Corporation Law Notes 10-34-1
Corporation Law Notes 10-34-1
the prescribed qualifications and none of the nominee may be elected as director
disqualifications under the Corporation Code. ● They may be mere nominees5 or
trustees even for one share ach for the
Qualifications for director or trustees: benefit of shareholders
1) Must own at least one share of the ● A person CEASES TO BE
capital stock of the corporation in his DIRECTOR the moment he CEASES
own name or if the corporation is a TO BE A SHAREHOLDER OF
non-stock1 corporation, he must be a RECORD of at least one share.
member thereof ● It has been opined, that a person who
2) Must not be disqualified under the does not own any stock at time of his
Corporation Code2; election or apportionment is not
3) Must be of legal age3; and disqualified as director if he becomes
4) Must possess other qualifications as shareholder before assuming duties of
may be prescribed in special laws or his office6
regulations or in the by-laws or ● Holder of a non-voting share cannot
regulations or in the by-laws of the be elected as director7
corporation ● One share requirement is only the
minimum. AOI may require more than
Natural Persons one share as long as the required
● A director or trustee must be a natural number is reasonable
person
● However, in the case of condominium Special Laws may provide for qualifications
corporations where all or part of the and disqualifications.
members thereof are corporate
members or juridical persons, an The Corporation may also provide in its
offficer or duly authorized agent or by-laws the qualifications and disqualifications
trustee who has been designated as of members of the board. These qualifications
its representative for the express CANNOT BE WAIVED.. If the shareholders
purpose of qualifying him as director, feel that the said qualifications should not
may be eligible as director. operate, the remedy is to AMEND.
Automatic membership in the Board is not All stockholders at the time of election must be
allowed. There must be an election in the considered. However, it is also proper for the
manner prescribed in this provision. by-laws to provide for a record date13.
13
The by-laws may provide that only
stockholders of record a certain date before
12
See Section 88 the elections are entitled to vote.
2) When authorized by a majority of the 3) Corporate Secretary (must be
directors; or a resident citizen)
3) Even without a provision in the 4) Compliance officer (for
By-laws, in corporations vested with Corporations vested with
public interest Public Interest)
5) Such other officers as may be
Business Judgment Rule provided in the By-Laws
Questions of Policy or management are left ● Elected by the majority of all directors
solely to the honest decision of officers and or trustees
directors of a corporation and the courts are
without authority to substitute their judgment AOI and By-Laws may create other coporate
for the judgment of the BOD; the board is the offices.
business manager of the corporation, so long
as it is in good faith, its orders are not Officers specified in By-Laws
reviewable by the courts or SEC. Directors are ● Position must be expressly mentioned
not liable to the stockholders in such acts. in the By-Laws in order to be
considered corporate office
Criminal Liability ● Person elected = Corporate Officer
Directors, corporate officers, or employees EXCEPT if the office is created by
through whose act, default ot omission the such law
corporation commits a crime, will be ● The Board of Directors (BOD) has no
individually held answerable for the crime. power to create additional offices
without first amending the by-laws as
to include the newly created office.
SEC. 24. Corporate Officers. – Immediately after ● Two requisites must concur:
their election, the directors of a corporation must 1) The creation of the position is
formally organize and elect: (a) a president, who under the corporation’s
must be a director; (b) a treasurer, who must be charter or by-laws; and
a resident; (c) a secretary, who must be a citizen
and resident of the Philippines; and (d) such 2) The election of the officers is
other officers as may be provided in the bylaws. by the director or stockholders
If the corporation is vested with public interest, ● If not specified in the By-laws, teh
the board shall also elect a compliance officer.
The same person may hold two (2) or more baord may still create appointive
positions concurrently, except that no one shall positions, since they are teh
act as president and secretary or as president corporation’s governing body, with
and treasurer at the same time, unless otherwise
power to exercise prerogatives in
allowed in this Code.
managing the business affairs of the
The officers shall manage the corporation and corporation.
perform such duties as may be provided in the ○ They are NOT corporate
bylaws and/or as resolved by the board of
directors.
officers though. They are not
empowered to exercise
powers aside from those
Corporate Officers
lawfully delegated to them.
