Missouri Suit
Missouri Suit
Plaintiff,
Defendants.
Plaintiff, Combat Veterans Motorcycle Association (“CVMA”), for its complaint against
Defendants, GearLaunch, Inc., Thatcher Claflin Spring, and Does 1-10 (collectively
“Defendants”), states:
1. This is a civil action for direct and contributory copyright infringement arising
under the copyright laws of the United States, 17 U.S.C. § 101 et seq.; for trademark
counterfeiting, direct and contributory trademark infringement, and unfair competition and false
designation of origin arising under the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1051 et seq.; and for common
2. By this action, CVMA seeks equitable and legal remedies for Defendants’
property rights.
organized and existing under the laws of the State of Missouri, with a principal place of business
corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, with a principal
resident of the State of California. Spring is the founder and chief executive officer of
GearLaunch, and therefore, upon information and belief, directs and controls the activities of
property laws, and knowingly has authorized, directed, and/or participated in the infringing
6. Upon information and belief, other potential parties related to, affiliated with, or
obfuscating their identities such that they are not readily identifiable to CVMA. Thus, upon
information and belief, the infringing activities alleged herein have been undertaken by unknown
Doe defendants 1-10 individually and/or jointly, who have engaged in illicit activities described
herein by their registration, ownership, operation, and/or authorization of, and/or profitability
7. This Court has subject-matter jurisdiction over CVMA’s federal Lanham Act and
copyright claims pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 1121 and 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338.
8. This Court has subject-matter jurisdiction over CVMA’s related claims arising
9. This Court has personal jurisdiction over Defendants because, upon information
and belief, Defendants engage in continuous and systematic business activities within the State
of Missouri and this District, such as distributing, offering for sale, and selling goods that
infringe CVMA’s intellectual property within Missouri and this District; and/or regularly solicit
business in Missouri and this District, deriving substantial revenue from interstate commerce, the
State of Missouri, and this District; and/or have purposefully directed substantial activities at the
residents of Missouri and this District by means of advertising and selling infringing products
through websites further described herein; and/or have committed and directed its willful,
tortious conduct described herein directed at persons located in Missouri and this District; and/or
intended, knew, or reasonably should have known that their conduct would infringe CVMA’s
intellectual property rights, causing harm to CVMA, which is located in this District; and/or have
otherwise made or established contacts with the State of Missouri sufficient to permit the
10. Venue is proper in this District under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b) because the events
giving rise to the claims complained of herein occurred in this District and the intellectual
property that is the subject of this action is owned by CVMA, who is situated in this District.
belonging to separate chapters formed across the nation and abroad, with a mission to support
and protect veterans and provide assistance and charity to individual veterans, veteran care
12. CVMA is the registered owner of the COMBAT VETS ASSOCIATION® (and
Design) trademark, which is shown below and is the subject of U.S. Trademark Registration No.
2878643, filed April 3, 2003 and registered August 31, 2004, for “Indicating membership in a
A true copy of the Certificate of Registration is attached as Exhibit 1, which provides prima facie
evidence of CVMA’s exclusive right to use the COMBAT VETS ASSOCIATION® (and
13. CVMA is the registered trademark owner of the mark COMBAT VETERANS
ASSOCIATION®, which is the subject of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 5797011, filed
March 27, 2018 and registered July 9, 2019, for “Association services, namely, promoting the
interests of motorcycle riding combat veterans” in Class 200. A true copy of the Certificate of
14. CVMA is the registered trademark owner of the mark COMBAT VETS
ASSOCIATION®, which is the subject of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 6085367, filed
November 17, 2019 and registered June 23, 2020, for “Drinkware, namely, cups and mugs” in
International Class 21, “Apparel, namely, shirts, sweatshirts, jackets, coats, hats and face masks”
in International Class 25, and “Patches and belt buckles” in International Class 26. A true copy
of the Certificate of Registration is attached as Exhibit 3, which provides prima facie evidence of
CVMA’s exclusive right to use the COMBAT VETS ASSOCIATION® trademark, as reflected
therein.
