Candyland Distribution and Channel Management: Faculty: Sir Tabish
Candyland Distribution and Channel Management: Faculty: Sir Tabish
REPORT
DISTRIBUTION AND
CHANNEL MANAGEMENT
Faculty: Sir Tabish
SUBMITTED BY:
KEHKASHAN KHAN 20699
TOOBA KHALID 20161-21172
TAHA AHMED SIDDIQUI 20161-21127
(GROUP LEAD)
NOMAN BURKHANI 20171-22200
SHAHZAIB 20171-21995
Contents
CONFECTIONARY INDUSTRY PAKISTAN..........................................................................................1
Confectionery and Chocolate Industry – An overview:...............................................................................1
Industry Breakdown....................................................................................................................................2
Confectionery and Chocolate Market – An overview..................................................................................5
Understanding The Company......................................................................................................................7
Introduction.............................................................................................................................................7
VISION...................................................................................................................................................8
MISSION................................................................................................................................................8
COPORATE VALUES...........................................................................................................................8
SALES OBJECTIVES............................................................................................................................8
SALES AND MARKETING INTERFACE............................................................................................9
ORGANIZATION’S SALES STRUCTURE ORGANOGRAM.............................................................9
DISTRIBUTORS’ STRUCTURE ORGANOGRAM............................................................................11
Secondary Sales Process............................................................................................................................22
WAREHOUSE AND STOCK MANAGEMENT.....................................................................................23
Primary Sales Ordering.............................................................................................................................26
Secondary Sales Ordering Process............................................................................................................26
Trade and Shopper marketing perspective.................................................................................................26
Occasion...............................................................................................................................................29
Brand....................................................................................................................................................29
Package.................................................................................................................................................29
Price......................................................................................................................................................29
Channel................................................................................................................................................29
Pakistan- Snapshot:
The Islamic Republic of Pakistan is a medium size, densely populated country with over
170 million people living in 796,095 square kilometers. With respect to population and
area, Pakistan stands at no. 7 and no.43 respectively among the nations of the world. It is
located at Southern Asia, bordering the Arabian Sea, between India on the east and Iran
and Afghanistan on the west and China in the north.
During 2010-19 GDP growth has been within the range of 6-8%. Inflation remains the
top concern among the public, jumping from 4.08% in 2017 to 5.08% in 2008, primarily
because of rising world fuel and commodity prices. In addition, the Pakistani rupee has
depreciated significantly as a result of political and economic instability.
The industry can be divided between two broader sectors namely organized sector
(branded segment) and un-organized sectors (generic segment). The branded segment is
more of monopolistic in nature where there are nine prominent, active players in the
competitive landscape of this sector. However, 80% of the industry’s share is being
enjoyed by the five companies listed below. A brief overview of major companies
estimated annual sales in PKR is as follows:
TOTAL 15.41
Billion
PKR
The branded confectionery and chocolate market is highly price elastic and growing with
the bulk of sales concentrated in mid-price range products. Urban markets account for the
major share and for a higher penetration rate. Various retail price points exist within the
mass market segment of chocolates between the range of PKR 3-25. In Sugar
Confectionery major running confectionery items fall into the retail price segment of Rs.
0.50-1.00. The efforts made for the induction of Rs.2 Confectionery unit by industry
giants have gone into vain so far. However, Rs. 2 and 3 are popular price points for lolly
pops and chocolates range. The industry has faced “coin-barrier” issue in sugar
confectionery products at least three times during last three decades when all key players
unanimously agreed to increase their products’ price due to escalating prices of raw
materials (first from 25 paisa to 50 paisa- in mid 80’s, than 50 paisa to Rs. 1 – in mid 90’s
and lastly from Rs.1 to Rs.2-in late 2008) whereby the active players of the industry were
compelled to raise their prices not less than any thing but 100% because next jump to
coin / price denomination was such that they had no way out. It would be interesting for
the readers to learn that such moves however have always been proved to be a “bitter
