Exam Report Yasser
Exam Report Yasser
2007
COMPREHENSIVE EXAM
A CASE STUDY OF
STUDENT NAME
EXAM DATE
INDEX
Situation Analysis............................................................4
Multinationals....................................................................................................4
Globalization......................................................................................................4
Egypt's business environment at a glance....................................................5
External Environmental factors: (extract from the case)..............................6
Societal environment:......................................................................................7
Task Environment (Porter’s 5 forces)............................................................10
TWOS Matrix....................................................................................................11
Corporate Strategy........................................................14
Grand Strategy................................................................................................14
- Growth.........................................................................................................14
- Stability........................................................................................................14
- Retrenchment..............................................................................................15
Boston Consulting Group Matrix..................................................................16
SPACE Matrix..................................................................................................17
Grand Strategy Matrix.....................................................................................18
Functional Strategy.......................................................22
Marketing Strategy..........................................................................................22
Market segmentation.....................................................................................22
Targeting........................................................................................................23
Product positioning........................................................................................23
Marketing Mix – Component Factors............................................................25
Military Strategy.............................................................................................25
Ansoff Matrix..................................................................................................26
Financial Strategy...........................................................................................27
Operational Strategy.....................................................28
Research and Development R&D..................................................................29
Management Information System MIS..........................................................29
Focus on Quality.............................................................................................29
Organization Structure..................................................30
Simple structure:.............................................................................................30
Functional structure:......................................................................................30
Divisional structure:.......................................................................................31
Matrix Structure...............................................................................................32
Network structure...........................................................................................33
Human Resources..........................................................34
Human Resource Policies and Programs....................................................34
HR Planning...................................................................................................34
How to attract qualified Human resources....................................................34
How to train and Develop qualified Human Resources................................34
How to maintain qualified Human Resources...............................................34
Multinationals
The mobility of capital brought by multinational corporations can create "a race to the
bottom". This refers to efforts by governments to change their laws and regulations to
become more corporate friendly in order to attract multinational investment. As they
become more responsive to the interests of multinational corporations, there is the risk
that governments can become less responsive to local constituents. Examples of this are
laws that bar unionization or permit lax environmental standards. Those laws are often
chosen because governments also find the corporate-friendly rules comfortable. China,
for example, bars unionization in most cases, but it also bars almost every other civil
society organization above the very local level that is not government controlled.
Globalization
Globalization refers to increasing global connectivity, integration and interdependence in
the economic, social, technological, cultural, political, and ecological spheres.
Globalization is an umbrella term and is perhaps best understood as a unitary process
inclusive of many sub-processes (such as enhanced economic interdependence, increased
cultural influence, rapid advances of information technology, and novel governance and
geopolitical challenges) that are increasingly binding people and the biosphere more
tightly into one global system.
- A global strategy seeks to meet the needs of customers worldwide with the
highest value & lowest cost
- Locating production in countries with lowest labor costs or abundant
resources
- Locating research where skilled scientists & engineers are found
- Locating marketing activities close to markets to be served
- Including designing, producing, & marketing products with global needs in
minds instead of considering individual countries needs.
- Challenges: combat inflation, stabilize the economy, enable private sector to
invest, attract private foreign capital, balanced budget, less debt , removing
constraints
Import/Export factors
Demand shifts for goods/services
Income differences by region/customer
Price fluctuations
Exportation of labor and capital
Monetary policies
Fiscal policies
Tax rates
Societal environment:
It is comprised of all the background conditions in the external environment of
an organization.
1. Economic: general state of the economy in terms of inflation, recession,
unemployment, interest rate, tax rate workers productivity, price
fluctuations
Economic challenges:
- dealing with the budget’s deficit
- Foreign economic assistance is decreasing. Remittances from Egyptians
working abroad is decreasing year after another
- Reinforcing confidence in the banking sector where loan defaulters will be
invited to settle their disputes.
1- Exchange rate: stability of the exchange rate in Egypt as expected for the coming 2
years in addition to the devaluation of the Dollar against the Euro would give the
company a very good chance to boost its sales level especially with the eye on
export..
