Tac87 07
Tac87 07
July 1987
             ·.. -.
                      ·.:   ..
                                                                 Angle of Attack
            features
 4 Interview with a Double Ace:                                                      No matter what the reason, you're not
                                                                                     feeling 100% and you know it. What are
   Colonel Vermont Garrison (USAF,                                                  you going to do?
   Ret.)
     He became an ace the first time with the
                                                                               25 Director of Aerospace Safety
     Fourth Fighter Group over Europe by
                                                                                  Special Achievement Award
                                                                                     388th Tactical Fighter Wing
     claiming 7.33 aerial victories. Later over
     Korea, he became an ace again with a                                      26 SOFing (Or How To Avoid Gray
     total of 10 MiG kills. Col. Vermont Gar-                                     Hairs At 30)
     rison shares his thoughts and experiences                                      The Supervisor of Flying fills a vital role
     on flying and fighting.                                                        in TAC's daily flying operations. How can
12 Weapon Words: K Factors and                                                      you do your best when it's your turn?
   Combat Aircraft Parking                                                    30 F-4 Situational Emergency
     A look at some of the things that can be                                    Procedure Training
     done to avoid an explosives mishap.                                                fepartments
TACRP 127-1
       TAC Attack is not directive in nature. Recommendations are intended to comply with existing directives. Opinions ex-
     pressed are those of the authors and not necessarily the positions of TAC or USAF. Mishap information does not identify the
     persons, places, or units involved and may not be construed as incriminating under Article 31 of the UCMJ. Photos and art-
     work are representative and not necessarily of the people or equipment involved.
       Contributions are encouraged, as are comments and criticism. We reserve the right to edit all manuscripts for readability
     and good taste. Write the Editor, TAC Attack, HQ TAC/SEP, Langley AFB, VA 23665-5001; or call AUTOVON 574-3658.
       Distribution F(X) is controlled by TAC/SEP through the PDO, based on a ratio of 1 copy per 10 persons assigned. DOD
     units other than USAF have no fixed ratio; requests will be considered individually.
       Subscriptions for readers outside DOD are available from the Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office,
     Washington, D.C. 20402. All correspondence on subscription service should be directed to the superintendent, not to
     TAC/SEP.                                           Volume 27 Number 07
                                         COL VERMONT GARRISON,
                                                     (USAF, RETIRED)
                                                                                                          Wing, in
                                                            Vermont     Gar-       Fighter Interceptor         Gar-
                                             Bio: Colonel                          Korea. Flying the F-86,MiG
                                              rison, from Mt. Victory,             rison brought his first
                                                              flying   with                              21st and be-
                                        Kentucky, began                            down on February
                                                                  in 1941           came an ace for the second
                                        the Royal Air Force            the                                     on June
                                        and later transferredGroup,
                                                                   to
                                                                      flying
                                                                                    time with two victories
                                                                                                             scored
               EDWARD C.                Fourth Fighter                 Squad-
                                                                                    5th. By July, he had
                                                                                                             Korean
             ALDRIDGE, JR.               with the   336th    Fighter                four more kills for a
             SECRETARY OF                ron out of Debden, England.
                                                                  gained his         War total of 10.
             THE AIR FORCE               Flying the    P-47,  he
                                                                            De-          Col Garrison's flying career
                                                                                                                    in-
                                         first air-to-air   victories  in            totaled nearly 8000 hours,
    GEN ROBERT D. RUSS                    cember 1943 and January                    cluding nearly all the Century
                                                                                                                  the
                COMMANDER                 1944. He then converted        to
                                                             considered to be         series aircraft, as well as to
                                          P-51s and was                 but, on       F-4 and B-57 in addition
                                           a possible  leading   ace,                 those he flew during Worldserved as
                                           March 3rd, after claiming                  War II and Korea. He
                                           another victory     which   raised          commander of the 405th sta-
                                                                     to 7 ,
                                           his total  for  the war                     Fighter Wing when it wasand
                                           Garrison was      downed    by              tioned at Clark Air the
                                                                                                             Base
                                                          and  became      a pris-           commander    of     8th Tac-
                                            ground fire                  of  the       vice
                                            oner for the remainder                      tical Fighter Wing.        Idaho
 COL "COUPE" DE VILL                        war.                               U.S         Col Garrison lives in the
                                                          returned    to  the
       CHIEF OF SAFETY                         Garrison                  the war         and remains active with
                                             and active   flying  after                  Air Force Association.
    MAJ DON RIGHTMYER                                            reassigned to
                                             In 1953, he was
                        EDITOR               his old unit, now the
                                                                        4th
           STAN HARDISON
              ART EDITOR
                                      TAC ATTACK: Colonel Gar-                 ing up against, what the other
SSGT DENNIS WALLACE                   rison, how do you think a                fellow has and how to beat
        STAFF ARTIST                  fighter pilot can best prepare           him. I guess the best thing is to
                                      himself to fly and fight?                be able to fly your equipment
                                                                               to the feathered edge of its
                                      GARRISON: Well, the obvious              capability.
                                      thing is to know your equip-
                                      ment to start with. Train as             TAC ATTACK: Without going
 TAC Attack (ISSN 0494-3880) is       much as possible in what that            over that edge.
published monthly by HQ TAC/SEP,      equipment is supposed to do. If
Langley AFB, VA. POSTMASTER:         you're supposed to be air-to-air,
Send address changes to TAC                                                   GARRISON: Yes. That's right.
Attack, TAC/SEP, Langley AFB, VA     air-to-ground or both, learn             Because you may have to.
