Role of Micro-Financing in Women Empowerment: An Empirical Study of Urban Punjab
Role of Micro-Financing in Women Empowerment: An Empirical Study of Urban Punjab
46                                                                              VolumeReview
                                                                      Pacific Business 5 IssueInternational
                                                                                               1 (July 2012)
*Reader, Department of Commerce and Business Management ,Guru Nanak Dev University, Amritsar
**Project Fellow, Department of Commerce and Business Management, Guru Nanak Dev University, Amritsar
Volume 5 Issue 1 (July 2012)                                                                                       47
line. This paper presents an empirical work on the impact   "gaining the ability to generate choices and exercise
of finance in the hand of women. The research has           bargaining power", "developing a sense of self-worth,
focused on the empowerment of women with financial          a belief in one's ability to secure desired changes, and
services at her disposal. Section-II outlines conceptual    the right to control one's life" are important elements
framework of women empowerment; Section-III                 of women's empowerment. It is the process of
highlights the literature work that has been done on        increasing the capacity of women to make choices and
women empowerment and micro-finance and finds the           to transform these choices into desired actions and
gap between the earlier studies and the present study.      outcomes (Krishna, 2003).
In section-IV, objective of the study and the research
methodology that has been used in the paper is discussed    It can be summarized that women empowerment refers
along with data methodology. The analysis and               to provision of leverages to women in the society who
interpretation of the data has been studied in Section V    are otherwise deprived.
and finally the paper concludes with the Section VI.
                                                            Review of Literature
Conceptual Framework                                        A lot of research work has been carried out in different
The term 'Empowerment' has been defined in different        parts of the world to know the success of micro-credit
perspectives by various authors. Many of them have          (finance) in empowerment of women. Goetz &Gupta
defined empowerment as a process of change in               (1996); Gibb Sarah (2008) found that micro-credit has
existing power structure. It is concerned with power,       failed to empower women as women could not change
and particularly with the power relations and the           her traditional household role and could not retain control
distribution of power between individuals and group         over money. Sijders and Dijstera (2009) also found that
(Kahlon, 2004). Batiwala (1994) describes                   micro-credit has failed to effect the political position of
empowerment as "the process of challenging existing         women and hence overall empowerment was not
power relations and of gaining greater control, over        observed. Similarly, Samanta (2009) propounded that
the sources of power".                                      women have no control over credit which is the failure
                                                            of microfinance to empower women.
The concept of empowerment has been considered
from social aspect by many authors (Bennett 2002;           However, Authors like Hashemi, Schuler and Riley
Malhotra 2002; Saraswathy 2008; Swain 2007). It has         (1996); Hunt. J & Kasyanathan N. (2002) Agha
also been viewed from political aspect by few.              et.al.(2004);        Anna       K.P.       Saraswathy
Women's participation in politics, her awareness and        &PanickerK.S.M.(2008); Aruna &Jyothimays (2011)
knowledge, her participation in political campaign are      studied the impact of micro- credit and micro finance
considered. Puhazhendi and Badatya (2002) defined           programme on the lives of women and found micro-
empowerment as, "Great depth of the concept of power,       credit as a significant factor contributing to empower
which ranges from inner power (covering                     women in one way or other. On the other hand,some
characteristics like confidence, will and self-esteem)      studies have concluded with the mixed impact of
to societal power."                                         micro-finance on Women. Leach et. al. (2002) found
                                                            that micro-credit has succeeded in socially empowering
Some literature work has conceptualized empowerment         women where economic empowerment could not be
as decision making ability. According to UNIFEM ,           possible due to lack of knowledge and understanding
48                                                                       Pacific Business Review International
among women about business. Berglund (2007) found               lives residing in urban Punjab. This research is an
the individual empowerment but no empowerment                   attempt to draw the attention of policy makers towards
impact was found on groups. Schechter (2007)                    the urban India where the microfinance services can
observed that credit facilities helped women to run a           serve in a more profitable and sustainable way to make
business and earn small profits but they were still found       a drastic change in the lives of women.
dependent on family members.
