PHOENIX
‘A BRITISH BOARD WARGAMERS MAGAZINE
Printed in Gt. Britain ISSUE24 PRICE 75p
Also in this issue:
Bloody April - Burmese
Days: Agincourt -
Commando: Olympica
and much more...Canes Spt Lis
Fen gee ean
rae eaten
ANT iy homaen
Phoenix is bemonthly magsrine ald at providing UK gamers with
forum in bleh they hay exprest thet opintony of, sugeuot improve
ments to and provide now ruicsjeunarios for bourd Wagar.
havaianas eaten ss
fee magarine come the property of Simp Limited and cannat
Hhcenls "nay not be teproduted without proc permission frm ihe
{nlude sie of sources from wien the seile has been compiled: este
Ouarler page £2000 pot issue
[ia teiee dicuume'for¢ consecutive insertions]
(camera eeady urework foured of charged extra)
SGneciptam kates T'ase (e sues) e578
ARUCLES,SUUMITLDN TOR TUMLICATION: Contbutors ate
Sopy in duplicate. Manuscripts should ‘be double fine: spaced with
Spproximstely one inch se margine and typed un A4 (Tax sie)
SEE paper: Messe remember to icluds your fll sume and address with
Psubmatston. Manuscripts exnnot aormally fe returned ones they
te been bried” Mops and alestrative itera should be supplied
om spats clean theugh they a ily oe
fame snd manfteturer of mes dined, Jurile are included
pourrait 1a pfu tou Tong arilos (S000 words) are
Readers on the N. American conlinant and Canada dhould contact the
following address regarding any queries oF ales telating to Phocai:
FIREFIGHT ENTERPRISES, 41/15 223d Strct, Bayside, N.V.11361,
New York, US
CONTENT:
Bloody Apri
Campaign for North Africa reviewed by Bab Campbell
Page 5 SP's game reviewed by B, Laidlaw
Page 9
Page 15
Page 19
Page 21
‘Burmese Days GOW's Burma reviewed by J.8.Poole
Ham Roles & Sweet Corn Commando by Andrew McGee
‘Agincourt GOW's 120 Series game reviewed by J. Loe
Olympics reviewed by K.D. Grimsley
Page 22
Page 23
Book Review by Hamish Wilson
Beda Fomm GDW's 120 Series game by A, Jordan
Grapevine News and Rumours by Doug Davies
Mail Call Readers
Target of Opportunity Rifleman Do
For Sale
Simpubs Briefing News from Malcolm Watson
Feedback Questions
Page 24 Letters
Page 26
Page 26
Pago 27
EDITORIAL
JOHN SPENCE
With this ive af Phoonix I complete twa yaar in
the egitors chai. The fact and. the earl in
S877 on SPs last and next ton yous set me 10
toring on the changes nthe hobby over the Tart
Couple of years and to wonder where they might
how ‘oar wrarsaring wil change and Progrert
ne ow you would like it to arogress ond fee!
{hat tumight bean interesting subject ar Mall!
