMPNESS
                                                                                                      ROOM
                                        ROOM
                                                                                                                CRACK IN
           CRACK IN WALL                                                                                         WALL
                                                                                                                                   DAMPNESS
         CRACK IN CORNER
                                                                                                    CRACK IN LINTEL
                                                 CRACK IN LINTEL           DAMPNESS & CRACK WALL
                                                 TO BANCH BOVE
                                                                                      CRACK
                                                  CRACK                                               CRACK
                                      CRACK               CRACK
CRACK
                                                                                                              UPPER FACED
                                                                                                              CEILING CRACK
                                                                                                              AT PARAPET
                                                                                                                               EDGE
CRACK IN LINTEL
         CRACK IN CEILING
                                  W/C                                        VOID
CRACK
TARRACE
            2-0 HIGHT
          MUMMTY COHKET
                                                                                                               CRACK
42                                                                   Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)
                                    CRACK IN SILL                                      CRACK IN SILL
                              TERRACE                                                                        TERRACE
                                                                                       CRACK IN ROOF
                 FLOOR DAMAGED
                                         CRACK IN SILL                                 CRACK IN LINTEL
                                                                      STAIR
                               SEAT TOP                                                           SEAT TOP
                               BOTTOM                                                             BOTTOM
                   CRACKING BANCH
                       & WALL
LOW ROOF
                                                                                VIOD
                      O. H. W. T.
Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)                                              43
                                                        FOOT PRNT G.F. WALL
                                                                                                    PROPERTY LINE
                                                                                   ROOM
                                                                              13-10X5-7 1/2
                                                                                                                   WALL THIKNESS NOT CONFIRMED
                                                                                    HALL
                                                                              13-10X10-9 1/2
                                                                                                    BEAM 9 DROP
                                                                                                HALL
                                                                                            27-10X7-7
PROPERTY LINE
44                                                      Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)
Figure-16: Front and side elevations.                                           Figure-17: Section.
Figure-18: Front façade of the haveli. Figure-19: Architectural elements adorning the front façade.
Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)                                                                  45
The haveli is located on a street that is only 35 ft wide.
There are no compulsory open spaces left between buildings,
and there were no bye-laws that were enforced at the time
of the construction of the haveli. So the ventilation and air
circulation is from the central courtyard of the haveli, that
is around eighteen feet in width and thirty four feet in length,
with the doors and windows opening into it (Figure 27).
The perepheral walls, including the mezzanine floor are
Figure-23: Rajput arch framing the doorway. Figure-24: Terrace on right, showing the staircase leading to the rooftop.
46                                                                 Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)
double height with each wall having, atleast four to six                        Conservation Significance
windows, making the rooms well lit and having proper
ventilation. Some wooden doors and windows used in its                          It has been analyzed that in built heritage ageing has always
construction are still in their original condition. Each room                   been a vital factor of decay, but there are some other factors
has an open space in front of it, which become internal                         too which accelerate the deterioration of the monument. As
courtyards with openings, making the place comfortable. In                      per Sir Bernard of the causes of decay in historic building,
winters these spaces are used to take sun bath by the family                    the most uniform and universal is gravity followed by the
members of the haveli whereas in summers this courtyard                         actions of man and then by diverse climatic and environmental
helps ventilate the house. Thick walls (13 inches) also help                    effect (Mughal, 1995). There is no single cause responsible
to make the house cool in summers and warm in winters.                          for the deterioration and decay of Pirzada Mansion.
Figure-28: Dampness on walls seenin the interior. Figure-29: Unstable soil conditions in the contect.
Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)                                                              47
the other reasons behind the deterioration of the haveli are         objective behind this research was to recommend the idea
discussed in detail in the following section.                        that the haveli should be preserved for future generations.