                                                                Research Methodology
There is no dearth of work done on women                        The objective of the study is to determine whether
empowerment and microfinance; it was found that a               microfinance services are instrumental in empowering
lot of research work has been done on Southern Region           Women in Urban Punjab.
of India. But as far as Punjab is concerned, there is
paucity of research especially in Urban Punjab. There           The sample size of 350 females' was selected to fill
is difference in the financial needs of urban and rural         the questionnaire out of which responses of 334 were
people. So, this research paper has focused on Urban            valid and complete. Table 1 provides the demographic
Punjab where microfinance industry is still in the              profile of the respondents. Judgment and Convenience
nascent stage and not much research work has been               Random sampling technique has been used for collecting
done to gauge the impact of microfinance on women's             information from those who belongs to lower income
     Occupation
     Domestic-Servant
     Street-Vendors                         30              36                    32                   98
     Petty Shop-keepers                     17              15                    14                   46
     Housewife
     Others                                 19              18                    17                   54
                                            15              18                    21                   54
                                            31              23                    28                   82
     Total                                 112             110                   112                  334
strata.Micro credit female clients has been selected      To analyze the impact of microfinance on Women,
from urban areas of Punjab namely i.e.., Amritsar,        Multiple Regression model was applied on factors to
Ludhiana and Jalandhar. Those women who are availing      test the null hypothesis i.e., Ho:There is no significant
loan from either informal or formal source have been      impact of Microfinance services onwomen
the part of sample size. The sample contains 142 women    empowerment.
taking loan from formal sources like Bank, MFI etc.
where 192 respondents were those who were taking          Analysis and Interpretation
loan from informal channels such as moneylender,          Factors impacting Women Status
employee, relative/friends etc. Various questions were    The questionnaire contained twenty six statements
made regarding their perception about the benefits of     reflecting the impact of micro credit services on women
credit on their lives.                                    empowerment. The respondents were asked to rate
                                                          these statements on five point likert scale as to how
Most of the respondents chosen were illiterate or less    they perceive the impact of micro credit on their lives,
educated, so the questionnaires were verbally explained   ranging from highly agree to highly disagree. Table
to them and responses were recorded according to the      2contains the list of the statements provided towomen
answers provided by the sample population. Table 1        respondents. The responses were further analyzed
provides the demographic profile of the sample.           using the technique of Factor analysis.
Further, In order to analyze the data, Factor Analysis
Technique was adopted which helped to load the
number of variables on few factors and reduced the
numbers of variables into more manageable factors.
Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was adopted to
rotate the variables followed by Varimax rotation.
Statistical Software SPSS 17.0 was used to analyze
the results.
50                                                                   Pacific Business Review International
For this purposethe internal consistency of the data was    adequacy was measured through Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin
verified through cronbach alpha which turned out to be      and Bartlett's Test of Sphericity which were also found
0.880. This is a good indicator of reliability proving it   to be favorable.
adequate for further analysis.Further, the sampling
Volume 5 Issue 1 (July 2012)                                                                                      51
                                     Table 3: Sampling Adequacy Tests
                                               Reliability Statistics
                                 Cronbach’s Alpha                                       N of Items
                                       0.880                                                 26
                           KMO and Bartlett's Test
             Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling                                         .868
             Adequacy (KMO)
             Barlett’s Test of                Approx. chi-Square                         3532.760
             Sphericity                       Df                                            325
                                              Sig.                                          .000
                                                           Factors                                    Eigen
    Variables              1            2             3              4           5            6       Values
    VAR 1                 .736         .265          .063         .171          .090        .014      7.826
    VAR 2                 .814         .214          .096         .178          .085        .013      1.913
    VAR 3                 .243        -.083          .148         .146         -.139        .792      1.759
    VAR 4                 .630        -.113          .250         .230          .022        -.085     1.399
    VAR 5                 .594         .163          .019         .094          .074        .253      1.369
    VAR 6                 .704         .346          .023         .069         -.010        .143      1.037
    VAR 7                 .690         .232          -.086       -.022         -.027        .085      .972
    VAR 8                 .695         .289          .328         .086         -.028        -.111     .940
    VAR 9                 .550         .264          .475        -.059         -.338        .132      .915
    VAR 10                .514         .288          .291         .003         -.316        .226      .794
    VAR 11               -.228        -.214          .212         .138         .616         .115      .744
52                                                                      Pacific Business Review International
The second last row of the table shows the percentage         factors were extracted on the basis of common
of variance explained by individual factor. It was            dimensions reflected by the variables.
observed that these six factors jointly explained 58.854
percent of the variance.                                      FACTOR 1: Improvement in Socio-Economic
                                                              Status This factor explained 30.09 per cent of the
Orthogonal Rotation with Varimax Rotation method was          variance of all the factors. This factor is inclusive of
applied on all the twenty six variables loaded on six         number of variables, namely, poverty reduction,
important factors extracted through Eigen values. Table       improved income level and standard of living,
4 shows the rotated factor matrix. Varimax Rotation           improvement in employment level, family consumption.
method is one of the popular method of orthogonal             Women are now socially more active and aware about
rotation and it has helped in reducing the number of          social issues. Theyconsider themselves in a better
variables and factor loadings greater than 0.50 (ignoring     position economically as well as socially. With financial
signs) have been retained.                                    services they are able to develop their entrepreneurial
                                                              skills and utilize the resources in an improved way (V7).
