Phosphorus Nutrition of Dairy Cattle: Dr. L. E. Chase Department of Animal Science Cornell University
Phosphorus Nutrition of Dairy Cattle: Dr. L. E. Chase Department of Animal Science Cornell University
Dr. L. E. Chase
                                      Department of Animal Science
                                           Cornell University
              INTRODUCTION
                                                                      Saliva contains P and can be a significant
          Increased environmental concerns and               contributor to the endogenous P pool (Horst, 1986).
regulations have stimulated renewed interest in              Any factors that depress saliva flow can shift some
phosphorus (P) in dairy cattle rations. The challenge        of the endogenous P excretion to the urine. One
is to design rations with adequate P to meet the             report indicated that P uptake was reduced in cows
needs of the cow while minimizing P excretion to             under heat stress conditions (Sanchez et al., 1994).
the environment. Environmental regulations, which            The authors suggested that decreased endogenous P
limit the quantity of P applied to land, are either in       recycling via saliva could at least be a partial
place or being considered (Tamminga, 1992; Van               explanation.
Horn et al., 1994). A number of papers have
examined the relationships which exist between P                      The primary route of P excretion is fecal
intake and excretion in dairy cattle (Brintrup et al.,       (Hibbs and Conrad, 1983; Morse et al., 1992b). In
1993; Chase, 1994; Dhiman et al., 1996; Harris et            one study, 68.6% of the total P excreted was in the
al., 1992; Morse et al , 1992b; Satter and Dhiman,           feces compared with 1% in the urine and 30.3% in
1996). Chandler (1996) indicated that P accounts             milk. The total yearly P excretion of a dairy cow
for more than 50% of the cost of typical vitamin-            producing 19,800 lbs of milk consuming a ration
mineral mixes used on dairy farms. Thus, there is            with 0.4% P was estimated to be 40 lbs (Van Horn et
rationale from both economic and environmental               al., 1994). This increased to 70 lbs/cow if ration P
considerations to minimize feeding P in excess of            was increased to 0.6%. Fecal P excretion was
requirements.                                                estimated at 30 lbs/year for cows producing 13,750
                                                             lbs of milk in a review paper (Tamminga, 1992).
                METABOLISM
                                                                           REQUIREMENTS
         Phosphorous has a multitude of functions in                   The NRC (1989) requirements provide the
animals. A primary role is the integrity and                 base for most formulation programs in the U.S.
development of the skeletal system. Approximately,           However, there is some disparity in the P
80-85% of the total P in cattle is in the bones and          requirements used for dairy cows in different
teeth (Horst, 1986; NRC 1989). Phosphorus is also            countries (Tamminga, 1992). Table 1 contains the P
involved with cellular energy transfer via the ADP,          requirements for cows at 2 levels of milk production
ATP system. Lipid metabolism is dependent on P,              calculated using current systems in 5 countries.
which is a component of phospholipids. Phosphorus            There are some large differences in both the
is involved in a number of enzyme systems and is a           maintenance and milk requirements. The variation
constituent of saliva.                                       in total P requirement between countries is smaller.
                                                             It is apparent that the P requirement for high
         The absorption of P in the dairy cow is             producing cows needs better definition. The 1989
affected by a number of factors (Horst, 1986;                NRC requirements are 10 to 22% higher than the
Miller, 1979 and NRC, 1989). The primary site of P           previous NRC (1978) due to a lowering of the
absorption is the small intestine (Care, 1994). This         assumed absorption efficiency. It is important to
absorption appears to be an active process which is          remember that daily requirements are for grams of P
influenced by vitamin D (NRC, 1989). The total
quantity of P absorbed is related to the quantity of P
consumed, calcium to phosphorus ratio, feed source,
age and levels of other minerals such as calcium,
magnesium and potassium.
