Ebube Proj1-3
Ebube Proj1-3
FACULTY OF ENGINEERING
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL
AND ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING
BY:
EMESHIE, EBUBE JOSEPH
159042014
TITLE PAGE
JUNE, 2018
i
CERTIFICATION
This is to certify that this project work is carried out by EMESHIE, Ebube Joseph with
matriculation number 159042014, in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of
Master of Science (M.Sc.) degree (Structures Option) in Civil and Environmental Engineering,
ii
DEDICATION
To my God, the Immortal, Invisible and only Wise One. I give all honour, thanks and sincere
adoration to Him and to His Son Jesus Christ to whom the Kingdom to come has been given and
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
My special gratitude goes to God Almighty, the creator of all things and giver of life for his
grace, wisdom, and protection throughout my industrial training. May His name be praised now
No achievement in life is without the help of many known and unknown individuals. Special
thanks to my parents, siblings and family friends who have been spiritual, physical, financial and
moral backbone.
To my Supervisor Dr. E. E. Ikponmwosa for his professional guidance and his fatherly touch
My in-depth gratitude goes to the Head of my Department Prof G.L Oyekan and all my
lecturers in the department, who have faithfully impacted their professional knowledge on me
and my colleagues (Structures Class 2015/2016) who have served to reshape my thoughts
Finally, I also wish to acknowledge my friends and colleagues; Martins, Lasisi, Emmanuel, Baba
Bolts, Ebuka, Isaac, Deji, Philips, Oluchi, Muyiwa, Opeyemi, Racheal, Saka, Joe, Femi,
iv
ABSTRACT
used. Innovations are much needed to meet the increasing demand for new and quality materials.
This report presents the strength indices of structural concrete elements with ceramic waste as
coarse aggregate to achieve economy and reduce its impact on the environment. The work
investigated the physical properties, setting time of cement paste, workability, compressive and
tensile strength, flexural strength and failure pattern of concrete elements with ceramic waste as
(75Nos.) 150x300mm cylinder moulds was cast and cured for a period of 7, 14, 28, 45 & 90 days
and tested on the specified age. Forty-five (45Nos.) Non-reinforced concrete beam of 750x150x
150mm and Ten (10Nos.) Reinforced concrete beam of 2.16m x150x250mm was cast and cured
for a period of 7, 14 & 28 days for non-reinforced beam while reinforced concrete beams was
cast and tested on the specified age to measure the correlation of strength parameter as observed
during the experiment. The concrete for this investigation was produced from cement, sand and
granite/ceramic waste in the ratio of 1:2:4 (Cement: Fine aggregate: Coarse aggregate) with
water/cement ratio of 0.45. The percentage replacement of granite with ceramic was varied from
0% to 100% at an incremental rate of 25%. The compressive and tensile strength of concrete
cubes and cylinder sample were determined using the Avery Dension Crushing Machine, while
the deflection of the reinforced concrete beams was determined by two-point loading test.
The results of the preliminary tests carried out shows that ceramic waste was found to have a
lesser ability to resist crushing. From the workability test results, it revealed an increase as the
content of ceramic waste increased from 70mm to 99mm at 0% to 75% replacement of granite
with ceramic waste but a decline was observed at 100% replacement. The results on compressive
v
strength shows that the strength value decreased as the percentage replacement increased from
control to 100% replacement. The strength values increased as the curing ages increased
progressively, and it was observed that from 25% to 75% replacement can be used for critical
structural works while 100% replacement are suitable for non-critical structural works. The
results show that tensile strength decreased as percent replacement increased, however as curing
age increases from 0 to 28 days, a gradual increase in tensile strength was observed and from 28
days to 90 days of curing, a decline in the values was noted. Results of non-reinforced beam
show the flexural strength increased as the curing ages are increasing but at 100% replacement a
declined was observed. Results of steel reinforced concrete beam, shows that the deflection
increased as percentage replacement is increased from control up to 75% and further replacement
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE PAGE i
CERTIFICATION ii
DEDICATION iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT iv
ABSTRACT v
LIST OF TABLES xi
LIST OF PLATES xv
vii
CHAPTER TWO LITERATURE REVIEW 23
2.0 PREAMBLE 23
2.1 POZZOLANS 24
2.1.1 History 25
2.1.2 Classification of Pozzolans 29
2.1.3 The Pozzolanic Reaction 30
2.2 COCONUT 32
2.2.1 History, Spread and Cultivation 32
2.2.2 Production 35
2.2.3 Parts of Coconut and Their Respective Uses 37
2.7 CONCLUSIONS 58
3.0 PREAMBLE 60
viii
3.1.1 Cement 60
3.1.2 Fine Aggregate (Sharp Sand) 61
3.1.3 Coarse Aggregate (Granite) 61
3.1.4 Potable Water 61
3.1.5 Coconut Shell Ash 62
3.1.6 Sodium Hydroxide (NaoH) 62
3.1.7 Sodium Silicates (Na3SiO2) 62
ix
3.6.2.1 Consistency/Setting Time of Cement 73
3.6.2.2 Workability 74
3.6.2.3 Split Cylinder Test 75
3.6.2.4 Compressive Strength Test 76
REFERENCES 99
x
LIST OF TABLES
Table 3.1: Showing Numbers of Cube for each Percentage Replacement of Ceramic
Waste
Table 3.2: Showing Numbers of Cylinder for each Percentage Replacement of Ceramic
Waste
Table 3.3: Showing Numbers of Beams without for each Percentage Replacement of
Ceramic Waste
Table 3.4: Showing Numbers of Large Beams with for each Percentage Replacement of
Ceramic Waste
Table 3.5: Showing Weights of Coarse Aggregate (Granite & Ceramic Waste) for each
Percentage Replacement.
Table 3.6: Showing Weights of Coarse Aggregate (Granite & Ceramic Waste) for each
Table 3.7: Showing Weights of Coarse Aggregate (Granite & Ceramic Waste) for each
Table 3.8: Showing Weights of Coarse Aggregate (Granite & Ceramic Waste) for each
Table 4.5: Showing Some Physical Properties of Aggregates, Cement and Ceramic Waste
xi
Table 4.7: Showing Slump Values and Degree of Workability
Table 4.12: Average Compressive Strength Values for 7, 14, 28 & 45 Days
Table 4.13: Average Tensile Strengths for each Percentage Replacement of Ceramic
Table 4.14: Average Flexural Strengths for each Percentage Replacement of Ceramic
Table 4.15: Average Flexural Strengths for each Percentage Replacement of Ceramic
Table 4.16: Load-Deflection Values for 28 Days Old Concrete Beam Replacement with
Ceramic Wastes.
Table 4.18: Cost Analysis Difference between Control concrete and Ceramic Waste
Concrete.
xii
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 4.1: Particle Size Distribution Curves for Sand, Granite and Ceramic Waste
Fig 4.8: Superimposed Graphical Representation of 7, 14, 28, 45 & 90 Days Compressive
Strength of Specimen
Fig 4.9: Superimposed Graphical Representation of Control, 25%, 50%, 75% & 100%
Fig 4.10: Superimposed Graphical Representation of Control, 25%, 50%, 75% & 100%
Fig 4.11: Superimposed Graphical Representation of 7, 14, 28, 45 & 90 Days Tensile
Strength of Specimen
Fig 4.12: Graphical Representation Tensile Strength of Control, 25%, 50%, 75% & 100%
xiii
Fig 4.13: Graphical Representation Flexural Strength of Control, 25%, 50%, 75% & 100%
Fig 4.14: Chart Representation Flexural Strength of Control, 25%, 50%, 75% & 100%
Fig 4.19: Load Deflection Curves for 100% Replacement of Ceramic Waste in Reinforced Concrete
Beam Specimen
Fig 4.20: Superimposed Load Deflection Curves for all Concrete Beam Specimen
xiv
LIST OF PLATES
Plate 3.1: Fine Aggregate (Sand)
Plate 3.6: Various Specimens of Cubes of Normal Concrete and those replaced with
Ceramic Waste
xv
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
types of construction works, including infrastructure, low and high-rise buildings, and
annually. The cement through hydration acts as the binder while the fine and coarse
aggregates serve to improve workability and provide bulk and stability respectively [Zongjin
Li, 2011]. Traditionally cement has been available at exorbitant prices and of various types
Cement, Masonry cements, Expansive cements, White blended cements etc. ) to suit all
purposes. However, the continued extensive extraction of its constituents (limestone, clay,
gypsum etc.) from nature has been questioned because of the depletion of limestone deposits
and the environmental concerns associated with its extraction and production. Environmental
concerns are the high energy consumption required to mine, manufacture, and transport the
cement; and the related air pollution, including the release of greenhouse gas (e.g., Carbon
dioxide- responsible for global warming), dioxin, Nitrogen dioxide, Sulphur (IV) oxide and
particulates.
Research on alternatives to cement, has so far centred on the partial replacement of cement
with different materials (Pozzolans). In Nigeria, the most common and readily available
materials that can be used to partially replace cement without economic implications are agro
1
1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT
ii) Economy
A study carried out by Nigerian Environmental Society (NES), examined types of wastes and
their effect on the environment (Enugu state, Nigeria). Data was collected with the aid of
structured questionnaire from 100 respondents from the study area. Data analysis was by the
use of descriptive statistics. It was found that wastes of rice husk, sawdust waste, coconut
shell waste, waste of coconut fibre, plastic bottles and waste of pure water bags were the
predominant types of wastes identified in the study area. These wastes are deposited in the
environment with little effective method of waste management and recycling. The findings
revealed that waste refuse disposal causes traffic jam on the roads in Enugu state, waste of
disease, drainage blockages, over flooding, possible water pollution and air pollution. Some
of these deposits are not easily decomposed and the accumulation has constituted an
environmental challenge hence the need to convert them into useful materials to minimise
Global pollution coupled with resource depletion (which has led to ecological imbalance) has
challenged many researchers and engineers to seek these locally available materials with a
2
1.2.2 Economy
The high cost of conventional building materials is a major factor affecting housing delivery
in Nigeria. This has necessitated research into alternative materials of construction. Coconut
shells are not commonly used in the construction industry but are often dumped as
agricultural wastes. However, with the quest for affordable housing system for both the rural
and urban population of Nigeria and other developing countries, various proposals focussing
on trimming down conventional building material costs have been put forward. One of the
suggestions in the forefront has been the sourcing, development and use of alternative, non-
conventional local construction materials including the possibility of using some agricultural
wastes and residues as construction materials. Coconuts shells (CS), are agricultural waste
products obtained in the processing of coconut, and are available in large quantities in the
tropical regions of the world, most especially in Africa, Asia and America. In Nigeria,
coconut shell is available in large quantities in the southern part of the country. Apart from its
Bags of cement routinely have health and safety warnings printed on them because, not only
is cement highly alkaline, but the setting process is exothermic. As a result, wet cement is
strongly caustic (water pH = 13.5) and can easily cause severe skin burns if not promptly
washed off with water. Similarly, dry cement powder in contact with mucous membranes can
cause severe eye or respiratory irritation. Some trace elements, such as chromium, from
impurities naturally present in the raw materials used to produce cement may cause allergic
dermatitis. Reducing agents such as ferrous sulphate (FeSO 4) are often added to cement to
3
convert the carcinogenic hexavalent chromate (CrO42−) in trivalent chromium (Cr3+), a less
toxic chemical species. Cement users need also to wear appropriate gloves and protective
clothing. In this regard the need for a reduction in the use of cement during construction is
The aim of this research work is to investigate the behaviour of alkaline (NaOH+Na 2SiO3)
activated concrete with Coconut Shell Ash (CSA) as partial replacement of Ordinary Portland
soundness. Etc. .
To investigate some engineering properties of both wet and hardened concrete with
Coconut shell Ash (CSA) is a cheap alternative to supplement the use of OPC in normal
concrete production. Since the disposal of coconut shell ash constitute environmental
pollution, its reuse in normal concrete production will have the following useful effects:
The results of this study will prove to be of great importance and benefits to the economy in
4
The study will help reduce the high demand for cement production, which causes
This study will help to curb or reduce the health hazards associated with working with
cement.
