CW 4: Plate No.
3 -
Subdivision Planning
                                                                                              4.     Tsalet                 (Chalet)
Phase 1: Research, Concept, Space Requirements and                                            As the United States stepped in, they
Strategies                                                                                    laid the foundation for the cubeta or
                                                                                              the use of toilets. The bathroom and
I. Nature of the Project/Background                                                           kitchen was situated inside the house
                                                                                              and had modern features such as the
a.History, Architectural History                                                              flush system and modern shower.
                                                                                              Private garages to secure vehicles
The Evolution of Residential Dwellings in the Philippines          were introduced. The early days of urban planning also emerged
Through the Years                                                  with this concept, via a neighborhood design called a sanitary
                                                                   barrio.
                          1.    Tungkod-Bahay sa Tubig
                          These stilt houses are the signature                                   5.    Bungalow
                          homes of Badjaos who do not live in                                    Major architectural developments
                          their balangays (boats). It is                                         occurred during the American
                          constructed from waste materials                                       regime, including the origin of the
                          and driftwood Constructed on stilts                                    most common type of house in the
                          that are skillfully positioned between                                 country, the bungalow. These low-
                          coral and coastal rocks.                                               rise homes sport a pitched roof and a
                                                                                                 horizontal shape, with the roof
                          2.     Bahay Kubo                                                      typically made of galvanized iron,
                          A small hut composed of nipa,            walls made of concrete, and equipped with a yard, a garden, or
                          bamboo, and other native materials.      covered carport–if not all three.
                          Many citizens to this day still adopt
                          this style of habitation due to its                                6.     Townhouse
                          simple design, ease of execution,                                  Townhouses are another common
                          and its readily available materials.                               type of home in the Philippines.
                                                                                             Subdivisions across the country have
                          3.     Bahay na Bato                                               adopted this type of design, which
                          Stone and masonry construction was                                 provides an urban feel without having
                          also introduced to the Philippines                                 to live in the city centre. Townhouses
                          during the Spanish colonial era. The                               are considered ‘starter homes’ for
                          ground level was made of massive                                   new families, especially as they are
                          cut stone or brick walls and the upper   the most economical in terms of lot area and overall cost of
                          built with hardwood.                     building and maintenance.
                              7.    Condominiums
                              Condominiums have taken over
                              major cities because of its price
                              range and strategic location in city
                              centres. It offers utmost convenience
                              to residents, seeing as they will have
                              direct access to gyms and
                              recreational areas and they won’t
                              have to worry about maintaining
yards and garages. These types of homes come with its own
building security, landscapers, repairmen, housekeepers, and
other servicemen. Its visual impact paints the skylines of the
country’s central city hubs today.
                                                                        Map of the walled city of Spanish Manila (Intramuros)
History on the Development of Gated Communities
The roots of this model of gated neighborhoods can be traced to
                                                                        AMERICAN ERA
notions of defense and refuge. The foremost example is the
                                                                        In 1898, the United States purchased the Philippines and two
fortification of territories by ancient civilizations. Throughout the
                                                                        other countries from Spain through the Treaty of Paris, a move
history, people have, at some point in their evolution, built
                                                                        that sparked hope for the long-awaited Philippine independence.
physical barriers to protect themselves from external entities.
                                                                        This did not come as anticipated, so the Philippine-American war
                                                                        broke out. The reign of the Americans lasted almost four decades
SPANISH ERA
                                                                        and led to the erection of military camps all over the country.
With the coming of the Spaniards, land was owned predominantly
by the friars, if not the state. This was the first appearance of
                                                                        Approximately 20 forts
privatization of property in the country. The foundation of the
                                                                        built to secure their Asian
modern urban layout is the Hispanic colonial towns. Planned as
                                                                        territory      were     also
a European-style city, Manila was immediately walled to protect
                                                                        designed for the comfort
the Spanish-only inhabitants from threats within and outside.
                                                                        and physical well-being
Natives were banned from Intramuros, or inside the walls and
                                                                        of their officers and men,
non-Europeans already merchandizing on the islands were made
                                                                        who had no experience
to occupy specific districts and constantly regulated.
                                                                        living in the tropics. The
                                                                        arrangement of spaces and
By the end of their reign, Spain had more than 20 fortresses in
                                                                        design      of    structures
the Philippines, with the churches also acting as defense
                                                                        mimicked the design of their homeland neighborhoods.
structures when needed.
