United State Court of Appeals Ninth Circuit: Notice of Supplemental Authority
United State Court of Appeals Ninth Circuit: Notice of Supplemental Authority
__________________________________
this Notice of Supplemental Authority in support of his argument the H.R.S. 134-8
complete ban on short barrel rifles fails strict scrutiny. Mr. Young g attaches the
following sources on rifles “Project Manager Soldier Weapons Briefing for NDIA”
“Small Arms-Individual Weapons”. Based on these sources Mr. Young argues the
short barrel rifle simply serves a different function for self-defense and there is no
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-1 Page: 2 of 4 (2 of 40)
government interest in banning them. To illustrate this point Mr. Young uses the
M4 rifle. It is a variant of the original AR-15 rifle designed by Eugene Stoner and
made by ArmaLite. The M4 is a shorter and lighter variant of the M16A2 assault
rifle, with 80% parts in common. The M4 has a 14.5 in (370 mm) barrel; its
shorter barrel allows its user to better operate in close quarters engagement such as
in the home where the right to self-defense is most acute. Many short barrel rifles
(carbines) are shortened versions of full size rifles, firing the same ammunition at a
lower rotational velocity due to a shorter barrel length. Accordingly they are
actually safer for the general public than long barrel rifles for self-defense within
the home because there is less risk of a stray bullet penetrating a wall and hitting
an innocent bystander. For the very seem reasons they are better for home defense
short barrel rifles are in fact less deadly outside the home. Per Heller, rifles are a
class of arms and short barrel rifles as a type of rifle are protected arms. There
complete ban fails any level of heightened scrutiny. Strict scrutiny should be
applied and HRS 134-8 unconstitutional ban on them must be struck down.
s/ Alan Beck_________________________
Alan Beck (HI Bar No. 9145)
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-1 Page: 3 of 4 (3 of 40)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
On this, the 31st day of March, 2013, I served the foregoing pleading by
electronically filing it with the Court’s CM/ECF system, which generated a Notice of
Filing and effects service upon counsel for all parties in the case.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and
correct.
Executed this the 31st day of March, 2013
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-1 Page: 4 of 4 (4 of 40)
s/ Alan Beck
Alan Beck (HI Bar No. 9145)
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 1 of 34 (5 of 40)
BG Peter N. Fuller
18 MAY 2010 COL Douglas A. Tamilio
Program Executive Officer Soldier Project Manager Soldier Weapons
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 2 of 34 (6 of 40)
Program Executive Office Soldier
As of 1 January 2010
Audits, Engagements
and Compliance
Congressional Affairs
Liaison Officers
(TRADOC) / (USAIC) / (FORSCOM)/
(FFID) / (MARCOSYSCOM)
PM Soldier Weapons
PM SW Total PM SW COL D. Tamilio LNOs
Military 2 10
– Fort Benning
Core 17 35 Deputy PM
Matrix 16 46* – Fort Knox
R. Audette
Contractor 13 40 – SOCOM
Total 48 131* Secretary
*Includes Part Time Contractors J. Cosh
Deputy PM Deputy PM
B. Muldowney P. Errante
Current
3
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 4 of 34 (8 of 40)
4
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 5 of 34 (9 of 40)
2009 Successes
5
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 6 of 34 (10 of 40)
Lighten Soldier’s Load
Heavy Heavy
Rifles/ Machine Gun Medium
Shotguns Machine Machine Gun
Carbines * Tripods Machine Guns
Guns Tripods
Before
M3, 44lbs
M16A4, 8.13 lbs M500, 7.7 lbs M122A1, 18 lbs M240B, 27.3 lbs M2, 128 lbs (Including T&E)
%Lighter
After
XM806 Lightweight
M26 MASS MK48, M240L, .50 Caliber MG, XM205, 31 lbs
M4, 6.75 lbs Mounted on M4 M192, 11.5 lbs 18.6 lbs 22.3 lbs 65 lbs (Including T&E)
Ongoing Programs
7
XM153 Common
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013Remotely
ID: 8571097 Operated Weapon
DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 8 of 34 (12 of 40)
Buffalo
RG31A1
M1151 JERRV
M1A2 RG33
MRAP Vehicles in progress 9
XM80603/31/2013
Lightweight
Case: 12-17808 .50 17-2
ID: 8571097 DktEntry: Caliber
Page: 10 of 34 (14 of 40)
Machine Gun
Lightweight
– Two Man Portable (62.0 Vice 128 lbs M2HB)
– Can Be Dismounted From Vehicle Platform And Remounted
On Ground Mount <30 Seconds
System Dispersion-1.1 Mils (Ground Mount No Ballast)
No Headspace Or Timing Adjustment
Minimized Logistic Impact: 133 Parts LW50 vs. 244 Parts M2HB
Weapon System
System Description:
3 Components that are Highly Integrated &
Optimized to produce noted P(effect):
– Semi-auto, Magazine Fed, 25mm Weapon
– Programmable, Low Velocity, High Explosive
Air Burst (HEAB) Ammo
– Fully Integrated Day & Thermal Night Sight w/
Full Solution Target Acquisition/Fire Control