23665-5001. Second-class postage     how to do your mission as well           Those were my primary
paid at Hampton, Virginia, and ad-   as possible. If you can, know a          goals-to know my equipment,
ditional mailing offices.            little bit about what you're go-         know the mission that we were
4
                                                                                                       July 1987
                                    interview with a double ace
TAC ATTACK                                                        5
                                                                                         interview with an ace
ership. The people that are go-      key. Getting your eyes on the       deal because the pilots were
ing to follow you, that you          target is vital.                    supposed to already have that.
command, must have con-                                                  A lot of fighter groups ran a
fidence in you. I think a lot of     GARRISON: Certainly and it          "Clobber College" (for want of a
good fighter pilots will do well     will be in the future as well .     better name) to break in the
whether they have a good                                                 new guys, give them a flight or
leader or not. That's been prov-     TAC ATTACK: It's been said          two and show them what you
en. But more of them will do         that no one has figured a new       could. In Korea, we had a rule
better under good leadership.        way to crash airplanes. What        that you had to take them up
                                     sort of mistakes did you see        and show them where the front
TAC ATTACK: You started              guys making in World War II         lines were for obvious reasons.
out as a wingman and eventu-         and Korea that led either to an     But, no, we didn't send a new
ally became a flight leader.         airplane crash or a loss in an      pilot into combat right off on
When you went out on amission,       air-to-air engagement?              the first flight he made over
what did you try to instill in                                           there. We took him up and
your wingmen? What sort of           GARRISON: I saw what I              tried him out. We'd say "This is
things would you attempt to          thought was lack of skill caus-     the way we want you to fly. "
teach them so that they could        ing landing accidents some-         Obviously he was going to be a
eventually become flight lead-       times. Even though, in theory,      wingman if he was a young
ers as well?                         they'd had good training, they      kid. We broke him in as best
                                     still made mistakes.                we could. Unfortunately, you
GARRISON: Well, how to                  In combat, I occasionally saw    might not do as much as you
offer each other mutual pro-         foolhardy aggressiveness lead       wanted to because of pressing
tection and to keep a "swivel"       to mistakes. Now, aggressive-
neck. Times have changed a           ness is absolutely necessary. A
little bit. There's a lot of elec-   fighter pilot in air-to-air com-
tronic gear today that's going       bat certainly isn't going to be
to tell you who's out there, but     successful without it. But stu-
the things that were going to        pidity is another thing. Don't
tell you that in those days were     allow yourself to get in front of
your eyeballs. Sometimes you         somebody and leave him sitting
might have radar telling you         back there where he can shoot
they're coming up; but when          you while you're trying to shoot
you get close in to the fight,       somebody else.
well, it's your eyeballs. Look
around and know how to look,         TAC ATTACK: During World
too. You have to remember            War II, Korea and Vietnam,
that that was all gun firing.        did you ever do any training
                                     sorties as such or was every
TAC ATTACK: I understand.            sortie totally committed to
As you say, you didn't have as       combat?
many electronic means of de-
tecting the enemy as we do to-       GARRISON: We were able to
day but visual contact is still      do a little training. Not a great
6
needs for the aircraft.           that maintained your aircraft?     nearly all cases was
                                                                     outstanding.
TAC ATTACK: Did you fly            GARRISON: Outstanding. I
the same airplane every day       don't think you could ever go      TAC ATTACK: You men-
during World War II and Korea     back totally to that but I know    tioned some thoughts on how a
or did you switch airplanes on    that they are doing more of        pilot can best prepare himself.
different days?                   that now. You buy a whole lot.     What gave you the decisive ad-
                                  You get a feel for the airplane    vantage over your adversary
GARRISON: I flew ninety           and your crew chief. It's the      during your air-to-air victories?
percent of my missions in         crew chiefs airplane and the
World War II and Korea in         armorer's, too. My crew chief      GARRISON: This is going to
what I called "my air-            and armorer in Korea asked if      sound a little like self-
plane"-the same airplane.         they could have their names on     aggrandizement. I had good
You didn't fly it on every mis-   one side with my name on the       eyes for one thing. I could
sion. If your airplane was        other. It was all right with me.   shoot. And I thought I was a
broken, then you flew another     They said, "Every kill that this   pretty fair pilot. I thought I
one. But if my airplane was       airplane gets, we're going to      could make the airplane do
ready to go, then I almost al-    put it under our names over        about anything that anybody
ways flew it.                     here. The ones that you get,       else could make it do.
                                  you can put on the other side."
TAC ATTACK: What sort of          I thought that was great.          TAC ATTACK: No matter
relationship did you have with       From my own experience, the     how good our eyes are, there is
your crew chief and the people    crew chief-pilot relationship in   a lot that you can do with the
                                                                     way you use them. As you said,
                                                                     knowing how to look and keep-
                                                                     ing your head on a swivel is
                                                                     important. If you have the best
                                                                     eyes in the world but don't use
                                                                     them effectively, they won't do
                                                                     you much good. Some of your
                                                                     ability obviously came as a re-
                                                                     sult of the practice and experi-
                                                                     ence you had.
                                                                                                      7
                                                                                     i nterview with an ace
TAC ATTACK: So you were a         motivate them right. It seemed       depend on my wingman or my
weapons instructor there at       to me that among fighter pi-         element lead to do all the look-
Nellis?                           lots, some people were just          ing back there. You shouldn't.
                                  automatically motivated. Give        Do your own looking.