                                                                        The United States retained the layout of cities formed during the
                                                                        lengthy Spanish occupation and improved on it with the
introduction of the City Beautiful Movement, a planning principle                       After a few decades, Filipinos finally occupied most of the
that began in the 1890s in the United States and centered on                            administrative seats, and in 1934, Manuel L. Quezon the first
material aesthetics.                                                                    president of the Commonwealth, held office.
Another notable influence on Manila’s built environment was the                         Among the initial steps taken to provide for the landless, Filipino
Sanitary Barrio introduced by American urban planners. This                             was the first government housing agency of the country, People’s
neighborhood concept, which integrated sanitation systems in                            Homesite Corporation (PHC) followed by National Housing
mass housing, promoted sanitary living, and enforced building                           Commission (NHC), as well as the housing model Barrio
standards. Housing lots were laid out in blocks , each having                           Obrero or Laborer’s Village. By 1936, the Vitas Tenement
built-in, communal facilities, and streets that were laid out in a grid                 Housing Project and Diliman Hacienda were partially
pattern.                                                                                implemented, which were developments based on the barrio
                                                                                        obrero concept. The rule of the Americans ended with the dawn
                                                                                        of World War II. The 1942-1945 period emphasized the survival
                                                                                        and building for self-protection, and in June 1946, the Republic of
                                                                                        the Philippines was born.
                                                                                        POST WAR ERA
                                                                                        Philippine gated community is shaped by both tangible and
                                                                                        intangible aspects that are deeply rooted in the history of the
                                                                                        country.
                                                                                                                           Forbes Park was one of the
                                                                                                                           exclusive neighborhoods built
                                                                                                                           outside the city center with
                                                                                                                           comprehensive regulations
                                                                                                                           for landowners, sufficient
                                                                                                                           utilities, and    world-class
                                                                                                                           amenities, and then, was
Luneta Park in the foreground, and Intramuros on the upper left in a photograph dated                                      gated due to felonious acts
October 25, 1933
                                                                                                                           brought by civil unrest after
                                                                                                                           centuries of colonial rule.
Residential districts outside Intramuros were offered by                                                                   Other real estate developers,
businessman Henry M. Jones, who acquired huge tracts of land,                           many American-owned during the 20th century, bought huge
subdivided them into smaller lots, and sold them at a reasonable                        parcels of land and subdivided them to be sold finished with
price with utilities already provided. Houses, markets, schools,                        utilities, as Jones did with the residential districts around
and other institutional buildings were designed by the Americans                        Intramuros. Philam Homes added facilities that would make living
and many were built to beautify their empire in Asia.                                   within the subdivision complete, and its master plan
already had walls and gates included to assure safety for               Today, threats of rebellion do not exist but privatized
residents during that turbulent time in Philippine history.             neighborhoods flourish. Nishioka regards the Philippine’s gated
                                                                        community as a sub-system of the city.
                                                                        The following are the characteristics of EHS: they are planned
                                                                        developments for residential use, mainly single-family housing,
                                                                        with inbound restrictions such as fences and walls. Besides
                                                                        encompassing sizable lots, common parameters for these
                                                                        secured villages still are accessible to major roads or streets
                                                                        leading to city centers, availability of utilities (water, electricity,
                                                                        sanitation) within the neighborhood, as well as amenities to
                                                                        encourage residence within the master-planned communities.
The figure shows the site development plan of Philam Homes in
Quezon City and Epifanio delos Santos Avenue (EDSA), West               Site development plan, a conceptual diagram of a Philippine
Avenue, and Anaran Creek as the edges, amenities at the middle,         gated community. 1—Perimeter walls and regulated access
and the numbered housing lots laid out in blocks surrounding it.        points into the gated community such as gates, boom barriers,
                                                                        and guardhouses influenced by Intramuros and other Spanish
Presently, the neighborhood strictly maintains the R-1                  forts as well as American military camps. 2—Shared amenities
classification or low-density residential zone, except for lots along   area, usually park, recreational facilities, sports courts, and a
EDSA and West Avenue, which were reclassified as major                  multi-purpose hall were found at the center of the development
commercial zones with the urbanization of Quezon City through           inspired by principles of the Garden City.
the decades.
PRESENT
b.Types
                                                                         4. Rowhouse
The different types of dwelling units in the Philippines                 Dwelling units containing 3 or
                                                                         more living units that abut each
Dwelling                                                         Unit    other, where each unit is
A structure used as a residence.It has one or more rooms for             separated by firewall and has
sleeping, cooking, and toilet facilities with a private entrance from    independent access. Usually, the
outside the building or from outside the building or from a common       developer clustered 4,6,8 up to 10
                                                                         units per row. Normally the end unit
hallway or stairway inside the building.
