Roasting Reduction Kinetics of An Indonesian Nickeliferous Laterite Ore
Roasting Reduction Kinetics of An Indonesian Nickeliferous Laterite Ore
stages of the reductive process. This is a strong        - continuous weighing of the test sample with
indication that the controlling mechanism is               a weighing device having a resolution of 1 g,
strongly related to the mineralogical composi-           - cooling to room temperature, at a low N2
tion of the starting raw material, the applied             flow rate.
temperature range and the reducing gas compo-               The degree of reduction after time t, Rt, rela-
sition.                                                  tive to the ferric iron was calculated according
                                                         to the requirements of the ASTM standard test
2. EXPERIMENTAL                                          method by the following general equation:
Chemical analysis of the bulk ore sample is              Rt = (mt/Oxh)*100                               (1)
given in Table 1. In the same Table, the chemi-          where:
cal analysis of iron and nickel of the -12.5+9.5            mt: is the mass loss, in grams of the test
mm and -9.5+6.3 mm fractions used in the ex-                    sample after reduction time t.
perimental procedure is also given.
   As revealed by the XRD patterns (obtained                Oxh is the hypothetical oxygen content of test
by a Siemens D-5000 diffractometer, Ni-filtered          sample, assuming that the iron and nickel oxides
CuKa radiation /λ=1.5405 Å) the ore mainly               present in the laterite sample are Fe2O3 and
consists of goethite, (a-FeOOH), nickeliferous           NiO, respectively.
serpentine [(Mg,Fe,Ni)6Si4O12(OH)6,], which is              The experimental data obtained concerning
the main nickel-bearing mineral in this particu-         iron oxide reduction, were applied to the follow-
lar type of ore, maghemite (γ-Fe2O3) and quartz          ing mathematical models:
(SiO2). It is noted that its mineralogical and che-      i)   Chemically controlled mechanism:
mical character mainly approaches the interme-
diate type of laterites (Zevgolis et al., 2009).
   A thorough description of both the experi-
                                                         ⎛ ri d i
                                                         ⎜
                                                         ⎜C −C
                                                                        ⎞
                                                                         [              ]
                                                                        ⎟ 1−(1 − R )1 / 3 = k1t
                                                                        ⎟
                                                                                                         (2)
mental set-up, as well as the preparation of the         ⎝ o      eq    ⎠
test samples and the step-by-step conduction of          where:
the experiments, has already been discussed              ri, di:  are the initial radius and density of the
(Zevgolis et al., 2009). The main steps of the                    grain respectively,
experimental procedure in brief, involved:               R:       the reduction degree,
- preheating - heating up to the desired tem-            k1:      the rate constant and t the time of reac-
  perature and calcination till all the volatile                  tion,
  matter (H2O and CO2) of the ore is expelled-           Co, Ceq: are the fluid reactant concentration at
  of the test sample (250 g) at a specified size                  the external surface of the grain and at
  range (-12.5+9.5 mm) and (-9.5+6.3 mm),                         the surface of the core respectively.