15. CVMA is the registered trademark owner of the Skully Design, which is shown
below and is the subject of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 6151261, filed November 17, 2019
and registered September 15, 2020, for “Drinkware, namely, cups and mugs” in International
Class 21, “Apparel, namely, shirts, sweatshirts, jackets, coats, hats and face masks” in
International Class 25, “Patches and belt buckles” in International Class 26, and “indicating
A true copy of the Certificate of Registration is attached as Exhibit 4, which provides prima facie
evidence of CVMA’s exclusive right to use the Skully Design trademark, as reflected therein.
VETS®, which is the subject of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 6436851, filed November 27,
2019 and registered August 3, 2021, for “Drinkware, namely, cups and mugs” in International
Class 21, “Apparel, namely, shirts, sweatshirts, jackets, coats and hats” in International Class 25,
“Ornamental cloth patches; Belt buckles” in International Class 26, and “Indicating membership
in a motorcycle club” in Class 200. A true copy of the Certificate of Registration is attached as
Exhibit 5, which provides prima facie evidence of CVMA’s exclusive right to use the
17. CVMA is the registered trademark owner of the mark SUPPORTER COMBAT
VETS®, which is the subject of U.S. Trademark Registration No. 6481462, filed November 27,
2019 and registered September 14, 2021, for “Drinkware, namely, cups and mugs” in
International Class 21, “Apparel, namely, shirts, sweatshirts, jackets, coats and hats” in
International Class 25, “Ornamental cloth patches; Belt buckles” in International Class 26, and
“Indicating membership in a motorcycle club” in Class 200. A true copy of the Certificate of
Registration is attached as Exhibit 6, which provides prima facie evidence of CVMA’s exclusive
18. CVMA is the owner of trademark application U.S. Serial No. 97/423323, for the
mark AUXILIARY COMBAT VETS and Design (shown below), filed on May 23, 2022 and
claiming a date of first use at least as early as 2001, for “Drinkware, namely, cups and mugs” in
International Class 21, “Apparel, namely, shirts, sweatshirts, jackets, coats and hats” in
International Class 25, “Ornamental cloth patches; Belt buckles” in International Class 26, and
Trademark Office’s Trademark Status and Document Retrieval system is attached as Exhibit 7.
19. CVMA is the owner of trademark application U.S. Serial No. 97/423326, for the
mark SUPPORTER COMBAT VETS and Design (shown below), filed on May 23, 2022 and
claiming a date of first use at least as early as 2001, for “Drinkware, namely, cups and mugs” in
International Class 21, “Apparel, namely, shirts, sweatshirts, jackets, coats and hats” in
International Class 25, “Ornamental cloth patches; Belt buckles” in International Class 26, and
causes on national and state levels.” A true copy of the status pages from the U.S. Patent and
Trademark Office’s Trademark Status and Document Retrieval system is attached as Exhibit 8.
Collectively, CVMA’s trademarks identified above may be referred to as the “CVMA Marks.”
which is shown below and is the subject of U.S. Copyright Registration No. VA0002304370,
registered with the U.S. Copyright Office on May 18, 2022. A true copy of the Certificate of
Collectively, the trademarks and copyrighted work of CVMA may be referred to hereafter as
21. The CVMA Intellectual Property is an integral part of CVMA’s branding and
marketing in connection with its association, membership, and other charitable services.
22. CVMA has continuously used the CVMA Marks in connection with (i) its
membership organization since at least as early as 2002, (ii) apparel products, such as shirts,
sweatshirts, and jackets, since at least as early as 2004, and (iii) drinkware products, such as cups
23. CVMA prominently uses the CVMA Intellectual Property on CVMA’s website,
membership merchandise, print advertising, digital advertising, and social media outlets.
10
11
12
25. CVMA’s membership organization services, and products bearing the CVMA
Intellectual Property, are offered to select groups and individuals who must qualify to participate
26. In addition to its continuous and prominent use of the CVMA Intellectual
Property, CVMA licenses the rights to use the CVMA Intellectual Property to third parties for
use in connection with authorized merchandising programs featuring a wide variety of goods,
27. Through CVMA’s rigorous licensing program, the licensed products bearing
CVMA Intellectual Property, are permitted for distribution only among qualified CVMA
13
to non-members.