● Officers who are designated or
specified as such or given that
The same person may hold two or
character in the law, AOI and the
more positions concurrently. However:
By-Laws of the corporation:
1) Treasurer cannot be the
1) President (who shall be a
President at the same time
director)
2) Corporate Secretary cannot
2) Treasurer (who may or may
likewise be the president
not be a director but must be a
3) Single stockholder in a One
resident)
Person Corporation may not
be appointed as Corp removal of directors or
Secretary but he/she can be trustees16
treasurer subject to the giving 2) To call for a special meeting of
of a bond to the SEC.14 the BOD/T at any time as
provided by the by-laws17
Officers are elected by the Board, removal is 3) To preside at all meetings of
also by them and no stockholder’s the BOD/T as well as of the
concurrence is required. stockholder or members,
unless the by-laws provide
Qualifications and Functions otherwise18
Minimum qualifications are provided for in the 4) To sign the certificate of
Corporation Code and the By-Laws.15 stocks representing shares
issued by the corporation;19
President 5) To sign verification of a
● There can only be ONE petition for dissolution of the
● Not covered by compulsory retirement corporation20
age for employees
● Often given general supervision and Vice-President
control over corporate operations ● In the absence of the president, or in
● In the absence of a charter or By-Laws event of vacancy, has the authority to
provision to the contrary, he is act in his stead, or perform any duty of
presumed to have the authority to act the office.
within the domain of the general ● Ordinarily assigned the duty of
objectives of the corporation’s succession
business and within the scope of his
usual duties Chairman
● Possesses the power to enter into ● The concept and functions as
contract for the corporation, when “the executive vary in different companies.
conduct of both the president and teh ● The duties according to the Code of
corporation shows that he had been in Corporate Governance
the habit of acting in similar matters on 1) Ensure that the meetings of
behalf of the corporation and the the Board are held in
company had authorized him so to act accordance with the By-laws
and had recognized, approved and or as the chair may deem
ratified his former and similar actions. necessary
○ A party dealing with the 2) Supervise the preparation of
president is entitled to assume the agenda of the meeting in
taht he has authority to enter cooperation with the
into contracts that are within Corporate Secretary. Taking
teh scope of the powers of into considertaions the
said corporation and do not suggestion of the CEO,
violate any statute or rule on maangement ad directors
public policy. 3) Maintain qualitative and timely
● Certain duties are provided for under lines of communication and
the Corporation Code: infromation between the board
1) To order calling by the and the management
Secretary of a special meeting
of the stockholders or 16
See Section 27
members for the purpose of 17
See Section 52
18
See Section 53
14
See Section 122 19
See Section 62
15
See Section 47 20
See Section 135
● Custodian of the funds with authority
Corporate Secretary to disburse them in proper cases.
● There shall only be ONE ● In the absence of provisions to teh
● Need not be a lawyer unless contrary. He is authorized to:
corporation is covered by the Revised 1) Receive funds
Code of Corporate Governance and 2) Issue receipts
the secretary is also the Compliance 3) Keep the money of the
officer, a lawyer is preferred corporation
● Primarily duty bound to keep the
corporate records and to make proper Appointment and Removal of Officers
entires thereto Unless the By-Laws specifies other officers
● SEC Memorandum Circular No. 3 who have appointment authority, the Board of
Series of 2013 imposes the Directors/Trustees shall appoint the officers,
responsibility of monitoring and and as incident of the power of appointment,
observing compliance with the may also remove or discharge those
provisions of Filipino and Foreign appointed.
Ownership requirements as required
in the Constitution and Foreign Corporation is not prohibited from hiring
Investment Act corporate officer to perform services that will
● Other specific functions make him an employee.
1) Maintains the stock and
transfer book, makes the Anti-Dummy Law
entries and records transfer ● Foreigners cannot be officers of a
book wholly nationalized and partly
2) Must sign the certificates of nationalized corporations. He may be
stock of a corporation a director in a partly nationalized, but
3) Must send notices of the he cannot be an officer. The difference
meeting of the directros and/or lies in the fact that a director cannot
stockholders act on his own, while an officer acts
4) Takes nad prepares written individually for the corporation.
