HHS Public Access: Aerobic Exercise Improves Measures of Vascular Health in Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy
HHS Public Access: Aerobic Exercise Improves Measures of Vascular Health in Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy
Author manuscript
                               Int J Neurosci. Author manuscript; available in PMC 2018 January 01.
Author Manuscript
                    Abstract
                         Aims—Aerobic exercise improves vascular endothelial function in people with Type 2 diabetes
                         mellitus (T2DM). There is minimal information is available regarding vascular health in people
                         with T2DM and diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN). Thus, the primary aim of this secondary
                         analysis was to determine whether a 16-week aerobic exercise intervention could improve vascular
                         health in people with T2DM and DPN. A secondary aim was to explore the relationship between
                         changes in flow-mediated dilation (FMD) and the number of years since diagnosis of DPN.
                         artery diameter and peak shear at baseline and post-exercise. Paired t-tests were used to determine
                         whether the outcome measures improved from baseline to post-intervention. Pearson correlation
                         assessed the relationship between DPN (years) and the percent change score (pre- to post-
                         intervention) for FMD.
                         Results—Seventeen individuals were included in the data analysis. After the intervention, peak
                         diameter increased (3.9 (0.5) to 4.0(0.5) mm; p = 0.07). Time to peak shear occurred at 60.5 (24.6)
                         seconds when compared to baseline at 68.2 (22.7) seconds; p = 0.17). We found that a longer
                         duration (in years) of DPN demonstrated a fair, negative relationship (r = −0.41, p = 0.19) with the
                         percent change in FMD.
                         Conclusion—Aerobic exercise was beneficial for improving measures of vascular health but
                         these were not statistically significant. The magnitude of change may be affected by the duration
Author Manuscript
of DPN.
                    Keywords
                         ultrasound; cardiovascular; diabetes; physical activity
                    Corresponding Author: Sandra A Billinger, University of Kansas Medical Center, 3901 Rainbow Blvd, MS 2002, Kansas City, KS
                    66160; 913-945-6685 (office); 913-588-6910 (fax) sbillinger@kumc.edu.
                    Conflicts of Interest
                    The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors along are responsible for the content and writing of the paper.
                    Billinger et al.                                                                                           Page 2
                        Introduction
Author Manuscript
                                       People with Type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) often present with impaired vascular
                                       endothelial function.(1–4) The vascular endothelium may be greatly affected by the chronic
                                       alterations in blood glucose regulation(5) and may be the result of advanced hyperglycemic
                                       damage.(6, 7) At rest, lower extremity blood flow was reduced in people with T2DM when
                                       compared to healthy controls when matched for age, gender, weight and fitness level.(7)
                                       However, these differences were not statistically significant. During a bout of exercise, the
                                       people with T2DM had significantly lower leg blood flow than the control group. The
                                       authors reported that those with T2DM had an impaired response to acetylcholine. These
                                       findings suggest that those with T2DM exhibit vascular endothelial dysfunction when the
                                       system is challenged such as physical exertion.
                                       function in people with T2DM.(3, 8) Increasing shear stress such as during exercise is
                                       generally beneficial and may facilitate adaptive structural remodeling of the artery wall
                                       through these endothelium-mediated mechanisms.(9) One study implemented an 8-week
                                       aerobic exercise intervention in people with T2DM and age-matched controls. The study did
                                       not find adaptive arterial remodeling but reported improved vascular endothelial function
                                       within 2 weeks of the intervention and this improvement was maintained in both groups at 4,
                                       6, and 8 weeks of the intervention.(3)
                                       function of the brachial artery the authors used a non-invasive technique called flow-
                                       mediated dilation (FMD). To determine the presence of neuropathy, the study examined
                                       sensory conduction velocity of the sural nerve and motor conduction velocity of the median
                                       nerve. The authors reported that FMD was positively and significantly related with both the
                                       sensory and motor conduction velocities. A negative association was found between duration
                                       of diabetes (in years) and FMD.
                                       Thus, the primary aim of this secondary analysis was to determine whether a 16-week
                                       aerobic exercise intervention could improve vascular health in people with T2DM and DPN.
                                       Therefore, we hypothesized that our measures of vascular health would improve after the
                                       aerobic exercise intervention. A secondary aim was to explore the relationship between
                                       changes in FMD and 1) the number of years since diagnosis of DPN and 2) the change in
                                       neuropathy symptoms using the Total Neuropathy Score (TNS), which is a composite
Author Manuscript
                                       aerobic exercise intervention and methodology used for confirmation of DPN has been
Author Manuscript
                                       described in detail in our previous work.(12) The original study was approved by the Human
                                       Subjects Committee at University of Kansas Medical Center. Institutionally approved
                                       written informed consent was obtained prior to study participation.
