Furnace design and
operation
    Pollutant formation
Pollutant formation
 The combustion of fossil fuels results in the
  emission of flue gases into the atmosphere and
  in the case of some solid and liquid fuels in ash
 The primary products of the combustion
  process, carbon dioxide and water vapour, are
  no in themselves toxic, but contribute to the
  ‘greenhouse effect’ in the atmosphere
 Impurities in the fuel, combustion air and
  processed materials all give rise to unwanted
  emissions or pollutants
Pollutant formation
 Most fuels consist of carbon and hydrogen with small
  quantities of sulphur, chlorine, phosphorous and
  nitrogen etc. together with traces of metals. Gaseous
  pollutant chemistry can be reduced to
             C      +     O2           CO2
             CO2    +     C            2CO
             2C     +     O2           2CO
             N2     +     O2           2NO
             2NO    +     O2           2N
             Cl2    +     H2           2HCl
             S      +     O2           SO2
             2H2S   +     3O2          2H2O + 2SO2
Pollutant formation
 With the exception of water vapour, all of the compounds on the
  right hand side of the equations are designated pollutants.
 Most of these reactions are reversible and depend on the
  concentration of the species and the temperature for their
  equilibrium state.
 High temperature and/or the presence of oxygen drive most of
  these reactions to the right.
 In addition to the above reactions, there are some compounds,
  formed during intermediate reactions, which may persist in the flue
  gases under certain combustion conditions. Typical of these are
  volatile organic compounds (VOC’s), dioxins and furans.
Pollutant formation
 A further source of emissions comes from the mineral matter
  contained primarily in solid fuels but also in heavy fuel oil fractions
  and some waste liquids.
 These minerals are usually converted to metallic oxides and emitted
  with the flue gases as fly ash, or deposited in the furnace as
  residual ash.
Pollutant formation
 Carbon, nitrogen and sulphur each have more than one oxide
 The two oxides of carbon have a special importance, since the
  concentration of CO present in the final flue gas is a very good
  indicator of combustion performance, whilst CO2 has been identified
  as a primary cause of global warming.
 The oxides of nitrogen are precursors in the formation of
  atmospheric smog, and together with the oxides of sulphur give rise
  to acid rain.
Carbon monoxide
 Carbon monoxide CO is highly toxic and is the result of
  incomplete combustion
 There is always some residual CO in furnace flue gases
  because mixing processes are not perfect
 CO should be limited to a few parts/million (ppm),
  normally in the range of 10 - 50 ppm. Higher values
  indicate poor combustion conditions
 CO is the first step in the oxidation of carbon. Oxidation
  of CO to CO2 is a ‘slow’ reaction, but is catalysed by the
  presence of water vapour
Nitrogen oxides
 Oxides of nitrogen formed during combustion include
  N2O, NO, NO2 and N2O4, and are termed collectively as
  NOx emissions. NO is usually the primary form
  generated in a flame, subsequent oxidation or reduction
  producing the other oxides
 There are three routes whereby NOx is formed in a
  flame
    Thermal NOx
    Fuel NOx
    Prompt NOx
Nitrogen oxides
 Thermal NOx        -      formed from atmospheric
  nitrogen and oxygen and is a function of combustion
  temperature
 Fuel NOx           -      formed from nitrogen in the
  fuel and is a function of fuel composition
 Prompt NOx         -      formed from atmospheric
  nitrogen and fuel and is a function of mixture
  stoichiometry
Thermal NOx
 Thermal NOx is formed by the combination of atmospheric nitrogen
  and oxygen at very high temperatures
 It is formed by a mechanism known as the Zeldovich couple
                          k1f
                    O  N2  NO  N
                          k1b
                                          10.1
                          k 2f
                    N  O2  NO  O
                          k 2b
                                          10.2
 The extended Zeldovich mechanism includes
                    N + OH  NO + H
 The amount formed depends exponentially on the temperature and
  local [O2] concentration
 Thermal NOx formation is not significant at temperatures below
  1550oC
Thermal NOx
Fuel NOx
 Most fuels, other than gas, contain nitrogen bound as an organic
  compound in the structure
 When the fuel is burnt this organic nitrogen becomes converted
  into a range of cyanide and amine species, which are subsequently
  oxidised to NOx, depending mainly on the local oxygen availability