28. All licensed products are further subject to extensive quality control and
supervision to ensure that officially licensed products bearing CVMA Intellectual Property are of
the highest quality and thereby consistent with CVMA’s own goods and services offered in
29. CVMA has promoted, marketed, advertised, and used its CVMA Intellectual
Property extensively, and has made substantial sales of products and services offered under, in
30. CVMA, on its own and through its members and licensees, has made exclusive
use of CVMA’s Intellectual Property for over two decades in connection with its goods and
services, including among other things, on apparel and drinkware, which have been sold,
displayed, used, and distributed nationwide among appropriate and authorized members and
recipients.
31. CVMA has expended substantial resources, engaged in extensive marketing, and
vigorously enforced licensee compliance to develop and maintain the considerable goodwill it
enjoys in the CVMA Intellectual Property and the valuable reputation associated therewith.
veteran organizations, together with its advertising and sales of products bearing the CVMA
Intellectual Property, CVMA’s Intellectual Property is recognized by consumers and the relevant
purchasers as associated with CVMA, CVMA’s charitable and membership association services,
14
33. Upon information and belief, Defendant GearLaunch was formed in 2013,
platform, providing tools and resources for online retailers to build scalable online businesses.
platform wherein it operates numerous ecommerce websites that sell merchandise, such as
provides everything necessary to build and operate an online ecommerce business, including the
tools, and customer service for products offered and sold through GearLaunch-created websites.
38. Upon information and belief, Defendants GearLaunch and Spring secure URLs
for hosting online storefronts for its clients and provide the means for uploading unauthorized
apparel and drinkware products, which GearLaunch prints and distributes nationwide within a
39. Under this business model, GearLaunch operates or has operated numerous
15
Websites”), which appear to be operational for up to 36 hours before becoming disabled, and
during which time are solely offering and selling counterfeit merchandise, including apparel and
40. Upon information and belief, Defendants GearLaunch and/or Spring have been
made aware of its illicit business activities by CVMA and many others, who have brought the
copyright infringement:
- Indian Motorcycle International, LLC v. GearLaunch, Inc. and John Doe d/b/a
Company a/k/a Biker’s Corner, and Tee Dig, and John Does, Case No. 16-cv-
1167 (filed August 30, 2016, E.D. Wis.), alleging trademark counterfeiting,
LLC v. Sunfrog, LLC, Josh Kent, GearLaunch Inc., Michael Schell, Thatcher
16
(filed November 21, 2016, C.D. Cal.), alleging trademark infringement, right of
Thatcher Claflin Spring, Case No. 4:17-cv-02280-DMR (filed April 24, 2017,
and false designation of origin, and direct and contributory trademark dilution;
- Hold This, Inc. v. GearLaunch and Doe 1 d/b/a DLS-Store.com, Case No. 1:18-
cv-01386 (filed April 1, 2018, N.D. Ga.), alleging trademark infringement and
copyright infringement;
- Tim Okamura v. GearLaunch, Inc., Thatcher Claflin Spring, Tee Eco, Barrett
June 8, 2018, C.D. Cal.), alleging copyright infringement, violation of the Visual
17
KK (filed July 13, 2018, C.D. Cal.), alleging trademark counterfeiting, trademark
- Sanrio Co., Ltd. and Sanrio, Inc. v. GearLaunch, Inc., Thatcher Claflin Spring,
- White River Marine Group, L.L.C. and Bass Pro Intellectual Property, L.L.C. v.
(filed April 22, 2022, W.D. Mo.), alleging counterfeiting, trademark infringement,
trademark dilution.
41. Given the number of lawsuits brought against Defendants GearLaunch and Spring
for their persistent counterfeiting and infringing activities described herein, there is a clear
history of illicit and remorseless violations of third-party intellectual property rights through a
sham business grounded in palming off the goodwill and valuable reputations of established
brands’ intellectual property, including CVMA Intellectual Property, as further alleged herein.