                                                                         lots benefit from larger lot areas
                                1. Single                Detached
                                A single-detached property sits          5. Condominium
                                alone and there is an open space on      A dwelling with multiple-units each
                                the sides plus the front and back,       owned individually and has
                                the house is in the middle of the lot.
                                                                         common areas that are owned
                                Single-detached housing provides
                                space between neighbors, it has          and shared by all unit owners.
                                more floor area and a better sense
                                of privacy
                                2. Single Attached
                                A dwelling unit with one side
                                attached to a firewall.
                                Firewall, any wall that divides a
                                building to resist the spread of fire.
                                It starts at the foundation and
                                extends continuously through all
                                storeys to or above the roof.
                                3. Duplex
                                A dwelling unit that has 2 separate
                                living units, divided by firewall, and
                                has       independent         access.
                                Duplexes are not twin homes; they
                                are properties that share a single
                                lot. You may have several owners,
                                but they have the same shared lot
                                ownership.
II. Site Considerations & its contribution to Energy Efficiency    sizes, right-of-way of roads, open space, allocation of areas for
                                                                   common uses and facilities
A. PLANNING
                                                                   Land allocation and alignment of the various utilities (roads,
Subdivision and site design standards are used by                  drainage, power and water) of the subdivision shall be integrated
communities to regulate how parcels of land are divided into       with those of existing networks as well as projects outside the
developable lots, and how those lots are subsequently designed     boundaries of the project site' e.g. access roads set forth herein
                                                                   and should follow the standard specifications of the Department
and laid out through the development process.
                                                                   of Public Works and Highways (DPWH)
   •   Slopes. Slopes greater than 30 percent, or otherwise        2. Slte Preservation/Alteration
       unstable or subject to hazards, are not allowed to be       a.Slope
       platted or developed for residential uses without           The finished grade shall have a desired slope to allow terrain
       mitigation controls in place.                               water to be channeled into street drains. Where cut and fill is
                                                                   necessary, an appopriate grade shall be attained to prevent any
   •   Natural Features. Subdivisions or development shall
                                                                   depression in the area.
       protect waterways, vegetation, and rocks and other          Grading and ditching shall be executed in a manner that will
       natural features or vistas.                                 prevent erosion or flooding of adjoining properties.
   •   Areas of Special Flood Hazard. Mapped special flood         b. Preservation of Site Assets
       hazard areas identify areas where subdivisions shall not    Suitable trees with a caliper diameter of 200 milimeters or more,
       be approved without evidence that it is not in a flood      shrubs and desirable ground cover shall be preserved. Where a
       hazard or meets other flood damage protection               good quality top soil exists in the site, it shall not be removed and
                                                                   shall be preserved for finishing grades of yards, playgrounds,
       regulations to the satisfaction of the floodplain           parks and garden area.
       administrator.                                              c. Ground Cover
   •   Geologic Hazard Areas. Subdivisions and site plans          Grass, shrubs, plants and other landscaping materials used icr
       must meet mitigation conditions prior to approval in        ground cover shall be of variety appropriate for its intended use
       mapped geologic hazard areas in the Town as the             and location. They shall be so planted as to allow complete and
       information becomes available, including provisions to      permanent cover of the area.
       prevent danger to human life or property.
                                                                   3. Easements
   •   Riparian Setbacks. To promote and preserve the quality      Subdivision projects shall observe and conform to the provisions
       of the river ecology, aesthetic, and recreation.            of easements as may be required by:
                                                                   a. Chapter lV, Section 51 of the Water Code of the philippines on
1. Area Planning                                                   water bodies
Project design should consider not only the reduction of cost of   b. National Power Corporation (NpC) on transmission lines
development to a minimum but also the provision for possible       c. Fault traces as identified by pHTVoLCS per Resorution No. 5i5,
future improvement or expansion, as in the prescription of lot     series of 1992
                                                                   d. Right-of-way of other public companies and other entities
e. For project abutting national roads (primary roads) adequate            2. Lot and Building Site Design. Proposed lots shall be
easement shall be provided for road including loading and                  designed, where feasible, to provide building sites that
unloading as may be required by national/local govemment units             permit the orientation of structures in east-west alignment
other related laws                                                         for southern exposure, and to take advantage of existing
                                                                           shade or prevailing breezes.