This study will give an insight into the possible reduction of self-weight of concrete
produced from partially replaced OPC with CSA in the presence of Sodium
Hydroxide of NaOH+Na2SiO3
The cost implications on the use of CSA as pozzolan in the presence of Sodium
more than 86 countries worldwide, with a total production of 54 billion nuts harvest per
annum. Nigeria currently can boast of 265,000 metric tonnes of coconut production and it’s
in 18th position of the world coconut production index. Limited research has been conducted
substitute for cement (pozzolan). However, further research is needed for better
understanding of the behaviour of coconut shell as pozzolan. The main concern of this
5
Use of alternative, non-conventional local construction materials including the
This research work will investigate the possible effect of addition of Sodium hydroxide+
coconut shell ash (CSA) as partial replacement for Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) in
(NaOH+Na2SiO3). Other constituents of the concrete mixes will be held constant. The
OPC:CSA ratio will be at 90:10. The Sodium Hydroxide+ Sodium Silicate (NaOH+Na 2SiO3)
1. Evaluation of the physical and mechanical properties of the materials to be used. E.g.
uniformity and curvature, dry density, moisture content, fineness, soundness. Etc.
and hardened stage. Concrete mix of 1:2:4 is to be adopted for normal concrete cubes,
6
Prepare and cast Ninety 150mm by 150mm by 150mm concrete cubes divided into six
categories(representingNormal,Normal+10%CSA,Normal+10%CSA+4
molality(NaOH+Na2SiO3),Normal+10%CSA+8Molality(NaOH+Na2SiO3),
(NaOH+Na2SiO3 ) . Representing 3 cubes each for 7, 14, 28, 90 and 120 days)
Prepare and cast Ninety 150mm by 150mm by 150mm concrete cubes divided into six
molality(NaOH+Na2SiO3),Normal+10%CSA+8Molality(NaOH+Na2SiO3),
(NaOH+Na2SiO3 ) . Representing 3 cubes each for 7, 14, 28, 90 and 120 days)
Prepare and cast sixty 300mm high by 150mm diameter short cylinders divided into
six categories(representingNormal,Normal+10%CSA,
Normal+10%CSA+4molality(NaOH+Na2SiO3),Normal+10%CSA+8Molality(NaOH+
Na2SiO3),Normal+10%CSA+12molality(NaOH+Na2SiO3)and
Prepare and cast twelve 1300mm by 500mm by 100mm reinforced concrete slabs
Normal+10%CSA+4molality(NaOH+Na2SiO3),Normal+10%CSA+8Molality(NaOH+
Na2SiO3),Normal+10%CSA+12molality(NaOH+Na2SiO3)andNormal+10%CSA+16m
7
3. Conduct preliminary tests to determine the oxides composition of CSA, organic
impurities test on fine aggregate, moisture content of fine aggregate, specific gravity
setting time of cement (without sugar, with sugar and with sugar/CSA).
5. Determination of the setting time (initial and final) of mortar produced from
8. Discussion of the results obtained from all the tests conducted for conclusions and
recommendations.
This research work is an add-on to works that precedes it; it contributes its own quota of
knowledge on the subject matter. It brings to bear the possibilities and potential inherent in
the partial replacement of Ordinary Portland Cement with pulverized Coconut Shell Ash
and concrete.
8
Chapter one gives a walk through on what to expect from the study and a form of general
knowledge on the terms and terminologies used i.e aims, objectives, background study,
Chapter two gives a review of pertinent literature to the study e.g Coconut, Agro waste,
Chapter three explains on the procedure, methodology used for the study and the test details
gotten.
Chapter four contains the test report where the test results are discussed and proper
Chapter five discusses the overall project outlining the summary of the results and the
recommendations proffered.
The reference has the list of sources where some of the literature was gotten from. The
fluid cement that hardens over time. Most concretes used are lime-based concretes such
fondu. When aggregate is mixed together with dry Portland cement and water, the mixture
forms fluid slurry that is easily poured and moulded into shape. The cement reacts chemically
with the water and other ingredients to form a hard matrix that binds the materials together
into a durable stone-like material that has many uses. Often, additives (such as Pozzolans
or super plasticizers) are included in the mixture to improve the physical properties of the wet
mix or the finished material. Most concrete is poured with reinforcing materials (such
9
1) Composition of concrete: Many types of concrete are available, distinguished by the
proportions of the main ingredients below. In this way or by substitution for the cementations
and aggregate phases, the finished product can be tailored to its application. Strength, density,
as well as chemical and thermal resistance are variables. The constituents of concrete are;
2a) Cement: Portland cement is the most common type of cement in general usage. It is a
basic ingredient of concrete, mortar and many plasters. It consists of a mixture of calcium
silicates (alite, belite), aluminates and ferrites - compounds which combine calcium, silicon,
aluminium and iron in forms which will react with water. Portland cement and similar
materials are made by heating limestone (a source of calcium) with clay or shale (a source of
silicon, aluminium and iron) and grinding this product (called clinker) with a source of
2b) Water: Combining water with a cementations material forms a cement paste by the
process of hydration. The cement paste glues the aggregate together, fills voids within it, and
makes it flow more freely. As stated by Abrams' law, a lower water-to-cement ratio yields a
stronger, more durable concrete, whereas more water gives a freer-flowing concrete with a
higher slump. Impure water used to make concrete can cause problems when setting or in
causing premature failure of the structure. Hydration involves many different reactions, often
occurring at the same time. As the reactions proceed, the products of the cement hydration
process gradually bond together the individual sand and gravel particles and other
10
Cement chemist notation: C3S + H → C-S-H + CH
the exact ratios of the CaO, SiO2 and H2O in C-S-H can vary).
2c) Aggregates: Fine and coarse aggregates make up the bulk of a concrete mixture. Sand,
natural gravel and crushed stone are used mainly for this purpose. Recycled aggregates (from
construction, demolition, and excavation waste) are increasingly used as partial replacements
furnace slag and bottom ash are also permitted. The size distribution of the aggregate
determines how much binder is required. Aggregate with a very even size distribution has the
biggest gaps whereas adding aggregate with smaller particles tends to fill these gaps. The
binder must fill the gaps between the aggregate as well as pasting the surfaces of the
aggregate together, and is typically the most expensive component. Thus variation in sizes of
the aggregate reduces the cost of concrete.[27] The aggregate is nearly always stronger than the
binder, so its use does not negatively affect the strength of the concrete. Redistribution of
aggregates after compaction often creates inhomogeneity due to the influence of vibration.
grained materials are added to the concrete mix to improve the properties of concrete
which incorporate limestone, fly ash, blast furnace slag, and other useful materials with
pozzolanic properties into the mix, are being tested and used. This development is due to
11
cement production being one of the largest producers (at about 5 to 10%) of global
greenhouse gas emissions, as well as lowering costs, improving concrete properties, and
recycling wastes.
process where amorphous structure is being transformed into a skeletal structure that exhibits
cementations properties.
2) Properties of fresh concrete: Concrete remains in its fresh state from the time it is mixed
until it sets. During this time the concrete is handled, transported, placed and compacted.
Properties of concrete in its fresh state are very important because the influence the quality of
the hardened concrete. Properties of concrete are divided into two major groups
Fresh concrete is that stage of concrete in which concrete can be moulded and it is in plastic
state. This is also called "Green Concrete". Another term used to describe the state of fresh
concrete is consistence, which is the ease with which concrete will flow.
Consistency
Workability
Plastic shrinkage
Loss of consistency
Setting of Concrete
Concrete Hydration
Air entrainment
12
4a) Consistency: Consistency of a concrete mix is a measure of the stiffness or sloppiness or
fluidity of the mix. For effective handling, placing and compacting concrete, consistency
must be the same for each batch. It is therefore necessary to measure consistency of concrete
4b) Workability: The workability of a concrete mix is the relative ease with which concrete
can be placed, compacted and finished without separation or segregation of the individual
materials. Workability is not the same thing as consistency. Mixes with the same consistency
can have different workabilities, if they are made with different sizes of stone – the smaller
the stone the more workable the concrete. It is not possible to measure workability but the
slump test, together with an assessment of properties like stone content, cohesiveness and
4c) Settlement, bleeding and segregation: Cement and aggregate particles have densities
about three times that of water. In fresh concrete they consequently tend to settle and displace
mixing water which migrates upward and may collect on the top surface of the concrete. This
upward movement of mixing water is known as bleeding; water that separates from the rest
particular form of segregation, in which some of the water from the concrete comes out to the
surface of the concrete, being of the lowest specific gravity among all the ingredients of
concrete. Bleeding is predominantly observed in a highly wet mix, badly proportioned and
insufficiently mixed concrete. In thin members like roof slab or road slabs and when concrete
13
Due to bleeding, water comes up and accumulates at the surface. Sometimes, along with this
water, certain quantity of cement also comes to the surface. When the surface is worked up
with the trowel, the aggregate goes down and the cement and water come up to the top
surface. This formation of cement paste at the surface is known as “Laitance”. In such a case,
the top surface of slabs and pavements will not have good wearing quality. This laitance
Water while traversing from bottom to top, makes continuous channels. If the water cement
ratio used is more than 0.7, the bleeding channels will remain continuous and un-segmented.
These continuous bleeding channels are often responsible for causing permeability of the
concrete structures. While the mixing water is in the process of coming up, it may be
intercepted by aggregates. The bleeding water is likely to accumulate below the aggregate.
This accumulation of water creates water voids and reduces the bond between the aggregates
The above aspect is more pronounced in the case of flaky aggregate. Similarly, the water that
accumulates below the reinforcing bars reduces the bond between the reinforcement and the
concrete. The poor bond between the aggregate and the paste or the reinforcement and the
paste due to bleeding can be remedied by re vibration of concrete. The formation of laitance
and the consequent bad effect can be reduced by delayed finishing operations.
Bleeding rate increases with time up to about one hour or so and thereafter the rate decreases
but continues more or less till the final setting time of cement.
Bleeding can be reduced by proper proportioning and uniform and complete mixing.
14
Use of finely divided pozzolanic materials reduces bleeding by creating a longer path
Bleeding can be reduced by the use of finer cement or cement with low alkali content.
The bleeding is not completely harmful if the rate of evaporation of water from the surface is
equal to the rate of bleeding. Removal of water, after it had played its role in providing
workability, from the body of concrete by way of bleeding will do good to the concrete Early
bleeding, when the concrete mass is fully plastic, may not cause much harm, because
concrete being in a fully plastic condition at that stage, will get subsided and compacted. It is
the delayed bleeding, when the concrete has lost its plasticity, which causes undue harm to
the concrete. Controlled re vibration may be adopted to overcome the bad effect of bleeding.
materials of concrete. A good concrete is one in which all the ingredients are properly
distributed to make a homogeneous mixture. There are considerable differences in the sizes
and specific gravities of the constituent ingredients of concrete. Therefore, it is natural that
the materials show a tendency to fall apart. Segregation may be of three types
1. Coarse aggregate separating out or settling down from the rest of the matrix.
3. Water separating out from the rest of the material being a material of lowest specific
gravity.
A well-made concrete, taking into consideration various parameters such as grading, size,
shape and surface texture of aggregate with optimum quantity of waters makes a cohesive
15
mix. Such concrete will not exhibit any tendency for segregation. The cohesive and fatty
characteristics of matrix do not allow the aggregate to fall apart, at the same time; the matrix
itself is sufficiently contained by the aggregate. Similarly, water also does not find it easy to
remembered, that only comparatively dry mix should be vibrated. If too wet a mix is
excessively vibrated; it is likely that the concrete gets segregated. It should also be
remembered that vibration is continued just for required time for optimum results. If the
vibration is continued for a long time, particularly, in too wet a mix, it is likely to result in
4d) Plastic shrinkage: If water is removed from the compacted concrete before it sets, the
volume of the concrete is reduced by the amount of water removed. This volume reduction is
called plastic shrinkage. Water may be removed from the plastic concrete by evaporation or
by being absorbed by dry surfaces such as soil or old concrete or by the dry wooden form
work.
