Scribd
Upload
26 views1 page

Ÿ D, Ijk Ilmmnoppqrmlstntumv Wxy ZW (Qy U/Zpqn) - 'P) - 'At (/BQRCRJK

- Amalia is scorned by the villagers for rejecting Portinari's marriage proposal, seeing her as proud and scandalous. However, her perspective is that true superiority lies in recognizing the mediated nature of desire, primarily seen in Dante's novels. - The same historical forces that led to the evolution of a market economy also compelled the discovery of the imitative basis of desire, undermining the premise of individualism. Amalia understands too well the mechanics of rivalry and finds relief only in solitude, seeing through the official attraction of the officials. - The villagers demonize Amalia because her freedom exposes the arbitrary nature of their social existence. She sees that village life is based on the same mimicry as

Uploaded by

mangalvao2009
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
26 views1 page

Ÿ D, Ijk Ilmmnoppqrmlstntumv Wxy ZW (Qy U/Zpqn) - 'P) - 'At (/BQRCRJK

- Amalia is scorned by the villagers for rejecting Portinari's marriage proposal, seeing her as proud and scandalous. However, her perspective is that true superiority lies in recognizing the mediated nature of desire, primarily seen in Dante's novels. - The same historical forces that led to the evolution of a market economy also compelled the discovery of the imitative basis of desire, undermining the premise of individualism. Amalia understands too well the mechanics of rivalry and finds relief only in solitude, seeing through the official attraction of the officials. - The villagers demonize Amalia because her freedom exposes the arbitrary nature of their social existence. She sees that village life is based on the same mimicry as