expand —" Games Day V wisn emple proot of that,
This wil br due 0 number of factors but one of
them wll be the increased ease of accets to Hoard
\orgames. Import of games of many of tho smaller
USS companies and a couple of the larger hes
Iteproved vecenty. with more reaching the etal
tutlts where they fave bean joined on tho shelves
by a number of Brith produets (Fusiier Gemes,
Simulation Games snd Philmar for example). Only
facenty the numoor of outlets have also inceseed
4nd game can now be found autege the soveaed
Tabby shop vom Harrods t9 the High Stret lar
Hationers store) and ate. thur able to cater the
impulse buyer with lit knowisdge of board war
fuming. Lasty, reports inthe press on vious
Sspects of gaming have displayed some of the more
mteraining expects ot gaming wlthout tating
vith "wemanger" brash hopefully tis wll
make ‘bord wargaming more scceptabla 10 the
ed increase Inthe size‘ the hobby in Britain
but nave'no idea vihere It may plateau out ~ the
Divorsiiestion as been another festura of board
‘wargaming ever the last couple of yeas wth nest
roleplaying games being spawned Tel, right ned
Contre and stienee fiction and fantary have con-
{inued 40° gain in importenen, Woether you Play
thse pames yourselves ar not fey av an important
force inthe hobby at the moment (yes, 1 do
Continue £0 incucse them ut mare of that Iter
nd are likely to have a pronounced effect on the
Sesion of historical gomes in the fitore | sr2.n0
fenton why mechentes fet formulated In those
‘lees shouldn't bp sranserred to historical et
Commando?) I would hope that innovative game
mecnonie do nat stop hore tere ie reope for
Continued improvement pnd a place for eomauter
‘ded imulotions as we epee Tor betters
Returning 10 the question 9s to what part ofthis,
veraieation does or doer not constitute bosrd
tiaegaming. I wae very interested and gratified by
thevesut'o the aus 2 feacback ey gp
toisian many. of the fields that some of the
more vociteous readers are wont to ral aginst
lene Table 1. p.27).Whst | @on'thaveall the Mover”
Fesults to hand | belmve thie poputesion of Brie
Brethren ihapetully Reamond Simonsen will coe
Feet 'me if I im surongih Another clear rel is
‘that inuovemséne in miniatures fe not aeeeptabie 0
risary role nearly ottainina 80%, Generally thes
Having said that though 1 must add that one
thought “that erossed “my. mind tos thet the
"tample" is even more “hased™ than wal — no
thar you have to buy Photnox many sil buy it
because they enjoy it format to some extent $0
those questions may b9 ne more than armiror hela
Up tothe Phoonixpotieytt One fat supporting this
oopestion fies In_question & of the awn 2) feed
bets in Moves more replies abel the hobby
“Contiet Simulation Gaming” [39%) than any
tier wmistn Phoenix most (40% replies favoured
‘Board Wargaming” These jum happen to be toe
raving board net agatn?
hhave more than jut the bare hones ofthe gare but
this means that ony 2 few games can be covered in
ny one reve. Personally I ont want to 90.08 0
inte marbers of 800-1000 mord reviews nce
fm I correct in this euppostion? In the fodack
{his time | am trying to sauge your Preferences 35
Dobiish a et ith alle more dota than the SP
fr Simpubs catalogue but ne more than 10 tines
fons)" al new somes ar they appear on the
market. | might be sting my siahts too high and
We would have 10 depend Upon the good wil oF
The Producers but | would stil ke £0 hese your
Lastly, occasionally we have had one or two Kind
‘comments on the format of Phosnix fapart from
ink that surges but that 9 problom thet I can
not hep and wendor how important the prose
tion iso you~ | have added 3 Tow fark
re ie se
‘Napoleon at Loipzip~ D, Davies “6.28
Kharkov Game Replay ~'N Crk ~634
tnd. Prize ~ £7°501
Tactical WWI Games — 6. Barnard 623
Constantinople R. Gibson = Bia
(31a. Prize ~ 8.001,
‘Aunham — R. Cremer Bercy
fee War Review Sy Hackett 84
