C W F S: Ommittee On Orld OOD Ecurity
C W F S: Ommittee On Orld OOD Ecurity
September 2012 E
Item V.a
Table of Contents
Paragraphs
I. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 1 – 2
II. SIGNIFICANCE OF THE REQUEST......................................................................... 3 – 5
III. EVOLUTION OF UNDERLYING CONCEPTS ..................................................... 6 – 16
IV. CURRENT USAGE OF TERMINOLOGY ........................................................... 17 – 29
V. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................... 30 – 33
ANNEX I: KEY TERMS.............................................................................................................
ANNEX II: CHRONOLOGICAL LIST OF SEMINAL WORKS..............................................
This document is printed in limited numbers to minimize the environmental impact of FAO's processes and
contribute to climate neutrality. Delegates and observers are kindly requested to bring their copies to meetings
and to avoid asking for additional copies. Most FAO meeting documents are available on the Internet at
www.fao.org
MD776
2 CFS 2012/39/4
ii) Acknowledges that the term “food and nutrition security” best reflects the conceptual linkages
between food security and nutrition security, while also expressing a single integrated
development goal to help guide policy and programmatic action effectively,
iii) Recognizes that currently there is no consensus among member states about the use of the
combined term “food and nutrition security” ; many strongly support the use of the combined
term whereas others question it for the following reasons: (a) the policy implications for
countries have not adequately been discussed, (b) the possible implications for the mandate
of the CFS have not yet been sufficiently explored, and, (c) linguistic reasons.
iv) Recommends that the Bureau, in consultation with the Advisory Group and the joint
secretariat determines the scope and timing of further work to be carried out to address the
issues under point ( iii) above, and that based on priorities and available resources the results
of this work should be presented to the CFS plenary.
I. INTRODUCTION
th
1. In 2011, the 37 Session of the Committee on World Food Security (CFS) called on ‘the
Bureau, in consultation with the Advisory Group and the Secretariat, as well as with relevant
international organizations, in particular World Health Organization (WHO) and United Nations
Children's Fund (UNICEF), to propose options on the meaning and different uses, if any, of the terms
"Food Security", "Food Security and Nutrition", "Food and Nutrition Security" and "Nutrition
Security" to the CFS Session for the standardization of the official terminology that the Committee
should use..." (CFS 37, 2011). This document responds to that request. It presents a brief review of the
historical evolution in the understanding of underlying concepts and then summarises current usage of
the various terms under review. Finally, it examines and proposes various options that the Committee
may consider for standardizing its official terminology.
2. Over the years numerous formulations and conceptual frameworks have been put forward to
define food security and nutrition and their inter-relationship. Some key terms used in this document
are included in Annex 1, in addition to an annotated list of the most seminal works related to the topic
under discussion in Annex 2. An effort has been made to use this body of literature to distil the
essential meaning of key terms and to suggest a way of thinking about them that will allow public
discourse to move forward in an integrated and constructive manner.
Key Messages:
i) We all work towards the eradication of food insecurity, hunger and malnutrition, consistent
with the right to adequate food and the right to be free from hunger. To ensure a successful
outcome of this multidisciplinary goal, professionals and policy makers across relevant
disciplines and sectors need to speak the same language.
CFS 2012/39/4 3
ii) The terms under discussion have evolved over several decades, based on different perspectives
by leading professional communities of practice, especially nutrition and public health experts
and professional groups working in the socio-economic, food and agriculture domains.
iii) There is wide recognition of the four dimensions of food security - availability, access,
utilization and stability - and the three main determinants of nutrition security - access to food,
care and feeding, and health and sanitation.
iv) The terms may take on a different meaning when applied at global or national levels versus
household or individual levels.
v) In those cases where translation is an issue caution is in order to ensure the agreed upon
language is adhered to; it is also noted that in certain languages countries may choose not to
use the combined term in their national contexts.
vi) While there is significant overlap in the content of the multidisciplinary definitions of food
security and nutrition security, some communities of practice will feel more comfortable with
one term or the other. Mutual agreement and acceptance of a common term, endorsed and
recommended by CFS, will greatly facilitate future communication, decisions and actions that
support the eradication of food insecurity, hunger and malnutrition.
