Shelf-Life of Aluminum Capacitors
Shelf-Life of Aluminum Capacitors
Abstract-Because of a lack of information on the electrical character- The industry type for the capacitors used is generally
istics of alumi&ni eJectrolytic capacitors whenoperated in a nonco&inu- referred to as a low-leakage miniature alutinum electrolytic.
ous manner in low-voltage circuit applications, an accelerated shelf-life
All capacitors tested were of the radial lead configuration
aging test was conducted for 3000 h at 85°C on three types of capacitors
from four vendors. The effects of accelirated conditioning on capaci- ranging in size from 5-mm diameter x 1l-mm length to 6.5-
tance value, effective seriesresistance(ESR), and leakage current ai 1 V, 2 mm diameter x 12.0~mm length. The end consttiction of the
V, and rated voltage are reported. General observations show a decrease units consisted of a nibber bung with the can crimped to
in capacitance and an increase in,ESR and ieakagk current. The results provide an effective seal around the leads and the bung-can
also show that leakage current and ESR cannot be optimized simultane- interface.
ously. Guidelines for the use df aluminum electrolytic capacitors in low-
voltage circuits are also presented. Initial capacitance values were measured using a Hewlett-
Packard 4261A Digital LCR Meter Which applied a 1.5 V dc
I. INTRODUCTION bias to the specimens under test. The same instrument and test
. signals were used to measure the initial dissipation factor (DF)
R ECENT
manufacturing
IMPROVEMENTS in the design and
processes of modern aluminum
electrolytic. capacitors, plus their cost effectiveness when
values at 120 and 1000 Hz, from which the ESR was
calculated using the relationship:
compared to tantalum capacitors is resulting in an increased DF
evaluation of these components for applications in the design
ESR=-.
2ufC
(1)
of electronic circuits. The use of these capacitors in low-
voltage circuitry (l-2 V dc) which are powered in a DC leakage current tias measured by connecting the
noncontinuous manner (such as electrotiic telephones) requires capacitor in series with a 1-MQ resistor to a dc power supply,
special attention since performance characteristics for ex- applying 1 V, 2V, and rated voltage across the capacitor, and
tended operation under these coriditions are generally not measuring the voltage drop across the resistor.. The voltage
available. The circuit designer requires knowledge of the was applied for 2 min at each step, and the three tests were
effbcts of these operating condi&ons on capacitance value, d&e sequentially.
leakage, current, and effective series resistance (ESR). Mea- The 2-min test interval ivas the same as that specified by the
surement of these characteristics before and after an acceler- manufacturers of the capacitors tested atid was chosen to allow
ated shelf-life aging test was considered to be an effective comparison of the results with the ieakage current levels, at
method of predicting their actual operating performance. rated voltage, specified by the vendors. The time interval is
The purpose of: the work reported here tias to determine the sufficiently long to eliminate the effect of the charging
suitability of aluminuni electrolytic capacitors for use in low- currents, stabilize the true leakage current and obtain repro-
voltage electronic circuit applications by using an accelerated ducible results.
shelf-life aging test as a simulation method. A total of 180 The capacitors were then conditioned in an oven at 85 “C foi
capacitors from four different tianufacturers (vendors A, B, 3000 h with no voltage applied. This jtepresents an accelera-
C, and D) were tested, and the results are presented. The tion factor of approximately 22 years at 25 “C or 11 years at
significance of the results will be discussed along with ?5’C shelf storage temperature. The relationship between
application guidelines for the use of these components in low- temperature and life is described in more detail in Section VI
voltage circuits. of this paper. Capacitance, dissipation factor, and leakage
were remeasured, using the same methods, upon completion
II. TEST PROCEDURE
of the tempera&ire conditioning.
Capacitor values tested were 1 PF at 50 V, 10 PF at 35 V,
111. RESULTS
and 22 PF at 10 V. The number of specimens t&ted by vendor
and type is given in Table I. General
Parameters were measured initially and after 3000 h.
Manuscript received Juhe 12, 1985; revised May 1.5, 1986. This paper was Intermediate measurements were not taken in order to simulate
presented iit the Electronic Components Conference, Seattle, WA, May 5-7,
1986. true shelf-life conditions and eliminate any parameter varia-
W. D. Greason is with the Faculty of Engineering Science, The University tions which might result from the periodic application of test
of Western Ontario, London, ON, Canada N6A 5B9. voltages. The initial and final data points are joined, using a
J. Critchley is with Department 2810, Northern Telecom Canada, Ltd.,
P.O. Box 5155, London, ON, Canada N6A 4N3. straight line, to clarify the presentation of the information and
IEEE Log Number 8609813. show the general direction of change.
