Cultural Awareness and Inclusion
Cultural Awareness and Inclusion
Cultural awareness and the ability to foster an inclusive work environment are
requirements in today's global business climate. Being effective at both means
conveying respect for different perspectives, backgrounds, customs, abilities, and
behaviour norms, and as well as ensuring all employees are respected and involved
by leveraging their capabilities, insights, and ideas.
CULTURAL AWARENESS
1|Page
TD professionals must develop the capacity to identify ways individuals differ among
various cultures. Understanding different people and their respective cultures is
critical to reach a higher level of cultural awareness and build skills for accepting
differences. This entails a process of interacting and communicating with people
from other cultures to identify personal obstacles. The following are helpful for
accepting differences:
Knowledge. Acquire a clear understanding of others by learning about their
cultural norms, history, basic language, and religion.
Listening. Take time to listen to the opinions of others; practice active
listening and dialogue skills. [See 1.1.7 and 2.3.2]
Empathy. Clarify, understand, and relate to the views and perspectives of
others toward situations that occur in the workplace. Work toward
compassion.
Self-confidence. A healthy self-confidence is required to control reactions to
personal weaknesses and difficulties. Work to eliminate or weaken any
difficulties and obstacles to accepting differences.
Cultural self-awareness. Having a clear understanding for what created a
current attitude, belief, or value may be helpful to appreciate and accept a
different perspective.
Cultural theories and models can build a greater understanding between different
cultures within an organization by identifying differences such as how they view
power or competition. Assessments can help to measure these norms. [See
1.4.1.10]
It may be difficult to fully understand culture from a single theory or model, since
“researchers have found the influences of national cultures shape strong value
systems” (Katz 2005). Therefore, knowing a country’s values provides a useful
framework from which to develop global awareness. This framework should be used
to describe the general cultural trends of a nation. Organizational consultants Fons
Trompenaars and Charles Hampden-Turner (2012) state, “It is now too simplistic to
try to describe the (single) culture of country X without taking into consideration the
effects of immigration, the development of multicultural societies, age and generation
differences, and where corporate culture is a major variable.”
2|Page
1.4.1.4 Globalization of Culture
Cultural theories describe what distinguishes people from one culture to another
based on their location. While culture can be understood by comparing and
contrasting beliefs, it is important to acknowledge that most approaches are limiting.
“Becoming culture savvy,” explains author Maureen Rabotin (2011), “means gaining
the ability to perceive culture not as a list of differences but as the added value that
expands our worldviews and cultural perspectives.”
TD professionals often work within the influence of their own cultures, other people’s
cultures, the organization’s culture, and possibly the cultures of where the
organization is located. The differences between these cultures can create conflicts
that could impede the organization’s ability to execute its global strategic plan.
However, if addressed well, this cultural variety can offer new opportunities for
synergy and innovation. TD professionals, particularly those in leadership roles, must
appreciate the complexity of culture and the effect that such forces can have on the
execution of global strategies and local business practices. It can be difficult to
determine how to manage the organization’s needs within other areas. In their
book Riding the Waves, Trompenaars and Hampden-Turner (2012)
discuss glocalization, saying that “This balance between consistency and adaptation
is essential for corporate success.”
To be successful with globalization, TD professionals should work to understand the
different layers of cultural influence that affect the work being done. They should ask
themselves, “What past and current major country, economic, political, and local
events have occurred or are occurring?”
Geographic boundaries have changed over time, and it is no longer sufficient to try
to understand a national culture merely by those boundaries. For this reason, many
researchers focus more on societal cultures, which are the larger, yet significant,
cultural groupings that exist within a country, such as French- and English-speaking
Canadians.
Some even question the degree to which national culture exists in the business
world. Data reviewed by Taras, Steel, and Kirkman (2011) showed that while some
aspects of culture are becoming more alike, others are actually growing more
different. While Western business philosophies may have significantly shaped the
international business landscape, the world continues to evolve under new
influences. Traditionally, the predominant industrialized countries were the providers
and users of highly skilled and educated talent, but that is now shifting to different
countries, such as Brazil and India. This shift, according to Towers Watson (2012),
has “massive implications, not only for sourcing talent, but also for managing and
engaging workforces with multiple generations from an array of different cultures—
with many working in nontraditional arrangements.” To accommodate these changes
—and to start increasing their global mindset—TD professionals will have to learn
more about multiple societal cultures and their ways of operating.
