Clean Energy Mini-Grid ESMP Template
Clean Energy Mini-Grid ESMP Template
Notes:
This Environmental and Social Management Plan (ESMP) template has been created for the purpose
of facilitating the assessment of environmental and social impact factors and the development of
adequate mitigation strategies for prospective mini-grid project developers and operators. The
approval of ESMPs by the applicable regulatory authorities are increasingly becoming a prerequisite
to proceed with the construction of mini-grid projects. This template, thus, is intended to facilitate part
of the project development work.
It is worth noting that the scope of environmental and social mitigation strategies that national
environmental agencies will demand from prospective project proponents are directly dependent on
the regulatory, geographic and demographic context where the future project is to be implemented.
Maximum and minimum threshold limits of, for instance, pollution levels, are not homogeneous
across countries and thus each Proponent must be familiar with the regulatory context where the
project is to be implemented. Nevertheless, clean energy mini-grids per se, regardless of where they
are located, imply a similar set of environmental and social risks, thus enabling the development of
this standardized ESMP template.
Instructions:
This template provides guidance for the preparation and implementation of Environmental and Social
Mitigation Plans. The prospective Project proponent is expected to become familiar with the national
regulatory framework and integrate those parameters of relevance to the template.
To adjust the Template to a specific context, the following is to be considered:
For each missing field, kindly fill in the blank space according to the associated instruction (as
specified in brackets). In some cases, this implies the name of an institution; in others, it implies the
maximum/minimum permitted thresholds as per national regulations.
Kindly attach all relevant environmental legislation under the section Reference
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 3
CONTENTS
LIST OF TABLES
Table 3. Minimum Environmental and Social Parameters (indicators) for Clean Mini-Grid Projects...........19
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 4
ACRONYMS
AC Alternating current
CdTe Cadmium Telluride
dB Decibels
DC Direct current
E&S Environmental and Social
EIA Environmental Impact Assessment
ESMP Environmental Social Management Plan
Ft. feet
GHG Greenhouse gas
kW Kilowatt
IEC International Electrotechnical Comission
m3 Cubic meter
NiCd Nickel-Cadmium
NiMH Nickel-Metal Hydride
NO2 Nitrogen dioxide
PAP Project Affected Person
PPE Personal Protective Equipment
ppm Parts per Million
PV Photovoltaic
RAC Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Equipment
SO2 Sulphur dioxide
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 5
DEFINITIONS
Environmental and additionally to Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) above, shall mean
Social Impact a decision-making process of identifying and evaluating the socio-cultural
Assessment (ESIA) impacts of a proposed project.
Environmental and shall mean a comprehensive document that directs effective and responsible
Social Management implementation and management of environmental and social impacts
Plan (ESMP) mitigation and enhancement measures during the construction, operation
and closure phases of a proposed project.
Power Generation shall mean the guaranteed active power that a generation plant can supply to
Capacity a load or network at any point in time under the given environmental
constraints (temperature, humidity, etc.) for at least one hour under the
assumption that the plant is well maintained and fully functional.
Project shall mean the Mini-Grid to be developed by the Proponent requiring the
ESMP Certificate.
Project Affected shall mean any person affected by the project activities directly and/or
Person (PAP) indirectly in the area of influence.
Clean Energy Mini- shall mean any electricity supply system with its own power generation
Grid capacity from any of the following: solar photovoltaic, wind, hydro,
biomass or geothermal energy together with any combination of battery
storage and diesel generation of up to 1MW in total, and low voltage and/or
medium voltage distribution system including electricity meters, supplying
electricity to more than one customer and which can operate in isolation
from or be connected to the network of a distribution company. In the
context of this ESMP Template, the focus are solar hybrid mini-grids, given
the predominance of this technology in SSA.
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 6
tariffs is to imply direct improvements on the community’s productivity, life comfort, health,
education and possibilities to thrive.
The key power generation components of clean energy mini-grids are solar PV modules organized in
arrays, battery banks (generally relying on lead-acid or lithium-ion batteries) and power electronic
components such as inverters, charge controllers and combiner boxes. Often diesel or petrol generators
are installed to complement the renewable energy components, given the fluctuating nature of
renewable resources such as solar and wind energy as well as overall loads. Battery banks and
inverters, combiner boxes and fuel gensets are located inside a power house. Transformers, low
voltage distribution cables, poles and energy meters compose the power distribution network of a
Mini-Grid Project. The higher the renewable energy fraction of a Mini-Grid, the lower its
environmental impact in terms of air and acoustic pollution during the operational phase; nevertheless,
particular attention ought to be placed on the correct disposal of large battery banks after the Project’s
operational phase comes to an end.