minutes of the meeting ● Foreigners cannot intervene in the
5) Issues certificates regarding management, operatioom,
the passage, existence and administration or control, whetehr as
binding effect of a board an officer, employee or laborer, with or
resolution (Secretary’s without remuneration, escept techincal
Certificate) personnel
6) Calls meeting of stockholders ● Applies only to those reserved by the
for the removal of the constitution or law to Filipinos, or the
directors/trustees upon order capital is owned 60% by Filipinos
of the president or on written
demand of teh stockholders Authority of Officers
representing or holding ay When authorized, corporate officers can bind
least a majority of the the corporation. The authority is generally
outstanding capital stock. derived from:
7) Other duties imposed by the 1) Law
Code of Corporate 2) AOI
Governance 3) Corporate by-laws
4) Authorization from the board,
Treasurer expressly or impliedly by habit,
● Shall be only ONE custom, acquiescence in the general
course of bushiness, or
5) Those inherent in office Ratification
In the absence of specific provision of law, The principal voluntarily adopts, confirms and
they may do so ONLY if authorized by the gives sanction to some unauthorized act of its
by-laws. agent on its behalf.
● Substance is confirmation after
General principles of agency govern the conduct as substitute of prior authority.
relationship between the corporate officers or ● Can be made expressly or impliedly[
agents and the corporation.
Apparent Authority
Corporate officer may represent and bind the If a corporation knowingly permits its officers
corproation in transactions with third persons pr any other agent, to do acts within the scope
to the extent that the authority to do so has of an apparent authority, and holds the officer
been conferred upon him, including: or agent out to the public as possessing power
1) Those that in the usual course of to do those acts, the corporation will, as
business are incidentall to those against one who has in good faith dealt with
expressly provided the corporation through such agent, be
2) May be implied from those conferred estopped from denying his authority.
3) Apparent powers as the corporation ● any body who alleges this must
has caused the person dealing with present evidence of similar acts
the officer to believe it has conferred executed
● There must be proof of reliance upon
Implied Authority representation which predated the
A corporate officer, entrusted with the general action
management and control of its business, has ● Action in behalf of the corporation
implied authority to make any contract or do must be established.
any other act necessary or appropriate to the
conduct of business of the corporation. Apparent authority is determined only by the
acts of the principal and not by the acts of the
Practice, Custom, Policy agent.
● Where the BOD approves imilar acts
as a matter of general practice, De Facto Officer
custom and policy, the officer may One who acts as such under color of authority,
bind the company without formal through election or appointment
authorization of the BOD. ● By color of authority - derived from an
● Existence of such authority is election or appointment, although
established by: irregular or informal
1) Proof of the course of ● Adopted to protect the interest of the
business public
2) Usage and practice of the ● The official dealings of officers or
company directors de facto with third persons
3) Knowledge that the BOD has are sustained as rightful and valid on
or must be presumed to have, the ground of continuous
of acts and doings of its acquiescence by the corporation and
subordinates and th e affairs suffering them to hold themselves out
of the corporation as having such authority thereby
inducing others to deal with them in
When corporate officers exceed their authority, such capacity.
their actions cannot bind the corporation
unless the BOD ratifies such acts or is
estopped from disclaiming them.
SEC. 25. Report of Election of Directors, involving fraud acts; and
Trustees and Officers, Non-holding of Election
and Cessation from Office. – Within thirty (30) (c) By a foreign court or equivalent foreign
days after the election of the directors, trustees regulatory authority for acts, violations or
and officers of the corporation, the secretary, or misconduct similar to those enumerated in
any other officer of the corporation, shall submit paragraphs (a) and (b) above. The foregoing is
to the Commission, the names, nationalities, without prejudice to qualifications or other
shareholdings, and residence addresses of the disqualifications, which the Commission, the
directors, trustees, and officers elected. primary regulatory agency, or the Philippine
Competition Commission may impose in its
The non-holding of elections and the reasons promotion of good corporate governance or as a
therefor shall be reported to the Commission sanction in its administrative proceedings.
within thirty (30) days from the date of the
scheduled election. The report shall specify a
new date for the election, which shall not be later Disqualifications are meant to assure that only
than sixty (60) days from the scheduled date. persons of rectitude can act as directors.
