Cavitation in Valves
Saleh
Daryabari
Introduction
Pressure drop occurs through the valves
because as velocity increases to its maximum
through the flow restriction, pressure
decreases to its minimum. As velocity
normalizes over distance downstream,
pressure recovers as well but not to the level
it was at upstream of the valve. The point at
which pressure is at its minimum is Vena
Contracta. In liquids at this point the local
pressure may drop below vapor pressure
forming bubbles.
                                                 Velocity Profile   Pressure Profile
                                                                                       2
Cavitation and Flashing
Cavitation: If the liquid pressure      Flashing: If liquid pressure
downstream of the Vena Contracta        downstream does not recover and
recovers to a point higher than vapor   remains below the vapor pressure,
pressure, bubbles will collapse and     bubbles do not collapse and cause
cause cavitation.                       further damage in downstream
                                        piping, especially at elbows.
                                                                            3
Cavitation and Flashing Profile
                                  4
Cavitation Index
A cavitation index, called Sigma (σ), has been developed by ISA-RP75 to
quantify cavitation in control valves. Sigma represents the ratio of the
potential for resisting cavity formation to the potential for causing cavity
formation. This cavitation index is defined as follows:
    σ = (P1-Pv)/(P1-P2)
    •   Where:
    •   P1 = Upstream pressure
    •   P2 = Downstream pressure
    •   Pv = Vapor pressure of the liquid at flowing temperature
                                                                               5
Cavitation Index Categories
Through laboratory and field-testing results, acceptable operating Sigmas for
eliminating cavitation (and its associated choking, noise, and damage) have been
established.
Following is general categories for a typical globe valve’s operating conditions:
      •   σ > 2.0 No cavitation is occurring.
      •   1.7 < σ < 2.0 No cavitation control required. Hardened trim provides protection.
      •   1.5 < σ < 1.7 Some cavitation control required. Mutual impingement trim may work.
      •   1 < σ < 1.5 Potential for severe cavitation. Use staged pressure drop trim.
      •   σ < 1 Flashing is occurring.
                                                                                              6
        Cavitation Control
Use staged pressure drop          Upgrade the material to resist
trim. Reduce the pressure         energy from energy of the
from inlet to outlet gradually,   imploding bubbles
thus avoiding a large
pressure drop at the Vena
Contracta.
                                                                   7
Thank you
Saleh Daryabari
Refinery Senior Process Engineer
daryabari@gmail.com