Marital Adjustment, Mental Health and Frustration Reactions During Middle Age
Marital Adjustment, Mental Health and Frustration Reactions During Middle Age
ISSN 2250-3153
Abstract- The present research was taken up with broad objective at some point (usually at about age 40 years). A mid-life crisis is
to study the marital adjustment, mental health and frustration an emotional state of doubt and anxiety in which a person
reactions in different age groups of middle age from Delhi, India. becomes uncomfortable with the realization that life is halfway
The sample comprised of 300 middle aged subjects (n=300) over.
which are bank employees, doctors and lecturers, within the age
range of 40-55 years from Delhi, India. It was seen that subjects
from AR1 (40-47 years) indicated better recreational adjustment, II. RATIONAL
role distribution and autonomy than age group AR2 (48-55 Human beings constantly have to adjust to various roles,
years). environmental demands and pressures. Throughout the course of
life, human beings strive for well-being and happiness in various
Index Terms- India, Marital adjustment, Mental health, spheres of life - personal, social, economic, marital and work.
Frustration Reaction, Middle age. Achievement and success in these spheres lead to satisfaction in
life, whereas inadequacy to do the same leads in frustration. In
the present modern era, professionals like bank employees,
I. INTRODUCTION doctors and lecturers have to spend more time at their work place
www.ijsrp.org
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 3, Issue 9, September 2013 2
ISSN 2250-3153
Sexual compatibility and mutual enjoyment is an important which the individual realizes his or her own abilities, can cope
factor contributing to the success of most marital relationship, with the normal stresses of life, can work productively, fruitfully
Job of spouse, shape families in a variety of ways. Two major and is able to make a contribution to his/her community (The
aspects of work directly affect family life: (1) the level of world health reports 2001). Mental health covers an elusive and
economic rewards associated with work and (2) the conditions diffuse field and the term in itself encompasses a multiplicity of
associated with performing a job. meaning.
Blanofield (1967) defined mental health as a composite of
Marital conflicts attitude towards oneself, ability to realize once potential through
No matter how satisfactory and inevitable marriage is, action, degree of independence form social influence and the
some conflict theorists assert that marital relationships reflect and ability to perceive realistically the world around. Fergson (1965)
reinforce gender inequalities (Degler, 1980). Examples that stated that mental health is the ability to cope with one's
support such an assertion are: (1) until the past few years, a environment in such a way that one's institutional drives are
husband could rape his wife and not be charged; (2) in traditional gratified. They considered that mental illness and mental health,
marriage vows the bride is given away to the groom; and (3) the are two opposite ends of the continuum on which any individual
woman has traditionally taken the surname of the husband after can be placed depending on the soundness of his mind. There is a
marriage. Conflict theory helps to explain the extent of violence general agreement that two terms mental health and mental
in families, where care and cooperation are supposed to exist ¬ illness refer to behaviors which are interpersonal in nature and to
something not easily explained by functionalist theory. Good mental illness is judged to be dysfunctional according to the
communication skills do not prevent conflict. Actually a conflict, norms of an observer.
followed by a confrontation, can produce positive results. Matsuoka (1996) conducted a study on 58 middle aged
Fujihara (1998) did a study on 153 married couples which people to determine the degree to which family cohesion
showed that marital adjustment was significantly correlated with accounted for different outcome measures of mental health
subcategories of social adjustment (1) household adjustment among native Hawiian families on an island on the verge of
(except the spouse), (2) external family adjustment, (3) work major tourism development. This development will cause
adjustment, (4) social leisure adjustment and (5) general economic changes that will pose major challenges for the native
adjustment. Thus, marital adjustment may be a part of social agrarian families. A series of interviews of focus groups elicited
adjustment for women, but the two may be discrete for men. A qualitative information on the relationship between family
study, made on 1,609 couples from the Russian Army, found that cohesion and mental health. The findings show a clear
marital dissatisfaction from husband will cross over to the wife relationship between family cohesion and mental health status.
directly, whereas the indirect crossover, when a stressor, such as Willitts, Benzeval, and Stansfeld (2004) interviewed 2127
economic hardship or a negative life event increases the strain of men and 2303 women aged less than 65 to describe the .mental
a partner, is mediated the impact of the wife's social undermining health of men and women with differing histories of partnership
behaviour on her husband (Westman, Vinokur, Hamilton & transitions. They came to the conclusion that partnership protects
Roziner, 2004). mental health. The negative outcomes of splitting partnership for
Eng, Kawachi, Fitzmaurice and Rimm (2005), studied health are long lasting in women.
