Variability in Fruit Characteristics of Chokanan Mango (Mangifera Indica L.)
Variability in Fruit Characteristics of Chokanan Mango (Mangifera Indica L.)
Abdullah
F. Abdullah1
1Director   General’s Office, MARDI Arau, Lot PT 3747, Jalan Tambun Tulang, 02600 Arau, Perlis, Malaysia
Abstract
This study was conducted with the aim to evaluate the characteristics of
Chokanan mango at harvest. The Chokanan fruits were harvested from selected
trees in commercial mango plot at Sintok MARDI Research Station, Kedah,
Malaysia. Data on the fruit characteristics such as weight, length (L), width (W),
thickness (T) and total soluble solid (TSS, °Brix) were measured and recorded for
13 weeks. The results revealed high significant differences (p <0.001) in terms
of recorded weight, W, L, T, size (W x L x T) and TSS of the Chokanan fruits
among the selected trees. The mean value of the fruits weight at harvest ranged
from 120 to 380 g and TSS ranged from 14.5 ºBrix to 22.8 ºBrix. In the present
study, the distribution of fruits weight was skewed to the left indicating larger
percentage of smaller fruits, but normal distribution was recorded for the TSS.
Apart from that, high significant correlation (R2 >0.80) was found in the weight
and size, L, W and T of the fruits. However, the weight and size of Chokanan
were inversely correlated with TSS. The coefficient of variation (cv) differed
among the harvested trees with the highest were recorded on weight and size of
fruits (cv = 9.5 and 11.4, respectively). Finally, the possible causes of variability
of Chokanan fruits were reported and discussed.
                                                                                                              55
Variability in fruit characteristics of Chokanan mango
affect consumer preferences. Also, the                   The fruits were ripened by means of using
characteristics of Chokanan fruits such                  standard practice, i.e. using calcium carbide
as weight, size and sweetness at harvest                 induction method (Tengku Ab. Malik
were highly variable between trees and                   et al. 1996).
season. To the researchers’ knowledge, no
study has looked into the variation on fruit             Measurement of fruit characteristics
characteristics or morphological traits of               Digital balancing was used to measure
this type of mango. Only a few publications              the fruit weight (g) at harvest (Satorius,
on the effect of preharvest and postharvest              ELT6000). The characteristics of fruits
factors on local mango cultivars have been               such as length-L (mm), width-W (mm) and
reported (e.g. Mohd Azhar et al. 2013;                   thickness-T (mm) were measured using
Pauziah Muda et al. 2014). It is noteworthy              digital calliper (Mitutoyo, Digimatic Calliper
that the knowledge of correlations within                Series 500). The size of fruits expressed
the fruit traits is beneficial in order to               by L x W x T was also calculated and total
improve breeding selection, which focuses                soluble solid (TSS) was measured by using
on special traits such as the size and colour            handheld Refractometer (Atago Model DBX
of the fruit. Apart from that, the assessment            -55, Japan). A few drops of solid liquid
of variability that present in this fruit crop           from the sampled fruits were applied to
may be useful to improve the breeding                    the measuring surface of the prism and the
programme, especially in developing                      results displayed on the screen panel were
suitable variety for better yield and                    recorded in ºBrix.
quality. Also, this information is of utmost
importance for the enhancement of cultural               Statistical analysis
management of mango (Tengku Ab. Malik                    All the data were manually recorded in
et al. 2000c; Léchaudel and Joas 2007).                  an Excel spreadsheet and summarised
Given such a backdrop, the present study                 using Pivot Table Microsoft Excel. The
was undertaken to evaluate the variability               ANOVA procedure of SAS (version 9.0,
of Chokanan mango fruit at harvest. Hence,               SAS Institute Inc., NC USA) was used
the possible reason for the variability of               to carry out the analysis and the mean
Chokanan fruit characteristics were reported             separation were compared by using Duncan
and discussed.                                           Multiple Range Test (DMRT) at p = 0.05.