                                                         1
        Table 1: Variation in P requirements of dairy cattlea
                                                        P Requirement                           Assumed
               Milk, b          Country          Maintenance          Milk          Total      Availability
                (lbs)                            ----------------(grams)------------------        (%)
                  50          U.S.                    17.5            44.9           62.4          50
                              Netherlands             25.7            34.0           59.7          60
                              UK                      12.7            35.4           48.1          58
                              France                  37.9            28.4           65.9          70
                              Germany                 24.5            37.6           62.1          60
                 100          U.S.                    17.5            89.8          107.3          50
                              Netherlands             25.7            68.0           93.7          60
                              UK                      12.7            70.8           83.5          58
                              France                  37.9            56.7           94.6          70
                              Germany                 24.5            75.3           99.8          60
        a
            Adapted from Tamminga, 1992
        b
            4% FCM, 1350 lb cow
                                                               with diverse crop management and environmental
not P as % of the ration dry matter (DM). Rations              conditions. The variation of P content of forage
should be formulated based on the grams of mineral             types grown on the same farm would be
required rather than as a % of DM.                             considerably less. These variations in P content
                                                               indicate the importance of forage testing as a base
          The P requirements for replacement heifers           for ration formulation. This will be even more
are calculated using 3 equations based on body                 essential as we balance rations to minimize P
weight (NRC, 1989). These equations reflect the                overfeeding. The median P level in total mixed
decreasing availability of ration P as calves get              rations fed to dairy cattle was 1.32 times the
older. In addition, the average daily gain influences          requirement at 0.49% (Spears, 1996). The range in
the P requirement. Phosphorus requirements of                  P content of these TMR=s was 0.36 to 0.66%.
growing heifers range from 0.23 to 0.31% of the
total ration DM. Two recent papers indicate that the                            AVAILABILITY
P requirement of replacement heifers gaining 2.2
lbs/day may range from 0.15 to 0.34% of total ration                     The availability of P in mineral sources has
DM (Bortolussi et al., 1996; Ternouth et al., 1996).           been examined in a number of trials (Jackson et al.,
                                                               1988; Macrominerals, 1995; Peeler, 1972; Witt and
              FEED COMPOSITION                                 Owens, 1983). Monoammonium phosphate and
                                                               dicalcium phosphate had similar biological
          The level of P found in feeds used in dairy          availabilities when used in rations for growing bull
cattle rations is quite variable. Adams (1975)                 calves (Jackson et al., 1988). A recent summary
reported a 10.6 fold range in the P content of                 indicated that the biological availability of
legume-grass forage samples. Table 2 contains the              monosodium phosphate, monoammonium
mean, standard deviation and normal range for P in a           phosphate, sodium tripolyphosphate and
number of feeds. Note the wide normal range for                diammonium phosphate were all 95-100%
these feeds, which represents about 67% of the total           (Macrominerals, 1995). Similar values for
samples analyzed within feed type. The range in P              monocalcium phosphate, dicalcium phosphate,
content of forages from the Southern U.S. was                  defluorinated phosphate, steamed bone meal, fish
previously presented at this conference (Greene,               meal, and soft rock phosphate were 95-98, 93-95,
1997). The mean P content in these forages ranged              88-91, 80-82, 90-95 and 25-35%.
from 0.1 to 0.66%. The P content in bermudagrass
ranged from .02 to .51%. A range from 0.1 to 0.3%
P encompassed 91% of the bermudagrass samples.