3|Page
1.4.1.6 Subcultures
Members of a subculture have beliefs, values, and behaviors that are distinct from
other members of the same society. Everyone belongs to a variety of subcultures,
including those that they are born into and those that they join. These groups and the
individuals who form them must choose to what degree they want to integrate into or
express their differences from the larger society in which they live.
Some subcultures develop from the immigration of new groups into an existing
society. “In complex, diverse societies in which people have come from many
different parts of the world, they often retain much of their original cultural traditions.
As a result, they are likely to be part of an identifiable subculture in their new society.
Members of each of these subcultures share a common identity, food tradition,
dialect or language, and other cultural traits that come from their common ancestral
background and experience” (O’Neil 2013). For example, India has more than 100
ethnic groups that speak more than 29 major languages, China is made up of many
different ethnicities, and Egypt is a blend of many different cultures and religions. “As
the cultural differences between members of a subculture and the dominant national
culture blur and eventually disappear, the subculture ceases to exist except as a
group of people who claim a common ancestry” (O’Neil 2013).
A slight variation on the concept of subculture involves the combination of multiple
countries or regions to define a particular shared belief or value. In Cultural
Anthropology, for example, Ember and Ember (2011) discuss “Western culture (the
cultural characteristics of societies in or derived from Europe) or the culture of
poverty (the presumed cultural characteristics of poor people the world over).” The
influence of these larger, commonly accepted beliefs should also be considered
when working with particular situations or groups.
Organizational culture is the sum of the values, beliefs, practices, and behaviors that
contribute to the organization’s social and psychological environment. Social
psychologist Geert Hofstede believed that while national cultures are based on
deeply held values, organizational cultures are more concerned with practices.
Organizational cultures are influenced by their industries, the personalities of their
founders and leaders, and the types of employees they hire. Organizational cultures
define expectations for such things as how people dress (casual or formal), how they
perceive and value employees (recognition), and how they make decisions (as a
group or by the manager alone; Carpenter and Dunung 2018).
The broadest definition of organizational culture manifests through the day-to-day
interactions of employees. Few members of an organization work as individual
contributors; most must engage others in a team environment to achieve business
results. These teams may be geographically dispersed, and many are virtual.
Globalization requires new structures for these teams, such as clearly defining work
hours when time zones differ, the communication methods to be used, how roles are
expected to relate to one another across distances, and new methods for developing
trust and creating learning opportunities. Organizations often struggle to balance
4|Page
consistent company values and rules with having the flexibility to adapt to and
integrate local influences
5|Page
investment, capital flows, migration, and the spread of technology. The changing
landscape of competition from other countries often forces organizations to change
to continue to compete in the market; for example, the global economy and
affordable, widely available technology created more competition, forcing
organizations to make process improvements, operate with less overhead, and
become more efficient.
These factors can significantly affect global business. Many of them will require
organizations to develop new knowledge, which means they’ll need to conduct
extensive research before engaging globally. In addition to doing an environmental
scan, organizations must talk with others, engage international consultants, learn
about negotiation skills, and develop a plan that includes contingencies.
TD professionals “need to understand regional or country differences regarding the
quality and types of skills available, typical turnover rates, employment regulations,
costs of labor, healthcare policies and costs, talent mobility policies, cultural norms
and values, the strength of the employer brand, and the specific employment value
proposition that will attract and retain people” (Gartside and Sloman 2014).
Beyond global cultural perspectives, a number of other methods and models are
used to classify organization culture. Several influential models exist.
This theory demonstrates that there are national and regional cultural groups that
affect organizational behaviors. Hofstede identified the five dimensions of national
culture that determined the values that distinguished countries, rather than
individuals. These dimensions—power distance, individualism versus collectivism,
masculinity versus femininity, uncertainty avoidance, and long-term versus short-
term orientation—influence managers who work globally. Hofstede later expanded
the original framework to include a sixth dimension—indulgence versus restraint—
based on research by Michael Minkov and more of his own research. Hofstede’s
work became one of the first quantifiable frameworks in the field of cross-cultural
communication.