                                                         The correlation matrix between variables
Materials and methods                                    in this study was analysed using Pearson
Study site and growing condition                         Correlation Coefficients in SAS to identify
This study was carried out during fruiting               the interaction among the characteristics.
season at Sintok MARDI Research Station,                 The distributions of selected variables were
Bukit Kayu Hitam, Kedah, Malaysia. The                   analysed using Kolmogorov-Smirnov at the
five-year-old Chokanan trees were planted                95% significance level (9.0, SAS Institute
at 12 m x 12 m distance and managed under                Inc., NC USA). Data for the general
standard normal horticultural practices for              characteristics, correlation and distribution
mango in the Northern Region of Malaysia                 analyses were conducted on pooled data
(Tengku Ab. Malik et al. 1996). Based on                 from all trees.
the standard nursery propagation method in
Malaysia, the trees were cleft grafted onto              Results and discussion
seedling rootstock cv. Telur. As regards the             The general characteristics of fruits
present study, twenty fruits per tree were               The weight of fruits ranged from 120
randomly harvested on the selected trees                 – 380 g with an average fruit weight of
(eleven trees) at 13 weeks after fruit setting.          200.9 g. The length (L), width (W) and
56
                                                                                                F. Abdullah
                                                                                                        57
Variability in fruit characteristics of Chokanan mango
                                50                                                                                           25
                                      (a)                    Mean = 200.9 g                                                        Mean = 18.8 °Brix
                                                                                                                                                                (b)
                                                             SD = 51.2                                                             SD = 1.9
                                                             Distribution test (p <0.01)                                           Distribution test (p >0.150)
                                40                           n = 220                                                               n = 220
                                                                                                                             20
Frequency of fruit weight (%)
                                30
                                                                                                                             15
                                10
                                                                                                                              5
                                 0
                                         100 – 149
                                                 150 – 199
                                                             200 – 249
                                                                         250 – 299
                                                                                 300 – 349
                                                                                         350 – 399
                                                                                                                              0
                                                                                                                                    14 – 15
                                                                                                                                    15 – 16
                                                                                                                                    16 – 17
                                                                                                                                    17 – 18
                                                                                                                                    18 – 19
                                                                                                                                    19 – 20
                                                                                                                                    20 – 21
                                                                                                                                    21 – 22
                                                                                                                                    22 – 23
                                     Range of fruit weight (g)
                                                                                                                                  Range of TSS (°Brix)
Figure 1. Percentages of fruit distributed into (a) different range of fruit weight (g) and (b)
different range of total soluble solid (°Brix)
W and T of fruits. It is worthy of note that                                                                                compared to bigger fruits size. As soluble
fruit size is an important factor influencing                                                                               solid and sugar content are related to dry
mango orchard profitability due to the fact                                                                                 matter content (Saranwong et al. 2004;
that mango fruit in Malaysia is normally                                                                                    Léchaudel and Joas 2007), it would also
graded by the size (the economic value of                                                                                   be reasonable to suggest that smaller fruit
a fruit). For future study, estimating yield                                                                                size of Chokanan mango may have higher
from equations using simple measurements                                                                                    dry matter content compared to bigger fruit
of L, W and T of fruits could be employed                                                                                   size. Thus, it would be interesting for future
as a non-destructive alternative method for                                                                                 study to evaluate the dry matter content
assessing mango yield at the orchard level.                                                                                 of Chokanan fruits by specifically looking
	     Additionally, weight and size of                                                                                      into whether there is a relationship with the
Chokanan fruit were positively correlated                                                                                   different individual size. Since dry matter
with L, W and T of fruits (R2 >0.80,                                                                                        content is also related to the fruit quality
p <0.0001). However, they were inversely                                                                                    attribute (Saranwong et al. 2004; Léchaudel
correlated with TSS (Table 2). A general                                                                                    and Joas 2007), smaller size Chokanan fruits
trend indicating that higher fruit weight                                                                                   is deemed to be graded as unmarketable fruit
and size may contain lower TSS (Figure                                                                                      and discarded for marketing. Nevertheless,
2a and b) was also observed. Although the                                                                                   further study is still needed to evaluate
correlations are weaker (R2 = 0.14 and 0.16),                                                                               this aspect of Chokanan and other tropical
these trends suggest that Chokanan fruits                                                                                   mango cultivars.