                                       Individuals who were between 40–70 years of age, who were previously sedentary, were
                                       safe to participate (by physician medical release form), and reported a diagnosis of T2DM
                                       with symptoms of neuropathy were enrolled into the study. The symptoms of neuropathy
                                       were bilateral, chronic symptoms of numbness, pain or tingling in the feet. The 16-week
                                       aerobic exercise intervention was three times per week. Individuals started at 50% of VO2
                                       reserve (VO2R) for 30 minutes and increased to 70% VO2R.(12) Exercise time increased
                                       during the aerobic exercise intervention.
                                       We have reported our methodology for FMD.(12, 13) Participants were asked to refrain from
                                       food or caffeine for 12 hours and no vigorous activity for 24 hours prior to the FMD
                                       procedure. Data was collected between the hours of 7:30am and 9:30am and kept at similar
                                       times of day for each participant. Individuals were also asked to refrain from morning
                                       medications but were allowed to take them immediately after the FMD procedure. The
                                       participant rested supine for 20 minutes in a temperature controlled (22–24 degrees Celsius)
                                       and a quiet, dimly lit room.(13) Participants were not allowed to cross the legs at rest or
                                       during the procedure. However, if participants reported low back pain during supine lying,
                                       we placed a bolster under the knees for participant comfort. After the 20-minute rest period,
                                       blood pressure (BP) was taken. Heart rate (HR) was monitored continuously using a 3-lead
                                       EKG.
Author Manuscript
                                       An automated cuff with rapid inflation system (D.E. Hokanson, Bellevue, Washington) was
                                       placed just distal to the olecranon process.(14, 15) We used a stabilizing device to allow for
                                       optimal scanning of the brachial artery and avoid arm movements during the ultrasound
                                       imaging. The brachial artery was identified longitudinally always at the same reference
                                       point, 2–3 cm proximal to the antecubital fossa using an ultrasound system and a 7.5 MHz
                                       linear array transducer (Siemens Medical Solutions, Malvern, Pennsylvania). Once a
                                       satisfactory image of the brachial artery was obtained, the transducer was stabilized using a
                                       custom-designed holder. We then marked the location of the ultrasound probe on the arm
                                       using a marker and measured the vertical and horizontal distance from the olecranon process
                                       to the probe to ensure identical placement of the probe at the post-intervention visit. We also
                                       saved the information from the ultrasound screen at the baseline study visit information for
                                       depth, frequency and insonation angle.
Author Manuscript
                                       minutes. All images were stored on a computer and analyzed off-line using specialized
Author Manuscript
                        Data Analysis
                                       We used paired sample t-tests to determine whether the measures of vascular health
                                       improved from baseline to post-intervention. Pearson correlation was used to assess the
                                       relationship between DPN (presence of neuropathy in years) and the percent change score
                                       (pre- to post-intervention) in FMD. We also wanted to assess whether the percent change
                                       score in FMD was related to the TNS change score. To understand the strength of the
                                       relationship of our selected outcome measures, we used criteria defined by Portney and
                                       Watkins:(16) Pearson’s coefficient (r) = 0.00 – 0.25, little to no relationship; r = 0.25 – 0.50,
                                       fair relationship; r = 0.50 – 0.75, moderate to good relationship; and r >0.75, good to
                                       excellent relationship. P-values were considered significant at p ≤ 0.05. All statistical
Author Manuscript
                                       analyses were performed using IBM SPPS® Statistics Software Version 20 (Armonk, New
                                       York).
                        Results
                                       Seventeen individuals were included in the secondary analysis. Of the 20 enrolled
                                       participants, two withdrew from the study and 18 completed the 16-week aerobic exercise
                                       intervention. One participant’s resting blood flow data (pre-cuff inflation) was not
                                       analyzable due to movement and not included in the secondary analysis. Participant
                                       characteristics are reported in Table 1. All outcome measures at baseline and post-
                                       intervention are summarized in Table 2. Resting baseline brachial artery diameter and shear
                                       stress was essentially unchanged after the intervention. We previously reported that percent
                                       FMD was significantly improved post-intervention.(12) The absolute mean difference in
Author Manuscript
                                       percent FMD was 2.1%, which is below a clinically relevant improvement of 3.6%.(17)
                                       Time to peak brachial artery dilation occurred 7.7 seconds faster post-intervention but this
                                       finding was not statistically significant. Peak diameter increased after the intervention but
                                       this was not statistically significant (p = 0.07).