38,865 men aged (40-75) to examine the affect of change in Tiffin, Pearce and Parker (2005) studied 503 subjects from
marital status on health behaviours among men and found a birth cohort to investigate the affect of socio-economic status
Marital termination (Remarriage, widowhood and unmarried) throughout the life course on self reported mental health at age
may adversely affect health and dietary behaviours of men. 50 years and land up with the conclusion that a downward socio-
Vohs, Catanese, and Baumeister (2004) ended that, economic trajectory over the whole life course is associated with
consistent with the traditional sexual script, research has poorer self reported mental health in men but not in women.
consistently shown that men have a stronger sexual motivation Research has shown that engaged workers report well
than do women. Further, Sprecher (2002) found that relationship mental and psychosomatic health (Demerouti et al., 2001).
satisfaction (but not sexual satisfaction) negatively predicted the Furthermore, they exhibit personal initiative, proactive behavior
likelihood of relationship breakup for women but not for men. In and learning motivation (Sonnentag, 2003; Schaufeli and
contrast, sexual satisfaction (but no relationship satisfaction) Salanova, 2007).
negatively predicted the likelihood of relationship dissolution for
men but not for women. Thus, perhaps for men decreased sexual
satisfaction leads to decreased relationship satisfaction, whereas V. FRUSTRATION REACTIONS
for women, the reverse is true. We are often unable to satisfy our desires or accomplish
our goals. Sometimes our ambitions exceed our abilities, or we
misperceive the possibilities. But sometimes we are blocked by
IV. MENTAL HEALTH an external barrier that precludes gratification. Frustration refers
The concept of mental health includes subjective well- to the thwarting or delaying of some ongoing course of action or
being, perceived self-efficacy, autonomy, competence, goal gratification. Frustration is a broad term, it refers to the
intergenerational dependence, and self-actualization of one's situation which produced thwarting or the psychological effects
intellectual and emotional potential among others. From a cross- of this situation, as when someone is frustrated tends to react
cultural perspective it is nearly impossible to define mental with anger, withdrawal depression, or distress. Frustration is an
health compressively. Mental health is a state of well being in important component of psychological stress, since virtually any
www.ijsrp.org
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 3, Issue 9, September 2013 3
ISSN 2250-3153
seriously harmful condition will thwart important needs and Anupama Shah et al (1992), to asses the problems faced by
goals and will requires some adjective activity to repair the unmarried women and their self-perception conducted a research
damage, if possible. study on 116 un-married women founded by ICSSR on single
Frustration has been defined in various ways by various women, in Baroda. It was found that the unmarried women faced
psychologists. Most of the definitions agree in stressing the role a lot of psychological and emotional problems. They had
of interference in goal response in producing frustration. insecure feeling regarding old age, loneliness and 34% of the
Rosenzweig (1944) defines frustration as "frustration respondents reported frustration with life.
occurs, whenever the organism meets a more or less Dill, Jody and Anderson, Craig (1996) tested Berkowitz's
insurmountable obstacle or obstruction in its route to the reformulation of the frustration aggression hypothesis which
satisfaction of any vital need." Dolland et al (1939) defined states that any negative or aversive stimulus such as frustration,
frustration as "an interference with the occurrence of an even if justified, will result in same measurable tendency to
instigated goal response at its proper time in the behaviour aggress. 34 college students served as selected samples. Degree
sequence." of hostile, aggression directed at the frustrating individual was
Obstacles of many kinds cause frustration. A useful measured. As predicted, justified frustration produced less hostile
distinction can be made between external and personal sources of aggression than unjustified frustration but even justified
frustration. frustration produced more hostile, aggression than no frustration
External frustration is based on conditions outside of the at all. Result support Berkowitz's frustration aggression
individual that impede progress towards a goal. All of the reformulation. Findings were also consistent with the view that
following are external frustrations: getting stuck with a flat tire; frustration induces negative affect, which in turn, increases
having a marriage proposal rejected. In other words external hostility toward the experimenter.
frustrations are based on delay, failure, rejection, loss and other
direct blocking of motives. External obstacles can be either social
or non-social. Frustration usually increases as the strength,
urgency, or importance of a blocked motive increases. VI. HYPOTHESIS
Motivation becomes stronger as we near a goal. Frustration On the basis of the previous researches the hypothesis
is more intense when a person runs into an obstacle very close to tested in this study are as follows:
a goal. Personal frustrations are based on personal
Significant difference will be seen in marital adjustment
characteristics; Frustration is actually based on personal
of middle aged couple from different age ranges i.e.
limitations. Yet failure may be perceived as externally caused.
AR1 (40-47 years) and AR2 (48-55 years).
All individuals at one time or another, in greater or lesser
Significant difference will be seen in mental health of
amount, have to tolerate frustration in their life. The term,
middle aged couples from different age groups i.e. AR 1
frustration tolerance, refers to the amount of stress one can
(40-47 years) and AR2 (48-55 years).
tolerate before his integrated functioning is seriously impaired.
Thus frustration tolerance refers to the capacity of the individuals Significant difference will be seen in frustration
to show persistence in efforts despite repeated failures and reactions of middle aged couples from different age
antagonistic environment to maintain the integration of the group i.e. AR1 (40-47 years) and AR2 (48-55 years).
personality.
The person who continues his/her efforts may be said to
have more frustration tolerance than the one who discontinues VII. METHODOLOGY
his/her efforts or indulges in any reactionary mode of behavior. For conducting the present study, "purposive sampling
In ability to tolerate frustration leads to mental breakdown, technique" has been used. The total sample consisted of 150
maladjustment and problems in also personal relationship. The couples i.e. 300 subjects (N=300). The sample was subdivided
low frustration tolerance also leads to antisocial behaviour or in into two categories according to the age i.e. AR1 (40-47 years)
other maladaptive behavior. and AR2 (48-55 years). Doctors, lecturers and bank employees
were included in the sample.
www.ijsrp.org
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 3, Issue 9, September 2013 4
ISSN 2250-3153
Research Design
(N=300)
test is having reverse key also. Higher the score higher is the
The following statistical tests were computed: adjustment, lower the score poor will be the adjustment.