- isothermal reduction with a gaseous reducing
  mixture consisting of CO and N2 40/60 % by             ii) Diffusion through the product layer:
  volume,
                                                         ⎛ ri 2 d i     ⎞ ⎡ 1 R (1 − R )2 / 3 ⎤
Table 1: Chemical analysis of laterite Ore               ⎜              ⎟⎢ − −                ⎥ = k 2t   (3)
                                                         ⎜ Co − Ce      ⎟ 2 3        2
                   Ore I
                                  Ore I        Ore I     ⎝          q   ⎠⎣                    ⎦
Component                      (-12.5+9.5    (-9.5+6.3
                  (Bulk)
                                  mm)           mm)      iii) Mixed control reaction, that is a combina-
   Fe2O3          31.84           31.94        29.09          tion of equations (2) and (3), based on the
    NiO            2.56            2.61         2.67          additivity of reaction times:
    SiO2          36.24
                                                                                          ⎡1 R ⎛1− R⎞2/3⎤
    CaO           traces
                                                                   [           ]
                                                                                  2
                                                              rd                 rd
                                                         ( i i ) 1−(1− R) +( i i ) ⋅⎢ − −⎜          ⎟ ⎥=t (4)
                                                                         1/3
   MgO            11.69                                   k1(Co −Ceq)        k2(Co −Ceq) ⎣⎢2 3 ⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎦⎥
   Al2O3           3.74
   Cr2O3           1.38                                     It is noted that the flow rate of the gaseous
   Mn3O4           0.39                                  reducing mixture CO/N2 -10 l/min- is in great
   L.O.I.         11.37                                  excess relative to the stoichiometrically required
3rd AMIREG International Conference (2009): Assessing the Footprint of                                                                                                                     461
Resource Utilization and Hazardous Waste Management, Athens, Greece
                           50                                                                                              50
                           45
                                    (a)                                                                                             (b)
                                                                                                                           45
                           40                                                                                              40
                                                                                                  Reduction Degree (R %)
  Reduction Degree (R %)
35 35
30 30
                           25                                                         750                                  25                                                         750
                                                                                      800                                  20                                                         800
                           20
                                                                                      900                                                                                             900
                                                                                                                           15
                           15
                                                                                                                           10
                           10                                                                                                                                Ore grain size: -9.5+6.3 mm
                                                             Ore grain size: -12.5+9.5 mm                                   5
                            5                                                                                                                                CO/N2 : 40/60% by volume
                                                              CO/N2 : 40/60% by volume
                                                                                                                            0
                            0                                                                                                   0         20   40                60         80              100
                                0         20   40                60          80             100
                                                                                                                                                    Time (min)
                                                    Time (min)
Figure 1: Reduction Degree as a function of time of the: (a) (-12.5 + 9.5) mm, (b) (-9.5 + 6.3) mm fraction of the ore.
amount of CO for the total transformation of the                                                     The reduction rate of Indonesian laterite is
ferric iron to metallic iron. Thus, we manage in                                                  significantly higher compared with the limonitic
this way to eliminate the effect of external mass                                                 type Greek nickeliferous laterites, which consti-
transfer on the process kinetics. Moreover, al-                                                   tute 80-90% of the laterite feed of the Rotary
though the effect of heat transfer was not inves-                                                 kilns in the Greek ferronickel industry (Zevgolis
tigated within the framework of the current                                                       et al., 2009). This can be attributed to the con-
work, it cannot be excluded as rate controlling                                                   siderably higher specific surface area of the Ore,
mechanism, since as reported, either thermal ra-                                                  determined by using the single- point Brunauer -
diation for higher temperatures (>1000oC) (Ray,                                                   Emmett - Teller (BET) method to be 162.6
1993), or conduction of heat in porous solids is                                                  m2/g, compared to the respective values fluctu-
a matter for investigation (Sun and Lu, 1999;                                                     ating among 15.5-26.5 m2/g for the same frac-
Huang, and Lu, 1993), can have a critical effect                                                  tion of the limonitic type Greek laterites. The
on reduction kinetics.                                                                            initial reduction rate of the examined Ore is
                                                                                                  comparable with that of the intermediate type of
                                                                                                  Greek nickeliferous laterite of Kastoria origin,
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION                                                                         in which goethite is also the main iron carrier
The results of the roasting reduction of the -12.5                                                mineral. Moreover, calcination prior to the re-
+ 9.5 and -9.5 + 6.3 mm fractions of the ore, ex-                                                 duction step, causes a decrease in the specific
pressed as reduction degree versus time, are                                                      surface area of the sample after goethite dehy-
presented in Figure 1. The experiments were                                                       droxylation at approximately 400 oC and proba-
carried out at the temperatures of 750, 800 and                                                   bly a coalescence of the narrow pores of the raw
900 oC.                                                                                           ore, due to high temperature treatment. This re-
   It is apparent from Figure 1 that reduction                                                    sults in an appreciable increase in total porosity
degree increases within the first 20 minutes of                                                   and the production of larger pores, which corre-
the process, and then reaction tends to equilib-                                                  spond to easier diffusitivity of the gaseous re-
rium, for all temperatures examined. From the                                                     ducing agent.