2- Tax and customs Laws: the modified tax law in Egypt (as the group is an Egyptian
Group) will be reflected on the net income of the company and accordingly on its
overall results.
3- Availability and price of Labor: the figure in the organization indicates the
availability and low price labor.
4- Political situation and Terrorist attacks: the political situation and terrorist attacks in
Egypt and allover the world and the image linked to the Arab community and its
projection on doing business with such community.
5- Economic growth: apart of the slow overall economic growth worldwide and
especially in Egypt, the pharmaceutical market has a relatively high percentage of
growth.
6- Increased Governmental regulation: Egypt for any new business as indicated from
the statistics.
7- Free trade agreements: The availability of a free trade agreement.
8- Governmental Price Fixation; discourages many businesses and reduces profits
drastically.
9- Import and export regulation:
10- Special tariffs: change in the tariffs for cars in the last few month affected the
industry in many different aspects
11- Level of disposable income: increased after measured decrease in fixed taxes
12- Trust in the government :
13- Educational systems :
14- Fair competition :?
15- Number and size of competitors:
16- Level of new entrants product differentiation
17- Ease of access to the distribution channels
18- Suppliers :
19- Price competition with dumped imports especially from china.
20- Unstable economic conditions (recession)
21- Trend for stabilization of exchange rate by utilizing the foreign currency strategic
reserve in the central bank to increase/decrease supply of dollars.
Four forces -- bargaining power of customers, the bargaining power of suppliers, the
threat of new entrants, and the threat of substitute products -- combined with other
variables to influence a fifth force, the level of competition in an industry. Each of these
forces has several determinants:
TWOS Matrix
Vision Mission and objective of the new entity
COMPANY Vision:
The organization vision is the dream to create or achieve in the future .Accordingly, the
vision statement must be revised to be broad enough and cover all company's
stakeholders.
Company vision is
COMPANY Mission:
The mission is the purpose of existence of any organization that sets it apart from other
firms. The organization mission statement identifies the domain in which the organization
intends to operate including the customers it intends to serve, the products and services it
will provide and the location it will operate. The mission statement should be well
communicated to all stakeholders. The firm strategy should comply with the mission
statement.
Company mission statement :
COMPANY objectives:
The organization objectives directs activities toward key and specific results, the coming
objectives are extracted from the current situation of the mother company describes and
quantifies the organization operating objectives in the following fields :( extract from
the case)
1. Cost reduction; highlighting the cost awareness of the organization with good
improvement in figures.
2. Innovation; as one of the competitive advantage in the pharmaceutical business
3. Co-petition; as an objective to increase enthusiasm between different parts of the
organization
4. Export; show with 20% of production as a strategic choice to secure hard
currency.
1. Efficiency
2. Growth
3. Reputation
4. Contributions to the employees
5. Market leadership
6. Profitability
7. Utilization of resources
Corporate Strategy
In most (large) corporations there are several levels of strategy. Corporate strategy is the
highest in the sense that it is the broadest, applying to all parts of the firm. It gives
direction to corporate values, corporate culture, corporate goals, and corporate missions.
Under this broad corporate strategy there are often functional or business unit strategies.
Grand Strategy
- Growth
Growth Strategy
It is the most appropriate strategy designed to achieve higher sales, assets, profits or
combination of all. Continuing to grow is increased sales, improve the per unit cost and a
better experience curve with an increased profit and market share.
