Portable Counter-Mortar Radar
Portable Counter-Mortar Radar
5853B2
                             FIG.2
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010     Sheet 3 of 18        US 7825,853 B2
                              24x8
                             SWITCH             AZMUTH
                             w                 BEAMFORMER
                                                  /30
                                                   AAZ   ELEVATION
                                                   y RX BEAM 1
                                                    50
                                                   AAZ ELEVATION
                                                   SRX BEAM 2
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 4 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
U.S. Patent         Nov. 2, 2010         Sheet 5 of 18                 US 7825,853 B2
30A 3OB
                                                F.G. 6
U.S. Patent       Nov. 2, 2010        Sheet 6 of 18         US 7825,853 B2
                                          -TRANSMT BEAM
                                          - SUM RECEIVE BEAM
                                          --- DIFFERENCE RECEIVE BEAM
                                 2N | | |
                                         /NN
                                        | \\
              V | | AZMUTE| ANGLE|(DEC)| |
                                 30
                                  FIG.8
U.S. Patent     Nov. 2, 2010      Sheet 7 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
                          -10
    - LOW RECEIVE BEAM           -N
    g-50 -20
                        A  L2       N
                   -10 / 0 10 20 \ 30 AQ                  50
                     f   / / | \, \
                         -10
        | |       || | | N
              AIH
            NIIT I I ha
        \ YAN/AELEVATION ANGLE
                          | (deg)| | | | \
                                FIG.9
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 8 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 9 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 10 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 11 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 12 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 13 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
U.S. Patent           Nov. 2, 2010          Sheet 14 of 18              US 7825,853 B2
                      46
        CONTROL                              PC-104 BUS
        Tysonal       NEM
                     GENERATOR/LO
                                                                      sER,
                                                                     RADIO MODEM
     AZMUTH DF | 4 CHANNEL
    ELEVATION DE   DIGITAL                                   44
                  RECEIVER
                                                POWER
                                                SUPPLY
                           42
                                     FIG.16
46
                                                              1200
                           6 MHz   50 MHz      462 MHZ
    WAVEFORM
    GENERATOR
                                                         1400 MHZ TO TRANSMIT
                                                                      MATRIX SWITCH
                         1200
     FROM RECEIVE      1400 MHz - 462 MHZ           30 MHZ           TO QUAD
     MATRIX SWITCH                                                A/D CONVERTER
                         1662
                       1862 MHZ
                                     FIG.18
U.S. Patent            Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 16 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
SOKO ZHN a
              a-Re-casessessenessssss
                       8N    OONNOO
                                  H
                                      I
U.S. Patent   Nov. 2, 2010   Sheet 18 of 18   US 7825,853 B2
                                                      US 7,825,853 B2
                               1.                                                                      2
          MAN-PORTABLE COUNTER MORTAR                                   array antenna mounted on a tripod to provide 360 degrees of
                  RADAR SYSTEM                                          azimuth coverage. A receiver-signal processor (RSP) unit is
                                                                        interconnected to the phased array antenna and provides sig
            CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED                                  nal conversion, detection, tracking and weapon location. The
                    APPLICATION                                         MCMR system is operated locally by a notebook computer.
                                                                        Power for the MCMR system may be provided by vehicle
  The present application is a continuation of U.S. Non                 auxiliary power, a small gasoline generator, or from battery
Provisional application Ser. No. 11/081,043, filed Mar. 15,             depending upon the particular situation and duration of
2005, now U.S. Pat. No. 7,248,210, which claims priority to             operation.
U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 60/553,262,           10      It is to be understood that both the foregoing general
filed Mar. 15, 2004.                                                    description and the following detailed description are merely
                  FIELD OF INVENTION
                                                                        exemplary of the invention, and are intended to provide an
                                                                        overview or framework for understanding the nature and
                                                                        character of the invention as it is claimed. The accompanying
   The present invention relates to radar systems and, more        15   drawings are included to provide a further understanding of
specifically, to a man-portable counter mortar radar (MCMR)             the invention, and are incorporated in and constitute a part of
system capable of 360 degrees of coverage over extended                 this specification. The drawings illustrate a preferred embodi
ranges.                                                                 ment of the invention, and together with the description serve
              DESCRIPTION OF PRIOR ART                                  to explain the principles and operation of the invention.