 This mechanism is only weakly dependent on temperature
 On heating, the nitrogen present in the fuel will divide between the
  char and volatile components, with typically 20% of the nitrogen in
  the char and 80% in the gaseous phase, the latter both as the light
  fractions and tars
 the mechanisms involved are not fully understood at present
Fuel NOx
                                            Nitrogen bearing fuel structures
 Simplified schematic for NOx formation from fuel nitrogen
Prompt NOx
 Involves the fixation of nitrogen by hydrocarbon compounds in fuel
  rich areas of the flame and is formed in the early portion of the
  flame
 Accounts for the first 15-20 ppm of NOx formed during combustion
 The nitrogen is initially fixed by hydrocarbon fractions
       CH      +        N2             HCN     +      N
       C       +        N2             CN      +      N
 and the resulting nitrogen atom is then oxidised
       N       +       O2             NO      +       O
       N       +       OH             NO      +       H
Predicting NOx
 The previous descriptions of NOx formation via the thermal,
  prompt and fuel routes are only a précis of processes which are
  extremely complex and not yet well understood
 Some of the currently available models are capable of predicting
  the trends of NOx formation with changes in flame conditions and
  fuel type, but the reliability of predictions is poor and sometimes
  little better than orders of magnitude
 Currently, the most reliable methods of estimating NOx emissions
  from full-scale flames is by direct comparison or scale-up from test
  flame data
Sulphur oxides
 Sulphur compounds are emitted where sulphur-bearing fuel (oil,
  coal etc.) is burnt or where sulphur-bearing materials are processed
 The reaction kinetics are such that it generally the case that all
  sulphur is oxidised (SOx), except under severe reducing conditions
  when H2S is formed
 Since most furnaces operate most efficiently at reasonably low
  excess air levels sulphur dioxide, SO2, is the primary oxide of
  sulphur found in the flue gases
 SO2 is acidic and corrosive, and causes major problems with metal
  and refractory corrosion in furnaces and in the surrounding
  environment
Sulphur oxides
 At high oxygen concentrations and moderate temperatures sulphur
  trioxide, SO3, tends to be be formed, as well as in the presence of
  heavy metals
 SO3 is even more corrosive than SO2 and leads to sulphuric acid
  formation with the water from combustion, at the so-called acid
  dew point
 It causes severe corrosion in flue gas ducting, air heaters and
  economisers of oil fired boilers, and with unburnt carbon leads to
  acid smuts
 A significant amount of the SO2 discharged to atmosphere in the
  flue gas is further oxidised to SO3 on mixing with air, and then
  combines with water vapour to create a persistent visible plume
  (i.e. acid mist)
SOx in the atmosphere
Products of intermediate
combustion (PIC’s)
 Under certain conditions some of the intermediate chemicals
  formed during the combustion process are released as products of
  incomplete combustion or PICs, although not all of them arise in
  flue gas emissions as a direct result of the inefficient combustion of
   fuel in the furnace
 These can be divided into three main groups
     Volatile organic compounds (VOC’s)
     Poly-cyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH’s)
     Poly-chlorinated bi-phenols, dioxins and furans
VOC’s
 These are compounds containing hydrogen, carbon and oxygen
 VOC emissions arise primarily from internal combustion engines
 They contribute to the formation of low level ozone, a respiratory
  irritant, and are noted for their generally offensive smell
 Expensive techniques are available for controlling VOC emissions
  such as incineration, condensation, absorption, or catalytic
  combustion
 They do not normally result from the combustion process in furnace
  operations, but are driven off from the raw feed in plants where
  feedstock materials, including solid fuels, containing organics are
  being processed
 They are emitted to atmosphere in processes such as drying, milling
  or preheating, where the temperature is too low for them to burn
PAH’s
 The simplest compound in this category is naphthalene, which
  contains two benzene rings. Naphthalene can occur in the
  combustion products of some petroleum-derived fuels
 Other examples of PAH occurring in combustion processes include
   anthracene and phenanthrene (three rings), pyrene (four rings)
 Most of the PAHs are known to have serious effects on health so
  attention has to be given to their formation even in trace amounts.
