Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 178

1st International Conference of Innovation in Education (ICoIE 2018)

Using Scaffolding Strategies in Teaching Writing

For Improving Student Literacy in Primary School
1st Ni Nyoman Padmadewi 2nd Luh Putu Artini
English Education Department of Post Graduate Program English Education Department of Post Graduate Program
Ganesha University of Education Bali Ganesha University of Education Bali
Singaraja, Indonesia Singaraja, Indonesia
nym.padmadewi@undiksha.ac.id tien_miasa@hotmail.com

Abstract—Writing skill in English is considered to be a grammar, organizing ideas, developing critical thinking and
difficult skill for most students especially for elementary school other related problems which contribute to low quality of
students. The results of observations on 10 elementary schools writing.
in Bali confirmed the phenomenon that writing is a difficult
skill for the students. For that reason a strategy is needed in Realizing the difficulties students have, scaffolding
order to solve the problem. The purpose of the study was to needs to be provided to students. Scaffolding is the support
analyze the implementation of scaffolding activities in teaching for learning and problem solving which might include clues,
writing for improving the English literacy of elementary school encouragements, providing examples and modeling which
students. The study was conducted at North Bali Bilingual allow students to grow independence as a learner [6].
School Singaraja. The Design of the study was using embedded
mixed method which was mainly in the form of qualitative
Scaffolding is a significant tool to contribute to the learning
study but supported with quantitative data analysis. The process because it assists students to solve their learning
subjects were three teachers and involving 21 students of grade problems [7].
5. The data were analyzed qualitatively as well as
Many researches have been conducted to investigate the
quantitatively. To maintain the trustworthiness of the results,
the data were triangulated in terms of several aspects such as
effect of scaffolding to students’ writing ability, and the
in terms of time, persons and also in terms of the techniques of researches revealed that scaffolding has significant effects
data collection. The results of the study showed that the on students’ writing ability. Despite many researches had
teachers used several scaffolding strategies which included been conducted on scaffolding, most of them were carried
process based writing techniques, sight word exercises, and out for adult students or post elementary levels [8], [9], [10],
problem solving based learning instructions provided with [11]. Research to analyze the effectiveness of scaffolding to
reading response journal. The use of scaffolding strategies young children has not been much conducted yet, and
reveals clear improvements not only in terms of the writing therefore need to be further investigated. Its importance is
quality but also students’ attitude and interests. The results
highlighted by the fact that younger children need more
implied that the quality of the scaffolding has beneficial
contribution to students’ writing competency.
supports, and especially for those who write English as a
foreign language. The purpose of the study is therefore
Keywords—scaffolding strategies, literacy, elementary intended to describe how scaffolding was implemented in
students teaching English, to analyze the types of scaffolding
strategies used for teaching writing for elementary school
I. INTRODUCTION students, and to investigate the impact of scaffolding
Writing is a form of communication [1] that involves strategies to students’ writing ability.
composing sentences to tell or retell pieces of information in
the forms of narratives, descriptions, or to transform into II. METHODS
new texts as in expository or argumentative writing [2] .
Writing is a complex activity since it covers several A. Design
cognitive and linguistic abilities [3], and most commonly The research was conducted using Embedded Mixed
learned in more formal settings and situations where Method design which mostly utilized qualitative design and
teachers teach gradually from the easiest parts to the most supported with quantitative data analysis. The
difficult ones [4]. implementation of the scaffoldings was analyzed using
Writing in English as a foreign language is observed as qualitative design, and its impact on the students’ English
a difficult skill which leads students feel reluctant to literacy was analyzed using qualitative as well as
voluntarily write and consider it mostly as a school quantitative design.
obligation. One of the sources of the difficulties is lack of
vocabulary. Vocabulary knowledge is considered as critical B. Setting
for second/ foreign language learners because a limited The research was conducted at North Bali Bilingual School
vocabulary in a language can impede successful Singaraja Bali, Indonesia. The school was started in 2012.
communication [5]. Students cannot learn how to write As the name says, the school is a bilingual school which
paragraph without first knowing how to compose a sentence employs two languages as the medium of instructions such
which requires sufficient vocabulary [4]. Other sources of as Bahasa Indonesia as the national language and English
difficulties which create problems can be in terms of which functions as a foreign language. The school has a

Copyright © 2019, the Authors. Published by Atlantis Press.