Despite high regard, Hofstede’s work is not without criticism, including arguments
that defining a culture by just a few dimensions is oversimplified and does not
address the regional differences within a country, as well as the blurred cultural lines
that have occurred through globalization. Hofstede does not deny that people are
influenced by regional and other influences, but his research and the research of
others validate the importance of national values to cultural identity. The six
dimensions are best used to compare the cultural attributes of one country or region
with another. A more detailed look at each includes:
Power distance. This dimension expresses the degree to which the less
powerful members of a society accept and expect that power is distributed
unequally. Countries that score low on this dimension are more likely to prefer
more democratic styles and challenge inequality.
6|Page
Individualism versus collectivism. This dimension describes the degree to
which people prefer to be integrated within groups. Self-interest is more
dominant in individualistic societies, with people focusing more on themselves
and their families.
Masculinity versus femininity. Masculine countries are typically more
competitive and reflect the more traditional male values of assertiveness,
achievement, and material rewards. Feminine societies prefer cooperation,
modesty, caring for others, and a concern for quality of life.
Uncertainty avoidance. This dimension involves a society’s level of
tolerance for ambiguity when facing new or unknown situations. Countries that
are high on uncertainty avoidance are more likely to enact numerous rules
and regulations to keep unknown situations from occurring.
Long-term versus short-term orientation. Cultures that include more long-
term orientations are more pragmatic and content with waiting on rewards, as
seen in such behaviors as saving, adapting, and persisting.
Indulgence versus restraint. This dimension describes countries with
indulgent values as those who permit and encourage the gratification of basic
needs, whereas restrained countries follow stricter norms.
1.4.1.10.2 Trompenaars and Hampden-Turner’s Dilemma Theory
The model for dilemma theory was developed by Trompenaars and Hampden-
Turner (2012) and published in their book Riding the Waves of Culture. Their work is
based on the concept that humans universally experience problems associated with
their relationship to others, time, and the environment. While these problems are
believed to be universal, the solutions for dealing with them are not. Their model
postulates that cultural preferences can be categorized into seven different
dimensions (that is, how cultures approach problems to solve them).
Their framework aims to be less dualistic and linear in its approach, which means
that having one cultural category does not exclude its opposite. Trompenaars and
Hampden-Turner theorize that the two values influence one another, and if people
work together, they can achieve a solution that is better than what one person could
achieve independently. The comprehensive model involves much data; however,
some critics find the seven dimensions too complicated. A more detailed look at
each dimension includes:
Universalism versus particularism. Countries with more universalist
preferences view rules, regulations, laws, and obligations as highly important
for helping them with decision making. They view rules as more important
than the relationships that people have with one another.
Individualism versus communitarianism. Similar to Hofstede’s second
dimension, it describes a preference toward individual or group identification.
Individualist countries are more oriented around personal responsibility,
freedom, and achievement; communitarian countries support group values of
safety, support, and loyalty.
7|Page
Specific versus diffuse. This dilemma involves the degree to which people
desire separation between their personal and work lives. Those who aspire to
a more diffuse outlook believe that work and personal lives overlap, and that
close relationships are important for successful work.
Neutral versus emotional. Neutral cultures prefer to stifle emotions and work
from a logical framework in their decision making. Emotional cultures do not
avoid expressing emotion, instead believing it is helpful.
Achievement versus ascription. This dimension describes how people view
status. Achievement orientation values performance, believing that what you
do defines you and your worth. A value of ascription recognizes power and
position for gaining status.
Sequential versus synchronous. This dimension describes the dilemma of
how people view and manage time. Sequential cultures value punctuality and
planning. Synchronous cultures see time as more circular and fluid, which
results in them being more flexible in their planning and follow-through.
Internal direction versus outer direction. An internal direction of control
means that people believe they control their environment, and motivation is
predominantly internal. People with an external direction of control believe
that the environment is more powerful and in control.