System Weight: 12.0-12.5 lbs
System Capabilities:
– Defeats Defilade Targets And Exposed Targets
– Point Target Range: 500 meters
– Area Target Range: 700 meters
Status:
Contractor Integration Testing: Aug 08
Government Testing at APG: Sep 08 – Present
Limited Safety Release: 4QFY09
MS B: 3QFY10
Current Development Future Development MS C: ~3QFY12
25mm Ammo
11
Case: 12-17808
M2E2 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 12 of 34
Quick Change Barrel Kit (16 of 40)
System Description:
Quick Change Barrel
Barrel Support * Flash suppressor to be
Barrel Extension fielded at a later date
Solid Breech Lock
Flash Suppressor*
Capabilities:
Enhancement will increase readiness by
providing a faster & simpler barrel change
without the need to set headspace
and timing
Reduces Training
Includes Flash Suppressor
Status:
Production Verification Test at Aberdeen
Test Center – May thru Oct 09
Limited User Evaluation at Ft. Benning – Jul 09
12
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 13 of 34 (17 of 40)
13
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 14 of 34 (18 of 40)
Carbine Path Forward
Dual Path
Strategy
Address Field Issues
Army Validation of Requirements
? 14
Individual Carbine Competition
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 15 of 34 (19 of 40)
Description:
The Individual Carbine (IC) will provide the US Soldier with the most accurate,
reliable, durable, maintainable, and modular individual weapon with improved
features such as ambidextrous controls and at a best value to the US Government
Capabilities:
Carbine will provide accurate and reliable firepower
Semi-auto and full auto fire
Integrated rails will accept Mil-Std-1913 rail mounted accessories
Fully ambidextrous
Status:
CDD in Joint Staffing – 10 May 2010
Congress provided RDT&E for FY10
Release draft RFP 1QFY11
Industry Day 1QFY11
Final RFP 2QFY11
15
Precision
03/31/2013 Weapon
Case: 12-17808 Portfolio
ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 16 of 34 (20 of 40)
M14EBR .308
Cal/7.62mm NATO
Mk211
M24 SWS .308
M118LR
$0.57/rnd
2900fps MV
M110 SASS .308 $0.87/rnd
Cal/7.62mm NATO
~25” ~37”
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1800 1900
RANGE in METERS
16
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 17 of 34 (21 of 40)
Sniper Weapons Suite
17
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 18 of 34 (22 of 40)
M14 Enhanced Battle Rifle
Description:
M14 Enhanced Battle Rifle is a rack stock M14 rifle mated to an enhanced aluminum billet stock,
Tactical Scope and Cantilever Mount. This weapon was built by Rock Island Arsenal in response
to numerous Operational Need Statements requesting long range capability.
Capabilities:
Accurate 7.62mm capability out to 800m
Status:
5000 Wpns produced & Fielded; Funding provided to produce additional 1200 Wpns
Potential for Night Vision
18
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 19 of 34 (23 of 40)
FY 10 Technology Shortfalls
Lethality Mobility
Accurate Range Determination Lightweight, High Strength Materials for Small and Medium
Caliber Weapons
Nano Explosives/Nano Propellants Multi-Function Laser
Miniature Non-Magnetic Direction Finding System Reduced Weight and Power Consumption Electronic
Components
Lightweight, Direct View Optics Wireless Weapon Interface
Covert Marking Ammunition for Small and Medium Caliber Wear Resistant Coatings for Weapon Mechanisms
Weapons
19
Case: 12-17808
Summary
03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 20 of 34 (24 of 40)
20
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 21 of 34 (25 of 40)
Questions
21
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 22 of 34 (26 of 40)
Findings
Individual Weapons
Crew Served Weapons
Acquisition Issues
Questions
23
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 24 of 34 (28 of 40)
INTERVIEW POPULATION
24
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 25 of 34 (29 of 40)
The Context
25
Case: 12-17808
THE
03/31/2013
BLUF
ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 26 of 34 (30 of 40)
26
M4/M16
Case: 12-17808
03/31/2013
SERIES RIFLE
ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 27 of 34 (31 of 40)
M4/M16:
Menu of approved Carbine accessories.
COTS Butt Stocks, Magazines, Slings, Bi pods, Handgrips
COTS Scopes / Optics
COTS Suppressors
In extreme cases, Soldiers have purchased upper receivers and high-
costs rifle scopes.
Simple camouflage applications for Carbines and Optics.
Suppression (noise/flash) technology for Carbines.
Need for variable powered Optics for Carbines.
Increased firepower (caliber) at extended ranges.
27
Case: 12-17808
03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 28 of 34 (32 of 40)
M14 ENHANCED BATTLE RIFLE
28
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 29 of 34 (33 of 40)
Mk 48 LIGHWEIGHT MACHINE GUN
Mk 48 LMG:
Original intent was to replace the M240B until the M240L was to be fielded.