13. In 1986, the World Bank released a report entitled Poverty and Hunger, focusing on the
temporal dynamics of food insecurity. The report attributed both chronic hunger and transitory food
insecurity to poverty and lack of income. Such vulnerable households could best be assisted by
simultaneously addressing the multitude of underlying factors that kept them trapped in poverty.
14. Multisectoral nutrition planning emerged in the early 1970s, as a bold new approach to
combating malnutrition. This approach emphasised nutritional deprivation as a concern of public
policy and in relation to economic planning at the national level and the planning for nutritional
improvement as a central component of overall development planning. This was in reaction to the
food-supply planning approach which is based on the assumption that if rates of growth in food
production can be made to increase faster than population growth rates, the nutrition problem will be
solved. The 1975 FAO report, Food and Nutrition Planning, fully elaborated nutrition-based
development planning approaches. It argued that malnutrition is not simply a problem of food
availability, but is rather a function of poverty and of deprivation. Thus, while food supplies may need
to be increased, the central thrust of food and nutrition planning must be the reduction of the causes of
deprivation that lead to malnutrition. Nutrition planning becomes central to overall development
planning because a prime objective of planning needs to be the sustained reduction of malnutrition.
15. Looking at both adequate food availability and access to food in the 1980s brought about a
new understanding of hunger and malnutrition, including undernutrition and micronutrient
malnutrition. In 1990, UNICEF introduced a Conceptual Framework for Understanding the Causes of
Malnutrition which made a clear distinction between food and non-food factors (care and health) that
were deemed essential for child nutrition. This was then further elaborated by the 1992 International
Conference on Nutrition (ICN) as the very first intergovernmental meeting on nutrition, which
developed and adopted the World Declaration and Plan of Action on Nutrition.
16. The nutrition and health community have long advocated for a better understanding of the key
determinants of good nutrition and their inclusion achieving development objectives. This has led to
new initiatives to mainstream nutrition considerations more effectively such as the Scaling-Up
Nutrition (SUN) Movement established in 2010 by a range of stakeholders concerned with the lack of
progress towards the reduction in hunger and undernutrition and the achievement of food and nutrition
security for all.
and stability. The nutritional dimension is integral to the concept of food security and to the work of
CFS.” (CFS: 2009/2 Rev. 2).
Nutrition Security
20. As the term “food security” evolved, the term “nutrition security” emerged in the mid-1990s.
Nutrition security focuses on food consumption by the household or the individual and on how that
food is utilized by the body. Building on UNICEF’s Conceptual Framework, IFPRI proposed the
following definition in 1995: “Nutrition security can be defined as adequate nutritional status in terms
of protein, energy, vitamins, and minerals for all household members at all times.”
21. In light of continuing hunger, poverty and malnutrition, efforts have continued to raise
awareness of the meaning of “nutrition security”. It’s a condition that’s achieved at the level of the
individual. It combines having access to adequate food that fully satisfies nutritional needs with non-
food factors that enable a person to metabolize their food and use the nutrients to support growth and
maintenance of the body and to carryout basic life functions. In 2006, the World Bank published a
book on Repositioning Nutrition as Central to Development. It gives the following more elaborated
definition of nutrition security: “Nutrition security exists when food security is combined with a
sanitary environment, adequate health services, and proper care and feeding practices to ensure a
healthy life for all household members.” This same definition of nutrition security is also used by
WHO in its forthcoming report of the Global Nutrition Policy.
22. The Road Map for Scaling-Up Nutrition (SUN), 2010 edition, elaborates on the definition as
follows: “Nutrition security is achieved when secure access to an appropriately nutritious diet is
coupled with a sanitary environment, adequate health services and care, to ensure a healthy and active
life for all household members.”