18
42. On or around May 11, 2022, CVMA first became aware of Defendants’ infringing
operations and activities through the online storefront www.teepublicsk.com, advertising and
offering for sale several products, including apparel and drinkware products, all of which
prominently displayed CVMA’s signature logo and member patch design—the registered
CVMA, further noting that the Counterfeiting Products would be available for purchase until
May 12, 2022, a period of time thought to be too short to effectively report the infringement
through available means, such as a complaint pursuant to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act
43. On or around June 7, 2022, CVMA learned of a new counterfeiting website run
letter, notifying GearLaunch of the CVMA Intellectual Property and demanding that all sales of
44. Although the Counterfeiting Products were promoted as being available only for
the next 6 hours—until June 8 (see Exhibit 11, pages 11-15)—GearLaunch responded on June 8,
2022, advising that the Counterfeiting Products would be removed from the
www.peacock24shop.com website.
45. Shortly thereafter, on or around August 3, 2022, CVMA became aware of a new
GearLaunch, and sent another cease-and-desist letter to GearLaunch, expressly noting the
19
marks and designs displayed on products being sold through websites operated by GearLaunch.
A true copy of correspondence sent to GearLaunch on August 3, 2022, is attached as Exhibit 12.
August 4, 2022, and was believed to be shortly disabled as indicated therein, without further
47. The following day, on August 5, 2022, CVMA became aware of yet another
desist letter to GearLaunch demanding the takedown of Counterfeiting Products. A true copy of
and offer for sale Counterfeiting Products that infringe the CVMA Intellectual Property.
49. For example, on or around August 18, 2022, and between October 14, 2022 and
October 25, 2022, GearLaunch websites were created using the domain names
to promote and sell Counterfeiting Products that prominently feature CVMA’s Intellectual
Property, all of which confirm in the footer that the websites are powered by GearLaunch. True
50. Each of the Class 21 and Class 25 Counterfeiting Products offered and sold
through GearLaunch-created online stores bear spurious designations of the CVMA Intellectual
20
are counterfeiting.
21
22
23
identical to, nearly identical to, and/or substantially similar to the CVMA Intellectual Property,
52. Defendants have a reputation for selling products of poor quality and providing
poor-quality customer service, inferior to the high-quality goods and services offered by CVMA
53. The Counterfeiting Goods have been and/or are currently offered for sale and sold
on numerous e-commerce websites that are owned, operated, controlled, registered by, and/or
otherwise affiliated with Defendants GearLaunch and Spring, as indicated on the Counterfeiting
Websites, each of which include the words “Powered by GearLaunch” and provide a customer
(see Exhibits 10-16), and further direct users to contact GearLaunch customer service for support
54. Upon information and belief, Defendants GearLaunch and Spring may
unilaterally remove content from those websites, and maintain discretion over the designs
displayed, advertised, sold, and/or offered for sale through the websites it operates and the
designs it prints on products it manufactures, packages, and distributes as part of its business
of Counterfeiting Products, both current and past, that use identical, nearly identical, and/or
be confused such that consumers will erroneously believe the Defendants are affiliated,
24
56. Upon information and belief, Defendants are aware of the CVMA Intellectual
Property and their infringing activities by using the same without authorization, at a minimum,
by virtue of the several notices of infringement sent to Defendants from CVMA; but willfully
continue to engage in operating online storefronts that advertise, offer, and sell Counterfeiting
Products and continue to manufacture, package, and distribute the Counterfeiting Products sold
57. The aforementioned illicit and infringing activities of Defendants have been
directed at consumers nationwide, including those located in Missouri and this District.
