Women Sucide Bombers
Women Sucide Bombers
Edmar Salem
              To cite this article: Edmar Salem (2015) Attitudes towards female suicide bombers in Palestine
              and Tamil Sri Lanka, Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression, 7:3, 200-209,
              DOI: 10.1080/19434472.2015.1009482
                                                                Although female suicide bombing has been occurring since the mid-1980s, in
Downloaded by [LMU Muenchen] at 07:14 11 January 2016
                                                        Introduction
                                                        There are two factors which have inspired the emergence of this pilot study. First, there
                                                        is a claim that women have significantly carried out suicide attacks on behalf of groups
                                                        operating in the Palestinian territories and Tamil Sri Lanka. According to Yaregal
                                                        (2011), after Wafa Idris’ mission on 27 January 2002, almost 30% of Palestinian
                                                        suicide operatives have been women. In 2012, it has been suggested by The Times of
                                                        Israel that ‘for the first time’ Hamas has set up an all-female suicide unit, ready to con-
                                                        front government policies by targeting buses or cafes in Israel (Miller, 2012). Similarly,
                                                        in the Tamil context, Rajan (2012) estimated that female participation in suicide
                                                        bombing is close to 50%. Research by the US Army and Training Doctrine
                                                        Command (2006) has further revealed that after 21 May 1991, roughly 20% of
                                                        LTTE (Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam) female suicide attacks were perpetrated
                                                        against high-rank officials, compared to 4% of male suicide attacks which targeted
                                                        public figures. Second, part of the reason why there has been a breadth of female
                                                        suicide bombing in those contexts is because of the ways women operatives are glor-
                                                        ified in their respective societies. Marway (2011), for example, is a strong proponent of
                                                        ∗
                                                            Email: edmar.salem@buckingham.ac.uk
                                                        this view, who suggested that media projections in those regions typically present the
                                                        characteristics of women bombers in highly mythical terms, describing their ‘martyr-
                                                        dom’ as even more heroic than men who perpetrate the same acts. The implication
                                                        of this hypothesis is that women are becoming more involved in suicide terrorism
                                                        because there is widespread approval for this phenomenon among the constituencies
                                                        this violence represents. Yet despite the breadth of female suicide missions and the
                                                        impact cultural depictions seem to have on public opinion, very few attempts have
                                                        studied how people in the terrorists’ constituencies actually feel about the employment
                                                        of women bombers.
                                                            Studying public attitudes towards female suicide bombing is important for two
                                                        reasons. First, some scholars have indicated that female-initiated missions elicit
                                                        much more passionate responses from their constituencies than male-initiated missions
                                                        (Avraham, 2014; Bloom, 2011; Cunningham, 2012; Dearing, 2009; Marway, 2011;
                                                        Nacos, 2005; Ponzanesi, 2014; Rajan, 2012; Schweitzer, 2006; Sutten, 2009;
Downloaded by [LMU Muenchen] at 07:14 11 January 2016
                                                           Perhaps you were born in the same city, the same neighbourhood and in the same house.
                                                           Perhaps you ate from the same plate or drunk from the same cup, the water flowing
                                                           through the veins of the holy city and who placed a child in Mary’s womb. Perhaps
                                                           the same holy spirit placed the martyr Wafa Idris and enveloped her pure body with dyna-
                                                           mite. From Mary’s womb issued this martyr who eliminated oppression while the body of
                                                           Wafa became shrapnel that eliminated despair and aroused hope. (Alvanou, 2007, p. 17)
                                                        The problem with these representations, according to some scholars, is that they largely
                                                        ignore the apolitical aspects which might have motivated the women to act (Cunning-
                                                        ham, 2012; Nacos, 2005; Ponzanesi, 2014). Indeed, research into the personal lives of
                                                        female bombers suggests that women are often compelled to forsake their lives once
                                                        they deviate away from patriarchal norms. In this sense, female suicide bombers
                                                        operate out of ‘shame’ and ‘dishonour’ in order to redeem fallen reputations, such as
                                                        being barren, divorced, defiled, unchaste, and so on (Avraham, 2014; Beining &
                                                        Evans, 2014; Dearing, 2009; O’Rourke, 2009; Sofer & Addison, 2012; WPSU,
                                                        2012). Most arguably, terrorists and their supporters expunge such information when
                                                        generating propaganda, to avoid losing the wider support of their constituencies. To
                                                        that end, existing research regarding the attitudes of people towards female-initiated
                                                        bombing demands further investigation. Assessing attitudes towards female partici-
                                                        pation in suicide terrorism can help us determine whether theoretical assumptions are
                                                        accurate about the widespread perceptions of the people represented by women
                                                        bombers.