If no new date has been designated, or if the
rescheduled election is likewise not held, the The disqualifications under this section are not
Commission may, upon the application of a exclusive. Additional grounds can be found in
stockholder, member, director or trustee, and other provisions of the code, by-laws, AOI, and
after verification of the unjustified non-holding of
the election, summarily order that an election be Code of Corporate Governance.
held. The Commission shall have the power to
issue such orders as may be appropriate,
including orders directing the issuance of a SEC 27. Removal of Directors or Trustees. – Any
notice stating the time and place of the election, director or trustee of a corporation may be
designated presiding officer, and the record date removed from office by a vote of the
or dates for the determination of stockholders or stockholders holding or representing at least
members entitled to vote. two-thirds (2/3) of the outstanding capital stock,
or in a nonstock corporation, by a vote of at least
Notwithstanding any provision of the articles of two-thirds (2/3) of the members entitled to vote:
incorporation or bylaws to the contrary, the Provided, That such removal shall take place
shares of stock or membership represented at either at a regular meeting of the corporation or
such meeting and entitled to vote shall constitute at a special meeting called for the purpose, and
a quorum for purposes of conducting an election in either case, after previous notice to
under this section. stockholders or members of the corporation of
the intention to propose such removal at the
Should a director, trustee or officer die, resign or meeting. A special meeting of the stockholders
in any manner cease to hold office, the or members for the purpose of removing any
secretary, or the director, trustee or officer of the director or trustee must be called by the
corporation, or in case of death, the officer’s secretary on order of the president, or upon
heirs shall, within seven (7) days from knowledge written demand of the stockholders representing
thereof, report in writing such fact to the or holding at least a majority of the outstanding
Commission. capital stock, or a majority of the members
entitled to vote. If there is no secretary, or if the
secretary, despite demand, fails or refuses to call
the special meeting or to give notice thereof, the
stockholder or member of the corporation signing
SEC. 26. Disqualification of Directors, Trustees the demand may call for the meeting by directly
or Officers. – A person shall be disqualified from addressing the stockholders or members. Notice
being a director, trustee, or officer of any of the time and place of such meeting, as well as
corporation if, within five (5) years prior to the of the intention to propose such removal, must
election or appointment as such, the person was: be given by publication or by written notice
prescribed in this Code. Removal may be with or
(a) Convicted by final judgment: without cause: Provided, That removal without
(1) Of an offense punishable by imprisonment for cause may not be used to deprive minority
a period exceeding six (6) years; stockholders or members of the right of
representation to which they may be entitled
(2) For violating this Code; and under Section 23 of this Code.
The Commission shall, motu proprio or upon
(3) For violating Republic Act No. 8799, verified complaint, and after due notice and
otherwise known as “The Securities Regulation hearing, order the removal of a director or trustee
Code”; elected despite the disqualification, or whose
(b) Found administratively liable for any offense disqualification arose or is discovered
subsequent to an election. The removal of a SEC 28. Vacancies in the Office of Director or
disqualified director shall be without prejudice to Trustee; Emergency Board. – Any vacancy
other sanctions that the Commission may occurring in the board of directors or trustees
impose on the board of directors or trustees who, other than by removal or by expiration of term,
with knowledge of the disqualification, failed to may be filled by the vote of at least a majority of
remove such director or trustee. the remaining directors or trustees, if still
constituting a quorum; otherwise, said vacancies
must be filled by the stockholders or members in
Requisites for Removal a regular or special meeting called for that
1) Must take place either at a regular purpose.
meeting or special meeting of the
When the vacancy is due to term expiration, the
stockholders or members duly called election shall be held no later than the day of
for the purpose such expiration at a meeting called for that
2) Ther emust be previous notice to the purpose. When the vacancy arises as a result of
removal by the stockholders or members, the
stockholders or members of the election may be held on the same day of the
intention to propose a removal at the meeting authorizing the removal and this fact
meeting must be so stated in the agenda and notice of
said meeting. In all other cases, the election
3) The removal must be by a vote of
must be held no later than forty-five (45) days
stockholders prepresenting at least ⅔ from the time the vacancy arose. A director or
ofoutstanding capital stock or ⅔ od trustee elected to fill a vacancy shall be referred
members; and to as replacement director or trustee and shall
serve only for the unexpired term of the
4) The director may be removed with or predecessor in office.