4e) Slump loss/ Loss of Consistency: From the time of mixing, fresh concrete gradually
loses consistency. This gives rise to the problems only if the concrete becomes too stiff to
handle, place and compact properly. Slump loss in concrete is caused due to the following
reasons.
16
4f) Setting of Concrete: The hardening of concrete before its hydration is known as setting
of concrete or, the hardening of concrete before it gains strength or, the transition process of
changing of concrete from plastic state to hardened state. Setting of concrete is based or
related to the setting of cement paste. Thus cement properties greatly affect the setting time.
-Suitable Temperature
-Cement content
- Type of Cement
-Fineness of Cement
-Relative Humidity
4g) Hydration in concrete: Concrete derives its strength by the hydration of cement
particles. The hydration of cement is not a momentary action but a process continuing for
long time. Of course, the rate of hydration is fast to start with, but continues over a very long
time at a decreasing rate In the field and in actual work, even a higher water/cement ratio is
used, since the concrete is open to atmosphere, the water used in the concrete evaporates and
the water available in the concrete will not be sufficient for effective hydration to take place
If the hydration is to continue, extra water must be added to refill the loss of water on account
favourable environment during the early period for uninterrupted hydration. The desirable
17
Concrete, while hydrating, releases high heat of hydration. This heat is harmful from the
point of view of volume stability. Heat of hydration of concrete may also shrinkage in
concrete, thus producing cracks. If the heat generated is removed by some means, the adverse
effect due to the generation of heat can be reduced. This can be done by a thorough water
curing.
4h) Air Entrainment: Air entrainment reduces the density of concrete and consequently
reduces the strength. Air entrainment is used to produce a number of effects in both the
2. Increased cohesion, reducing the tendency to bleed and segregation in the plastic concrete.
Strength of concrete
Concrete Creep
Shrinkage
Modulus Of Elasticity
Water tightness (Impermeability)
Rate of Strength gain of Concrete
Tensile Strength
Durability
18
5a) Strength: The strength of concrete is basically referred to compressive strength and it
Paste strength: It is mainly due to the binding properties of cement that the
ingredients are compacted together. If the paste has higher binding strength, higher
Interfacial bonding: Interfacial bonding is very necessary regarding the strength. Clay
hampers the bonding between paste and aggregate. The aggregate should be washed
especially coarse aggregates which act just like bones in the body. Rough and angular
Admixtures
5b) Creep in concrete: Concrete creep is defined as: deformation of structure under
sustained load. Basically, long term pressure or stress on concrete can make it change shape.
This deformation usually occurs in the direction the force is being applied. Like a concrete
column getting more compressed, or a beam bending. Creep does not necessarily cause
concrete to fail or break apart. Creep is factored in when concrete structures are designed.
19
5c) Shrinkage in Concrete: Concrete is subjected to changes in volume either autogenous or
induced. Volume change is one of the most detrimental properties of concrete, which affects
the long-term strength and durability. To the practical engineer, the aspect of volume change
in concrete is important from the point of view that it causes unsightly cracks in concrete.
We have discussed elsewhere the effect of volume change due to thermal properties of
aggregate and concrete, due to alkali/aggregate reaction, due to sulphate action etc. Presently
“shrinkage”.
One of the most objectionable defects in concrete is the presence of cracks, particularly in
floors and pavements. One of the important factors that contribute to the cracks in floors and
pavements is that due to shrinkage. It is difficult to make concrete which does not shrink and
Now the question is how to reduce the shrinkage and shrinkage cracks in concrete structures.
The term shrinkage is loosely used to describe the various aspects of volume changes in
5d) Rate of Strength Gain of Concrete: Strength can be defined as ability to resist change.
One of the most valuable properties of the concrete is its strength. Strength is most important
parameter that gives the picture of overall quality of concrete. Strength of concrete usually
Hardening is the process of growth of strength. This is often confused with 'setting'
Setting is the stiffening of the concrete after it has been placed. Hardening may
continue for weeks or months after the concrete has been mixed and placed.
20
5e) Tensile Modulus - Young's Modulus or Modulus of Elasticity - is a measure of
stiffness of an elastic material. It is used to describe the elastic properties of objects like
Tensile Modulus is defined as the "ratio of stress (force per unit area) along an axis
It can be used to predict the elongation or compression of an object as long as the stress is
5f) Permeability: is the ease with which liquids or gases can travel through concrete. This
property is of relation to the water tightness of liquid retaining structures and to chemical
attack. It is necessary for concrete to be reliable and to withstand the conditions it has been
designed for, to have trouble free service life. Thus it has to be durable. Durability is
The penetration of solutions into concrete depends on its permeability and as this result many
adverse effects that are not desired. Concrete which are permeable may have cracks during
freezing and thawing. Through time, these cracks may increase in size to affect the strength
of concrete. Also, the penetration of chlorides, water, water etc., through these cracks water
may lead to corrosion of the reinforcement to cause loss of strength. Another cause of
permeability of concrete is the pores within the cement matrix. The causes of these voids are
techniques and temperatures, rate of hydration and material size distribution. Due to these
21
adverse effects, preventive measures must be taken to avoid these problems such as optimum
water-cement ratio value, optimum compaction time, or / and adding mineral admixtures.
5g) Tensile strength of concrete: The estimate of flexural tensile strength or the modulus of
rupture or the cracking strength of concrete from cube compressive strength is obtained by
the relations
The tensile strength of concrete in direct tension is obtained experimentally by split cylinder.
5h) Durability of concrete: Durability of concrete is its ability to resist its disintegration and
decay. One of the chief characteristics influencing durability of concrete is its permeability to
The desired low permeability in concrete is achieved by having adequate cement, sufficient
low water/cement ratio, by ensuring full compaction of concrete and by adequate curing.
22
CHAPTER TWO LITERATURE REVIEW
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 PREAMBLE
The high cost of construction materials like cement and reinforcement bars, has led to
increased cost of construction, especially at a time where the local currency is being devalued
daily. This coupled with the pollution associated with cement production, has necessitated a
search for an alternative binder (which must be economical) which can be used sorely or in
partial replacement of cement in concrete production. More so, disposal of agricultural waste
(also known as Agro-waste) materials such as rice husk, groundnut husk, corn cob and
coconut shell have constituted an environmental challenge, hence the need to convert them
into useful materials to minimize their negative effect on the environment. Research indicates
that most materials that are rich in amorphous silica can be used in partial replacement of
cement (Pozzolans). It has also been established that amorphous silica found in some
pozzolanic materials reacts with lime more readily than those in crystalline form. Use of such
23
Pozzolans can lead to increased compressive and flexural strength. In order to produce
environmental friendly concrete, reduced use of natural resources, technology consuming less
amount of energy and producing lower carbon dioxide emissions is suggested. McCaffrey
suggested that the amount of CO2 emissions by the cement industries can be reduced by
decreasing the amount of calcinated materials in cement, by decreasing the amount of cement
The present study attempts to explore the possibility of using coconut shell ash in the
development of binding material with alkalis, that is, sodium hydroxide + sodium silicate in
the manufacture of concrete. The cementing material shall act as an alternative to cement
(partial replacement). This will address the issues of reducing the emission of greenhouse
gases, reduction in energy requirement and also the disposal of the by-products in an
This work is aimed at evaluating the characteristic of locally available coconut shell ash in
the vicinity of Lagos/Nigeria to check its use in the development of cementing material.
2.1 POZZOLANS
The term pozzolan (or pozzolana), in general sense of it, is employed to designate any
(consolidated volcanic ash or turf) found near Pozzuoli in Italy (Shetty, 2005). Pozzolans are
cementitious value, but will, in finely divided form and in the presence of moisture,
chemically react with calcium hydroxide released from the hydration of Portland cement, at
properties. This action is termed pozzolanic action. These materials are often added to
concrete to make concrete mixtures more economical, reduce permeability, increase strength,
24
or influence other concrete properties, which can be used individually or in combination with
Figure 2.1a: Volcanic ash (natural pozzolan) Figure 2.1b: Hot volcanic ash from a volcano
(Source: earthobservatory.nasa.gov)
2.1.1 History
Evidences exist to confirm that Pozzolans were used at the time of the ancient Greeks,
Egyptians and Romans because X-ray diffraction shows the presence of a zeolitic material
called "analcime" which ranges from 10 to 40% by weight in the lime mortars; this zeolite is
often found in tuffs and other pozzolanic materials of Europe (Davidovits, 1987).
The term "pozzolan" came from a U.S. simplification of "pozzolana" which evolved from the
location "Pozzuoli, Italy" where the Romans found a reactive silica-based material of
volcanic origin which they called "pulvis puteolanus” (Davis, 1950) (Spence & Cook,
1983).Today both the terms "pozzolan" and "pozzolana" are used (Day, 1990).
The Roman practice for using pozzolan was to mix it with lime and rubble, add as little water
as necessary and ram the mix into a compacted mass (Mielenz, 1948). The Romans used the
red or purple tuff found near Naples (Pozzuoli) after it was finely ground and mixed with
lime or hydraulic lime and sand. If pozzolanic earth was not available they used powdered
25
tiles or pottery (Anon, 1988) (Miles, 1974). The 42m-span dome in the Pantheon, Rome, is
one of several examples of Roman structures, many including pozzolans, that has survived
During technological developments in Greece and Rome, mortars and renderings of many of
India's ancient buildings were being manufactured from lime-surkhi (a mixture of lime and
crushed clay brick). From the 19th century to the present lime-surkhi is still used for canals
and damworks because (a) it is less liable to shrink, (b) it produces a more impermeable
structure, and (c) the material can better accommodate internal stresses (Spencer, 1984).
In Northern Europe, Rhenish trass has been known for 2000 years; mortars containing trass
have been found in Roman buildings along the Rhine. Such materials were even in use in the
U.K. at one time - in 1909 "Potters' red cement" was manufactured consisting of ground burnt
clay and Portland cement. The presence of bauxite has also been reported in some ancient
mortars - e.g. the ruins at Baux in the Rhone valley; some French mortars have been made
After the Roman era there does not appear to be many developments in construction practices
until the Industrial revolution when cements were required to ensure progress and later, when
Portland cement was discovered. In England it was not until the 17th century that imported
Dutch trass-lime mixtures were used. Such mixtures were also extensively used in Holland
for construction of harbours and sea defence (Miles, 1974). A common theme during this
period appears to be the realization that pozzolans produced construction materials that had
Contemporary use of natural pozzolans was, and still is, widespread in Europe. In the United
States considerable investigations and uses of natural pozzolans occurred after their first
substantial use for the Los Angeles aqueduct in 1912. In this structure, 1x108kg of 11
26
OPC/pozzolan cement, (50% OPC and 50% "deeply altered" rhyolite tuff) was used. The
savings due to the use of the pozzolan amounted to $700,000 and was one of the principal
reasons why the pozzolan was used in the first place (Drury, 1954).
Early construction under the control of the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation used pozzolans
which, today, would be thought very poor. Nevertheless, good performance resulted. In 1915
the Arrowrock dam in the U.S. was constructed using a "granite" pozzolan. Although this
dam had to be refaced in 1937 due to surface weathering, there was no problem with the
interior concrete and it was reported to have given 60 years of distress-free service (Elfert,
1973). Other dams built at the time were the Lahontan Dam, 1915, using siliceous silt and the
Elephant Butte dam, 1916, which used ground sandstone. Typically, 55% OPC was
interground with 45% of a pozzolan found near the site of the dam.
made with pozzolans had desirable properties such as improved permeability and resistance
to action by aggressive waters. As a result, in 1935 pozzolan was used in the Bonneville
Dam, in the Friant Dam in 1942. The Friant Dam marked the first use of a pumicite or first
"real" pozzolan, while for the Davis Dam in 1950 a calcined opaline shale was used. Use of
From 1940-1973 the Bureau of Reclamation has used 360,000 tonnes of natural pozzolans in
7.1 million cubic metres of concrete; over the same period they have used 275,000 tonnes of
It should be noted that the principal reason for the use of Pozzolans by U.S. authorities was
cost. On all of the projects involving large quantities of Pozzolans were discovered close to
the construction site; transportation costs were very small for applications in which high
strengths were not required. For example, local Monterey shale was used for the San
27
Francisco and Golden Gate bridges. In the anchorage of the Bay bridge 53,000 m 3 of shale
was used and the material was also used for the pier and fender of the Golden Gate Bridge.