Possessing increased firepower and controlling extended ranges has
forced:
Replacement of the M249 SAW by the Mk48 LMG Mk48 LMG
Lethality trumps Weight Reduction when extended fires are required
Leaders want to adopt the Mk48 LMG
Fully recognizing its reduced reliability WRT the M240B/L
M240B
M240L
29
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 30 of 34 (34 of 40)
Miscellaneous
Typical Observation Post (OP) field of fire along IED avenue of approach
31
Acquisition Issues
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013
with Small Arms
ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 32 of 34 (36 of 40)
M4 Bolts
– There is no need for lubricating the weapon
– Less cleaning is required for maintenance
– There is considerably less fouling and debris build up inside
the weapon
– The coating on the bolt will never rub off or flake off
– The weapon operates cooler than one with a regular bolt.
Testing was done by 5 soldiers who fired 1,000 each of M200 Blank
and M855 ball under range conditions
32
Personally Equipped
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013
and Unit Purchase
ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 33 of 34 (37 of 40)
By choosing to purchase equipment that has not been provided from the Army,
individuals and unit commanders:
Violate established Army Policy
– AR 750-10 Army Modification Program
Increase risk to Soldiers
33
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-2 Page: 34 of 34 (38 of 40)
QUESTIONS?
34
Case: 12-17808 03/31/2013 ID: 8571097 DktEntry: 17-3 Page: 1 of 2 (39 of 40)
290
INVESTMENT COMPONENT
Modernization thousand M14 EBRs were assembled be mounted on the shotgun. The bolt • 1QFY09: Materiel release and full-
at TACOM Lifecycle Management handle is mountable on either side for rate production decision
Recapitalization Command at Rock Island Arsenal in ambidextrous handling. • 3QFY09: First unit equipped
response to Operational Need Statements M26 Modular Accessory Shotgun
Maintenance
requesting a longer range capability. The MASS enables Soldiers to transition System:
The upgraded weapons are currently in between lethal and less-than-lethal fires • 4QFY09: Limited user test and
MISSION service with select Army units. and adds the capability of a separate evaluation with MP units
Enables warfighters and small units to shotgun without carrying a second • 2QFY10: Low-rate initial production
engage targets with lethal fire to defeat The M320 Grenade Launcher is the weapon. Additional features include a approved
or deter adversaries. replacement to all M203 series grenade box magazine, flip-up sights, and an • 4QFY10: First article testing
launchers on M16 Rifles and M4 extendable stand-off device for door complete
DESCRIPTION Carbines. A modular system, it attaches breaching.
The M4 Carbine replaces the M16 series under the barrel of the rifle or carbine PROJECTED ACTIVITIES
Rifles in all Brigade Combat Teams, and can convert to a stand-alone weapon. SYSTEM INTERDEPENDENCIES M4 Carbine:
Division Headquarters, and other The M320 improves on current grenade None • Continue: M4 production, deliveries,
selected units. It is 1.4 pounds lighter launchers with an integral day/night and fielding
and more portable than the M16 series of sighting system and improved safety PROGRAM STATUS M14 EBR:
rifles. The M4 series of carbines can also features. It also has a side-loading M4 Carbine: • 4QFY11: Complete remaining 1,200
be mounted with the M203A2 Grenade unrestricted breech that allows the • Current: Delivery and fielding systems
Launcher, M320 Grenade Launcher, or system to fire longer 40mm low-velocity M14 EBR: • Continue: In sustainment
M26 Modular Accessory Shotgun System projectiles (NATO standard and non- • 3QFY09: Army Requirements and M320 Grenade Launcher Module:
(MASS). standard). Resourcing Board approved 5,000 • Continue: Production and fielding
systems • Continue: Reduce size and weight of
The M14 Enhanced Battle Rifle (EBR) The lightweight M26 12-Gauge MASS • 1QFY10: 1,200 additional systems day/night sight
has a new adjustable buttstock, cheek attaches to the M4 Carbine and zeroes authorized M26 Modular Accessory Shotgun
rest and M4-style pistol grip, making to the host weapon. It is also designed • 3QFY10: First 5,000 complete System:
the rifle effective in both close quarters to operate as a stand-alone system, and (95 percent fielded) • 4QFY10–2QFY11: Ramp up to full
combat and in the Squad Designated comes with a recoil-absorbing, collapsible M320 Grenade Launcher Module: rate production
Marksman role. The EBR can be buttstock. The Picatinny rail mounted • 1QFY09: Type classification- • 2QFY11: Materiel release
returned to its original configuration on top allows accessory equipment to standard decisions • 3QFY11: First unit equipped
with no permanent modifications. Five
ACQUISITION PHASE
Technology Development Engineering & Manufacturing Development Production & Deployment Operations & Support
CONTRACTORS
M4 Carbine:
Colt’s Manufacturing Co. (Hartford, CT)
M320 Grenade Launcher Module:
Heckler and Koch Defense Inc.
(Ashburn, VA)
M26 Modular Accessory Shotgun
System:
Vertu Corp. (Warrenton, VA)