1: FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND FINANCIAL OBJECTIVES
1 Financial objectives
1.1 Profit maximisation is often assumed to be the main objective of a business. However,
shareholders sometimes express disappointment in a company's performance even when
profits are rising; this suggests that profit is not sufficient as a business objective.
Lecture example 1 Idea generation
Banana Co has just released its financial results for the year and its profits before tax increased by
38% over the previous year. This was due largely to a doubling of sales in South-East Asia.
However, the share price in Banana Co fell by almost 20% immediately after the profit
announcement.
Required
Which of the following is the LEAST likely explanation for the fall in share price?
A. Sales in South-East Asia had been expected to increase by more than 100%.
B. The depreciation charge was higher due to a change in accounting policy.
C. The level of Banana Co's business risk has increased over the year.
D. Delays in the launch of new products are expected in the coming year.
Solution
1.2 For a profit-making company, maximisation of shareholder wealth is assumed to be the
financial objective. The ability of a firm to create wealth for shareholders is measured by
total shareholder return.
2 A framework for maximising shareholder wealth
dividend+ change in share price
Total shareholder return =
share price at the start of the year
Maximisation of
shareholder wealth
Investment decision Financing decision Dividend decision
(and risk management)
17
1: FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND FINANCIAL OBJECTIVES
Investment decisions
2.1 Investment decisions (in projects, takeovers or working capital) need to be analysed to
ensure that they are beneficial to the investor; this is covered in later chapters.
2.2 Investments can help a firm to achieve key corporate objectives such as market share and
quality; these will be monitored by the management accounting department. Investments
also help a firm to achieve key financial objectives such as improving earnings per share.
Lecture example 2 Exam standard Section B 6 marks
Magneto plc has objectives to improve earnings per share and dividends per share by 10% p.a.
Last year Current year
$m $m
Profits before interest and tax 22,300 23,726
Interest 3,000 3,000
Tax 5,790 6,218
Profits after interest and tax 13,510 14,508
Preference dividends 200 200
Dividends 7,986 8,585
Retained earnings 5,324 5,723
No. of ordinary shares issued (millions) 100,000 100,000
Ordinary share price at the end of the year $4.70 $5.16
Required
1. What is the current year earnings per ordinary share?
A. 14.5 cents
B. 14.3 cents
C. 5.7 cents
D. 5.3 cents
2. What is the growth in the dividend per ordinary share?
A. 0%
B. 8.0%
C. 8.6%
D. 7.5%
3. What is the total shareholder return in the current year?
A. 11.6%
B. 10.6%
C. 9.8%
D. 1.8%
18
1: FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND FINANCIAL OBJECTIVES
Solution
Section 1.5
Financing decision
2.3 Financing decisions mainly focus on how much debt a firm should use, and aim to
minimise the cost of capital. This is covered in later chapters.
2.4 Other issues here can include risk management (again covered later) and financial
planning and control (covered in the chapters on working capital management).
Dividend decision
2.5 The dividend decision is determined by how much a firm has decided to spend on
investments and how much of the finance needed for this it has decided to raise externally,
and is a good example of the interrelationship between these three decisions. The dividend
decision is covered in Chapter 13.
3 Encouraging shareholder wealth maximisation
Agency theory
3.1 Why do managers (and other agents of the shareholders, such as employees) sometimes
have different objectives?
Unless they are also owners of the business, managers may prefer to:
(a) Maximise short-term profits – to trigger bonuses
(b) Minimise dividends – to free up funds to use within the business
(c) Reduce risk by diversifying – but shareholders can do this themselves
(d) Boost their own pay and perks
(e) Avoid debt finance – to avoid the need for careful cash management
3.2 The danger that managers may not act in the best interest of shareholders is referred to as
the agency problem. It can be dealt with by monitoring the actions of management
performance or by the use of incentive schemes; these are discussed below.
19
1: FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND FINANCIAL OBJECTIVES
Corporate governance
3.3 In the UK corporate governance regulations have been designed to monitor the actions
of management. Here are some of the main requirements:
Board of directors Key committees
Separate MD and chairman Remuneration committee
Minimum 50% non-executive directors Pay and incentives of executive
(NEDs) directors
Chairman independent Audit committee
Max one year notice period Risk management
NEDs should be independent (three NEDs only
year contract, no share options) Nomination committee
Choice of new directors
Lecture example 3 Exam standard Section A 2 marks
The following statements have been made about corporate governance.
(1) Sound systems of corporate governance involve the establishment of risk management and
internal control procedures for the organisation.
(2) Good corporate governance requires the organisation to always act in an ethically
acceptable manner even if that is contrary to the law.
(3) A non-executive director should not be paid for his services to the organisation in order to
keep him independent.
Required
Which of these statements is/are correct?