It is important to realize that the samples in all of
these summaries are from a large number of sources
                                                         2
                   Table 2: Phosphorus content of feedsa
                                                  Phosphorus                                             Normal
                               Feed            Mean       S.D.b                                          Rangec
                                                 (%)
                   Legume hay                   .25        .05                                         .20  - .30
                     A      silage              .29        .05                                         .24  - .34
                   Grass hay                   .21         .06                                         .15  - .27
                    A     silage                .28        .07                                         .21  - .35
                   Sudangrass hay               .19        .06                                         .13  - .25
                     A          silage          .26        .07                                         .19  - .33
                   Sorghum silage               .21        .08                                         .13  - .29
                   Sorghum-sudan silage         .25        .08                                         .17  - .33
                   Corn silage                  .21        .03                                         .18  - .24
                   Bakery goods                 .32        .20                                         .12  - .52
                   Beet pulp                   .09         .02                                         .07  - .11
                   Blood meal                   .35        .24                                         .10  - .59
                   Brewers grain, dry           .59        .24                                         .35  - .83
                   Canola meal                 1.13        .18                                         .94  - 1.31
                   Citrus pulp                  .11        .01                                         .10  - .12
                   Corn, shelled               .30         .03                                         .27  - .33
                   Corn gluten feed             .96        .29                                         .67  - 1.25
                   Cottonseed, whole            .59        .12                                         .47  - .71
                   Cottonseed, hulls            .17        .10                                         .07  - .27
                   Cottonseed meal             1.12        .14                                         .98  - 1.22
                   Distillers grains            .79        .15                                         .64  - .94
                   Hominy                      .46         .17                                         .29  - .63
                   Peanut meal                  .52        .15                                         .37  - .67
                   Sorghum grain                .29        .07                                         .22  - .36
                   Soy hulls                    .18        .08                                         .10  - .26
                   Soybean meal                 .67        .09                                         .58  - .76
                   Sunflower meal              .84          --                                             --
                   Wheat grain                 .41         .15                                         .26 - .56
                   Wheat midds                 .89         .23                                         .66 - 1.12
                   a
                     Source: Dairy One Forage Testing Lab, Ithaca, NY
                   b
                     Standard deviation
                   c
                     Mean + or - 1 standard deviation
                                                                     3
The relative bioavailability of P in canola meal and                   The rumen microorganisms have the ability
soybean meal was compared in Holstein bull calves            to hydrolyze the phytate P. The apparent total tract
(Ingalls and Okemo, 1994). The total tract                   hydrolysis of phytate P in young calves and steers
disappearance of P was similar for both protein              was > 99% (Nelson et al., 1976). A study using
sources at 94-96%. A second component of the trial           early lactation dairy cows reported that 98% of the
compared canola meal with a mixture of                       phytate P was hydrolyzed (Clark et al., 1986). Eight
monocalcium phosphate and dicalcium phosphate.               concentrates were used to evaluate phytate P
The authors concluded that the bioavailability of P in       hydrolysis both in vitro and in vivo with dairy cows
canola meal was similar to the inorganic P source.           (Morse et al., 1992a). These concentrate mixes
                                                             contained 32 to 81% of the total P in the phytate
          A ruminal P release of 73% was reported            form. The in vitro results indicated that > 90% of
for grass silages at a rumen outflow rate of 5%/hour         the P in the phytate form was hydrolyzed. Total
(Rooke et al., 1983). The release of P in the rumen          tract hydrolysis of the phytate P in this study was >
was investigated for 6 forage species (Emanuele and          94%. The results of these studies indicate that
Staples, 1990). The average P release for all forages        adjustments for phytate P levels in feeds do not need
was 66% with an initial washing in water and 80%             to be made when formulating rations for ruminants.
after a 72 hour incubation. The release of P was
significantly higher for alfalfa than bermudagrass                         REPRODUCTION
forage at both measurement times. This study did
not evaluate total tract P absorption.                                 A primary reason indicated for feeding P in
                                                             excess of requirements in many herds is to enhance
          Lactating dairy cows were used in a study          reproductive performance. Research data to support
to examine mineral absorption (Khorasani et al.,             this is weak. Many of the early studies reported
1997). The forages used were barley, oats, triticale         depressed reproduction when ration P levels were
or alfalfa silages. The absorption of P increased as         <0.2% (McClure, 1994).
P intake increased. However, there were no
differences in apparent P digestibility between these                 Two trials were conducted with growing
forages. The average total tract P digestibility was         dairy heifers to evaluate the role of added P on
30.9%.                                                       reproduction (Noller et al., 1977). These workers
                                                             reported no benefit to adding 0.1% P to basal rations
          A publication from Ohio State contains the         with 0.22% P. A similar result was reported with
results of a large number of trials examining calcium        beef heifers fed basal rations with 0.14% P
and P utilization in dairy cows (Hibbs and Conrad,           compared with supplemented rations containing
1983). These studies used a variety of forage                0.36% P (Call et al., 1978). The intensity of estrus
sources with or without grain and vitamin D                  was examined in another trial with dairy heifers
supplementation. In these studies, P digestion               (Hurley et al., 1982). Rations containing 73, 138 or
increased when grain was added to forage based               246% of NRC phosphorus requirements were fed to
rations.                                                     12-16 month old heifers. Ovarian function, estrous
                                                             behavior, serum progesterone or serum luteinizing
        PHYTATE PHOSPHORUS                                   hormone (LH) concentrations were not different
                                                             between these treatments.