This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/). 156
 Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 178

comprehensive literacy program from which the school is TABLE 1 KINDS OF SCAFFOLDING STRATEGIES IMPLEMENTED
IN TEACHING WRITING
labeled as literacy based school. English lesson was
allocated for 3 times a week each of which was about 40
No Kinds of Purpose Activities
minutes. Scaffolding
Strategies
C. Subjects
1 Process based Scaffolding in Providing students with
The subjects were two teachers and 21 students of 5th grade. writing developing some guidance through step-
One teacher is an experienced English native speaking ideas and by-step process such as:
teacher from Canada who has a rich teaching experience in developing browsing ideas, deciding
teaching English as a foreign language. The other teacher is sentences and topics, drafting, revising,
paragraphs editing and publishing
an assistant teacher who graduated from English Education
2 Scaffolding in Scaffolding in Steps of scaffolding:
Department. Besides the teachers, the school principal was developing developing 1. Guidance on problem
also the other subject of the study who provided information critical thinking critical thinking solving is guided through
pertaining to the policy related to the topic of the study. and high order and high order reading problem based
thinking skills thinking skills passage,
2. Problem solution
D. Instrument and Data Collection Techniques strategies are guided through
The researchers were the main instruments of the study. questions;
Besides that, additional instruments were also utilized such 3. Using the guided
questions to solve the
as interview guide, and assessment (test). The data were contextual problems
collected using different techniques such as through 3 Reading Scaffolding Steps:
observation, interview, document analysis and using response based on 1. Students read texts (can be
assessments. The assessments used were in the form of journal students’ novel or short stories).
individual 2. Students write
progress tests and also authentic test using performance needs and questions/problems in their
based type of assessment. The data collection were problems. journal as communication
conducted for 6 months started from December 2017 up to interaction with the teacher.
June 2018 3. The teachers answer the
students’ questions and
provide advices
E. Data Analysis 4 Sight word Scaffolding in 1. Students do exercises on
exercises increasing sight vocabulary and use the
There were two kinds of data collected such as
Vocabularies. words for expressing ideas.
qualitative data in the form of description about how the
scaffolding was implemented, and kinds of scaffolding
Different kinds of scaffoldings implemented at the
identified to be utilized by the teacher in teaching English.
school are intended to achieve different purposes. Process
This type of data was analyzed qualitatively. The second based writing activity aimed at providing students with
type of data was in the form of scores as the results of procedure or steps on how to develop ideas. In this activity,
assessments given to students to assess their English literacy
students are guided in every step until the students are able
after the scaffolding was implemented. This type of data
to produce a piece of writing. The supports provided in each
was analyzed quantitatively using descriptive statistical
step can be different for each student in the classroom, for
analysis.
that reason, the teacher must be committed to pay attention
on the areas of difficulties faced by the students. Sometimes,
F. Trustworthiness the guidance given to students needs to be differentiated in
To guarantee the trustworthiness of the study, the data accordance to the individual problems of the students, and
collections were triangulated in terms of time that is to be the teachers need to modify the materials in order to suit the
collected many times during one semester. The frequent students’ level of understanding.
data collections were conducted until the data were
considered as saturated and consistent results were It was also observed that, the tasks given to students
recognized. The data were also triangulated across several needed critical thinking and students had to be able to
persons that involved two teachers and a principal. critically organize their opinions which are often difficult
for some students. To stimulate high order thinking skill of
the students, scaffolding was needed. In this case, the
III. FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION
teacher used problem solving based materials in teaching
The analysis towards the data collected through English. The students were provided with an example of a
participatory observation, interview and document analysis case through reading passage and the students were guided
revealed that scaffolding strategies were implemented in the though question and answer activity which led the students
process of teaching and learning in the school. There were to associate the problem solving strategies to contextual
several scaffolding strategies provided to students each of problems they had to solve. The questions were started from
which has different purposes (Table 1). basic questions which guided students to comprehend
explicit information provided in the passage. After that,
more advanced questions were utilized. The teacher
sometimes restructured the questions in order to lead to the
targeted answers. The guidance through graded levels of