Explanation of Factors
Table 5 lists the factors extracted from the list of          FACTOR 2: Enhancement in Personality Factor
variables and the variables attached therewith. The           As women can easily avail credit services, they
Volume 5 Issue 1 (July 2012)                                                                                   53
perceive themselves more confident (V14). Generally,      are more knowledgeable about market (V17=0.615).
the women are so much occupied by household activities    Women perceive contribution of micro finance services
that they are not recognized as an equal partner in       towards the family rather than as an individual benefit.
household decisions. But with more credit services        Combination of all these variables addsto their
available at their doorstep women take decisions and      personality.
                    1.
                    3.       Improvement in                V 19:Control over loan use              0.760
                             Financial                     V20:Increase      in       self-        0.627
                             Liberation                    consumption
                                                           V22:Increase in mobility                0.684
                    2.
                    4.       Improvement in                V 23:Reduced           domestic         0.814
                             Familial                      violence
                             Relations                     V24:Positive     change      in         0.740
                                                           men’s attitude
                    3.
                    5.       Positivity                    V 11: Increase in children              0.616
                             towards      Child            enrollment to schools.
                             Development                   V 12:It does not result into            0.647
                                                           increase child labor in family
                                                           business
                    6.
                    4.       Inhibiting Factor             V 3:Rise in unnecessary                 0.792
                                                           expenditures on consumption
                                                           V 25:Increased burden                   0.512
Dependent Variable                                             that were extracted from factor analysis out of the list
Dependent Variable taken was the empowerment of                of 26 variables as provided in the table 4.
women with microfinance services as perceived by
them and the same was rated on five point likert scale.        Model formulation
Independent Variable                                           Before formulating model for regression analysis, it is
                                                               necessary to validate the data by checking whether
All the six factors were taken as Independent Variables        the multi-collinearity exists between data. For this
56                                                                          Pacific Business Review International
purpose, estimated partial correlation between                   correlation matrix also indicates the nonexistence of
dependent and independent variables was calculated               collinearity as no correlation is too high. It is insignificant
which measures the correlation among women                       in case of X5 and the same variable is removed in later
empowerment and the factors affecting the women                  stage while forming equation.
micro credit clients (Table 7). Moreover, the Pearson
X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 Y
X1 1
X2 -.106 1
(.053) -
X3 -.173 -.081 1
(.001) (.143) -
In order to obtain more accurate results, tests such as          be 1.000 for each independent variable; hence it can
Variance Inflation factor (VIF) and Tolerance level (1/          be accepted from the analysis that there exists no
VIF) were measured to test the multi-collinearity. VIF           collinearity among the data.
equivalent or below 10 is said to be acceptable as it
reflects that data is free from multi-collinearity. In this      After checking the multicollinearity, we can estimate
case, the value of VIF and Tolerance level came out to           the regression model. To meet the objective, the
Volume 5 Issue 1 (July 2012)                                                                                           57
perceived impact of microcredit services on the lives           Where,
of women has been studied. Following model was used             Y= Dependent Variable;
for studying the relationship between dependent and               =Intercept term β1,β2,β3,β4, β5,β6
independent variables:                                              are Regression coefficients
Y= α+ β1X1+ β 2X2 +β 3X3 +β 4X4+ β 5X5+ β 6X6 +Ut.              X1, X2, X3, X4, X5,X6 represent Independent variables;
                                                                Ut= Error term.
