The Characteristics and Engineering Properties of Soft Soil at Cyberjaya
The Characteristics and Engineering Properties of Soft Soil at Cyberjaya
                                                             Abstract
           This paper provides information on the distribution and characteristics of peat and organic soil which is distributed
      around the Multimedia Super Corridor area. Peat and organic soils are the ultimate soft soils in engineering terms. The
      behavior of peat and organic soils is usually determined using the concepts and methods developed for inorganic soil.
      However, important anomalies exist, and these are given emphasis in the present overview of the mechanical behavior
      of these soils. Peat and organic soils are difficult to sample and test using normal soil techniques, and in fact there is
      not even an adequate engineering system in place for classifying these soils. The characteristics and engineering
      properties of these soils are presented with respect to its earthwork and geotechnical performance. A preliminary
      classification system of these soils are also proposed.
          I
              ,.! ...}
      /
          '.  .
                                                                                        J4ead:
                                                                                                  Korm:y l:lill Formation
                                                                                        c:::J     (Schilt. pbylilo, quaaitc and •W..)
                                                                                                  Shallow d<:plb of
                                                                                        ~         Sot\ DlJitnlilll {2.-3ru)
Figure I: Map show ing the geology and soil distribution in the stu dy area.
    The deposition of soft soil in the site are in single                                      Ground Water
layers of 2.0 m to 25.0 min thickness.
                                                                                                  In the plains and valleys, the groundwater level is
Residual Soil, Colluvium and Bedrock                                                          generally near to the ground surface, at depths of at between
                                                                                              0.1 m and 0.5 m. The level is slightly lower at the upper
     The high ground in the study area rises between 30 m
                                                                                              end of some valleys but even then it is not more than I m
to 150m. This high ground is mainly covered by residual
                                                                                              in depth.
soils, derived from the weathering of foliated
metasedimentary rock, which occur as a series of parallel
hills aligned in a south-easterly to north westerly direction
                                                                                                            SOFT SOIL DESCRIPTION, TEST
with a dip of between 65° and 95°. The metasedimentary                                                      METHOD AND CLASSIFICATION
rocks are inferred to be of the Kenny Hill Formation
comprising essentially sandstone, shale, phyllite and                                          Description
quartzite (Plate 2). The denudation of residual soils has led                                      Soft clay is defined as soils with large fractions of fine
to the formation of the present valley systems. This contact                                  particles such as silty and clayey soils, which have high
zone between the soft sediments and the residual soils is                                     moisture content, peat foundations and loose sand deposits,
quite complex and an overlying deposit of colluvium                                           located near or under the water table (Kamon and Bergado,
generally masks its location.                                                                 1991).
     The colluvium is generally encountered as soft to stiff                                       Any discussion on construction involving peats or soft
silty clay overlying medium dense to dense very clayey                                        soils requires a definition of the terms used to describe
gravel or sand. The residual soil is typically firm to stiff,                                 these materials. Depending on the geographic origin and
becoming very stiff and hard sand silty clay with increasing                                  training of the engineer or geoscientist involved, a "peat/
depth. Residual soil eventually grades into moderately to                                     soft soil" may be defined as soil with an organic content
completely weathered rock, a hard dense clayey sand or                                        greater than anywhere from 20% to 70% of the total weight.
sandy silt but generally only at depths greater than 20 m.                                    At worst "peat/soft soil" may be used interchangeably with
                                                                   USCS Classification
                                                                        This classification is used by most engineers. It is
                                                                   outlined in Tables 2 and 3. The definition of having greater
Plate I: Peat at the proposed Cyberjaya Park, Cybetjaya Flagship
                                                                   than 75 % organic content, is most commonly used by
Zone.                                                              engineers in North America, ASTM D4427, Classification
                                                                   of Peat Samples by Laboratory Testing, is described as
                                                                   follows:
                                                                   (a) Slightly Organic Silts or Clays will most probably
                                                                        appear as inorganic fine grained soils, probably black
                                                                        or dark brown in colour, have an organic odor and
                                                                        possibly some visible organic remains. Their plasticity
                                                                        limits should be evaluated as for other fine grained
                                                                        inorganic soils. These soil would then be classified as
                                                                        silts or clays of low, medium or high plasticity , for
                                                                        example ML, CH. It is suggested that a small "o" be
                                                                        appended to indicate that they are slighty organic
                                                                        differentiate them from purely inorganic soils, MLo
                                                                        and CHo.