without cause unless he was elected
by a minority, in which case, cause is However, when the vacancy prevents the
remaining directors from constituting a quorum
required for removal
and emergency action is required to prevent
grave, substantial, and irreparable loss or
Call must be made by the Corporate Secretary damage to the corporation, the vacancy may be
upon: temporarily filled from among the officers of the
corporation by unanimous vote of the remaining
1) Order of the president; or directors or trustees. The action by the
2) Written demand of stockholders designated director or trustee shall be limited to
reoresenting majority of outstanding the emergency action necessary, and the term
shall cease within a reasonable time from the
capital stock, or a majority of members
termination of the emergency or upon election of
entitled to vote the replacement director or trustee, whichever
OTHERWISE the meeting is VOID comes earlier. The corporation must notify the
Commission within three (3) days from the
creation of the emergency board, stating therein
Stockholders may elect replacement in the the reason for its creation.
same meeting for removal.
Any directorship or trusteeship to be filled by
reason of an increase in the number of directors
Removal vs Disqualified
or trustees shall be filled only by an election at a
There is no need to follow procedure in this regular or at a special meeting of stockholders or
provision for disqualified director, by operation members duly called for the purpose, or in the
of law, such director is disqualified to act same meeting authorizing the increase of
directors or trustees if so stated in the notice of
creating vacancy in the board, the meeting.
Removal does not result to transfer of In all elections to fill vacancies under this section,
the procedure set forth in Sections 23 and 25 of
Director’s share, he remains a stockholder.
this Code shall apply.
Hold-over Directors
See explanation in Section 22
When valid
The contract is valid if the following conditions SEC 32. Contracts between Corporations with
are present: Interlocking Directors. – Except in cases of fraud,
and provided the contract is fair and reasonable
1) the presence of the director or trustee under the circumstances, a contract between two
in the baord meeting in which the (2) or more corporations having interlocking
contract was approved was not directors shall not be invalidated on that ground
alone: Provided, That if the interest of the
necessary to constitute quorum
interlocking director in one (1) corporation is
2) The vote of such director or trustee substantial and the interest in the other
was not necessary for the approval of corporation or corporations is merely nominal,
the contract the contract shall be subject to the provisions of
the preceding section insofar as the latter
3) Teh contract is fair and reasonable corporation or corporations are concerned.
under the circumstances
4) In case of corporations vestwed with Stockholdings exceeding twenty (20%) percent
of the outstanding capital stock shall be
public interest, material contracts are
considered substantial for purposes of
approved by at least ⅔ of the entire
interlocking directors.
The rule under this provision does not apply if
a third party corporation will be prejudiced.
There is an interlocking director in a
corporation when one (or some or all) of the
directors in one corporation is (or are) a
director(s) in another corporation. SEC. 33. Disloyalty of a Director. – Where a
director, by virtue of such office, acquires a
business opportunity which should belong to the
Interest both Substantial corporation, thereby obtaining profits to the
If the interest of the interlocking directors in the prejudice of such corporation, the director must
account for and refund to the latter all such
corporation are both substantial (stockholdings
profits, unless the act has been ratified by a vote
exceed 20% of the outstanding capital stock): of the stockholders owning or representing at
● General Rule: VALID It shall not be least twothirds (2/3) of the outstanding capital
invalidated on that ground alone. stock. This provision shall be applicable,
notwithstanding the fact that the director risked
● Exception: VOIDABLE at the option of one’s own funds in the venture.
the Cpororation, if the contract is
fraudulent or not fair and reasonable.
It may be annulled under the grounds
Doctrine of Corporate Opportunity
provided in the New Civil Code for
This covers cases when a director takes a
voidable contracts.
business opportunity that belongs to the
corporation:
Interest Substantial in one, Nominal in the
1) Corporation is financially able to
other
undertake
● General Rule: VOIDABLE at the
2) From its nature, it is in line with the
option of teh corporation where the
corporation’s business; and
interlocking director has nominal
3) It is one which the corporation has
interest
interest of reasonable expectancy
● Exception: It will be valid if the first 3
conditions in Section 31 are met:
The duty of loyalty mandates that directors
1) Presence of director not
should not give preference to their own
necessary to constitute
personal amelioration by taking the opportunity
quorum in the meeting
belonging to the corporation. No criminal
2) Vote not necessary for
liability is attached to the offending director.