A (1) and (2) only
B (1), (2) and (3)
C (1) only
D (3) only
Solution
20
1: FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND FINANCIAL OBJECTIVES
Incentive schemes
3.4 There are two main types of incentive schemes that you need to be aware of:
(a) Performance-related pay – against either profit or a strategic performance measure
(b) Share options – options to buy shares in say three years' time at today's share price
4 Needs of other stakeholders
4.1 Stakeholders are defined as 'any groups affected by the activities of the firm'. They can be
classified as:
(a) Internal – staff, managers
(b) Connected – finance providers (shareholders, banks), customers, suppliers
Section 3
(c) External – government, trade unions, pressure groups
4.2 Shareholders are normally the most important stakeholder group, but the interests of other
stakeholders are often important too. To ensure that the interests of these other stakeholder
groups are not neglected, non-financial objectives can be used; here are some examples:
(a) Staff – staff turnover
(b) Bank – gearing, interest cover
(c) Customers – liquidity ratios, complaints, market share
(d) Suppliers – payables (creditor) days
4.3 Note that there is often a conflict between stakeholder objectives, eg profit to
shareholders and pay rises to staff. This will require the development of acceptable
compromises eg pay rises linked to productivity gains.
5 Measuring the achievement of stakeholder objectives
5.1 As indicated above, ratio analysis is often used by stakeholders to assess the performance
of a company. Ratios are normally split into four categories:
(a) Profitability – important to assess managerial performance
(b) Debt – important to banks
(c) Liquidity – important to suppliers and customers
(d) Shareholder investor ratios – important to shareholders
5.2 Profitability ratios include:
ROCE = Profit from operations %
Capital employed
ROCE = Profit from operations Revenue
Revenue Capital employed
Profit margin Asset turnover
21
1: FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND FINANCIAL OBJECTIVES
Return on capital employed (ROCE) should ideally be increasing. If it is static or reducing it
is important to determine whether this is due to a reduced profit margin or asset turnover. If
both profit margin and asset turnover are getting worse then the company has a profitability
problem. Profit from operations = before interest and tax.
Profits after interest and tax
ROE (return on equity) =
Shareholder funds
5.3 Debt ratios include:
Gearing = Book value of debt
Book value of equity
(alternatively this could be debt/(debt + equity) and could use market values – so read the
question carefully)
Interest cover = Profit from operations
Interest
5.4 Liquidity ratios include:
Current ratio = Current : Current
assets liabilities
Acid Test ratio = Current : Current
assets (less inventory) liabilities
5.5 Shareholder investor ratios include:
Dividend yield = Dividend per share ×100
Market price per share
Profits distributable to ordinary shareholders
Earnings per share (EPS) =
Number of ordinary shares issued
Price/earnings (P/E) ratio = Market price per share
EPS
The value of the P/E ratio reflects the market's appraisal of the share's future prospects –
the more highly regarded a company, the higher will be its share price and its P/E ratio.
Lecture example 4 Home study
Summary financial information for Robertson plc is given below, covering the last two years.
Previous year Current year
£'000 £'000
Turnover 43,800 48,000
Cost of sales 16,600 18,200
Salaries and wages 12,600 12,900
Other costs 5,900 7,400
Profit before interest and tax 8,700 9,500
Interest 1,200 1,000
Tax 2,400 2,800
Profit after interest and tax 5,100 5,700
Dividends payable 2,000 2,200
22
1: FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND FINANCIAL OBJECTIVES
Previous year Current year
£'000 £'000
Shareholders' funds 22,600 25,700
Long-term debt 11,300 9,000
Number of shares in issue ('000) 9,000 9,000
P/E ratio (average for year)
Robertson plc 17.0 18.0
Industry 18.0 18.2
Required
Review Robertson's performance using profit, debt, and shareholder investor ratios, and assess its
total shareholder return in the current year.
Solution
23
1: FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND FINANCIAL OBJECTIVES
6 Not for profit organisations
Value for money
6.1 Many organisations are not for profit; in this case a more appropriate objective is to make
sure that the organisation is getting good value for money; economy, efficiency,
effectiveness.
Section 6
(a) Economy – purchase of inputs of appropriate quality at minimum cost
(b) Efficiency – use of these inputs to maximise output
(c) Effectiveness – use of these inputs to achieve its goals (quality, speed of response)
6.2 When the existence of not for profit organisations is taken into account then we need to
recognise that financial management is not always about shareholder wealth maximisation.
A more complete definition of the primary objective of financial management is:
'the efficient acquisition and deployment of financial resources to achieve an
organisation's key objectives'.
7 Chapter summary
Section Topic Summary
1 Objectives The prime financial objective of a profit-making company
is to maximise shareholder wealth; this can be
measured by total shareholder return.
2 Framework for To maximise shareholder wealth an organisation must
achieving take sensible investment, financing, risk
objectives management and dividend decisions.
3 Encouraging Corporate governance regulations and incentive
shareholder schemes are used to check that shareholder wealth
wealth maximisation is taken seriously.
maximisation
4 Needs of other Internal – staff, managers
stakeholders
Connected – finance providers, customers, suppliers
External – government, trade unions, pressure groups
5 Ratio analysis To assess the impact of these decisions on shareholders
and other stakeholders, it is important to monitor profit,
debt, liquidity and shareholder ratios. These ratios are
not given in the exam and need to be learnt.
6 Not for profit Economy – purchase of inputs of appropriate quality at
organisations minimum cost
Efficiency – use of these inputs to maximise output
Effectiveness – use of these inputs to achieve its goals
(quality, speed of response)
END OF CHAPTER
24