                                                                   (b) Peat on the other hand may well appear to be completely
                                                                        organic, contain recognizable plant remains, have a
Plate 2: View of the Kenny Hill Formation at the Cyberjaya Park.        low density and also black or dark brown. Following
                                                                        a Von Post test it could be categorised as listed in
the term "organic soil" to describe any soil that appears to            Tables 3 and 4.
have some organic content. In the Unified Soil Classification           Thus, for example, a peat could be described as a
System (USCS) peats are described as soils consisting                   Fibrous Peat and given a symbol, Ptf.
"predominantly" of plant remains, often with a distinctive         (c) Organic Soils is more difficult to sub-divide lying , as
smell. Organic clay, silt or sand contains "substantial                 it does, between the other two categories. There is
amounts" of vegetable matter.                                           insufficient infmmation at present to determine whether
                                                                        this group can be meaningfully sub categorised.
Test Method                                                             Currently, for these materials, an attempt should be
    The following parameters were determined to                         made to provide both the Atterberg Limits and the
characterize the soft soil:                                             Degree of Humification to allow establishment of a
    Water content : The water content is measured using                 database from which future analyses can be made . In
    procedures specified in ASTM D2974 orBS 1377.                       fact, it may be that neither of these tests work for the
    Organic Content : As a percentage of dry weight. The                Organic Soil category. The degree of humification is
    organic content is measured in the laboratory using a               only meaningful for soils that are predominantly
    Loss on Ignition Test, ASTM D2974 orBS 1377 Part                    organic. The presence of inorganic material tends to
    3(4), or a Chemical Oxidation Test, BS 1377 Part 3(3).              confuse the interpretation of the degree of humification.
•   Degree ofHurnification (Decomposition) of the organic               Similarly the Atterberg limits are only truly meaningful
    material. The degree of humification represents the                 for soil that are primarily inorganic and the presence
    degree to which the organic remains have decayed.                   of organic material may well interfere with those tests.
    The range lies between fresh plant remains and a
    completely decayed visibly amorphous material with             VARIATION OF SOFT SOIL PROPERTIES
    no recognizable plant structure. Where a soft so il/peat
    lies within this spectrum radically affects its engineering        The so il data in this paper is from pre-construction and
    behaviour. In the field it may be assessed by the Von          construction soil investigations conducted for the Cyberjaya
    Post Squeeze Test. A sample of the peat is squeezed in         Development project. Unlike other construction materials ,
                                                               Geological Society of Malaysia Annual Geological Conference 2000
                               THE CHARACTERISTIC AND ENGINEERING PROPERTIES OF SOFT SOIL                                              317
  Degree of
                                                                       Description
 Humitication
                Completely undecomposed peat which releases almost clear water. Plant remains easily identifiable. No amorphous
        HI
                material present.
                Almost completely undecomposed peat, which releases clear or yellowish water. Plant remains still easily between
        H2      the fingers. Plant remains still easily identifiable. No amorphous material present.
                Very slightly decomposed peat which releases muddy brown water, but for which no peat passes between the fingers.
        H3
                Plant remains still identifiable and no amorphous material present
                Slightly decomposed peat, which releases very muddy dark water. No peat is passed between the fingers but the
        H4
                plant remain are slightly pasty and have lost some of identifiable features.
                Moderately decomposed peat which releases very "muddy" water with also a very small amount of amorphous
        H5      granular peat escaping between the fingers. The structure of plant remains is quite indistinct, although it is still
                possible certain features. The residue is strongly pasty.
                Moderately strongly decomposed peat with a very indistinct plan structure. When squeezed, about one-third of the
        H6      peat escapes between the finger. The residue is strongly pasty but shows the plant structure more distinctly than
                before squeezing.
                Strongly decomposed peat. Contains a Jot of amorphous material with very faintly recognizable plant structure.
        H7      When squeezed, about one-half of the peat escapes between the fingers. The water, if any is released, is very dark
                and almost pasty.
                Very strongly decomposed peat with a large quantity of amorphous material and very dry indistinct plant structure.
                When squeezed, about two-third of the peat escapes between the fingers. A small quantity of pasty water may be
        H8
                released. The plant material remaining in the hand consists of residual such as roots and fibers that resist
                decomposition.
                Practically fully decomposed peat in which there is hardly any recognizable plant structure. When squeezed, almost
        H9
                all of the peat escapes between the fingers as a fairly uniform paste.