23. In an effort to focus attention on the point that nutrition security is only achieved when
individuals actually consume the food they need rather than simply having access to it (as in the
currently-accepted definition of food security), FAO has developed the following draft formulation:
“Nutrition security exists when all people at all times consume food of sufficient quantity and quality
in terms of variety, diversity, nutrient content and safety to meet their dietary needs and food
preferences for an active and healthy life, coupled with a sanitary environment, adequate health,
education and care.” (FAO/AGN, March 2012)
Partnership for Agriculture, Food Security and Nutrition” that was also emerging at that time, and in
many parts of the UN system this usage has become common practice. In line with this, the Secretary
General’s Special Representative carries the title “Special Representative for Food Security and
Nutrition”.
been to focus attention on actions needed to mainstream nutrition considerations at all points
throughout the food chain.
31. The current term used by CFS - “food security and nutrition” - places emphasis on the
importance of two complementary but overlapping, concepts, namely “food security and nutrition”.
Food security has its origins in “freedom from hunger” and has over time evolved into a broad concept
encompassing food availability, access, stability and food utilisation. Similarly, the nutrition concept
has evolved and places emphasis on access to adequate food, care and feeding practices and health and
sanitation issues. The term “food security and nutrition” has been typically used to represent actions
required such as securing adequate and safe food supplies and stable food prices. Ensuring that
individuals consume the right quantities of an appropriate variety and quality of food at the household
level and that they are healthy enough to absorb the nutrients from the food are part of the concept.
Many multi-disciplinary actions and investment plans have been formulated under this term and policy
makers at all levels are generally aware of the importance of investing in both reducing food insecurity
and malnutrition. If there is a weakness in the meaning and use of this combined term, it relates to the
fact that the overlapping content of the term, both conceptually and operationally, causes confusion.
32. On the other hand, the term “food and nutrition security” represents a more integrated way to
combine the two concepts. It emphasizes that the overall objective is to achieve both “food security”
and “nutrition security” as a single, unitary goal of policy and programmatic actions. It is also argued
that this formulation encourages different communities of practice to better integrate their work
towards achieving food security and nutrition security objectives. It is in this context that the
formulation has come into increasingly widespread use. With the term “food and nutrition security”,
food production, food systems, and socio-economic aspects at the origins of the food security concept
are complemented by the biological approach in which the human being is the starting point, as
emphasized by the nutrition security concept.
33. Keeping in mind that we are all working towards the eradication of food insecurity, hunger
and malnutrition, and based on the in-depth review of the meaning and different uses of the terms
under consideration in this document, it is recommended that the Committee:
i) Recognises the long history and evolution of the meaning and use of the terms food
security and nutrition security,
ii) Acknowledges that the term “food and nutrition security” best reflects the conceptual
linkages between food security and nutrition security, while also expressing a single
integrated development goal to help guide policy and programmatic action effectively,
iii) Acknowledges that in certain languages countries may choose not to use the combined
term in their national contexts,
iv) Recommends the Committee should use, as appropriate, the following definition of “food
and nutrition security”:
v) “Food and nutrition security exists when all people at all times have physical, social and
economic access to food, which is safe and consumed in sufficient quantity and quality to
meet their dietary needs and food preferences, and is supported by an environment of
adequate sanitation, health services and care, allowing for a healthy and active life.”
CFS 2012/39/4 9
1
The Codex Alimentarius defines food as “any substance, whether processed, semi-processed, or raw, which is intended for
human consumption, and includes drink, chewing gum and any substance which has been used in the manufacture,
preparation or treatment of "food" but does not include cosmetics or tobacco or substances used only as drugs.” (Codex
Alimentarius Commission, Procedural Manual, 11th edition).
10 CFS 2012/39/4
Nutrition is the consequence of the intake of food and the utilization of nutrients by the body. Good
nutrition produces a healthy physical and physiological condition. It is secured when food intake,
absorption and utilization provide all essential nutrients in required amounts. Poor nutrition produces
an unhealthy physiological condition and is caused by lack of physical, economic, social or
physiological access to the right amounts of dietary energy and nutrients. Consequences of poor
nutrition can be impaired physical and mental development, reduced immunity, increased
susceptibility to disease, decreased ability to do work and reduced productivity. Since parasites, poor
hygiene and diseases can compromise a person's ability to absorb and biologically utilize the nutrients
consumed, a safe food supply, clean drinking water, a sanitary environment, adequate health,
education and care are essential for good nutrition, along with a balanced diet. Optimal nutrition
supports development to obtain each individual’s full genetic potential.