GARRISON: Part of the time.       them the guidance and experi-        Everybody should be looking
I was a squadron commander        ence they need and hope they         around at all times.
most of the time; of course,      listen. If they respect you, they      In Korea, I had a wingman
you're in the same business.      will. Go through the training        that shot an aircraft down
We trained for both air-to-air    that you need to to keep them        when I switched places with
and air-to-ground- strafe, dive   up on that feathered edge all        him. We were flying pretty
bombing and just air-to-air       the time.                            high over there-45 to 50,000
dogfighting.                                                           feet some of the time. You just
                                  TAC ATTACK: How do you              .don't horse an airplane aroun"d
TAC ATTACK: You obvi-             feel a squadron commander            up there, especially with those
ously had a few hours of expe-    goes about getting the respect       airplanes, because you're just
rience· under your belt from      of his people?                       about hanging there. When we
your World War II experience                                           got attacked, he was in the best
and postwar flying before you     GARRISON: I think being              position for the kill, so I said,
arrived in Korea.                 honest is very important. If         "Go." My wingmen knew that
                                  your people don't trust you to       and it helped morale, too.
GARRISON: Not so much in          be honest about things, they're
World War II, compared to Ko-     not going to respect you very
rea. But, going to Korea I had    much. Let them know that you        TAC ATTACK: What were
quite a few hours. Nobody had     have their welfare and their        some of the qualities that you
very much flying going into       training under consideration at     mosf admired about the in-
World War II. I thought they      all times. Everybody likes to       structor pilots or flight leaders
were all kids. I was a little     get promoted but don't give         you served under in your early
older than everybody else. We     your people the feeling that        days? How did they help you
had 21-year old majors,           you're just using them as a         learn to become a better pilot?
colonels that had to be accom-    stepping stone to further your
panied by their mothers into      own career.                         GARRISON: In combat,
the bar and things like that.                                         having a leader who knew
                                  TAC ATTACK: What is your            what he was doing-what he
TAC ATTACK: You had the           view of the role of the flight      was about. We had some good
opportunity on several occa-      leader and the wingman?             ones in every outfit.
sions to serve in leadership                                            Experience, assuming you
positions. What did you con-      GARRISON: In my view, two           have everything else, has a lot
sider to be your greatest chal-   people fighting together are        to do with it. I followed a guy
lenges as a leader of fighter     about 10 times as strong as one     named Don Blakeslee, our
pilots?                           alone. I always figured I was       group commander. He probably
                                  going to see the enemy. Of          had more fighter experience
GARRISON: I don't know if         course, you hope your wingman       than anybody else in Europe,
motivating them is the right      does as well. Fortunately, I        maybe in the entire Army Air
word or not. Some people can      looked around myself. I didn't      Forces. He knew what he was
8                                                                                                  July 1987
about. We also had guys like       engaged in combat?                  your mind on what you're
Jim Goodson, Willard Millikan,                                         about. What are you there
and several others. When you       GARRISON: There are all             for-to kill that target. It
got into a hassle and needed a     kinds of combat. Are you going      doesn't do much good to go in
little assistance, you never       to hit a target on the ground?      and peck at it a little bit, lose
heard those guys say, "I'm         If it is an important target (and   some people, not get it and
short on fuel." They were there;   it ought to be or they shouldn't    have to go back after it again
they would come if they pos-       be sending you against it), then    the next day.
sibly could. You get to know       go in to kill the target. Take
and appreciate those kind of       advantage of all the equipment      TAC ATTACK: Aircraft today
people.                            you've got if you're going to be    are more complex than when
                                   shot at (and you will be today      you first started flying but all
TAC ATTACK: What do you            with surface-to-air missiles and    flying requires some sort of
think is the most important        that kind of stum. Take all the     preparation. How did you pre-
thing to remember when you're      training you can get. Keep          pare for missions?
TAC ATTACK                                                                                                 9
                                                                                    interview with an ace
     tac tips
                                                       FOR THE TAC AIRCREWMAN
TAC ATTACK
                                                                                weapons words
12                                                                                              July 1987
pressure) which is produced by an explosion. The                                 will be 126 feet. That means that this wing's air-
larger the K factor, the greater the amount of                                   craft must be separated by 126 feet (measured
protection provided. Some resources require                                      between the explosives of one aircraft and the
greater protection than others; for example,                                     explosives of the next aircraft). This equates to a
buildings with people assigned inside require                                    protection factor of K-11. Now, how close can we
greater protection (K40/50) than munitions stor-                                 park the aircraft to related facilities like squad-
age igloos (K1.25). General K factors are already                                ron operations? We know the required protection
computed for you in AFR 127-100, table 5-1 (Fig-                                 factor is K-18 from table 5-1 and that the NEW
ure 2) and all you need to know is what type of                                  is 1152. Find the NEW under the weight line and
facilities you are measuring for separation. Since                               follow it over to the column K-18 and the dis-
we are discussing
combat aircraft all
                                             11,
we need to know is
that the distance                   BLE 5-1. Quantity - Distance Separation Criteria:
between explosives
                              HAZARD CLASS/DIVISION                                                                    CL AS           IA0 tf 1.1
loaded aircraft
requires K-11 and
                                            COLUMN -                        T2           J
                                                                                                    3        I         4               5              6             7               8         9            10
                                    FROM: -                   EARTH                                                             ABOVE          ABOVE                         OPER-      OPER-        COMBAT
from related facilities       TO:               POTENTIAL COVERED
                                                EXPLOSION IGLOO
                                                                                                                                GROUND
                                                                                                                                MAGA-
                                                                                                                                               GROUND
                                                                                                                                               MAGA-
                                                                                                                                                              BARR-
                                                                                                                                                              ICADED
                                                                                                                                                                             ATING
                                                                                                                                                                             LOCA-