                                                                     It not only adds to the cultural heritage, but is an example
Rain and Moisture                                                    of a rich architectural edifice having interesting elements
                                                                     and features. In contrast to the adaptive re-use of the building,
In Lahore the average rainfall is twenty inches annually.            it should be restored or conserved on priority basis with
Rain has damaged the masonry above the ground level and              immediate and long term plans. The objective of retaining
penetration of rainwater through capillary action has caused         its original usage is that, at times, the original identity of
decay of structure internally. At some places in the haveli,         the building is lost while preparing it for adaptive re-use.
this water penetration has also caused dampness (Figure              And for this reason the proper conservation plan must be
28).                                                                 made first.
                                                                     Sensible maintenance and repair can reduce the necessity
Topography and its Effects                                           for restoration work in historic buildings, as it is extremely
                                                                     important to maintain the originality of historic building,
The nature of the ground and stability of soil, on which the         with minimum interventions. A detailed conservation plan
building is erected are of an utmost importance. The site is         is essential before carrying out any restoration work, as it
located in an area with up to thirty feet of back fill, making       helps to decide which part of the building needs replacement
it extremely unstable. Normally the back fill is upto 3 ft           and which part can be preserved after minor repair. Any
(Figure 29).                                                         intervention must be minimum, necessary and be allowed
                                                                     the maximum amount of existing material to be retained."
Man Made Causes                                                      (Fielden, 2003) As already mentioned, after the foundation
                                                                     survey, it was clear that the foundation of the building is
The haveli has also been adversely affected by political             highly unstable. In order to enhance the structural support
instability in the region, general neglect and traffic and air       and to resolve the problem, piling is the immediate solution.
pollution within the immediate context.                              Furthermore, regular pointing and grouting is necessary. It
                                                                     is necessary to restore the surrounding environment of the
CONCLUTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS                                      building. Surroundings must be kept clean. It is also necessary
                                                                     to use the original material in case any conservation work
A detailed study of the architectural significance of the            is done to restore the building.
building, that is located in one of the oldest parts of Lahore,
concludes that the building has seen years of wear and tear          The conservation of a heritage building is generally perceived
under all kinds of weather conditions. Apart from the natural        to be in the long term interest of the society as built heritage
deterioration to the various parts of the building that has led      plays a very important role in developing the identity of a
to the structural cracks and depletion of the structure of the       city. It helps people to stay connected to religion, traditions,
mansion, the whole structure is standing on scaffoldings             culture and beliefs. This study directs towards the requirement
which is a threat to the structure. The owners are no more           for a proper conservation policy to be initiated by the
interested in retaining the structure and they want it to be         government, that should take measures for the conservation
demolished and a new building to be builtin its place. Wasif         of heritage buildings and respect the Antiquities Acts that
Ali Associates Design office, an architectural firm, was             was made for the sake of protection of old heritage buildings.
approached to propose on the location a five star hotel, but         Pirzada Mansion requires the attention of the Government
due to serious structural threats it was advised that instead        of Pakistan. Heavy traffic flow should be discouraged near
of the original structure, a new structure for the new function      the haveli, as according to the Antiquity Act of 1975 no
should be built by demolishing either the whole structure            vehicular traffic or construction should be done within 2000
of Pirzada Mansion or parts of it. This proposal was not             ft of a historic edifice. This and similar laws and policies
approved by the Walled City Authority and they have taken            should be enacted to help preserve this and other such
a stay against the demolition of the structure. The major            buildings.
48                                                                Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue)
REFERENCES
Browne, P., 1942, Indian Architecture: Buddhist and Hindu Period, Tobey Press, India
Fatima Q., 2013, Haveli Bakhshi Ram-A Unique Potohar Architecture, viewed- 02-05-2017., from
https://quratulainfatima.wordpress.com/2013/02/10/haveli-bakhshi-ram-a-unique-potohar-architecture
M. R. Mughal, 1995, Legislation for the Protection and Management of Archeological Heritage of Pakistan: UNESCO:
Educational Publishers, Karachi
Pakistan Environmental Planning and Architectural Consultants Ltd. (PEPAC), 1993, "Monograph of the Walled City of
Lahore", Pack Art Press (Pvt) Ltd., Lahore.
Journal of Research in Architecture and Planning: Vol. 24, 2018 (First Issue) 49