Malnutrition
Malnutrition is defined as nutritional disorder in all its forms and includes both undernutrition and
overnutrition. It relates to imbalances in energy, and specific macro and micronutrients- as well as in
dietary patterns. Conventionally, the emphasis has been in relation to inadequacy, but it also applies to
both excess and imbalanced intakes. Malnutrition occurs when the intake of essential macro- and
micronutrients does not meet or exceeds the metabolic demands for those nutrients. These metabolic
demands vary with age, gender and other physiological conditions and are also affected by
environmental conditions including poor hygiene and sanitation that lead to food- as well as water-
borne diarrhoea (WHO Global Nutrition Policy Review). When micronutrient malnutrition occurs in
persons who are of a normal weight or who are overweight or obese, it is sometimes referred to as
hidden hunger. Hidden hunger often has no visible warning signs, leaving sufferers unaware of their
dietary deficiency and its potentially adverse impact on their health. Pregnant and lactating women
have additional specific needs. The additional food needed during pregnancy and lactation is critical to
ensuring adequate nutrient intake sufficient in both quantity and quality for fetal growth and
production of breast milk. Maternal undernutrition at this stage can lead to intrauterine growth
retardation and low concentrations of certain nutrients in breast milk. Malnutrition is especially serious
for infants during the first 1000 days of life (from conception through the age of two), and for young
children and has largely irreversible long-term effects on the ability of children to grow and learn, and
to develop into productive adults later in life. This can restrict the development potential of whole
societies and nations, and create a costly and continuing health and humanitarian burden for the
country.
Nutritional status
The nutritional status of a person can be measured by different methods, such as anthropometry,
biochemical, clinical assessment and dietary intake methods. Anthropometry is the method commonly
used. It can be defined as the measurement of physical dimensions and gross composition of the
human body. The nutritional status of a person alone does not indicate the causes of this status.
CFS 2012/39/4 11
1943
Declaration of the Hot Springs Conference. Cited in FAO (1981). FAO: its origins, formation and
evolution 1945–1981. Rome. Available online at: http://www.worldfooddayusa.org/?id=16367
1945
Constitution of FAO: Preamble. Cited in FAO (1981). FAO: its origins, formation and evolution
1945–1981. Rome. Available online at: http://www.fao.org/docrep/009/p4228e/p4228e00.htm
1946
FAO (1946). First World Food Survey. Rome.
1948
UN (1948). Universal Declaration of Human Rights. http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/
1966
UN (1966). International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Adopted and opened
for signature, ratification and accession by General Assembly resolution 2200A (XXI) of 16
December 1966. New York
1975
UN (1975). Report of the World Food Conference held in Rome in November 1974. New York.
Joy, L. and Payne, P.R. (1975). Food and Nutrition Planning, Nutrition Consultants’ Reports
Series No. 35, ESN: CRS/75/351. FAO. Rome.
1976
UN Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) (1976). Institutional arrangement relating to
nutrition, Statement of the Administrative Committee on Co-ordination, New York. Available
online at:
http://www.unscn.org/files/mandate/ECOSOC_statement__re_SCN_E5805_April_1976.pdf
UN ECOSOC (1976). Food Problems, Institutional Arrangements Relating to Nutrition: State of
the Administrative Committee on Co-ordination. ECOSOC E/5805, 28 April 1976.
1977
UN ECOSOC (1977). Institutional Arrangements Relating to Nutrition. Supplementary statement
by the Administrative Committee on Co-ordination. ECOSOC E/5968, 26 April 1977.
1981
Sen, A. (1981). Poverty and Famines: An Essay on Entitlement and Deprivation. Oxford:
Clarendon Press, New York: Oxford University Press.
1983
FAO (1983). Committee on World Food Security (CFS 83/4): Director-General's Report on World
Food Security: A Reappraisal of the Concepts and Approaches. Rome.
1986
World Bank (1986). Poverty and Hunger. Washington D.C.
1990
12 CFS 2012/39/4
FAO (2003). Measurement and Assessment of Food Deprivation and Undernutrition. FIVIMS
International Scientific Symposium. June 2002. Rome.