          Phytate phosphorus may account for 50 to
70% of the total P in many concentrates. In                           Holstein cows were fed rations containing
monogastrics, the ability to utilize P in the phytate        0.24, 0.32 and 0.42% P beginning in the 7th month of
form is limited by low intestinal phytase levels.            gestation for a 12 month period (Call et al., 1987).
Rations are commonly formulated using available P            Cows fed the low level (0.24%) of P produced
rather than total P content of feedstuffs to account         significantly less milk than the other 2 groups.
for this. There is also considerable interest in the         There were no significant differences in reproductive
addition of phytase to monogastric diets to enhance          performance in this study. Milk production of these
P utilization.                                               cows was about 15,000 lbs per lactation.
          A trial was conducted at Michigan State            al., 1980). This was a 2 x 2 factorial design
using 2 levels of energy and P (> 100 and 75% of             conducted for the first 84 days of lactation. There
requirements) in first-lactation heifers (Carstairs et       were no differences in this study on reproduction
                                                         4
related to either energy or P status of the rations.             averaging 16,500 lbs of milk/year. The effect of
Actual P intakes for the 2 groups were 98 and 138%               dietary P level in rations for mid to late lactation
of the NRC requirement. Milk production was 1795                 cows was recently reported (Dhiman et al., 1996 and
lbs lower for cows on the high P ration (Carstairs et            Satter and Dhiman, 1996). Rations contained either
al., 1981).                                                      0.39 or 0.65% P. There were no effects on feed
                                                                 intake or milk production in cows producing 53 lbs
            MILK PRODUCTION                                      of milk per day.
                                                             5
ration Ca:P ratio can be altered by P contributed                         content of dairy cattle feeds. J. Dairy Sci. 58:1538.
from saliva.
                                                                          Bortolussi, G., J. H. Ternouth, and N. P. McMeniman. 1996.
                                                                          Dietary nitrogen and phosphorus depletion in cattle and their
                       SUMMARY                                            effects on liveweight gain, blood metabolite concentrations and
                                                                          phosphorus kinetics. J. Agric. Sci. 126:493.
1.         The phosphorus requirements of the high                        Brintrup, R., T. Mooren, U. Meyer, H. Spiekers, and E. Pfeffer.
           producing dairy cow are not well defined.                      1993. Effects of two levels of phosphorus intake on performance,
                                                                          and fecal phosphorus excretion of dairy cows. J. Anim. Physiol.
                                                                          a. Anim. Nutr. 69:29.
2.         Rations should be formulated based on the
           grams of P required not the % P in the                         Call, J. W., J. E. Butcher, J. T. Blake, R. A. Smart, and J. L.
           ration. The NRC requirements for Holstein                      Shupe. 1978. Phosphorus influence on growth and reproduction
           cows producing 60, 80 or 100 lbs of milk                       of beef cattle. J. Anim. Sci. 47:216.
           are 68, 85 and 100 g of P per day. At
                                                                          Call, J. W., J.E. Butcher, J. L. Shupe, R. C. Lamb, R. L. Boman,
           normal levels of DM intake, this is                            and A. E. Olson. 1987. Clinical effects of low dietary
           equivalent to ration levels of 0.36, 0.39 and                  phosphorus concentrations in feed given to lactating dairy cows.
           0.42% P. If DM intake were 95% of                              Am. J. Vet Res. 48:133.
           expected, then ration P levels would be
                                                                          Care, A. D. 1994. The absorption of phosphate from the
           0.38, 0.41 and 0.44% P.                                        digestive tract of ruminant animals. Br. Vet J. 150:197.