                Completely decomposed peat with no discernible plant structure. When squeezed, all the wet peat escapes between
        HIO
                the fingers.
                Table 2: Organic content of soil.                     2% and 25%. On the other hand, the clay content increases
                                                                      with depth to a depth of 16m from 25 % and 75%.
                                                  Organic
   Basic Soil Type           Descriptor                                    The variations of the Atterberg limit increases with
                                                 Content(%)
                                                                      depth (Figure 6). The typical range of plastic limit (PL) is
 Clay or Silt or Sand     Slightly Organic           3-20             between 10% and 80% while for the liquid limit (LL) it is
 Organic Soil               Organic Soil            20-75             between 10% and 90%. The plastic index (PI) is from 3%
 Peat                            Peat                                 and 50%. The liquid limit increases with depths, reflecting
                                                      >75
                                                                      the decrease in sand content with depth.
                                                                           Figures 7 shows the variation between the following
soft soil is non-homogeneous and its properties are highly            compressibility parameters: compression index (Cc), the
variable and complex.                                                 recompression index (Cr), and the coefficient of
     The distribution of the soft soil ranges from fibrous to         consolidation (Cv) against depth. Generally, the
amorphous and consists of peat, clay and silt (Table 5 and            compressibility parameters increase with depth. This
Figure 3). Some engineering properties of the soft soil               increase is consistent with the effect of the increase in
identified from boreholes is shown in Table 6. The natural            moisture content with depth and the decrease in the sand
water contents are greater than liquid limits at most depths.         content with depth.
The natural moisture content of the Cyberjaya soft soil is                 The variation of recompression ratio (Cr) with depth
extremely variable and range between 10% to 700%. Figure              indicates that there are no obvious trends between the
4 shows the trend decreasing with depth. The high water               recompression ratio (Cr) and depth. Consequently, the
content is due to the nature of soft soil characteristics and         variability in this measure is more a function of the soil test
its location below the water table.                                   than soil properties.
     Wet seiving was used to obtain the grading curves                     The preconsolidation pressure (Pc) is important in
shown in Figure 5. Grain size distribution range from sand            determining the settlement of soft soil under external loading.
to clay size. The profiles show decreasing clay content and           Figure 8 shows the trend between preconsolidation pressure
increasing silt content with depth, i.e. upper parts of               (Pc) and depth. The trend shows a general increase in Pc
distribution profile have higher clay content than lower              with increasing depth. Ho and Dobie (1990) describe how
part. The clay content generally decreases with depth, from           uniform incremental loading can be used to determine Pc
Table 4: Malaysian Soil Classification Systems for engineering purposes and their field identification for organic soils and peat (after JKR and Jarrett, 1995)
3.50- 3.95 Dark grey soft sandy silty CLAY Organic Soil - H3 Fibrous f
• • ~...
                                       -·'
                               2.00                                                                   2.00
                                              ~-~
                               4.00                                                                   4.00                          .s.
                               6.00
                                       i~                                                             6.00
                                                                                                                                    ~
                                                                                                                                     7.
                                                                                                                                     ~
                        g 8.00
                        '8. 10.00      '
                                       )
                                                                                               g
                                                                                               £
                                                                                                      8.00
                                                                                                     10.00
                                                                                                                                   .....
                         CD
                        0 12.00
                                       ••                                                      c..
                                                                                               CD                                    •·--•
                                                                                               0 12.00
                              14.00    •                                                             14.00
                                                                                                                                         ••
                              16.00
                                          •                                                          16.00
                                                                                                                                    •
                              18.00
                                       •                                                             18.00
                                                                                                                                         •
                              20.00                                                                  20.00
Figure 3: Plots of moisture content and bulk density with depth (m).
                                                                                                                                                   ........
         0.00
2.00
         4.00
                    ••••
                      1..
                    t.•:.
                                                                2.00               ...•_. .. •••• ..••• •                               2.00
                                                                                                                                        4.00
                                                                                                                                                       . .:-
                                                                                                                                                     • •
                                                                                                                                                   • ••••
                                                                   4.00
                                                                                                   ••• •
         6.00
                     .,
                    •••"#• •
                      ~··
                      ~
                                                                6.00
                                                                                    •     • I     .....
                                                                                         I • ......
                                                                                                                                        6.00
                                                                                                                                                    .· .......
