Benefits of Physical Exercise For Older Adults With Alzheimer's Disease
Benefits of Physical Exercise For Older Adults With Alzheimer's Disease
The physical and mental benefits of exercise         evidence on the benefits of exercise on the health
are widely known but seldom available to per-        and functioning of older adults with cognitive dis-
sons suffering from Alzheimer’s disease (AD).        orders, the available literature lacks clinical evi-
This article presents information on the po-         dence that supports recommendations for
tential benefits of physical exercise for people     exercise guidelines in people with AD.5 This arti-
with AD, discussing some of the metabolic            cle describes the main symptoms of AD and the
and neuropathological changes regarded as            possible benefits of exercise for this disease. It
underlying causes of AD, as well as some of          also reviews the major studies that have exam-
the psychological and organic abnormalities          ined the influence of exercise in patients with
that can be modified through exercise. The           AD and provides basic exercise guidelines for
extent to which physical exercise programs           older adults with dementia.
can play a role in the treatment of AD is ad-
dressed in the second part of the article, de-
scribing the most relevant clinical studies in       Potential Benefits of Physical
this field. Finally, the article provides informa-   Exercise in Alzheimer’s Disease
tion about how to prescribe physical exercise
for AD patients, mainly by giving examples of          Benefits of exercise in AD patients can be ex-
structured physical programs designed for            plained through 3 pathways. First, some meta-
older adults with dementia. (Geriatr Nurs            bolic and neuropathological changes, regarded
2008;29:384-391)                                     as underlying causes of AD, can be modified in
                                                     some way through exercising. Second, some psy-
                                                     chological and organic abnormalities that accom-
        lzheimer’s disease (AD), the most com-
                                         Table 1.
                                            Physical interventions programs with early to early-moderate AD patients.
                                            Study     N         Intervention                Frequency          Volumen/Intensity           Interventionist          Outcomes
                                         Namazi       11 Mobility (joint             Daily sessions for     20 min/8 rpt per          Specialized fitness    Reduced agitated
                                          et al.38         movements and               7 weeks                exercise.                 instructor             behaviors
                                                           stretching); Light                                 20 min/8 rpt per
                                                           exercise movement                                  exercise
                                                           tasks (walk, sit and
                                                           stand, etc.)
                                         Palleschi    15 Aerobic: Cycling            Thrice-weekly-         20 min at 70% of          Not described          Improved attention,
                                           et al.39        on arms only                sessions, during       maximal heart rate                               verbal and cognitive
                                                           stationary bike             3 months.                                                               capabilitites
                                         Arkin30      11 Flexibility (stretching);   Twice-weekly-          2 rpt of 15 for 10 min;    University            Significant
                                                           Aerobic (walking on         sessions, plus         5 min with weekly          students              improvements in
                                                           treadmill, cycling on       a weekly               increases of 1 min until                         aerobic capacity,
                                                           stationary bike);           volunteer-work         reach 20 min (treadmill                          muscular strength, and
                                                           Strength                    out, during a year     set at one mile/hour). 2                         mood
                                                           (strengthening large                               sets of
                                                           muscle groups using                                10-12 rpt, resting
                                                           MedX weight                                        30 min (weights
                                                           machines)                                          increased by 2-5
                                                                                                              pounds)
                                         Rolland      23 Aerobic: Walking            A mean of 7            Main daily duration of     Caregivers            Improved nutritional
                                           et al.40        and cycling                 (5-12) weeks           exercise was 35 min                              staturs and cognitive
                                                                                                              (10-80 min). Intensity                           function; Less frequent
Geriatric Nursing, Volume 29, Number 6
                                         Teri et al.47 76 Same as above                    Same as above            Same as above           Same as above   Increased levels of
                                                                                                                                                              physical activity,
                                                                                                                                                              physical function and
                                                                                                                                                              health; Decreased
                                                                                                                                                              levels of depression
                                         Rolland       56 Aerobic (walking);               Twice-weekly-            Moderate walking         Occupational   Slower progressive
                                           et al.48         Strength (callisthenic          sessions held in          up to 30 min.            therapist      deterioration in ADLs
                                                            movements);                     groups of 2-7             Individualized
                                                            Flexibility(stretching);        people for                intensity; Total
                                                            Balance (small step             12 weeks                  volume of each
                                                            trials)                                                   session: 60 min
                                         Arkin49       24 Balance; Flexibility;            Two-weekly-sessions,     20-30 min of moderate    University     Significant fitness and
                                                            Aerobic (treadmill              plus one voluntary        walking/cycling,         students/      mood gains; no effect
                                                            and stationary bike);           session of brisk          combined with            Family         in behavioural
                                                            Strength (weight                walking, for 2-8          cognitive stimulation;   member         disturbances,
                                                            resistance machines)            semesters                 20-30 min of upper-                     depression or
                                                                                                                      lower body strength on                  nutritional scores
                                                                                                                      5 machines
                                         Williams  90* Aerobic group                       5 individual sessions    Walking at normal        Graduate       Improvements in affect
                                          and            (walking), vs.                       a week for 16 weeks     pace up to 30 min; 30    nursing/       and mood (especially
                                          Tappen50       Comprehensive                                                min; (walking up to      Physical       in the comprehensive
                                                         exercise group:                                              20 min);                 therapy        exercise group)
                                                         Strength (callisthenic                                       3-9 rpt per exercise     students
                                                         movements); Balance
                                                         (side stepping);
                                                         Flexibility; Aerobic
                                                         (walking)
                                         * 44% of the sample rated as severely impaired patients.