157
 Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 178

questions stimulated the high order thinking skills of the It cannot be denied that as foreign language learners,
students. The ability of the students to solve the problems basic problems faced by the students are on vocabulary. For
depended on the ability of the teachers to provide leading that reason, improving students’ vocabulary is a necessity
questions. In other words, the problem solving strategies and obligation. To achieve that purpose, the English teacher
exercised in the passage then can be utilized by the students inserted sight word exercises every time the teacher teaches
to solve similar problems encountered. English. It was conducted briefly between 5-7 minutes
communicatively to ascertain that students always increase
During interactions in the classroom, not every student
their vocabulary. This gave impacts that the students can
can use the chance to ask questions in the classroom, so the
improve their vocabularies which can lead to improvement
teacher provided the students with reading response journal.
in their literacy skills.
The scaffolding in the form of the journal was intended to
function as an individual medium of interaction between the The implementation of scaffolding activities was
teacher with the students on how the problem can be shared perceived as very positive and beneficial by the teachers
and discussed, and how the teacher can guide the student (Table 2). The teachers considered that the supports
individually. This support functioned well and had very provided by the teachers were very important and highly
significant impacts on students’ attitude as well as students’ needed by the students.
competency.
TABLE 2 TEACHERS’ PERCEPTION ABOUT THE IMPLEMENTATION OF SCAFFOLDING STRATEGIES
Teachers’ perception on
Scaffolding Strategies
Process based writing activities Problem solving based instruction Reading Response Journal Sight word exercise
This activity is very powerful This activity is truly important This strategy is certainly This exercise is very important
1 because the students are guided and very beneficial because the needed by the students. It is for increasing students’
step by step from browsing ideas, students are trained on used to explore and record the vocabulary.
deciding topics, drafting, understanding contextual problems faced by individual
revising, editing and publishing problems through reading, and student who did not have the
then associating the strategy to chance to discuss it orally in
solve the problems mirroring real the classroom.
problems.
The guidance helps students’ This strategy improved students’ This is also good to train The increase of sight words
2 understanding and lead them on critical thinking and problem students to read and write daily will help students improve the
how to develop ideas and solving strategies. quality of their writings.
sentences

The positive perceptions about the use of scaffolding 15 minutes before the English lesson started. The novel
strategies were confirmed by the information from the reading was completely finished at the end of the semester
school principal acknowledging that the implementations of before the students had to write the summary.
the scaffoldings are all by design. In other words, the school
The assignment of writing a summary itself has been
created a system on how the supports in the forms of
reflecting a high demand of English use because the
scaffolding must be implemented and how the teachers
students must be able to listen to the native speaking English
modified the supports in order to suit the students’ needs.
teacher who read the novel in English and then write the
The teachers’ perception was in line with the students’
summary. Understanding the reading story from a native
literacy skills where all students could achieve high scores
speaker needs a good skill of English in order to be able to
in English literacy.
grasp the plot of the story. The demands needed not only to
listen to the foreign accent, pronunciation and the flow of
ideas in English, but also how to put the main ideas of the
story into a summary. However, the scaffoldings which had
been provided to the students have been able to enhance
students’ writing competency.

FIG.1. ONE SAMPLE OF STUDENT’S WRITING

From the sample of the student’s writing, it can be seen

that the student was able to express their understanding in
the form of a summary. The sample paper in Picture 1 was
one of the tasks assigned by the teacher in order to make a
FIG.2. ANOTHER SAMPLE OF THE WRITING FROM GRADE 5
summary of a novel in English. The summary was about an STUDENT
English novel which was read by the teacher part-by-part for

