Coal RTD in Pressurized Gasifier
Coal RTD in Pressurized Gasifier
Abstract
A pressurized fluidized bed gasifier (PFBG) system of an integrated coal gasification and combined cycle (ICGCC) plant is designed to
behave as a well-mixed flow system for coal; and any deviation from the well-mixed flow condition will deteriorate the performance
and efficiency of the gasification system. This paper describes a radiotracer investigation carried out to measure RTDs of coal particles
in a pilot-scale PFBG with objectives to determine mean residence time (MRT) of coal/ash particles in the gasifier and estimate degree
of mixing at different operating and process conditions. Lanthanum-140 labeled coal (100 gm) was used as a radiotracer. The tracer
was instantaneously injected into the coal feed line and monitored at ash and gas outlets of the gasifier using collimated scintillation
detectors. The measured RTD was used to determine mean residence time (MRT) of coal particles within the system and simulated us-
ing fractional tank-in-series model. The results of simulation indicated that the system behaved as a well-mixed system with undesired
bypassing of a small fraction coal particle from the system. The results of the study were used to improve the design of the gasifier and
optimize the system.
Keywords: Pressurized fluidized bed gasifier, residence time distribution, radiotracer, Lanthanum-140, tanks-in-series
model, bypassing
1. Introduction                                                          investigations in this system to evaluate feasibility of using
                                                                         radiotracer technique for measurement of RTD of the coal
    Integrated coal gasification and combined cycle (ICGCC) is
                                                                         particles in the PFBG at cold as well as hot conditions [8]. They
one of the most promising advanced clean coal technologies
                                                                         reported use of two different radiotracers i.e. gold-198 and
wherein coal is converted into low calorific value (CV) gaseous
                                                                         lanthanum-140 and concluded that both are equally suitable to
fuel in a pressurized fluidized bed gasifier (PFBG) and
                                                                         trace the coal particles in gasifiers. They used fractional tanks-in-
combusted in a gas turbine combustor of combined cycle plant.
                                                                         series model to simulate the measured RTD and found that the
The gasifier involves flow of two different phases i.e. solid (coal)
                                                                         system behaved as a well-mixed system with bypassing of some
and gas (mixture of air and steam) and knowledge of dynamics of
                                                                         of the coal particles from the system. The paper describes some
these two phases is important to assess the performance of the
                                                                         of the preliminary results of the RTD measurement carried out in
system as well as for scale up of the process. The concept of
                                                                         the same PFBG system as described by Pant et al. (2009).
measurement and analysis of residence time distribution (RTD) is
often used to investigate dynamics of flowing phases in industrial       2. Experimental
process system [1]. The analysis provides vital information such
as mean residence time (MRT) of process fluid, degree of axial           2.1. Pressurized fluidized bed gasifier (PFBG)
mixing and abnormality in flow behavior, if any. Radiotracer                   The schematic diagram of the pilot-scale PFBG system is
techniques are widely used to measure RTD of process material            shown in Fig.1 [8]. The system consists of various subsystems
in pilot-scale as well as the full scale industrial systems because      such as gasifier, coal feeding system, combustor, air compressor,
of their high detection sensitivity, online detection,                   steam supply system, gravity recycle system, gas cleaning and
physicochemical compatibility, availability of wide range of             cooling system and ash extraction system. The gasifer is designed
suitable tracers, limited memory effect and utility in harsh             for gasifying 50 kg/h of sub bituminous coal has an internal
industrial environment [2,3,4,5,6,7].                                    diameter of 200 mm and consists of air plenum, distributor
      The Research and Development Division of M/s Bharat                assembly and freeboard section. An air compressor supplies the
Heavy Electricals Limited, Hyderabad, India has designed,                fluidizing air required for the process. The steam required for the
fabricated and commissioned a pilot-scale of the PFBG system to          process is supplied by a steam generating system and passed to
study the feasibility of coal gasification/combustion process for        the fluidizing bed through fluidizing air supply line. The
power generation. It was required to investigate flow dynamics of        combustor assembly is directly coupled with the air plenum of
coal particles in the system to evaluate its performance and scale       the gasifier. The gasifier is designed to operate at 3 atmospheric
up of the process. Pant et al. [8] carried out a series of radiotracer   pressure and 1000oC temperature. The air-plenum acts as a
www.indjst.org                                                       3746                                                       Research article
48
Indian Journal of Science and Technology                                                         Vol:5 Issue:12 December 2012 ISSN:0974-6846
header for the fluidizing media i.e. air/steam and also distribute Fig.1. Schematic diagram of PFBG facility and
the same uniformly into the gasifier by means of a conical                      experimental set-up
distributor attached to it. The freeboard section is slightly conical
with 200 mm diameter at the bottom and 250 mm diameter at the                                        D3                  D4    Gas to cleaning and
top. Gasifier and free board sections were provided with a                                                                     cooling system
number of view ports and tappings for temperature and pressure                                        Cyclone
measurements.                                                                                                                 Coal feed
      Initially the gasifier is filled with a known quantity of coal                                     Fines to
particles (50 microns-4 mm). Subsequently, coal and fluidizing                          Freeboard        combustor
air/steam are fed to the gasifier through the respective feeding
                                                                                                   Tracer
systems. During the fluidization process, the gasification and                                     Injecti
combustion of coal occurs and various gases such as carbon                                         on
dioxide, carbon monoxide, hydrogen, methane etc. are produced.
