GRADING ON: musicality, technique, quality of sound
School: Christa Mcauliffe
Song #1
The group could use more musicality and technique. For starters, a lot of the members
stood with their hands in front of themselves while performing. The group has about 12
members. The majority are girls however, they are very strong. I would say the altos are
the most musical. They had two male members who I could not hear the entire time until
to the end. Despite this, they were knowledgeable on their part and did not lack any
quality of sound. Another thing I noticed about this piece was a need for more
technique. They could use more dynamics and attention to directer. I liked how you
could really feel the energy on the songs.
Song #2
For their second piece, I liked how tall their vowels were. They’re very open and
expressive. On the phrase, “Come again tomorrow night”, I’d like to hear more of a
hairpin crescendo into a decrescendo. Furthermore, I’d like a bit crisper diction. On
some soprano parts, there was a bit of sliding to and from notes. Adding onto this, some
members need to try getting “on top” of the note.
Song #3
For this piece, I’d like clearer diction. I couldn’t really understand all the words they had
been saying. I liked how they used themselves as instruments in addition to the snare
drum. I like the different harmonies and how clear and concise they were. I couldn’t
make out where the tenors were in the song. I don’t know if they were just quiet or
singing the same part as the sopranos and altos.