Rao, Kothari, Prakash
Rao, Kothari, Prakash
© 2020, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 1742
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 07 Issue: 09 | Sep 2020 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
transformation is completed at Af temperature. In the similar (VAR) . Subtle adjustments in the ratio of the two elements
fashion when it is cooled from Austenite phase, it starts to can make a large difference in the properties of the NiTi alloy,
transform into Martensite at Ms temperature and completes particularly its transformation temperatures. If there is any
this transition at temperature Mf. Crystals in Martensite excess nickel over the 50:50 ratio, one sees a dramatic
phase can have different variants (orientations in which they decrease in the transformation temperatures and an increase
can shear). Variants of Nitionol assemble either by Twinned in the austenite yield strength. Increasing the nickel-to-
Martensitic structure and Detwinned martensitic structure. titanium ratio to 51:49 causes the active Af to drop by over
Figure 1 shows the highly twinned Martensitic Structure of 373.15K [3]. Other non-conventional methods used are
Nitinol. Growing and Shrinking of Twin Boundaries occurs electro beam melting (EBM) and plasma arc melting (PAM).
dur to the applied external stress. Furthermore, under the Undeniably, every machining process has its benefits and
removal of the applied external stress, the deformed shape is limitations and hence a suitable process must be selected
retained at this temperature. Lastly, upon subsequent according to the application.
heating to the initial temperature, the material reverts back
to its original size and shape (stage 4). This process is The process of alloying of nickel – titanium is a very tactful
accompanied by a phase transformation from the deformed process. VIM ensures control over the elements that the
martensite to the original high-temperature austenite phase. molten metals may come in contact with but the inclusion of
For these shape-memory alloys, the martensite-to-austenite oxides or carbides is very hard to control in VIM. It prevents
transformation occurs over a temperature range, between the interaction of melted titanium with reactants in air
temperatures As and Af. preventing the formation of oxides and carbides. VIM is the
most widely used process for the commercial production of
NiTi alloys [4]. Carbon contamination is a major issue since
graphite crucible is used , carbon is highly soluble in nickel
and titanium reacts with carbon to form carbides, but
research on VIM of nitinol from 2000-2005 has found better
practices to get less inclusions and maintain relative high
purity. VAR is a secondary process which improves the purity
of the pre-cast.
eliminated due to melting in a water-cooled copper crucible, and cons of hot or cold methods we can assume the best
and oxygen contamination is minimized due to operation in method which has a minimal impact on the life of the end
high vacuum (better than 10-20 Pa). Therefore, the carbon product and does not affect the shape memory effect in a
and oxygen contents in the final product depend mainly on negative way. By exposing nitinol to high temperatures, we
their levels in the initial raw material [7]. There is need for risk the inclusion of oxides in the product, which may induce
extensive research here as pure alloys will crucially benefit brittleness and shorten the life of the product. Finally, the
Biomedicine for better quality of Apparatus and implants. product is cold worked and annealed at 873.15 – 1073.15 K.
After the ingots are casted and have undergone a secondary A combination of cold working and ageing treatments is
melting to remove inclusions, they are subjected to hot/cold necessary in order to achieve optimal superelastic
forging to form a cylindrical shape and then they are performance. [8]
hot/cold drawn to a suitable diameter. By weighing the pros
VAR No need for a crucible, superior purity compared Susceptible to presence of small inclusions, remelting can
to VIM result in carbon and oxygen pick-up in case of vacuum leak,
extreme melt reactivity and segregation possible, rapid grain
growth
PAM High energy concentration, high plasma flow Low melted metal degassing, insufficient homogeneity;
velocity, quick heat transfer hence quick melting. multiple torches required for homogeneity
EBM No further carbon contamination, carbon content [Small volume production, poor chemical composition control
is 4–10 times lower than in VIM.