likelihood of consumer confusion and deception has caused and is causing irreparable harm to
CVMA’s reputation and goodwill, particularly given the lack of quality and poor customer
service perceived or experienced by the public in connection with the Counterfeiting Websites
59. Defendants’ continued violation of CVMA’s intellectual property rights is and has
been in bad faith, with malicious intent, and with blatant and intentional disregard to CVMA’s
60. Defendants’ illicit and infringing activities complained of herein are an extension
61. Upon information and belief, Defendants have generated profits through the
25
financial interest in permitting, encouraging, and overseeing, and continuing the counterfeiting
CVMA, Defendant Spring had knowledge or reason to know of the infringing activities, and
participating in the promotion, manufacture, distribution, offer for sale, and/or sale of
64. CVMA realleges and incorporates by reference the averments of all preceding
65. Defendants have used spurious designations that are identical with, or
substantially indistinguishable from, the CVMA Marks on goods covered by CVMA’s trademark
66. Defendants have intentionally and willfully used these spurious designations,
without authorization, knowing they are counterfeit in connection with the advertising, offering,
Counterfeiting Products.
67. Defendants’ unauthorized use of the CVMA Marks is likely to cause the public to
believe that Defendants’ goods and services are the same as CVMA’s goods and services, and/or
26
connected, or associated with or in some way related to CVMA, which is not true.
68. As a result of Defendants’ unauthorized use of the CVMA Marks, Defendants are
unfairly benefiting and profiting from CVMA’s highly regarded reputation and goodwill
69. Defendants’ actions complained of herein are to the substantial and irreparable
injury to the public, CVMA, and CVMA’s Marks, and the substantial goodwill represented
thereby.
counterfeit the federally registered CVMA Marks for private financial gain.
notice of infringement of the CVMA Marks, demonstrating an intentional, willful, and malicious
intent to counterfeit the federally registered CVMA Marks and making this an exceptional case.
compensatory damages, treble damages, disgorgement of profits, and costs and attorneys’ fees,
or, at CVMA’s election, statutory damages of up to $2,000,000 per counterfeit mark per type of
goods and/or services advertised, sold, and/or offered for sale, pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 1117.
74. CVMA realleges and incorporates by reference the averments of all preceding
27
76. CVMA has used each of the registered CVMA Marks continuously in commerce
since at least early as 2008, with many uses dating back to 2001.
77. Defendants’ use in commerce of one or more of the registered CVMA Marks
infringes CVMA’s rights in its registered marks, in violation of 15 U.S.C. § 1114 because it
renders Defendants’ Counterfeiting Products confusingly similar to goods and services CVMA
78. Defendants’ unauthorized use of one or more of the registered CVMA Marks
creates the erroneous impression in consumers’ minds that Defendants’ Counterfeiting Products
have been manufactured, approved, sponsored, endorsed, or guaranteed by, or are in some way
79. Defendants’ use in commerce of one or more of the registered CVMA Marks has
caused irreparable injury to CVMA by, inter alia, destroying consumers’ unique association of
the CVMA Marks with CVMA and/or its licensees, and engendering confusion in the
marketplace.
81. Unless Defendants are enjoined and restrained from continuing their
infringement, consumers will continue to be confused and CVMA’s injuries will continue to
occur.
82. CVMA is entitled to recover three times its actual damages, as well as
to be proven at trial.
28
entitling CVMA to attorney’s fees and to treble damages, statutory damages, and interest,
84. CVMA realleges and incorporates by reference the averments of all preceding
85. CVMA owns all right, title, and interest in the CVMA Marks, each of which it has
used continuously in commerce in connection with apparel products and drinkware since at least
86. Defendants’ use in commerce of one or more of the CVMA Marks infringes
Counterfeiting Products confusingly similar to goods and services CVMA and its licensees offer
87. Defendants’ unauthorized use of one or more of the CVMA Marks creates the
erroneous impression in consumers’ minds that Defendants’ Counterfeiting Products have been
manufactured, approved, sponsored, endorsed, or guaranteed by, or are in some way affiliated
with CVMA and the CVMA Marks, constituting unfair competition and a false designation of
88. Defendants’ use in commerce of one or more of the CVMA Marks has caused
irreparable injury to CVMA by, inter alia, destroying consumers’ unique association of the
CVMA Marks with CVMA and/or its licensees, and engendering confusion in the marketplace.
29
infringement, consumers will continue to be confused and CVMA’s injuries will continue to
occur.