(If the company is intending to share the market, the company must peruse growth
strategy)
- Stability
(Stability strategy: if the company is operating in reasonably stable environment,
stability strategy will be very appropriate for successful operation)
- Retrenchment
(Retrenchment strategy: when the company is in a weak competitive position, some or
all of its products results in a poor performance, sales are down and profits are becoming
losses. Therefore using retrenchment strategy to eliminate the weakness that are dragging
the company down)
Integration
Forward (distribution)
Horizontal (Competitors)
Backward (suppliers)
Buy Manufacture sell
Intensive Strategies
Market penetration --- more considered to be stability strategy
Market development --- Borderless markets
Product Development --- Short PLC
Diversification Strategies (new prod, new MKT) Do not put all eggs in one basket:
Concentric Diversification --- (expanding in the same line of business)
Conglomerate Diversification --- (holding company)
Horizontal Diversification --- new unrelated to same customers
Seek a strategic fit = 1+1> 2 synergy () مع بعض لهم معنى
Defensive Strategies
Retrenchment --- Cost and asset reduction to reverse declining profits (work out= loosing
fat)
Divestiture ---- use Jack Welsh Matrix (GE)
Liquidation ---- Selling company assets in parts
Boston Consulting Group Matrix
Relative Market Share Position
High Medium Low
1.0 .50 0.0
High
+20
Industry Sales Growth
Medium
0
WEAK
COMPETITIVE
Quadrant III Quadrant IV STRONG
POSITION
COMPETITIVE
Retrenchment Concentric diversification
POSITION
Concentric diversification Horizontal diversification
Horizontal diversification Conglomerate diversification
Conglomerate diversification Joint ventures
Liquidation
Differentiation Strategy
Focus Strategy
In this strategy the firm concentrates on a select few target markets. It is also called a
niche strategy. It is hoped that by focusing your marketing efforts on one or two narrow
market segments and tailoring your marketing mix to these specialized markets, you can
better meet the needs of that target market. The firm typically looks to gain a competitive
advantage through effectiveness rather than efficiency. It is most suitable for relatively
small firms but can be used by any company. As a focus strategy it may be used to select
targets that are less vulnerable to substitutes or where a competition is weakest to earn
above-average return on investments.
Size and economies of scale The ability to: Vulnerability to even lower
Globalization cost operators
Cost Leadership
outperform rivals
Relocating to low-cost parts of Possible price wars
the world
erect barriers to entry
The difficulty of sustaining it
Modification/simplification of in the long term
resist the five forces
designs
Strategic alliances
The consistent pursuit of pursuit The creation of a major Possibly higher costs
of those factors which customers competitive advantage
perceive to be important
The difficulty of achieving
Flexibility true and meaningful
High performance in one or more differentiation
of a spectrum of activities
Functional Strategy
Functional strategies include marketing strategies, new product development strategies,
human resource strategies, financial strategies, legal strategies, and information
technology management strategies. The emphasis is on short and medium term plans and
is limited to the domain of each department’s functional responsibility. Each functional
department attempts to do its part in meeting overall corporate objectives, and hence to
some extent their strategies are derived from broader corporate strategies.
Many companies feel that a functional organizational structure is not an efficient way to
organize activities so they have reengineered according to processes or strategic business
units (called SBUs). A strategic business unit is a semi-autonomous unit within an
organization. It is usually responsible for its own budgeting, new product decisions,
hiring decisions, and price setting. An SBU is treated as an internal profit centre by
corporate headquarters. Each SBU is responsible for developing its business strategies,
strategies that must be in tune with broader corporate strategies.
Marketing Strategy
Market segmentation
Subdividing of a market into distinct subsets of customers according to needs and
Demographic
Age
Family Size
Family Life Cycle
Income/Occupation
Education
Religion
Race/Nationality
Psychographic
Social Class
Lifestyle
Personality
Behavioral
Use occasion
Benefits sought
User status
Usage rate
Loyalty status
Readiness stage
Attitude toward product
Targeting
- evaluate attractiveness of each segment
- select the target segment(s)
Product positioning
-- Schematic representations that reflect how products/services compared to competitors’ on
dimensions most important to success in the industry
Product positioning guidelines
Look for vacant niche
Avoid sub optimization
Don’s serve 2 segments w/ same strategy
Don’t position in the middle of the map
High
Convenience Rental Car Market
•
Firm 1
Firm 2
•
High Low
Customer Customer
Loyalty Loyalty
•
Firm 3
Low
Convenience
Choosing a Value Positioning
• More for More.