Method Determining factors and their allowable ranges. Values exceeding recommended range are Suitability rating
shown in bold
VIM Carbon content: (300–700 ppm against a ≤500 ppm recommended , Can reach 0.22 wt.-% Good
(recommended ≤0.05 wt.%) on first crucible use ) Oxygen content: ≈0.025 wt.%
(recommended ≤0.05 wt.%) , Homogeneity: good due to electrodynamic stirring , Inclusions:
5–40 μm
VAR Carbon content: (≤100 ppm against a ≤500 ppm recommended ,Oxygen content: 0.03 wt.% Excellent
(recommended ≤0.05 wt.%) Inclusions: ≈ 17 μm (≤39 μm recommended)
PAM Carbon content: 0.0094 wt.% (recommended ≤0.05 wt.%), Oxygen content: 0.031 Good
(recommended ≤0.05 wt.%) Inclusions lesser than 5 μm, poor homogeinity as compared to
VIM
EBM Carbon content: 0.012–0.016 wt.% (recommended ≤0.05 wt.%) , Oxygen content: 0.01 wt.% Good
(recommended ≤0.05 wt.%), poor chemical composition
© 2020, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 1744
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 07 Issue: 09 | Sep 2020 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
3. PROPERTIES OF NITINOL DESIRABLE IN against failure.” “In order to analyze the lifetime of a device
subjected to both a cyclic and static strain, a modified
BIOMEDICINE
Goodman diagram may be used (Fig) [10]. First a strain
approach is used in the constructing the axes. But then, as
3.1 Corrosion and Surface Properties one might expect based on the shape of stress-strain
curves, the line itself is non-linear, departing from the
All the studies of surface modifications of Nitinol have been endurance limit along a tangent to the first yield, then
aimed at improving its corrosion behavior and It has been finishing at a second yield.” [11]
shown that localized corrosion resistance of bare Nitinol
may vary significantly, depending on its surface state.
However, in scratch corrosion tests when surface damage
is caused mechanically, the ability of Nitinol happens to be
inferior to that of pure Ti, though comparable with the
scratch healing ability of stainless steel. The potentials of
NiTi determined in scratch tests are low (from 150 to 300
mV) compared with PD and PS polarization, and this is the
problem to be targeted in the development of Nitinol
surface modifications [9]. When Nitinol implants receive
appropriate surface treatment through electropolishing
and passivation, they develop a passive titanium oxide
layer, which forms a barrier that will prevent corrosion and
release of toxic Ni ions into the bloodstream.
© 2020, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 1745
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 07 Issue: 09 | Sep 2020 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
Patterns of nickel release from Nitinol is a central issue in rather large embolized blood clots. One more example is
Nitinol biocompatibility. Our understanding of the patterns osteosynthesis plates and staples, these can be inserted
of Ni release from Nitinol evolved significantly. and placed in the body. Then after heating it can help
Observations on Ti–Ni alloys prepared in laboratories closure the facture of the bones. [12] [13] [14]
[Ryhänen, 1997, Wever, 1998, Michiardi, 2006a] showed
that Ni release from Nitinol might be higher than from SS 3.6 Elastic Deployment
during the first days of exposure to biological solutions,
even though it dropped to almost undetectable levels after One of the reasons to use nitinol in medical device is that
10–14 days. Studies of Ni release from commercial with one or two small incisions will be certainly more
material, however, pointed at different patterns, where an appealing than the patient undergoing surgery with a long
increase was noted at the beginning of exposure and its scars and other complications that result from traditional
stabilization was observed only after a few months [Cisse, surgery. With using nitinol devices, it can be inserted
2002, Kobayashi, 2005, Sui, 2006, Clarke, 2006]. The through small openings and then expand to the desired
amount of released Ni differed significantly [Clarke, 2006], size and function. The concept of making a curved device
pointing at the effects of processing, which is in agreement through a straight needle is probably the most common
with variable Ni surface concentrations reported for use of Nitinol in medical instrumentation. One of the first
Nitinol wires (0.4–15 at.%) [Shabalovskaya, 2003a]. High- products was Homer Mammalok (shown in the figure
temperature treatments, which promote the formation of a below), which radiologists use to 'mark' the location of a
thicker external TiO2 layer, result in Ni accumulation in the breast tumour. It has a Nitinol wire hook inside a Stainless
internal surface layers. These buried layers can be easily Steel annulated needle. [12], [13], [14]
activated due to surface damage.