158
 Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 178

Figure 2 is another sample of a student’s piece of were provided based on the needs of the students who were
writing which showed good quality of paper for a student heterogeneous in the classroom. The teacher modified the
who was in grade 5 of elementary school. The summary supports so it was just on the right level for the students so
made by the students was a reflection of how students they all looked satisfied. The recognized attitude observed
acquired the daily interactions and communication of in the classroom afterward that the students were confident
English use in the school. The supports provided could be in delivering their works and has positive behavior in the
anytime not limited to during the English sessions in the classroom.
classroom. Students could also make use of their time while
The success of the scaffolding implementation at the
they were in library. The interpersonal communication
school is directed by the main philosophies of teaching such
among the teachers and the students while they were in the
as differentiated instruction and constructivism. Following
school and during the lesson also made students feel
the philosophy of differentiated instruction, the services
convenient to share their difficulties and seek guidance. As
during the learning process are provided based on different
a result, students’ literacy skills were satisfying and showed
needs of the students. The supports provided to students can
good scores in their writing skills as stated in Table 3.
be individualized and modified in terms of process, content
and end product (Tomlinson, 1999, 2001). The benefit of
TABLE 3 THE SCORES ON LITERACY SKILLS OF THE GRADE 5 differentiated instruction is also evident in Padmadewi and
STUDENTS
Artini (2017) that modified the learning materials for an
Scores using different types of Assessments
Writing inclusive classroom of different students in the same
Answering Average classroom. The benefit of giving individualized support can
Students Finishing a news in the
Problem Score
story school
based Task be seen from the quality of the students’ writing as shown in
tabloid the students’ scores.
No 1 82 88 86 85.33
No 2 80 85 80 81.66 The success of the scaffolding was also determined by
No 3 83 82 80 81.66 how the teacher managed the supports given to the students.
No 4 85 86 86 85.66
No 5 88 80 86 84.66
The mechanism of providing supports to the students was
No 6 80 84 84 82.66 also inspired by the philosophy of constructivism which
No 7 88 80 86 84.66 states that students construct their understanding and
No 8 80 85 82 82.33 knowledge of the world through experiencing and reflecting
No 9 84 80 86 83.33 on those experiences (Hein, 1991). The teaching learning
No 10 80 82 84 82
process were task based and the students were allowed to
No 11 86 80 84 83.33
No 12 85 86 86 85.66 experience real world literacy activities at the school. For
No 13 88 84 84 85.33 example the students had to carry out a real observation to a
No 14 84 86 86 85.33 rice field in order to write about how the paddies are
No 15 80 84 84 82.66 planted, and after that they had to ask questions to farmers
No 16 88 88 84 86.66 before they had to write a report about it. Other example
No 17 86 84 84 84.66
No 18 88 86 86 86.66
was the task to write tabloid news for the school. The
No 19 84 88 88 86.66 students had to interview people/teachers, and the results of
No 20 86 86 84 85.33 the interview must be written in simple news to be put in the
No 21 86 86 88 86.66 school tabloid by the students.
Average 84.33 84.28 84.66 84.33
Score To be able to write news for the tabloid, the teachers had to
provide students with different kinds of scaffolding.
The results of observations revealed that the students Students were provided with guided questions on how to
also improved in their characters. The obvious changing interview the respondents. After that, based on the results of
attitude was the character to like reading. It was observed the respondents then the students wrote the news. Since the
that the students love reading and frequently took initiatives students were in grade five, the number of guided questions
to borrow books during the weekends and school holiday. was also adapted so all can be done by the students. By
When students love reading and willingly read books, it is a having that kind of tasks, the students were exposed to
strong indicator that they like readings because they were direct experiences on how to collect information to make
not only directed by an obligation to fulfill the school news. Those experiences emphasized on the process which
assignments but the habits of reading has been built and provided real knowledge in the students’ brain. In other
established. The results of the interview with the teacher words, these tasks allowed students to construct knowledge
and the school principal confirmed the findings that the for themselves based on the experiences provided by their
reading habits have been successfully formed for most teachers during the teaching learning process.
students since the literacy program was implemented and
The success of scaffolding strategies was reflected in
the teachers are obliged to provide sufficient support or
the students’ scores as assessed with different types of
scaffolding whenever needed by the students.
assessments (Table 3). When the students were assigned to
The provision of supports by the teachers had to be finish the end part of a story read by their teacher, all of
conducted in such a way which made students feel them performed good results with average score of 84.33
convenient and under stress-free environment. The supports (out of maximum score 100). Similar results were also