approval of the contract
3) Contract is fair and
This doctrine rests fundamentally on the
reasonable under the
unfairness wherein an officer or director takes
circumstances
advanteg of an opportunity for his own
● Where any of the first two is absent,
personal profit when the interest of the
can be ratified by vote of stockholders
corporation justly calls for protection.
representing at least ⅔ of outstanding
capital stock or by vote of at least ⅔ of
General Rule
the members in a meeting called for
If a director, by virtue of such office, seizes a
the purpose, as long as the following
business opportunity which should belong to
are present:
the corporation thereby obtaining profits to the
1) Full disclosure of teh adverse
prejudice of the corprations, he must account
interest of the
and refund to the corporation all the profits
directors/trustees involved is
made on such meeting
Exception
2) The contract is fair and
The contract or act may be ratified by a vote of
reasonable under the
the stockholders owning or representing at
circumstances
least ⅔ of the outstanding capital stock
Section 33 expressly apply only to directors. Fairness and Mixed test can be applied in our
However, the conflict of interest in Section 30 jurisdiction. The line of Business cannot be
applies not only to directors, but also to strictly applied because there is no wholesale
officers and trustees. prohibition against a director to engage in the
same line of business as the corporation.
Prohibition does not apply if made after
resignation or where the corporations are In fact, if there is no express prohibition in the
involved even if there is interlocking AO or by-laws, a director can also be a
directorship, director in a competing corporation.
Non-competition clauses are expressly
Interest or Expectancy Test stipulated to prevent this.
Precludes acquisition by corporate officers of
property or business opportunity to which teh Burden of Proof
corporation has a “beachhead” in the sense of The burden on the questions of good faith, fair
a legal or equitable interest or expectancy dealing, and loyalty of the officer rests upon
growing out of pre-existing right or the officer who appropriated the bsuienss to
relationship. his own advantage.
● More restrictive and inflexible ● Because fiduciary with a conflict of
interest should be requried to justify
Line of Business Test his actions
Characterizes an opportunity as
corporatewhenevr a managing officer become Opportunity or Business ceases to be a
involved in an activity intimately or closely corproate opportunity and is transformed into
related with the existing or prospective personal opportunity where the corporation is
activities of the corporation. definitely no longer able to avail itself of the
● “In line of business” is applied opportunity, whetehr by financial insolvency or
reasonably and sensibly based on legal restrictions or any other factor taht
facts and circumstances prevents the corporation.
● Where a corporation is engaged in a 1) The officer must give notice to the
certain business and an opportunity is corporation that such opportunity
presented to it embracing an activity exists and the corporation does not
as to which: want to avail of it.
1) It has fundamental knowledge 2) He must inform teh corporation that
2) Practical experience kloss of certain business is imminent
3) Ability to pursue, and the corporation must be given
4) which is logically and naturally reasonable chacne to undertake the
adaptable to its business business
having regard for its financial
position; and is
5) one that is consonant with its
reasonable needs and
aspirations for expansion
Fairness test
Determines existence of corporate opprotunity
by applying ethical standards of what is fair
and equitable under teh circumstances.
Mixed test
Applying any two or all the tests
Just like any board, the resolution of teh
Executive Committee may be repealed by
SEC. 34. Executive, Management, and Other
Special Committees. – If the bylaws so provide, subsequent Board resolutions unless what is
the board may create an executive committee involved is an accomplished fact or a contract
composed of at least three (3) directors. Said that is binding on third persons.
committee may act, by majority vote of all its
members, on such specific matters within the
competence of the board, as may be delegated In a meeting of executive committe, a member
to it in the bylaws or by majority vote of the may ask for deferment if actions in the certain
board, except with respect to the: (a) approval of
actions in case teh board members feel
any action for which shareholders’ approval is
also required; (b) filling of vacancies in the board; strongly that it should be decided by the entire
(c) amendment or repeal of bylaws or the board.
adoption of new bylaws; (d) amendment or
repeal of any resolution of the board which by its
express terms is not amendable or repealable; Quorum
and (e) distribution of cash dividends to the Same as that for directors
shareholders. The board of directors may create
special committees of temporary or permanent
Required Vote
nature and to determine the members’ term,
composition, compensation, powers, and Majority of committee members regardless of
responsibilities. their classification of membership
(director/members of non-director/members.)