HISTORY OF
ECONOMIC IDEAS
LECTURE 1
                        Ideas?
•   What are economic ideas?
•   Are they theories and empirics?
•   What do we mean by history of economic ideas?
•   Where is the Origin of Economics?
•   What is Economics?
•   Is this apart from Politics?
         Wealth is the Centre
•   Question is how to increase wealth?
•   Wealth lies in precious metals.
•   Precious metals meant money.
•   Money as a store of value.
•   Increase in the value of money can only come through
    trade
•   Exchange creates value
                 Mercantilism
•   Trade regulation
       • Protectionism through Import quotas, export subsidies,
          tariffs and export duties on imported goods
       • Merchants create wealth
•   Importance of Colonies
•   Promote National Power
•   Guaranteed Markets
                  Physiocrats
•   Where lies the wealth?
•   Who creates wealth?
•   Land and cultivation: Post hunter-gatherer, post
    trading society
•   Emergence of classes: landlords, merchants, peasants
•   Bourgeoisie and Labourer
           Ideas and Ideology
•   Ideology: historically –relative character of ideas
•   Analytical separation between the two is not possible
•   Ideology refers to a whole system of thought, or
    coordinated set of beliefs and ideas
•   Ideology is a framework
•   When we discuss Ideas, the reference to framework
    and ideology is inseparable
•   Philosophical Standpoint
     Role of Ideology in Economic
                Theory
•    Contrasted with scientific core of the subject, by
    implication being regarded as accretion of ethical
    postulates and so-called value judgments
•   Objective vs Subjective
•   Normative vs Positive
•   Metaphysical Analysis does not have a place in
    scientific theory
         Schumpeterian View
•    Vision : Complex shape of reality and of the nature of
    problems confronting mankind in any given historical
    situation is ideological
•   Ideology enters in pre-analytic cognition
•   Ideology before Ideas
•   Can we distinguish between the way in which we see
    things from the way in which we wish to see things?
    Behind Economic Thought
•   Economic thought is ideologically conditioned
•   Economic analysis is independent and objective?
•   History of the formal structure of economic ideas
•   Where are the propositions coming from?
•   Is there independence between economic content and
    meaning of propositions?
•   Necessity of study of history of economic ideas
    Towards Classical Political
           Economy
•   Mercantilists in 17th and early 18th centuries spoke in
    terms of favourable balance of trade
•   Idea of generation of surplus
•   Favourable to firms engaged in foreign trade
•   Trade meant power and wealth
•   Implied state intervention in trade and economy
•   This provided the background to intellectual protests
    of Physiocratic School
    Towards Classical Political
           Economy
•    Physiocrats believed that agriculture was the only
    genuinely productive sector of the economy.
•   Agriculture is the generator of surplus
•   Agriculture was seen as multiplicative compared to
    Industrial Production
•    Quesnay’s Tableau Economique communicated this
    finding.
•   Surplus was diffused through transactions
           Surplus and Power
•   Where does economic power and source of wealth lie?
•   Concept of class
•   This was the centre stage of contribution of Classical
    Political Economy by Adam Smith, David Ricardo
    and Karl Marx
•   Generation of Neoclassical Economic Ideas