Economy was of prime concern, but the pozzolan was also used because of its proven
resistance to alkali soils and sulphates and its favourable heat generation (Price, 1975)
(Meissner, 1950).
Early applications of pozzolan in ancient civilizations and contemporary uses in Europe, Asia
and America have shown pozzolans to be useful materials. This potential has caused a surge
of research about many types of pozzolanic materials for use in a multitude of applications
(Day, 1990).
It has been noted that natural pozzolans, either in a pulverized state or in compacted form,
can be found in 6 countries in Africa: Burundi, Cameroon, Cape Verde, Ethiopia, Rwanda
and Tanzania (HABITAT, 1985). However, examination of the literature has also revealed
The Moroccan Volcanic rocks are centered on Casablanca. Compression tests on a 80:20
OPC: Rhyolite glass pozzolan gave strengths at 180 days in the region 40 - 50Nmm-2. In
Egypt, "Karnak" cement is being used as blended cement with 25% OPC replaced by finely
ground siliceous sand. The strength of concrete at 28 days is about 50% of an OPC control
concrete (Eldarwish & Shehata, 1983). Nevertheless, this is perhaps recognition that modern
28
Tanzania has been the site of fairly extensive scientific evaluations of this pozzolan (Stulz,
1983) (Allen, 1983) (Makange & Massawe, 1986). Tests indicate good strengths, even up to a
60% replacement level of OPC. Other test results are reported in more detail in subsequent
sections.
Another possible pozzolanic source in Africa is bauxite waste. Bauxite is mined in Ghana
and approximately 25% of this is washed away as "red mud" (Day, 1990).
There are clays everywhere in Africa that could be used as pozzolans; there are also oil-spent
shales in Nigeria, Gabon and the Ivory Coast that could also be used (Hammond, 1983).
Finally, in Africa alone there are about 40 countries where rice is grown, thus making the
Day (1990) noted that several classification systems have been proposed for pozzolans. These
The most common classification system used today is one which the primary division of
Artificial Pozzolans
These include materials such as fly ash, blast furnace slag, surkhi, siliceous and opaline
shales, spent oil shale (used in Sweden to make "gas concrete"), rice husk ash, burnt banana
leaves, burnt sugar cane stalks and bauxite waste (Grane, 1980) (Lea, 1970). Other potential
materials, such as bagasse ash, laterite soils and red tropical soils which require firing to
29
induce pozzolanicity would also presumably be classified as artificial pozzolans, but if
Natural Pozzolans
Among the natural pozzolans are tuff, Santorin earth (volcanic ashes), trass, rhyolitic
One other classification system worthy of mention is that of Sersale (1980), who
There are several steps involved in the pozzolanic reaction in concrete. As Portland cement
reacts with water, the tri-calcium silicate (C3S) and di-calcium silicates (C2S) react to form
calcium silicate hydrates (C-S-H), largely responsible for strength development, together with
calcium hydroxide, Ca(OH)2 (often referred to as “lime”). At the same time, the alkalinity of
the water (now referred to as pore fluid) increases to pH 13 or higher. This combination of
30
events provides ideal conditions under which the pozzolan can react. The high pH first causes
the silicate network structure of the pozzolan to break down to smaller units, which then react
with the calcium hydroxide to form more calcium silicate hydrate binder. The net effect is
that the calcium hydroxide in the concrete — which itself has no strength-forming properties
and is also a potential site of weakness for certain forms of chemical degradation — is
converted by the pozzolan to additional C-S-H binder which is deposited in pore spaces. This
leads to a general densification of the cement matrix, which contributes to increased strength,
Portland cement requires only about 25% water to completely react to form concrete.
However, many concrete mixes employ larger percentages of water content to allow the mix
to flow properly into the formwork or to achieve proper workability. This excess water
inevitably introduces void spaces in the concrete that make the concrete porous and provide
conduits for the passage of water and aggressive solutions. It is therefore easy to understand
that the water-to-cement (w/c) ratio is a major controlling factor in the strength potential of a
given concrete mix design: low w/c ratios are associated with higher strengths; whereas high
31
w/c ratios are associated with lower strengths. The conversion of the calcium hydroxide to C-
S-H by the pozzolanic reaction and the filling of the void spaces both contribute to improved
concrete quality, compressive and flexural strength, and long-term durability [Vitro, 2006].
Ash pozzolans have relatively slow and variable reaction rates depending on the following:
Type of ash (e.g. coal combustion fly ash, agricultural waste ash)
It has been demonstrated that the best pozzolan in optimum proportions mixed with Portland
Improved resistance to attack from salts and sulphates from soil and sea water.
Reduced permeability.
32
Lower costs of concrete production.
2.2 COCONUT
Coconut palm (Cocos nucifera) is one of the most essential and valuable palms in the world,
it is an important crop in the agricultural economy of many countries of the world providing
food, drink, housing and raw materials for industries (Nair et al., 2003). The coconut palm,
Cocos nucifera is the only accepted species in the genus Cocos. The term coconut refers to
the entire palm and the seed or the fruit. There are two natural sub-groups, simply referred to
as “Tall” and “Dwarf” cultivars. The Tall cultivar group is sometimes given the name Cocos
nucifera var typica and the dwarf cultivar group Cocos nucifera var nana (Perera et al.,
2009).The tall cultivars are grown for commercial purpose because they live longer and are
higher yielding than the dwarf cultivars (Chan et al., 2006). The origin of the plant is the
subject of debate (Grimwood et al., 1975). Several authorities submit an Indo-Pacific origin
either around Melanesia and Malesia or the Indian Ocean, while others see the origin in
northwestern South America (Perera et al., 2009). The coconut palm is now widely
distributed throughout Asia, Africa, Latin America, the Caribbean and the Pacific region
(FAO, 2011). In Africa, the northern limits are located on the West Coast in Cape Verde
(15oN) and on the east, Djibouti (11.5oN) with isolated coconut palms found in the far north
on the Red Sea and up to 24 oN. The Southern limits in Africa is located at 15 oS on the West
Coast and the Zambezi River (19oS), on the east and also found farther south in Port Dauphin
in Madagascar at 25oS.
33
Coconut fronds
Coconut shell
Edible nut
Coconut husk
Stem
Root
Figure 2.1c: Components of a coconut palm and makeup of its drupe. (Source: Wikipedia)
In Nigeria, the coconut palm is found mostly in the Southern states and in some marginal
areas up to 10oN. Though coconut palms are known to grow under diverse types of climate
and are highly adaptable, they are usually grown along sea coasts and in plain ground. They
can be cultivated up to 1000m above sea level, and tends to grow best in places with a mean
annual temperature of 25°C - 28°C and an annual rainfall of 200mm. More than 90% of
Nigeria’s coconut belt is a continuation of the plantations or grooves along the West African
coast running from Cote d’evoire and southeast towards Ghana, Togo and Benin to Lagos
state in Nigeria. This belt continues in a 1km wide strip of grooves along some 200km of
coastline in Lagos state. The largest coconut palm plantation is found in the Badagry local
government area of Lagos State located in the South West of Nigeria. The first coconut
plantation in Nigeria was established in 1876 by the Roman Catholic Mission in Badagry,
Lagos State, and a good number of palms are found along the beach while most are found as
34
home stead palms. It can also be found along banks of small streams and stagnant pools of
water in some northern states. The farthest distance from the sea shore with yielding coconut
in Nigeria is about 1,400 kilometres which are to be found in the palace of the Emir of Dutse
Figure 2.2: A map of Nigeria showing the states where coconut can be cultivated (in red thick
marks), with Lagos (in yellow) accounting for most of the cultivated coconut trees.
The cultivation of coconut is in scattered holdings and mostly in groves in the rainforest zone
of Nigeria, so it is difficult to estimate the number of farmers that grow the crop. An
estimated 36,000ha is presently under cultivation mostly in Lagos and Rivers states and an
estimated 1.2million hectare of land is suitable for coconut cultivation (NIFOR, 2008). The
West African tall (WAT) is the most extensively grown tall variety both as a plantation and
compound crop. Traditionally, tall varieties are commercially cultivated are usually known
by the places where they are cultivated. They grow to a height of 15-18metres and their life
span extends up to 60 to 75 years. They come to flowering 6 to 7 years after planting and
produces large-sized nut with good quality copra and oil content of 67% (Nair et al., 2003).
Coconut is the main cash crop in Lagos State where 30,000 families who are farmers use it as
source of livelihood. Lagos’ coconut belt stretches about 180km length from Seme Border
35
through Badagry, Ojo, AmuwoOdofin, EtiOsa and IbejuLekki. The belt continues through
Ogun, Edo, Delta, AkwaIbom and Cross River States (LASMAC, 2010).
2.2.2 Production
On very fertile land, a tall coconut palm can yield up to 75 fruits per annum. The bulk of the
coconut produced in Nigeria is mainly for home consumption and local trading. As at 2004
Nigeria’s annual coconut production in value was 195,000MT, then Nigeria was in the 20th
position among the world’s major coconut producing countries. By 2005, there was an
increase in the production of coconut in Nigeria to 209,000MT. In 2006 Nigeria moved to the
19th position in the world with an annual production of 225,000MT, 16000MT higher than the
previous year. In 2007 the country produced 225,500MT. 2008 saw the national coconut
production rise to 234,000MT. Nigeria became the 5th major producer of coconut in Africa,
producing a total of 1,088,500MT of coconut between 2004 and 2008 (Uwubanmwen et al.,
2011). With reference to the information available on FAOSTAT website, Nigeria’s coconut
36
2005 209000 2014 267520
It should be noted that, it is very difficult to capture all coconut production in the country,
because a reasonable amount of the crop are being cultivated as home stead crops. However,
the figures quoted above are reasonable representation of Nigeria’s coconut production since
300000
250000
200000
150000
100000
50000
0
Figure 2.3: A line chart showing Nigeria’s coconut production from 2000 to 2014
(Chart data is from Table 2.1)
The different uses of the different parts and components of a coconut tree and its nut are
37
2 Trunk Coconut trunks are used for building small bridges and huts;
Trunks are preferred for their straightness, strength, and salt
resistance.
The trunk of coconut may be used as wood logs processed for
use as furniture;
Dried logs may further be broken into pieces for use as firewood
3 Roots Used as a dye, a mouthwash, and a medicine for diarrhea
and dysentery.
A frayed piece of root can also be used as a toothbrush
5 Husk The smoke from burning husk may be used to repel mosquitos.
Husks are used for fuel and are a source of charcoal;
A dried half coconut shell with husk can be used to buff floors
Fresh husk of a brown coconut may serve as a dish sponge or
body sponge
Fiber from the husk of the coconut is used in ropes, mats, door
mats, brushes, sacks, caulking for boats, and as stuffing fiber
for mattresses
Husks are used as a potting medium to produce healthy forest
tree saplings.
6 Shell Pulverized coconut shell may be used as partial replacement for
fine aggregate in concrete production
Coconut shell ash may be used as pozzolana in concrete and
sancrete blocks.
Activated carbon manufactured from coconut shell is considered
extremely effective for the removal of impurities in treatment of
water
May be used as carvings and artifacts for decorations.
7 Seed (Edible nut) Primarily serves as food
provides oil for frying, cooking, and making margarine
used fresh or dried in cooking, especially in confections
Coconut flour has been developed for use in baking
Oil, butter, chips, milk, etc., may be produced from fresh or
processed coconut seed.
8 Water Taken as sport drinks
Coconut water can be fermented to produce coconut vinegar
Summarized from an article on coconut in Wikipedia
2.3.1 Definition
People have to know the real definition of waste. Waste is anything that is unusable and
unwanted. Around the world there are billions of waste materials that are continuously being
produced by man. That is why there is a great need for human to understand the types and
38
According to the Basel convention on the control of trans-boundary movements of hazardous
wastes and their disposal of 1989, Art. 2(1), "'Wastes' are substance or objects, which are
prime products (that is, products produced for the market) for which the generator has no
and of which he/she wants to dispose. Wastes may be generated during the extraction of raw
materials, the processing of raw materials into intermediate and final products, the
consumption of final products, and other human activities. Residuals recycled or reused at the
waste as "an object the holder discards, intends to discard or is required to discard."[3] For a
more structural description of the Waste Directive, see the European Commission's summary.