Vector 3 Rewow ~P. King 28550
Up Seope Scenerio ~ M1. Dean 513
Rittman Dorkde — So
The idea of a Contact column = 60
(that stay)
Grapevine 837
areal! Sea
Book Review =a9
This sue of Phosni =655
Phoenix 22 Feedback Results:
Ian effort to et Bock up to date I azo give you
the most rocent feedback reults and the anual
"pest article al
Rommel in Tunisia A.MeGee = 629
Fed Sun Fusing ~D. Mack 598
(i, pre £10)
‘Swords snd Sorcory —J.&D. Evang 5.05
(nd. prise ~ £7.50),
Notes frm the Underworld — D.Tuenbull = 82
ULebesite "A Gibeon 239
Ripnia— A Gibson 570
EGG = T.Uovereux 567
(Grd. prine — £5.00)
Mayday — J. Evans st
Grapevine =682
Simpubs Brieting =850
Boon Review -8a1
Mae 550
Christmas Quie concep 677
‘This sue of Phos 651
“Three articles mere so close in The Poll that had
the" greatest aiiculty spperating them. After oe
‘counting for the number of readers who had seen
fich gue. "Tho ‘Discussion ‘on Napolgonie War
Simos" by J. Parker nosed shed of "Oporation
‘Fehon snd "Third Reich” E10 gors “0 eft
‘ee Page 27 for Table 1From The Workshop
Operation Crusader s sinsied, atic boxed same com
bining pers operations with strategic activity for a truly’ impressive game of North
Africa, Rommel and the desert. «0.0.0.0... see e eee sees £22.50
acne
Case White tart or the turora sees, but playable separately, thi
boxed game covers the Wehrmacht's initial, overpowering blitzkrieg against Poland in
1939. Victory or defeat is measured by the rate of German progress. ......... £8.95
Road to the Rhine sinsgomery. . srrem, . .Remagen
the West Wall. . the Bulge. . .and the final offensives against the Reich, This boxed game
simulates the Allied drive against the Reich of 1944, ae £8.95
Marrita-Merkur piaystie sensraty, rae prt ofthe Europa Series,
this boxed game recreates the Balkan campaigns of World War Il. Beginning with the
Italo-Greek War, the game continues through to the air-invasion of Crete. .... £11.95
fe leet pa telereg saUlng
La Bataille de la Moskowa
‘The classic Charles Roberts Award winner, now newly packaged
in a boxed version, This is the original game of tactical
Napoleonic warfare which recreates the Battle of Borodino,
1812, and captures the flavour and history of the French
the Cossacks, the uhlans and all the other warriors on
the climactic field of battle in Russia, From this seminal
simulation sprang the legion of 19th century taetgal imi
Gon C £16.50
NEW 4th EDITION CATALOGUE
I enclose a large stamped (13%p) addressed
envelope plus 30p in stamps. Please send me
your 56 page illustrated games catalogue, des-
cribing oxer 300 games with over 130 illust-
rations
Name:
Address:Games er
‘50-54 MANCHESTER ST.. LIVERPOOL L1 6ER_ Tel: 051-296 2005,
‘OPEN: KhonSAT. Sam to 65m,
i
|
TUNNELS & TROLLS
FANTASY GAMES SYSTEM
eee, cd WE STOCK THE FULL RANGE OF Sonate BS
AVAILABLE GAMES BY SPI, GDW, eet GAMES oo 25
BATTLELINE, OSG, AVALON HILL, Fae eS
AND MANY OTHER MAJOR AND MINOR eR ot An to
PUBLISHERS’ PRODUCTS Se eee
NEW MICRO-GAMES eee
[EINIUATONONE WOR: To gy PHONE FOR DETAILS HACE Se Mgr ran
IRS sw BS acme TARSAL ENTERPAES ADE enous eLcoNe)
seuanon cement ce | ANDEXTRAS : EN
Pade Bir wo wone concn, | SQsebUeesORNaMe 888 FSD aeton Sere
120 games are inexpensive and easy to learn: perfect for beginnérs and for veterans seeking a
change of pace. Each contains 2 17°22" map, 120 die-cut counters and a rules book. Most are now presented in 914"x6" bxed format.
1942! sve e+ of4.50 DARK NEBULA, £450 BATTLE OF THE ALMA,....... .£4.50
A simulation of the opening japanese moves inthe Interstellar War in unknown space, Uilzing the compete historical simulation ofthe Battle of
Facile during World War Ml, they invaded the award winning game system of IMPERIUM, the Almas the first major atte of te Crimean
Philipines, Malaya, Singapore and Java, atheldprnyerssrugple forctory on eghtastromorphie War, 1834,
by me acs, int imapn
1940. . .