91. CVMA is entitled to recover three times its actual damages, as well as
to be proven at trial.
92. Defendants’ intentional and willful misconduct renders this an exceptional case,
entitling CVMA to attorney’s fees and to treble damages, statutory damages, and interest,
93. CVMA realleges and incorporates by reference the averments of all preceding
94. Defendants are engaging in illegal conduct, including without limitation, the
promotion, advertisement, offer for sale, manufacture, sale, and distribution of the Counterfeiting
95. Defendants GearLaunch and Spring have actual knowledge of the illegal activities
96. With blatant disregard to CVMA’s written notice and rights in the CVMA Marks,
Defendants GearLaunch and Spring have continued to materially encourage, enable, and
contribute to the counterfeiting and infringing activities by, among other things, providing a
platform for the Counterfeiting Websites wherein the Counterfeiting Products are displayed,
promoted, offered for sale, and sold, facilitating communications by and between the sellers of
30
97. Defendants GearLaunch and Spring are therefore contributorily liable for the
counterfeiting and infringing activities alleged in this Complaint, in violation of the Lanham Act
98. CVMA has no adequate remedy at law for the contributory trademark
infringement of Defendants GearLaunch and Spring, and has suffered irreparable harm as a
99. As a result of the Defendants’ wrongful contributory conduct, CVMA has been
damages, attorney’s fees, the costs of this action, and any and all other relief authorized by law.
100. CVMA realleges and incorporates by reference the averments of all preceding
101. CVMA owns all right, title, and interest in the valid U.S. Copyright Registration
No. VA0002304370, for the Skully graphic work of art (“Skully Design”).
102. CVMA has complied in all respects with the provisions of the Copyright Act, 17
U.S.C. §§ 101 et seq., and all other laws governing copyright to secure the exclusive rights and
103. Defendants’ Counterfeiting Products use and feature a design that is identical,
strikingly similar, or at least substantially similar to the protectable elements of the Skully
Design.
31
Design and by using, displaying, advertising, promoting, offering for sale, and selling
105. The copying of the Skully Design and the use, display, advertising, promotion,
offer for sale, and sale of Defendants’ Counterfeiting Products has resulted in damage to CVMA
and continues to damage CVMA, including but not limited to lost product sales and the loss of
licensing revenue.
106. Defendants have profited from and received a direct financial interest from the
107. Because Defendants have directly copied the Skully Design, knew of their
infringement, and/or acted with reckless disregard for or willful blindness to CVMA's copyright
from further unauthorized use, copying, reproduction, display, marketing, or sale of products
109. Pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 503(a) & (b), CVMA is entitled to an order impounding
110. Pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 504, CVMA is also entitled to recover actual damages
and any profits of Defendants, or an award of statutory damages up to $150,000 per registered
work.
111. Pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 505, CVMA is entitled to an award of attorneys' fees and
costs.
32
112. CVMA realleges and incorporates by reference the averments of all preceding
113. Defendants GearLaunch and Spring supply the advertising space for
Counterfeiting Products, and further manufacture, sell, accept payment for, and distribute each of
the Counterfeiting Products sold through the Counterfeiting Websites for a share in the profit.
114. Defendants GearLaunch and Spring have actual knowledge of the illegal acts of
the Counterfeiting Websites from, at a minimum, repeated written notice from CVMA, which
Defendants GearLaunch and Spring have knowingly and willfully permitted and continue to
permit the Counterfeiting Websites to promote, offer for sale, and sell Counterfeiting Products
bearing CVMA Intellectual Property, which are manufactured, packaged, and distributed by
enabled, and contributed to the counterfeiting and infringing activities of the Counterfeiting
117. CVMA has sustained and will continue to sustain damage to their exclusive rights
in the Skully Design, including but not limited to lost product sales and the loss of licensing
revenue.
118. As a result of the Defendants’ wrongful contributory conduct, CVMA has been
33
damages, attorney’s fees, the costs of this action, and any and all other relief authorized by law.
119. CVMA realleges and incorporates by reference the averments of all preceding
120. CVMA owns common law trademark rights in the CVMA Marks and has priority
rights in and to the CVMA Marks that date back to at least as early as 2001.