                                                                                                                                                       'f' ••
 ~
         8.00
                    ••                   •               ~
                                                                8.00
                                                                                         •• •            •                    ~
                                                                                                                                        8.00               rl'l' •
 £      10.00       • \                                  t    10.00                  •               •           •            £        10.00           •         •       •
                    • •                                                                                  •                                                           •
                      ..
  D..                                                                                                                         D..
 0
  Q)
        12.00
                                                         Q)
                                                         0    12.00
                                                                                    •                                         Q)
                                                                                                                              0        12.00
                                                                                                                                                       •
        14.00                                                 14.00
                                                                                                                  ••                   14.00
                                                                                                                                                            ••
        16.00
                               •                              16.00
                                                                                                             •                         16.00
                                                                                                                                                            •
        18.00
                           •                                  18.00
                                                                                                             •                         18.00
                                                                                                                                                               •
        20.00                                                 20.00                                                                    20.00
more accurately than recognized international standards. In                                  high illite. Figure 10 shows the relationship between the
this trend, Pc for soft soil deposits may be determined together                             plasticity index, percentage of clay fraction and the activity
with the extent to which it will consolidate. This is extremely                              of the clay. The figure indicates that the clay samples from
useful when any ground treatment is to be undertaken.                                        this soft soil have activities ranging from 0.2 to more than
      The plasticity chart plot (Figure 9) shows that the soft                               2.0. The liquidity index falls in the low expansion to medium
soil material are variable. Generally, the soft soil material                                expansion categories.
can be classified as very low plastic to highly plastic. The                                      Figure 11 shows that soft soils have range from inorganic
influence of increasing clay content on the plasticity index                                 clays of high plasticity limits into inorganic silts of high
is also depicted in Figure 9. In accordance with Skempton                                    compressibility and organic clays. The Cyberjaya soft soils
(1953), the activity index (AI) is an indicator of clay                                      is similar to the organic silt and clay of Venezuela Clay and
mineralogy. A high activity index (AI > 1.25) usually                                        New London Clay.
denotes montmorillonite, while a low activity index (AI <
0.75) denotes kaolinite.                                                                                          SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION
      The results from the study area, shows that the soft soil
have a high activity index (AI> 1.25), even though the clay                                      This paper provides an overview of the distribution
mineralogy of the soft soils comprise mainly kaolinite and                                   and characteristics of soft soil in Cyberjaya, with emphasis
                                                                                         ...-                                                             ..
          0.00 -~-~-~~-~---1                                                     0.00   -r-~-~-~~~~--;                                    0.00 -r--~--~-~---~
          2.00
                 •••• •                                                          2.00                                                     2.00
                                                                                                                                                                 •
          4.00
                     •                                                           4.00                                                     4.00
                                                                                                                                                                      •
                                         ••                                                         ••                                                  • • ••••
          6.00
                     '
                          • ••
                                     •                                           6.00   ,.•• •                                            6.00
                                                                                 6.00                                                     6.00
    ~
          6.00
                                 •                                         ~                 •                                     ~                •
    :5
     Q.
        10.00        •                                                     :5
                                                                            Q.
                                                                               10.00     •                                         :5
                                                                                                                                    Q.
                                                                                                                                       10.00                     •
    Q)                                                                     Q)                                                      Q)
         16.00
                                 •                                              16.00
                                                                                             •                                          16.00
                                                                                                                                                                          •
         16.00                                                                  16.00                                                   16.00
                                                  •
                                                              -    •                                         50
                          2.00
                                                                       •
                          4.00
                                                      .,.I
                          6.00                •                    • ••
                          6.00
                 ~                                    •
                 :5
                  Q.
                     10.00                                             •
                 Q)
                 0       12.00                                                                               10
14.00
                         16.00
                                                              •                                                     10   20   30     40       50       60
                                                                                                                                          Liquid Lirrit (%)
                                                                                                                                                            70       80    90   100   110    120
                         16.00                                                                           Figure 8: Modified plasticity chart for use with Unified Soil
                                                                                                         Classification system. Soil represented by points within shaded area
                         20.00   ,L__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___J
                                                                                                         are considered borderline and are given dual symbols (after USBR,
                                                                                                         1974). Note: L:low; !:intermediate; H:high; V :very high; E:extremely
Figure 7: Plot ofpreconsolidation pressure (Pc) with depth.