During the combustion process, the temperature of the fluidized
                                                                                                                     DAS
bed ranges from 900-1000 oC. The mixture of gases flows Gasifier and                                 D1
upward in the freeboard section of the gasifier and passes through Combustor
                                                                       Air/Steam in                 D2            D1 D2 D3 D4
the cyclone system, where the fine coal particles are separated.
                                                                        Distributor
The separated fines are fed back to the gasifier using recycle              and
system while the gaseous mixture is fed to the wet gas cleaning Air plenum                      Ash extraction hopper
system. The cleaned gaseous mixture is used as a fuel gas for
power generation and various other applications.                                    Valve     To ash collection tray
      The burnt coal i.e ash is generated in the process is extracted
from the bottom of the gasifier at regular intervals.                   2.2. Residence time distribution measurements
    Properties of the coal used as fluidizing material are given in
                                                                             Radiotracer technique was employed to measure the RTD of
Table 1. The fluidization phenomenon of gas-solid systems
                                                                        the coal in the gasifier. The technique involves the instantaneous
depends very much on the particle characteristics. Geldart [9]
                                                                        injection of a suitable radiotracer into the process stream and
was the first to classify the behavior of the solids fluidized by
                                                                        monitoring its movement at strategically important locations,
gases into four distict groups, namely A, B, C and D,
                                                                        using scintillation detectors. A series of four different RTD runs
characterized by the density difference between the particle and
                                                                        were carried out at different process and operating conditions as
the fluidizing medium and mean particle size. According to the
                                                                        shown in Table 2. All the experiments were carried out at
Geldart classification of fluidizing particles, coarser coal particles
                                                                        atmospheric pressure. The temperature of the bed during the hot
are classified as Type D particles, whereas the fine coal particle
                                                                        run ranged from 900-1000 0C. For the present study, lanthanum-
can be classified as Group B particles.
                                                                        140 radioisotope (gamma energies: 1.16 (95%), 0.92 (10%), 0.82
Table 1. Properties of coal particles used in experiments
                                                                        (27%), 2.54 (4%), half-life: 40 hours) as lanthanum chloride was
                                                                        selected to be used as a tracer, as it has strong affinity to get
    Property                            Value
                                                                        adsorbed on solid particles. Lanthanum-140 was produced by
    Bulk Density                        815 Kg/m3
                                                                        irradiating lanthanum oxide powder (La2O3) in DHURVA reactor
    Particle density                    1680 Kg/m3
                                                                        at Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, Trombay Mumbai. The
    Average particle size               1.86 mm
                                                                        irradiated target was processed to produce lanthanum chloride
    Composition of coal Content         Caron (C): 38.3% wt,            (LaCl3). About 1 mCi (37 MBq) activity of lanthanum-140 was
                                        Hydrogen (H2): 2.4 % wt,        taken from mother solution and diluted in about 300 ml of
                                        Sulphur (S): 0.3 % wt           distilled water. About 100 gm of coal was poured into the diluted
                                        Nitrogen (N2): 0.71 % wt,       solution and stirred for about 5 minutes using a glass rod. The
                                        Oxygen (O2): 9.6% wt.           coal soaked in the radioactive solution was left for about half an
    Type of particle according to       Group D                         hour. After half an hour, the radioactive solution was decanned
    Geldart Classification                                              and the coal particles were dried using an electrical heater. Based
                                                                        on the previous studies, it was observed that more than 60-70%
                                                                        of the initial lanthanum activity gets adsorbed on the coal
                                                                        particles. So it was assumed that about 600-700 micro curie (220-
                                                                        260 MBq) activity might have got adsorbed on the coal particles
(100 gms) and was used as tracer in each run. The lanthanum-140                                                                                          t
labeled coal was instantaneously injected into the coal feed line                                                                                        ∫ t .c( t ).dt
using a specially fabricated injection arrangement. The injection
                                                                                                                                                    tE = 0                                                   (3)
point is shown in Fig. 1. The tracer was injected after the system                                                                                        t
was stabilized and attained a steady state condition. The                                                                                                  ∫ c( t ).dt
movement of the tracer in the gasifier was monitored using seven                                                                                          0
different collimated scintillation detectors (D1 to D7) mounted at                                                                         The first moment of the RTD curve gives MRT of the process
four different locations as shown in the Fig.1. The detectors were                                                                      material in the system. The MRTs determined from measured
connected to corresponding channels of a common computer                                                                                RTD curves for four different runs are shown in Table 3. The
controlled data acquisition system (DAS) set to record tracer                                                                           theoretical MRT ( t T . ) of the material in a closed system is given
concentration data at an interval of every one minute. The tracer                                                                       as:
concentration versus time data acquired was saved in the                                                                                                   M
computer for further analysis.                                                                                                                      tT =                                                      (4)
                                                                                                                                                           Q
Table 2. Operating and process conditions during experiments                                                                            Where M: weight of bed material and Q: flow rate. The above
                                                                                                                                        equation holds good for systems with closed-closed boundaries.