                                       We found that the amount of time (in years) DPN was present demonstrated a negative, fair
                                       relationship with the change in FMD (r = −0.41, p = 0.19). This suggests that the
                                       improvement in FMD after an aerobic exercise program may be negatively affected or
                                       blunted by the number of years with DPN. We report that the pre-to post-intervention
                                       improvement in the change score in FMD was fairly related to a decrease in the TNS (r =
                                       −0.40, p = 0.13).
Author Manuscript
                        Discussion
                                       The major findings in this study were, first, that people with a history of T2DM and DPN
                                       demonstrate impaired FMD. Although not a primary aim of the study, we found that our
                                       reported values are similar to previously published values in people with T2DM and no
                                       DPN.(1, 3, 4, 10, 18) Second, a structured 16-week aerobic exercise intervention at moderate
                                       intensity beginning at 50% VO2R and increased to 70% of VO2R can improve vascular
                                       measures in people with DPN. Since brachial artery endothelial dependent dilation reflects
                                       cardiovascular risk, our data suggest that moderate aerobic exercise may reduce
Author Manuscript
                                       cardiovascular risk by improving overall vascular health. Third, we demonstrate that the pre-
                                       to post-intervention change in percent FMD may be blunted by the duration of time
                                       diagnosed with DPN.
                                       “vascular smooth muscle sensitivity to nitric oxide.”(19) This is one limitation in our study
                                       since people with DPN have nerve damage.
                                       T2DM.(8) The authors reported extremely low baseline FMD values, 1.7% compared to
                                       5.0% in our participants. Another potential reason may be due to the exercise training
                                       intensity prescribed. We prescribed beginning exercise at 50% VO2R and increased to 70%
                                       during the 16 weeks. Maiorana and colleagues progressed aerobic exercise to participant
                                       tolerance for the first 3 weeks but then maintained aerobic exercise between 70–85% of HR
                                       reserve for the remaining weeks. Although the starting work rate was not clearly stated, the
                                       ending workrate was considered high intensity and may have resulted in a greater
                                       improvement in FMD. A recent study used an 8-week aerobic and resistance exercise
                                       training protocol(3) except the aerobic exercise training intensity was 70–75%HRR. At this
                                       work rate, the magnitude of change in FMD is similar but slightly less than our findings.
                                       Differences in study procedures may account for the variability in the magnitude of change
                                       in FMD. All of our testing procedures were done at similar times of day in the morning
Author Manuscript
                                       (between 7:30am and 9:30am) following an overnight fast and study participants were asked
                                       to refrain from taking medications until after the procedure. The study by Maiorana and
                                       colleagues differs in a couple of ways.(8) First, individuals were allowed to take medications
                                       4 hours prior to the FMD scan. Current recommendations for FMD procedures suggests
                                       medications should be witheld for at least 6 hours to avoid confounding effects on FMD.(15)
                                       If medications are not witheld for at least 6 hoursthen information regarding which drugs
                                       and time taken in proximity to the FMD scan is recommended. (15) Medications were not
                                       Second, the methodology for the study by Maiorana et al(8) for FMD was strain-gauge
                                       plethysmography versus Doppler ultrasound. While both methods are acceptable, these may
                                       account for differences in measures. Third, DPN is a complicaton of T2DM and can result in
                                       “slow peripheral nerve degeneration”.(12) It is plausible that people with DPN may not
                                       respond as effectively to improved vascular function as healthy individuals or those with
                                       T2DM and no DPN. Future work should consider a randomized controlled trial to determine
                                       whether vascular function in people with DPN responds to a similar magnitude as people
                                       with T2DM.
                                       targeted at improving symptoms of DPN. In a prior study of people with DPN, a 10-week
                                       aerobic exercise intervention improved neuropathic symptoms and increased the number of
                                       intraepidermal nerve fiber branching.(20) While a positive finding of the study, there was no
                                       mention of DPN duration in relationship to intraepidermal nerve fiber branching. Therefore,
                                       we wanted to examine whether a longer duration of DPN may have a negative impact such
                                       as blunting the response to an aerobic exercise intervention on FMD. This is the first study
                                       to address whether the years with DPN are related to changes in FMD after an aerobic
                                       exercise intervention. We report those with a longer the duration of DPN (in years) had less
                                       improvement in FMD following the 16-week exercise program. Although the findings were
                                       not statistically significant in this small sample, there is early evidence that the longer DPN
                                       exists, the less improvement in FMD. We recognized that this is subjective and the exact
                                       time point for DPN symptoms is unknown. Therefore we chose to use a valid and
Author Manuscript
                                       reliable(11) measure of peripheral nerve function to determine whether a change in the TNS
                                       would be related to change in FMD pre- to post-intervention.