with smaller size and less weight tended to
have higher soluble solid and sugar content
58
                                                                                                                           F. Abdullah
                              25
                                    (a)                                 (b)
                              20
Total soluble solid (°Brix)
15
Figure 2. The relationship between total soluble solid (TSS, °Brix) and
(a) fruit weight (g) and (b) fruit size (L x W x T) of Chokanan mango
                                                                                                                                   59
Variability in fruit characteristics of Chokanan mango
                                                                                           3 cm
                                                R1T17         R6T28            R7T15
            R19T15           R6T27
Table 3. Comparison of the characteristics of Chokanan mango fruits at ripening stage from different
individual trees
60
                                                                                      F. Abdullah
future studies should focus on evaluating        et al. 2000). Both compounds contributed
the relationship between fruit size and crop     to the sweetness and acidity of the mango
load in tropical mango. In addition, as,         fruits (Malundo et al. 2001). It is noteworthy
manipulation on the fruit growth is also         that the carbohydrate level in mango fruit
required in order to increase the percentage     is dependent on the amount produced by
of bigger fruit since tropical mango such as     leaf photosynthesis and the availability of
Chokanan is graded by size. Hence, this will     the reserve pool, and also sink demand
help the growers to get higher income.           (Léchaudel and Joas 2007). However,
	     From the breeding perspective, one         in most tropical mango cultivars, the
possibility is to grow a selected Chokanan       knowledge of these aspects is still wanting.
accession with an inherent ability to produce    	     As regards tropical mango, it is worth
big fruit. Even though an attempt has            highlighting that the source of variation
been made to breed and select a potential        for fruit characteristics within a tree,
Chokanan accession (e.g. Mohd Azhar et al.       such as limb position, canopy position
2013), conventional breeding of mango fruit      and fruit position within a cluster have
trees is still constrained to certain inherent   not been characterised. The researchers
characteristics, such as long juvenile period    strongly believe that various factors such as
and complex reproductive biology (Iyer and       environmental condition (i.e. light, canopy
Degani 1997).                                    management and crop load) and pre-harvest
	     Also, it was reported that the choice      cultural practices may influence the final
of rootstocks and interstock may affect          quality of tropical mango (Léchaudel and
the fruit quality and yield of mango, as         Joas 2007). Moreover, phenotypic variation
discovered on tropical cultivars such as         of Chokanan mango fruits could also be
Masmuda and Harumanis (Ahmad Tarmizi             affected by genetic effect of maternal plants
et al. 2005; Tengku Ab. Malik 2000a; b)          as found in the present study. Therefore, to
and other mango cultivars (Avilán et al.         improve the manipulation of quantitative
1996; Smith et al.1996; 2003). To date,          and qualitative traits of tropical mango
the effect of rootstock on fruit quality of      trees, these aspects warrant further study in
Chokanan and other tropical mangoes is still     the future.
unknown. Nonetheless, considerable effort        	     Furthermore, information with regards
has been made to study this matter in recent     to fruit and tree variability is a prerequisite
year (e.g. Fadhilnor 2016). Other important      for the cultivar improvement or breeding
characteristics in mango are TSS and sugar       purposes. The phenotypic variability among
contents, which are related to dry matter        fruit characteristics provides an indication
content (Léchaudel and Joas 2007). In the        of potential genotypic variability. Further
present study, it was found that TSS (°Brix)     research to explore more on phenotypic and
of Chokanan mango varied significantly           genotypic characteristics in tropical mango
(p <0.0001) among trees (Table 3).               trees is of utmost importance.