Thus, key environmental impacts to be considered during the ESMP process of a clean energy mini-
grid and their corresponding risk assessment are:
Acoustic & air pollution from operating Excavation works for power house foundation
machinery (high probability/low impact) and distribution network poles as well as earth
works for protection of power generation
Soil erosion & sedimentation components
(medium probability/high impact)
Loss of natural assets Need for tree cutting to construct the distribution
(medium probability/low impact) network/power generation assets.
Operation Phase
Water/ground pollution from spill overs Improperly transported and stored fuel for
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 9
Closure/Disposal Phase
Key social impacts to be considered during the ESMP process of a clean energy mini-grid and their
corresponding risk assessment are:
Table 2. Social impacts during life-cycle of a clean energy mini-grid
Operation Phase
Risk of burns/fire Fuel spill overs during refilling if proper systems are not
(low probability/medium impact) used.
Negative health impact Associated with genset fuel and battery bank acid
(low probability/high impact) leakages (for Lead-acid batteries). Nickel-Cadmium &
Lead-acid batteries are partially composed of heavy
metals, exposure to which can lead to headaches, brain
and kidney damage, abdominal discomfort affect
children’s growth, cause sleep problems and in severe
cases lead to comas.
Positive economic and social impact Savings for households (provided affordable tariffs in
relation to present expenditures on e.g. kerosene/diesel).
Creation of business opportunities.
Access to information (televisions, laptops, internet).
Community gatherings are facilitated during night-hours
as well.
Potential employment of local personnel during the
operation phase.
Closure/Disposal Phase
Negative health impact Improver disposal of batteries after their life-time can
(low probability/high impact) potentially lead to health risks as described above.
4.1 PV PANELS
Solar modules are the source of conversion from solar energy to renewable electricity. They produce
DC power, which is in turn fed into batteries through charge controllers or fed into the grid after being
converted from DC to AC by inverters. PV panels are made of silicon, metal and glass. The key
components of a PV module are the solar cells (heart of the component), a metal frame (typically
aluminium), glass sheets for casing, wires and steel screws. PV panels are classified as
monocrystalline, polycrystalline or amorphous thin-film modules. Solar panels are known for being an
environmentally-friendly technology, free from noise and air pollution throughout their operational
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 12
phase. For small-scale projects, PV panels are easily integrated into the environment without
fundamentally changing the landscape.
90% of the modules in the market are made of silicon as a semiconductor material. Nevertheless, some
thin-film PV modules use Cadmium Telluride (CdTe). Cadmium is a dangerous and highly poisonous
heavy metal when inhaled or ingested, both for animals and humans, and should be properly disposed
after the Project’s lifetime. Furthermore, the PV manufacturing process is an energy-intensive one, and
priority ought to be given to manufacturers implementing environmental and social mitigation
measures in their processes. Other than the need to properly dispose PV panels as well as rely on
environmentally-conscious PV panel suppliers, no other environmental requirements have to be
fulfilled.
1. Mitigation measures:
a. During construction and operation, no major considerations are required. It is nevertheless
important to keep into account regular PV panel cleaning requirements, for which a
nearby body of water will be necessary. While water access should be ensured, it must
also be properly communicated to the recipient community during early stages of project
design (especially in areas with water scarcity issues).
b. Silicon-based PV panels present little concern during disposal. However, thin-film PV
modules need to be handled carefully. Exposure to heavy metals such as Lead and
Cadmium is a growing problem throughout the world. While the combination of Cadmium
and Tellurium found in some thin-film PV panels reduce the toxicity of the former (with a
concentration of only 0.04% on the entire panel), it is of paramount importance to develop
a proper disposal plan of modules after the end of Project’s lifetime.
c. Emissions from Cadmium and Tellurium are assumed to be close to 0 1. However,
exposure of Cadmium on panels to rain water on landfills can lead to the formation of
leachate in the mid-term. The landfill where PV panels would eventually be disposed of
must ensure the treatment of its effluent. ………………… (kindly state name of country)
environmental regulations set a Cadmium concentration limit on effluents of less than
………… (kindly state maximum level of cadmium concentration levels on effluents as
per national regulations) mg/liter as per ………………… (kindly state source of
applicable national environmental regulation). Minimization of exposure to water of the
modules would
significantly reduce the formation of leachate, and thus minimize the negative
environmental impact in terms of direct soil and water pollution.
d. Furthermore, to minimize potential negative environmental and social impacts of the
entire PV panel value chain from a life-cycle perspective, proper mitigation measures
would include procurement provisions from suppliers regarding recycling and appropriate
precaution practices throughout the manufacturing process. Operators and developers of
mini-grid systems must subscribe to ……………………………… (Kindly state, if
applicable, name of national program regulating end-of-lifecycle equipment disposal).