  One of the earliest reported identifications of a substance believed
  to cause cancer was soot, in 1775, and it is now known that PAH
  deposited on soot is largely responsible for the carcinogenic activity
PAH’s
 Sources of PAH’s include
    Unburnt petroleum based fuels - PAH’s are an inherent
     constituent of crude oil
    Fuel synthesis from heating fuels under non-combusting
     conditions - e.g heating acetylene to 700oC yields ~6.5%
     pyrene and smaller quantities of other PAH
    Coal pyrolysis - formed from the volatile fuel components
    PAH’s have been measured in the flue gases of natural gas fired
     equipment - this may be the result of hydrogenation of soot
     particles
PCB’s, PCDD’s and PCDF’s
 Another class of PIC pollutants includes the carbon-hydrogen-
  oxygen-halogen compounds, They fall into three main categories
    PCB’s - polychlorinated biphenyls - family of 209 compounds based on
     two partially chlorinated benzene rings linked by a single bond
    PCDD’s - polychlorinated dibenzene-para-dioxins, or dioxins for short
    PCDF’s - polychlorinated dibenzofurans, or furans for short
PCB’s PCDD’s and PCDF’s
 These pollutants have been shown to be extremely toxic to some
  laboratory animals, but their effect on humans is not fully
  understood
 Human exposure is generally from the soil via the food chain,
  especially via eggs and meat
 They are of particular importance as a pollutant, owing to their
  chemical and physical stability. They do not readily degrade in the
  environment and have a tendency to bio-accumulate
 They have been identified as occurring in most human and animal
  tissue, although their toxicity is highly dependent on both the
  degree of chlorination and isomeric arrangement
 From some 419 identified types of dioxin related compounds, only
  29 are currently considered to have significant toxicity, with
  2,3,7,8-T4CDD being the most toxic.
Toxicity
 The toxicity of pollutants is defined by the toxic equivalence
  factor
 The toxic equivalence factor is an assign value, describing how toxic
  each dioxin and dioxin-like compound is compared to the most toxic
  members of the category: 2,3,7,8- T4CDD and 1,2,3,7,8-PnCDD
 To account for how emissions vary in toxicity, we use a weighted
  value called the toxic equivalent (TEQ)
Sources of PCB’s etc.
 PCB’s, dioxins and furans can form in any combustion process
   where chlorine and fluorine are present
 They are most commonly found in waste incineration and coal
  combustion processes
 The chemistry of their formation is not fully understood, but as with
  PAHs, synthesis rather than pyrolysis is more likely to be the route
  of the formation of these pollutants in the combustion process.
         Pre-existing PCB’s, dioxins and furans that have been generated from other
          sources and deposited from the atmosphere onto the fuel and/or feedstock
          being volatilised at low temperature and released into the flue gases
         Gas phase formation from chloro-phenol groups inherent in the fuel in the
          temperature range 500-700oC.
         Reaction of benzene type ring structure in the fuel (e.g. lignin) with chlorine
          in the temperature range 500-700oC.
         Heterogeneous catalytic formation promoted by heavy metals present in the
          fly ash in the temperature range 150-400oC. (often termed ‘de-novo’
          synthesis)
Sources of PCB’s etc.
 Current wisdom suggests that the ‘de-novo’ synthesis route is the
  most likely primary source from combustion as the temperature
  window corresponds to that used by most high efficiency flue gas
  cleaning equipment e.g. electrostatic precipitators, bag filters
 In the most industrialised societies, the greatest measured sources
  of dioxins and furans are the combustion of coal and municipal
  waste incinerators, both of which have significant quantities of
  metallic ashes
 In more primitive societies they arise from inefficient combustion of
  wood, etc in open fires
Particulate emissions
 Particulate emissions arise from ash in the fuel (coal and oil), and in
  the case of direct contact processes also from the feedstock and/or
  product (e.g. cement and lime manufacture, alumina calcination,
  ferrous and non-ferrous metals production and glass manufacture)
 Combustible particulates, such as soot and sub-micron unburnt
  carbon, may also be emitted from combustion of gaseous
  hydrocarbons as the products of incomplete combustion (PIC’s)
 Particulate emissions from combustion of fuels fall into three main
  categories
     soot
     ash
     non-combustible volatiles
Soot
 Soot may form in all combustion systems, but it is especially
  common in those using diffusion flames
 Most furnaces operate using this type of flame as it has the
  advantages of a large stability range
 The time taken for soot to form is in the order of milliseconds
 It is formed from fuel in the gaseous phase, burning in the absence
  of sufficient oxygen to produce heavy hydrocarbons, which in turn
  condense as liquids, and then become solid as soot.