                                                                                 BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
   The mortar is a projectile weapon that launches explosive
shells in high trajectories to penetrate enemy revetments and
trenches and to inflict damage on enemy equipment and per                  The present invention will be further understood and
Sonnel. It is a light-weight, low-cost weapon, that can easily          appreciated by reading the following Detailed Description in
be carried and deployed by foot soldiers. The mortar can be
                                                                   25   conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:
operated effectively from dense cover, and can be moved                    FIG. 1 is an exploded perspective view of a MCMR system
quickly to different locations, to avoid counterattack.                 according to the present invention.
   Countering a mortar attack is a difficult technical and tac             FIG. 2 is a perspective cutaway of an antenna array accord
tical problem, due to the ubiquity and flexibility of the          30
                                                                        ing to the present invention.
weapon. The current practice consists of deploying a large                 FIG.3 is a schematic of the circuitry for the electronically
and very accurate radar (for example, the United States                 steered antenna array according to the present invention.
AN/TPQ-36) to detect the incoming projectiles, compute                     FIGS. 4a and 4b are opposing side elevation views of an
their trajectory, and determine the launch point location.              antenna column panel according to the present invention.
Then, an immediate counterattack can occur, using mortars or       35      FIG. 5 is a photograph of a transmit matrix Switch assem
artillery, before the enemy can move his weapon.                        bly according to the present invention.
   Conventional counter-mortar radars are very large, vehicle              FIG. 6 is a photograph of a receive matrix switch assembly
mounted systems capable of 90 degrees of coverage. Such                 according to the present invention.
systems employ large, high-power, precision planar array
antennas to determine accurate launch point locations at                   FIG. 7 is a schematic of antenna beam positions according
                                                                   40   to the present invention.
extended ranges. Present mortar-locating radars are also
highly specialized to their single task, and have little capabil           FIG. 8 is a graph of azimuth beam patterns according to the
ity for other useful radar functions; for example, defense              present invention.
against attack by airplanes or helicopters. The radar system               FIG. 9 is a graph of elevation beam patterns according to
cannot be moved quickly, thus rendering it vulnerable to           45
                                                                        the present invention.
mortar attack. The radar is also sufficiently costly, in equip            FIGS. 10-13 are elevation views of an MCMR at various
ment and operating personnel, that only a limited number can            stages of assembly.
be assigned to any single battalion.                                       FIG. 14 is an elevation view of a tripod according to the
              OBJECTS AND ADVANTAGES                                    present invention.
                                                                   50      FIG. 15 is a perspective view of an antenna connector ring
   It is a principal object and advantage of the present inven          for interconnecting the antenna cylinder to the tripod.
tion to provide a portable counter mortar radar system that is             FIG. 16 is a block diagram of the radar electronics that are
carried or moved with ease.                                             housed in the antenna cylinder according to the present inven
   It is an additional object and advantage of the present              tion.
invention to provide a portable counter mortar system capable      55      FIG. 17 is a block diagram of a waveform generator
of 360 degrees of azimuth coverage.                                     according to the present invention.
   It is a further object and advantage of the present invention           FIG. 18 is a block diagram of a receiver downconvertor
to provide a portable counter mortar system capable of mortar           according to the present invention.
location to 5 kilometers with a fifty percent CEP accuracy of              FIG. 19 is a block diagram of a digital signal processor
100 meters.                                                        60
                                                                        according to the present invention.
   Other objects and advantages of the present invention will              FIG. 20 is a block diagram of the hardware of an MCMR
in part be obvious, and in part appear hereinafter.                     system according the present invention.
               SUMMARY OF INVENTION                                        FIG. 21 is a block diagram of the firmware of a digital
                                                                   65   signal processor according to the present invention.
  The present invention comprises a man-portable counter                   FIG. 22 is a block diagram of software for operating a
mortar radar (MCMR) system including a cylindrical phased               MCMR according to the present invention.
                                                      US 7,825,853 B2
                               3                                                                      4
                DETAILED DESCRIPTION                                       A diagram of 24 azimuth beams is seen in FIG. 7. The
                                                                        azimuth beams extend radially outward from the central
   Referring now to the drawings, wherein like numerals refer           antenna cylinder 26. As shown in FIG. 7, MCMR 10 has 24
to like parts throughout, there is seen in FIG. 1 a MCMR                azimuth beam positions from which the azimuth beams are
system 10 according to the present invention. MCMR system               transmitted. These positions, as well as the proximal ends of
10 generally comprises an antenna 12, a laptop computer 16,             the azimuth beams, are spaced apart at equidistant intervals in
and a power Supply 18.                                                  circumferential relation to the central antenna cylinder 26.
   Referring to FIG. 2, antenna 12 comprises an L-band,                 These equidistant intervals are equal to 15 degrees, which
24-column cylindrical phased array radar mounted on a light             yields 360 degrees of coverage by the azimuth beams. The
weight tripod 20. Antenna 12 scans electronically in azimuth       10   azimuth 3-db beamwidth is slightly wider at 18.7 degrees,
using an electronic matrix Switch and has a pair of fixed               which accounts for the overlap of the individual azimuth
elevation beams. Both azimuth and elevation monopulse                   beams with other azimuth beams as shown in FIG. 7.
angle measurement is used to provide accurate three-dimen                 FIG. 8 depicts the transmit, receive sum, and difference
sional target coordinates (range, azimuth, and elevation).              beam patterns in azimuth.
   Antenna 12 is constructed of 24 radially extending antenna      15     FIG. 9 illustrates the three elevation beam patterns of
panel columns 22, spaced at fifteen degrees and mounted by              antenna 12, i.e., the transmit beam, lower receive beam, and
Support rings 24 to a central antenna cylinder 26 that houses           upper receive beam.
a transmit matrix assembly 28 and receive matrix switch                    Referring to FIGS. 10-16, antenna 12 is constructed on top
assembly 30 of which there are two, as well as a receiver 42,           of tripod 20. Tripod 20 includes a tri-bracketed connector 36
digital signal processor 44, waveform generator 46, and CPU             having thumb wheels for leveling antenna 12 and a boresight
48, as illustrated in FIG.16. Antenna panel columns 22 can be           Scope 38 for aligning antenna 12 in azimuth.
removed and Stacked for transport, and can be quickly reas                 Antenna cylinder 26 is positioned on tripod 20. Two (top
sembled when the radar is deployed.                                     and bottom) or three (top, bottom, and intermediate) levels of
                                                                        Support rings 24 consisting of multiple interlocking panels
   Referring to FIGS. 3 and 4, each panel column 22 is an          25   are mounted around the base, middle, for added stability if
etched Substrate containing six vertically polarized dipole             needed, and top of antenna cylinder 26. As seen in FIG. 11,
elements 22a, each with a pre-selector filter, limiter, and low         Support rings 24 have a series of twenty-four circumferen
noise amplifier. The six elements are combined on panel                 tially spaced slots 24.a for accepting a longitudinal peripheral
column 22 to form two stacked elevation beams that are offset
in elevation angle by 17 degrees. A single elevation beam is            edge of panel columns 22. Panel columns 22 are then
generated on transmit, centered on the lower receive elevation
                                                                   30   mounted to Support rings 24 using slots 24a. Once panel
beam. The elevation beams are independently tapered in                  columns are in position, a series of ground planes 32 are
amplitude and phase to reduce the below the horizon eleva               positioned between adjacent columns 22 by slidingly engag
tion angle sidelobes to suppress the effects of ground-bounce           ing the peripheral edges into longitudinal slots 22d. Cable
multipath. Each panel column 22 also contains a pair of                 connectors 22c of panel columns 22 are then engaged with
solid-state power amplifiers 22b that generate 30 Watts of
                                                                   35   corresponding connectors 26a on antenna cylinder 26 to elec
peak RF power at up to a 10% duty cycle. Each power ampli               trically interconnectantenna electronics of panel columns 22
fier drives three elements through an unequal split, three-way          with transmit matrix switch assembly 26 and receive matrix
power divider. Panel column 22 further comprises cable con              switch assembly 30 housed within antenna cylinder 26.
nectors 22c for electrical interconnection to radar electronics            A Small monopole 34 may be placed over antenna 12 (on
housed in central antenna cylinder 26 and longitudinal slots
                                                                   40   top of cylinder 26) to provide an omnidirectional beam used
22d formed parallel and adjacent to their respective inner              for sidelobe blanking. Monopole 34 generates a hemispheri
edges. In addition, each panel 22 includes a placement pin22e           cal pattern with a null at Zenith.
that engages an opening 23 formed through support rings 24                 With reference to FIG. 15, an antenna connector ring 37
in axial alignment with the slots 24a to further ensure accurate        may be used to interconnectantenna cylinder 26 to tri-bracket
alignment of the panels relative to cylinder 26.
                                                                   45   connector 36. Connector ring 37 includes brackets 39 that
                                                                        securely receive the thumbwheels of connector 36, and fur
   Each of the elevation receive beam RF signals and the                ther includes a circumferential sidewall 41 that envelops the
transmitter RF signal from each column are fed into a 24 to 8           lower portion of cylinder 26, and a plurality of electrical
electronic matrix that instantaneously selects an 8 column              interconnects 43 and vent openings 45 for connecting cylin
sector and reorders the columns appropriately for the azimuth      50   der 26 to interface with antenna panels 22. A base plate
beam formers. For each azimuth dwell period only 8 of the 24            includes openings 49 for power cables, data cables, Ethernet
columns are active. On reception, the azimuth beam formers              cables, and the like. A bubble level 51 provides visual indi
form an azimuth Sum beam and an azimuth difference beam                 cation of the level of MCMR System 10 relative to the ground.
with independent amplitude tapering for optimal sidelobe                   As shown in FIG. 16, radar electronics comprise a four
Suppression. The transmit beam is untapered in azimuth.            55   channel digital receiver 42, a digital signal processor (DSP)
   Referring to FIG. 5, transmit matrix switch assembly 28              44, a coherent waveform generator 46 including local oscil
includes an azimuth beam former 28a that creates the eight              lators, and a data processor or CPU 48. Waveform generator
equally weighted transmit signals that form the transmit                46 digitally generates a coherent linear FM pulse at 6 MHz IF.
beam. A matrix switch 28b provides beam steering by routing             The IF waveform is up-converted to L-band using a three
the eight transmit signals to the appropriate eight antenna        60   stage up-converter. The output of waveform generator 46 is
columns 22 through a 3:1 selector switch 28c.                           sent to a transmit matrix module for distribution to appropri
   Referring to FIG. 6, receive matrix switch assembly 30               ate antenna columns 22. A block diagram for waveform gen
works in reverse of transmit matrix 28 and routs received               erator 46 is seen in FIG. 18.
signals from each of the eight active antenna columns 22                  Digital receiver 42 uses a double-conversion superhetero
through 3:1 selector switch 30a and an 8x8 matrix switch 30b       65   dyne design with an output IF of 30 MHz. Receiver 42 has
to an azimuth beam former 30c. Azimuth beam former 30c                  four channels: low beam sum, low beam azimuth difference,
forms Sum and difference beams on receipt of signals.                   upper beam Sum, and omni. Receiver 42 outputs are fed into
                                                      US 7,825,853 B2
                             5                                                                        6
a four channel A/D converter card that directly samples the             complex demodulator and pass band filter. The filter may be
four 30 MHz IF signals with an A/D converter as a sample rate           changed by loading a different set of filter coefficients in a
of 24 MHz. The four channels are then converted into a                  configuration file. Acceptable MCMR System 10 filter char
baseband complex signal using a digital downconverter,                  acteristics are listed below in Table 1.
implemented in a field programmable gate array with an             5
internal clock rate of 144 MHz. The complex data is sent to                                                 TABLE 1
DSP 44 using high-speed data links. A block diagram for                               Parameter                                    Value
receiver 42 is seen in FIG. 18.