                                         rpt5repetitions;
                                         ADls5activities of daily living.
387
motor cortices36 and activating endogenous ho-                performance.41,42 However, similar interventions
meostatic mechanisms that counteract the ongo-                did not confirm this beneficial effect,43,44 and the
ing neurodegenerative process.37 However,                     issue remains controversial.
although these results are remarkable, the appli-                Because AD patients are sometimes cared for
cability of studies using animal models human                 by family members, teaching caregivers to facili-
conditions is unknown, and further research is                tate and supervise exercise activity has been re-
needed.                                                       garded as a useful solution.45 In this regard,
                                                              a community-based program designed to in-
Clinically Relevant Studies                                   crease balance, flexibility, strength, and endur-
                                                              ance in AD patients guided by their caregivers
   Despite the growing evidence showing that                  has shown important and beneficial effects.46
physical exercise can be an appropriate nonphar-              Moreover, follow-up research that included a con-
macological strategy in the treatment of AD pa-               trol group and tested a larger sample showed that
tients, few studies have focused on the benefits              AD patients who trained with their caregivers
of exercise in AD, and some of those available                were more active, improved their physical func-
have serious methodological flaws. For instance,              tion and affective status, and had fewer depres-
several studies have confirmed the efficacy of                sive symptoms.47
aerobic and weight-training sessions in reducing                 It is important to note, however, that care-
agitated behavior,38 improving cognitive func-                givers are sometimes elderly and unlikely to
tion, and reducing the risk of falls,39,40 as well            seek out structured exercise programs. There-
as improving mood and fitness level.30 However,               fore, it is necessary to include specialized person-
the samples sizes were small, interventions in                nel to guide the training sessions or to take part in
some cases were short, and some studies did                   long-term exercise programs carried out in nurs-
not include a control group (Table 1).                        ing homes. Clinically relevant studies have
   In well-controlled studies (Table 2), walking,             shown that following this trend, more complex
whether alone or combined with cognitive                      exercise training programs, resulting in fitness
stimulation, was shown to be an appropriate                   and mood improvements, can be carried out
intervention for improving communication                      with AD patients.48-50
 Table 2.
      Effects of walking alone or combined with conversation, versus only
      conversation in AD patients
       Study                 N (n)       Intervention                 Outcomes                 Conclusion
                   41
 Friedman et al.        30           Walking for 30        Improvement in             A conversation only
                                      minutes, three times   communication              group, did not get
                                      a week, for 10 weeks   skills                     a higher
                                                                                        improvement
 Tappen et al.42        71 (261/212) Walking (assisted1 or     Improved adherence     Walking while talking,
                                      combined with              to exercise sessions   is a better
                                      conversation2) for 30      and less functional    intervention than
                                      minutes, three times       decline in combined    assisted walking
                                      a week, for 16 weeks       group                  alone
 Sobel43                50           One 20-minute session     No effect on language Playing Bingo (20’)
                                      of walking or arm          ability and verbal     induced a significant
                                      and leg extension          recognition            improvement than
                                                                                        did physical activiy.
 Cott et all.44         74 (30)      Talking while walking     No significant         Walking did no better
                                       in pairs for 30           differences in         than talking 5 days
                                       minutes three times       communication          a week, for 16 weeks
                                       a week for 16 weeks       skills
 Table 3.
    Structure of a typical exercise session designed for demented older adults
             Activity                             Objective                               Example