                                                                                                                                                                                        ATING
                                                                                                                                                                                        LOCA-
                                                                                                                                                                                                     ACFT
                                                                                                                                                                                                     PARK-
                                                                  1
requires K-18.                                  SITE (PES)                                   FRONT   FRONT
                                                                                                                                ZINE           ZINE           MODULE         TION       TION         ING
                                EXPOSED                                                                                         UNBARR- BARR-                                UNBARR- BARR.           AREA
  OK, OK, these K                SITE (ES)                      SIDE         REAR            UNBARR- BARR-
                                                                                             LADED   ICADED                     LADED   ICADED                             LADED        LADED
                                (EXPLOSNES)
factors still don't                                                                                     39                 39              2         2    3             38      46            3 46
relate to distance.             EARTH
                                COVERED
                                                              K125          K1.25            1(235               K2.75          K4             K4             K1.25          1(4        K4           K4
                                                   SIDE
This is why the                 IGLOO       1
                                                                       14           14                  14                 14                                           14
writers of AFR 127-                                           K1.25         K1.25            K2                  1(2            1(4            K4             1(1.25         K4         1(4          1(4
100 provided table                                REAR
formula. Are there any non-related facilities in                           repaired locally. While this is bad enough, if the
the area such as the fire department, wing head-                           same mishap happened while the aircraft were
quarters or the control tower? If so, they must be                         parked at 48 feet as specified by AFM 86-2, the
located at greater distances.                                              closest aircraft would experience 120 psi over-
  Earlier I stated that K factors equate to pro-                           pressure and the explosion would propagate to a
tection from overpressure caused by an explosion.                          point where K-11 distances exist. Remember
Overpressure, if great enough, can cause immedi-                           that the greater the explosives weight, the more
ate propagation of explosions from one aircraft to                         distance will be required to meet the K-11 sep-
the next. To protect explosives from propagation,                          aration criteria. The probabilities are that the
they must be separated by K-11 distance. While                             entire row of explosives-loaded aircraft parked at
K-11 protects from propagation, it provides little                         40 feet would be destroyed.
protection from explosive communication caused                               To make this mishap more severe, during an
by fire or fragments. However, if our aircraft                             exercise more personnel are on the parking ramp.
were parked at 126 feet and a mishap occurred,                             All of these personnel would not have a chance to
the overpressure which would be experienced by                             evacuate to the 2000 foot criteria. Personnel pro-
the closest aircraft to the explosion would be 7.8                         tection for a NEW of 1152 lbs requires K-18 dis-
psi. The overpressure would totally disable these                          tance (210 feet) and at this distance they would
aircraft, buckling the bulkheads and panels. The                           experience 3.5 psi overpressure. We could expect
next aircraft would be 252 feet from the mishap                            10 percent ear damage at this distance. Even at
and would experience 2.8 psi, requiring major                              2000 feet, 2% of the personnel in the open could
depot repair. The remaining aircraft would suffer                          be killed by hazardous fragments.
damage by fragments and could be repaired by                                 The bottom line is that our resources require
local specialists. This is assuming that no ex-                            protection. The more protection required, the
plosive communication by fire or fragments oc-                             larger the K factor and the greater the separa-
curred. By parking our aircraft at K-11 distance,                          tion. These are weapons of war designed to kill
we will lose two aircraft completely and another                           and destroy the enemy. If the weapons are mis-
two aircraft until the depot level repairs are                             handled or improperly positioned, you become the
made. The remaining damaged aircraft could be                              victim.
                                                                   figure 3.
      W       hile performing
              normal duties
           during aircraft re-
                                    their area with a serious fuel
                                    leak; of which the aircrew was
                                    unaware. Both sergeants imme-
                                                                        Recognizing the severity of the
                                                                        problem, SSgt Novak felt that
                                                                        he could stop the leak even
             covery, MSgt Tedford   diately notified individuals        though fuel continued to
               and SSgt Novak       with radios to declare an emer-     stream out of the aircraft.
                 spotted, from      gency while they proceeded to          Unable to lower door 22 due
T    he 363d
     Tactical
Fighter Wing's
                   separate loca-
                     tions, an
                       RF-4 taxi-
                                    flag down the pilot who stopped
                                    the aircraft. Once the aircraft
                                    was stopped, they communi-
                                                                        to the high performance center-
                                                                        line tank, SSgt Novak lowered
                                                                        doors 28 L/R, reached inside
Vehicle Operations                  cated the need for an immedi-       and found a leaking drain
Branch has demonst-                 ate engine shutdown.                valve. His technical expertise
rated its dedication to                MSgt Tedford coordinated the     and intimate knowledge of the
safety by providing Shaw            emergency response while SSgt       aircraft allowed him to close
AFB with an accident-free           Novak identified the location of    the valve by feel which stopped
environment in vehicle oper-        the fuel leak as the door 22        the leak.
ations for 180 consecutive days.      area. This area is located in       The alertness of MSgt Ted-
   This branch is responsible for       front of the auxiliary air      ford and SSgt Novak to aircraft
providing a 120 vehicle fleet 24           doors and a catastrophic     operating outside their im-
hours a day, 7 days a week in                engine bay fire could      mediate work area and their
support of 9AF, USCENTAF,                       easily have been        positive actions to remedy a se-
the 363 TFW and the 507             have           caused by leaking    rious safety deficiency have
TAIRCW. Over 25,000 passen-         earned'         fuel being blown    earned them the TAC Out-
gers and 7 million pounds of        them the          back into the     standing Achievement in
cargo were safely moved more        TAC Out-            engine bay by   Safety Award.
than 400,000 miles to myriad        standing               prevailing
locations-an unprecedented          Achievement              25-knot
safety record for a vehicle op-     in Safety Award.
erations branch of this size.
   The success of the 363d's Ve-
hicle Operations Branch is due
to a conscious effort to
thoroughly train new operators
                                    OUTSTANDING
on all aspects of each vehicle.