The model has been summarized in the table given below (Table 8):
The value of R in the model shows a marked degree of            it is confirmed through normal probability curve and
correlation.The value of adjusted R2 is 0.374 which             histogram.
indicates that all the variables extracted could explain
37.4 per cent of the variation in the dependent variable.       The significance of the model is measured through
Hence, the model can be confidently said to be a                ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) to test the following
generalized model. The difference between R square              null hypothesis:
and adjusted R square is also satisfactory (0.385-
0.374=0.009), which is interpreted as the 0.09% less                       H0:β1=β2=β3=β4=β5=β6=0
variation in the outcome if it is derived from the actual       The Null hypothesis explains mean values of regression
population. To check whether the model fulfills the             co-efficient are equivalent to zero. Table 9 has been
assumption of independent errors, Durbin- Watson test           drawn to reveal the significance level for F statistics. F
is applied. The result of Watson test (1.968) is found to       ratio is highly significant; hence the null hypothesis is
be near 2, which is considered to be significant. It has        rejected i.e., there is no significance difference between
been proved through the test that the data meets the            the mean values of co-efficient. It is evident that the
assumption of independent errors. To cross check the            value of one or more regression coefficient is not equal
assumption of normal distribution of the standard errors,       to zero.
All these favorably support the argument that the model      Regression Equation
is significant and can predict the outcomes.                 The estimated equation is as follows:
                                                             Y=3.108+0.357 X1+0.180X2+0.282X3+0.98X4+
Table 10 reveals the coefficient for regression variables.     0.106X6
The beta value coefficient allows us to test the strength
of relationship between women empowerment and the            This equation can be used to know whether the micro-
impact of micro credit services on the lives of Women        finance services are instrumental in women
clients.Independent variables i.e., X1, X2, X3, X4, and      empowerment given the values of the factors
X6 have positive correlation as well as significant          determining the impact of such services on women
values at 5 per cent level of significance. X5 which         respondents. The equation has been obtained by
has negative beta has been eliminated for the purpose        capturing the values of beta co-efficient through Table
of interpretation as well as from regression model.          10.
The significant t-value corresponding to each variable       as well socially. Similar results are shown by other
confirms the significant contribution of each                variables such as positive impact of micro credit services
independent variable to the model. All factors have          on personality of women and financial status of
significant values except X5 hence excluded while            respondents. The next highest contributing factor that
formulating equation. Larger the value of t statistics,      leads to empowerment of women is inhibiting factor (X6)
the contribution of the respective variable is known to      which is making an indirect contribution to empower
be greater. The same fact has been shown through             women. The positive results (Beta=0.128) reflects that
beta values.                                                 it has very small contribution in women empowerment
                                                             and the respondents does not hesitate to avail micro
The value of Beta coefficient is highest in case of          services due to this variable. The smallest Beta in case
X1(improvement in socio-economic status of women)            of X4 i.e. 0.119 shows that micro credit services
revealing that 43.2 percent of the variation in the          contribute least to the family relationship of women
women empowerment can be explained by this                   clients. As proved by Table No. 9, Standard error (S.E.)
variable. So, it can be said that micro credit services      corresponding to the beta value is 0.036 shows that only
lead to improvement in status of women economically          small portion of S.E. varies across the samples.
Volume 5 Issue 1 (July 2012)                                                                                      59
Conclusion                                                         sector Midwives in Uganda', Health Service
In this paper the impact of micro credit services on the           Research, 39(6pt2): 2081-2100.
empowerment of women clients has been discussed.               •   Aruna, M. (2011). "The role of microfinance in
The factor analysis and regression test revealed several           Women Empowerment: A study on the SHG Bank
factors that can influence the lives of women. The six             Linkage Program in Hyderabad". The Indian
factors socio-economic status; enhancement in                      Journal of Commerce and Management Studies.
personality; financial liberation; improved familial               Vol. II, Issue -4,May, pp.77-95.
relations; child development and inhibiting factor were        •   Batliwala, S. (1994). "The Meaning of Women's
extracted with Facto analysis technique. Then, Multiple            Empowerment: new concepts from action." In G.
regression analysis was applied to test whether these              Sen, A.Germain and L.C. Chen, eds. Population
factors have any significant impact on women                       policies reconsidered: Health, empowerment and
empowerment. Out of the six factors, five variables                rights. Boston: Harvard University Press, pp. 127-
were found significant and X5 (Positivity towards child            138.
development)was eliminated that was highly                     •   Bennett, Lynn. 2002. "Using Empowerment and
insignificant and hence it is not a part of regression             Social Inclusion for Pro-poor Growth: A Theory of
equation. The results of the study showed that women               Social Change." Working Draft of Background
clients are benefitted highly as far as their status (social       Paper for the Social Development Strategy Paper.
and economic) is concerned (X1). It revealed that yet              Washington, DC: World Bank.