4. Circulation
a. Depending on the classification of roads adjacent to the           b. Drainage Plan. No inter-lot or “cross drainage” shall be
subdivision and the size of the project site, road network should     permitted. Each lot shall drain its own water to a public street,
result into a hierarchy of functions and should define and serve      approved public or private drainage facility, or natural drainage
the       subdivisions       as       one      integrated      unit   course without passing through or across an adjacent lot, except
b. Roads complemented with pathwalk within the subdivision            where a legal right exists (e.g., a drainage easement), and is
must be so the nearest to facilitate movement within and in linking   authorized by the city engineer. No lot shall drain water over the
the subdivision the nearest transportation route and adjacent         bank of a flood control channel.
property.
Whenever there is/are existing roads within the project site which    c. Public Utilities and Utility Easements. Each approved
shall be made part of the subdivision, these shall be improved in     parcel shall be provided connections to public utilities, including
accordance with the standards set forth herein.                       electricity, gas, water, sewer, and telecommunications services,
c. Streets should conform to the contours of the land as much as      which shall be installed as part of the subdivision improvements
practicable.                                                          as provided by this section.
d. Provisions of major street extension for future connection to
adjoining developed and/or underdeveloped properties shall                 1. Underground Utilities Required. Utilities in new
mandatory integrated or aligned with existing ones, if any.                subdivisions shall be installed underground, as follows.
e. Streets shall be so laid out to minimize critical intersections         These requirements do not apply to utility lines which do
such as blind comers, skew junctions, etc.                                 not serve the area being subdivided. Telecommunications
f. Roads shall conform with civil work design criteria as per              facilities are also subject to the requirements of
Section 10.B.3 of this Rules and sound engineering practices               Chapter 17.44 (Telecommunications Facilities) of this title.
B. BUILDING TECH/UTILITIES                                                      a. When Undergrounding is Required. All existing and
a. Energy Conservation. Each proposed subdivision shall be                      proposed utility distribution facilities (including electric,
designed to provide maximum opportunities for energy                            telecommunications and cable television lines)
conservation, including opportunities for passive or natural                    installed in and for the purpose of supplying service to
heating or cooling opportunities, in compliance with Map Act                    any subdivision shall be installed underground.
Section 66473.1, as follows:                                                    Equipment appurtenant to underground facilities,
                                                                                including transformers, pedestal mounted terminal
     1. Street Layout. The streets proposed in a subdivision                    boxes and meter cabinets, and ducts, shall also be
     shall be planned in a primarily east-west orientation where                located underground or entirely within a building, not
     feasible.                                                                  located with a right-of-way or required setback.
          The subdivider is responsible for complying with the         subdivider shall also pay the street light maintenance and
          requirements of this section and shall make the              energy fee required by the city.
          necessary arrangements with the affected utility
          companies for facility installation.                         f. Storm Drainage. Storm water runoff from the subdivision
                                                                       shall be collected and conveyed by an approved storm drain
          b. Location of Installation. Underground utility lines       system.
          may be installed within a public or private street right-
          of-way or along a lot line, subject to appropriate                1. The storm drain system shall be designed for ultimate
          easements being provided if necessary. When                       development of the drainage area, and shall comply with
          installed within a public street right-of-way, their              any applicable NPDES requirements.
          location and method of installation, insofar as it affects
          other improvements within the street right-of-way, shall          2. The storm drain system shall provide for the protection
          be subject to the approval of the city engineer.                  of abutting and off-site properties that would be adversely
                                                                            affected by any increase in runoff attributed to the
     2. Utility Easements – Minimum Width. The minimum width                development; off-site storm drain improvements may be
     of easements for public or private utilities, sanitary sewers,         required to satisfy this requirement.
     or water distribution systems shall be determined by the
     review authority based on the recommendations of the city              3. Any easement for drainage or flood control shall be
     engineer for city facilities, and the recommendations of the           improved as specified by the city engineer.
     applicable utility company, for public or private utilities.