The branch has also strategi-
                                    ACHIEVEMENT
cally placed a tote board in the
operations compound dis-
playing the number of accident-
                                     IN SAFETY
free days accumulated. This
visibility provides incentive for
their drivers to practice
                                       AWARD
good safety habits.                            Vehicle Operations
  The men and                                     Branch , 363d
women ofthe                                       Transportation
363d Transport-                                         Squadron
ation Squadron's                                                                                     67 AGS,
Vehicle                                                                                              67TRW
                                                     363d Tactical
                                                     Fighter Wing
ence, their pro-                                    Shaw AFB, SC
fessionalism and
extraordinary ·
safety record                                                           MSgt David B. Tedford
TAC ATTACK
WHERE IS YOUR AI
          The Editor
               ATTACK
          TAC
 Let Compas be your guide
UR GUIDE
18                                                                                              July 1987
business? Do we just think of      tigation does it for them.            The mission briefing was
this as the cost of doing busi-       Using COMPAS, let's take         adequate, but rushed because
ness or can we prevent this        apart the scenario described        of the requirement to brief 3
type of mishap? Using the TAC      above. The key to remember is       missions. It was the fourth day
COMPAS system, let's look at       that many people and super-         of the surge, so much of the
this mishap in greater detail.     visors had identified one or two    "motherhood" items were stan-
Let's see how many indications     of the indications of trouble,      dard. Nothing much was said
there were that this pilot         but the mishap still happened.      about night procedures or pos-
should not have been flying        TAC COMPAS allows us to put         sible disorientation.
this sortie at this time.          these independent observations        The range was totally dark.
   First, you are probably ask-    into a framework from which a       There was no moon and very
ing, "What is the TAC COM-         decision could have been made.      few ground lights. Though
PAS system?" COMPAS stands            The pilot was an experienced     there were a few scattered
for Combat Oriented Mishap         fighter pilot with over 1000        clouds, it was night VMC. The
Prevention Analysis System.        fighter hours. He had an excel-     area however, was a "great
Simply put, COMPAS uses a          lent record as an instructor pi-    black hole."
logic tree (you know, like those   lot in a 2-seat fighter; however,     The aircraft had no low-
charts in the Dash One that try    he had just transitioned into a     altitude warning system or
to make pilots handle emer-        new single-seat fighter. At the     radar altimeter. The location of
gencies like a computer) to        time of the mishap, he had less     the radar/electro-optical (REO)
provide a framework for taking     than 20 hours at his new base       display caused reflection prob-
a step-by-step look at a prob-     and was still in Mission Qual-      lems on the canopy. Though
lem. These analytical trees are    ification Training.                 the HUD gave copious amounts
tools in understanding a mis-         The new aircraft, apart from     of information, it was not easy
hap sequence, not just as an       being a single-seat fighter , had   to remain spatially oriented
independent event, but as a        several innovations. The HUD        with reference only to the
failure of a total system. When    was a new tool for the mishap       HUD.
this type of approach is used,     pilot and the large bubble can-       The wing had been involved
normally many more contribut-      opy and instrument locations        in the normal routine of 3-go
ing factors that led to the mis-   were different. The aircraft        days. The normal duty day,
hap are discovered. The impli-     didn't have the "feel" nor the      when they weren't flying a
cation is that such in-depth in-   aural warning of the old one.       surge schedule, was 12 hours.
vestigation should lead to
better recommendations to
keep these mishaps from
recurring.
  On the positive side, COM-
PAS's best application is to
identify problems with a sys-
tem before they result in mis-
haps. Two of the areas COM-
PAS evaluates are change
(what you or your people are
doing different from normal
and what the impact is) and
system performance review
(what the UEI does , without
the pain of a re-visit in 90
days). Bottom line, COMPAS is
a road map that allows an
organization to take a mean- ·
ingfullook at itself and its op-
erations before a mishap inves-
TAC ATTACK                                                                                           19
                                                                         Let compas be your guide
                              COMPAS BE
                               GUIDE
Maintenance was attempting to        "Can do anything" mentality         pilot averaged 4.8 hours sleep
support a 22 UTE and the             prevailing.                         per night during the surge. Be-
normal flying day was a                 The mishap pilot was also        cause of the briefing time, he
14/12/10.                            subjected to several stresses in    was attempting to sleep during
   The wing surge was designed       his personal life. He had re-       his normal awake time and fly
to support all four squadrons'       ported into his new squadron        during his normal sleep cycle.
participation. Because of in-        36 days before the mishap. He       The result was chronic and
sufficient daylight, the decision    had flown 15 times in those 36      cumulative fatigue. His plate
was made for morning players         days, 9 of which had been dur-      was full, but his ego would not
to fly 1 night and 2 day gos.        ing the last 3 days. He was ea-     allow him to call "Knock it off."