pill” for the industry as it brought immense resistance from consumers and trade. In some
of the cases decline in sales as a reaction of price increase was so huge that it forced to
leading brands to take their decision back yet they were not able to retrieve their original
volumes again. Mitchell’s Milk Toffees and Kidco 4ever are classic examples. To avoid
and defer this situation (up to last extend) pro-active companies in Pakistani
confectionery industry adopt three kinds of strategies , without reducing or with slightly
reducing trade margins, namely
Reduce the no. of units per pack, unit size, and packaging ( in an endeavour to
reduce cost)
Compromising in product quality by reducing qty and/or quality of expensive raw
material
By using close substitute that is available relatively at cheaper price as a
replacement of expensive raw materials
About (70-80) % sugar confectionery and chocolate sales generate through wholesale
channel depending upon the nature of product and strategies of manufacturing
companies. Almost all but precisely Hilal and B.P rely much on wholesale channel to
generate bulk chunk of their total sales. To support their sales through this channel they
advertise heavily on electronic media to create brand pull for their brands and
subsequently it force retailers to buy these brands from whole sale. The underlying reason
behind limited coverage in retail sector by these two companies is they do not have
premium priced items that could yield sufficient revenues to make retail distribution
viable for their distribution partners so they do a limited coverage in retail sector. Since
these companies themselves do not emphasize on retail penetration so their distributors
also take an escape route and adopt the way of easy selling through WS. However there
are companies like Cadbury, Candyland, Mitchell’s and Mayfair that are fully aware of
the importance of retail penetration .Hence these companies pay due importance and
attention to retail coverage and subsequently allocate resources for retail sector. As
stated earlier the emphasis of Hilal and B.P has always been on building consumer pull
through mass media advertising ( mostly through television) and pushing their brands
through wide-spread network of distributors and wholesalers throughout the nation . This
combination of “Push & Pull “ has proved to be a successful tool in their cases because
the nature of their brands also support this strategy as they produce products of mass
market with as low price as Rs.1 , 2 and beyond. Because of this pricing strategy their
products are equally popular in rural and urban towns among middle and lower middle
class. Candyland and Hilal having this advantage enjoy the benefits of a wide-spread
distribution network in 300+ towns and over 350 distributors nation wide (as they have
more than one distributors in some towns). They always try to adopt cost leadership
strategy and generate revenues through high volumes of sales. Frequent launches, re-
launches, re-introduction of old brands with slight modifications, withdrawals,
adjustments in packaging, product designing and even recipe changes are common
phenomenon in the brands of these two major companies. Contrary to this Cadbury’s and
Mitchell’s believe on establishing brands and brand equity and therefore protection of
quality up to last possible extend remains their top priority.
Introduction
RSM (4)
OB (Multiple)
Merchandiser
(Multiple)
DISTRIBUTORS’ STRUCTURE ORGANOGRAM
14 distribution centers
Providing the product available for delivery to shops from the warehouse
Dist. Exclusive distributors of the company
Target Vs
MOMENTUM
Achievement
Targets are planned on the basis of momentum by examining the progress of target vs
achievement, by DSR, by product, weather conditions etc.
-Two factors are crucial for indication of upcoming month’s target setting:
1) Sales of current month.
2) Sales of the same month in recent year.
Each TSM assigns target to every six section in PJS on the basis of their last month sales
and considering weather conditions. Each section has specific route, there are 5 different
ranges and each ranges possess different categories. DSRs are given targets with respect
to their assigned ranges. Range A possess Jellies and Range B possess Chocolates.
Considering example of Territory: Fb Area, Range A is serve on Monday and its
execution is on Tuesday. Similarly range B is serve on Thursday and its execution is on
Friday.
There are two categories some Territories have one DSR for these two categories and
some have one DSR who caters both categories:
5 Ranges
Category Bubble, candies, chews,chocolates, coated
chews jelly, lollypop,marshmellow, toffee,
A pure chocolate
5 Ranges
Category jelly, lollypop,marshmellow, toffee, pure
chocolate
Targets are assigned to DSRs in terms of cartons on monthly basis and his visited
schedule pops and productive calls are maintained on daily basis.
MONITORING OF ACHIEVEMENTS
Two types of online dashboard tool are being used for achievements’ monitoring given
below, where manager can monitor sales with respect to brand, category share, ranges,
territories and by time :
DISTRIBUTION
DSS
CLICK
VIEW
ANALYSIS REPORTS
-By brand
-By day
- By same day of periods
-By category
-By DSR performance
-By Range
3.5 Number of distributors in Pakistan with their business contribution
Candyland has a vast distribution network which has been set up through extensive
planning and strategic efforts over many years. It has more than 415 cities and towns are
covered through direct and indirect distribution via their extensive distribution network.
The company has 5 satellite warehouses, in addition to factory warehouses, which are
located at Hyderabad, Multan, Lahore, Faisalabad and Rawalpindi. These satellite
warehouses provide Ismail Industries Limited significant flexibility to adjust to short-
term fluctuations in demand due to seasonality, holidays, weather conditions. It possess
more than 1200 distributors amongst which 12 belongs to Karachi. During the course of
interview RSM excused us in providing the insights about the distributor’s contribution
margin and their ROI.