                                                            The second reason why studying public attitudes towards female suicide bombing is
                                                        important is because there is a significant gap in the literature with regard to postulating
                                                        the way a society perceives women bombers through sufficient empirical evidence.
                                                        Indeed, upon examining the literature, a very small percentage of researchers have
                                                        202                                     E. Salem
                                                        based their generalisations on data obtained from primary or quantitative methods, such
                                                        as surveys administered to sample sets of the people in the geographies where female
                                                        suicide bombing is a feature. Instead, much of the generalisations expressed tend to be
                                                        drawn from secondary/anecdotal or qualitative sources, such as media-derived data-
                                                        bases, or testimonials of very few individuals, which are then extrapolated to the popu-
                                                        lations under examination. Although there are advantages to qualitative research, this
                                                        method is arguably flawed when describing public opinion, as the views observed
                                                        are very limited and may not necessarily denote the typical perceptions of the wider
                                                        population being studied. Therefore, the aim of this study is to provide an empirical
                                                        account of how people in the general population perceive the phenomenon of
                                                        female-initiated bombing. Ultimately, the present study is guided by the following
                                                        research questions. Do the majority of respondents justify and react positively to
                                                        female participation in suicide bombing? Do most respondents predominantly consider
                                                        female agency with altruistic motives?
Downloaded by [LMU Muenchen] at 07:14 11 January 2016
                                                        society might, in the general sense, down play female agency, despite the ‘heroic’
                                                        depictions that surface in the Palestinian media. Yet, putting forward this claim
                                                        would be problematic for two reasons: first, the sample size is relatively low for one
                                                        to generalise the Palestinian community; and second, one cannot easily summarise
                                                        the generated cases as statistics or frequencies since responses were aggregated
                                                        through the opinions expressed by a single participant.
                                                            Consequently, the present study aims to counter these significant gaps by introdu-
                                                        cing a survey that comprises several questions and statements regarding female-
                                                        initiated bombing. In doing so, we are able to determine exactly how many individuals
                                                        concurred with the respective items presented.
                                                        Method
                                                        The sample set selected for participation in this pilot study includes respondents from
Downloaded by [LMU Muenchen] at 07:14 11 January 2016
                                                        the Palestinian territories and Tamil Sri Lanka. The rationale behind this sampling
                                                        decision is to analyse perspectives from two different geopolitical arenas where
                                                        female suicide bombers operated significantly. In addition, there appears to be a lack
                                                        of empirical research with regard to Tamil attitudes. Therefore, the present study
                                                        aims to generate raw data which address this matter in the context of female suicide
                                                        terrorism. Seeing that data gathering required participation from individuals in
                                                        distant locations, the questionnaire was therefore administered over the Internet. Ques-
                                                        tionnaire administration involved creating posts on various online forums and groups
                                                        specific to Palestinian and Tamil interests. Undeniably, the respondents selected for
                                                        participation in this study would not normally use English to communicate in everyday
                                                        life. Therefore, the questionnaire was translated in Arabic and Tamil to enable adequate
                                                        response rates. Data gathering involved two phases: first, participants were asked to
                                                        respond to 6 items which related to their social characteristics, including age, gender,
                                                        ethnicity, and so on; second, participants were asked to respond to 13 interval-scale
                                                        questions and statements which related to the employment of female suicide
                                                        bombing. In the latter, participants reported their responses on a 3-point Likert scale
                                                        of 1 (Agree) to 3 (Disagree). To be specific, the interval-scale measure asked respon-
                                                        dents whether they justified female suicide bombing, whether they would mostly attri-
                                                        bute egoistic or altruistic motives behind women perpetrating suicide missions, and
                                                        how they normally react to news of female suicide attacks. Once data were gathered,
                                                        the Statistical Product and Service Solutions was used to generate data frequency ana-
                                                        lyses and cross-tabulations.
