3D C-Arm Demo Comparison
Comparison Criteria GE Healthcare
OEC 3D
Overall Preference of end users:
Surgeon, Radiologist, Technologist #1
Pricing (pre-negotiation) $367,200
Trade in value of 9900 $30,000
Cost after trade in $337,200
Warranty
12 months
Applications
4 days - 8 hours = 32 hours
System Specification
Type
CMOS flat panel detector
Field of View
31 cm x 31 cm
Power Output
15kW power
Lasers
2 Green laser aimers - sagittal and coronal
Connectivity with 7D Yes - immedately sends scan once obtained
Technologist Features
Contolled by 4 different ways; Workstation, OEC Touch, OEC Touch Tableside
or RUI
Movement controlled by
Motorized movements
Position Tools
Integrated stereo vision depth camera to allow for more precise
positioning
3 set position recall and last position recall
Positioning
Step by step intutive guidance with one less step
3D Set up
Foot print was smaller, easier to maneuver
Technologist Ergonomics
3D Imaging
200 degree isocentric sweep
Orbital movement
up to 512
Projections for 3D reconstruction
19 cm x 19 cm x 19 cm
3D volume size
512 x 512 x 512
3D volume resolution
3 minutes prescan reconstruction
Prescan time
30 Seconds
Acquisition time
Stimultaneous display of 3 projections (coronal, sagittal,
3D viewing transversal)
Yes - more effective reduction
Metal artifact reduction
mparison
Siemens
Cios Spine
#2
$438,214
$37,250
$400,964
12 months
3 days - 8 hours = 24 hours
CMOS flat panel detector
30 cm x 30 cm
25kW / 12 Kw 1
2 Green laser aimers - sagittal and coronal
Yes - additional step to send scan
2 ways; Workstation and Tech monitor
Motorized movements, except in and out movement
None
2 set position recall
Step by step guidance
Larger foot print, heavier movements
190 degrees isocentric sweep
up to 400
16 cm x 16 cm x 16 cm
512 x 512 x 512
3 minutes prescan reconstruction
30 Seconds
Simultaneous display of 3 projections (transversal, coronal and sagittal)
Yes