experimental results it was observed that maxi-                                                      The progress of iron metallization regarding
mum reduction degree achieved was 44% for                                                         the -9.5+6.3 mm reduced fractions after 90 min-
the -9.5+6.3 mm fraction. It is also noted that                                                   utes reduction, was determined by wet chemical
under the examined experimental conditions,                                                       analysis (ASTM E277, 1988; Xu et al., 2003),
temperature does not play an important role in                                                    as the ratio Femetal : Fetotal. The degree of metal-
the progress of the reduction, since the final re-                                                lization was: 10.11%, 10.44%, and 15.45% at
duction degree obtained was fluctuating be-                                                       750, 800 and 900 oC respectively. The above
tween 32.5 and 44%, in the temperature range                                                      values verify the reduction degree values calcu-
examined. Moreover, it is deduced by Figure 1                                                     lated by equation (1) according to the weight
that decrease of the ore grain size favors the                                                    loss technique, taking into consideration that a
progress of the reduction.                                                                        reduction degree of 33.3% corresponds to the
3rd AMIREG International Conference (2009): Assessing the Footprint of                                                                                           462
Resource Utilization and Hazardous Waste Management, Athens, Greece
total transformation of hematite to magnetite                                                                       min, since after 20 minutes the reduction proc-
and the start point for metallic iron formation.                                                                    ess practically tends to equilibrium.
The mineralogical characterization of the -                                                                            It is deduced that either the diffusion or the
12.5+9.5 mm reduced laterite fractions at the                                                                       mixed control kinetic mechanism -i.e. equations
temperature of 900 ºC, verified the presence of                                                                     (3) or (4)- seem to prevail. It should be noted
metallic iron (a-Fe) and magnetite (Fe3O4), as                                                                      though, that since equation (4) comes from the
the main iron-bearing mineral phases. Quartz,                                                                       combination of equations (2) and (3) and it is
olivine     [(MgFe)2SiO4]       and     pyroxene                                                                    not a mathematical model based on the intro-
[(Mg,Fe)SiO3] were also indentified.                                                                                duction of new physicochemical parameters of
   For the kinetic analysis of the experimental
                                                                                                                    the process, cannot give a clear picture whether
results, the kinetic model equations (2) - (4)
have been applied to the experimental data for                                                                      diffusion or surface chemical reaction phenom-
the temperatures of 750, 800 and 900 oC. The                                                                        ena constitute the controlling mechanism. The
kinetic model equations that best fit the experi-                                                                   conclusions, are in agreement with those drawn
mental data for the two examined fractions are                                                                      by former reducibility kinetic studies of Greek
presented in Figures 2 and 3, based on the ap-                                                                      nickeliferous laterites with solid reducing agents
plication of the least square method for the line-                                                                  (solid fuels) (Zevgolis et al., 2006b; Halikia
arity assessment of the kinetic equation dia-                                                                       et al., 1998) and gaseous reducing agent - (mix-
grams. The kinetic analysis of the experimental                                                                     ture of CO - N2).