Soot formation
 Soot is formed in a number of stages
    an initial stage in which the first particles, solid or liquid are formed
    coalescent collision of these species to form larger spherical particles
    surface growth on species formed in stages 1 and/or 2 from the
     complex gas phase hydrocarbon soup of the flame
    carbonisation of the spherical particles after which further collisions will
     result in chain structures
    surface growth onto the chain structures
 Stage 1 corresponds to nucleation, stages 2 and 3 to the formation
  of the primary spheres and stages 4 and 5 to the formation of the
  characteristic soot structure
Soot formation
                          Agglomeration
                                                                         Temperature ~1000oK
                                   Condensing
            Hydrocarbon
                                   aromatics
                fuel
  Dehydr
  ogenati
  on                                            Increasing temperature
                                                and reducing time
                              Carbon
                Atomic        particles
                carbon
   Temperature >3500oK
Soot combustion
 The critical amount of oxygen required to suppress soot formation
  is less than the stoichiometric quantity for complete combustion,
  but considerably more that required for carbon to exist in
  equilibrium
 For aromatic hydrocarbons, the stoichiometry lies between 0.75 and
  0.8, whilst for aliphatic hydrocarbons with 6 to 16 carbon atoms it is
  between 0.67 and 0.74
Soot combustion
                         0.2
                        0.18
                        0.16
                        0.14
 Burning time seconds
                        0.12
                         0.1
                        0.08
                        0.06
                        0.04
                        0.02
                          0
                           1600   1700    1800     1900        2000          2100   2200   2300   2400
                                                    Particle temperature K
                         Soot burning times for 500 Å particle at an oxygen partial pressure of 0.05 bar
Ash
 Fuel ash is the residual incombustible material remaining after the
  combustion of char particles
 The mineral matter in the original fuel is usually a combination of
  adventitious or excluded (i.e. discrete mineral particles) and
  inherent or included (i.e. chemically bonded into the organic fuel
  structure) material
 Mineral matter contains some or all of the following elements, Al,
  Ba, Ca, Cr, Cu, Fe, Hg, K, Mg, Mn, Na, Ni, Sn, Si, Sr and Ti as salts,
  or complex organo-compounds
 As char combustion proceeds, the carbon matrix is oxidised and the
  mineral inclusions melt. As more of the carbon surface is removed,
  the molten mineral matter agglomerates with other molten ash
  particles
Ash formation
 The ash melt is primarily an Al-Si-Fe-Ca-O complex
 The physical appearance of ash particles is dependent primarily on
  the specific fuel properties and combustion temperature, and falls
  into one of three structures
      solid fused ash particles
      fused cenosphere containing some blowholes
      loose lacy structures
       Solid fused ash particle   Fused cenosphere   Lacy ash structures
                                   with blowholes
Ash formation
   Excluded minerals
                       Pyrite1100C
                       fusionClays1300C
                       Quartz1550C
                       expansion
                                                 H2O
                                                 CO2
                                             Cenospheres
                             Framhiodal
                                pyrite
                             fragmentation
                             Clay mineral
                               halloysite
Ash formation
  Included minerals and organically bound cations
                                                           fragmentation
                   swelling
                                                                                                    5-30μm
                                                                     Na
                                                                     K
  70μm                                                               S        heterogeneous
  25% ash                                                                                      Surface enrichment
                                         vaporisation                Mg       condensation
                non-swelling                                                  homogeneous
                                                                    SiO       nucleation
                                                                    MgO       coalescence
                                                                                                0.02 – 0.2μm
                                                 coalescence
                                                                                                      30μm
              shedding of larger discrete
                    mineral grains                      expansion
                                                                      CO              quench
      coalescence of smaller minerals
      and organically bound inorganics                                                            10 - 90μm
                                                                           disintegration
                                                                                                   < 30μm
Non-combusting volatiles
 Inorganic alkaline metal species, such as sodium and potassium