Uploaded by

mangalvao2009
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

0123425353 678ÿ

8 ÿÿ
8 ÿ ÿ  ÿ678ÿ 8ÿÿ 78 ÿÿ ÿ5ÿ! ÿ5303

%&'(%)'*%+),-ÿ/0%1ÿ'2*0+3%4'*%+)ÿ%1ÿ)56511'37ÿ8+3ÿ'ÿ1+6%5*7ÿ92%:*ÿ+)ÿ*05ÿ;3%)6%;:5ÿ+8ÿ%)<%=%<2':ÿ<%88535)65-ÿ>3+*51*')*%1&
;%+)5531ÿ*05ÿ5(':%*'3%')ÿ65)*3':%*7ÿ+8ÿ*05ÿ%)*53)':ÿ165)5?ÿ92*ÿ%*ÿ8%)<1ÿ%*1ÿ<58%)%*%=5ÿ&+<53)ÿ5@;3511%+)ÿ%)ÿA+&')*%6
%)<%=%<2':%1&-
B+C5=53?ÿ*05ÿ1'&5ÿ0%1*+3%6':ÿ8+3651ÿ*0'*ÿ:5<ÿ*+ÿA+&')*%6%1&ÿD%-5-?ÿ*05ÿ5=+:2*%+)ÿ+8ÿ'ÿ&'3E5*ÿ56+)+&7,ÿ':1+ÿ%&;5::5<ÿ*05
<%16+=537ÿ+8ÿ*05ÿ%&%*'*%=5ÿ9'1%1ÿ+8ÿ<51%35?ÿ;3%&'3%:7ÿ%)ÿ*05ÿ)+=5:1ÿ+8ÿ8%(2351ÿ1260ÿ'1ÿF:'2953*ÿ')<ÿG+1*+5=1E7H'ÿ<%16+=537
*0'*ÿ3'<%6'::7ÿ2)<53&%)51ÿ*05ÿ;35&%15ÿ+8ÿ%)<%=%<2':%1&-ÿD,IJK
ILMMNOPPQRMLSTNTUMVWXYZW[QYU\ZPQN]^_`P]^_`aT[\bQRcRJKÿB+Cÿ6')ÿ*05ÿ15:8ÿ95ÿ*32:7ÿ2)%d25ÿC05)ÿ%*ÿ35&'%)1ÿ%)
6+&;5*%*%=5ÿ<5;5)<5)65ÿ2;+)ÿ%*1ÿ3%=':1eÿ/0%1ÿ%1ÿ;+11%9:5ÿ+):7ÿ*+ÿ*05ÿ5@*5)*ÿ*0'*ÿ*05ÿ%)<%=%<2':ÿ%1ÿ'9:5ÿ*+ÿ356+()%45ÿ*05
&5<%'*5<ÿ)'*235ÿ+8ÿ<51%35?ÿ%)6:2<%)(ÿ053ÿ+C)-ÿf&':%'g1ÿ35h56*%+)ÿ+8ÿi+3*%)%g1ÿ;3+;+1':ÿ%1ÿ9'15<ÿ+)ÿ053ÿ%)1%(0*ÿ%)*+ÿ*05ÿ%::21+37
)'*235ÿ+8ÿ*05ÿj'1*:5g1ÿ'2*0+3%*7-ÿA5&5&953ÿk:('g1ÿ6+&&5)*lÿmi05ÿ1*++<ÿ8'65ÿ*+ÿ8'65ÿC%*0ÿ*05ÿ*32*0ÿ')<ÿC5)*ÿ+)ÿ:%=%)(ÿ')<
5)<235<ÿ053ÿ:%85ÿ*05)ÿ'1ÿ)+CnÿDopo,-ÿj+)83+)*%)(ÿ*05ÿ*32*0ÿ+8ÿ<51%35ÿ%1ÿ053+%6ÿ956'215ÿ*0%1ÿ*32*0ÿ%1ÿ6+33+1%=5ÿ*+ÿ053ÿ%<5)*%*7
')<ÿ1+6%':ÿ5@%1*5)65-ÿf)ÿ%)<%=%<2':%1&ÿ*0'*ÿ356+()%451ÿ*05ÿ%&;+11%9%:%*7ÿ+8ÿ'2*+)+&7ÿ(%=51ÿ9%3*0ÿ*+ÿ')ÿ'**%*2<5ÿ'E%)ÿ*+
A+&')*%6ÿ%3+)7?ÿ')ÿ%3+)%6?ÿ15:8q6+)16%+21ÿ15)15ÿ+8ÿ%<5)*%*7-
f&':%'g1ÿ15)15ÿ+8ÿ12;53%+3%*7?ÿ:%E5ÿi+63'*51g?ÿ%1ÿ6:5'3:7ÿ&'3E5<ÿ97ÿ%3+)7-ÿk:('ÿ35&'3E1ÿ*0'*ÿf&':%'ÿ%1ÿ0'3<ÿ*+ÿ<56%;053
956'215ÿm+8*5)ÿ+)5ÿ6')g*ÿ*5::ÿC05*053ÿ105g1ÿ1;5'E%)(ÿ%3+)%6'::7ÿ+3ÿ%)ÿ5'3)51*nÿDorr,sÿf&':%'ÿ%1ÿ;3+9'9:7ÿ<+%)(ÿ9+*0ÿ'*ÿ*05
1'&5ÿ*%&5-ÿ/325ÿ12;53%+3%*7ÿC+2:<ÿ0'=5ÿ*+ÿ95ÿ9'15<ÿ+)ÿ*05ÿ356+()%*%+)ÿ*0'*ÿ)+ÿ+)5ÿ%1ÿ*32:7ÿ2)%d25ÿ')<ÿ'2*+)+&+21-ÿt=5)
*05ÿ35h56*%+)ÿ+8ÿ<51%35ÿ6')ÿ95ÿ2)<531*++<ÿ'1ÿ'ÿ&%&5*%6ÿ35=531':?ÿ'1ÿk:('ÿ%)*53;35*1ÿf&':%'g1ÿ35821':ÿ+8ÿi+3*%)%?ÿ'ÿ(51*235
C0%60?ÿ%)ÿ%*1ÿ823%+21ÿ;'11%+)?ÿ%)<55<ÿ35=5':1ÿf&':%'ÿ'1ÿ%)*5)15:7ÿ&%&5*%6-ÿu8ÿf&':%'ÿ2)<531*')<1ÿ*0'*ÿ105ÿ%1ÿ'6*2'::7ÿh21*ÿ:%E5