3.         There is little research data to support                       Carstairs, J. A., D. A. Morrow, and R. S. Emery. 1980.
           feeding P in excess of requirements to                         Postpartum reproductive function of dairy cows as influenced by
                                                                          energy and phosphorus status. J. Anim. Sci. 51:122.
           enhance reproductive performance.
                                                                          Carstairs, J. A., R. R. Neitzel, and R. S. Emery. 1981. Energy
4.         The cow, primarily via feces, excretes                         and phosphorus status as factors affecting postpartum
           phosphorus consumed in excess of                               performance and health of dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 64:34.
           requirements.
                                                                          Chandler, P. T. 1996. Environmental challenges as related to
                                                                          animal agriculture-dairy. In Nutrient management of food
5.         Dietary P levels will decrease as we fine                      animals to enhance and protect the environment. Ed: E. T.
           tune protein nutrition and decrease the                        Kornegan. CRC Lewis Publishers, New York. p. 7.
           crude protein levels in rations. This is a
                                                                          Chase, L. E. 1994. Environmental considerations in developing
           reflection of the high P levels in most                        dairy rations. Proc. Cornell Nutr. Conf., Rochester, NY. p. 56.
           protein supplements (Table 2).
                                                                          Clark, W. D., Jr., J. E. Wohlt, R. L. Gilbreath, and P. K. Zajac.
6.         Testing of forages for P is essential as an                    1986. Phytate phosphorus intake and disappearance in the
                                                                          gastrointestinal tract of high producing dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci.
           input for ration formulation.                                  69:3151.
7.         Environmental concerns will increase the                       Coppock, C. E., R. W. Everett, and R. L. Belyea. 1976. Effect of
           need to minimize the overfeeding of P.                         low calcium or low phosphorus diets on free choice consumption
                                                                          of dicalcium phosphate by lactating dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci.
                                                                          59:571.
8.         Lowering ration P levels can reduce                            Coppock, C. E., R. W. Everett, and W. G. Merrill. 1972. Effect
           purchased feed costs.                                          of ration on free-choice consumption of calcium-phosphorus
                                                                          supplements by dairy cattle. J. Dairy Sci. 55:245.
                                                                      6
minerals from six forage species. J. Anim. Sci. 68:2052.
                                                                          National Research Council. 1978. Nutrient requirements of dairy
Greene, L. W. 1997. Mineral composition of Southern forages.              cattle. 5th. Rev. ed. Natl. Acad. Sci. Washington, DC.
Proc. Mid-South Ruminant Nutr. Conf., Dallas, TX. p. 9.
                                                                          National Research Council. 1989. Nutrient requirements of dairy
Harris, B., Jr., D. Morse, H. H. Head, and H. H. Van Horn. 1992.          cattle. 6th rev. ed. Natl. Acad. Sci. Washington, DC.
Phosphorus nutrition and excretion by dairy animals. Circ. 849.
Univ. of Florida, Gainesville, FL.                                        Nelson, T. S., L. B. Daniels, J. R. Hall, and L. G. Shields. 1976.
                                                                          Hydrolysis of natural phytate phosphorus in the digestive tract of
Hibbs, J. W., and H. R. Conrad. 1983. The relation of calcium             calves. J. Animal Sci. 42:1509.
and phosphorus intake and digestion and the effects of Vitamin D
feeding on the utilization of calcium and phosphorus by lactating         Noller, C. H., A. G. Castro, W. E. Wheeler, D. L. Hill, and N. J.
dairy cows. Res. Bull. 1150. Ohio Agric. Res. Develop. Center.            Moeller. 1977. Effect of phosphorus supplementation on growth
Wooster, OH.                                                              rate, blood minerals and conception rate of dairy heifers. J. Dairy
                                                                          Sci. 60:1932.
Horst, R. L. 1986. Regulation of calcium and phosphorus
homeostasis in the dairy cow. J. Dairy Sci. 69:604.                       Peeler, H. T. 1972. Biological availability of nutrients in feeds:
                                                                          availability of major mineral ions. J. Anim. Sci. 35:695.
Hurley, W. L., L. A. Edgerton, D. Olds, and R. W. Henken. 1982.