  organic acid salts in the fuel are readily vaporised in the flame as
  hydroxides and chlorides at temperatures above 950oC
 In the cooler parts of the furnace, these alkali metals re-condense
  reacting with mainly sulphur dioxide to form sub-micron sulphate
  particles (<1100oC), or dissolve into the surface of silicate particles
  (1200-1600oC)
 These sulphates will also react with the aluminosilicates in the ash
  at temperatures above 750oC to form cementaceous compounds,
  giving rise to the build up of severe hard ash deposits on surfaces
   in the furnace and downstream equipment and ductwork
Fouling index
 Prediction of the fouling tendency using the analysis of the ash is
  expressed as a Fouling Index
                      Na2O  K 2O  Fe 2O3  CaO  MgO
    Fouling Index                                     x%Na 2O in ash
                             SiO2  Al 2O3  TiO
 The fouling potential classified by the Index value are
       Low                     <0.2
       Medium                  0.2 – 0.5
       High                    0.5 – 1.0
       Severe                  >1.0
                 Deposition on coal fired boiler tubes
                 after 700hrs operation
Control of emissions
 The operation of almost any furnace will be subject to either
  regulatory or voluntary environmental control by local, national and
  sometimes international bodies
 In many cases, the furnace is considered as part of a wider
  industrial site operation, the’ bubble’ principle and regulation is
  based on the emissions at the periphery of the site, rather than on
  individual unit operations
 Traditionally monitoring of furnace operations were reported
  regularly to a designated agency with local knowledge to meet local
  standards
 Newer controls are based on integrated pollution and prevention
  legislation covering whole industry sectors, both nationally and
  internationally. Thus factors such as energy efficiency, noise, raw
  materials, health and safety, site remediation etc. are covered
   within the legislation, as well as the monitoring of emissions
Prevention and abatement
 Of the emissions considered
     some may be controlled by adjusting equipment design and operation
      to avoid their formation (viz. pre-flame and in-flame techniques)
     some may be chemically modified or destroyed within the furnace (viz.
      reburning, and catalytic reduction)
     some may only be captured by treating the flue gases prior to
      discharge to atmosphere (viz. end–of-pipe treatments)
 It is important when considering abatement techniques to take a
  holistic view, as some of the available technological solutions may
  just ‘shift’ the pollutant problem to another part of the process
 Some pollutants, such as sulphur oxides and ash, will be the
  inevitable result of the burning process, whilst others, such as CO,
  VOC’s, PAH and NOx, can be minimised or avoided by design
  and/or operational changes
Pre-flame control
 Any process that improves the quality of the fuel, usually termed as
  beneficiation, will reduce emissions by removing potential pollutants
  and/or by improving the thermal efficiency
 Pre-flame treatment of the fuel is an effective method of controlling
  the impact of pollutants such as ash and sulphur
     Washing coal at the pithead to remove excluded mineral matter - slag
      heaps
     Froth floatation to deep wash coal, and also reclaim from slag heaps
     The slag is either returned to the mine or used for cement making
     There are no commercially viable processes for the removal of sulphur
      from coal, but desulphurisation of fuel oil is a well-established
      technology within the normal commercial refinery process, and is
      required to avoid catalyst poisoning in the cracking and reforming
      processes
Pre-flame control
 A ‘poor’ fuel can be improved by gasification or liquifaction. These
  processes alter the chemical or physical state of the initial fuel
  source, but are expensive and not generally economic
 It is inevitably the case that the more beneficiated the fuel, the
  higher its cost, however all such processes (viz. liquefaction,
  gasification, catalytic cracking) tend to produce an expensive high
  quality fuel stock, and a cheap residual, which is usually almost
  pure carbon with a significant proportion of the original impurities
In-flame control
 We have discussed the importance of mixing and turbulence in the
  combustion process, and concluded that for most industrial flames,
  these processes control the rate of combustion
 Research efforts through the first part of the 20th century
  developed ground breaking designs in combustion
     Whittle     -     jet engine
     Swirling flames   -         smaller, more efficient furnaces
 These techniques ‘intensify’ the combustion process by promoting
  higher turbulence and mixing rates
 This results in increased NOx formation
 The latter part of the 20th century has been spent trying to develop
  flames that minimise pollution
NOx control
 A wide range of ‘Low NOx’ combustion technologies have been
  developed
       flue gas recirculation
       combustion staging
       reburn
       oxy-fuel
 NOx control requires control of one or more of the parameters
  which effect NOx generation in a flame
     flame temperature
     residence time of hot gases in the flame
     oxygen availability - particularly in the hottest regions of the flame
 The choice of which combination of these parameters is best to
  target depends upon the fuel and the combustion system. For
  example, control of the temperature has limited effectiveness if the
   dominant source of NOx derives from the nitrogen in the fuel
NOx control
 It is important to note that each of these parameters is
  interdependent, fluctuating and plant specific.