                                                        Results
                                                        Demographic information
                                                        Data gathering for this pilot study took place between January and April 2013. In total,
                                                        64 participants took part in this small-scale experiment. As presented in Table 1, the
                                                        sample set comprises 30 (46.9%) Palestinians and 34 (53.1%) Tamils. More than
                                                        half (N ¼ 36, 56.3%) of those surveyed were female. There was also more participation
                                                        from respondents under 29 years (N ¼ 37, 57.8%), who were unmarried (N ¼ 31,
                                                        48.4%), educated to university level (N ¼ 38, 59.4%), and considered their financial
                                                        status as ‘Somewhat or much poorer than most’ (N ¼ 35, 54.7%). With regard to reli-
                                                        gion, Palestinians were predominantly Muslim (N ¼ 25, 80%), while 20% (N ¼ 5)
                                                        204                                       E. Salem
                                                        Muslim                                                   25                3       28
                                                        Marital status
                                                        Married                                                  11                1       12
                                                        Unmarried                                                17               14       31
                                                        Divorced                                                  2                3        5
                                                        Education
                                                        Primary                                                   1                0        1
                                                        Secondary                                                 8               17       25
                                                        University                                               21               17       38
                                                        Income
                                                        Somewhat or much poorer than most                        15               20       35
                                                        Similar to most people                                   10               11       21
                                                        Somewhat or much richer than most people                  5                3        8
                                                        were Christian. In the Tamil case, 90.3% (N ¼ 31) were Hindu, while 9.7% (N ¼ 3)
                                                        were Muslim.
                                                         8. Most female suicide bombers belong to the poorest classes in   43.3     20       36.7
                                                            the society
                                                         9. Women are often forced to become suicide bombers               26.7    13.3          60
                                                        10. Insurgent groups employ female bombers because they are        53.3     6.7          40
                                                            more effective than men
                                                        11. Insurgent groups employ female bombers because men have         10       3.3     86.7
                                                            higher value of life
                                                        12. Women are often manipulated into becoming suicide bombers       50     26.7      23.3
                                                        13. How do you usually react upon hearing of a suicide bomb         6.7    33.3       60
                                                            attack by a woman? (1 ¼ Favourably to 3 ¼ Unfavourably)
                                                        women become forced to carry out suicide attacks, 50% agreed that some manipulation
                                                        might be required for women bombers to act. Nevertheless, most (63.3%) of the partici-
                                                        pants reported that women bombers are typically motivated to act by passion for the
                                                        political aims of their hosting organisation.
                                                        Tamil responses
                                                        Table 3 presents the responses of Tamils participants to the questions and statements
                                                        regarding female suicide bombing as percentages. As set out, the vast majority
                                                        (70.6%) of respondents in this sample set did not justify female-initiated bombing,
                                                        as opposed to 23.5% who agreed. The majority (64.7%) of respondents also reported
                                                        unfavourable reactions upon hearing of a female suicide attack, while 29.4% reported
                                                        neutral reactions. A large majority of 85.3% of the respondents disagreed with the
                                                        notion that female bombers are motivated to act for feminist objectives. Nor did
                                                        most (64.7%) respondents agree with the concept that some women attempt to
                                                        redeem their lost honour by engaging in suicide terrorism. In response to the item
                                                        regarding female bombers avenging the deaths of loved ones, 76.5% of the sample
                                                        set disagreed, compared to 5.9% who agreed. When asked if some women tend to
                                                        be forced into conducting suicide missions, most (61.8%) respondents disagreed.