FAO (2003). “Food security: concepts and measurement” Trade Reforms and Food Security,
Chapter 2. Rome.
WHO (2003) Technical Report Series 916. Diet, nutrition and the prevention of chronic diseases.
Joint WHO/FAO expert consultation, Geneva 2003.
2004
IFPRI (2004). “Africa’s Food and Nutrition Security Situation: Where Are We and How Did We
Get Here?” By Todd Benson. Chapter 2 in Food and Nutrition Security. IFPRI 2020 Discussion
Paper 37. Washington D.C.
WFP (2004). “Food for Nutrition: Mainstreaming Nutrition in WFP”(WFP/EB.A/2004/5-A/1).
2005
FAO (2005). Family Nutrition Guide. Available online at:
http://www.fao.org/docrep/007/y5740e/y5740e06.htm#bm06.1).
FAO (2005). Voluntary Guidelines to support the progressive realization of the right to adequate
food in the context of national food security. Adopted by the 127th Session of FAO Council,
November 2004. Rome.
2006
FAO (2006). Policy Brief, Issue 2: Food Security. Rome.
Shakir (2006). Repositioning Nutrition as Central to Development. Washington D.C. World Bank.
UN-SCN (2006). Strategic Framework 2006-2010, approved at the 33rd Session in March 2006.
WFP (2006). Ending Child Hunger and Undernutrition Initiative: Global Framework for Action
(WFP/EB.2/2006/4-A).
WFP (2006). World Hunger Series – Hunger and Learning, WFP and Stanford University Press.
2007
FAO (2007): FAO Right to Food Web Site. Available online at: www.fao.org/righttofood
FAO (2007) Guide on Legislating for the Right to Food. Available online at:
http://www.fao.org/righttofood/publi09/guide_on_legislating.pdf).
WFP (2007): World Hunger Series – Hunger and Health, WFP and Earthscan.
WFP (2007): Global Framework for Action - Ending Child Hunger and Undernutrition Initiative -
Global Framework for Action Addendum (WFP/EB.1/2007/5-A/Add.1).
2008
UNICEF (2008). Food prices increases / Nutrition security: Action for Children.
WFP (2008). WFP Strategic Plan 2008 – 2013 (WFP/2009/EB.A/3).
2009
CFS (2009). Reform of the CFS, Final version. CFS 35: 2009/2 Rev. 2. October 2009.
FAO (2009). Declaration of the World Summit on Food Security, WSFS 2009/2, 16 November
2009
Pinstrup-Anderson P. (2009).” Food Security: definition and measurement”, pp. 5-7 in Food
Security Vol. 1.
UNICEF (2009). Tracking Progress on Maternal and Child Undernutrition. New York.
14 CFS 2012/39/4
UNICEF and African Union (2009). Improving nutrition security for Africa's children. New York.
UNSCN (2009). Report of the Brussels High Level Nutrition Meeting. October 2009. Geneva.
2010
UN HLTF (September, 2010). Updated Comprehensive Framework for Action (CFA).
SUN Movement (September 2010). Scaling Up Nutrition Road Map, First Edition.
UNSCN (2010). The 6th Report on the World Nutrition Situation. Geneva.
2011
CFS (2011). Final Report. CFS 37/2011.
EuropeAid (2011). Glossary on page 71 of Addressing undernutrition in external assistance. Joint
document prepared by the EC, Germany, Ireland, France, Poland and the United Kingdom.
September 2011.
FAO/AGN (November 2011). Final Report: Evaluation of FAO's Role and Work in Nutrition.
FAO Office of Evaluation, MB663. 108th Programme Committee and UN Scaling Up Nutrition
(SUN).
2012
UN-HLTF (2012). Food and Nutrition Security for All through Sustainable Agriculture and Food
Systems. 14 March 2012.
WHO (forthcoming). Global Nutrition Policy Review. Forthcoming. Geneva.
WHO online. Health Topics: Nutrition. Available at: http://www.who.int/topics/nutrition/en/).
WFP (2012). WFP Nutrition Policy (WFP/EB.1/2012/5-A).