Afternoon flyers flew 1 day and      ger to finish MQT and become          All these factors added up to
1 night sortie. This exercise        a flight lead again. He had         a Class A mishap, a destroyed
was to prepare the wing for an       moved into base housing 8 days      aircraft and the loss of a highly
ORI expected in the near             prior to the mishap. Though         skilled pilot.
future.                              still trying to get settled, the      We in the TAF have gotten
   To fill the surge schedule,       pilot asked to fly in the surge     smarter. The 3-go day has been
the squadron needed every pi-        in order to get the flying time.    reduced to a normal 2-go day.
lot available, including MQT.        During his off-duty time, the       ORI surge rates have been re-
Squadron supervision had to          pilot was mission planning at       duced from 100 sorties per day
cover a 20-hour period from          home and trying to unpack           and 24-hour tasking to a more
first briefing to last landing. In   since his wife was unable to lift   realistic 74 sorties per day and
addition, with winter approach-      heavy objects due to an ad-         18-hour tasking. Flight com-
ing, the squadrons were trying       vanced pregnancy. The mishap        manders have become more in-
to bank sorties. There was a
20                                                                                                  July 1987
volved with their people and      tion, which might have pre-        bed at 1800 and wake up at
are now deeply involved in        vented this mishap. Here is the    0200? Were the wife and kids
programming. Briefing guides      true potential of the TAC          quiet? If so, your risk factor is
stress night procedures, and      COMPAS system. But, let's be       very low and you should volun-
there has been an increased       realistic. TAC COMPAS is not       teer to fly all the morning gos.
emphasis on spatial misorienta-   going to stop all mishaps, but     But, if you are normal, your
tion and disorientation. Avi-     perhaps it will reduce the price   warning lights should be on
onics innovations such as         we must pay to learn from our      and flashing. As a supervisor,
CARA and line-in-the-sky are      mistakes. COMPAS will allow        understand your people are at
providing the pilot with alti-    us to gain the maximum             risk. Watch them close. You
tude warning. Perhaps any one     knowledge from every mishap        might just cut them out of a
of these innovations would        and prevent many others from       sortie, but save their life.
have prevented this mishap.       happening.                            Finally, when you are plan-
   Unfortunately, all of these       But, have we totally pre-       ning for deployments or local
changes were not the result of    vented the possibility of this     flying at strange and exotic
mishap investigation board        particular type of mishap from     times, remember this article.
recommendations from this one     happening again, even with         Ask your flight doc what the
incident. Without the TAC         this COMPAS analysis? How          limits of the human body are.
COMPAS system to guide in-        about each pilot's individual      Ask your safety office to use
vestigations, it has taken the    responsibility to see the signs    TAC COMPAS and tell you
recommendations of over 30        of impending trouble? When         where the threat lies. You
mishap boards to bring the        was the last time you got a        wouldn't fly a combat sortie
TAF to the present configura-     0300 brief time? Did you get to    without an Intell brief, would
                                                                     you? The same logic applies. ->-
TAC ATTACK                                                                                         21
                                                                                                             II
                        •                                                                                    I
                                                     self-medication:
22                                                                                              July 1987
  THERE'RE NO "PLUSES" TO IT
pilot, an IP, a squadron opera-      lent physical health-with one       eine cabinet there was only one
tions officer. He'd led a mod-       exception. A routine drug           Alka-Seltzer box and it was a
erate life style, had a great        screen, performed on all acci-      box of Alka-Seltzer Plus.
family with few problems and         dent victims, revealed thera-
was in perfect health. Good jets     peutic levels of a strong decon-             ng: The mishap pilot
flown by good pilots just didn't     gestant, a strong antihistamine       ad self-medicated with a
impact the ground on CAS mis-        and aspirin in the pilot's blood    powerful antihistamine and
sions without some sort of sig-      and tissues.                        decongestant which in addi-
nificant system failure.                There were no prescriptions      tion to aspirin were at thera-
    Later in the day, the mishap     ordered in the pilot's medical        eutic levels in his blood
briefing proceeded through the       record for antihistamines, de-        ream and tissues at the
established protocol. There          congestants, or, for that matter,   time of the accident. (Caustill
were no identifiable aircraft        medication of any type. He
system or mechanical failures.       hadn't even been seen in the          Causal? Taking an extremely
Through a reconstruction of the      flight surgeon's office since his   common over-the-counter, non-
flight profile, the board had de-    last physical, some eight           prescription medication isn't
termined that the mishap air-        months prior to the mishap.         safe? The chief flight surgeon
craft had performed a non-           The source of the medication        knew the answer and the
standard reversal of flight          was puzzling.                       reason for the feeling in the pit
course at low altitude and, al-         Slim's wife had reported to      of his stomach. It was found in
though there was sufficient al-      the mishap board flight sur-        his (and almost every other
titude to perform the maneu-         geon that her husband had           physician's) office in a bright
 ver, a perfectly functioning air-   complained of a minor "sinus-       red book entitled Physician's
 craft had simply been flown         type" headache and had taken        Desk Reference for Nonprescrip-
 into the ground. There was no       a couple of Alka-Seltzer tablets     tion Drugs. Under the caution
 attempt to eject.                   about three hours prior to his      section of the listing for Alka-
    The flight surgeon again felt    final flight. In the squadron,      Seltzer Plus were the words:
 a sick feeling in the pit of his    Slim had appeared to be his         "Product may cause drowsiness:
 stomach. What had gone              usual jovial self to his squadron   use caution if operating heavy
 wrong? Something must have          mates when he reported for the      machinery or driving a ve-
 happened to or distracted his       mission brief.                      hicle." Surely piloting a mod-
 friend to cause him to lose his        The wing commander inter-        ern high performance jet quali-
 spatial orientation. The au-        rupted the briefer and, turning     fies as "driving a vehicle" in
 topsy findings noted by the         to his Chief Flight Surgeon,        spades! Once again self-medica-
 board and the medicine cabinet      commented, "Surely, Doc, a          tion had contributed to the loss
 in the pilot's home provided a      couple of Alka-Seltzers couldn't    of a life and an aircraft.