Mean and Standard Deviation were computed.
Pearson's 'r' was computed. Mental health Inventory
Mental Health Inventory is a self-reporting four point scale
Criteria for sample selection and developed by Dr. Jagdish and Dr. A.K. Srivastava (1984).
• Subject must belong to the upper middle socioeconomic status. Validity and reliability of Mental Health Inventory is .54 and .73
• The age range of the subject should fall between (40-55 years). respectively. The six dimensions have been inculcated in the
• Minimum working hours of men and women should be 6 to 8 scale are Positive self - evaluation (PSE), Perception of Reality
hours per day. (PR), Integration of Personality (IP), Autonomy (AUTO), Group
• Subject must be either doctors or lecturer or working with the Oriented Attitudes (GOA), Environmental Mastery (EM). The
banks only. items of the scale are in statement form seeking information for
each in any of the four options, which are Always, Most of
Tools For Measurement Times, Sometimes, and Never. The weight is 4, 3, 2 and 1
Two tools were used for the measurement of the Marital respectively. Therefore, the higher the score on the scale, higher
adjustment and Mental health. Those are: the status / level of mental health, or vice versa.
www.ijsrp.org
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 3, Issue 9, September 2013 5
ISSN 2250-3153
VIII. RESULTS
Table 1
z-values of marital adjustment of middle aged couples (N=300) belonging to different age groups : AR 1 (40-47 years) and AR2
(48-55 years)
Table 2
z-values of mental health of middle aged couples (N=300) belonging to different age groups : AR1 (40-47 years) and AR2 (48-
55years)
The table shows no significant difference in both age Results revealed that couples of AR1 (40-47 years) enjoy high
groups of middle aged couples regarding their mental health in level of autonomy than couples of AR2 (48-55 years).
total but significant differences were found in autonomy of z values of other dimensions of mental health, have been
middle aged couples of both age groups. The calculated z value found non significant. It may be due to the fact that middle aged
for autonomy is 2.99, which is higher than table value (2.59). couples of both age groups are striving for and proceeding
www.ijsrp.org
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 3, Issue 9, September 2013 6
ISSN 2250-3153
towards the achievements of their life time goals, settling down mental health.
their children and securing their future, maintaining their sound
Table 3
z-values of frustration reactions of middle aged couples (N=300) belonging to different age groups : AR 1 (40-47 years) and AR2
(48-55 years)
www.ijsrp.org
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 3, Issue 9, September 2013 7
ISSN 2250-3153
www.ijsrp.org
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 3, Issue 9, September 2013 8
ISSN 2250-3153
[26] Perry-Jenkins, M., Repetti, R.L. & Crouter, A.C. (2000) Work and family in [32] Westman, M. Vinokur, A.D. Hamilton V.L. & Roziner, I. (2004)
the 1990's Journal of Marriage and the family 62, 981-998 . "Crossover of Marital Dissatisfaction during Military Down / Sizing Among
[27] Reddy, C.R. (1986) Changing status of educated working women. A case Russian Army Officers". Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 89, 769-779.
study Delhi: B.R. Publishing Corporation. pp. 205-224. [33] Willitts M., Benzeval M. and Stansfeld S. (2004) "Partnership history and
[28] Schaufeli, W.B. and Salanova, M. (2007), “Work engagement: an emerging mental health over time". Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health,
psychological concept and its implications for organizations”, in Gilliland, 58 : 53-58.
S.W., Steiner, D.D. and Skarlicki, D.P. (Eds), Research in Social Issues in
Management (Volume 5): Managing Social and Ethical Issues in
Organizations, Vol. 5, Information Age Publishers, Greenwich, CT, pp.
135-77. AUTHORS
[29] Sprecher, S. (2002). Sexual satisfaction in premarital relationships: First Author – Dr. Shikha Goel, Bhagini Nivedita college,
Associations with satisfaction, love, commitment, and stability. The Journal
of Sex Research, 39, 190-196.
University of Delhi, New Delhi
[30] Tiffin P.A., Pearce M.S. and Parker L. (2005) "Social mobility over the life
Second Author – Dr. Darshan Kaur Narang, Department of
course and self reported mental health at age 50 : prospective cohort study". Home Science, University of Rajasthan, Jaipur(Rajasthan)
Journal of epidemiology and community health, 59 : 870-872. Third Author – Dr. Kavita Koradia, Department of Home
[31] Vohs, K. D., Catanese, K. R., & Baumeister, R. F. (2004). Sex in "his" Science, University of Rajasthan, Jaipur(Rajasthan)
versus "her" relationships. In J. H. Harvey, A. Wenzel, & S. Sprecher (Eds),
Handbook of sexuality in close relationships (pp. 455-474). Mahway, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum.
www.ijsrp.org