There is a need today for an effective waste management since inaccurate waste disposal is a
huge threat to the health of people and also to the environment. A lot of experts have been
proven over the years that inappropriate waste disposal has a lot of detrimental effect to the
lives of the people all over the world. These effects can cause diseases to spread because of
rodents, insects, and other pests that can cause gastrointestinal problems.
These gastrointestinal problems are also caused by poor disposal of garbage that leads to the
multiplication of mosquitoes and cockroaches. These pests can spread a lot of bacteria that
can cause illness to people. Improper waste disposal can contaminate the resources around
the world. It can greatly contaminate water, soil, and the air. If this thing happens, it can lead
39
2.3.2 Classification of Waste Products
Biodegradable Wastes - The biodegradable wastes are those that can be decomposed
by the natural processes and converted into the elemental form. For example, kitchen
decomposed and remain as such in the environment. They are persistent and can cause
The types listed here are not necessarily exclusive and there may be considerable overlap so
that one waste entity may fall into one to many types
40
Household hazardous waste Packaging waste
(radioactive/hazardous)
Sludge
Spent nuclear fuel
Litter Sewage
waste) Wastewater
Calcium hydroxide is one of the soluble hydrates that formed from the reaction between
Ordinary Portland Cement and water. It exists in the interfacial zone which promotes micro-
cracks. The Ca(OH)2 product can be reduced and the production of C-S-H which contributes
41
to the strength can be further increased with the addition of pozzolanic materials. This is due
to the reaction between pozzolans and the Ca(OH) 2 formed (Lee et al., 2003). It has been
reported that the use of chemical activators namely sulphate activation and alkali activation
may be utilized to accelerate fly ash reactivity. It was stated that sulphate activation can be
studied by using several chemicals such as gypsum, CaSO4·2H2O and sodium sulphate,
Na2SO4, whereas NaOH and Ca(OH)2 are used for alkali activation studies. The effect of
using other types of chemical to accelerate pozzolanic reactivity such as CaCl 2·2H2O and
Martinez-Ramirez and Palomo (2001) defined alkali activation as a chemical process where
the amorphous structure is being transformed into a skeletal structure that exhibits
cementitious properties. Polymeric gel with variable composition is formed in the media of
high alkalinity. The gel is produced when the solution of high alkalinity reacts with the
starting materials. The main behaviour of the products formed via these conditions is having
Palomo et al. (1999b) investigated the way to activate fly ash by alkali activation method.
They reported that the Si-O-Si and Al-O-Al covalent bonds collapsed and the (Si and Al) ions
travel into the liquid phase. Condensation of structure occurred, then, forming a cementitious
According to Alonso and Palomo (2001), as the metakaolin is activated in the media of high
alkalinity in the presence of Ca(OH)2, it will produce sodium aluminosilicate that have
amorphous structure with similar features to geopolymeric gel. The product formed is similar
to the product obtained once metakaolin is activated in the absence of Ca(OH)2 and it was
found that the secondary product which is also known as C-S-H is formed. Subjecting
42
metakaolin to alkali activation is a way of producing cementitious materials with high
strength (Palomo et al., 1990). However, the quantity of additives used must be limited. The
addition of alkali in excess also results in cement paste degradation (Wu et al., 1990).
Wu et al. (1990) studied the activation of ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBS) and
reported that the activation of slag can be done by reaction with high alkalinity solution. This
is because the bonds in the slag network structure are easily broken and enhances the slag
hydration process. When the pH value of the solution reaches 12, the hydration of slag is
most accelerated and the ettringite is formed stably. Sufficient hydroxyl should be provided
in order to create an environment of high alkalinity in order to break the bonds in the glass
Palomo et al. (1999b) concluded that there are two alkali activation models which are based
on the conditions of the starting situation. The first model is the activation of blast furnace
slag (Si + Ca) with a mild alkaline solution and the second model is the activation of
metakaolin (Si + Al) with a medium to high alkaline solutions. The content of reactive silica,
amorphous phase and calcium are some of the most important reactivity parameters
Granizo and Blanco (1997) stated that a solid having an aluminosilicate network structure are
NaOH solution (the concentration ranging from 7 to 12 M) and then cured at temperatures
below 100°C have been suggested by them. Data obtained shows that this solid possesses
interesting mechanical properties. This is due to the network structure formed, where it
consists of a series of SiO4 and AlO4 tetrahedral linked by their corner and sharing all
oxygen ions. The negative charge of the tetra-coordinated aluminium ions is balanced by the
alkali ions from the activating solution present in the structure (Palomo et al., 1999a).
Ma et al. (1995) found that an additional material is required to enhance the hydration
43
process of the lime-fly ash system. They reported that when the lime is mixed together with
fly ash, the mechanical strength obtained at the early age is reduced. The way to activate the
been previously reported that in the presence of Ca(OH)2, the amorphous SiO2 in fly ash
tends to dissociate much more easier (Lokken et al., 1990; Brown, 1986). The bonds are
broken down and dissolution of the three dimensional network structure of the glass
noticeably increases (Fraay et al., 1989; Roy and Silsbee, 1992). Puertas et al. (2000) have
studied the effect of introducing specific amount of NaOH solution into pastes made from a
combination of fly ash and slag. They found that fly ash is partially dissolved and participates
in the reactive process with the most important product which is C-S-H gel containing high
Martinez-Ramirez and Palomo (2001) disclosed the results of Portland cement hydration in
the high alkalinity medium. In their findings, the Portland cement hydration process tends to
be retarded due to the effect of common ion: the increasing of hydroxide ion, OH-
concentration in the system causes the equilibrium to shift towards the left side in the
hydration process of C3S and C2S. This phenomenon impeding the common evolution of the
hydration process:
Therefore, they concluded that as the alkaline concentration of the hydrating solution
increases, this reduces the degree of hydration of anhydrous silicates, for this reason, the
compressive strength also reduced. Martinez-Ramirez and Palomo (2001) investigated the
mechanical properties of pastes using NaOH solution in the hydration process. They
concluded that mechanical strength of the pastes hydrated with NaOH solution drastically
decreases compared to the one that is hydrated with waterglass, Na 2CO3 and deionized water.
Figure 1a) shows the SEM image of C-S-H gel produced when the sample hydrated with
44
deionized water and Figure 1b) shows the formation of the hexagonal-like shape of Ca(OH) 2
Neville (1995) also agreed with that reported by Martinez-Ramirez and Palomo (2001). He
also found that when the hydration of cement is carried out in the media of high alkalinity
and subjected to curing processes of less than 28 days, the strength is affected and he
The principle of sulphate activation also involves the dissolution of the network structure of
the glass (Xu and Sarkar, 1991). This can be monitored by the addition of CaSO4·2H2O into
45
pozzolan materials where the sulphate ions, SO42- react with aluminate which comes from
fly ash. Based on Li et al. (2003) cited by different researchers, previous studies have
measured the mechanism of sulphate activation and can be summarized into the following
points:
i. Introduction of sulphate activators speed up the reduction of Ca(OH)2 in the fly ash-cement
ii. At early ages, the ettringite (AFt) generated in the fly ash-cement system are much more in
the presence of activators and the network structure of the glass is broken down in an alkaline
iii. Pore distribution in fly ash-cement pastes is affected by the presence of sulphate activators
where the pore size becomes smaller and also reduced the porosity (Ma et al., 1995).
iv. The strength of fly ash mortar at an early age is enhanced with the presence of activators
but at later ages the strength is almost similar to that fly ash mortar without activators (Xu
The ettringite formed at the early stage of hydration in fly ash–cement pastes is increased
with the addition of Na2SO4 and K2SO4 since the SO42- ions will react with tri-calcium
aluminate, C3A. At 7 days of hydration, ettringite is mostly formed and is later converted to
46
mono-sulphates, C4AH13 and C2ASH8. This shows that, the production of ettringite is
influenced by the addition of Na2SO4 and K2SO4 which contributes to early strength
development of mortars consisting of fly ash and cement. Lee et al. (2003) used Na 2SO4 and
K2SO4 as activators in the fly ash-cement paste system. According to XRD patterns, it was
found that a small ettringite peak was observed when no activator is added to the fly ash-
cement pastes. For the fly ash-cement pastes with the presence of chemical activators, a peak
was observed at early stage of hydration (up to 7 days) resulting from the formation of
ettringites. These hydration products were created by the reaction between SO 32- ions which
As the time increased, the ettringite is converted to mono-sulphate and other products, but, a
small amount of ettringite still remains at 28 days. On the other hand, the major product
generated from the hydration process is Ca(OH) 2 and its peak shows the highest intensity at 3
days of hydration, but decreases thereafter due to the pozzolanic reaction. These results tally
with the research done by Poon et al., (2001) and Shi (1998). They point out that the
production of ettringite is helpful for early strength development of the fly ash–cement pastes
content. Figure 2 shows the XRD patterns at different ages of hydration for fly ash-cement
pastes.
Figure 3 shows SEM images of C-S-H, Ca(OH)2 and ettringite produced from the pozzolanic
reaction at 3 days of hydration. C–S–H and mono-sulphate products are mainly formed in the
fly ash-cement pastes in the absence of a chemical activator; however, for the fly ash-cement
ettringite was formed. These hydration products were created by the reaction between SO 32-
ions which come from the activators and the aluminates (Lee et al., 2003).
Qian et al. (2001) investigated the mechanism of fly ashes by Na2SO4. Amorphous
47
aluminosilicate is the major component in the fly ash. Ca(OH)2 is hydrolysed first when water
without an activator is mixed with lime-fly ash cement, and the pH value of the solution
In the solution with high alkalinity, various ions that are present in the fly ash are quickly
dissolved into the liquid phase. Examples of the ions are Ca 2+, K+ and Na+. This condition also
causes the silicate or aluminosilicate structure to dissociate and dissolve into the solution. As
the dissolved mono-silicate and aluminate react with Ca2+ ions, the formation of C-S-H and
calcium aluminate hydrate, C4AH13 are promoted. As Na2SO4 is added to the system, there is
a reaction between Na2SO4 and Ca(OH)2 and this can be expressed in the equation:
The pH value of the liquid phase is increased by this reaction hence the resulting fly ash
dissociates and the Ca(OH)2 tends to react much more with the fly ash. Simultaneously, the
SO42- ion concentration increases with the presence of Na2SO4 thus producing additional
ettringite (AFt). For this reason, the structure becomes denser and results in the increase of
The addition of chemical activators in concretes with various natural and artificial pozzolans
has been examined by previous researchers. Many types of activators can be used to
accelerate the reactivity of pozzolan materials. Shi and Day (1993) found that there are
significant effects on the pozzolanic activity over a period of time with the presence of CaCl 2
in the pozzolanic materials. Referring to Shi and Day (2000b) which is from Guo (1986), the
Ca(OH)2 dissociates very slowly. The introduction of CaCl 2 reduced the Ca(OH)2 solubility,
The presence of 4% CaCl2.2H2O caused a decrease in alkalinity of the liquid phase from pH
value of 12.5 to 11.75. However, the detailed mechanism of the hydration process of cement
with the addition of CaCl2 is still unclear. For the lime-pozzolan system with the presence of
When the CaCl2 solution was added into the lime-pozzolan blend, the resulting Ca(OH) 2
dissolves and reduces the solution alkalinity. A reduction of the alkaline environment shows
the negative effect where the pozzolan dissolution process tends to be retarded. The addition
of CaCl2 leads to a greater Ca2+ content but the amount of dissolved mono-silicate and
aluminium species are much less in the activated pastes solution as compared to the control
Through this solid solution formation, the reaction increases the consumption of the dissolved
mono-silicate and aluminate. The product produced is precipitated away from the pozzolan
particles so that a further reaction can take place. The solid volume increased greatly with the
49
formation of C3A·CaCl2·10H2O. The solid volume produced by this product is higher than
those of the C-S-H and C3A·Ca(OH)2·12H2O formation. Therefore, the paste structure
become denser and high in strength compared to the control pastes at certain periods of time.