Other Models
8|Page
The Organizational Cultural Profile is a model developed by O’Reilly,
Chatman, and Caldwell based on the belief that cultures can be distinguished
by the values that are reinforced within their organization. It’s a self-reporting
tool that distinguishes between eight categories: innovation, support, stability,
respect for people, outcome orientation, attention to detail, team orientation,
and aggressiveness.
Denison’s model asserts that organizational culture can be defined by four
dimensions: mission, adaptability, involvement, and consistency.
Deal and Kennedy defined organizational culture as “the way things get done
around here”: work-hard, play-hard culture; tough-guy macho culture; process
culture; and bet-the-company culture.
Schein states that culture is the most difficult attribute to change and the two
key reasons are due to external adaptation and internal integration. He sees
culture at three levels: artifacts, espoused values, and basic underlying
assumptions.
The Organizational Culture Assessment Instrument (OCAI), developed by
Cameron and Quinn, distinguishes four culture types: clan, adhocracy,
market, and hierarchy.
1.4.2 Knowledge of Social and Cultural Norms That Influence Decision Making
and Behavior
Culture develops and shapes people’s values, assumptions, and behaviors. There
are many ways in which people can increase their awareness. TD professionals
should start by learning more about themselves and then move on to learning about
what influences their behaviors.
Self-Awareness
It is important to first acknowledge and understand one’s own cultural context and
how that influences their perception of others. This step of self-awareness is
necessary for all individuals to take, particularly for leaders of organizations with a
diverse staff who are trying to evaluate policies and practices in a more global
environment. TD professionals are frequently in critical positions of championing or
facilitating this type of cultural self-assessment.
Self-awareness is difficult because most deeply held beliefs and values (of a person
or organization) are ingrained and even unconscious. These beliefs can go so deep
9|Page
that they are treated as fact. Without a deliberate approach to increase one’s
awareness, a person may not realize that they need to question their beliefs or
recognize how their beliefs differ from those of others.
Bennett’s Developmental Model of Intercultural Sensitivity
zoom image
This is a more detailed look at each stage in Bennett’s model:
Denial of difference. People are uninterested in or unaware of cultures other
than their own experience and have little motivation to expand their
awareness.
Defense against difference. People might acknowledge cultures outside
their own, but they believe that theirs is better. This belief often results in
negative stereotyping and openly expressed disdain of those who are
different.
Minimization of difference. At this stage, people acknowledge different
outward expressions of culture, such as food and clothing, but do not fully
recognize the deeper levels of cultural differences. This increased awareness
of differences leads people to be less blatantly stereotypical of other groups.
Individuals view themselves as more tolerant and accepting than they actually
are.
Acceptance of difference. This is the first stage of sensitivity that comes
from an ethnorelative perspective. People recognize that there are multiple
cultural views that influence beliefs and behaviors, although they do not
always understand them.
Adaption to difference. People are more willing to expand their own
worldview through the increased awareness of others’ experiences. They can
offer empathy and compassion.
10 | P a g e
Integration of difference. People at this stage can integrate the views of
other cultures within their own. They easily move in and out of different
cultural perspectives.
1.4.2.2 How Social and Cultural Norms Influence Behaviors and Decisions
Cultural beliefs and behaviors are not innate or inherited; they are learned.
Beginning with infancy and continuing throughout adulthood, people learn about how
to think and behave by interacting with their environment. Behaviorism and
cognitivismare two explanations of how people acquire and maintain behavior
patterns. In addition, enculturation is the process by which people gradually acquire
the norms and beliefs of their culture, and it happens in many ways. Understanding
these processes can help TD professionals to be more sensitive to the different
contexts in which they work. [See 2.1.1.2]
Values, Beliefs, Preferences, and Attitudes
As young children, people are taught values by parents or other familiar adults. As
people age, their experiences include more people and values, from which they may
need to choose. Developing self-awareness of those values can be difficult because
they are deeply held and not always articulated. In addition, people do not always act
according to what they say that they value—they may go against their stated values
in situations where it appears the reward will be greater if they don’t act on a value,
or where another value is more highly prioritized. Values are often realized when
someone is challenged to explain or defend why they believe something or acted in
a certain way. This conflict of values can be the catalyst that pushes people to stop
denying differences and moves them to a more aware stage, as discussed in
Bennett’s Developmental Model of Intercultural Sensitivity.