data was conducted for the time period 2-20                                                                            Within the framework of further assessment
                                                                                                                    of the reduction kinetic data, a methodology of
                                  0.14                                                                              work was additionally used, for approaching the
                                  0.12                                                               2
                                                                                                                    rate controlling step of the process within the
                                                                                                    R = 0.9493
                                                  2
                                                                                                                    examined temperature range, based on the ap-
    1-(1-R) +1/2-R/3-[(1-R) ]/2
                                                 R = 0.9795                                2
 2/3
                                                                                         R = 0.9941
                                  0.10
                                                                                                                    plication of the diagnostic equation to the ex-
                                  0.08
                                                                                                         750        perimental data:
                                                                                                         800
                                  0.06                                                                   900        ln[− ln(1 − R )] = n ln t + ln b             (5)
 1/3
                                  0.04
                                                                                                                    where:
                                  0.02
                                                                               Ore grain size: -12.5+9.5 mm
                                                                                CO/N2 : 40/60% by volume
                                                                                                                       R: reduction degree (%) of iron oxides
                                                                                                                           calculated by equation (1)
                                  0.00
                                         0       5             10                15            20              25      t: time (sec)
                                                                    Time (min)                                         b: constant and
Figure 2: Kinetic models application to the experimental                                                               n: constant depending on the rate control-
data of the reduction of the (-12.5 + 9.5) mm fraction of                                                                  ling mechanism and the geometrical
the ore at the temperature of 750, 800 and 900 ºC.                                                                         characteristics of the ore.
                                  0.0120
                                                                                                                       The obtained ‘n’ values from application of
                                                                           2
                                                                          R = 0.9985
                                                                                                                    the experimental data R - t concerning the (-
                                  0.0100
                                                                                                                    9.5+6.3) mm fraction of the ore, which repre-
                                                                                                                    sent the slopes of the linear graphic representa-
  1/2-R/3-[(1-R) ]/2
                                  0.0080
                                                                                                                    tion of equation (5), are compared with the theo-
                                                                                                2
 2/3
R = 0.9966
Table 2: Theoretical and experimentally obtained ‘n’ Val-   increases with time. Moreover, it can be said
ues of the Kinetic Equations for Gas - Solid Reductive      that the diffusional resistance after 20 minutes is
Reaction.
                                                            such that the reaction practically tends to equi-
                                          Experimental
                                Theo-                       librium.
                                           ‘n’ Values
                                retical                        A metallographical section of grains of the
      Kinetic Equation                     Grain size:
                                  ‘n’                       reduced fraction -12.5+9.5 mm of the ore at
                                           (-9.5+6.3)
                                Values
                                               mm
                                                            800oC was studied by SEM/EDS (JEOL® JSM-
D1: (1-R) ln (1-R) + r = Kt      0.57
                                                            6380LV). A back-scattered electron image of a
D2: [1- (1-R)1/3]2 = Kt          0.54
                                                            partly reduced iron oxide grain, is presented in
                                          750oC: 0.66       Figure 4. This is a typical feature of a reduced
D3: 1- (2/3)R – (1-R)2/3 = Kt    0.57
                                          800oC: 0.49       ore grain when diffusion of the gaseous reduc-
F1: -ln(1-R) = Kt                 1.0
                                          900oC: 0.41       ing agent through the pores as well as through
R2: 1- (1-R)1/2 = Kt             1.11
R3: 1- (1-R)1/3 = Kt             1.07                       the iron product layer controls the process. As
                                                            can been seen, an unreacted core of the iron ox-
                                                            ide -magnetite and probably wuestite- is pre-
sion controlling step (Equations D1-D3).The Ar-             served; in the mantle area a metallic iron layer
rhenius activation energy values of the rate-               formed, whilst at the outermost rim of the grain
determining step at various conditions have                 the iron oxide remained unreduced . This indi-
been evaluated by considering the initial rate              cates that there is not just a certain reaction zone
values from the first two pairs of points in R - t          but the reducing agent penetrated through the
diagrams, i.e reduction degree values obtained              pores of the ore, as well as the cracks inside the
for t = 0 and t = 2 sec and calculating ”mean“              grain formed probably by the dehydroxylation
rate rmean as:                                              of goethite and its transformation to porous
          R − R0                                            hematite.     The     presence       of    pyroxene
rmean =                                             (6)     [(Mg,Fe)SiO3] detected by X-Ray analysis, was
          t − t0
                                                            also verified by SEM/EDS; it probably acted as
where R0 and t0 correspond to zero recovery and             an additional kinetic inhibitor for the diffusion
time respectively. Thus, the activation energy              of the gaseous reducing agent.
for the reduction of the two fractions (-                      The same reducibility tests were applied to
12.5+9.5) and (-9.5+6.3 mm), was determined                 pellets of the ore (diameter of -9.5 + 6.3 mm),
to be 0.88 and 6.73 kcal/mole respectively, by              for two temperature values (750 and 800 ºC).