Strength development of mortars containing various chemical activators has been reviewed
for the evaluation of the pozzolanic activity of each sample studied by previous researchers
Alkali activation is also known as a method that transforms a glassy network of structures
into a very compact well-cemented composite (Palomo et al., 1999b). The addition of
alkaline activators breaking the Si-O and Al-O bonds in the slag glass structure and thus
accelerates the rate of dissolution of Si and Al ions into the liquid phase. Some of the
chemicals that are commonly used by previous researchers for alkaline activation are
Puertas et al. (2000) used NaOH solutions as an activator in the fly ash/slag pastes system.
50
They found that the addition of 10 M NaOH solution into the mixture consisting of 50% fly
ash/ 50% slag and subjected to curing temperatures of 25°C produce a compressive strength
of about 50 MPa at 28 days of hydration. Paya et al. (2000) studied the rice husk ash (RHA)
activation using the NaOH solution and it was noticed that the presence of NaOH caused the
days period, the compressive strength values were lower than those for mortars without this
addition, indicating the negative role of the addition and the non-activation of RHA. This
shows that NaOH did not act as an effective pozzolanic activator for crystallized RHA. The
compressive strength developments for mortars with and without the NaOH additions were
presented in Figure 4.
Ma et al. (1995) noticed that the SiO 2 solubility in the fly ash increased with the presence of
Ca(OH)2. As the Ca(OH)2 activator was added into the fly ash, this resulted in a reaction
between the most part of Ca(OH)2 and the silicate, forming a C-S-H gel and ettringite (Li et
al., 2000). At 7 days of hydration, he found out that a lot of needle-like shaped ettringite were
formed hence improving the properties and mechanical strength of cement at an early age.
Paya et al. (2000) carried out research on the activation of the rice husk ash (RHA)/ cement
strength development of mortars containing RHA with a 15% cement replacement. However,
they found that the compressive strength increased slightly at 1 day and was lower than those
Quicklime (CaO)
Antiohos and Trismas, (2004) studied the activation of fly ash/ cement (FC) systems by
quicklime. Fly ash from class C which consists of high calcium content was used. The fly ash
mortars were used to determine the mechanical strength and any changes in the fly ash during
51
the hydration process was measured. It showed that the compressive strength of mortars
Alkaline-slag cement has been widely used for a long time and possesses significant
properties of high strength. Other behaviours such as porosity, permeability and heat
evolution is markedly low instead of having a high resistance to chemical attack (Wu et al.,
1990). However, alkali such as NaOH is expensive and potentially harmful to the operators
while handling it, therefore, neutral salts such as Na2SO4 and others that provide similar
consequences can be used to substitute the alkali activators since it is less harmful in addition
of less expensive.
The activation of lime-pozzolan cements (LPC) using a chemical activator was reported by
Shi and Day (1993). The addition of 4% Na 2SO4 activator considerably enhanced the strength
of LPC at early age. The LPC is a mixture of 20% hydrated lime and 80% natural pozzolan
and chemical activators added based on the mass of LPC. They also found that the strength of
52
hardened LPC pastes were also enhanced at later age with the Na2SO4 addition, however, the
Lee et al. (2003) investigated the use of Na 2SO4 to accelerate the strength of mortar
containing fly ash at an early age. 40% of the fly ash used in the mortar mix consisted of 1%
Na2SO4 addition based on the weight of the cementations materials. The compressive strength
increased noticeably for mortars containing 1% and more Na2SO4 at 1 day but the strength
was similar to that mortar containing 40% fly ash without the presence of Na2SO4 at 28 days.
Shi and Day (1995) also studied the effect of using Na 2SO4 as an activator on the strength
development using two different kinds of fly ash (low calcium content, LFA and high
calcium content, HFA) on lime/ fly-ash pastes system. The reactivity of ashes was studied
based on the strength development of the mixtures consisting of 80% fly ash and 20%
hydrated lime. The results obtained show that the pozzolanic reactivity of pozzolans for both
forms of ash increased with the addition of Na 2SO4. This was shown by significant
improvement in strength. Na2S04 mainly influences the strength development during early
age of hydration whereas the effect on later ages differed depending on the type of fly ash
An experiment on the strength of lime-fly ash mortars was carried by Qian et al. (2001). They
reported that the lime-ungrounded fly ash mortars without an activator did not show any
strength development (Figure 6). However, the strength of lime-fly ash mortar increased
considerably when the fly ash used was subjected to the grinding process. On the other hand,
they found that grinding is an energy intensive process and requires a complex instrument.
The strength of the lime-fly ash mortars containing Na2SO4 also increased significantly and
was greater than of grinding effect. By comparing the different activation techniques
according to the price for one unit strength, Shi and Day (2001) concluded that the most
53
Gypsum (CaSO4·2H2O)
Xu and Sarkar (1991) mentioned that when an activator such as gypsum is being used, it
produces sulphate ions which are able to react with aluminate causing the dissolution of the
glass structure. The increase of compressive strength for pastes containing fly ash (Class F:
gypsum as compared to pastes without the addition of gypsum that produces a lower
compressive strength.
Poon et al. (2001) investigated the use of an anhydrite to activate the fly ash cement system.
The mortar was subjected to steam curing at a temperature of 65°C for 6 hours before normal
curing at room temperature. He made a comparison between the mixture with the absence of
an activator and the mixtures containing various anhydrite contents. A 10% anhydrite was
found to be the maximum addition for mortars containing fly ash with a replacement of up to
35%.
An evaluation was done between gypsum and anhydrite to compare their roles in activating
the fly ash reactivity. It shows that the compressive strength resulting from the fly ash mortar
with a 35% cement replacement containing 10% anhydrite is greater than 10% gypsum (Poon
54
et al., 2001).
Shi and Day (1993) used various dosages of CaSO 4·0.5H2O as an activator to study its effect
on the development of strength of lime-pozzolan cement (LPC) pastes. They discovered that
the strength was highest with the addition of 6% CaSO 4·0.5H2O. Although at later ages of
hydration, the strength of pastes increased with an addition of 6% CaSO 4·0.5H2O, however,
its effect is lower than those activated pastes with the addition of 4% CaCl2·2H2O.
According to Shi and Day (1995), the addition of other chemicals which do not belong to the
alkali or sulphate group such as CaCl2 has a considerable influence on the strength at an early
age and at the intermediate ages. It was discovered that the strength of pastes containing a 3
Shi and Day (1993) also utilized various dosages of CaCl2.2H2O activator in the LPC system
in order to study its effect on the compressive strength development. An insignificant effect
on the development of compressive strength of LPC pastes containing CaCl 2 was found at 3
days of hydration. At all ages, the strength of the LPC pastes was reduced with the addition
of 1% CaC12.2H2O, however, the strength increased when increasing the amount of dosage
used. The strength was enhanced with the addition of CaCl2.2H2O above 3%. Their results led
them to conclude that the addition of a CaCl2 activator is not effective on the early strength
development; however, the later strength is much more accelerated using this chemical
activator. The pastes containing a 4% CaCl2 activator resulted in a greater strength at later
The effect of using a CaCl2 activator on the strength development of fly ash (low calcium
content) LFA and (high calcium content) HFA pastes (Figure 7) was investigated by Shi and
55
Day (1995). An insignificant effect had been observed with the addition of CaCl2 on 1 day
strength for both types of the pastes and this effect is found to be the same to that strength
resulting from the lime-pozzolan pastes without an activator. However, after 1 day and
thereafter, the improvement on strength of LFA pastes was observed with the addition of
CaCl2 from 1 to 5% dosage. However, the improvement of strength for HFA pastes is only
helpful with the addition of 3 to 5% CaCl 2 dosage. Therefore, they concluded that, CaCl2
activators are much more activate in the LFA pastes than in the HFA pastes.
The strength development of LPC pastes containing certain amounts of NaCl was studied by
Shi and Day (1993). It was found that as NaCl was added into the system, it does not
contribute to the strength development of the pastes with an addition of up to 5 % and at 180
days of hydration.
Shi and Day (1995) also studied the influence of 0 to 5% NaCl addition on the development
of the strength of HFA pastes. They also found that the addition of a NaCl activator had an
insignificant effect on the development of strength of HFA pastes. A similar observation was
obtained when pastes consisting of lime-natural pozzolan blends were tested in 1993. Even
56
though the tests using NaCl as an activator on LFA pastes were not performed, it can be
concluded that the same observation would be obtained since there is a similarity between the
chemical composition of LFA and natural pozzolans which had been tested before.
Ca(OH)2 is not a desirable product in the concrete structure. It is soluble in water, hence,
may be leached out making concrete porous and is harmful for the concrete strength (Shetty,
2008; Yang et al., 2000). The use of pozzolan materials such as fly ash, silica fume and other
pozzolanic materials are the steps to reduce the amount of Ca(OH)2 in order to improve the
The amounts of Ca(OH)2 present in the samples can be determined by thermo gravimetric
analysis, TGA ( Bhatty and Reid, 1985; Vessalas et al., 2009). Degree of reaction of Ca(OH) 2
in lime-pozzolan pastes was studied by Shi and Day (2000a). They found that the remaining
Ca(OH)2 in Na2SO4-activated pastes was less than that of the control pastes. Similar
observations were also made by Lee et al. (2000). Lee et al. (2000) determined the amount of
Ca(OH)2 produced with and without the presence of chemical activators for the fly ash-
cement pastes system (Figure 8). They showed that the amount of Ca(OH) 2 in the cement
paste containing 40% fly ash was nearly 50% less compared to the cement paste without fly
ash. The addition of chemical activators resulted in similar trends to cement pastes containing
40% fly ash. However, it was found that Na2SO4 was the most effective in decreasing the
Antiohos and Trismas (2004) have shown that cement paste without fly ash is constantly
producing Ca(OH)2 throughout the hydration period. On the contrary, the specimens with fly
ash were explained by the simultaneous production and consumption of Ca(OH) 2. However,
small replacement of fly ash by 3% lime accelerated the Ca(OH) 2 depletion from the early
period of hydration. The Ca(OH)2 contents of the high-calcium (class C) fly ash designated as
57
Td with 3 and 6% fly ash replacement by quicklime with hydration age are shown in Fig. 9.
2.7 CONCLUSIONS
work, it can be concluded that for maximum benefits, choosing a suitable activator and the
type of material to be activated is very important. The rate of pozzolanic reaction, mainly the
58
early strength development, together with the pozzolanic reactivity can be improved using
suitable chemical activators instead of using other techniques such as the thermal and
mechanical methods. The reaction of pozzolanic materials with a solution in high alkaline
environments was found to be one of the principal ways in which the pozzolanic materials
can be activated. This involves breaking down the bonds in the network structure of glass and
hence, accelerating the rate of hydration of the pozzolan. However, many aspects should be
considered in selecting proper activators especially those including the financial and practical
59
CHAPTER THREE METHODOLOGY
METHODOLOGY
3.0 PREAMBLE
The aim of this research study is to determine the behaviour of alkaline activated coconut
shell ash as partial replacement of ordinary Portland cement in reinforced concrete slabs.
To achieve this, certain preliminary tests were carried out on the parent materials in the
laboratory. They are the determination of the physical properties of aggregates (coarse, fine)
and cement used, tensile and compressive tests on the hardened concrete after curing,
moment of resistance, workability and setting time test on green concrete. Density and
3.1.1 Cement
Cement is a hydraulic binder and is defined as a finely ground inorganic material which,
when mixed with water, forms a paste which sets and hardens by means of hydration
reactions and processes which, after hardening retains its strength and stability even under
60
water. The cement used was Ordinary Portland cement (Lafarge Elephant Portland Cement
32.5R). This cement satisfies international standards on cement (BS 12 Portland Cement).
This ensures that the cement passes the test (soundness) for which its properties being
determined.