                                                                       g. Water Supply. Each approved parcel shall be served by the
     3. Timing of Installation. All underground utilities, water       city’s water distribution system and shall be designed and
     lines, sanitary sewers, and storm drains installed in streets,    constructed to accommodate both domestic and fire flows,
     shall be constructed before the streets are surfaced.             together with necessary fire hydrants to serve each lot proposed
     Connections to all underground utilities, water lines, and        to be created.
     sanitary sewers from approved parcels shall be laid to
     sufficient lengths, as determined by the city engineer, to
     avoid the need for disturbing the street improvements
     when service connections are made.
d. Sewage Disposal. Each parcel within an approved
subdivision shall be provided a connection to the city’s sewage
collection, treatment, and disposal system, in compliance with
the city’s improvement standards and specifications. The
subdivider shall also pay the city’s required connection fee.
e. Street Lighting. All proposed subdivisions shall provide
street lighting facilities designed and constructed in compliance
with the city’s improvement standards and specifications. The
C. APPLICATION IN SUBDIVISION PLANNING & DESIGN                       d. Shading from Neighboring Houses
                                                                      Neighboring houses to the front or rear are typically
a. Energy and Subdivision Design                                      too far away to cause shading. Neighboring houses to
For new construction, houses are typically built in subdivisions      the left and the right, however, can cause significant
where street layouts largely determine the distribution of house      shading. For houses on east-west streets, shading
orientations. Energy and peak demands for heating and cooling         from neighboring houses occurs primarily during the
are functions of house orientation, window area distributions         summer when the sun is low in the eastern and
                                                                      western skies and can reduce air-conditioning energy
(front, back, left, right), and shading from neighboring houses.
                                                                      use. For houses on north-south streets, shading
Orientations of solar hot water (SHW) collectors and                  occurs primarily during the winter when the midday
photovoltaic (PV) arrays depend on available roof surfaces            sun is low in the southern sky and can increase
(front, back, left, right) and house orientation. Therefore, street   heating energy use.
layouts fundamentally influence both the energy efficiency and
energy generation opportunities for houses in subdivisions.
                                                                      e. Design Variants
                                                                      Orientation-specific variants of house plans can be designed to
b. Heating
                                                                      achieve energy efficiency on particular lots while maintaining the
Heating energy is affected by solar gains through windows
                                                                      general architectural appearance of the original house plan. For
during the heating season, primarily as a function of south-
                                                                      example, specifying different glass properties for windows would
facing window area, glass type (solar heat gain coefficient
                                                                      create a variant that that would be visually indistinguishable from
[SHGC]), overhangs to ameliorate summer overheating, and
                                                                      the original plan but would have potential heating and cooling
possibly thermal mass to store heat from day to night.
                                                                      energy savings if assigned to appropriate lot orientations.
c. Cooling
Cooling energy is affected by solar gains through windows             Other variants, such as changing the distribution of window
during the cooling season as influenced primarily by east and         areas or use of overhangs or fins on different sides of a house
west window areas and glass type (SHGC). Solar gains through          plan, may have acceptably minor changes in visual appearance
east and west windows are significant, because during the             and still offer heating and cooling energy savings. To the degree
summer the sun rises north of east and sets north of west so          that variants are visually acceptable and interchangeable in their
that during the early morning and late afternoon and evening,         assignments to particular lots, they can be optimally assigned
solar radiation impinges directly on east and west windows,           within a subdivision area to achieve energy efficiency over a
respectively. Because the sun is low in the sky during these          range of lot orientations.
times, overhangs or eaves do not provide effective shading.
f. Roof Surfaces                                                                 environme           ensure the
Roof surfaces are house plan dependent. For a given house                        nt to live in       safety of
plan, the floor plan may determine the direction of ridgelines,                                      residence
with the roof style dictating the direction and tilt of roof surfaces.                               and to
                                                                                                     prevent
For example, a simple floor plan with a side-to-side ridgeline and                                   thieves
a gable style roof would have front and back roof surfaces only.         T   •   Weather         •   Local laws    •   Span of
A hip style roof would have front, back, left, and right roof                    and                 and               paints,
surfaces. Aside from the roof surface areas, availability for                    changing of         regulations       roof etc.
rooftop solar (PV and/or SHW) may be limited by issues such as                   climate
aesthetic acceptability of placing collectors on a particular roof
surface (say, the front roof).
D. SITE ANALYSIS
         NATURAL               CULTURAL             AESTHETIC
          FACTOR                FACTOR                FACTOR
 S       • Trees on            • Existing            • Along the
            help for              water and             main road
            shading               electrical            for easy
            and                   lines                 access to
            flooding                                    site
 W       • Possible            •   Having            • High
            areas on               staff                maintenan
            site prone             personel to          ce cost
            to flooding            clean up
                                   the site
                               •   Realible
                                   workers to
                                   build a
                                   houses
 O       •   Areas are         •   Providing         •   To build a
             sufficient            transportati          playgroun
             for events            on for                d, mini
             and to give           mobility              park and
             a good                around site           clubhouse
             accomodati        •   Providing             for the
             on and                security to           residence