 Estrous behavior and endocrine status of dairy heifers with varied       Rodehutscord, M., A. Pauen, P. Windhausen, and E. Pfeffer.
intakes of phosphorus. J. Dairy Sci. 65:1979.                             1994. Balances of phosphorus and calcium in dairy goats during
                                                                          periods of phosphorus depletion and subsequent phosphorus
Ingalls, J. R., and R. C. Okemo. 1994. The bioavailability of             repletion. J. Anim. Physiolo. Anim. Nutr. 72:57.
phosphorus from canola meal as measured by Holstein calves and
mobile bag technique. Anim. Feed Sci. Tech. 47:321.                       Rooke, J. A., A. O. Akinsoyince, and D. G. Armstrong. 1983.
                                                                          The release of mineral elements from grass silages incubated in
Jackson, J. A., Jr., D. L. Langer, and R. W. Hemken. 1988.                sacco in the rumens of Jersey cattle. Grass For. Sci. 38:311.
Evaluation of content and source of phosphorus fed to dairy
calves. J. Dairy Sci. 71:2187.                                            Sanchez, W. K., M. A. McGuire, and D. K. Beede. 1994.
                                                                          Macromineral nutrition by heat stress interactions in dairy cattle:
Kincaid, R. L., J. K. Hillers, and J. D. Cronrath. 1981. Calcium          review and original research. J. Dairy Sci. 77:2051.
and phosphorus supplementation of rations for lactating dairy
cows. J. Dairy Sci. 64:754.                                               Satter, L., and T. Dhiman. 1996. Enhancing profitability and
                                                                          reducing environmental impact. Proc. Dairy Forage Res. Center
Khorasani, G. R., R. A. Janzen, W. B. McGill, and J. J. Kennelly.         Conf., U.S. Dairy Forage Research Center, Madison, WI. p. 93.
1997. Site and extent of mineral absorption in lactating cows fed
whole-crop cereal grain silage or alfalfa silage. J. Anim. Sci.           Schoneville, J., Th., A. Th. Van T=Klooster, and A. C.Beynen.
75:239.                                                                   1994. High phosphorus intake depresses apparent magnesium
                                                                          absorption in pregnant heifers. J. Anim. Physiol. a. Anim. Nutr.
Macrominerals. 1995. IMC-Agrico Co., Mundelein, IL.                       71:15.
McClure, T. J. 1994. Nutritional and metabolic infertility in the         Spears, J. W. 1996. Optimizing mineral levels and sources for
cow. CAB International, Oxon, UK.                                         farm animals. In Nutrient management of food animals to
                                                                          enhance and protect the environment. Ed. E.T. Kornegay. CRC
Miller, W. J. 1979. Dairy cattle feeding and nutrition. Academic          Lewis Publishers, New York. p. 259.
Press, New York.
                                                                          Steevens, B. J., L. J. Bush, J. D. Stout, and E. I. Williams. 1971.
Morse, D., H. H. Head, and C. J. Wilcox. 1992a. Disappearance             Effects of varying amounts of calcium and phosphorus in rations
of phosphorus in phytate from concentrates in vitro and from              for dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci. 54:655.
rations fed to lactating cows. J. Dairy Sci. 75:1979.
                                                                          Tamminga, S. 1992. Nutrition management of dairy cows as a
Morse, D., H. H. Head, C. J. Wilcox, H. H. Van Horn, C. D.                contribution to pollution control. J. Dairy Sci. 75:345.
Hissem, and B. Harris, Jr. 1992b. Effects of concentration of
dietary phosphorus on amount and route of excretion. J. Dairy
Sci. 75:3039.
Ternouth, J. H., G. Bortolussi, D. B. Coates, R. E. Hendricksen ,
and R. W. McLean. 1996. The phosphorus requirements of
growing cattle consuming forage diets. J. Agric. Sci. 126:503.
                                                                      7
Van Horn, H. H., A. C. Wilkie, W. J. Powers, and R. A.
Nordstedt. 1994. Components of dairy manure management
systems. J. DairySci. 77:2008.