The above enunciated point of purchase relating KPIs which is directly dependent on
distributor’s performance, help managing the distributors to maintain the KPIs of the
company and their progress can be evaluated on basis of each KPI which helps sales team
to fill the gap where the observe any shortcoming or loop holes by providing the
appropriate incentives to the DSR considering the changing situations. This DSS system
also help looking at zonal view and evaluate the performance of the complete zone with
the help of click view. The performance of zone can be evaluated on the basis of brand
performance or distributor performance on basis of 5key performance indicators shown
below:
ZONE OVERVIEW
ZONE
Brand Distributor
Performance Performance
-Volume -Volume
-Callmade -Callmade
-Drop Size -Drop Size
-SKU per bill -SKU per bill
-Productivity -Productivity
3.7 Distributors ROI calculation
During the course of interview RSM refused to provide any insight regarding any of the
distributor’s ROI.
Modes of transportation:
The Modes of transportation used by the company and the distributor are Suzuki van,
Mini van, Rikshaw and Trailer
It help to commute within the city and to other city as well. They Cater all General and
Modern trade.
National footprint:
Candlyland operate all over Pakistan. It operate using following resources
1400+ Vans
1200+ Distributor
135,000 Outlet
10 Production facility
3000+ Sales force
It cover 400+ Towns
5 Regional sales office
400,000 weekly sales call
Route to market:
Order booker visit to the market and follows the following steps:
OrderBooker goes on his assigned PJP route after morning meeting, keeping his
monthly targets aligned with his daily sales
Greets customers Identifies the available stock in the godown of each shop
Proposes the customers to order the unavailable SKUs and new flavors, if any
Completes his shops as per the PJP and with the DMS(Distribution Management
System), ERP system
Shop wise bills are printed
The process of market return is conducted when a company takes responsibility for the
fault in its products upon claiming. The market return is further classified into:
Fault in products can be Melting due to excessive heat, Damage while distribution or
Minor production faults. In such cases, the Actual market return doesn’t take place
because AMR is not functional and doesn’t happen in most cases. The process of AMR
mostly takes place in Pharmaceutical companies and 99% of these companies provide an
actual market return. If there is a loss or fault in your product, you can return it upon
claiming to the company and through a systematic process the company caters to your
needs. Candyland is a confectionery industry and no such processes of Actual Market
Return take place here. But for trusted distributors who have been with the company for a
long time, to honor the relationship, the company sometimes pays from their own pocket.
They ask the distributor to discard the loss and charge them from the company’s pocket.
But if there isn’t a relationship between the two, you are charged as usual.
Mouse cut: A concept that is mostly applicable in confectionery industries. Mouse cut
happens when food items are attacked by mice, insects and they tend to destroy food
items. Candyland doesn’t take responsibility if such a case of mouse cut occurs. They
urge their customers to take preventive measures and ask them to discard the products.
Therefore Market return is dependant upon the type of relationship the distributor has
with the company. The percentage of return is high when you’re a loyal customer and
have been with the company for a long time. The company values its relationships and
provides incentives and partial refunds to its esteemed clients.
Types of Claims:
Claims are the rights provided by the company to the distributor. They fall under the
category of market return, the distributor is given a right to ask for a partial refund called
a Rebate or a certain percentage of a quota of the occurred damage. Following are the
types of claims that the distributor can ask for:
Damages on in-voice: If there are any damages that occur in the product, it is settled on
the invoice.
Rental Trade: We negotiate trade and offer trade prices. Depending strictly upon the
headcount.
Profit and loss: Candyland does not follow the profit and loss claim.
Settlement Process:
After distributor files for a claim for market return. These claims are submitted in
Candyland’s head office. A team of experts deals with catering to all claims and deciding
what to offer in return respectively. The settlement process happens all year long.
Candyland typically follows the ‘n-1’ strategy. Where they focus on last month’s claims.
For example, if a distributor claimed in April, he will get a response in May. A proper
checklist is maintained and recorded so no claims get unnoticed. Furthermore, to keep a
progress check, tracker reports are present. These reports track and provide the needed
information to the company. These settlement processes depend upon the type of claims
and the kind of relationship the distributor has with the company.
Credit Management:
Credit is defined as the return on investment that you receive when you invest your
money in trade. Every end of the month, the company calculates the percentage of credit
from the total infrastructure. Candyland usually has a credit of 20-30%. The wholesale
industry is credit dominated and providing credit they are able to generate sales and
products are sold in the market. Credit management in the confectionery industry is the
lowest because of the majority in sales of ‘kachay items’. These items are low in quality
and are available at local shops at a throw-away price. These items prevent sales and put
Candyland at risk in terms of sales. Kachay items may include replicas or Fanty and
Chilli Milli priced at rupees 1 and 2. The only issue that comes at hand is the difference
in quality. Therefore, Candyland is an ISO certified company and if they provide
products of better quality and own up to their severe batch-faults to offer a premium
service to their customers.