TABLE I
DISTRIBUTION OF CAPACITORS TESTED, BY VENDOR AND TYPE
2.00
VENDOR 1.09 t
A B C D
1 pF, 5d V 30 10 10 10
10 pF, 35 V 10 10 30 10
22 pF, 10 V 30 10 10 10’
0 0.92 -
Capacitance
a90h TIME
For the three different capacitor types, plots showing the Fig.- 1. Effect of accelerated temperature test on capacitance (I-pF 50-V
change in capacitance value-are presented in Figs. l-3.- The capacitor).
capacitance was 0.94. Fig. 2. Effect of accelerated temperature test on capacitance (IO-pF 35-V
capacitor).
ESR
Table III summarizes the initial ESR values. Figs. 4-6 show
the effect of the accelerated temperature test on ESR,
calculated from, the measured values of dissipation factor and
capacitance:
Tables IV and V summarize the-normalized final values of .
ESR at 120 Hz and 1000‘ I-Iz, respectively. The average
normalized final value of ESR, at .both measurement frequen-
ties, was approxi.mately 1.6. The results did indicate, how-
ever, that for the 120-Hz measurement,’ the relative change in
ESR decreased as the capacitor value increased, while for the
lOOO-Hz measurement; the, relative change in ESR increased I I
INITIAL 3000 h
as the capacitance value increased. A comparison of capacitors TilE
by vendor showed a change in ESR which varied from i .09 to Fig. 3. Effect of accelerated temperature test on capacitance (22~pF 10-V
capacitor).
1.95 times the initial levels. Also note that capacitors supplied
by Vendor B had a significantly smaller change in. ESR
compared to the specimens from the other vendors.
TABLE II
Le&w G / SUMMARY OF NORMALIZED FINAL VALUES OF CAPACITANCE AFTER
3000-h TEST
Table VI summarizes.the average initial leakage currents
measured, while plots showing ‘the change in leakage current
VENDOR
for the three types of capacitors, measured at 1 V, 2 V, and
rated voltage, are given in Figs. 7, 8, and 9. Note that the ‘A it C D Average
leakage currents at the l- and 2-V levels were measured in
nanoamperes while the leakage current at rated voltage was 1 gF, 50 V 0.96 0.99 0.47 0.97 0.97
measured in microamperes. 10 pF, 35 V 0.92 0.98 0.93 0.93 0.94
22 pF, 10 V 0.92 0.99 0.88 0.88 0.92
Table VII summarizes the normalized final value of leakage Average 0.93 0.99 0.93 0.93 0.94
current, measured at rated voltage. The overall normalized
final leakage current was 4.3 times the initial amount.
Wide variations existed in the measurement of leakage
GREASONANDCRITCHLEY:ALUMINUMELECTROLYTICCAPACITORS 295
VENDOR
Vendor
Parameter A B C D
A B C D Average
ESR at 120 Hz, fl
1 pF, 50 V 36.4 24.4 28.8 50.0 1 /IF, 50 V 2.25 1.33 2.34 1.75 1.92
10 ~JF, 35 V 8.5 6.3 6.2 6.7 10 gF, 35 V 1.67 1.05 1.91 1.74 1.59
22 /LF, 10 V 6.0 4.2 6.9 6.7 22 pF, 10 V 1.53 1.09 1.59 1.58 1.45
Average 1.82 1.16 1.95 1.69 1.65
ESR at I kHz, Q
1 pF, 50 V 10.8 5.9 11.5 15.5
10 pF, 35 V 2.6 2.1 2.1 1.9
22 ~IF, 10 V 2.1 2.0 6.5 2.5 TABLE V
SUMMARY OF NORMALIZED FINAL EsR VALUES AT 1000 HZ AFTER
3CO-~TFST
ESR AT 120 Hz -
100 ESR AT I kHz ---
t A B C D Average
TABLE VI
INITIAL 3000 h
TIME AVERAGEINITIALLEAKAGECURRENTFORCAPACITORS
Parameter A B C D
INITIAL 3000 h
TIME
Fig. 5. Effect of accelerated temperature test on ESR (10qF 35-V
capacitor).
ESR AT 120 Hz -
IO ESR AT I kHz --
O.ll 1 , (
INITIAL 3000 h
lNlTlAl 3000 h
TIME TIME
Fig. 6. Effect of accelerated temperature test on ESR (22-PF 10-V Fig. 7. Effect of accelerated temperature test on leakage current (1-gF SO-V
capacitor). capacitor).