                                                                                                         high; M:silt; and C:clay.
on its anomalies relative to the behaviour of inorganic                                                  •    Methods of analysis have been developed that will
clays. Some of the anomalies and outstanding characteristics                                                  allow greater confidence in design involving these soft
as well as the research needs are listed below:                                                               soils.
                                                                                                         •    Water content can be used to identify and compare the
•        Deposits of peat and organic soils are extremely                                                     range of different soft soils by using the Atterberg
         variable, large differences occur over centimeters or                                                Limit characteristics.
         decimeters. The variability extends throughout all scales                                       •    The distribution of Cyberjaya soft soil ranges from
         up to the kilometer scale in many cases.                                                             fibrous to amorphous and consists of peat, clay and
•        Any site investigation involving organic soils must                                                  silt.
         involve measurement of the organic content of all                                               •    Generally, Cyberjaya soft soil material can be classified
         forms of organic soil and the degree of humification of                                              as very low plastic to highly plastic.
         soft soil. A rational engineering classification system                                         •    Cyberjaya soft soils is similar to organic silt and clay
         must be adopted for soils with an organic content.                                                   of Venezuela Clay and New London Clay.
         ••r----n.----,-----r-----r,~--,-----~--~r----,----~
                                                                                                                                            There is a need for detailed mapping of the Cyberjaya
                                                                                                                                       area to determined the extent of the terrain that is covered
         50                                                                                                                            by peat, as defined from the engineering and geology
                                                                                                                                       perspectives. Isopach contours to delineated the thickness
 ~··                                                                                                                                   of the peat should also be established. In addition, other
 I
 ~30
                                                                                                                                       varieties of soft soils should be delineated.
 ~
 ~       20                                                                                                                                          ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
                                                                    .:.--.:::-1··~
                        -;-r=~..-;:::::-.~---r -.-..-·~"!>~
                                                                                     0       ••          •         ..
         10
                                                              I I I I I I                                                                   John Wiley & Sonc, Inc.
                                                                                                                                       Ho, H .S ., & Dobie, MJ .D., 1990. Consolidation testing: alternative
                                                       -    lno~BniClis-of¥eCuU'"jCOmP1ssibH-,~-
                                                            an1 Organt Silts             1          1                                       loading pressure for soft clays in Proceedings. Seminar on
                                                                                                                                            Geotechnical Aspects of the North South Expressway,
                   10      20         30   40       50       60          70              60        90        100        110   120           November 1990, Kuala Lumpur. (Unpublished),hlm. 135-
                                                Liquid Lirrit, wl
                                                                                                                                            139.
Figure 10: Correlation between the Atterberg limits using the                                                                          Anderson, J.A.R. 1983. Tropical peat swamp, bog, fen and moor,
plasticity chart (after Casagrande, 1932 in Terzaghi & Peck, 1995).                                                                         Regional Studies. Amsterdam: Elsevier Scientific Publishing
                                                                                                                                            Company.
                                                                                                                                       Jabatan Kerja Raya Malaysia and Jarret, P.M.l995, Geoguide 6:
         60                                                                                                                                 Site Investigation for Organic Soils and Peats,JKR Document
                                                                                                                                            20709-0341,95.
          50
                                                                                                                                       Kamon, M. And Bergado, D.T. 1991. Ground Improvement
                                                                                                                                            Techniques. Proc. 9 1h Asian Regional Conf.Soil
                                                                                                                                            Mech.Found.Eng'g., Bangkok, Thailand, 2. 526-546.
  ~40                                                                                                                                  N.B.Hobbs. 1986. "Mire morphology and the properties and
  ~c:                                                                                                                                       behaviour of some British and Foreign Peats", Quarternary
  ~30                                                                                                                                       Jour of Eng. Geo.l9(4): 7-80.
  :g              Gltal   cia~ (Bosi:;;;J:it,                                                                                          Skempton, A.W., 1953. 'The colloidal Activity of clay'. Proc. 3rd
                  Chk:aAO &Canada)
  ~                                                                                                                                         Int. Conf. On Soil Mechanics & Foundation Engineering, 1,
  0..20
                   -1- j -·I- -N""--A!                                                                                                      57-61.
                                                                                                                                       U .S.Bureau ofReclamation., 1974. Earth Manual,2"ded. Washington
          10
                                                                                                                                            D.C.,8l0
              0             7.
                   10       20        30   40        50     60           70              80         90       100        110   120
                                                Liquid Lirrit(%)