                                       Similar to the findings related to duration of DPN, we report an inverse relationship between
                                       the change in FMD and TNS. Thus, the decrease in TNS score (improvement in symptoms)
                                       demonstrated a fair relationship with improved FMD score (r = −0.40, p = 0.13). While
                                       previous work demonstrated improved pain rating and neuropathic symptoms after aerobic
                                       exercise,(20) this study extends the findings by using a more comprehensive composite
                                       assessment of neuropathy and examining vascular function (FMD). A limitation of this
                                       current study was not assessing non-endothelial dependent vasodilation. This assessment
                                       would have provided information related to smooth muscle response to a vasodilator such as
                                       nitroglycerin. Using this technique would have provided a more complete picture of vascular
                                       health in those with DPN. Future work needs to further examine whether both endothelial-
Author Manuscript
                                       dependent and endothelial-independent vasodilation are impaired in people with DPN and
                                       the contribution to peripheral vascular health. This is a secondary analysis of the parent
                                       study(12) and acknowledge the small sample size is a limitation of the study. Since the
                                       parent study was an exploratory study to determine safety of aerobic exercise in people with
                                       DPN, we are not powered to detect changes in the vascular outcome measures and the
                                       results should be interpreted with caution. Finally, aerobic exercise has demonstrated
                                       improvements in intraepidermal nerve fiber branching(20) and now we demonstrate
                                       of future work to be considered is whether changes in FMD and intraepidermal nerve fiber
                                       branching are improved to a similar magnitude after an aerobic exercise intervention.
                        Conclusion
                                       In conclusion, we found that a 16-week aerobic exercise program can improve measures of
                                       vascular health in people with DPN. We found improvements in peak arterial diameter and
                                       faster response time to peak dilation. However, the absolute mean different in percent FMD
                                       was 2.1%, which is below a clinically relevant improvement of 3.6%. We also report that
                                       people with DPN can improve measures of vascular health but the improvements may be
                                       blunted by duration and severity of DPN.
                        Acknowledgments
Author Manuscript
Acknowledgement of Support:
                                       SAB is supported in part by K01HD067318 from the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health
                                       and Human Development. JFS was supported in part by Award Number T32HD057850 from the National Institutes
                                       of Health. ASA was supported in part by funding from King Saud University. This project was supported by an
                                       Institutional Clinical and Translational Science Award, NIH/NCATS Grant Number UL1TR000001. The content is
                                       solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the Eunice Kennedy
                                       Shriver National Institute of Child Health & Human Development, or the National Institutes of Health. Thank you
                                       to Sarah Kwapiszeski for her assistance with manuscript preparation.
                        References
                                       1. Christen AI, Armentano RL, Miranda A, Graf S, Santana DB, Zocalo Y, et al. Arterial wall structure
                                          and dynamics in type 2 diabetes mellitus methodological aspects and pathophysiological findings.
                                          Current diabetes reviews. 2010; 6(6):367–377. [PubMed: 20879975]
Author Manuscript
                                       7. Kingwell BA, Formosa M, Muhlmann M, Bradley SJ, McConell GK. Type 2 diabetic individuals
                                          have impaired leg blood flow responses to exercise: role of endothelium-dependent vasodilation.
                                          Diabetes Care. 2003; 26(3):899–904. [PubMed: 12610056]
                                       8. Maiorana A, O'Driscoll G, Cheetham C, Dembo L, Stanton K, Goodman C, et al. The effect of
                                          combined aerobic and resistance exercise training on vascular function in type 2 diabetes. J Am Coll
                                          Cardiol. 2001; 38(3):860–866. [PubMed: 11527646]
                                       9. Mattsson EJ, Kohler TR, Vergel SM, Clowes AW. Increased blood flow induces regression of
                                          intimal hyperplasia. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 1997; 17(10):2245–2249. [PubMed: 9351396]
                                       10. Suetsugu M, Takebayashi K, Aso Y. Association between diabetic microangiopathy and vascular
                                           endothelial function evaluated by flow-mediated vasodilatation in patients with type 2 diabetes. Int
Author Manuscript
Table 1
                    SD = Standard deviation; SBP = Systolic blood pressure; mmHg = Millimeters of mercury; DBP = Diastolic blood pressure; HbA1C = Glycated
                    hemoglobin
Author Manuscript
Author Manuscript
Table 2
                        Pre-cuff inflation
                        Vessel diameter (mm)             3.6 (0.6)          3.6 (0.5)         0.27
                        Shear                          223.0 (80.9)       217.6 (64.5)        0.48
                        Post-cuff deflation
                    1
                     Percent FMD has been previously reported. Values are means (standard deviation) unless otherwise noted.
Author Manuscript