Scribd
Upload
119 views3 pages

Comment To Formal Offer

This document is a filing from an Accused opposing the prosecution's formal offer of exhibits in a criminal case. It lists each exhibit being offered by the prosecution and provides comments/objections to the admission of each. For many of the exhibits, the Accused only admits them as part of specific witness testimony. Other exhibits are entirely opposed because the Accused claims no illegal drugs were sold or possessed. The filing is submitted to the court for consideration and ruling on the admission of the prosecution's exhibits.

Uploaded by

mitch_simon23
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
119 views3 pages

Comment To Formal Offer

This document is a filing from an Accused opposing the prosecution's formal offer of exhibits in a criminal case. It lists each exhibit being offered by the prosecution and provides comments/objections to the admission of each. For many of the exhibits, the Accused only admits them as part of specific witness testimony. Other exhibits are entirely opposed because the Accused claims no illegal drugs were sold or possessed. The filing is submitted to the court for consideration and ruling on the admission of the prosecution's exhibits.

Uploaded by

mitch_simon23
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

Republic of the Philippines

FIRST JUDICIAL REGION


REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
BRANCH ______

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,


Plaintiff,

- versus - CRIMINAL CASE NOS. 12345


to 12346

xxx,
Accused.
x------------------------x

COMMENTS/OPPOSITIONS TO THE
FORMAL OFFER OF EXHIBITS FOR THE PROSECUTION

ACCUSED, by and through the Public Attorney’s Office, unto this


Honorable Court, respectfully submits this Comments/Oppositions to the
Prosecution’s Formal Offer of Exhibits, as follows:

EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION COMMENTS/OPPOSITIONS

A Affidavit of Poseur- The exhibits are admitted only as part


Buyer found on pages 5-6 of the testimonies of PO2 Andrei
Piniera, PO1 Marciano P. Tacdol and
P/Lt. Alex C. Lorenzo.
B Joint Affidavit of Police
Officers found on pages
7-9

D and Receipt/Inventory of These exhibits are not admitted as there


series Property Seized found on was no legitimate buy-bust operation
pages 12-15 of Crim. and that the exhibits contain items that
Case No. 18296-14 were not truly seized from the accused.

F and Digitally printed pictures


series found on pages 25-28

E Extract Copy of Police This is admitted only as part of the


Blotter found on pages testimony of P/Lt. Lorenzo.
23-24

G Pre-operational Report The said exhibits are admitted only as


found on page 29 of Crim. part of the testimony of P/Lt. Lorenzo.
Case No. 18296-14
Coordination Form found
H on page 30 of Crim. Case
No. 18296-14
EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION COMMENTS/OPPOSITIONS

I and I-1 Php 500.00 bill buy-bust These exhibits are not admitted because
money with serial the Accused neither sold any illegal
numbers D587610 and drugs to the alleged police poseur buyer
D587610 nor was in possession of any.

J Sketch found on page 29 This exhibit is admitted only as part of


the testimony of PO2 Piniera and P/Lt.
Lorenzo.

K Request for Laboratory Exhibits “K”, “L”, “N”, “O” and series,
Examination “P” and “Q” are admitted only as part
of the testimonies of those who actually
L Request for Drug Test testified in court and those whose
testimony were dispensed with.
M, M-1, Plastic packet containing
M-2 two plastic sachets Exhibits “M” and series are not
admitted because the Accused neither
N Criminal Drug Test Form sold any illegal drugs to the alleged
police poseur buyer nor was in
O & O-1 Pertinent pages of the possession of any.
dangerous drugs logbook
found on pages 47-48

P Chemistry Report No.


CDT-023-2018-IN

Q Chemistry Report No. D-


027-2018-IN

R, R-1 & Cellphones They are admitted only as part of the


R-2 testimony of PO1 Tacdol.

S Slingbag

T and Items inside the slingbag


series

WHEREFORE, premises considered, it is most respectfully prayed that the


formal offer of exhibits of the Prosecution be admitted and/or excluded based on the
above-stated grounds.

Respectfully submitted.

July 12, 2019, ________________, Philippines.


ABC
Roll Number ______
IBP Lifetime No. _________
MCLE Comp. No. _______

NOTICE

DEF
Clerk of Court
Regional Trial Court
Branch ________

-and-

GHI
Provincial Prosecutor’s Office
___________

Greetings!

Please take notice that the undersigned shall submit the foregoing for the kind
consideration and approval of the most Honorable Court immediately upon receipt
hereof.

Thank you.

ABC
Copy Furnished:

GHI
Provincial Prosecutor’s Office
_________

You might also like