The fine aggregate used in this research study was River sand obtained from Ogun River bed
located at Ibafo town in Ogun state. The sand particles were confirmed free from clay, loam,
dirt and organic impurities of any form. The particles passed through BS sieve No 4 (aperture
2.36mm) but retained on sieve No 220 (aperture 0.06mm) ensuring that the dust particles
The coarse aggregate used in this research study were crushed granite of igneous origin. They
come in different sizes but the recommended size is 12.5mm to 19mm. It helps to improve
the strength of the concrete. The granites were sieved off dust particles and dirt to ensure it is
The water used was from the University of Lagos concrete laboratory. Being the same source
of water that have been used severally to produce concrete cubes specimens over the years, it
has been proven to be suitable for concrete production as the 28th day strength of cubes
produced using this water fall within the acceptable range of not less than 90% of a
comparable cube obtained from distilled water. Care was taken during collection of water
from this source to avoid the introduction of external impurities by using clean containers or
bowls (or buckets) every time the water is collected from the source.
61
3.1.5 Coconut Shell Ash
Coconut shell sourced from Badagry town in Badagry local council was burnt in open air for
5hours and allowed to cool. The resulting material was ground to very fine particles in a
milling machine, and then sieved through 75µm sieve to obtain CSA needed for this project.
The Sodium Hydroxide gotten is in flakes and was sourced from Ojota, Lagos. Sodium
Hydroxide, commonly known as caustic soda, lye, or sodium hydrate, is a caustic compound
which attacks organic matter. (Caustic soda is sodium hydroxide, caustic potash is potassium
hydroxide and silver nitrate is lunar caustic.) It is hygroscopic and readily absorbs water from
A well-known member of this series is sodium metasilicate, Na 2SiO3. Also known as water
glass or liquid glass, these materials are available in aqueous solution and in solid form. The
pure compositions are colourless or white, but commercial samples are often greenish or blue
owing to the presence of iron-containing impurities. The sodium silicate gotten was in liquid
The solution of sodium hydroxide and sodium silicate are used as alkaline solutions in the
present study. Commercial sodium hydroxide in pellets form and sodium silicate solution are
used.
In this work, concrete is activated with different concentration of alkaline solution and their
physical and mechanical properties are tested and observed. The molecular weight of sodium
sodium hydroxide flakes are weighed and dissolved in distilled water to form 1 litre solution.
62
Volumetric flask of 1 litre capacity is taken, sodium hydroxide flakes are then added solely to
As there are no code provisions for the mix design of geo-polymer concrete, the density of
geo-polymer concrete is assumed as 2400Kg/m3. The alkaline solution to the binder ratio is
kept at 0.4. The ratio of sodium hydroxide to sodium silicate is kept as 2.5. The convention
method used in making of normal concrete is adopted to prepare geo-polymer concrete. Prof.
Davidovits (Geopolymer Institute, France) has recommended that the sodium silicate solution
and the sodium hydroxide solution be mixed a day prior to preparing the geo-polymer
concrete.
Mixing of concrete was carried out in the concrete workshop. Mixing of concrete was done with
the use of concrete mixer. All the materials were weighted accurately before mixing. The
machine mixer was turned on and the materials poured into the tilting drum in the order of,
granite, sharp sand, coconut shell ash, cement, water and alkaline activator. The mixture was
thoroughly mixed for about a minute and poured on to a flat metal container where the mixing is
completed via hand mixing with the aid of shovel. The surface of the flat metal container was
wetted before putting the materials to reduce the water loss. The alkaline activator was added into
the water before poured into the dry mixture. Then the mixture of water alkaline activator was
added slowly to the dry mixture and mixed consistently to form fresh concrete. After the fresh
concrete was formed, slump and compaction factor tests were performed to check its workability.
The fresh concrete was then poured into the steel cylindrical moulds and cube moulds. The inner
surface of the steel mould was lubricated with oil for the ease of demoulding/striking. The
concrete was demoulded after 24 hours, cured in a tank of fresh water or lagoon water (different
media). The concrete samples were tested at the concrete age of 7, 14 and 28 days after curing.
63
3.4 CURING OF CONCRETE
A total of fifty four concrete cubes, thirty six concrete cylinders were cured (for 7, 14 and 28
days) in the laboratory with normal water, while another fifty four concrete cubes were cured
The apparatus, tools and equipment used for the tests and observations in the laboratory are
This is comprised of a metal platform where the material to be measured is placed, a standing
rod that holds the reading meter and a reading meter on which the value of the mass
measured is displayed. The capacity of this weighing machine is 150kg. The Avery weighing
machine was used to measure the mass of concrete materials such as water, cement, CSA,
These were made of cast iron with inner dimensions of 150x150x150mm.They have a sheet
metal base and they were well tightened and greased to prevent excessive slurry escape and
The slump mould is a metal hollow frustum of a cone having the following dimensions;
64
It is used to determine the workability of a mix by measuring the slump height. It also
comprises of a tamping rod and a base plate to facilitate compaction and prevent moisture
escape respectively.
This is a diesel engine powered tilting drum mixer. It has a single cylinder engine as well as a
mobile rotating drum which rotates in order to ensure proper mixing of constituent materials
This is used to determine initial and final setting times of the Lafarge cement used for this
work. It is comprised of a circular metal base, a stem that holds the base and the measuring
65
3.5.6 Avery Dennison Compression Testing Machine (Capacity: 1500kN)
indicators or pointers (black and red). The indicators must be set to zero marks before testing.
The load is applied to a test specimen through two steel loading platforms; a fixed upper
platform and an up warding moving the lower platform. The lower platform has markings
which help in centralizing a test specimen to receive the concentric load. At failure, the black
pointer drops back while the red pointer stays fixed at the failure value.
This was used to transfer large masses of aggregates and tested specimens
The tamping rod is a straight steel bar or circular cross-section of 16mm diameter and
600mm long. It was used to compact the concrete in the cube moulds.
These are of different aperture sizes used to obtain the grain size classification of aggregates.
The other equipment used in this project includes trowel, shovel, head pan, greasing oil and
curing tanks.
The experimental procedure began with the preliminary investigation on the CSA, granite,
sand and cement and ended with the compressive strength determination of 180N0s of
150mm x 150mm x 150mm concrete cubes. A prescribed mix ratio of 1:2:4 by weight of
cement, sand and granite was used throughout for all batches of concrete mixes with constant
water/cement ratio of 0.55. The ratio of CSA to OPC was kept constant at the optimum value
66
of 10%, while the molality of alkaline activator (NaoH+Na 3SiO2 ) was varied in step of 5 (i.e
The preliminary investigation carried out is to determine the properties of each material. The
tests include:
Sieve analysis
Specific gravity
Bulk density
Dry density
Moisture content
Sieve analysis is the name given to the simple operation of dividing a sample of aggregates
into the fraction, each consisting of particles of approximately the size. Before this
experiment, the aggregates (sand, granite, polyvinyl waste and steel slag) were dried
sufficiently to avoid lumps of fine particles being classified as the large particle (in the case
Apparatus:
2. Sieve brush
3. Weighing Balance
5. Drying oven
6. Evaporating pans.
Procedure:
67
Fine Aggregate (Sand)
• A set of sieves with aperture sizes ranging from 10mm to 75µm was arranged in order
• A clean measuring tray was placed under the 10mm sieve and the measured sand poured
into the sieve, and shaken over the tray and jarred until not more than a trace passes for a
• The sand retained on this sieve was poured into a separate clean tray and weighed.
• The sand passing the sieve in the first clean tray is then poured into the next sieve size and
• This continued until after the least sieve size of 75microns for which the remaining particles
• A set of sieves with aperture sizes ranging from 25mm to 2.36µm was arranged in order
• A clean measuring tray was placed under the 25mm sieve and the measured granite poured
into the sieve, and shaken over the tray and jarred until not more than a trace passes for a
• The granite retained on this sieve was poured into a separate clean tray and weighed.
• The granite passing the sieve in the first clean tray is then poured into the next sieve size
68
3.6.1.2 Specific Gravity
Specific gravity is the ratio of the density of a substance to the density (mass of the same unit
volume) of a reference substance. Apparent specific gravity is the ratio of the weight of a
volume of the substance to the weight of an equal volume of the reference substance.
The specific gravity of a soil is often used to describe the relationship between the weight of
soil and its volume. As soil contains different particles with different specific gravities; the
Apparatus
1. Density bottle
2. Glass rod
4. Drying Oven
Procedure
• About 25.0g of the oven dried material was measured and transferred into a density
bottle. The stopper is replaced and the bottle and contents weighed, (W2).
• Tap water from the concrete laboratory was added so that the soil in the bottle is just
covered. The mixture was then stirred thoroughly with a glass rod and shaken to remove air
• The bottle is filled with tap water and the stopper replaced. The density bottle and its
contents were shaken carefully to remove any remaining air and weighed, (W3)
• The content of the bottle was emptied, washed and the bottle filled with distilled
W 2 −W 1
Gs=
( W 4−W 1 )−( W 3−W 2 )
69
Where;
W1 = Weight of bottle
The specific gravity is used in the laboratory to help with the calculation of the void ratios of
soil specimens, in the determination of the moisture content of a soil, and in the particle-size
The volume of the metal container is first obtained by determining the weight of water
required to fill it. The container is then filled to overflowing with aggregate being discharged
from a height of not more than 50mm above the top of the container. The aggregate in the
container is then weighed and divided by the volume of the container to give the bulk density
in kg/m3.
Apparatus:
1. A 6” (150mm) diameter open-ended steel cylinder with plunger and base plate.
3. Weigh balance
Water content or moisture content is the quantity of water contained in a material. It is the
ratio of water present in the soil mass to the weight of the soil solids. . The moisture content
70
of the sand and granite used for this work was determined by the oven-drying method.
The aggregate specimen of sand was weighed and placed in the oven for 24 hours, then
weighed when removed from the oven. The decrease in weight of the specimen shows the
Apparatus:
Spatula
Procedure
3 empty cylindrical cans were cleaned, dried, labelled (A,B,C) and weighed to get
Each can and its content was weighed to get M2A, M2B, M2C
The cans and contents were then placed in the oven and turned on, with the heating
After 24hours, the cans and their content were removed from the oven and allowed to
cool; the cans and their content were weighed to obtain M3A, M3B, M3C
M 2 −M 3
w= ❑ M 2−M
The water content is obtained using the relation M 3 −M 1 w=
M 3−M
3
71
3.6.1.5 Dry Density Test
The moisture content of the sample was first determined. Then, the sample was placed in a
mould and weighed. The volume and weight of the mould were also determined. The bulk
density (ᵞ) was calculated by dividing the mass of sample by the volume of the mould.
The material for this test consists of aggregate passing the 14mm B.S. test sieve and retained
on the 10mm B.S. test sieve and tested in a surface-dry condition. The apparatus required for
this test consists of an open-ended steel cylinder of normal size 150 mm internal diameters
with plunger and base plate. The approximate quantity may be found conveniently by filling
the cylindrical measure in three layers, each layer being tamped 25 times from a height of
about 50mm above the surface of the aggregate with the rounded end of the rod and finally
levelled off. Record the mass (weight) of the sample (W1). Insert the plunger so that it rests
Place the apparatus between the platens of the testing machine and applied a load of
399.5KN. (40ton) Release the load and remove the crushed material into a clean tray. Sieve
the whole of the sample on the No. 7 (2.36mm) B.S. test sieve. Weigh the fraction passing the
sieve (W2). The ratio of the mass of fines formed to the total mass of the sample expressed as
The aggregate impact value gives a relative measure of the resistance of an aggregate to
sudden shock or impact, which usually differs from its resistance to a slowly applied
72
compressive load. The aggregate impact value is usually not more than 30.
The standard aggregate impact test is made on aggregate passing a 14mm B.S. sieve and
retained on a 10mm sieve. The impact test machine is a circular metal base weighing between
22kg and 30kg with a plane lower surface of not less than 300mm diameter. A cylindrical
steel cup having an internal diameter of 102mm and an internal depth of 50mm. A metal
hammer weighing 13.5kg to14kg and 100mm diameter with 50mm long. Means for raising
the hammer and allowing it to fall freely between the vertical guides from a height of 380mm
on to the test sample in the cup. Also, means for automatically recording the number of blows
is desirable.