micro credit can empower women by providing them               •   Berglund, Knut- Erland (2007). "The effects of
financial liberalization (X3) but the family relations (X4)        Microfinance of women and its Societal
are being least influenced by micro credit services.               Consequences. A study of Women Self- Help-
Moreover, inhibiting factors are taken up as a challenge           Group Members in Andhra Pradesh." Minor Field
by women. So it can be concluded that in urban India               Studies-reports, 2007:1, Uppsala Universities
micro finance services had been a boon to women as it              Sweden, Department of Economic History.
had led to their empowerment. The credit services can          •   Gibb, S. (2008). "Microfinance's impact on
be more beneficial if the funds are taken up from formal           education, poverty and empowerment: A case study
sources rather than informal. Poor and underprivileged             from Bolivian." Altiplanio Development Research
women clients must be taught about the benefits of                 Working Paper Series, Institute for Advanced
productive use of loans and more sources of finance                Development Studies.
must be provided to them. There is quick need to take          •   Goetz, A.M. and Gupta, R.S. (1996). "Who takes
some action to empower women by providing them                     the credit? Gender, power, and control over loan
more financial services. The finance in the hand of                use in rural credit programs in Bangladesh." World
women can led to empowerment of family as well as                  Development, 24(1), pp. 45-63.
society so they must be encouraged to make productive          •   Hashemi, S.M., Schuler, S.R.and Riley, A.P.(1996).
use of finance which could help them to step out of the            "Rural Credit Programs and Women's
poverty trap.                                                      Empowerment in Bangladesh." World
                                                                   Development, 24(4), pp. 635-653.
References                                                     •   Hunt, J &Kasynathan, N. (2002). 'Reflections on
Agha, S., Balal, A., and Ogojo-Okello,Francis. 2004.               microfinance and women's empowerment',
   'The Impact of Microfinance Programs on client                  Development Bulletin, No. 57, pp. 71-75.
   Perceptions of Quality of care provided by private
60                                                                  Pacific Business Review International
•    Kahlon, P. (2004). "73rd amendment and women's        •   Saraswathy, Anna.K.P .and Panicker, K.S.M.
     empowerment: A Punjab study", A paper presented           (2008). "Microcredit and women empowerment:
     in the seminar on Rural Women and Economic                A study in India." International Journal of global
     Empowerment of Women in south Asia at G B                 Business, 1(1), pp. 184-213.
     Pant Social Science Institute, Allahabad.             •   Schechter, Shani. 2007. "Client Profiling Study A
•    Krishna, A, 2003. "Social capital, community driven       qualitative study of Experiences of Female
     development and empowerment: a short note on              Microfinance Clients", Institute of Financial
     concepts and operations."WorldBank working                Management and Research- Centre for Micro
     paper 33077.                                              Finance, Case study, December. http://www.centre-
•    Leach, Fiona and Sitaram, Shashikala. (2002).             for-microfinance.com/wp-content/uploads/
     "Microfinance and Women's Empowerment: A                  attachments/csy/800/schechter-client-profiling-
     Lesson from India", Development in Practice, 12           study.pdf.
     (5): 575-588.                                         •   Snijders, A.L. and Dijkstra, G. (2009). "Microcredit
•    Majoor, H. and Manders, J. (2009). "Women                 and women's empowerment in South India." Paper
     Empowerment: Comparing concepts &                         presented at Second European Research
     Assessment Implications for microfinance."                Conference on Microfinance.http://www.rug.nl/
     Commissioned by Oikocredit.                               gsg/Research/Conferences/EUmicrofinconf2011/
•    Malhotra, A., Schuler, S. R. and Boender, C. (2002)       Papers/1new.12.Dijkstra.pdf .
     "Measuring Women's Empowerment as a Variable          •   Swain, R. B., &Wallentin, F. Y. (2007). "Does
     in International Development." Washington, DC,            microfinance empower women? Evidence from
     The World Bank.                                           self-help groups in India."Working Paper No.
•    Puhazhendi, V., & Badatya, K. C. (2002). "SHG-            2007:24, Department of Economics, Uppsala
     bank linkage program for rural poor: An impact            University, Sweden.
     assessment."Paper presented at the seminar on         •   Tiwari, A.M,and Thakkur,S. G. (2007). "SHG based
     SHG-bank linkage program. New Delhi:                      Microfinance programs -Can they remove
     NABARD.                                                   poverty?" London and New York: Routledge. pp-
•    Samanta, Gopa. (2009). "Microfinance and                  177-193.
     Women: Gender Issues of poverty alleviation and
     empowerment." The Microfinance Review, 1(1),
     January-July, pp.100-120.