BATTLE OF AGINCOURT. £3.95 GUILFORD COURTHOUSE. ..... £3.95 the German inason of France and Wien
Set in 1415, The Bote of Agincourt simulates Counties Tis ast movlg corps/esonal sare
SeLin AMIS. Toe fie of Agincourt simulates, Fasumoving Revolutionary Wat game set on the road st Moving corsa
; to Yorktown Greane meets Cortwal Inthe North. fetes the onslaught of the German Bizkeeg,
in he Hundred Year Wur, Earolina woods Fire, melee snd!morate si ithe West
EDA FOMM. . 02... £4.50 contribute to the action THE BATTLE OF LOBOSITZ £3.95
‘A Serie 120 game sein ihe Westem Desert of THE BATTLE OF RAPHIA £3.95 This game imposes the rue fog of wae 3
North Afvia, BEDA FOMM “pits the Brith Fredrick the Grea’ fores meet the Austin
acunst the Htllans, Aguiek clean, action tame for Set in 2178C, The ote of Raphia simulates this army in an early morning mist Each side must grope
tho players with mininum setup time las anciené atic from the Fourth Syrian War. foradvantage while wattng for he fog to cleat
NOTE: Games priced £3.95 ore stl in Foia format
ner Mondayiaye, 10 306.0; Saturdays 1000-530
Games Workshop Ferre cat op
4 DALLING RD, HAMMERSMITH, LONDON W6 Wail oer enquires 01 00 2775,
Moar Ravenscourt Park Tube Station Tel 01-741 3446 TRADE ENQUIRIES WELCOME: 01.960 4775,“Bloody April
THE BATTLE OF SHILOH, 1862
THE STRATEGIC SITUATION
Wreh the ration of Forts Donelion ond Hen in
February 1862, both schined with snot lad
queue, detfarton Dever ll Conceieg cotton
Seioncealay inthe west wat in ins Only one
‘month serer_an entve army was Wat at Lagat
Gross Roads wile efending the Cumberand Gap
tnd row the wiote 300 mile ine was utfanked
tnd out manomyvied
General U.S, Grant, recently promoted 10 Malo
General and in command of the Army of the Yen
rosso, now controieg the Tennesice vd Cr
Tana visors nd, by advancing uptssorn by ord the
forts, threstonad to spit General Alor’ Sidney
donaton's forens‘in Tmo and mpele the heer
land oF the Contaderacy. Realising tht his wide
Spread forces eould otter only token verter and
Being nreatened in the contro by. Major Genes
Buel’: Army to the Onio advancing eh Nessie,
Johnston abandoned the Tennessee cepts) not
‘nly"a malar supply depot ut also one of the
Symbais of Southern oe,
Grant, nicknamed Unconditional Surrender by 3
[bilan public. saw that "the way war open tothe
fuiek Toliow up he hoped for vse nt to be
Instead, racked by petty Jealousy” and vinden
near, the Union cantmand turned in on itt aa
Susndered ‘ts opportunity. Major General Fslieek
merged a5 commander of sil Union forces in he
West including Buel's army in Nahai He had
Johnston meanwhile, pllried by the press but sil
Supported by Davies, found hil in command of
the nemly "designated Army of the. Mastsppr
which had_boon ssembled in Covith, Miss, by
General P.G.T- Beauregard. Besides is value 8s 20
"siembly point Corinth provided 9 convanient hows
ftom wien to. defend the hemphis and Ohio
Rairosd, the South's only adequate spay ine
betwnen the Misssinpi and the ante oss!
In aarly March the Southern Command heard of
Union moves and.