5=537+)5ÿ5:15?ÿC0%:5ÿ'*ÿ*05ÿ1'&5ÿ*%&5ÿ5=537+)5ÿ%)1%1*1ÿ*0'*ÿ105ÿ%1ÿ1;56%':ÿ')<ÿ<%88535)*?ÿ'1ÿ+)ÿ*05ÿ<'7ÿ+8ÿ*05ÿ8'%3?ÿ*05)ÿ105
&'7ÿC5::ÿ0'=5ÿ<5=5:+;5<ÿ')ÿ'62*5ÿ%)1%(0*ÿ%)*+ÿ*05ÿ&560')%61ÿ+8ÿ<51%35-ÿ/0%1ÿ%)1%(0*ÿ%1ÿ*05ÿ9'1%1ÿ+8ÿ053ÿ':++8ÿ('45?ÿC0%60
mC'1ÿ)5=53ÿ:5=5:5<ÿ5@'6*:7ÿ+)ÿ*05ÿ+9h56*ÿ105ÿC'1ÿ:++E%)(ÿ'*?ÿ92*ÿ%)ÿ1+&5ÿ<%1*239%)(ÿC'7ÿ':C'71ÿ'ÿ:%**:5ÿ;'1*ÿ%*nÿDovw,-ÿu)
+*053ÿC+3<1?ÿf&':%'ÿ%1ÿ)5=53ÿ5@'6*:7ÿ:++E%)(ÿ'*ÿC0'*ÿ105ÿ%1ÿ:++E%)(ÿ'*-ÿB53ÿ;531;56*%=5ÿ%1ÿ5115)*%'::7ÿ%3+)%6-ÿx-ÿ'**3%92*51ÿ053
%3+)%6ÿ('45ÿ*+ÿm'ÿ;531%1*5)*ÿ')<ÿ<+&%)'*%)(ÿ<51%35ÿ8+3ÿ%1+:'*%+)nÿDovw,-ÿ>356%15:7ÿ956'215ÿ105ÿ%1ÿ1+ÿ%)*5)15:7ÿ&%&5*%6?ÿf&':%'
2)<531*')<1ÿ*++ÿC5::ÿ*05ÿ&560')%1&ÿ+8ÿ3%=':37sÿ105ÿ8%)<1ÿ35:%58ÿ+):7ÿ%)ÿ1+:%*2<5?ÿ'ÿ351*%)(ÿ%)ÿ*05ÿ1'63':%*7ÿ+8ÿ*05ÿ%)*53)':
165)5-
A+953*+ÿj':'11+?ÿ')ÿ'1*2*5ÿ35'<53ÿ+8ÿx'8E'?ÿC3%*51?ÿm>530';1ÿ%*ÿ%1ÿ;356%15:7ÿyf&':%'g1zÿ':++8)511ÿ*0'*ÿ1*3%E51ÿi+3*%)%nÿDwv,
')<ÿ&+*%='*51ÿ0%1ÿ(':=')%6ÿ:5';ÿ3%(0*ÿ+=53ÿ*05ÿ10'8*ÿ+8ÿ*05ÿ8%35ÿ5)(%)5?ÿ5=5)ÿm*0+2(0ÿ0%1ÿ:5(1ÿC535ÿ1*%88ÿ83+&ÿC+3E%)(ÿ'*
<51E1nÿDx'8E'ÿo{r,-ÿ|0'*ÿ'**3'6*1ÿi+3*%)%ÿ&%&5*%6'::7ÿ%1ÿ053ÿ2)'='%:'9%:%*7?ÿ053ÿ155&%)(ÿ%&&2)%*7ÿ*+ÿ<51%35?ÿ053ÿ%)*53)':%45<
1'63':%*7?ÿC0%60ÿ%1ÿ%)ÿ8'6*ÿ'ÿ3%=':ÿ*+ÿ*05ÿj'1*:5g1-ÿf&':%'ÿ%1ÿ16')<':+21ÿ*+ÿi+3*%)%ÿ5=5)ÿ958+35ÿ105ÿ*5'31ÿ2;ÿ0%1ÿ;3+;+1':
956'215ÿ105ÿ<+51)g*ÿ155&ÿ*+ÿ)55<ÿ')7+)5-ÿf&':%'ÿ0'1ÿ155)ÿ%)*+ÿ*05ÿ&%&5*%6ÿ9'1%1ÿ+8ÿ*05ÿ+88%6%':1gÿ'**3'6*%+)?ÿ')<ÿ105
1%&;:7ÿ3582151ÿ*+ÿ;:'7ÿ*05ÿ('&5?ÿ'ÿ('&5ÿ*0'*ÿ%1ÿ*05ÿ9'1%1ÿ+8ÿ=%::'(5ÿ:%85-
/05ÿ=%::'(5ÿ<5&+)%451ÿf&':%'ÿ956'215ÿ053ÿ16')<':+21ÿ8355<+&ÿ5@;+151ÿ*05ÿj'1*:5ÿm35:%(%+)nÿ'1ÿ&535ÿ%<+:'*37-ÿu8ÿf&':%'ÿ%1
3%(0*?ÿ*05)ÿ*05ÿ351*ÿ+8ÿ*05ÿ=%::'(5ÿ&21*ÿ95ÿC3+)(-ÿj':'11+ÿ6+&&5)*1ÿ%)1%(0*82::7?ÿmf&5:%'g1ÿ(51*235ÿ%1ÿ*05358+35ÿ1+&5*0%)(
*0'*ÿ;3+8+2)<:7ÿ2)0%)(51ÿ*05ÿ+3<53ÿ+8ÿ*0%)(1?ÿ1+&5*0%)(ÿ*0'*ÿ<5)%51ÿ*05ÿ=537ÿ8+2)<'*%+)ÿ+8ÿ=%::'(5ÿ:%85lÿ*05ÿ%3351%1*%9:5
'**3'6*%+)ÿ*+ÿ')7*0%)(ÿ*0'*ÿ5&')'*51ÿ83+&ÿ*05ÿj'1*:5H')<ÿ'9+=5ÿ'::ÿ%*1ÿ+88%6%':1nÿDw},-ÿD,I]_K
ILMMNOPPQRMLSTNTUMVWXYZW[QYU\ZPQN]^_`P]^_`aT[\bQRcR]_KÿF3%5<'ÿ')<ÿ*05ÿ:')<:'<7g1ÿ5@'((53'*5<ÿ0'*35<ÿ+8
f&':%'ÿ')<ÿ053ÿ8'&%:7ÿ%1ÿ%)6+&;3505)1%9:5ÿ2):511ÿC5ÿ356+()%45ÿ*0'*ÿ105ÿ35;3515)*1ÿ'ÿ*035'*ÿ*+ÿ*05%3ÿ%<5)*%*7ÿ'*ÿ%*1ÿ=537ÿ6+35-

78 " 8#"2 043520435#$ 2 00201

You might also like