Example : Mont Blanc, Gucci apparel, Haagen-Dazs
• More for the Same.
Example: Lexus automobile
• The Same for Less.
Example: Arrow shirts, Goodyear tires, Panasonic TV
• Less for Much Less.
Example: VCRs offering fewer features
• More for Less
Example: Toys ‘R’ Us, Wal-Mart store
Marketing Mix – Component Factors
Product Place Promotion Price
Distribution
Quality Advertising Level
channels
Distribution Discounts &
Features Personal selling
coverage allowances
Inventory
Packaging
levels/locations
Transportation
Product line
carriers
Warranty
Service level
Entry strategy
Why we go international?
Market saturation
Competition is high in domestic market
Emerging markets (higher profits)
Globalization trends
to achieve economies of scales
Entry strategy
- Ethnocentric (same system all over the globe)
- Polycentric/ Multidomestic (Nestle)
- Geocentric/Global (50% ethnocentric, 50%Multidomestic)
Competitor Analysis
What are your main competitors (Direct, indirect, substitute)
Strategies of main competitors (Cost leadership, Diff)
Military Strategy
PRINCIPLES OF OFFENSIVE MARKETING WARFAREOffensive
1. THE MAIN CONSIDERATION IS THE STRENGTH OF THE LEADER’SPOSITION
2. FIND WEAKNESS IN THE LEADER’S STRENGTH AND ATTACK AT THAT POINT.
3. LAUNCH THE ATTACK ON AS NARROW A FRONT AS POSSIBLE.
Ansoff Matrix
(Market development or diversification)
The Ansoff Product-Market Growth Matrix is a marketing tool created by Igor Ansoff.
The matrix allows marketers to consider ways to grow the business via existing and/or
new products, in existing and/or new markets – there are four possible product/market
combinations. This matrix helps companies decide what course of action should be taken
given current performance. The matrix consists of four strategies:
Production processes typically constitute more than 70% of firm’s total assets
Production/Operations Decisions
Plant size
Inventory/Inventory control
Quality control
Cost control
Technological innovation
Location
Supply chain
Logistics
Distribution network
1. Process: process decisions concern the design of the physical production system.
Specific decisions include choice of technology, facility layout, process flow
analysis, facility location, line balancing, process control & transportation
analysis.
2. Capacity: Capacity decisions concern determination of optimal output level. It
includes forecasting, facilities planning, scheduling & capacity planning.
3. Inventory: managing raw materials, work in process & finished goods. What to
order? When to order? how much to order?
4. Workforce: managing skilled, unskilled, clerical & managerial employees. It
includes job design, work measurement, job enrichment, work standards &
motivation techniques.
5. Quality: aims at providing high quality to goods; quality control, sampling,
testing, quality assurance & cost control
Questions:
1. Are supplies of raw materials, parts, assemblies reasonable & reliable?
2. Are facilities, equipment, machinery & offices in good condition?
3. Are inventory policies & procedures effective?
4. Are quality control policies effective?
5. Are facilities, resources & markets strategically located?
Research and Development R&D
3 Major R&D approaches according to marketing strategy adopted:
1. 1st firm to market new technological products
2. Innovative imitator of successful products
3. Low-cost producer of similar but less expensive products
Focus on Quality
As our culture do not by nature focus on quality, our products and services face low
quality grade against others produced in Europe, US and Far East. In order to grab more
market share and win more customers, we will focus on achieving high level of Quality.
This should be done through involving quality in our objectives, strategic plans as well as
functional plans by having the right quality assurance and control measures.
Quality Assurance
Emphasis on finding and correcting defects before reaching market
Strategic Approach
Proactive, focusing on preventing mistakes from occurring
Greater emphasis on customer satisfaction
Simple structure:
Owner-manager makes decisions.
Little specialization of tasks.
Few rules, little formalization.
Functional structure:
The company is lead through a team of managers who have functional specializations.