Assumptions and Biases
An assumption is something that is accepted as true “without proof,” which is the part
people forget. Intuition is a big part of making assumptions because people use it to
attribute meaning to an experience. However, intuition isn’t always correct. Because
many people only share experiences with people who are similar to them, their
viewpoints can go unchallenged. This reinforces to them that their viewpoints are
correct even if they’re not, and eventually, their brains will begin to see patterns and
look for what is similar (Rabotin 2011). This pattern becomes limiting if they engage
outside their usual experiences.
Bias is prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with
another, and it’s usually considered to be unfair. People are generally biased in
believing that their values are truths that define what is good or bad, right or wrong,
fair or unjust. This can be especially true when people are exposed to something that
does not fit with their view. When assumptions are based on such biases, people
can feel legitimized in their actions and can deem another culture as wrong.
Negative stereotypes may eventually occur as people fit situations into their biased
categories. [See 1.2.3]
11 | P a g e
Behavioral Patterns and Norms
Behaviors are the explicit forms of culture that result from the more implicit values
and assumptions. Norms are the “unwritten rules that govern behavior, behavior
patterns typical of specific groups, which have distinct identities based on culture,
language, ethnicity, race, etc., that separate them from other groups” (Ember and
Ember 2011). While individual variations of a behavior may exist, most behavior falls
within culturally accepted limits because there is a tendency toward cultural
consistency within a group. These behaviors play a role to form each culture.
Semiotics
12 | P a g e
recognizing when one’s own cultural behavior may appear strange to those from
different cultures can help eliminate it.
Nuances, Idioms, Expressions, Slang, and Colloquialisms
Language is full of nuance, which can significantly influence meaning. Even in the
same language, different cultures may assign special meanings to expressions and
terms. These meanings cannot be easily understood without having significant
interactions with that group to determine the context in which the sayings are used. If
the language is not one’s own, nuances can be even harder to decipher. Because
idioms and colloquialisms cannot be translated literally or figuratively, they may
appear abstract and nonsensical to the listener. One of the main tenets is to remove
culture-specific references, such as idioms, colloquialisms, and slang. Whether
they’re writing or speaking, TD professionals must attempt to remove culturally
specific terms when working with groups that are different from their own.
Humor
While every culture has humor, what a culture determines to be funny can vary
greatly. Humor can help to calm people in new situations; however, if perceived by
others as inappropriate, humor can also be disrespectful. Humor is often
ethnocentric—told from the teller’s worldview without enough understanding of the
other’s viewpoint. To understand a joke, they must understand the context as well.
TD professionals should recognize that it is probably better to avoid using humor in a
new situation.
Dress Codes
13 | P a g e
understand what business relationships may mean to the people with whom they are
working, so that they will not be perceived as being too personal or impersonal.
Customs
Culture can influence business practices in many ways. From how people physically
and verbally meet and interact to how an organization approaches selling products
or delivering value to customers, business norms may vary greatly by region or
country:
Managing employees and projects. Power distance values may dictate how
people are best managed. For projects, collectivist cultures might favor
groups, while individualist cultures would prefer individual contributions.
Cultural views on time for some might result in doing one project singularly
until completion; for others they might mean performing multiple projects
simultaneously.
Propensity for risk taking. Risk taking can include what information is
divulged and to what extent, a willingness to consider new approaches, and
the comfort that someone has for tolerating uncertainty. Negotiations between
a high uncertainty-avoidance country and one that likes to have group
consensus could be more involved than negotiations with countries that are
more comfortable with risk.
Marketing, sales, and distribution. Country views and regulations will
determine marketing approaches and sales practices, such as level of comfort
with discounts and promotions.
Decision making and negotiating. Cultural views on negotiating can focus
on win-win or win-lose outcomes. Some cultures approach decision making
by looking at what’s best for individuals and others look at what’s best for
everyone.
