Lecture 13
Earnings Management
1
Chapter overview:
Overview of Earnings Management
Types of Earnings Management
Patterns of Earnings Management
2
Earnings Management
Purposeful intervention in the external financial reporting process,
with the intent of obtaining some private gain. (Schipper 1989)
Earnings management occurs when managers use judgment in
financial reporting and in structuring transactions to alter financial
reports to either mislead some stakeholders about the underlying
economic performance of the company or to influence contractual
outcomes that depend on reported accounting numbers. (Healy
and Wahlen 1999).
The active manipulation of earnings towards a predetermined
target. (Mulford and Comiskey 2002)
3
Types of Earnings management
There are two types of Earnings
management
Accrual based Earnings management
Real Earnings management
4
Accrual based Earnings management
The exploitation of within-GAAP discretion over the level of
accruals is by far the most studied EM method. Examples of
discretionary accounting choices include accounting
depreciation rates; deferred tax assumptions; stock (inventory)
valuation assumptions; bad debt provisions; and revenue
recognition.
Accruals are the accounting adjustments that explain the
difference between free cash flows and operating income:
Operating Income = Free Cash Flows + Accruals.
5
Real Earnings management
RM is different because, since it is now
assumed that firms may change economic
decisions to achieve financial targets, there
may be real free cash flow consequences.
6
Patterns of Earnings Management
Big Bath
Cookie Jar Reserve
Big Bet
Shrink the ship
7
Big Bath
Big bath technique based on a belief that if
you must report bad news, it is better to
report all at once and get away from it.
Common circumstances are
Operations Restructuring
Operations Disposals
8
Cookie Jar Reserve
Record more expanses in current period
may take it possible to report less expanse
in future period. Common areas are
Estimating Sales return and allowances
Estimating Bad Debts writes off.
9
Big Bet and Shrink the ship
Big Bet permit companies to boost in current
or future earnings. Common circumstance is
Acquisition
Shrink the ship allow companies to increase
its earnings per share. Common
circumstance is
Share Repurchase
10