296 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON COMPONENTS, HYBRIDS, AND MANUFACTURING TECHNOLOGY, VOL. CHMT-9, NO. 3, SEPTEMBER1986
TABLE VIII
SUMMARY OF NORMALIZED FINAL VALUE OF LEAKAGE CURRENT AT
1v
Vendor
A B C D Average
TABLE IX
SUMMARY OF NORMALIZED FINAL VALUE OF LEAKAGE CURRENT AT
Fig. 8. Effect of accelerated temperature test on leakage current (lo-PF 35-
2v
V capacitor).
Vendor
A B C D Average
IV. DISCUSSION
where tan 6’ is the dissipation factor for the A1203 layer. The Leakage Current
ESR can then be calculated as Leakage current is a function of the oxide quality, geome-
tan 6’ + wCRl try, and the applied voltage. The resistance of the oxide is
ESR= _ . (3) RL = p&A where p is the volume resistivity (Q - m), d is
WC
thickness (m), and A is the plate area (m2), and the
It has been shown that tan 6 ’ decreases with frequency in the capacitance is C = Ke,-J/d with K the dielectric constant, e.
range of 10-1000 Hz and is also inversely related to oxide the permittivity of free space (8.85 x lo-l2 F * m-l).
thickness or formation voltage [9]. Therefore, the leakage current 1, for an applied voltage VA is
It was observed from the initial measurements that the given by
capacitor with the lowest capacitance value and highest voltage IL= VA/RL=K, VaC (4)
rating yielded the highest ESR value. As the capacitance value
increases and the voltage rating drops, two opposing effects where K1 = l(pKeo).
can be seen from an examination of (3). If the oxide layer is Thus for a given voltage, the leakage current is proportional
assumed to be the major contribution to ESR, then at a given to the capacitance value. Due to the nonlinear V-Icharacteris-
frequency: tic of aluminum electrolytic capacitors [l 11, leakage current
will decrease at a greater than linear rate as the applied voltage
1) the ESR will increase due to the inverse relationship
is decreased from the capacitor’s rated voltage. Nevertheless,
between tan 6’ and oxide thickness; and
the linear relationship can be used as a first-order approxima-
2) the ESR will decrease due to the inverse relationship
tion when evaluating aluminum electrolytic capacitors.
between ESR and capacitance.
From (4), for a fixed value of capacitance:
The latter effect predominates, and the net result is a decrease
in the ESR which is in agreement with the results obtained. IL=K2VA
It was also observed that the ESR at the lOOO-Hz test where K2 = K1 C. Then
frequency was smaller than that at the 120-Hz test frequency.
This is due to a decrease in tan 6 ’ as frequency increases [9] log IL = log K2 + log VA. (5)
and the presence of w in the denominator of (3). At even
higher frequencies, the wCRl term can be expected to Figs. 11 and 12 give the least-squares straight line plots of the
predominate compared to the tan 6 ’ term [lo]. initial and final leakage currents, respectively. The results are
An interesting observation was made when the results of the in agreement with the linear relationship between leakage
accelerated life test were analyzed with respect to ESR current, capacitance value and applied voltage.
change. The ESR of electrolytic capacitors is the sum of The effect of an accelerated life test causes an increase in
several elements with the electrolyte and the anodic oxide film leakage current which may be due to a decrease in oxide
being the major contributors. It has been noted [4], [lo] that resistivity. The greater relative change at the l- and 2-V test
the contribution of the electrolyte is frequency independent levels may be due to the nonlinear conduction mechanism of
while the contribution due to the series resistance of the film is the oxide layer [ 1l] and the presence of a polarization current
inversely proportional to frequency. component in the currents measured [12]. However, a linear
At 120 Hz, the change. in ESR was greatest for those V-I characteristic can still be used to give an estimate of
capacitors with the higher voltage ratings or thicker oxide. If leakage currents at low operating voltages, compared to
the oxide is the main contributor to ESR at this test frequency, leakage currents at rated voltages after exposure to an
the results suggest that the accelerated life test causes a bulk accelerated life test.
related effect in the aluminum oxide which is more predomi-
nant in the higher voltage rated capacitors. V. VENDOR VARIATIONS
In contrast, the change in ESR at 1000 Hz was greatest for The discussion has been based on average results obtained
lower voltage higher capacitance devices. This suggests that from measurements made on devices supplied by four differ-
the electrolyte is the main contributor to ESR at this ent vendors. It is interesting to note how initial values and
frequency, and that electrolyte dryout may be responsible for relative changes varied among vendors.
the observed results. An accelerated life test could cause both Table III and VI show that Vendor B had units with a
298 IEEETRANSACTIONSONCOMPONENTS,HYBRIDS,ANDMANUFACTURINGTECHNOLOGY,VOL.CHMT-9,NO.3,SEPTEMBER1986