Neutral versus emotional. Neutral cultures prefer to stifle emotions and work
from a logical framework in their decision making. Emotional cultures do not
avoid expressing emotion and will often do so spontaneously, believing it is
acceptable and helpful.
Cross-Cultural Concepts
14 | P a g e
People observe and evaluate things differently. What is considered acceptable
behavior in one culture may be inappropriate in another. Problems arise when
people use their meanings to understand other people’s reality. With increased self-
awareness, people can recognize the influence that their experiences have had on
shaping their worldview and can more easily accept this mindset as their own.
Becoming self-aware means people must become more:
conscious of their own biases and values without favoring them over another’s
aware of how their own values and biases affect clients from a different
cultural group
comfortable with these cultural differences
aware of any attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors that may be oppressive (Weng
2005).
TD professionals should know that promoting cultural awareness is more than just
something nice to do. It helps teams function better and make better decisions.
Diversity brings fresh ideas and a multicultural view to stimulate creativity and
broaden the messaging to customers. A workplace that values and embraces broad
viewpoints helps create a corporate identity that more easily attracts and retains a
talented workforce.
15 | P a g e
1.4.3.3 Promote Cultural Awareness
The workplace has become a melting pot of culture, which enhances communication
and unity in organizations. TDprofessionals can promote cultural awareness and
help others recognize cultural differences. Individuals work better together when they
recognize and appreciate these differences. TD professionals can help by:
fostering sharing and open discussions about the different cultures in the
organization
seeking to build awareness and knowledge of cultures represented in the
organization
creating formal learning and assessment opportunities.
Inclusion
TD professionals should focus on how diversity and inclusion (D&I) can be a natural
part of the organization’s values and priorities. Diversity is a broad term that
encompasses race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, faith, age, and other factors that
make each person unique. Diversity areas include a focus on gender equality, race
16 | P a g e
awareness, generational differences, personal space, disability awareness, religious
accommodations, multiple languages, and diversity of thought.
Gender Equality
Gender discrimination may exist in the workplace, with women in particular still
experiencing discrimination in pay and advancement. However, many organizations
have become role models of gender equality, thanks in part to increased use of
diversity training. The importance of gender equality varies by culture, nationality,
and country; therefore, TD professionals are well advised to approach such issues
on a case-by-case basis.
Racial Equality
The way people manage personal space varies greatly from culture to culture.
People from cultures that use plenty of personal space to reinforce social distance
may seem cold and isolating to people from cultures where close proximity is the
norm. Proxemics is the relationship of people's positions in space. Researchers state
that in a person’s brain, the amygdala intercedes to maintain what is believed to be
the “right” distance from another human being (Kennedy et al. 2009). TD
professionals play a role in increasing awareness of the importance of respecting
different ideas of acceptable personal space (for example, in meetings, coaching
sessions, and training classes).
Disability Awareness
The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990 and legislation in other countries
have implications for training design for people with disabilities. In the United States,
the ADA prohibits discrimination in employment, public services, transportation,
public accommodations, and telecommunications services against persons with
disabilities. All aspects of employment are covered, including application and
17 | P a g e
selection processes, on-the-job training, wage increases, benefits, and employer-
sponsored social activities.
Religious Accommodations
Diversity of thought refers to employees being hired for their ability to see an issue
differently, solve problems differently, or bring a different thought process to the job.
On the surface this may seem like a good idea, but it has many opponents. The
argument is that it should not be viewed at the same level as hiring for demographic
diversity. However, opponents say that diversity of thought should be achieved as a
result of diverse representation.
The way people think, problem solve, and communicate is shaped by their lived
experiences—the way they learned to think. Therefore, although the concept has
both proponents and opponents, TD professionals should consider the specific goal
of diversity.
18 | P a g e
1.4.4.2 Adaption and Flexibility
19 | P a g e
TD professionals should be prepared to lead, support, and leverage any
organizational strategy that promotes workplace diversity and inclusion in their
organizations.