The aggregate in a surface dry condition is filled into the cup of the machine and tamped
evenly with 25 blows of the tamping rod. The net mass of aggregate are measured and
recorded (W1). Fix the cup firmly in position on the base of the machine. Subject the test
Then remove the crushed aggregate and sieve the whole of the sample in the tray on the
2.36mm sieve. Weigh the fractions passing the 2.36mm sieve (W2). The ratio of the mass of
W1/W2 ×100
Where
W1 is the mass of fraction passing the sieve for separating the fine (g).
The secondary investigations carried out in the course of this research study are:
The aim is to get the consistence of standard cement paste and to determine the initial and
final setting time of fresh Lafarge cement paste of standard consistence; to determine as well
the setting times of alkaline activated coconut shell ash partially replacing ordinary Portland
cement.
Initial setting time is the time from mixing dry cement with water till the beginning of
interlocking of the gel. Final setting time is the time from mixing dry cement with water till
It is very important to know the setting times. Knowing the initial setting time is important in
estimating free time for transporting, placing, compaction and shaping of cement paste.
Apparatus:
1. VICAT Apparatus.
4. Trowel.
5. Mixing bowl.
6. Stop-watch.
8. Water.
Procedure:
•Once we determine the normal consistency, we can use the taken specification of that paste
to measure the initial and final setting times. So we make a fresh cement paste using the
amount of water and cement to the standard consistency. The stop-watch shall start at this
step.
•We use the 1 mm diameter needle, and penetrate the sample with this needle by leaving it to
free fall, and then we read the VICAT ruler scale. We do a trial each 15 minutes until the
depth of penetration is 5 mm. The elapsed time from mixing the water with dry cement till
74
•We replace the needle with another angular one (Final setting needle), and penetrate the
sample by it every 15 minutes till only the needle makes an impression on the paste surface
3.6.2.2 Workability
Slump Test
The concrete slump test is an empirical test that measures the workability of fresh concrete. It
Apparatus
1. Mould : (in form of the frustum of a cone) the mould is provided with suitable foot pieces
as well as handles to facilitate placing the concrete and lifting the moulded concrete test
2. Tamping rod: (16mm diameter, 600mm long and rounded at one end)
3. Steel rule
4. Stopwatch
5. Hand trowel.
6. Head pan
Procedure:
• The surface of the mould was first cleaned and the mould placed on a smooth,
• Some quantity of freshly mixed concrete from each batch mix was collected and placed
in the slump mould in four layers, each approximately ¼ of the height of the mould;
• The strokes were distributed evenly over the entire cross-section of the mould; the
concrete was then struck off level after the top layer is rammed.
• The mould was removed immediately by raising it slowly and carefully in a vertical
75
• The difference in level between the height of the mould and that of the highest point of
• This procedure was repeated for the concrete mix of all four batches
The split cylinder test is to determine the split tensile strength of concrete.
Apparatus
Procedure
3. Draw diametrical lines on the two ends of the specimen to ensure that they are on the same
axial place.
6. Keep the plywood strip on the lower plate and place the specimen.
7. Align the specimen so that the lines marked on the ends are vertical and centred over the
bottom plate.
14850kg/minute)
76
3.6.2.4 Compressive Strength Test
Apparatus
Vibrator
77
Procedure
1. A set of 3No.s concrete cubes from each of the batches were removed from the curing
tanks (plastic drums) at the maturity age of 7, 14, 28, 90, and 120days.
2. The water on each cube was allowed to drain off for just about 2minutes, immediately
3. Each concrete cube was then placed and set properly in the Avery Dennison machine
4. The machine is turned on operated to apply load on the cube until the cube fails
5. The value of load at failure is recorded from the meter reading of the machine
6. The recorded failure load is divided by the area of a face of the cube to obtain the
A total of 180 cubes (90cubes to be cured in normal water and another 90 cubes to be cured
in lagoon water) were cast with 3 cubes for each sample category (Table 3.2).
93
Since the binder (cement) is to be partially replaced with coconut shell ash; a sample
calculation of the partial replacement weights of wastes materials and cement is shown
below;
No of cubes required for 10% replacement = 150 cubes (refer to table 3.1)
Total weight of binder (cement) reqd. for 0% replacement (30 cubes) = (208.29/180) x 30 =
34.715kg.
Total weight of coarse aggregate reqd for X% replacement = X x total wt. of binder reqd for X %
replacement 100
The weight of Coconut shell ash required for 10% replacement = (10/100) x 34.715 = 3.4715kg.
Normal 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 30
Normal + 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 30
10%CSA
Normal +
10%CSA+ 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 30
4moldm-3
Normal +
10%CSA+ 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 30
8moldm-3
Normal +
10%CSA+ 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 30
12moldm-3
Normal +
10%CSA+ 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 30
16moldm-3
94
SUMMATION 180
*NW---- Normal water for curing, *LW----Lagoon Water for curing
Table 3.1: Showing Numbers of concrete cubes cast, age and method of curing in their respective
categories
Concrete Cubes
WT. OF
TOTAL WT. WT OF FINE
W/C CSA CSA WT. CEMENT COARSE
OF AGGREGATE
SAMPLES RATIO % (Kg) WT. (Kg) AGGREGATE
BINDER(Kg) WASTE (Kg)
REQD. (Kg)
Normal+
10%CSA+ 10 3.4715 31.2435 34.715 13.886 27.77
4moldm-3
Normal +
10%CSA+ 10 3.4715 31.2435 34.715 13.886 27.77
8moldm-3
Normal +
10%CSA+ 10 3.4715 31.2435 34.715 13.886 27.77
12moldm-3
Normal +
10%CSA+ 10 3.4715 31.2435 34.715 13.886 27.77
16moldm-3
A total of 60 cylinders were cast with 2 cylinders for each sample category (Table 3.4).
2. Volume of single cylinder (concrete) 150mm (dia) and 300mm (height) = 3.142 x 1502 x
0.25 x 300 = 0.0053m3.
3. No of cylinders required= 60
95
Total volume required for 60 cylinders = 60 x 0.0053= 0.318m3.
Since the binder (cement) used is to be partially or totally replaced with coconut shell ash a
sample calculation of the partial replacement weights of wastes materials and cement is
shown below;
Total wt. of cement reqd. for 0 %replacement (10 cylinders) = (109.03/60) x 10 = 18.172kg.
Total weight of coarse aggregate reqd for X% replacement = X x total wt. of binder reqd for X %
replacement 100
The weight of CSA required for 10% replacement= (10/100) x 18.172kg = 1.8172kg.
Concrete Cylinders
Normal+
10%CSA+ 10 1.8172 16.3548 18.172 36.343 72.687
4moldm-3
Normal +
10%CSA+ 10 1.8172 16.3548 18.172 36.343 72.687
8moldm-3
Normal + 10 16.3548 18.172 36.343 72.687
10%CSA+ 1.8172
12moldm-3
96
Normal +
10%CSA+ 10 1.8172 16.3548 18.172 36.343 72.687
16moldm-3
Normal 2 2 2 2 2 10
10
Normal +
2 2 2 2 2
10%CSA
Normal +
10%CSA+ 10
4moldm-3 2 2 2 2 2
Normal +
10%CSA+ 10
2 2 2 2 2
8moldm-3
Normal +
10%CSA+ 10
2 2 2 2 2
12moldm-3
Normal + 10
10%CSA+
2 2 2 2 2
16moldm-3
SUM 10 10 10 10 10 60
Table 3.4: Showing Numbers of concrete cylinders cast, and age in their respective categories all
cured in normal water
97
MATERIAL ESTIMATIONS AND COSTING
Unit Quantity
Items 10% Total Cost (Naira)
(Kg) Purchased. (Kg)
Sharp
1169.492 kg 116.9492 kg 1286.4412 1.5 tons 15000
Sand
Granite 2338.983 kg 233.8983 kg 2572.8813 3 tons 25000
Workmanship 30000
Marine
boards and 40000
labour cost
TOTAL 242900
Table 3.7: Total material quantification and total costing of project
98
REFERENCES
[1]
Eglinton, M., 2006. Resistance of concrete to destructive agencies, in “Lea's Chemistry of Cement and
Concrete”. 4th ed., Peter C. Hewlet, Ed., Elsevier, pp. 843-863.
[2]
Pierre-Claude Aitcin, 2008. Binders for durabale and sustainable concrete, Modern Concrete
Technology 16. Taylor & Francis, p.500.
[3]
Z. AhmadPrinciples of corrosion engineering and corrosion control609-616Elsevier Ltd (2006)
[4]
P.K. MehtaSulfate attack on concrete: separating myth from realityConcrete Intern, 22 (8) (2000),
pp. 57-61
[5]
B.A. Clark, P.W. BrownFormation of ettringite from monosubstituted calcium sulfoaluminate
hydrate and gypsumJ. Amer. Ceram. Soc., 82 (10) (1999), pp. 2900-2905
[6]
ACI E4, Chemical Admixtures for Concrete, 2003. ACI Education Bulletin E4-03, American Concrete
Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan, p. 12.
[7]
H. Donza, O. Cabrera, E.F. IssararHigh-strength concrete with different fine aggregateCem. Concr.
Res., 32p (2002), pp. p.1755-p.1761
[8]
Edmeades, R.M., Hewlett, P.C., 2006. Cement admixtures. Lea's Chemistry of Cement and Concrete.
4th ed., Peter CHewlett edt., Elsevier, 2006, pp. 843-863.
[9]
N. JainEffect of nonpozzolanic and pozzolanic mineral admixtures on the hydration behavior of
ordinary Portland. CementConctr. Build. Mater., 27 (2012), pp. 39-44
ArticlePDF (1MB)
[10]
E. Serafimova, M. Mladenov, I. Mihailova, Y. PelovskiStudy on the characteristics of waste wood
ashJournal of the University of Chemical Technology and Metallurgy, 46 (1) (2011), pp. 31-34
[11]
G. Itskos, S. Itskos, N. KoukouzasSize fraction characterization of highly-calcareous fly ashFuel
Processing Technology, 91 (2010), pp. 1558-1563
ArticlePDF (475KB)
[12]
A. Korpa, T. Kowald, R. TrettinHydration behaviour, structure and morphology of hydration
phases in advanced cement-based systems containing micro and nanoscaleCem. and Concr. Res.,
38 (2008), pp. 955-962
ArticlePDF (936KB)
[13]
99
O. Zeng, K. Li, T. Fen-Chong, P. DanglaDetermination of cement hydration and pozzolanic
reaction extents for fly-ash cement pastesConctr. Build. Mater, 2 (2012), pp. 560-569
[14]
P.K. Mehta, P.J.M. MonteiroConcrete: Microstructure, Properties and Materials(3rd Edition),
McGraw-Hill (2006)p.387
[15]
Nair, D.G., Fraaij, A., Klaassen, A.A. K., Kentgens, A.P. M., 2008. A structural investigation relating
to the pozzolanic activity of rice husk ashes, Cem. and Concr. Res. 38, pp. 861-869.
[16]
Costa, U., Massazza, F., 1981. “Natural pozzolanas and fly ashes: analogies and differences”, Materials
Research Society, Proceedings of Symposium N Annual Meeting. Diamond, S., Ed., 16-18. November,
1981, Boston, USA, pp. 134-144.
[17]
Setina, J., Krage, L., Juhnevica I., Shakhemko, G., 2012. “The ifluence of different pozzolanic
admixtures on structure and properties of concrete”, Proc. of the 18th International Baustofftagung
ibausil’2012, 12-15. September, 2012, Weimar, Germany, pp. 2-0154-2-0161.
[18]
Taylor, H .F. W., 1997. Cement Chemistry (2nd ed.), Thomas Telford Publishing, London.
[19]
Rougeau, P., Borys, B., 2004. “Ultra High Performance Concrete with ultrafine particles other than
silica fume”, Int. Symp. on UHPC; 13-15. September, 2004, Kassel, Germany, p. 214.
[20]
L VS EN 196-2:2005. Methods of testing cement - Part 2. Chemical analysis of cement. Standard
Latvian, 2005.(in Latvian).
100