 possible answer.                    explain this finding." Unfortu-        The mishap briefing over, the
    There were no medical condi-     nately, they did.                   chief flight surgeon left wing
tions found at autopsy such as          After the autopsy laboratory     headquarters. As he walked
heart disease, stroke or other       values were reported to the         back to his office, he again no-
vascular problems which could        board flight surgeon, she re-       ticed the pleasant March
 have caused a sudden and com-       turned to the pilot's home and      weather. It was indeed a beau-
 plete incapacitation. In fact,      asked to see the box from           tiful day! The bright sun felt
 the autopsy confirmed the           which Slim had taken his            warm on his face. "I've got to
 flight surgeon's clinical impres-    Alka-Seltzer. Her suspicions       do it again," he thought. "Once
 sion that the pilot was in excel-   were confirmed. In the medi-        again I've got to brief our crew
TAC ATTACK                                                                                              23
                                                         self-medication
-MEDICATION
24                                                                     July 1987
TAC--------------
CREW CHIEF
SAFETY AWARD
S    gt Eric Ziegler is dedicated
     to flight line ground safety
as well as the safety of his sec-
                                     areas and maintenance re-
                                     quirements of each available
                                     aircraft. This training con-
tion and the transient aircraft      tinues until each person is fa-
they service. His section            miliar with the different types
handles over 600 aircraft each       of aircraft that land at Luke.
month, including a variety of        The success of this program is
aircraft from all branches of        illustrated by the record of
DOD as well as numerous civil-       accident-free service to thou-
ian aircraft. The vast experi-       sands of transient aircraft. The
ence and knowledge which Sgt         transient alert section has also
Ziegler has acquired on a vari-      received numerous "excellent"
ety of aircraft have contributed     and "zero defects" ratings from
immensely to his training of         the squadron, wing and air
fellow transient maintenance         division.
personnel and their out-                A specific example of Sgt
standing safety record.              Ziegler's thoroughness and
   Sgt Ziegler begins his safety     safety consciousness occurred
training program by giving                                               Sgt Eric D. Ziegler
                                     recently during a quick-turn
                                                                         Transient Alert Section
each newly assigned crew chief       thruflight inspection on a tran-
                                                                         405 EMS, 405 TTW
a complete briefing covering all     sient F-15. During the inspec-
                                                                         Luke AFB, AZ
danger areas of the flight line      tion, Sgt Ziegler noticed appar-
and the common hazards on            ent damage to the first row of
most aircraft. This initial train-   compressor blades on one en-
ing is further augmented as          gine. On closer examination, he    ther damage to the engine and
dissimilar aircraft show up at       found that the damage ex-          possible loss of the aircraft.
the base. Sgt Ziegler takes all      tended to several rows of the        Sgt Ziegler's dedication to
available on-duty crew chiefs        compressor and an engine           excellence and continual safety
and, through one-on-one train-       change was performed. Sgt          awareness have earned him the
ing, points out the danger           Ziegler's actions prevented fur-   T AC Crew Chief Safety Award.
T    he Director of Aerospace
     Safety Special Achieve-
ment Award is presented each
                                     contributions or achievements.
                                     The 388th Tactical Fighter Wing,
                                     Hill AFB, Utah, has been
year to persons and or organi-       selected as recipient of the
zations for outstanding safety       award for 1986.
                                                                               SOFing
26                                                                                             July 1987
                                                                    your judgment and capability
 (1) Study the schedule:                                            so your decisions must be based
                                                                    on cold, hard facts. Study the
      a. Players?                                                   books beforehand and keep up
      b. Experience?                                                with all the changes. Many
      c. Weather Category?                                          wings have a read file avail-
      d. Ranges/exercises?                                          able in the tower to include
      e. Bomb load (live)?                                          wing guidance, temporary pro-
                                                                    cedures and recent changes-
 (2) Check the field facilities/condition at Base Ops:              read it!
      a. Airfield Construction?                                     Decision Ability
      b. ILS out?                                                     How does one develop this?
      c. TACAN maintenance?                                         Some guys seem to come by it
      d. Inbound heavy weight aircraft?                             naturally, others have to learn
      e. PAR?                                                       it. The key point here is that
                                                                    your wing supervisors (DO/
                                                                    squadron commander) selected
 (3) Weather:                                                       you based on your capabilities.
       a. Local-ask to see the satellite pictures.                  Take confidence in that fact.
       b. Ranges/M0As?                                              Remember that the first two
       c. Any cross-country sorties? Departure                      factors we discussed, prepara-
          base/en route weather?                                    tion and knowledge, make deci-
                                                                    sion ability much easier. Re-
       d. Alternate? (backup, just in case?)                        member also that you're in
                                                                    charge-think logically and
 (4) Ramp check:                                                    then act. Double check as soon
       a. SOF vehicle-gas, radio check?                             as you have the time-use the
       b. Taxi and runway approach lights / VASIs?                  SOF emergency action
       c. Snow-Are the snow removal crews                           checklist.
                                                                      Brief your tower personnel
          working on it?                                            on what you expect of them.
       d. FOD?                                                      Know and understand their
       e. Construction?                                             duties and responsibilities. A
                                                                    good working relationship with
                                                                    the ATC folks can be the basis
                                  Knowledge                         for a smooth running organiza-
The biggest problem after these      The SOF, by definition,        tion. As AFR 60-2, TAC Sup 1
necessary checks are accom-       should be the most knowledge-     says, "A cooperative, teamwork
plished is the fact that things   able individual available and     approach is a must." Work
very seldom go perfectly. Be-     one of the most experienced.      through the tower personnel for
cause of this you must be men-    But since we all have to start    radio calls and directives in all
tally prepared for the million    somewhere, experience in the      cases except where time critical
and one things that might go      jet comes first, and experience   emergencies dictate the im-
wrong. By anticipating prob-      as a SOF follows at a some-       mediate use of the radio by the
lems, you're in the right state   what slower rate. In any case,    SOF. For all normal activity,
or frame of mind to handle any    you've got to know the books      the watch supervisor in the
problem. In short, have a plan.   cold. Many people will rely on    tower is the person to talk to.