A diverse and inclusive workforce fosters a more creative and innovative work
environment. It attracts talent and avoids employee turnover costs. As organizations
adapt to the changing world, diversity helps the organization increase its
competitiveness. TD professionals should promote these advantages to the
workforce by implementing specific procedures, including:
helping employees acknowledge differences
communicating the importance and value through various communication
vehicles
creating a business case that examines the cost and the return on investment
asking questions and opening conversations about diversity and inclusion
evaluating recruiting and hiring processes to better attract and retain a diverse
workforce.
Effective leaders will achieve buy-in before launching any new strategy. By creating
a shared sense of responsibility and clarifying what constitutes accountability for
promoting workplace diversity and inclusion, it becomes everyone’s obligation. TD
professionals have a number of approaches available to them, including:
helping employees identify specific steps they can take toward D&I
accountability
providing a clear understanding about why D&I is being emphasized
ensuring everyone is speaking the same language with clear definitions of all
terms
encouraging others to get involved to identify targeted solutions.
20 | P a g e
clarification for inclusion and communication
role plays that practice specific skills
case studies that highlight the difference between acceptable and
unacceptable conduct
discussions uncovering sensitive topics that are difficult to discuss.
Mentoring diverse candidates helps to ensure their development and success within
the organization. The benefit of having the support of someone who knows the
organization can be invaluable for the diverse employee and the organization. All
mentoring programs require structure—and that is particularly true for a diversity
mentoring program. TD professionals should develop a plan for mentoring diverse
candidates with goals, such as:
providing training and support for both the mentors and the diverse candidate
ensuring funding and staffing
establishing goals that align with the organization’s diversity strategy
rallying committed knowledgeable staff as mentors
making sure leadership is involved
ensuring quality interactions (Labin 2017).
TD professionals should use tools that are validated for general assessment or
learning-solution purposes. Assessments focus on two targets: the organization and
individuals. One universally accepted tool for organizations is the Global Diversity
and Inclusion Benchmarks (GDIB), which provides enough data to develop a
comprehensive approach for a diversity and inclusion strategy. The GDIB is a free
resource developed by diversity and inclusion pioneers Julie O’Mara and Alan
Richter, along with a panel of 80 experts. Organizational assessments can highlight
a company’s future educational needs and provide input for strategies.
In addition to conducting an organizational assessment, employees may be
encouraged to complete a D&I self-assessment, which is an early step in
understanding personal bias, prejudice, and stereotypes. People need to make an
intentional effort and examination to expose their own deeply held values of what is
good, right, and preferred, because they’re often unknown to others as well as to the
individuals who hold them. Regardless of the tool used, an assessment should
gather information about knowledge, understanding, acceptance, and behavior.
21 | P a g e
TD professionals demonstrate how to value diversity and inclusion, while also
coaching others to value diversity and demonstrate inclusion. For example, they can:
Acknowledge and celebrate holidays of different cultures.
Move team members around to increase development, provide new
opportunities, and encourage diversity of work units.
Celebrate differences to help build awareness of other cultures and groups.
Emphasize that differences combine to create unique opportunities, and that
the whole is worth more thanthe sum of its parts.
Develop diversity mentorship pairings.
Establish transparent leadership accountability.
22 | P a g e
Identifying cultural influences. Cultural values affect business outcomes,
and problems can occur when there is a disparity between the two. TD
professionals can analyze an organization using a culture audit to examine
the organization’s assumptions, norms, philosophy, and values and determine
whether they hinder or support its vision and mission.
23 | P a g e
Employees learn to communicate with and truly understand one another,
which enables them to be more innovative, responsive, and productive.
Candidate pools expand, and objective criteria for hiring and promotion
increase fairness and opportunity.
Employee engagement increases, which leads to increased employee
retention.
Diversity fosters a wide range of perspectives, resulting in better decisions. A
broader perspective leads to better customer service, innovative product
development, and expansion into new markets.
An inclusive culture develops more flexible and broader-thinking leaders who
are better prepared for a global economy.
Overall organizational performance improves when people are encouraged to
overcome cultural misunderstanding and appreciate differences.
Employees feel more valued and tend to be more productive.
TD professionals may be involved in helping their organizations identify a rationale
for a stronger D&I culture. TD professionals should be able to explain how the
organization’s culture is socially constructed and changed through conversations.