‘dag of launching ‘Beauregard
land was aceepted by the nw Command shout
alteration Indeed, the popular hera at Fort Sumtor
nd Firat Mansssar inte Says ahead funcroned
‘much 35'the army's commander under dahwsions
“The final diepatehes from General FLE Loe
Jetfrson. Danes teft Johnston inno dou
‘oubt thore had ever born, that On his Shou
fasted the destiny of the Confederate south west
‘This was to.bo 2 battle the South enply had to
{Ganiederate rontiasin the Kentucky Ohio Valley
ol lel lial (ered ee
THE GAME
Ie is this attack on Grant's Army, encamped near
the Shiloh Meeting House on the Fenesse, ad
the fascinating and comix bate whieh esd
Shieh forms the subject of SPFs letet Chal Wa
Simulation "Bloody Apri” based an the T8S
erie andthe demerits of 1m systam which
"rate an the developments aneiorencts whey
aye manifest the now game, ether by may of
ST this quite eitfrent ba“The game components wil be familiar oa layers
OFFS of Stonewal. There ae 1200 counters of
Which ‘sbout ne third are combet units and 2
Yorther 200 are leeders and officers of both sides
{fhe vet are informational counters of one Kind or
nother, Fhe Contederste OOB Includes the Arrny
‘Of the Trans Massing! not presant st Sieh but
Included forthe what scenario,
‘Toe map jin two sections which, when butted
together, form a playing sree of 38°» 44". The
north map ie ved more or less agonal, one
half completing the tiangulorshope of the battle
Feld ond the other devoted to the various charts
tre indiestore for use curing the gare.
Although the physical quality is adequate | would
‘ereriba the presentation alittle oeppolnting,
We're rl sede, pardon the pun, with tho old
Emery silhouette wrth the cape covered horse
‘Fhe Union tice counters are bacely distingutes
Able in eolour trom the resimenta units, What's
‘more, We ahouid be getting aay By nom from Whe
ver stated ue and grey. There wn aide variety
oF uniform colours at Shiloh. The Louisigna reg
‘ments, for example, wore blue while Hardee's
Gorn’ was cain is oetie buena Tne
wooded arsar which ‘aizo represents. the rough
{round and tangled undergrowth which forme that
part of the Tennessee valley. Tho est is oHoctve
hough my copy i Perhaps aver heal printed
‘he hex numone ee almost Impossbis toread
‘SURPRISE AND CONFUSION
[Aided by good fortune and some remarkable short
Liphtednees on the part of the Union command the
Contederater aehioved almost total surprise. The
tgneamped Federat regiments. were suddenly con
Fronted by waues of screaming febels pouring out
‘of the woods. Few pickets had Been paste 3nd
Some of thoes had gifieuit ia convincing thelr
Spriors tat ful scale sttatk ws mminent.
“These conditions are fithfully simulated in the
Game, The Federal regiments ae so Up inthe en
cemement hexes printed on the map with aitferent
facinge for unste within the some brigade fo reiect
the Sundey picnic duorgonsation of the Pitsourg
Utnaing eamarite. Only thea small pleket forces
of one svenath pint each are temporary deteched
from their unite 0 patrol the approach to the
Camp not protected ‘by the Tennesree River or
the Ow! Creek
Movemant for the picksts is ploted in advance for
the fret nine urna and the unis are ploced onthe
ins’ ‘oniy "hen an enemy unit if spotted or en
‘countered. Since the pickets move only one Nex
ber turn until these conditions are met and can 00
an owt, However, By opting for the hstrial set
tp forthe picket om’ Petbogy's Brgode, the
Fegerae con't help. but spot Hardecs. advance
Setachmant across Fraly's Field on the fst turn
‘Once the Fibs ace sighted oF the picket is attacked
fevimoy dash back 10 the camp to alert hie ove
brigade or division by stacking wath the rerpectve
tfice or commander. On 9 roll of 5 or 6 the
tear wil tll the picker to go to hell unt the
text ture. When hes finaly been convinced, the
‘ivsianel commander can order his aide to alert
‘ther commanders Alerted unite may fre but may
stot move unt the following tum. There 8 pro
‘lam mere with actilory shih sconsigered In park?