                                                        Nevertheless, 55.9% of the sample set agreed with the concept that women may
                                                        need some convincing to act, compared to 32.3 who disagreed. Ultimately, a vast
                                                        majority of 70.6% perceived women bombers as motivated by passion for the ideas
                                                        and aims of their political movement.
                                                        206                                      E. Salem
                                                         8. Most female suicide bombers belong to the poorest classes in   35.3    11.8      52.9
                                                            the society
                                                         9. Women are often forced to become suicide bombers               38.2     0        61.8
                                                        10. Insurgent groups employ female bombers because they are        20.6     8.8      70.6
                                                            more effective than men
                                                        11. Insurgent groups employ female bombers because men have        17.6     8.9      73.5
                                                            higher value of life
                                                        12. Women are often manipulated into becoming suicide bombers      55.9    11.8      32.3
                                                        13. How do you usually react upon hearing of a suicide bomb         5.9    29.4      64.7
                                                            attack by a woman? (1 ¼ Favourably to 3 ¼ Unfavourably)
                                                        Discussion
                                                        As indicated earlier, very little research has attempted to assess the attitudes of a sample
                                                        set of respondents regarding female-initiated bombing. The current pilot study is the
                                                        first of its kind to design and implement an online survey that generates raw data on
                                                        the subject matter. It is also the first study to conduct a quantitative experiment
                                                        which analyses and compares the perceptions of Palestinians and Tamils regarding
                                                        this phenomenon. Overall, the pilot study received approximately equal proportion
                                                        of responses from the population groups under examination. The study significantly
                                                        found that the vast majority (67.2%) of respondents denounced female suicide
                                                        bombing, with 62.5% reporting that they usually react unfavourably to news of a
                                                        female suicide attack. Such finding clearly contradicts some of the claims expressed
                                                        in the literature, which assert that societies embroiled in promoting female-generated
                                                        bombing, typically tend to approve and laud the violence. Those who agreed with
                                                        the concept of female suicide bombing accounted for 20.3% of the responses, with
                                                        Tamils, interestingly, representing 4.7% more justification than Palestinians.
                                                        However, a much larger sample size is needed to determine this pro-female suicide
                                                        bombing sentiment. The other significant finding is that respondents, for the most
                                                        part, tended to disagree with the survey items that question egoistic motives behind
                                                        women engaging in suicide terrorism. For example, all together, 60.9% of the
                                                        sample set disagreed with the idea that women are often forced to conduct suicide oper-
                                                        ations, nor did 51.6% agree that women attempt to redeem lost honour by engaging in
                                                        suicide terrorism – although in the Palestinian case, the latter would need a larger
                                                                       Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression                 207
                                                        sample size in future research as opinions were more mixed. Moreover, a majority of
                                                        67.2% disagreed that women are typically motivated to act out of personal revenge
                                                        for the death of relatives. Instead, female suicide terrorists were generally recognised
                                                        as driven by an altruistic passion for self-determination, similar to the host organisation;
                                                        67.2% agreed, while 21.9% disagreed. Such responses, undeniably, seem to comply
                                                        with the literature, most specifically, that nations participating in terrorism are generally
                                                        exerted to interpret suicide agency as an extension of ‘martyrdom’ or self-sacrifice.
                                                        Another significant finding worth noting is that Palestinian participants were 14.1%
                                                        more likely to perceive female suicide bombers as strategically more effective than
                                                        men, compared to Tamil participants.
                                                            Despite these significant findings, there are a few limitations in this pilot study. As
                                                        emphasised, the first limitation is that a much larger sample size is required to determine
                                                        the attitudes and perceptions of the reported cases. According to Brooker and Schaefer
                                                        (2006), a sufficient response rate in survey-based research would be to gather between
Downloaded by [LMU Muenchen] at 07:14 11 January 2016
                                                        Conclusion
                                                        In summary, there was very little support for female involvement in suicide terrorism
                                                        among this study’s participants. The majority denounced it and react unfavourably
                                                        upon hearing that a woman perpetrated a suicide attack. Nevertheless, when asked
                                                        about the characteristics of female bombers, the majority of participants seemed to
                                                        have perceived their motives in less negative terms. The majority perceived women
                                                        suicide terrorists as altruistic actors, motivated by the notions of achieving martyrdom
                                                        and political freedom, rather than redeeming lost honour or avenging personal losses.