     For example, changing the oxygen availability will change the
      temperatures in the flame. Unfortunately the reaction rates
      associated with the oxidation of the fuel, and notably of CO, also
      depend upon the same parameters. That is, if the residence time,
      the oxygen availability and the temperature are reduced, the
      formation rates of both NO and of CO2 will be reduced. This gives
      rise to a dilemma, in that that most changes to a system which
      reduce NO also increase CO emissions
 Pre-mixed systems (e.g. internal combustion engines and some
  gas turbines) can operate with low NOx in the very lean region
  while diffusion flames cannot
NOx control
An example of the trade-off between
                                       Effect of stoichiometry on NOx emissions
NO and CO emissions from an internal
                                       for diffusion and premixed flames
combustion engine, which operates as
pre-mixed flame
Reducing thermal NOx
 Reducing the flame temperature will reduce NOx formation by the
  thermal route
    The addition of an inert species - most commonly achieved by flue gas
     recirculation (FGR)
    Fuel and air staging
    Increasing the flame emissivity - by changing fuel or modifying the
     mixing
    Reducing the amount of air preheat - poor option as it also reduces the
     efficiency
    Increasing the amount of air preheat – this requires a redesign of the
     furnace system, and process operation to use very high air preheating
     with delayed fuel mixing to give an even temperature environment in
     the furnace, Variously termed as flameless oxidation (FLOX), high
     temperature air combustion (HTAC), high efficiency combustion (HEC)
     or excess enthalpy combustion (EEC)
Flue gas recirculation
 Some of the warm flue gases
  are returned to an injection
  point behind the flame front,
  and added into the flame
 can achieve a 60% - 70% NOx
  reductions in boilers with 25% -
  35 mass% of the flue gas
  recirculated
Low NOx burners
 Most of the ‘low NOx’ burner technologies that are commercially
  available use combustion staging to create fuel rich and fuel lean
  zones
 The zones can either be created within individual flames, as in low
  NOx burners or, in the case of multi-burner systems, can be
  generated within different regions of the furnace
Low NOx burners
 It is a general requirement
  for a low NOx burner that all
  of the combustion air is
  controlled, so it is not
  possible to fit low NOx
  burners to furnaces where
  the secondary air is
  uncontrolled e.g. rotary kiln
 In multi-burner furnaces        Aerodynamically air staged burner
  burner biasing may be used
  to create the required zones,
  whereby some burners are
  operated in a fuel rich mode
  and others are operated with
  additional excess air to
  compensate
Reburn
 Even greater reduction of fuel
  NOx can be achieved using the
  ‘reburn’ technique, which has
  three stages of combustion
    The first stage operates with
     normal amounts of excess air
     and will therefore produce
     normal amounts of NOx
    The hot products of combustion
     are fed directly into a zone of
     secondary fuel-rich combustion by adding more fuel (usually natural
     gas) where the fuel-rich conditions drive the NO reaction scheme back
     to the formation of molecular nitrogen
    The final stage occurs with a low mixing intensity as air is added to
     complete the combustion
FLOX
 Combustion air is preheated to <1000oC by flue gases
 The fuel and preheated air/flue gases are injected through separated
  ports and mixing and combustion proceed evenly throughout the
  furnace enclosure
 There are no significant peak temperatures and the furnace
  corresponds closely to the well-stirred model
 Usually use two regenerative burners to achieve air preheating
Oxy-fuel
 Thermal NOx can be reduced by removing the source of nitrogen,
  i.e. by burning in an oxygen rich atmosphere
 Experimental studies have shown that the amount of thermal NOx
  formed in a gas flame is reduced once the oxygen content is >60%
 Oxy-fuel flames have significantly higher flame temperatures and
  lower flue gas volumes, and the furnace must be specifically
  designed to meet these changes
 Inert (flue gas or water) gas recycling can be employed to reduce
  the flame temperature and increase flue gas volumes as a retrofit
  option for existing furnaces
 This is an expensive reduction technique, and is only justifiable if
  there are other process or operational benefits
In-flame control
 The essence of most in-flame emissions control technologies is to
  design a burner and furnace system that does just enough to meet
  the process demands, whilst satisfying emissions legislation