2. Monitoring of mitigation measures for PV panels:
1
Okkenhaug, et.al., 2010.
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 13
a. In order to ensure the recipient community’s comfort with a developed clean energy Mini-
Grid Project as well as the impact of the PV arrays on the environment, the system
operator should hold meetings with the respective communities periodically to ensure
continued acceptance and comfort with the Project. This is particularly the case when a
scale up of the PV arrays is planned as the community’s load grows.
significantly less hazardous materials than Lead-acid batteries. The battery cell’s anode is
generally made of Graphite, while the cathode is made of Iron Phosphate, Lithium Cobalt Oxide,
Lithium Manganese Oxide or Lithium Nickel Manganese Cobalt Oxide. While Lithium does not
present any major concerns from the pollution perspective, Cobalt and Manganese are examples of
toxic heavy metals. The electrolyte is comprised of Lithium salt in an organic solution. While
proper recycling of the battery maximizes the use of its components, its relative novelty leads to
limited recycling methods until now.
a. Adhering to IEC’s international safety standards for the selection of Lithium-ion battery
banks as well as their construction and operation should ensure Lithium-ion batteries’
environmental and social impact is independent on the site and thus a more in-depth EIA
would not be needed.
b. If improperly maintained (not kept cooled and regularly exposed to complete discharging)
or are physically damaged, Lithium-ion batteries can be subject to thermal runaway risk,
which involves the rapid expulsion of a toxic gas that can eventually explode if ignited. It
is thus of fundamental importance to keep the battery banks cool and operational as per
manufacturer’s guidelines.
3. Mitigation measures for Nickel-based batteries
a. No major mitigation measures are required during construction and operation.
b. Mitigation strategies for the disposal of Nickel-based batteries will ultimately depend on
the specific compounds present on the battery cells. As previously discussed for PV
panels, the Cadmium present in NiCd batteries is highly poisonous and requires a careful
disposal plan. Alternatively, NiMH batteries can be disposed in properly managed waste
landfills, given their significantly lower composition of poisonous materials.
4. Monitoring of mitigation measures for battery banks
a. Existence/availability of battery recycling points must be ensured. Mini-grid operators
shall subscribe to the ……………………………… (Kindly state, if applicable, name of
national program regulating end-of-lifecycle equipment disposal).
b. Battery manufacturers/suppliers ought to be required to provide information on the
source/origin of used raw materials.
c. Fire alarm systems must be set in place in case of an outbreak of fire due to the battery
banks.
3
Such organizational structure ought to be adjusted to the given national regulatory framework.
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 18
Every mini-grid operator must set up an emergency response plan to combat all types of pollution
hazards, as well as submit to ………………… (kindly state the name of the national environmental
regulatory agency) a list of chemicals used in the construction, operational and closure phases of the
Mini-Grid Project.
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 19
Legend
Required ü
Not required
Table 3. Minimum Environmental and Social Parameters (indicators) for Clean Mini-Grid Projects.
Climate change
ü ü ü ü
projections
Solar Radiation
and Temperature
(air and land ü
surface
temperature)
Rainfall – Pattern,
ü ü ü ü
amount, trend
Prevailing wind –
direction, speed
ü
Particulates ü ü ü ü
Noise ü ü ü ü
Vibrations ü ü ü ü
Voluntary and
Land ü
Acquisition Involuntary land
acquisitions
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 20
Socio- Demography of
economic PAPs and ü ü ü ü
communities
Considerations
Economy and
livelihood patterns
ü ü ü ü
Amenities and
infrastructure
ü ü ü ü
Religion, cultures
and traditions
ü ü ü ü
Public health,
safety and security
ü ü ü ü
Traffic ü ü ü
Surface water
quality
[ü]4 ü ü
Wastes Wastes
Management (solid and liquid)
ü ü ü
4
Surface water tests are often only applicable for projects located below a specified distance to surface water sources
(minimum distance varies from country to country).
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 21
Safety
Site
Landscape,
Remediation
and
drainage, ü
community use
Restoration
Habitat types
Ecosystem services
5
It is expected that biodiversity will not be applicable for ESMP given that same is only applicable for projects in sensitive
areas.
ES M P G UI DEL I N ES F OR CL EA N M I N I - G RI D P R O J EC T S 22
6.) REFERENCES
(Kindly list all relevant national environmental regulations)