121. CVMA and its licensees have used the CVMA Marks continuously and
consistently for an extended period of time to identify, advertise, promote, sell, and provide a
wide variety of goods and services, including without limitation, use of the marks on and in
connection with apparel, drinkware products, stickers, patches, belt buckles, magnets, headwear,
motorcycle accessories, flags, pins, keychains, signs, baggage, coins, canopies, and license
plates, which has indelibly impressed on the minds of the consuming public the impression that
the CVMA Marks identify CVMA and its licensees as the source of goods and services offered
122. Defendants unauthorized use of the CVMA Marks began long after CVMA and
its licensees first began using the CVMA Marks in connection with, among other things, apparel
123. Defendants’ acts have created, and unless restrained by this Court, will continue
to create, a likelihood of confusion and deception of the consuming public, causing irreparable
34
under the common law of Missouri by a deliberate course of conduct, all without authorization,
125. Upon information and belief, Defendants have acted with full knowledge of
CVMA’s rights in and use of the CVMA Marks, and without regard to the likelihood of
trade on the goodwill associated with CVMA and its licensees, to the substantial and irreparable
injury of CVMA.
127. As a result of Defendants’ acts, CVMA has been damaged and will continue to be
damages, attorneys’ fees and costs, and any and all other relief authorized by law.
Based on the foregoing, CVMA requests that this Court enter judgment in its favor on
each and every claim for relief set forth above and award it relief, including without limitation,
the following:
1. Preliminarily and permanently enjoin and restrain Defendants, and their officers,
directors, agents, dealers, representatives, servants, and employees, and all others acting in
the Counterfeiting Products or any other goods bearing the CVMA Intellectual
35
c. Using any trademark, name, logo, design, or source designation of any kind on or
Intellectual Property;
d. Using any trademark, name, logo, design, or source designation of any kind on or
e. Passing off, palming off, or assisting in passing off or palming off goods as those
utilizing any other device for the purpose of circumventing or otherwise avoiding
2. Direct Defendants to file with this Court and serve on CVMA’s counsel within
thirty (30) days after the service on Defendants of the injunction, a report in writing under oath
setting forth in detail the manner and form in which Defendants have complied with the
injunction;
3. Order Defendants to cease offering for sale, marketing, promoting, and selling,
and to recall all products sold under or bearing any of CVMA’s Intellectual Property, or
36
and to deliver to each such customer from which products are recalled a copy of this Court’s
4. Order Defendants to destroy, and certify the destruction of, all infringing and
counterfeiting products and materials in Defendants’ possession, custody, or under their control,
5. Order Defendants to provide CVMA with an accounting of any and all profits
6. Award CVMA Defendants’ profits resulting from the acts of counterfeiting and
infringement alleged in this Complaint in order to redress Defendants’ unjust enrichment and to
7. Award CVMA any damages sustained and the costs of this action, pursuant to 15
U.S.C. § 1117(a)(2);
8. Triple any damages and increase any profits awarded to the amount this Court
9. Award CVMA its attorneys’ fees pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 1117(b), as well as pre-
10. Award CVMA, should CVMA so elect, an award of statutory damages pursuant
to 15 U.S.C. § 1117(c) of up to $2,000,000 for each counterfeit mark for each good and service
11. Award CVMA its damages, together with prejudgment interest, for the lost sales,
loss of goodwill, and other damages suffered by CVMA as a result of the acts of trademark
37
Missouri; and
12. Grant to CVMA such further relief as may be equitable and proper.
Jury Demand
Respectfully Submitted,
Dated: October 27, 2022
s/ C. Blair Barbieri
C. Blair Barbieri, MO State Bar No. 67941
bbarbieri@hoveywilliams.com
Scott R. Brown, MO State Bar No. 51733
sbrown@hoveywilliams.com
HOVEY WILLIAMS LLP
10801 Mastin Boulevard, Suite 1000
Overland Park, Kansas 66210
(913) 647-9050 Fax: (913) 647-9057
38