Culture involves a shared view of the world and value system. It includes how
employees talk to one another, their tolerance for uncertainty, their willingness to
take risks, and their comfort level in interacting with leaders and peers. These and
other factors have a direct effect on learning and development preferences and how
people interact on the job.
24 | P a g e
aligning all training and development opportunities to ensure they project the
D&I image that the organization desires, represent different cultures, and are
accessible to all
providing teambuilding or other exercises to teams and groups to overcome
negative stereotypes, develop skills, or improve communication
giving D&I support to supervisors and managers who have diverse employees
establishing a mentoring program for diverse employees
designing an inclusive succession planning process
procuring and administering organizational D&I assessments or self-
assessments
increasing the rate of success for underrepresented groups throughout the
organization
proposing suggestions for how to leverage employee diversity
providing input to how D&I supports the organization’s brand and visibility
expanding the diversity strategy to customers and suppliers
advising leaders whether the D&I strategy has achieved the desired goals
helping leaders understand their responsibility to support D&I
determining measures of accountability.
The organization’s culture can enable or hinder D&I success. TD professionals can
play a role in the process by aligning the D&I strategy and implementing supporting
tactics to build and reinforce the desired culture. They should remember that
conversations change the culture.
25 | P a g e
Community. This might include goals that represent the organization, the
community, and diversity all at once, such as donating time and financial
resources to worthy causes.
The plan also should include a mission, vision, and values to help achieve a more
inclusive workplace:
Vision. The vision statement sets the desired inclusion goal and defines the
future. It incites action and generates commitment to achieving the goals.
Mission. A mission statement must be clear and linked to the organization’s
identity. It should be motivating and encouraging. Even though it may not
seem immediately apparent, all constituents can benefit from a commitment to
workplace diversity and inclusion.
Values. Values reflect the organization’s deepest beliefs. They are
nonnegotiable and are how the organization identifies and differentiates itself
from others. Values should be embodied in specific behaviors that the
organization identifies and institutionalizes at all levels. A leader must
exemplify the inclusion values of the workplace (Silveira and Walters 2017).
TD professionals may need to facilitate the addition of new cultural ideas or minority
and gender groups in the training analysis and planning processes for employee
development programs. During this process, the HR function and top management
may develop a strategy to interview and hire for differences to broaden diversity in
the organization. Facilitating inclusion may include things such as attracting a
diverse workforce and maximizing learning and development.
Attracting a diverse workforce. To attract a diverse workforce, TD
professionals need a corporate structure that is supportive of varying
backgrounds and predispositions. Also required are internal resources and
26 | P a g e
the ability to identify a variety of cultures. Depending on the corporate
structure, talent development may work with other functions in HR to access
job boards or social networks to find the right people to fill the roles. TD
professionals will want to think ahead to determine whether any additions and
changes need to be incorporated in the onboarding process.
Maximizing learning and development. TD professionals need to consider
all cultural concepts and differences when they design and deliver training
programs or interact with the workforce. They will want to examine the design
of all training and development programs, communication efforts, and all
products and services for a diversity and inclusion focus, considering
accessibility, gender neutral vocabulary, appropriate examples, and
others. Delivery should also consider jargon-free language, appropriate dress,
attitudes about age, personal space, work, time, reactions to authority, and
others.
In the United States, regulations governing the hiring, promotion, and discharge of
employees are administered by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
(EEOC). These regulations also cover some aspects of training. For example, the
EEOC’s Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures “apply to tests and
other selection procedures which are used as a basis for any employment
decision . . . hiring, promotion, demotion. . . . Other selection decisions, such as
selection for training or transfer, may be considered employment decisions if they
lead to any of the decisions listed above.” TD professionals should check their
country’s regulations. [See 1.6.5.2]
Disabilities
27 | P a g e
TD professionals should be aware that the ADA requires that effective
communication and training not exclude people with disabilities. This may mean
providing written materials, sign language interpreters, close-captioned video for the
hearing-impaired, or recorded text or special reading software for the visually
impaired. TD professionals in other countries should check their country’s
regulations.
Hiring Practices and Testing
28 | P a g e