 If the combustion process is ‘too’ good then NOx regulations are
  likely to be exceeded, whilst if the performance is not quite good
  enough then PIC’s will be the inevitable consequence
 Such performance can be achieved on a fully instrumented and
  monitored test furnace, but to translate this to a production furnace
  requires equivalent monitoring instrumentation, accurate control of
  the fuel, air, etc. inputs, and flexibility in the burner design to
  perform over the required operating range
End-of-pipe control
 End-of-pipe control techniques and equipment are primarily
  concerned with the capture of sulphur oxides and particulates,
  although there are also techniques available for the reduction of
  NOx and CO2 capture
    Sulphur oxides are captured either by wet or dry scrubbing
    Particulates emissions can be minimised by the use of dust control
     equipment (cyclones, electrostatic precipitators and bag filters)
    NOx control techniques involve the injection of ammonia or urea into
     the flue gases to reduce NOx to nitrogen under controlled temperature
     conditions
    Sequestration, which is the liquefaction of CO2 from the flue gases, is a
     technically proven method for CO2 capture
Sulphur oxides
 Wet scrubbers, generally consisting of a water spray tower through
  which the flue gases are passed, are highly efficient in the removal
  of SOx, as these gasses are extremely hygroscopic. They will also
  remove a significant quantity of NOx from the flue gases, sufficient
  to meet most regulatory requirements
     The resulting effluent water from the spray tower is itself a hazardous
      acidic waste
 Dry scrubbing is carried out using either granular limestone, or lime
  as an absorbent
     in-flight techniques where the absorbent is ‘blown or sprayed’’ into the
      flue gases
     fixed bed absorption, where the flue gases pass through a packed bed
      of the absorbent
Particulates
 The design of dust
  extraction equipment is
  well established
    Cyclone - captures >10
     micron particles
    Electrostatic precipitator
     - capture >2-5 microns
     depending on gas
      condition
    Baghouse filters -
     collection down to sub-
     micron particles
     depending on filter
     medium and
     temperature
Particulates
 Emissions limits can be set according to local, national, international
  or industry specific standards. A typical value would be 50mg/Nm3
  flue gases (6%O2 equivalent)
 Further limits may refer to PM10 (sub 10 micron) and PM2.5 (sub 2.5
  micron) values, as these are related to respiratory retention
 Toxic metal emissions are contained
  in the smaller particles, or are
  condensed on to particles
  (viz. mercury)
NOx
 Injection of ammonia or urea into the flue gases to reduce NOx to
  nitrogen under controlled temperature conditions
 This may be carried out by passing the treated flue gases
    over a catalyst at a controlled temperature (selective catalytic
     reduction, or SCR)
    or within a carefully controlled time and temperature window in the
     flue gas ducting (selective non-catalytic reduction or SNCR)
 Both these techniques involve considerable additional cost for the
  ammonia or urea, and the SCR route has the additional cost of the
  catalyst, which is subject to poisoning and fouling
Carbon dioxide
 Carbon dioxide has been identified as the primary greenhouse gas
  responsible for climate change. Although VOC’s, and in particular
  methane, are an order of magnitude more damaging to the
  environment, their much lower emission rate reduces their impact,
  relative to CO2
 Sequestration, which is the liquefaction of CO2 from the flue gases,
  is a technically proven method for CO2 capture, although no
  commercial installations have been built
                                                                                     Flue gas
                                                                                   inerts e.g. N2
                   N2
                                                Wet flue gas        Dry flue gas
                                                 recycle              recycle
       Air                    O2
             Air separation
                  unit                Furnace   Dust                Condenser         CO2
                                      Process   filter                             Liquifaction
                                                         CO2 rich
                                                         flue gas
                               Fuel
                                                Dust                Acidic waste        CO2
                                                                       water