	     Generally, the TSS of Chokanan mango
is between 16 and 17 °Brix (Zainal Abidin        Conclusion
and Tengku Ab. Malik 1996b). The result          It is of advantageous to breeders to know
from the present study indicated that fruits     the information of variability that is
from some trees tended to produce higher         available in some important economic traits
TSS up to 21 °Brix (Table 3). Similarly,         and their heritability in order to improve
Mohd Azhar et al. (2013) also found that a       breeding programmes for tropical mango.
few selected Chokanan accessions produced        Overall, it was found that the characteristics
higher TSS. Dry matter content in mango          of Chokanan mango at harvest were highly
mainly consists of carbohydrates and almost      variable and this supported the review by
60% compounds are sugar and acids (Ueda          the Léchaudel and Joas (2007).
                                                                                              61
Variability in fruit characteristics of Chokanan mango
62
                                                                                               F. Abdullah
Smith, M.W., Hoult, M.D. and Bright, J.D. (2003).     Tengku Ab. Malik, T.M. (2000c). Production
     Rootstocks affect yield efficiency and harvest         and potential of dwarf mango trees for
     rate of ‘Kensington Pride’ mango. HortSci.             home gardens. Proceedings of the National
     38(2): 273 – 276                                       Horticulture Conference and Landscape
Tengku Ab. Malik, T.M., Ahmad Tarmizi, S., Zainal           Horticulture, p. 85 – 91. Serdang: MARDI
     Abidin, M. and Choo, S.T. (1996). Amalan         Ueda, M., Sasaki, K., Utsunomiya, N., Inaba, K.
     kultur. In: Panduan Penanaman Mangga.                  and Shimabayashi, Y. (2000). Changes in
     p. 17 – 31 Serdang: MARDI                              physical and chemical properties during
Tengku Ab. Malik, T.M. (2000a). Effect of                   maturation of mango fruit (Mangifera indica
     interstock on growth, leaf nutrient                    L. 'Irwin') cultured in a plastic greenhouse.
     concentration and insidious fruit rot (IFR)            Fd. Sci. Technol. Res. 6: 299 – 305
     incidence of Harumanis mango. Hort. Res.         Zainal Abidin, M. and Tengku Ab. Malik, T.M.
     Ctr. Tech. Rpt. 3.2(29)                                (1996b). Klon Mangga Terpilih. In: Panduan
Tengku Ab. Malik, T.M. (2000b). Effect                      Penanaman Mangga. Serdang: MARDI
     of rootstock on growth, leaf nutrient
     concentration and insidious fruit rot (IFR)
     incidence of Harumanis mango. Hort. Res.
     Ctr. Tech. Rpt. 3.1(28)
Abstrak
Kajian ini dijalankan bertujuan untuk menilai ciri-ciri buah mangga Chokanan
semasa tuaian. Buah Chokanan tersebut dituai daripada pokok yang terpilih di
plot mangga komersial di Stesen Penyelidikan MARDI Sintok, Kedah, Malaysia.
Data ciri-ciri buah seperti berat, panjang (L), lebar (W), ketebalan (T) buah-
buahan dan jumlah larut pepejal TSS (°Brix) telah diukur dan direkodkan pada
minggu ke-13. Keputusan kajian menunjukkan perbezaan yang bererti (p <0.001)
telah direkodkan pada berat buah, W, L, T, saiz (W x L x T) dan TSS daripada
buah Chokanan di antara pokok. Berat minimum buah yang dituai adalah di
antara 120 – 380 g dan TSS adalah di antara 14.5 ºBrix dan 22.8 ºBrix. Kajian
ini mendapati bahawa taburan berat buah telah condong ke kiri dan menunjukkan
bahawa peratusan yang lebih besar untuk buah yang kecil, tetapi taburan
normal dicatatkan bagi TSS. Selain itu, hubungan yang amat bererti (R2 >0.80)
telah diperoleh antara berat dan saiz, L, W dan T buah. Walau bagaimanapun,
perhubungan yang songsang telah dikaitkan antara berat buah dan saiz Chokanan
dengan TSS. Di samping itu, pekali variasi (cv) juga berbeza antara pokok-pokok
dengan berat dan saiz buah menunjukkan catatan yang tertinggi (cv = 9.5 dan
11.4, masing-masing). Akhir sekali, kemungkinan dan punca kepelbagaian ciri-
ciri buah Chokanan turut dilaporkan dan dibincangkan.
63