Scribd
Upload
68 views3 pages

Part 2: Watch and Respond: Question #7

The document discusses de-extinction, which is the process of reviving an extinct species using its DNA. It presents an ethical dilemma around de-extinction: the large expense and inefficiency required. Arguments for and against de-extinction based on this dilemma are provided. The document asks to discuss the ethics of de-extinction in relation to five principles from BIOTECanada's Statement of Ethical Principles, which values applying biotechnology for human benefit, public education, health and safety, social issues, and biodiversity conservation.

Uploaded by

Prenita Ramcharitar
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
68 views3 pages

Part 2: Watch and Respond: Question #7

The document discusses de-extinction, which is the process of reviving an extinct species using its DNA. It presents an ethical dilemma around de-extinction: the large expense and inefficiency required. Arguments for and against de-extinction based on this dilemma are provided. The document asks to discuss the ethics of de-extinction in relation to five principles from BIOTECanada's Statement of Ethical Principles, which values applying biotechnology for human benefit, public education, health and safety, social issues, and biodiversity conservation.

Uploaded by

Prenita Ramcharitar
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

PART 2: WATCH AND RESPOND

To complete this section, please first listen to the following two (2) productions:

1) The Science of De-Extinction!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MurFdzEpQbQ

2) Should We Bring Back Extinct Species?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6cOmLubndQ

Question #7:

What is de-extinction?
De-extinction is a process of reviving an extinct or nearly extinct species by use of the extinct
species’ DNA.
(3 marks)

Question #8:

Identify one ethical dilemma presented in the videos and provide statements that supports
each school of thought (each side) of the ethical debate.
(5 marks)

Ethical Dilemma: (1 mark)


The expense and inefficiency of de-extinction

For (2 marks) Against (2 marks)


The process of de-extinction will repair Successful resurrection of one or few
diminished ecosystems and restore animals doesn’t bring back an entire
biodiversity. species, the population would have low
It brings back the balance in nature that genetic diversity and make them susceptible
humans have disrupted and advances the to diseases and highly likely to be infertile.
science of preventing extinctions of Hundreds or even thousands of the
endangered species. organism would have to be created
requiring so much genetic tools, research,
time and money for just better odds not
guaranteed results.
Genetic tools and funds should be directed
to help living species in eminent danger.
Question #9:

With reference to the ethical dilemma you identified in the previous question, discuss the
ethics of de-extinction, making specific reference to BIOTECanada’s Biotechnology
Statement of Ethical Principles. Choose 5 principles to discuss.
(2 marks X 5 responses = 10 marks total)

Summary of BIOTECanada’s Biotechnology Statement of Ethical Principles


1. Apply the power of biotechnology for the benefit of humankind
2. Listen carefully and respond to concerns.
3. Educate the public about benefits and implications of biotechnology
4. Priority on health, safety and environmental protection
5. Sensitive to and considerate of social issues related to genetic research
6. Agricultural products enhance food supply and promote sustainable agriculture and
environmental benefits
7. Efficiently clean up hazardous waste and to prevent pollution by treating waste
8. Oppose the development of weapons.
9. Support the conservation of biodiversity

You might also like