TAC ATTACK                                                                                         27
                              Fing
28                                                                                               July 1987
                                       ploy and fall from an F -4 air-     continued to monitor the F-16
                                       craft on takeoff. He immedi-        dv.ring the final turn and, as
                                       ately contacted the expediter       the aircraft rolled out on final
                                       who contacted the maintenance       approximately 300 feet above
                                       operations center who notified      the ground in a gear-up con-
                                       the control tower. The tower in-    figuration , A1C Piano fired a
                                       formed the aircrew to prepare       flare. The flare alerted the pilot
                                       for a no-chute landing. That's      to his landing configuration
                                       exactly how the system is de-       and the pilot safely executed a
                                       signed to work-but it takes         go-around. A1C Piano's alert-
                                       motivated people like Airman        ness and timely actions pre-
                                       Williams whose quick action         vented a gear-up mishap.
                                       eoobled the aircrew to take the
    TAC A'ITACK                                                                                           29
N.."\.\\\.\\\X"\\XXN.
                                                                                            16/22 area fire.
                                                                                               One of the most important
                                                                                            things to do is to quickly run
                                                                                            the controlled bailout checklist.
                                                                                            Things to think about: tighten
                                                                                            all belts and straps (hopefully
                  F-4 Emergency Situation training                                          your seat kit straps aren't
                                                                                            loose so you can "check 6"),
                                                                                            stow loose equipment (like the
                                                                                            $49.95 massive checklist holder/
EME                         NC                       ITUATION TRAINING                      tape recorder on your
                                                                                            leg) and run your seat down to
Major Vandy Vandenberg                                 good place to have a fire (as if     where the face curtain doesn't
TAC Flight Safety                                      any place is), since under door      prevent you from getting your
                                                       16 is the LOX system, aft            head all the way back (seat full
SITUATION: It's Day 2 of Red                           emergency canopy jettison bot-       down is a good technique). Let
Flag 88-X and your F-4E is in                          tle, and massive wire bundles,       the world know what you're go-
the third two-ship of a massive                        while door 22 shelters the           ing to do, crew coordinate and
gorilla heading west from Stu-                         heart of the fuel system, utility    perform a dual-sequenced ejec-
dent Gap. While approaching a                          hydraulic reservoir, bleed air       tion when the situation
turn point at 300', the pitter                         ducts and the pneumatic com-         dictates.
says, "Check Master Caution                            pressor. No matter how or               The WSO must be ready to
Light." You start a climb and                          where a fire starts, if it spreads   use the "Canopy Fails to
check the telelight panel.                             to the LOX, hydraulic or fuel        Separate" procedures in
"Oxygen Low" is staring at                             systems, you're sitting in a jet     case his canopy jettison bot-
you. The WSO then calmly in-                           that probably isn't going to         tle has been breached. This
forms you that smoke is coming                         make it and you need to plan         will involve some fancy hand -
up around his seat.                                    accordingly. Other considera-        work, but assuming the regular
   Yo!.   .what's your plan?
              .                                        tions are loss of utility hydrau-    pneumatics system is oper-
OPTION 1: Pull the oxygen                              lics, spurious flight control in-    ating, you probably won't have
gauge circuit breaker in the                           puts and other unpredictable         to go past the second step:
rear cockpit, since the thing                          malfunctions as the fire             "Normal canopy control
has obviously shorted out.                             spreads.                             handle-open."
OPTION 2: Eject. After all,                               Now that you're alerted to           There are a couple of things
since there's no oxygen, you                           the problem, you can continue        in the works to help us with a
can't breath.                                          to run the checklist. What's a       door 16/22 fire. The first is a
OPTION 3: Continue to climb                             safe altitude? Your choice, but     fire detection (and possibly
away from the ground, call                              I'm going to use 5000' as a         suppression) system to warn us
"Knock-it-off", and inform your                         minimum. Going 100% and             of the problem; OO -ALC is cur-
leader/wingman that you have                            Emergency probably isn't going      rently evaluating this proposal.
a possible bleed air duct                              to do much for you in this situ-     The second is the addition of a
failure/fuselage fire.                                  ation, since the LOX system is      redundant aft canopy emer-
DISCUSSION: Option 3 is the                             probably out of there. Also, the    gency jettison bottle, to be
correct choice, though option 2                         new WARNING in the Dash             placed in the rear cockpit. At
may follow shortly thereafter.                          One says that the bailout bottle    this point, it looks like late
The most important thing to do                          can't supply enough pressure        1988 before this modification
is step 1 of the checklist: "At                         for normal breathing unless the     starts. We hope to expedite
tain and maintain safe ejection                         CRU-60/P supply hose is dis-        starts of both modifications, but
altitude."                                              connected, allowing fumes into      meanwhile, crews have to be
   Since January 1986, there                            the mask. Talk about a rock         able to analyze a fire in the
have been three documented                              and a hard place! No wonder the     door 16/22 area and carry out
cases of inflight fire in the door                      Dash One recommends early           the appropriate emergency
16/22 fuselage area. That's not a                       ejection with a confirmed door      procedures.
                                            TIC TALLY
                                                     TAC                          ANG                       AFR
                                                       Thru May                    Thru May                   Thru May
                                             MAY        1987     1986
                                                                         MAY          1987   1986
                                                                                                      MAY      1987   1986
AIRCREW FATALITIES                               0          6    6            0        3                3       4
TOTAL EJECTIONS                                  0          4     1           0        2                1       1
SUCCESSFUL EJECTIONS 0 4 0 2 0 0
                          2.7    2.2
TAC      1987    3.5                       2.0       1.6
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC