The Borowiak Rose Water Company expects with some degree of certainty to generate the following net income
and to have
the following capital expenditures during the next five years (in thousands of dollars):
                                                              Year
                                     -                                       1           2          3
                               Net Income                                  2000        1500       2500
                           Capital Expenditure                             1000        1500       2000
The company currently has 1 million shares of common stock outstanding and pays annual dividends of $1 per share.
a. Determine dividends per share and external financing required in each year if dividend policy is treated as a residual
decision.
b. Determine the amounts of external financing that will be necessary in each year if the present annual dividend per share is
maintained.
c. Determine dividends per share and the amounts of external financing that will be necessary if a dividend-payout ratio of
50 percent is maintained.
d. Under which of the three dividend policies are aggregate dividends (total dividends over five years) maximized? External
required financing (total financing over five years) minimized?
ollowing net income and to have
                  4          5
                2300       1800
                1500       2000
ividends of $1 per share.
icy is treated as a residual
sent annual dividend per share is
ry if a dividend-payout ratio of
ve years) maximized? External
                        A. Dividend policy treated as a residual decision:
  Under this policy, the company will first fund its capital expenditures and then distribute t
remaining earnings as dividends. The dividends per share and external financing required in
                                            year will be:
                                                Year
-                            1             2                 3                      4
Income                    2000          1500             2500                   2300
Cap ex                    1000          1500             2000                   1500
Surplus/(deficit)         1000             0              500                    800
Dividend paid last year   1000          1000             1000                   1000
Dividend per share           1             0               0.5                    0.8
External borrowings          0             0                 0                      0
Dividend of this year     1000             0              500                    800
    Total Dividend                                       2300
                        B. Present annual dividend per share is maintained:
  Under this policy, the company will maintain the current dividend per share of $1 and fund
   capital expenditures and any shortfall in earnings with external financing. The amounts o
                           external financing required in each year will be:
                                                Year
-                            1             2                 3                      4
Income                    2000          1500             2500                   2300
Cap ex                    1000          1500             2000                   1500
Surplus/(deficit)         1000             0              500                    800
Dividend                  1000          1000             1000                   1000
Dividend per share           1             0               0.5                    0.8
External borrowings            0          1000            500                    200
Dividend of this year       1000             0            500                    800
                          C. Dividend-payout ratio of 50% is maintained:
   Under this policy, the company will distribute 50% of its earnings as dividends and fund
   capital expenditures and any shortfall in earnings with external financing. The dividends p
                    share and external financing required in each year will be:
                                                 Year
           -               1         2               3                  4
        Income           2000      1500            2500               2300
         Cap ex          1000      1500            2000               1500
   Surplus/(deficit)     1000        0              500               800
 Dividend as per 50%
                         1000      750             1250               1150
     payout policy
 External borrowings       0       750              750               350
  Dividend per share       1       0.75            1.25               1.15
 Dividend of this year   1000      750             1250               1150
        D. Maximizing aggregate dividends and minimizing external financing required:
   To maximize aggregate dividends over five years, the company should adopt the dividen
  payout ratio of 50% as it distributes the highest amount of dividends. However, to minim
  external financing required over five years, the company should adopt the policy of treati
  dividends as a residual decision as it requires the least amount of external financing over f
                                                years.
nd then distribute the
 ancing required in each
                        5
                     1800
                     2000
                     -200
                     1000
                        0
                        0
                        0
:
hare of $1 and fund its
 ng. The amounts of
                        5
                     1800
                     2000
                     -200
                     1000
                        0
                      1000   2700
                         0   2300
 vidends and fund its
ng. The dividends per
  be:
                 5
               1800
               2000
               -200
                900
                900          2750
                0.9
                900          5050
ncing required:
  adopt the dividend-
However, to minimize
 the policy of treating
nal financing over five