                                                        This paradox suggests that cultural projections could have less impact on the opinions
                                                        of observers when interpreting female suicide missions as ‘heroic’ since support was
                                                        low. Instead, perceiving female bombing as ‘altruistic’ could be due to factors
                                                        208                                        E. Salem
                                                        associated with the notions of countering state oppression. Two explanations could
                                                        possibly explain why support for female-initiated bombing was lower than anticipated
                                                        in some of the literature. First, places such as the Palestinian territories and Tamil Sri
                                                        Lanka are largely patriarchal, where women tend to be discouraged from functioning
                                                        in roles and duties deemed ‘masculine’, in this case, fighting for the nation. Second,
                                                        participants might have possibly recalled female suicide operations in contexts not
                                                        specific to theirs when completing the survey. For example, as of July 2014, Ayanniyi
                                                        (2014) noted that women bombers account for roughly 30% of all suicide operations in
                                                        the pan-Islamic movement. If there has been notable media coverage of female suicide
                                                        bombing taking place in disparate settings, we can reasonably expect very few people
                                                        to sanction the phenomenon since women bombers would be serving different causes.
                                                        To that end, future researchers may wish to consider altering the survey items used in
                                                        order to ask questions specific to the contexts under examination. Furthermore, there is
                                                        a need for future research to address the findings that emerged in this experiment with
Downloaded by [LMU Muenchen] at 07:14 11 January 2016
                                                        Notes on contributor
                                                        Edmar Salem is a doctoral student at the Centre for Security and Intelligence Studies, University
                                                        of Buckingham. His research involves studying attitudes and perceptions towards female suicide
                                                        bombing, taking into consideration the implications for counter-terrorism policy formation.
                                                        References
                                                        Alvanou, M. (2007). Palestinian women suicide bombers: The interplaying effects of Islam,
                                                            nationalism and honor culture. Tel Aviv: Strategic Research and Policy Center National
                                                            Defense College, IDF.
                                                        Avraham, R. (2014). Women and Jihad: Debating Palestinian female suicide bombings in
                                                            American, Israeli, and Arab Media (Postgraduate). Beer Sheva: Ben Gurion University of
                                                            the Negev.
                                                        Ayanniyi, T. (2014). Posers over emergence of female suicide bombers. Nigerian Tribune.
                                                            Retrieved October 8, 2014, from http://www.tribune.com.ng/news/top-stories/item/12062-
                                                            2014-07-29-22-35-18/12062-2014-07-29-22-35-18
                                                        Beining, C., & Evans, K. (2014). Is a bomber just a bomber? A multilevel analysis of women
                                                            suicide bombers. The George Washington University. Retrieved December 20, 2014,
                                                            from http://www.gwu.edu/~imes/assets/docs/Capstone%20Papers%20-%202014/Beining_
                                                            Evans_Capstone_Final.pdf
                                                        Bloom, M. (2011). Bombshell: The many faces of women terrorists. London: Hurst.
                                                        Brooker, R., & Schaefer, T. (2006). Public opinion in the 21st century: Let the people speak?
                                                            Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
                                                        Cunningham, K. J. (2012). Countering female terrorism. In J. Horgan & K. Braddock (Eds.),
                                                            Terrorism studies: A reader (1st ed., Ch. 27, pp. 439– 453). Oxon: Routledge.
                                                        Dearing, M. P. (2009). Agency and structure as determinants of female suicide terrorism: A
                                                            comparative study of three conflict regions (Postgraduate). Naval Postgraduate School.
                                                        Haddad, S. (2004). A comparative study of Lebanese and Palestinian perceptions of suicide
                                                            bombings: The role of Militant Islam and socio-economic status. International Journal of
                                                            Comparative Sociology, 45(5), 337 – 363.