                                                            Bentonite 1% by weight was used as a binding
the use of ”mean“ rate values, which are typical
                                                            agent. The kinetic curves of the process are pre-
values corresponding to the diffusion control-
                                                            sented in Figure 5. The kinetic model equations
ling step.
                                                            (2) - (4) that best fit the experimental data for
   The conclusion deduced by the kinetic as-
sessment of the experimental data, regarding the
prevalence of diffusion as the rate controlling
mechanism, also justifies the negligible effect of
temperature on the progress of the reduction
within the temperature range examined. On the
contrary, in case that the effect of the surface
chemical reaction was predominant, increase of
temperature should enhance the reduction rate.
Moreover, the reduction rate is favoured by the
decrease of the ore grain size, since decreasing
of the ore particle size, results in an increase of
the free surface and concequently the total rate
of reduction. The kinetic curves (Fig. 1), show
clearly that the reaction rate declines with time,
something which indicates that the diffusion                Figure 4: Back–scattered electron image of grains of the
path lengths and therefore diffusional resistance           (-12.5+9.5) mm fraction of the ore reduced at 8000C.
3rd AMIREG International Conference (2009): Assessing the Footprint of                                                                                                                                               464
Resource Utilization and Hazardous Waste Management, Athens, Greece
                           50
                                                                                                                  of the reduction. This is enhanced by the kinetic
                           45
                                                                                                                  assessment of the experimental data, conducted
                           40                                                                                     by the application of equations (2) - (4) (Fig. 6).
                                                                                                                  Thus, it is seen that for both temperatures, the
  Reduction Degree (R %)
                           35
                           30                                                                                     procedure is chemically controlled at the initial
                           25                                                                                     stage up to 20 minutes, justifying in such a way
                           20
                                                                                                   750
                                                                                                   800
                                                                                                                  the positive effect of temperature. This is
                           15                                                                                     probably attributed to the fact that the reductive
                           10                                                                                     gas penetrates easier through the spherical po-
                            5
                                                          Pellet diameter (from the ore): -9.5+6.3 mm             rous pellets contrary to the irregularly shaped
                                                                  CO/N2 : 40/60% by volume
                            0                                                                                     grains of the examined fraction of the bulk ore.
                                0               20       40                60            80              100      On the contrary, for the time range 20-60 min-
                                                              Time (min)
                                                                                                                  utes, till equilibrium is attained, the formation of
Figure 5: Reduction Degree as a function of time of the                                                           the iron layer probably renders the diffusion of
pellets of the Ore.                                                                                               CO as the controlling mechanism.
                                                                                                                                       0.01
                                                                                                                  2/3
                           0.08
 1/3
                                                                                                                                                                                              2
                                                                                                                                                                                            R = 0.9949
     1-(1-R)
                                                                                 2
                                                                                R = 0.9609         750                                 0.01
                           0.06                                                                    800                                                                                                               750
                                                                                                                                       0.01                                                                          800
                           0.04
                                                                                                                                       0.00
Figure 6: Kinetic models application to the experimental data of the reduction of pellets from the ore (diameter: -9.5 +
6.3 mm), for the time range: (a) 2-20 min, (b): 20-60 min.
3rd AMIREG International Conference (2009): Assessing the Footprint of                                          465
Resource Utilization and Hazardous Waste Management, Athens, Greece
pellets of the same origin and the same diame-                  tuating Temperature Conditions, Thermochimica
ter, showed that the final reduction degree ob-                 Acta, 111, pp. 143-166.
