Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
11th Judicial Region
JUSTICE ON WHEELS
Malungon, Sarangani Province
o00o
THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, CRIM. CASE NO. 3870-11
Plaintiff,
- versus - - for -
SATURNINO R. CAGALFIN, JR., DIRECT BRIBERY
Accused.
X ---------------------------------X
COMMENT
ACCUSED, through counsel and unto this Honorable Court,
most respectfully submits his comment/objection to the exhibits
offered in evidence by the prosecution, to wit;
Exhibit “A” - Joint Affidavit of Apprehension executed
And series by PO1 Morales and PO1 Panayaman
Comment/Objection – Only PO1 Panayaman was presented; the
Testimony of PO1 Morales was stipulated;
Admitted that he was arrested but no
marked money was recovered from the
accused.
Exhibit “B” - Affidavit of PI Alex Joe Orcajada
And series
Comment/Objection – Hearsay, not identified in open court;
Exhibit “C” - Join Affidavit of PO1 Jamero and PO1
And series Bishmael
Comment/Objection – Inadmissible for being hearsay; not
Affirmed in open court
Exhibit “D” - Request for Ultra Violet Examination
Comment/Objection – Inadmissible being hearsay; not identified
And affirmed in open court;
Page-1
Cont/formal offer/cagalfin…………..page-2
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exhibit “E” - Physical Examination Report PI-1426-2007
And series
Comment/Objection – Hearsay; not identified in open Court;
WHEREFORE, it is most respectfully prayed that the evidences
and exhibits submitted by the prosecution subject of the
comment/objection by the accused be denied admission for the
purpose it was offered.
Other relief just and equitable are likewise prayed for.
Alabel, Sarangani Province, 02 July 2014.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED:
PUBLIC ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
Department of Justice
Sarangani District Office
Alabel, Sarangani Province
BY:
SALVADOR G.TALAMAYAN
District Public Attorney
Roll N0. 43509
MCLE-IV N0. 0010737 - 21 Dec 12
Copy Furnished: PPO
As regards to Casicas, as stipulated;
Exhibit “D” - Death certificate of Elvie D. Rosal
And series
Comment/Objection – Admitted as stipulated
Exhibit “E” - Marriage Contract
And series
Comment/Objection – Admit as stipulated.
Page-1
Cont/comment/rosal………Page-2
Exhibit “F” - Pictures
Comment/Objection – Not duly authenticated
Exhibit “G” - Affidavit of Concordio Daño
And series
Comment/Objection – Not affirmed in open Court; hearsay
Exhibit “H” - Knife
Comment/Objection – Not identified in open Court; hearsay
WHEREFORE, it is most respectfully prayed that the evidences
and exhibits submitted by the prosecution subject of the
comment/objection by the accused be denied admission for the
purpose it was offered.
Alabel, Sarangani Province. 23 April 2013.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED:
PUBLIC ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
Department of Justice
Sarangani District Office
Alabel, Sarangani Province
BY:
SALVADOR G.TALAMAYAN
District Public Attorney
MCLE-IV N0. 0010737 - 21 Dec 12
Roll N0. 43509
Copy Furnished: PPO
Exhibit “D” - Affidavit of Leopoldo V. Custo
Comment/Objection – In consistent with the testimony in open court; the
affidavit was based on assumption and conjecture;
Exhibit “F” Death Certificate of Danilo B. Mina;
sub-markings
Comment/Objection – Admitted as stipulated;
Exhibit “G” - Admitted a stipulated;
WHEREFORE, it is most respectfully prayed that the evidences and
exhibits submitted by the prosecution subject of the comment/objection by the
accused be denied admission for the purpose it was offered.
Alabel, Sarangani Province. 21 May 2010.
PUBLIC ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
Department of Justice
Sarangani District Office
Alabel, Sarangani Province
Page-1
Cont/offer/buayaban--------------Page-2
BY:
SALVADOR G.TALAMAYAN
District Public Attorney
NOTICE
The Clerk of Court
Justice on Wheels
Glan, Sarangani Province
Greetings!
Please submit the foregoing comment on the formal offer of exhibits
immediately upon receipt hereof for the kind consideration and evaluation of the
Honorable Court.
SALVADOR G.TALAMAYAN
Copy furnished: Office of the Provincial Prosecutor