How the process starts is when the distributor has placed in an order now that order
fulfillment process starts when the purchase order is generated by the company and then
then distributor has to fulfill the payment requirements for the order and then thus order
dispatch date and the amount of the required SKUs is generated .After that it is the job of
the order booker what is his order requirements accordingly and updates it on his
handheld devices.
Today, almost all leading manufacturers have a trade marketing function in their
business. But this fact alone does not mean that all businesses have a common
understanding of trade marketing. Indeed, one of my colleagues urged me to check-out
the definition of trade marketing on Wikipedia; the long, rambling and incoherent
‘definition’ is accompanied by a request for help in improving it!
There’s no doubt that in most companies the support of trade marketers is valued by their
colleagues in sales and marketing. But different companies seem to have different
requirements of their trade marketers. For some it’s a strategic stand-alone function, for
others it’s an administrative support function. Indeed, there appear to be four common
forms of trade marketing in operation globally, all with quite different roles and
responsibilities. As a result, for many companies trade marketing is the sum of its
activities.
No surprise then that with the advent of the term ‘Shopper Marketing’ over the last
decade we have seen many managers rebranding trade marketing as shopper marketing.
Shopper marketing with respect to Candyland is more about vibrant colors and attracting
the younger generation sold to purchase their products that is why they certainly have an
edge over creative marketing with their tactics to ace the best results in terms of brand
marketing.
They have always stood out in terms of their SKUs from their food segments. The most
revenue generated is from must have Skoshes must have skus are different for each
segment even in each segment there is a variety of must have SKUS.
The visibility of the product on racks ,basically eye level is where their premium brand
that is novella is placed, Then as we look at lower levels of the racks we crown and
paradise. They are different packing wise as well they are small chocolates.
MERCHANDISING TEAM
Head Of Modern
Key account
MERCHANDISING TOOLS
SHELF GONDOLAS
TALKERS POSTERS GONDOLAS
The confectionary market is not restricted to racks but also hot selling areas like podiums
placed in the middle new product choc-oh. Then as we look at lower levels of the racks
we crown and paradise,they are SKU wise as well they are bite size chocolates skus per
brand differs,sku differs as placement is different
Each store has a different planogram for eg has by category usually IMTs are category
based , It also depends on each company and what it ahs paid for ,if candly land pays
heavily to a store it might get the entire shelve legally By company as well,like
candyland is given entire shelf depends on contract as well that what is based in the
contract
OBPPC
Our OBPPC (Occasion, Brand, Package, Price and Channel) strategy offers people the
right product, in the right pack, at the right price to suit the occasion.
We’ve established clear category and brand priorities, offering consumers the right
product, in the right pack, at the right price to suit the occasion: we call this our OBPPC
(Occasion, Brand, Package, Price and Channel) strategy.
Well-executed OBPPC strategies mean that we have an offering to suit every shopper’s
need. This, in turn, helps us to capture people’s disposable income faster than our
competitors. Being innovative around the occasions when people enjoy our brands allows
us to tap into less price-oriented shopping trips, so growing our revenue ahead of volume.
Occasion
Candyland provides a variety of products to match shopper needs in every channel and
for every occasion. We make sure that we link our brands and packs to the most relevant
occasions to drive incremental transactions.
Brand
We offer consumers a broad choice of brands in different categories. People can
choose from one bite chocolates to giant bars , such as the legendary Novella and other
popular brands like Now and Fanty.
Package
Our products come in an increasingly diverse range of packaging which is designed to
reflect today’s diverse lifestyles., while family multi-packs help people celebrate special
occasions at home. Premium consumers will enjoy the feel of our brands at imts,lmts and
GT.
Price
Affordability considerations are key in our offer. The ambition is to match our offer to
different consumer needs and opportunities.
Channel
Huge hypermarket, discounter, restaurant or the small convenience store next door - we
have the right product range for every channel. Our rich knowledge of shopping patterns
lets us understand different shoppers’ motivations across different channels. As a result
of this, and our longstanding cooperation with different customers, we’ve designed our
portfolio so that our customers are satisfied by having the right product range people are
looking for in their outlets
RECOMMENDATIONS
● PLACEMENT NEEDS TO IMPROVE
● PRODUCT VISIBILITY
● PRODUCT PROMOTIONS