© 2020, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 1746
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 07 Issue: 09 | Sep 2020 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
metals for mitigation has not proved beneficial. Cobalt- forces to be produced when the wire is engaged in the
chromium Alloy has higher density, Young’s modulus, yield bracket slots of teeth. High strength would prevent any
strength, tensile strength and overcomes the limitations of permanent deformation when the wire is engaged in teeth
stainless steel as it possesses better radio-opacity and which are severely crowded [19].
better overall strength. These properties have enabled
stent struts to become thinner and still have the same The use of NiTi alloy in this field also demands for higher
ability to resist deformation as a thicker strut with a lower grade and pure nickel-titanium as any inclusions that are
elastic modulus [16]. Thinner struts improve the flexibility, not suitable may result in undesired effects or even
increase the inner diameter of the stent and mainly medical complications. Nitinol is preferred overall for
decreases the potential injuries. orthodontic use as it has general corrosion resistance as
compared to stainless steel wires that have shown to
The mechanical properties of the superelastic Nitinol alloy corrode after some use. Nitinol is also found to have high
have played a major role in the explosion of CAD and PAD working range compared to stainless steel or twist flex
stenting, with modern stents demonstrating reasonable wires shown in a study by Andrearson. In his study he
resilience and durability. The majority of nitinol stents are mentions in conclusion ”the time-linked performance of
of the self-expanding type. Self-expandable vascular stents one 0.019 inch cobalt unannealed nitinol wire will
made up of Nitinol exploits its pseudoelasticity property. approximate that of having to change two to four single
The stenting procedure using a Nitinol stent consists of: (i) strands of round levelling wire with the slope of the curve
setting the stent in open condition i.e. austenitic phase (Af following Hooks’ law to the elastic limit of approximately a
is lower than body temperature), (ii) compressing and 0.014 inch round stainless steel wire” [20].
inserting the stent into the catheter (iii) removal of the
sheath and expansion of the stent. The inverse 4.3 Clinical Instruments
transformation from martensite to austenite occurs during
this, which is due to the martensitic instability at a There is a growing market for nitinol in clinical
temperature higher than Af. Hence avoiding the usage of instruments. Instruments that are steerable, hingeless, kink
balloon and minimizing inflation problems caused by the resistant, highly flexible and that provide constant force
forces exerted by the cardiovascular tissues. The have all been developed. These include: Biopsy forceps
Biocompactibility of Nitinol stents are exceptional tissue ablators hingeless graspers and retrieval baskets for
compared to other MBS. However the mechanical laparoscopy. [21]
behaviour of Nitinol under multiaxial conditions remains
poorly understood and hence the deformation and fracture 4.4 Magnetic Resonance Imagining
behaviour for long term safe use is still to be researched.
Magnetic Resonance Imagining (MRI) is a non-invasive
imaging technology which is used as a diagnostic
4.2 Nitinol in Orthodontics
procedure to get high quality results in the form of
pictures. MRI scanners use strong magnetic fields to
Nitinol alloy in orthodontics was a revolutionary feat of generate the images of the organs in the body. Stainless
engineering as it allowed for newer research, faster and steel is susceptible to magnetic fields and as a result
easier ways to make dental corrections. George F interferes with the image to the point where it is
Andrearson was a determined researcher in this field a unrecognizable. Nitinol is very much less sensitive to
published numerous articles in the 1970’s. He mainly magnetic resonance and therefore yields a much better
focused on nitinol’s use in dental archwire. Archwire is results. [21]
used along with metal brackets to align the teeth to make a
person look cosmetically appealing. They also help to align 5. CONCLUSIONS
disfigured or even impacted teeth so as to make them more
functional or to prevent future misalignment. in
orthodontics an archwire also helps in conforming to the Our review has ventured far into the understanding of
alveolar or dental arch that can be used with dental braces NiTinol and its biomedical uses, but it is evident that far
as a source of force in correcting irregularities in the more research can be done with regards to this super alloy
position of the teeth. An archwire can also be used to and we expect it to provide solutions to problems we might
maintain existing dental positions; in this case it has a not know yet. Research about NiTinol in the field of Bio-
retentive purpose [17]. Levelling is the process in which medicine has many uses as discussed above and further
the incisal edges of the anterior teeth and the buccal cusps more in surgical tools and self tightening stitches that are
of the posterior teeth are placed on the same still under development and require further research .Our
horizontal level; and alignment is the lining up of teeth of review has exhibited the ways in which NiTinol has
an arch in order to achieve normal contact point improved pre-existing solutions by showcasing its
relationships [18]. Wires used in this initial phase in an material properties which has yielded the name super alloy
orthodontic treatment requires them to have low stiffness, .NiTinol has proven itself to be a robust, versatile and
high strength and long working range. The ideal wires to progressive super alloy that will bring forth a monumental
use in this phase of treatment is a Nickel-Titanium change in science and technology in the future.
archwires. Low stiffness will allow small
© 2020, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 1747
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 07 Issue: 09 | Sep 2020 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
© 2020, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 1748