                                                        Marway, H. (2011). Scandalous subwomen and sublime superwomen: Exploring portrayals of
                                                            female suicide bombers’ agency. Journal of Global Ethics, 7(3), 221– 240.
                                                        Miller, E. (2012). Hamas says it has ‘Suicide Units’ ready to confront Israeli ground forces in
                                                            Gaza. The Times of Israel. Retrieved from http://www.timesofisrael.com/hamas-prepares-
                                                            suicide-units-to-confront-israeli-soldiers-in-gaza/
                                                        Nacos, B. L. (2005). The portrayal of female terrorists in the media: Similar framing patterns in
                                                            the news coverage of women in politics and in terrorism. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism,
                                                            28(5), 435 –451.
                                                                        Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression                      209
                                                        O’Rourke, L.A. (2009). What’s special about female suicide terrorism. Security Studies, 18(4),
                                                            681– 718.
                                                        Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research. (2003). Survey research unit: Public
                                                            Opinion Poll # 9. Retrieved from http://www.pcpsr.org/survey/polls/2003/p9a.html#peace
                                                        Ponzanesi, S. (2014). Female suicide bombers and the politics of gendered militancy. In S.
                                                            Ponzanesi (Ed.), Gender, globalization, and violence: Postcolonial conflict zones (1st ed.,
                                                            Ch. 4, pp. 82– 107). New York: Routledge.
                                                        Rajan, V. G. J. (2012). Women suicide bombers: Narratives of violence. Milton Park: Routledge.
                                                        Schweitzer, Y. (2006). Introduction. In Y. Schweitzer (Ed.), Female suicide bombers: Dying for
                                                            equality? (1st ed., pp. 7 – 12). The Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies. Retrieved from http://
                                                            www.inss.org.il/upload/%28FILE%291188302013.pdf
                                                        Sofer, A., & Addison, J. (2012). The unaddressed threat of female suicide bombers. Center for
                                                            American Progress. Retrieved from http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/security/news/
                                                            2012/01/05/10992/the-unaddressed-threat-of-female-suicide-bombers/
                                                        Standish, K. (2008). Human security and gender: Female suicide bombers in Palestine and
                                                            Chechnya. Peace & Conflict Review, 1(2), 1 –40.
                                                        Sutten, M. L. (2009). The rising importance of women in terrorism and the need to reform coun-
Downloaded by [LMU Muenchen] at 07:14 11 January 2016
                                                            terterrorism strategy (Postgraduate). United States Army Command and General Staff
                                                            College. Retrieved from www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA506225
                                                        Szalkai, K. (2012). The failure of female empowerment through suicide terrorism in Palestine. e-
                                                            International relations. Retrieved from http://www.e-ir.info/2012/07/11/the-failure-of-
                                                            female-empowerment-through-suicide-terrorism-in-palestine/#_ftn11
                                                        U.S. Army Training and Doctrine Command (TRADOC). (2006). Suicide bombing in the COE.
                                                            Fort Leavenworth: U.S. Army. Retrieved from http://www.fas.org/irp/threat/terrorism/sup3.
                                                            pdf
                                                        WPSU. (2012, July 24). Mia bloom: The new face of terrorism – Conversations from Penn State
                                                            (Video file). Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHaRPox06No.
                                                        Wright, K. B. (2005). Researching internet-based populations: Advantages and disadvantages of
                                                            online survey research, online questionnaire authoring software packages, and Web survey
                                                            services. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 10(3), Article 11. Retrieved from
                                                            http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1083 – 6101.2005.tb00259.x/full
                                                        Yaregal, W. T. (2011). Female suicide bombers: Desperation or weapon of choice?
                                                            (Postgraduate). Georgetown University. Retrieved December 20, 2014, from https://
                                                            repository.library.georgetown.edu/bitstream/handle/10822/553419/yaregalWoineshet.pdf?
                                                            sequence=1
                                                        Zedalis, D. (2008). Beyond the bombings: Analyzing female suicide bombers. In C. D. Ness
                                                            (Ed.), Female terrorism and militancy: Agency, utility, and organization (1st ed., pp.
                                                            49– 68). Milton Park: Routledge.