                                                             Zevgolis, E.N., C. Zografidis, J. Gaitanos, I.-P. Kostika
tained after 90 minutes reduction, was almost                   and I. Halikia 2006a. Energy requirements in nicke-
the same with that of the bulk ore.                             liferous laterite treatmen. Paper presented at the EPD
   The reductive procedure tends to equilibrium                 Congress, San Antonio, Texas, 12-16 March 2006, pp.
after 60 minutes and increase of temperature                    487-496.
among 750-800°C favours the progress of the                  Zevgolis, E.N., Ch. Zografidis, I. Halikia and E. Devlin,
reduction. This is indicative of the fact that as               2009. Roasting reduction study of Greek nickeliferous
                                                                laterites, Paper presented at the 138th TMS Congress,
verified by the kinetic analysis of the experi-                 San Francisco, California.
mental data, the procedure is chemically con-                Zevgolis, E.N., I. Halikia and I.-P. Kostika, 2006b. Re-
trolled up to the first 20 minutes. Later on, dif-              ductive behavior of the recycled dust during nicke-
fusion becomes the rate controlling step, till                  liferous laterite treatment, Erzmetall - The World of
equilibrium is attained.                                        Metallurgy, 59 (6), pp. 350-359.
                                                             Xu, Z., J. Hwang, R. Greenlund, X. Huang, J. Luo and S.
   The significantly higher reducibility of po-                 Anschuetz, 2003. Quantitative Determination of Me-
rous Indonesian laterite, where iron is mainly                  tallic Iron Content in Steel-Making Slag, Journal of
present in the form of goethite, than that of the               Minerals & Materials Characterization & Engineering,
Greek nickeliferous limonitic type laterites,                   2(1), pp. 65-70.
verifies the predominant effect that the physical
parameters such as specific surface area and po-
rosity have on the progress of the reduction.
REFERENCES
ASTM Standard E277, 1988. Test Method for Total Iron
   in Iron Ores by Stannous Chloride Reduction and Di-
   chromate Titration.
Halikia, I., P. Neou-Syngouna and M. Katapotis, 1998.
   Reductive Roasting of Iron-Nickel Ore Using Greek
   Lignite Thermodynamic and Kinetic Approach, ed.
   NTUA, In honor of Professor Emeritus of NTUA A.Z.
   Fragiskos, Athens, (Greek Text).
Huang, B-H. and W.-K. Lu, 1993. Kinetics and Mecha-
   nisms of Reactions in Iron Ore/Coal Composites, ISIJ
   International, 33 (10), pp. 1055-1061.
Hughes, R., et al., 1982. The Reduction of Iron Ores by
   Hydrogen and Carbon Monoxide and their Mixtures,
   Thermochimica Acta, 59, pp. 361-377.
Mondala, K., H. Lorethovab, E. Hippoa, T. Wiltowskia,
   and S.B. Lalvani, 2004. Reduction of iron oxide in
   carbon monoxide atmosphere-reaction controlled ki-
   netics, Fuel Processing Technology, 86, pp.33-47.
Moon, I.J. and C.H. Rhee, 1998. Reduction of hematite
   compacts by H2-CO gas mixtures, Paper presented at
   the TMS Annual Meeting, Orlando, 9-13 February,
   pp. 302-306.
Pineaua, A., N. Kanaria and I. Gaballah, 2006. Kinetics of
   reduction of iron oxides by H2. Part I: Low tempera-
   ture reduction of hematite, Thermochimica acta, 447,
   pp. 89-100.
Ray, H.S., 1993. Kinetics of metallurgical reactions, Ox-
   ford & IBH Publishing CO.PVT.LTD.
Sun, S. and W.-K. Lu, 1999. A Theoritical Investigation
   of Kinetics and Mechanisms of Iron Ore Reduction in
   an Ore/Coal Composite, ISIJ International, 39 (2), pp.
   123-129.
Swatantra Prakash and Hem Shanker Tay, 1987. Reduc-
   tion of Iron Ore Under Rising Temperature and Fluc-