Advantages
• Centralized control of operations
• Promotes in-depth functional expertise
• Enhances operating efficiency where tasks are routine
Disadvantages
• Functional coordination problems
• Inter-functional rivalry
• Overspecialization and narrow viewpoints
• Hinders development of cross-functional experience
• Slower to respond in turbulent environments
President
Divisional structure:
It occurs especially when the organization is managing diverse product line or when the
organization is expanding to cover wider geographical areas
Advantages:
Decentralized decision making
Each business is organized around products
Puts profit/loss accountability on manager
Facilitates rapid response to environmental changes
Allows efficient management of a large number of units
Disadvantages
May lead to costly duplication of functions
Inter-divisional rivalry
Corporate managers may lose in-depth understanding
President
Product Product
division A Marketing division B
Finance Finance
Manufacturing Manufacturing
HR HR
Marketing
Matrix Structure
The matrix structure (some times called the matrix organization) it combines the
functional and divisional structure. It is designed to gain the advantage and minimize the
disadvantages of the functional and divisional structures.
The matrix is formed by using permanent cross functional teams to integrate functional
expertise in support of a clear divisional focus on project, product or program.
The matrix structure in the multinational organizations offers a flexibility to deal with the
regional differences as well as the multi products, programs or regional needs.
The matrix structure is the common solution for the organizations that pursues the growth
strategies in a dynamic and complex environment
Functional & product form are combined simultaneously at the same level.
Employee have 2 superior, functional superior & horizontal product manager
When to use?
• Scarce resources
• Ideas need to be cross fertilized across projects
• External environment is very complex and changeable
3 Distinct phase exist in the development of matrix structure
1 -Temporary cross functional task forces:
Project manager is in charge as the key horizontal link
2 -Product or brand management:
The functional is still the primary organizational structure, product manager act as
integrator of semi permanent product or brand
3-Mature matrix:
A true dual authority structure, functional & product structure are permanent
Network structure
• many activities are outsource
• series of independent firms or business units that are linked together by
computers in an IS
• Used when the environment is unstable
Nike, Reebok, Benetton use the network structure on there operation functions by
subcontracting manufacturing to other companies in low cost location around the world .
Advantages:
The human resource Strategy addresses the issue of whether to recruit a low skill, low
paid, high turnover employees or higher a high skill, high paid, low turnover employees.
The organization policy to go international must be a highly paid high skill, low turn over
employees to improve creativity of the employees and the turnover must be kept at its
minimum levels.
1. Estimating the growth in sales can be done by the available capacity and the
growth rate of the both the country and industry.
2. Using the last year margin and adjusting it to reflect the effect of inflation
and company competitive strategy.
3. Estimating the Depreciation: we use last year depreciation and adjust it with
the effect of new CAPEX
4. Estimating the Interest: affected by loans and interest rates and can easily be
estimated.
Beginning Projected
as of mm/dd/yyyy as of mm/dd/yyyy
Assets
Current Assets
Cash in bank $ - $ -
Accounts receivable - -
Inventory - -
Prepaid expenses - -
Other current assets - -
Total Current Assets $ - $ -
Fixed Assets
Machinery & equipment $ - $ -
Furniture & fixtures - -
Leasehold improvements - -
Land & buildings - -
Other fixed assets - -
(LESS accumulated
depreciation on all fixed
assets) - -
Total Fixed Assets (net
of depreciation) $ - $ -
Other Assets
Intangibles $ - $ -
Deposits - -
Goodwill - -
Other - -
Total Other Assets $ - $ -
TOTAL Assets $ - $ -
Current Liabilities
Accounts payable $ - $ -
Interest payable - -
Taxes payable - -
Notes, short-term (due
within 12 months) - -
Current part, long-term
debt - -
Other current liabilities - -
Total Current Liabilities $ - $ -
Long-term Debt
Bank loans payable $ - $ -
Notes payable to
stockholders - -
LESS: Short-term portion - -
Other long term debt - -
Total Long-term Debt $ - $ -
Total Liabilities $ - $ -
Owners' Equity
Invested capital $ - $ -
Retained earnings -
beginning - -
Retained earnings -
current - -
Total Owners' Equity $ - $ -