   Referring to FIG. 19, DSP 44 comprises three high-speed                            Input IF                                     6.0 MHz
field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs). Such as a Xilink           10                 Pass band                                   O.375 MHz
Virtex-EM having more than 9 billion usable operations per                            Pass band weight                            1.O
                                                                                      Pass band ripple                         -0.21 dB
second. Each FPGA node has 4 Mbytes of 100 MHz static                                 Stop band                                0.675 MHz
RAM. There are 50 MBPS bi-directional communication                                   Stop band weight                           2O.O
links and 50 MBPS data channel loops between each node. A                             Stop band ripple                        -60.99 dB
constant false alarm rate (CFAR) detector extracts target          15
detections from the lower sum beam while rejecting clutter                 Time domain correlator 52 takes the received data and
and other extraneous returns. Once a detection is declared in
the lower Sum beam, the corresponding data in the azimuth               correlates it against a stored replica or the transmitted pulse,
difference beam, the upper Sum beam, and the omni channel               the equivalent of using a matched filter. Because all MCMR
are used for azimuth and elevation angle determination and              waveforms use linear FM coding with a 1 MHZ excursion,
for detecting side-lobe targets. All detection data are sent to         this operation results in a compressed pulse width of approxi
the embedded CPU 28 for further processing.                             mately 1 microsecond.
   Embedded CPU 48 is a single board computer that is                      Doppler filter (DOP) 54 is carried out using a 128 or 256
PC/104 compatible and has four serial channels, 48 digital              point FFT operation. The number of points in the FFT is equal
I/O lines and 10/100 Ethernet networking capability. For           25   to the number of pulses in a radar dwell. In normal operation,
example, a WinSystems EBC-TXPLUS configured with an                     MCMR 10 uses 128 or 256 pulses per dwell. However, other
Intel Pentium 166 MHz processor is acceptable. CPU 48                   dwell modes, such as 512 or 1024 pulses, are available for
operates the radar. For each multiple-pulse radar dwell, CPU            use. The two-dimensional array of range-Doppler cell data
48 selects that azimuth beam position, chooses the waveform             generated by Doppler filter 54 is stored in memory and
to be transmitted, and receives resulting detections. CPU 48       30   accessed by target detection module 56. Parameters for Dop
also processes detection data to provide range and angle                pler filter 54 for three commonly used PRI dwells are listed in
sidelobe blanking, monopulse angle measurement, fine range              Table 2 below.
measurement, and single scan correlation. The processed
detection data is then sent to laptop computer 16 for addi                                                  TABLE 2
tional processing and display.                                     35
                                                                                                                      Maximum
   Laptop computer 16 is used for radar control and display,                   PRI               Number of Pulses Unambiguous               Doppler Filter
as well as data processing. Embedded CPU 48 sends pro                     (microseconds)            per dwell       Velocity               Bandwidth (HZ)
cessed detections to laptop 16 for processing by target track                    50                   128              +f-1154                156.2SO
ing Software. Target track files are maintained on all detected                  50                   256              +f-1154                 78.125
targets. Once Sufficient track points are collected on a target,   40           1OO                   256               -j-577                 39.063
the data is processed by a discriminator that makes an initial
determination as to whether the target is a projectile. All               Target detector 56 is accomplished by using a sliding win
targets that discriminate as projectiles are then processed by a
trajectory estimator that performs a more detailed target dis           dow constant false alarm (CFAR) detector. CFAR detector
crimination function to help eliminate false launch point loca     45   options are show in Table 3 below. Detector 56 also carries out
tions from being generated. The trajectory estimator uses a             bump detection in both range and Doppler to reduce the
Kalman filter technique to estimate the launch and impact               number of detections caused by large targets.