                                                                                                                                        The freeboard section of the present experimental setup is a
                               QExtraction (kg/hr)
                                                                                                                          tT (min)
Run No.
   the tracer concentration at the outlet of the system is obtained by solving the above equation0.07                                                                                           N=0.75
of the tracer is injected at the inlet of the first tank, then the tracer
   and is given as:                                                                                     0.06                                                                                    N=1
concentration       at the outlet of the system is obtained by solving
                                                                                                                                                                                                N=2
the above equation and is given as: N (N -1)                                                            0.05
                                                     AN   t                                                                                                                                     N=5
                                            C (t)=                 e
                                                                    - Nt/τ m         (6)                 0.04
                                             N          N
                     N (N - 1)                       Qτ m (N - 1)!                                                                                                                              N=15
                    AN t         - Nt/τ                                                      (6)
                                                                                                         0.03
                                        N N - 1 - Nt/τ m
                                                 N   t       e
                                                                                                         0.01
                                        E(t) =                                       (7)
In normalized form the above equation
                               τ mN (N - 1)! (6) can be written as:                                      0.00
                                                                                                                0        20        40     60      80          100         120   140     160     180      200
                                                                                                                                                            Time (Min.)
     Where, E(t) is called dimensionless residence time distribution function. t and τm are time
                                                                                                       Fig.4. Experimentally measured residence time distributions
                                - Nt/τ
    variable and model predicted mean residence time, respectively. The value of N equal to
                   N N t N - 1e               m
    unity for well-mixed system or continuously stirred tank reactor and tends to be infinity for a Fig. 3 : Impulse responses of gamma function model for different tank number
       E(t) =
    plug flow system. The main drawback of the model is that the value of N should    (7) be an Normalised tracer concentration, E(t)
                           τ (N - 1)!
                           N
                           m                                                                       0.05                                            "Experimental RTD measured by
                                                                                                                                                      detector D2 (MRT=31.7 Min.)
                                                                                                                                                                     Gamma distribution model simulated RTD
 Where, E(t) is called dimensionless residence time distribution      0.04                                               (N=0.74, MRT =30 Min., RMS=0.00149)
function. t and τm are time variable and model predicted mean 0.03
to be infinity for a plug flow system. The main drawback of the 0.01
degree of mixing with bypassing of some of the process material Time (Min.)
                                                                                                                               ∫
                                                                                                                                                         
                            0                                                                                       RMS =  [E(t) − E m (t, N,τ m )]2 dt           = Minimum
                                                                                                                           n                                                                  (10)
                                                                                                                           0                            
Research article                                                                                  3749                                                                                www.indjst.org
                                                                                                    where, RMS is root mean square n is number of data points. The comparison of experimental
                                                                                                                                                                                 51
Vol:5 Issue:12 December 2012 ISSN:0974-6846                                                                                                 Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Fig 8.
                                                                                 0.02
D3 and D4 mounted at the inlet and outlet of the cyclone during Time (Min.)
the coal feed inlet and by detector D2 at the distributor outlet 0.01 Time (Min.)
are shown in Fig. 5 to Fig. 8. The model parameters i.e. tanks                0.02
                                                                                          0.00
number (N) and mean residence time (τm) corresponding to best                 0.01
                                                                                                  0                50                       100                  150                200                    250
                                                                                                                                                  Time (Min.)
fit i.e. minimum RMS value are tabulated in Table 3                           0.01
www.indjst.org                                                             3750                                                                                               Research article
52                                                                            0.00
                                                                                      0                      50                 100                       150                 200                   250
   Indian Journal of Science and Technology                                                                      Vol:5 Issue:12 December 2012 ISSN:0974-6846
7. Nomenclature
     A: Amount of radiotracer (MBq)
     t: time variable (second)
     C(t): Radiotracer concentration (Counts/unit time)
     E(t): Experimental RTD curve (second-1)
     Em(t,τm, N): Theoretical RTD curve (second-1)
     t E : Experimental mean residence time (second-1)
     τm: Model predicted mean residence time (Min)
     tT : Theoretical mean residence time (second-1)
     T: Temperature (0C)
     M: Weight of bed material (kg)
     N: Number of tanks
     N: Data points
     V: Volume of tank (m3)
     Vf: volume of fractional tank (m3)
     x: Fraction of volume (m3)
     Q: Flow rate (kg/hr)
     QFeed : Feed flow rate of coal particles (kg/hr)
     QExtraction: Extraction flow rate of coal particles (kg/hr)
     Q Air : Flow rate of air (kg/hr)
     QSteam: Flow rate of air steam (kg/hr)
     HBed: Bed height (m)
     WBed : Bed weight (kg)
8. Greek Symbols
     τm: Model predicted mean residence time (Min)
     Γ : Gamma function