159
 Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 178

found when the students were asked to write school tabloid ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
news with the average score 84.28, and the average score
was 84.66 when assessed with problem based task. All types The authors of the study would like to acknowledge their
of assessments are authentic in nature in the forms of gratitude and appreciation to the management and the
performance tests which require students to use the language teachers of North Bali Bilingual School for the permit to
authentically. collect data at the school. The appreciation is also forwarded
to the Ministry of Research, Technology, and Higher
The positive impacts of scaffolding in the teaching Education for the support through the Ganesha University of
learning process were also proven by other researchers Education Bali.
(Sinaga, Suhandi, and Liliasari, 2015; Veerappan, 2011;
Faraj, 2015; Ahangari, Hejazi, and Razmjou, 2014). All REFERENCES
studies confirmed the power of scaffolding which contribute [1] Budiarta, A. K., Padmadewi, N., & Budasi, G. “The Effect of
to the improvements of students’ writing abilities. The Student Team Achievement Division Technique and the
Achievement Motivation on the Writing Achievement of the Tenth
management of scaffolding strategies in the classroom Year Students of SMA Negeri 4 Singaraja in the Academic Year
assists students in how they were “learning how to mean” 2011/2012”. Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris Indonesia, 1, 2013.
using the target language, a term by Haliday in McKay [2] Myles, J. “Second language writing and research: The writing
(2006) to describe learning how to use the language. process and error analysis in student texts”. Tesl-Ej, 6(2), 1-20, 2002.
[3] Chikita, G. P., Padmadewi, N. N., &Suarnajaya, I. W. “The Effect of
The success of scaffolding is recognized not limited to Project Based Learning and Students' Perceived Learning Dicipline
the improvement of the students’ literacy skills. The way toward the Writing Competency of the Eleventh Grades Students of
how scaffolding was provided by the teachers also affects SMAN 5 Mataram in the Academic Year 2012/2013”. e-Journal
the success. The scaffolding must be gradually removed in Program Pascasarjana Universitas Pendidikan Ganesha, 1, 2013.
accordance with the progress of the students. The key of its [4] Al-Roomy, M. “Developing Students’ EFL Writing Skills by
Enhancing their”. International Journal of Applied Linguistics &
implementation is on the increasing support provided and its English Literature, 5(5), 2016.
gradual removal along with the development of students’ [5] Alqahtani, M. “The Importance Of Vocabulary In Language
understanding until the students are able to be independent Learning And How To Be Taught”. International Journal of
to achieve the purpose of their learning. It is confirmed by Teaching and Education, 3 (3),21-34, 2015.
how the scaffolding is defined by Majid and Stapa (2017) as [6] Slavin, R. E. “Educational Psychology” .United States of Amerika :
the gradual removal of a teacher’s support which is provided Pearson, 2006.
through modeling, instructions, feedback and questioning. [7] Zarandi, S. Z., & Rahbar, B. “The Impact of Interactive Scaffolding
on Iranian EFL Learners' Speaking Ability”. International Journal of
The power of scaffolding is also reflected in its Language Learning and Applied Linguistics World (IJLLALW), 7
underlying ideology of promoting learning autonomy. (2), 344-353, 2014.
Promoting learning autonomy refers to the ability to take [8] Faraj, A. K. “Scaffolding EFL Students’ Writing through the Writing
Process Approach”. Journal of Education and Practice, 6 (13), 131-
charge of one’s learning (Thanasoulas, 2016), which gave 141, 2015.
positive impacts to students (Kamberi, 2013; Hayta and [9] Ahangari, S., Hejazi, M., &Razmjou, L. “The Impact of Scaffolding
Yaprak, 2013). With scaffolding, students are slowly and on Content Retention of Iranian Post-elementary EFL Learners'
gradually guided to be independent and know how to take Summary Writing”. International Conference on Current Trends in
care of themselves in learning. Scaffolding activities which ELT, 2014.
lead to learning autonomy allow students to have a sense of [10] Veerappan, V. A. “The Effect of Scaffolding Technique in Journal
Writing among the Second Language Learners”. Journal of
self confidence and responsibility because they are given Language Teaching and Research, 2 (4),934-940, 2011.
space to decide on the issues which will guide them to [11] Sinaga, P., Suhandi, A., &Liliasari. “The Effectiveness of
increase their independence (Padmadewi, 2016). Therefore, Scaffolding Design in Training Writing Skills Physics Teaching
scaffolding strategies must be all by design, and Materials”. International Journal of Instruction, 8 (1), 19-34, 2015.
implemented in accordance with students’ progress and [12] Rembulan, P. D., Saputra, I. N. P. H., & Piscayanti, K. S. “The
development. Effect of Using Scaffolding Technique on the Competency in
Writing Descriptive Text at the Eighth Grade of Mts Negeri Srono in
Academic Year 2015/2016”. Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris
IV. CONCLUSION undiksha, 1(1), 2016.
Scaffolding in teaching English as a foreign language
can be of many variations, and provided to students based
on their needs Scaffolding in teaching English as a foreign
language gave positive impacts on students’ English literacy
skill. It is proven by the consistent results of students’ scores
as assessed by different types of authentic assessments.
Scaffolding also promotes students’ learning autonomy
which leads students to be more confident and responsible
in their learning and help them learn how to mean using the
language.

160