aque unt alorted. Since it must expend 4 MPs >
Convert to limbered or unilmbered status i Pre
Sumobly may not fire wot th turn following ser,
‘Scome reasonable anyway. Unalrted nts are
‘rrualiy parlysed unt they ether spor an enemy
Unit or are attacked, When this Rapens toy are
Sonsidored.terted fram the next turn with aly
[At 0540 on April then tho Rebels have eaoiden
‘pportunity to wield e meshing opening blow. Or
So thoy? By oe ofthe remarkble sree of events
‘whieh meke the tie 0 fascinating Beauregard
fad slected to. send the army. into. bate in
Napolson's order fr the Battle of Waterloo, a mas
"ve line abreast ith ane eorbs Behind the Stern
waves, Considering the tersin which wat totally
UUneuitabie'to thie type of formation ana the fact
thot the tactical plan suas to turn the Federal Ie
Hank, when the aporoach was st an angle tothe
font flank this detain sear neredile.Jonnston,
‘Renevar accapted the plan and witnested te Dut
Heaton ‘in his own name, His wer the ultimate
‘The Confederate player. if ho isnot to witness his
Givisons. and. begades come Nopelessy rag
‘lad and intermingled at happened on that Sunday
{n'1862 wil be obliged vo sit this formation it
‘mediately and probably take up an approximation
‘fF Johnston's own original pion, sm attack with
‘oops abreat, each corps being enigned toa sector
Df the front (This sesumes of cour that players
Ste Tollowing the histareal est up.) Fram the fet
frm the raea isn To Teorganse ond yet take adv
antage of the surprise situation before the Union
‘Salted, At the some time the Confederate must
Denore of repeating the historia! piscomea stack
ins anxiety to dre fst Blood
VIVE LES DIFFERENCES
Infantry units, a in TSS. depandont on
leaders to\enabie them 10 function propery. Ari
Iory and Cavalry ae independent of ier canto
“The moin changes here are thatthe H.G. units ors
one and the commanders Nave aides The sides. os
bon above, are the means of communication on
the batieied and apart trom the Union alert
‘hase wil be used mainiy in eonjunetion with the
‘multi-commander” optional rules placement
Gilicore are "used “to replace Brigade OFtiers
promoted in the field or Becoming conalties, In
Feeaing with the marvelous deval f the same, a
the replacements ee named and historiealy
When the Confederate attack struck the Union
feamp 00 the Tennesse, Grant's omy was still
being sexembled and some urasigned units had
Iotely svrived at the Pitsburg landing. Thie fact,
combined with the difficulty experienced, histor
feally "ana during the game, in keeping brigedes
To Corinth
‘To Hamburg
From Purdy
= ROUGH SKETCH OF AREA COVERED BY “BLOODY APRIL”with them which are allowed to exit the map to
felaad. However, the ease with which this con-
‘ition can be aehiewed Giminahes the Succaats
‘re pushed back. The overrun Union camps. ae
‘zo fair gama to the Souter wroope and infenty
fnd_‘sritery” may pick up limited smounts of
mma from shi souree if they spend ome turn ran
feeking the plac, Only one unt may reat eh
‘Soy an thereafter the camp is depece.
Looting, however, tokss precedence over the need
1to'ting ‘ammunition. The Confederates, many of
ther raw recruits wha hed Tinished their eld
Fationg the previous Gay, simply gorged themseves
fon Wenkee rations. and "Cineinat whiskey”
thers prabbod belts, sashes, swords, lattes and
Sry other trophice they could find ena Reade for
the rear. Confederate units moving adjacent to 2
Union camp on the fist aay must enter the camp
fr the next movement point expended ond make &
‘morale check against steppers caused by looting
Union troops are supplied trom ten field wagons,
43 wll their own camps and the dump at the
Pitsburg” Landing. Nevther ede can “obtain am
munition from any of the, cevairy camps and
haturlly_arilery eames will provide etliery
Srmmunition ony
‘The second of these conditions, Getle Fatigue, is