points from the target track data. The target detections, track,                                            TABLE 3
launch points, and impact points are all displayed on a PPI
display on laptop 16.                                              50
                                                                        Parameter                     Options                         MCMR Setting
   Power for MCMR system 10 may be provided by a con
ventional AC-DC power Supply 18a singularly or in conjunc               Target cell position          Leading, center, trailing       Center
                                                                        CFAR dimension                Range, Doppler                  Range
tion with portable battery/generator 18.                                CFAR length                   4, 8, 16, 32, 64, 128, 256      32
  FIG. 20 illustrates the interconnection of the various hard
ware comprising MCMR 10, such as antenna columns 22,               55
laptop 16, power source (e.g., battery box) 18, and receiver               Referring to FIG. 22, software installed on laptop 16 pro
signal processor 14 housed in antenna cylinder 26. Program              vides radar control, data processing, information display, data
mable firmware and Software operations occur largely in digi            recording, and playback capabilities. It should be understood
tal signal processor 44 and laptop 16, and are discussed in             that a variety of software implementations are possible for
greater detail hereafter.                                          60   managing and displaying the reading obtained by MCMR10.
   Referring to FIG. 21, digital signal processor 44 comprises          Similarly, a variety of graphical user interfaces are possible
a series of firmware operations including a discrete Hilbert            for enhancing user operation of MCMR 10. For example,
transform (DHT) 50, a time domain correlator (TDC) 52, a                custom windows may be designed for the entry of radar
Doppler filter (DOP) 54, and target detection (DET) 56.                 parameters and controls as well as turning the radar on and
   Discrete Hilbert transform performs digital down conver         65   off. Similarly, Software may provide a plan position indicator
sion and filtering. An integrated FPGA converts the digital IF          (PPI) display for tracking relative motion of targets, an oscil
data to complex in-phase and quadrature data using a digital            loscope display for visualizing the contents of DSP 44
                                                   US 7,825,853 B2
                            7                                                                       8
memory, or a waterfall display of historical parameters and             6. The portable radar of claim 1, wherein said portable
targets detected by MCMR 10.                                         radar is powered by a power source selected from the group
  What is claimed is:                                                consisting of vehicle auxiliary power, a portable gas genera
  1. A portable radar, comprising:                                   tor, and a battery.
  a housing for securely storing antenna electronic compo               7. The portable radar of claim 1, wherein said portable
     nents therein, wherein said antenna electronic compo            radar is operated by a laptop computer.
     nents comprise a transmit matrix Switch assembly;
  said transmit matrix Switch assembly comprises an azi                 8. The portable radar of claim 1, further comprising a scope
     muth beam former element adapted to actuate a plurality         attached to said housing for aligning the radar.
     of azimuth transmit beams;                                 10      9. The portable radar of claim 1, further comprising a first
   said plurality of azimuth transmit beams collectively             ring attached to said housing.
     extend radially outward from said housing are in 360               10. The portable radar of claim 9, further comprising a
     degree circumferential relation to said housing; and            second ring attached to said housing.
  a ground engaging member on which said housing is
     removably mounted.                                         15      11. The portable radar of claim 10, wherein said housing
  2. The portable radar according to claim 1, wherein said           has a top end and a bottom end, said first ring is positioned
housing is cylindrical in shape.                                     adjacent said top end, and said second ring is positioned
  3. The portable radar of claim 1, wherein said predeter            adjacent said bottom end.
mined radial amount is about 15 degrees.                                12. The portable radar of claim 10, wherein each of said
  4. The portable radar of claim 1, wherein said ground              azimuth transmit beams are untapered and overlap other azi
engaging member is a tripod.                                         muth transmit beams beyond said proximal ends of each of
  5. The portable radar of claim 1, wherein said portable            said azimuth transmit beams.
radar is operable to locate an incoming projectile from up to
five kilometers.